Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP NO.22 OF 2021
1. Smt. Jyoti Rani Debnath(49)
W/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
2. Shri Suman Debnath(30),
S/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
3. Shri Subir Debnath(27),
S/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
All are residents of Garjanmura,
P.S. Kakraban, Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura.
……… Claimant-Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Shri Bimal Sutradhar,
S/o. Late Chandra Hari Sutradhar,
Resident of Rajdharnagar, P.S. Kakraban,
Udaipur, District:- Gomati Tripura.
(Owner of Vehicle bearing No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE)
2. Shri Biswajit Das,
S/o Shri Swapan Das,
Resident of Tepania, Udaipur,
P.S. R.K. Pur, District-Gomati Tripura.
(Driver of vehicle bearing No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE).
3. The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.
Branch Office at Udaipur, of Central Road, Udaipur.
P.S.-R.K. Pur, District Gomati, Tripura.
(Insurer of Vehicle bearing No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE)
……Opposite Parties/Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. A. Acherjee, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
MAC APP NO.30 OF 2020
The Branch Manager,
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Udaipur Branch, Central Road, Udaipur.
P.S.-R.K. Pur, District Gomati, Tripura.
(Office under jurisdiction)
(Insurer of Truck Regd. No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE)
Represented by its Divisional Manager,
Agartala Divisional Office, Central Road,
P.S. East Agartala, District:- West Tripura.
……Appellant-Petitioner(s).
Vs
1.
Smt. Jyoti Rani Debnath,
W/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
2.
Shri Suman Debnath,
S/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
3.
Shri Subir Debnath,
S/o Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath.
All are residents of Garjanmura,
P.O. & P.S. Kakraban, Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura.
……… Claimant Respondent(s).
4.
Shri Bimal Sutradhar,
S/o. Late Chandra Hari Sutradhar,
Resident of Rajdharnagar, P.O & P.S. Kakraban,
Udaipur, District:- Gomati Tripura.
(Owner of Vehicle bearing No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE)
………Owner-Respondent(s).
5. Shri Biswajit Das,
S/o Shri Swapan Das,
Resident of Tepania, Udaipur,
P.O. & P.S. R.K. Pur, District-Gomati Tripura.
(Driver of vehicle bearing No.TR-03-A-1917(TATA ACE).
………Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A. Acherjee, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 12.04.2022.
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
MAC Appeal No.22 of 2021 has been filed under
Section
of
enhancement
of
the
Motor
the
Vehicles
awarded
Act,
for
compensation
of
Rs.12,82,552/- (Rupees Twelve Lakhs Eighty Two Thousand
Five Hundred Fifty Two only) passed on 26.06.2020 by the
learned Member Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2,
Gomati Judicial District Udaipur in T.S.(MAC) 48/2018, to
the extent of Rs.16,20,000/- or more and MAC Appl. No.30
of 2020 has been filed under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 read with Section 168 of the Act ibid,
against
the
impugned
judgment
and
award
dated
26.06.2020 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur, in Case No.T.S.
(MAC) 48 of 2018.
2.
Both these two Motor Accident Claim Appeals
have been heard together and disposed of since both the
appeals arise out of common judgment.
3.
The facts in brief common in both these appeals
are that on 17.09.2013, at about 09.00 pm, the deceased
Chitta Ranjan Debnath was returning from his shop at
Udaipur Market riding his bicycle and when he reached
Khilpara on Udaipur road to Kakraban under R.K. Pur P.S.
Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura near Gas Godown, vehicle
No. TR-03-A-1917 (Tata Ace) knocked him down. As a
result of which, he fell down on the roadside and received
fatal injury to his head, lacerated blood clot on the left side
of his scalp frontal bone fracture, and multiple injuries. The
above-mentioned vehicle immediately fled away towards
Kakraban. Thereafter, local people shifted him to TSD
Hospital, Udaipur where he succumbed to his injuries. The
Medical Officer of AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala after
examination of the injured person, declared him brought
dead.
4.
On 18.09.2013, the Post Mortem Examination
was conducted on the body of the deceased, and the Post
Mortem Examination report was prepared by the Medical
Officer at AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala. Thereafter, the
dead body of the deceased was handed over to his
relatives. Subsequently, a written compliant qua the said
accident was registered at R.K. Pur P.S. vide Case No.R.K.
Pur P.S. 320 of 2013 under Section 279/304A of IPC dated
18.09.2013. Thereafter, the IO of the case conducted an
investigation and filed a charge sheet against the driver of
the offending vehicle for causing death due to rash and
negligent
driving.
The
claimant-petitioners
therein
approached the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in case No.T.S.
(MAC) 48/2018 with a claim for compensation amounting to
Rs.16,20,000/- only for the death of Chitta Ranjan Debnath
in a motor vehicle accident on 17.09.2013 caused by the
vehicle No.TR-03-A-1917(Tata Ace).
5.
On the basis of the pleading of the parties, the
learned Tribunal framed 2(two) issues of determination
which are as follows:“i. Whether Chitta Ranjan Debnath, S/o Late
Debendra Debnath succumbed to injuries sustained in a
road traffic accident on 17.09.2013 at about 09.00 pm
at Khilpara near Gas Godown on Udaipur-Kakraban
road under R.K. Pur P.S., due to rash and negligent
driving by the driver of the vehicle bearing
No.TR.03.A1917(Tata Ace)
ii. Are the claimants entitled to be compensated
under the MV Act, 1988? If so to what extent and who
shall be laible to so compensate?”
6.
The learned Tribunal after hearing both the
parties awarded compensation of a sum of Rs.12,82,552/(Rupees Twelve Lakhs Eighty Thousand Five Hundred and
Fifty Two) only along with interest at 6% per annum from
the date of filing of the claim petition and the said amount
shall be paid wholly by the Oriental Insurance Company
within a period of one month from the date of the order
passed by the learned Tribunal.
7.
Being
aggrieved
and
dissatisfied
with
the
impugned judgment and award passed on 26.06.2020, by
the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2,
Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in T.S. (MAC) 48 of 2018,
the claimant-appellant in MAC Appeal No.22 of 2021 has
prayed for following reliefs:"1) admit the appeal;
2) call for the records from the learned
Tribunal below;
3) issue notice upon the respondents; and
4) after hearing the parties would further be
pleased enough to modify the impugned judgment and
award dated 26.06.2020 by way of enhancing the
compensation of Rs.12,82,552/-(Rupees twelve lakh
eighty two thousand five hundred fifty two only) passed
on 26.06.2020 by Sri Anshuman Chowdhury, the Ld.
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, Gomati
Judicial District, Udaipur in T.S. (MAC)48/2018 to the
extent prayed by the appellant before the Ld. Tribunal
otherwise the appellant would be highly prejudiced.”
8.
The Appellant Insurance Company in Mac Appl
No.30 of 2020 has prayed for the following reliefs:“a) Admit the appeal;
b) Call for the case records from the learned
Tribunal below;
c) Stay the operation of the impugned
judgment and award dated 26.06.2020 passed by the
Ld. Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Sri Anshuman
Chowdhury) Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in T.S.
(MAC)48 of 2018 and the Hon’ble High Court may
kindly be pleased to direct the ld Tribunal, not to
proceed with any execution proceeding if any filed by
the claimant respondents in the meantime, till disposal
of the present appeal
d) After hearing the parties be pleased enough
to set aside/quash the impugned judgment and award
dated 26.06.2020 passed by the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal, (Sri Ansuman Chowdhury) Gomati
Judicial District, Udaipur, in Case No.T.S.(MAC)48 of
AND
Pass such other order or orders as the Hon’ble High
Court may deem fit and proper”
9.
Heard
Mr.
A.
Acharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appellants and Mr. P. Gautam, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents in Mac App No.22 of
2021, and Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant-Insurance Company and Mr. A. Acharjee, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents in MAC App. No.30 of
2020.
10.
It is the case of the claimant-appellants that
Chitta Ranjan Debnath(deceased herein) was working as a
tailor and earning Rs. 15,000/-(Rupees fifteen thousand
only) per month. He died in the accident and, accordingly,
the claim petition has been filed. Since, the proof of income
has not been filed, the learned Tribunal has taken the
notional income based on the notification of the State of
Tripura dated 01.04.2020 and fixed Rs.7,263/- per month
and
rounded
Accordingly,
off
the
learned
figure
Tribunal
upward
while
to
Rs.8,000/-.
considering
Sarla
Verma and ors, Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
anr. reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121, National Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and ors. reported in
(2017) 16 SCC 680 and Magma General Insurance
Company Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram and ors., reported in
(2018) 18 SCC 130, awarded Rs. 12,82,552/- as against
the claim of Rs.16,20,000/-. The claimant-appellants herein
seeking enhancement has preferred the present appeal.
11.
Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the
Insurance Company submits before this court that the
vehicle number was not indicated when the accident has
taken place and there was also no eye-witness.
12.
This court is not inclined to accept the said
argument
of
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
Insurance Company since the said argument has not been
advanced before the learned Tribunal by the Insurance
Company. In the counter affidavit filed by the Insurance
Company, the averment with regard to the accident caused
by the vehicle involved has not been denied. The other
witnesses who were present before the learned Tribunal has
not shaken in giving their deposition in favour of the
claimants. In view of the above, the argument of the
learned counsel appearing for the Insurance Company is
negated. Further, if the argument of the learned counsel
appearing for the Insurance Company is tested in the light
of the charge sheet filed and the investigation done, this
argument of the insurance company has no weightage.
13.
With regard to enhancement, this court finds
that there is no infirmity in the order passed by the learned
Tribunal
except
while
following
Magma
General
Insurance Company(supra), the learned Tribunal has
considered Rs.25,000/- to each of the three dependants
amounting to Rs. 75,000/-. The said head is incorrectly
considered by the learned Tribunal.
14.
As
per
Magma
General
Insurance
Company(supra), the claimant-appellants No.2 & 3
are
the sons of the deceased and towards love and affection,
they are entitled to get Rs. 50,000/-(Rupees Fifty Thousand
only) each and, accordingly, it comes to Rs. 1,00,000/-
(Rupees One Lakhs only). Hence, the amount of Rs.
12,82,552/- which have been awarded by the learned
Tribunal is enhanced by Rs. 25,000/-(Rupees Twenty Five
thousand only). Accordingly, it comes to Rs.13,07,552/(Rupees Thirteen Lakhs Seven Thousand Five Hundred Fifty
Two only).
15.
With the above observation and directions, the
appeals are allowed in part and thus disposed of and as a
sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review