Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/the-branch-manager-oriental-insurance-company-ltd-vs-smt-dampa-rung-reang-damparung-reang-dampaurng--20240930-2/ · Printed 19 Nov 2026
Civil

The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. vs Smt. Dampa Rung Reang @ Damparung Reang @ Dampaurng Reang and Ors

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Tripura High Court
Date
30 September 2024
Case No.
MAC App. 34/2024
Result
Partly allowed
Bench
Biswajit Palit
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

17. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby partly allowed. The respondent-claimant-petitioners would entitled to get Rs.26,95,200/- along with 9% interest per annum from the date of filing the claim-petition till the date of actual payment. The appellant be asked to deposit the said amount either to the Registry of this High Court or to the Learned Tribunal below within a period of two months from the date of passing of this judgment. The disbursal of amount to the respondent-claimants would be made as per the observation made by the Learned Tribunal below by judgment dated 18.11.2023. With this observation, this appeal is disposed of and modified to the extent as stated above. Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment. A copy of this judgment/award also be furnished to the Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company for compliance. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Purnita

Filed under

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166, Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 167, Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Motor Vehicles Act and accident claims

Work out the figure: Motor accident compensation calculator

Guides on this topic, in plain language:

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

In this case

Other papers of MAC App. 34/2024 on LegalFirms.in, oldest first.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA MAC App. No.34 of 2024 The Branch Manager Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. BC Ambassa, TRTC Complex Ambassa, PS:- Ambassa Dist: Dhalai, PIN:- 799289 (Insurer of the bike vehicle bearing Registration Number TR041911, Bolero Maxi Truck). ------ Appellant Versus 1. Smt. Dampa Rung Reang @ Damparung Reang @ Dampaurng Reang, W/O Lt. Padaram Reang. 2. Shri Dainya Ram Reang @ Dainyaram Reang, S/O. Lt. Padaram Reang. 3. Miss Debika Reang D/O- Lt. Padaram Reang 4. Miss Rebika Reang D/O- Lt. Padaram Reang 5. Smt. Larabati Reang W/O Daharam Reang All are resident of Village- Ulemchara PS:- Ganganagar District- Dhalai, Tripura (The Petitioner No.2, 3 and 4 being minor be represented by their mother, the Petitioner No.1), PIN-799289 -------Claimant Respondents 6. Sri Matilal Rudrapaul S/O Lt. Birendra Rudrapaul Of Ambassa Colony, PS:- Ambassa, Dist:- Dhalai Tripura (Owner of the vehicle bearing No. TR04-1911, Bolero Maxi Truck), Pin-799289. --------Owner Respondent 7. Sri Rakhshi Kumar Reang S/O Lt. Uday Kumar Reang present address C/O Smt. Ratnabati Reang W/O Mastanjoy Reang of 11/2 Miles, Jagannathpur, Dist: Dhalai Tripura, P.S.- Ambassa, (Driver of the vehicle bearing No.TR04-1911, Bolero Maxi Truck) Pin:- 799289. ------Driver Respondent For Appellant(s) : Mr. K. De, Adv. For Respondent(s) : Mr. D. C. Saha, Adv, Ms. S. Deb Gupta, Adv. Date of hearing : 26.09.2024 Date of delivery of Judgment & Order : 30.09.2024 Whether fit for reporting : YES HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT Judgment & Order This appeal under Section 173 of M.V. Act is preferred challenging the judgment and award dated 18.11.2023 delivered by Learned Member, MAC Tribunal, Dhalai Judicial District, Ambassa in connection with case No.T.S.(MAC) 08 of 2022. By the said judgment and award, Learned Tribunal has determined the amount of compensation amounting to Rs.33,19,360/- (Rupees thirty three lakhs nineteen thousand three hundred sixty only) along with 7.5% S.I. from the date of registration of the claim-petition i.e., w.e.f. 03.06.2022 till the date of realization of the amount. 02. Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. K. De representing the appellant and also heard Learned Counsel, Ms. S. Deb Gupta for the claimant-respondents and Mr. D. C. Saha for the owner of the vehicle. In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the claimants first of all drawn the attention of the Court that in Para No.10 of the claimpetition, it was specifically stated that on the alleged day, the deceased Padaram Reang boarded in the offending vehicle of DWS Department, which was hired for the purpose of supplying water in the interior village of Gandacherra to Ganganagar locality along with the driver was proceeding towards Ganganagar from Gandacherra side and on the way, the same met with an accident at Ramnagar turning of Salbagan, 7 k.m. West from Gandacherra Police Station and due to that accident, he succumbed to his injuries but the respondent-claimants in place of filing the claim-petition under Section 166 of M.V. Act ought to have filed the claimpetition under Section Employees’ Compensation Act. Learned Counsel further submitted that as per Schedule 2 in State Amendment, since the deceased was a pump operator under Drinking Water Supply Department, so, there was no scope on the part of the claims tribunal to entertain the claim-petition filed by the respondent-claimants. So, Learned Counsel for the claimants submitted that the petition before the Learned Tribunal was not maintainable and as such urged for allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below. Learned Counsel further submitted that in para No.21 of the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below, a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- was awarded towards love and affection which was not permissible in the eye of law in view of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. Learned Counsel further submitted that in determining the monthly income of the deceased, the Tribunal below first of all considered the wages of the deceased as a temporary pump operator at Rs.4,600/- per month and further assessed the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month as an unskilled labourer in view of the notification dated 04.08.2023 of the High Court of Tripura and clubbed both the income and finally, determined the monthly the monthly income amounting to Rs.14,600/- per month which was not permissible because the Rs.4,600/- Tribunal or ought Rs.10,000/- as to have total considered income as the either said notification of the High Court says that the notional income of the deceased for unskilled labourer at Rs.10,000/-, but there was no scope to club both the incomes, for which the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal suffers from infirmity. Learned Counsel for the appellant urged for allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below and referred some citations which would be discussed in due course. 03. On the other hand, Learned Counsels for the respondent-claimants submitted that although the claim was filed under Section 166 of the M.V. Act but it is liberty of the claimant-petitioners either to ought any of the forums to claim compensation. Furthermore, the appellant before the Learned Tribunal below did not raise any issue in this regard regarding maintainability of the proceeding. So, at this stage, there is no scope to accept the contention raised by Learned Counsel for the appellant. Learned Counsel for the claimants further submitted that there was no infirmity in the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below and the determination of amount of Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of love and affection was proper by the Tribunal and in support of her contention, she referred one citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in (2021) 2 SCC 166. Learned Counsel for the claimants further submitted that in this case, the Learned Tribunal below awarded rate of interest @7% per annum which should be 9% in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the said judgment. Finally, Learned Counsel for the claimants submitted that as there is no infirmity in the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below, so, there is no merit in the appeal filed by the appellant and urged for dismissal of this appeal with cost. Learned Counsel for the owner of the vehicle fairly submitted that the owner of the offending vehicle had valid documents including insurance coverage on the day of accident. 04. Here in the case at hand, the respondent- claimants filed one claim-petition before the Learned MAC Tribunal, Dhalai, Ambassa. The gist of the claim-petition filed by the claimant-petitioners was in short is that on 09.12.2021 at about 2130 hours, when Padaram Reang (since dead) after boarding in a vehicle bearing No.TR04-1911 (Bolero Maxi Truck) which was attached to the DWS Department, Government of Tripura on hire, for the purpose of supplying water in the interior village of Gandacherra, Ganganagar area was proceeding towards Ganganagar from Gandacherra, that time on the way the driver of the said vehicle dashed with a teak tree at Ramnagar turning of Salbagan due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of the said vehicle. As a result of which, Padaram Reang and the driver of the vehicle suffered severe injuries. Immediately, thereafter, both the injured brought to Gandacherra Hospital where Padaram Reang succumbed to his injuries. According to the respondent-claimants, the accident took place due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending truck bearing No.TR04-1911 (Bolero Maxi Truck). In this regard, a specific case vide Gandacherra PS case No.38 of 2021 under Section 279/304A IPC was registered. It was further submitted by the respondent-claimants that at the time of accident, the deceased was a temporary Pump Operator under the DWS Department, Government of Tripura and his monthly wages was Rs.4,400/- and more so, the deceased was also a Jhum Cultivator by profession and used to earn Rs.15,400/- per month by way of jhum cultivation and in total he used to earn Rs.20,000/- per month and he was 33 years old at the time of death. Hence, the respondent-claimants filed the claim-petition before the Tribunal. The owner of the offending vehicle as OPW-1 appeared before the Tribunal and filed written statement denying the allegation raised in the claim-petition and submitted that he was the registered owner of the vehicle bearing registration No.TR04-1911 at the time of accident and it was duly insured with the Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. vide policy No.322794/31/2022/116. The O.P. No.2, i.e. the driver of the offending vehicle inspite of receiving notice did not appear before the Tribunal, so, the proceeding was proceeded exparte against him. The Insurance Company i.e. O.P. No.3 appeared and submitted that there was no cause of action to file the claim-petition and denied the assertions of the respondentclaimants in their claim-petition and further submitted that the claim-petition was subjected to strict proof. 05. Learned Tribunal below upon the pleadings of the parties framed the following issues: (I) Whether the claim petition filed by the claimantpetitioners U/S-166 of MV Act maintainable in its present form and nature? (II) Whether the deceased Padaram Reang died out of a road traffic accident occurred on 09.12.2021 at about 21- 30 hrs at Ramnagar turning of shalbagan on Gandacherra-Ambassa road at about 7KM west from Gandacherra Police Station? (III) Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of the vehicle bearing registration No- TR-041911(Bolero Maxi Truck)? (IV) Whether the claimant-petitioners are entitled to get compensation as claimed for? If so, what should be the quantum of compensation and to what extent and who will make the payment of compensation? (V) What other relief(s) the parties to this case are entitle to get? To substantiate the issues, the respondent claimants have adduced oral/documentary evidence on record. For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein below the names of the witnesses of the respondent-claimants and their exhibited documents. Plaintiff’s witnesses: PW-1: Smt. Dampa Rung Reang @ Damparung Reang @ Dampaurang Reang. PW-2: Shri Lum Bahadur Thapa. PW-3: Shri Mungthangha Reang. Plaintiff’s Exhibits: (i) Exhibit P-1 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the printed FIR in connection with Gandacherra Police Station Case No. 2021/GNC/038, dated 10.12.2021, in 2 (two) sheets. (ii)Exhibit P-2 (as a whole)- Certified copy of written Ejahar. (iii) Exhibit P-3 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the seizure list dated 10.12.2021 with a prayer of Investigating Officer, in 2 (two) sheets. (iv) Exhibit P-4 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the hand-sketch map in connection with Gandacherra Police Station Case No. 2021/GNC/038, dated 10.12.2021. (v) Exhibit P-5 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the index of the hand-sketch map in connection with Gandacherra Police Station Case No. 2021/GNC/038, dated 10.12.2021. (vi) Exhibit P-6 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the inquest report over the dead body of the deceased Padharam Reang. (vii) Exhibit P-7 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the Autopsy Report of the deceased Padharam Reang, in 3 (three) sheets. (viii) Exhibit P-8 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the joint PO visit report in connection with Gandacherra Police Station Case No. 2021/GNC/038, dated 10.12.2021. (ix) Exhibit P-9 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the Final Report (under Section 173 Cr.P.C.), in 10 (ten) sheets. (x) Exhibit P-10 (as a whole)- Certified copy of the detailed accident report with a prayer from the Investigating Officer, in 18 (eighteen) sheets. (xi) Exhibit P-11 (as a whole)- Photocopy of Survival Certificate of the legal heirs of the deceased Pada Ram Reang (compared with the original). (xii) Exhibit P-12 (as a whole)- Photocopy of Pupilage Certificate of Late Pada Ram Reang (compared with the original). (xiii) Exhibit P-13 (as a whole)Photocopy of Aadhaar Card of Late Pada Ram Reang (compared with the original). 06. On the other hand, the O.P. No.1 has examined as OPW-1 and he relied upon certain documents which were also marked as Exhibits in the claim-petition: Opposite Party’s Exhibits: (i) Exhibit: D-1 (as a whole)- Xerox copy of certificate of registration of vehicle bearing No. TR04-1911 (compared with original). (ii) Exhibit: D-2 (as a whole)- Xerox copy of Insurance Certificate of vehicle bearing registration No. TR04-1911 (compared with original). (iii) Exhibit: D-3 (as a whole)- Certified copy of seizure list dated 15-12-2021 in connection with Gandacherra PS Case No. 2021/GNC/038, dated 10-12-2021 for the commission of the offences punishable under Sections 279/304A of the IPC. But the O.P-3, i.e. the present appellant did not adduce any oral/documentary evidence on record in support of their defence. 07. Finally, on conclusion of the proceeding, the Learned Tribunal below allowed the claim-petition by the judgment and award dated 18.11.2023. For the sake of convenience, the operative portion of the judgment and award of the dated 18.11.2023 of the Tribunal below runs as follows: Order “Resultantly, the application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the claimant-petitioners is allowed on contest. Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of Rs.33,19,360/- (rupees thirty three lacs nineteen thousands three hundred sixty) only with 7.5% Simple interest per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 03-06-2022 till the date of realization thereof. Out of the total awarded amount, Rs. 1,00,000/shall be paid to the wife of the deceased, i.e., claimant petitioner No. 1 and the rest amount, i.e., Rs.32,19,360/(Rs.33,19,360/- minus Rs. 1,00,000/-) shall be paid equally among the claimantpetitioners (Petitioner Nos. 1 to 5). The entire share of the claimant petitioner Nos. 1 (wife of deceased) and 5 (mother of deceased) in the award shall be paid to them directly to their individual bank accounts. The entire share of the claimant petitioner Nos. 2, 3 and 4 (minor son and daughters of the deceased) in the award be invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificate from any Nationalized Bank till they attain the age of 18 years and no loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal. However, the claimant petitioner No. 1 shall have the liberty to withdraw the monthly interest from the Fixed Deposit Certificate of her minor son and daughters only for the welfare and benefit of themselves. The Opposite Party No. 3, i.e., The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., B.C. Ambassa, TRTC Complex, Ambassa, PSAmbassa, District- Dhalai Tripura shall deposit the awarded amount along with interest thereon within one month to this Tribunal. Supply a copy of this award free of cost to the parties by not later than 15 days from the date of the award. The case stands disposed of on contest.” Challenging that judgment, this appeal is preferred before this High Court. 08. I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides and gone through the citations referred by the parties and also perused the record of the Learned Tribunal below. Admittedly, in this case, there is no dispute on record regarding the fact and accident on the alleged day i.e. on 09.12.2021 and also the fact of death of the deceased Padaram Reang due to said accident. Now, we are to see whether the claim-petition preferred by the respondent-claimants was maintainable before the Learned Tribunal below. On perusal of the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below, it appears that at the time of delivery of judgment, Learned Tribunal below framed one specific issue regarding maintainability of the proceeding. Before the Learned Tribunal below, the present appellant did not submit any objection in this regard, nor raised any argument on this point before the Tribunal. So, the Learned Tribunal below regarding maintainability of the petition decided the same infavour of the respondent-claimants. 09. Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in National Insurance Company Ltd. versus Mastan And Anr. dated 09.12.2005 reported in (2006) 2 SCC 641, wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para Nos.33 and 34 observed as under: “33. On the establishment of a Claims Tribunal in terms of Section 165 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, the victim of a motor accident has a right to apply for compensation in terms of Section 166 of that Act before that Tribunal. On the establishment of the Claims Tribunal, the jurisdiction of the civil court to entertain a claim for compensation arising out of a motor accident, stands ousted by Section 175 of that Act. Until the establishment of the Tribunal, the claim had to be enforced through the civil court as a claim in tort. The exclusiveness of the jurisdiction of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal is taken away by Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act in one instance, when the claim could also fall under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. That section provides that death or bodily injury arising out of a motor accident which may also give rise to a claim for compensation under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, can be enforced through the authorities under that Act, the option in that behalf being with the victim or his representative. But Section 167 makes it clear that a claim could not be maintained under both the Acts. In other words, a claimant who becomes entitled to claim compensation under both the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and the Workmen’s Compensation Act, because of a motor vehicle accident has the choice of proceeding under either of the Acts before the forum concerned. By confining the claim to the authority or the Tribunal under either of the Acts, the legislature has incorporated the concept of election of remedies, insofar as the claimant is concerned. In other words, he has to elect whether to make his claim under the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 or under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. The emphasis in the section that a claim cannot be made under both the enactments, is a further reiteration of the doctrine of election incorporated in the scheme for claiming compensation. The principle “where, either of the two alternative Tribunals are open to a litigant, each having jurisdiction over the matters in dispute, and he resorts for his remedy to one of such Tribunals in preference to the other, he is precluded, as against his opponent, from any subsequent recourse to the latter” (see R. v. Evans:(1854) 3 E & B 363: 118 ER 1178 is fully incorporated in the scheme of Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act, precluding the claimant who has invoked the Workmen’s Compensation Act from having resort to the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, except to the limited extent permitted therein. The claimant having resorted to the Workmen’s Compensation Act, is controlled by the provisions of that Act subject only to the exception recognized in Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act. 34. On the language of Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act, and going by the principle of election of remedies, a claimant opting to proceed under the Workmen’s Compensation Act cannot take recourse to or draw inspiration from any of the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 other than what is specifically saved by Section 167 of the Act. Section 167 of the Act gives a claimant even under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, the right to invoke the provisions of Chapter X of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. Chapter X of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 deals with what is known as “no fault” liability in case of an accident. Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 imposes a liability on the owner of the vehicle to pay the compensation fixed therein, even if no fault is established against the driver or owner of the vehicle. Sections 141 and 142 deal with particular claims on the basis of no fault liability on the owner of the vehicle to pay the compensation fixed therein, even if no fault is established against the driver or owner of the vehicle. Sections 141 and 142 deal with particular claims on the basis of no fault liability and Section 143 re-emphasises what is emphasised by Section 167 of the Act that the provisions of Chapter X of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, would apply even if the claim is made under the Workmen’s Compensation Act. Section 144 of the Act gives the provisions of Chapter X of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 an overriding effect.” On perusal of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforesaid case, it appears that it is the liberty of the claimants to prefer any of the method for seeking compensation. The claimant in such a situation, may claim compensation under the M.V. Act or under the Employees’ Compensation Act. Here in the given case, the respondentclaimants filed the claim-petition under Section 166 of M.V. Act and regarding maintainability of the case, a specific issue was framed by the Learned Tribunal below and the present appellant did not raise any objection before the Tribunal regarding maintainability of the claim-petition. So, it appears that the Learned Tribunal below rightly decided the said issue in favour of the respondent-claimants. So, as submitted by Learned Counsel for the appellant, that the suit was not maintainable, cannot be accepted in the eye of law. More so, Section 167 of M.V. Act protects the claim-petition filed by the claimant. 10. Now, regarding determination of award amounting to Rs.1,00,000/- towards love and affection, Learned Counsel for the appellant in course of hearing of argument relied upon few judgments: Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Others dated 31.10.2017 reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680 wherein in para No.52 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under: “52. As far as the conventional heads are concerned, we find it difficult to agree with the view expressed in Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh: (2013) 9 SCC 54. It has granted Rs. 25,000 towards funeral expenses, Rs. 1,00,000 loss of consortium and Rs. 1,00,000 towards loss of care and guidance for minor children. The head relating to loss of care and minor children does not exist. Though Rajesh (supra) refers to Santosh Devi, it does not seem to follow the same. The conventional and traditional heads, needless to say, cannot be determined on percentage basis because that would not be an acceptable criterion. Unlike determination of income, the said heads have to be quantified. Any quantification must have a reasonable foundation. There can be no dispute over the fact that price index, fall in bank interest, escalation of rates in many a field have to be noticed. The court cannot remain oblivious to the same. There has been a thumb rule in this aspect. Otherwise, there will be extreme difficulty in determination of the same and unless the thumb rule is applied, there will be immense variation lacking any kind of consistency as a consequence of which, the orders passed by the tribunals and courts are likely to be unguided. Therefore, we think it seemly to fix reasonable sums. It seems to us that reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs. 15,000, Rs. 40,000 and Rs. 15,000 respectively. The principle of revisiting the said heads is an acceptable principle. But the revisit should not be fact-centric or quantum-centric. We think that it would be condign that the amount that we have quantified should be enhanced on percentage basis in every three years and the enhancement should be at the rate of 10% in a span of three years. We are disposed to hold so because that will bring in consistency in respect of those heads. Further, Hon’ble the Apex Court in another citation in United India Insurance Company Limited vs. Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur and Others dated 30.06.2020 reported in (2021) 11 SCC 780 wherein in para Nos.34 and 35 observed as under: “34. At this stage, we consider it necessary to provide uniformity with respect to the grant of consortium, and loss of love and affection. Several Tribunals and High Courts have been awarding compensation for both loss of consortium and loss of love and affection. The Constitution Bench in Pranay Sethi (supra), has recognized only three conventional heads under which compensation can be awarded viz. loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. In Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram: (2018) 18 SCC 130, this Court gave a comprehensive interpretation to consortium to include spousal consortium, parental consortium, as well as filial consortium. Loss of love and affection is comprehended in loss of consortium. 35. The Tribunals and High Courts are directed to award compensation for loss of consortium, which is a legitimate conventional head. There is no justification to award compensation towards loss of love and affection as a separate head.” In another citation, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in Janabai WD/O Dinnkarrao Ghorpade and others vs. ICICI Lambord Insurance Company Limited dated 10.08.2022 reported in (2022) 10 SCC 512 wherein in para Nos.13 and 14 observed as under: “13. The appellants have not filed any appeal seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the Tribunal before the High Court. The Constitution Bench judgment in National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi (supra), was rendered when the appeal was pending before the High Court but since the appeal filed by the Insurance Company was accepted, there was no occasion for the High Court to examine the question of enhancement of compensation. We find that the appellants are entitled to enhanced compensation particularly in respect of future prospects and other damages in terms of the judgment of this Court in Pranay Sethi (supra). Therefore, in exercise of powers conferred under Article 142 of the Constitution, we have decided to recompute the amount of compensation to be in tune with the Constitution Bench judgment. 14. The appellant has claimed compensation on account of love and affection as well on account of spousal consortium for wife and for the parental consortium for the children in the calculation given to this Court but in view of three-Judge Bench judgment reported as United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur: (2021) 11 SCC 780, the compensation under the head on account of loss of love and affection is not permissible but compensation on account of spousal consortium for wife and for the parental consortium for children is admissible. This Court held as under: (SCC pp. 797-98, paras 30-35) “30. In Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram:[Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram: (2018) 18 SCC 130 this Court interpreted “consortium” to be a compendious term, which encompasses spousal consortium, parental consortium, as well as filial consortium. The right to consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort, guidance, solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his family. With respect to a spouse, it would include sexual relations with the deceased spouse. 31. Parental consortium is granted to the child upon the premature death of a parent, for loss of parental aid, protection, affection, society, discipline, guidance and training. Filial consortium is the right of the parents to compensation in the case of an accidental death of a child. An accident leading to the death of a child causes great shock and agony to the parents and family of the deceased. The greatest agony for a parent is to lose their child during their lifetime. Children are valued for their love and affection, and their role in the family unit. 32. Modern jurisdictions world over have recognised that the value of a child's consortium far exceeds the economic value of the compensation awarded in the case of the death of a child. Most jurisdictions permit parents to be awarded compensation under the loss of consortium on the death of a child. The amount awarded to the parents is the compensation for loss of love and affection, care and companionship of the deceased child. 33. The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is a beneficial legislation which has been framed with the object of providing relief to the victims, or their families, in cases of genuine claims. In case where a parent has lost their minor child, or unmarried son or daughter, the parents are entitled to be awarded loss of consortium under the head of filial consortium. Parental consortium is awarded to the children who lose the care and protection of their parents in motor vehicle accidents. The amount to be awarded for loss consortium will be as per the amount fixed in Pranay Sethi (supra). 34. At this stage, we consider it necessary to provide uniformity with respect to the grant of consortium, and loss of love and affection. Several Tribunals and the High Courts have been awarding compensation for both loss of consortium and loss of love and affection. The Constitution Bench in Pranay Sethi (supra), has recognised only three conventional heads under which compensation can be awarded viz. loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. In Magma General (supra), this Court gave a comprehensive interpretation to consortium to include spousal consortium, parental consortium, as well as filial consortium. Loss of love and affection is comprehended in loss of consortium. 35. The Tribunals and the High Courts are directed to award compensation for loss of consortium, which is a legitimate conventional head. There is no justification to award compensation towards loss of love and affection as a separate head.” Referring the same citations, Learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that the determination of award amounting to Rs.1,00,000/- towards love and affection was not proper by the Tribunal and the same was beyond the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the afore-noted cases and urged for deducting the said amount from the award. 11. Per contra, Learned Counsel for the respondent- claimants drawn the attention of the Court referring another judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in (2021) 2 SCC 166. Referring the same, she submitted that in the said case, Rs.2,50,000/- was awarded towards funeral charges and loss of estate and rate of interest was given at the rate of 9% per annum. 12. I have gone through the aforesaid citations referred by Learned Counsel for the appellant and also Learned Counsel for the respondent-claimants and it appears that here in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the citations as referred by Learned Counsel for the appellants seems to be more appropriate. There was no scope on the part of the Learned Tribunal to determine any award towards love and affection amounting to Rs. 1,00,000/-, which in my considered view, Learned Tribunal below committed error in determining the said amount. Now, regarding the monthly income amounting Rs.14,600/-, it appears that Learned Tribunal below at the time of delivery of judgment first of all considered the monthly income/wages as a temporary pump operator Rs.4,600/-. Thereafter, Learned Tribunal below further taken into consideration Rs.10,000/- as notional income for unskilled labourer in view of the notification dated 04.08.2023 issued by this High Court. Then, after adding both the amounts determined the monthly income of the deceased at 14,600/per month which in my considered view was not proper. Learned Tribunal could opt either any of the amount because if the notification of the High Court was determined, in that case, there was no scope to take into consideration the said amount of Rs.4,600/- i.e. the monthly wages of the deceased. However, the accident took place in the year 2021. The respondentclaimants took the plea that the deceased was also a Jhumia Cultivator in addition to his temporary work as pump operator. But in this regard, no such documentary evidence could be adduced by the respondent-claimants before the Tribunal. However, considering the prevalent market price of the year 2021, assuming that the deceased was a daily rated worker. His monthly income could be assessed to Rs.12,000/- per month in place of Rs.14,600/- per month, as Tribunal below committed error in calculating the said amount, i.e. Learned Tribunal below without any basis clubbed both the income which in my view was not proper. But since, in addition to temporary pump operator, the deceased was also a daily labour and he belongs to Gandacherra, a remote area of Tripura. So, considering all, this Court is of the considered view to determine Rs.12,000/per month as his monthly income i.e. his wages as temporary pump operator and the balance amount is considered towards his income as a labour of jhum cultivation. 13. Furthermore, it also appears that Learned Tribunal below at the time of awarding compensation awarded monthly interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum. But in this regard, there is no any specific guideline by any High Courts. Even the Hon’ble Apex Court also in some cases has awarded interest at the rate of 9% per annum. 14. So, considering the judgment referred by Learned Counsel for the respondent-claimants, it appears that at the time of determination of compensation, the Tribunal wrongly calculated the rate of interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum which should be 9% per annum with effect from the date of filing of claim-petition to till the date of realization. 15. Thus, in the given case the compensation would be recalculated as follows: (i) Income per month= Rs.12,000/- only. (ii) 40% of the award to be added as future prospects= Rs.4,800/(iii) The sum total of (i) and (ii) works at= Rs.16,800/(iv) One fourth (1/4) of the said amount to be deducted as personal and living expenses of deceased= Rs.16,800-(minus) ¼ of Rs.16,800/-) i.e. Rs.12,600/(v) Compensation after applying multiplier of 16= Rs.12,600/- x 12 x 16= Rs.24,19,200/-, as per Pranay Sethi (Supra) and Sarala Verma judgment. 16. So, the respondent-claimants under the head loss of income would be awarded Rs.24,19,200/- in place of 33,19,360/- awarded by the Tribunal below. In addition to that the respondent-claimants also would get compensation towards loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. The Tribunal below awarded Rs.18,000/- towards loss of estate, Rs.18,000/- towards funeral expenses and for the five claimants awarded Rs.2,40,000/- as loss of consortium. Since, there was no objection to this aforesaid amount, so, the same is also accordingly, awarded in favour of the respondent-claimants. Thus, the total compensation after modification would comes to Rs. 18,000/-+ Rs.18,000/-+ Rs.2,40,000/- + Rs.24,19,200/-= Rs.26,95,200/-. Since, the Learned Tribunal below fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon the present appellant and there is no dispute on record in this regard, so, the present appellant shall pay the aforesaid amount with interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing the claim-petition to till the date of actual payment to the claimants. 17. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby partly allowed. The respondent-claimant-petitioners would entitled to get Rs.26,95,200/- along with 9% interest per annum from the date of filing the claim-petition till the date of actual payment. The appellant be asked to deposit the said amount either to the Registry of this High Court or to the Learned Tribunal below within a period of two months from the date of passing of this judgment. The disbursal of amount to the respondent-claimants would be made as per the observation made by the Learned Tribunal below by judgment dated 18.11.2023. With this observation, this appeal is disposed of and modified to the extent as stated above. Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment. A copy of this judgment/award also be furnished to the Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company for compliance. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. JUDGE MOUMITA DATTA DATTA Date: 2024.10.01 16:18:12 +05'30' Purnita

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Tripura HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →