Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP. NO.115 OF 2024
The Branch Manager National Insurance Company Ltd.
…… Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Jayanta Debnath and anr.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Shubajit Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. S. Das, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
Ms. Saswanti Nag, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 04.04.2025
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 has been filed by the appellant-Insurance Company,
challenging the Judgment and Award dated 31.08.2023, passed by
the
Learned
Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
South
Tripura,
Sabroom, in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 13 of 2022.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that on 30.06.2016,
when the victim was proceeding towards his home by boarding the
vehicle bearing No. TR-08-2580 (Auto-Rickshaw), and when it
reached the Manu River Bridge, due to the rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the Auto-Rickshaw, it dashed against the
left-side iron railing of the bridge. As a result, the victim sustained
grievous fracture injuries on his leg. Immediately after the accident,
the victim was taken to Manubazar Primary Health Centre, from
where he was referred to GBP Hospital, Agartala for treatment. The
claimant-respondent, i.e., Respondent No.1 herein, on 25.02.2020
filed an application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 for granting compensation of Rs.13,38,000/- due to the
injuries sustained by the victim in the alleged accident that took
place on 30.06.2016. After hearing the parties and upon conclusion
of the trial, the Learned Tribunal below passed the Judgment and
Award dated 31.08.2023, whereby the petition under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act was allowed. The Claimant-Respondent No.1
was awarded a sum of Rs.3,65,000/- (Rupees Three Lakh Sixty-Five
Thousand only) with interest thereon at the rate of 9% per annum,
effective from the date of filing the claim application i.e., from
25.02.2020 till realization. Against the impugned Judgment and
Award, which is claimed to be excessive and erroneous, the
appellant-Insurance Company has preferred the instant appeal.
3.
Heard Mr. Shubhajit Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the appellant-Insurance Company, as well as Ms. S.
Nag, learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.1.
4.
When the case is called, learned counsel for the
appellant-Insurance
Company
places
on
record
the
proof
of
payment of Rs.20,000/- in compliance with the Order passed by this
Court dated 10.02.2025. Accordingly, the Order dated 10.02.2025
of this Court stands complied with, and the condone delay
application is closed. Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the
appellant-Insurance Company, submits that the learned Tribunal
erred in law in fastening the liability to pay compensation upon the
appellant-Insurance Company. He contends that the impugned
Judgment and Award dated 31.08.2023 is unsustainable in law and
deserves to be set aside or suitably modified. Learned counsel
submits that the driver of the offending vehicle, bearing registration
No. TR-08-2580 (Auto-Rickshaw), held only a Non-Transport driving
license at the time of the accident, which is a clear violation of
Section 3 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. He further refers to the
charge sheet filed in the matter, wherein it is specifically mentioned
that the Owner-cum-Driver (Respondent No.2) was operating the
vehicle without the requisite authorization, thereby committing an
offence under Section 182 of the Motor Vehicles Act. It is further
submitted that the Owner-cum-Driver violated the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy by driving the vehicle without a
valid transport license and without producing any valid route permit
for the said Auto-Rickshaw on the date of the accident. These
violations, according to the appellant, exonerate the Insurance
Company from any liability to pay compensation, and the burden of
compensation should rightfully shift to the Owner-cum-Driver, i.e.,
Respondent No.2. In light of these submissions, learned counsel for
the appellant-Insurance Company prays that the appeal be allowed,
and the impugned Judgment and Award passed by the learned
Tribunal be set aside.
5.
The claimant and the owner of the vehicle alone deposed
in the case before the learned Tribunal. The appellant did not
present any witness or take steps to produce evidence before the
learned Tribunal. The Insurance Company made no attempt to
substantiate its case during the trial. Having chosen to remain
passive and silent during the proceedings before the learned
Tribunal, it is now impermissible for the appellant to raise new
contentions or challenge factual findings before this Court. The
Insurance Company, having failed to discharge its burden of proof
or contest the claim effectively at the trial stage, cannot now seek
to re-argue its case on merits.
6.
At times such careless and indifferent approach by
the Insurance Company directly contributed in the awarding of a
higher compensation amount. Such conduct reflects a lack of
seriousness in defending the claim and results in misuse of public
funds, as insurance payouts are ultimately sourced from public
contributions in the form of premiums. When officers of a public or
government-run Insurance Company fail to fulfill their duties, the
financial burden falls on the public, leading to increased premiums
and loss of trust in the system.
7.
This Court is of the considered view that such
behavior must not go unchecked and that accountability must be
fixed on the officers responsible for mishandling the case despite it
is intentional or due to negligence or mistake for whatever the
reasons.
8.
This Court has previously held in several matters
that, in cases of laches and non-performance of duties by officers,
as required under their service conditions, the resulting loss and
hardship caused to the institution cannot be attributed to the
institution itself. Instead, the liability should be fastened upon the
erring
officers
whose
actions
led
to
such
outcomes.
Any
compensation decided in this regard must be recovered from the
concerned erring officer, and the burden cannot be imposed upon
the institution, which would, in turn, shift the burden onto innocent
citizens by collecting enhanced premiums in subsequent years.This
principle was laid down by this Court in reported judgments such as
MAC. APP. No. 89 of 2023, titled as Oriental Insurance
Company
vs.
Smt.
Aparna
Nath
and
Others,
dated
22.07.2024; MFA(FA) No. 02 of 2023, titled as The Tripura
State Electricity Corporation Ltd. and Others vs. Smti.
Kamalapati Kaloi and Others, dated 11.07.2024; and MAC.
APP. No. 94 of 2023, titled as The United India Insurance Co.
Ltd.
vs.
Smti.
Champa
Rani
Saha
and
Others,
dated
17.01.2025.
9.
Along the same lines, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India, in its judgment passed in Civil Appeal No. 1876 of 2016,
titled as Central Bank of India and Others vs. Smt. Prabha
Jain and Others, and its Judgment reported in (2021) 3 SCC
806, titled as Boloram Bordoloi vs. Lakhimi Gaolia Bank and
Others, has taken the view that if any loan is disbursed by erring
officers in contravention of their service conditions, the liability
cannot be fastened upon the Bank. Instead, such liability must be
also borne upon the concerned officer/manager whose actions led to
the erosion of public trust in the Bank and the Bank employee is
liable to be actioned against him.
10.
The relevant paragraphs from the said Hon’ble
Supreme Court Judgments are referred here-under:-
i. Para-44 of Central Bank of India and ors. Vs.
Smt. Prabha Jain:“44. Before we close this litigation, we
deem it necessary to observe that Banks should remain very
careful with inadequate title clearance reports, more particularly,
when such reports are obtained cheaply and at times for external
reasons. This concerns the protection of public money and is in
the larger public interest. Therefore, it is essential for the Reserve
Bank of India and other stakeholders to collaborate in developing
a standardized and practical approach for preparing title search
report before sanctioning loans and also for the purpose of
determining liability (including potential criminal action) of the
Officer who approves loan. Additionally, there should be standard
guidelines for fees and costs associated with title search reports
so as to ensure that they maintain high quality.
ii. Para-13 of Boloram Bordoloi Vs. Lakhimi Gaolia
Bank and ors(supra):“13. The manager of a bank plays a vital role in
managing the affairs of the bank. A bank officer/employee deals
with the public money. The nature of his work demands vigilance
with the inbuilt requirement to act carefully. If an officer/employee
of the bank is allowed to act beyond his authority, the discipline of
the bank will disappear. When the procedural guidelines are issued
for grant of loans, officers/employees are required to follow the
same meticulously and any deviation will lead to erosion of public
trust on the banks. If the manager of a bank indulges in such
misconduct, which is evident from the charge memo dated
18.06.2004 and the findings of the enquiry officer, it indicates that
such charges are grave and serious. Inspite of proved misconduct
on such serious charges, disciplinary authority itself was liberal in
imposing the punishment of compulsory retirement. In that view of
the matter, it cannot be said that the punishment imposed in the
disciplinary proceedings on the appellant, is disproportionate to the
gravity of charges. As such, this submission of the learned counsel
for the appellant also cannot be accepted.”
11.
Accordingly,
the
appeal
stands
dismissed,
confirming the impugned Judgment and Award as passed by the
learned Tribunal below. The entire awarded amount as determined
by the learned Tribunal is to be paid by the appellant-Insurance
Company to the claimant within a period of 1(one) month from
today.
12.
The Insurance Company shall recover the said
amount from the erring officers responsible for handling the matter
relating to this Motor Accident Claim, who failed to act with due
diligence, resulting in an adverse outcome. The claimant is
permitted to withdraw the said amount upon deposit as per
procedure. The Registry is directed to do the needful.
13.
A copy of this judgment be marked to the Chairman
and Managing Director, National Insurance Company Ltd., Ms.
Rajeshwari Singh Muni, at the Company Head Office located at
Premises No. 18-0374, Plot No. CBD-81, New Town, Kolkata700156 to get the compensation paid to the claimant and recover
the same from the erred officers of the Insurance Company.
14.
As a sequel, any stay stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any, also stand closed.
JUDGE
Suhanjit
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SINGHA
SUHANJIT SINGHA Date: 2025.04.10 13:11:50 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review