Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
M.A.C. App. No.24 of 2024
Along With
M.A.C. App. No.97 of 2024
IN M.A.C. App. No.24 of 2024
Sri Dipak Majumder,
Son of Sri Phanibhusan Majumder,
aged about 45 years,
resident of Nandannagar, P.S.- New Capital Complex,
District- West Tripura.
(as the appellant is unable to move, he is represented
by his wife, Smt. Anita Choudhury (Majumder),
wife of Dipak Majumder, resident of Nandannagar,
P.S.- New Capital Complex, District-West Tripura).
......Claimant-Petitioner-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. (A) Smt. Sadhana Chakraborty (Sharma),
W/O Late Nepal Sharma,
Resident of Gandhigram,
Airport, Mohanpur, P.S.-Airport,
District-West Tripura, P.O.- Gandhigram,
Pin-799012.
1. (B) Nayan Sharma,
S/O Late Nepal Sharma,
Resident of Gandhigram,
Airport, Mohanpur, P.S.- Airport,
District- West Tripura,
P.O.- Gandhigram, Pin-799012.
1. (C)Smt. Nisha Sharma,
D/O Lt. Nepal Sharma,
Resident of Gandhigram, Airport,
Mohanpur, P.S.-Airport, District-West Tripura,
P.O.-Gandhigram, Pin-799012.
(Legal heirs of the registered owner of the offending
vehicle bearing its registration No.TR-01-H-2593,
Auto).
2. The Branch Manager,
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Ltd. of 3rd
Floor, Aitorma, Agartala Sentrum, Sakuntala road,
P.S.- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
P.O.- Agartala, Pin-799001
(Insurer of the offending vehicle No.TR-01-H-2593
(Auto)).
……Respondent-OPS
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Subhajit Chakraborty, Adv.
IN M.A.C. App. No.97 of 2024
The Branch Manager,
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited
Having its Branch Office at Agartala,
3rd Floor, Aitorma Centrum Agartala,
Sakuntala Road, Near Metro Bazar,
P.S.- West Agartala, District-West Tripura,
(Insurer of the vehicle No.TR-01-H-2593 Auto
Rickshaw)
...... Appellant
Versus
1. Dipak Majumder,
S/O Sri Phani Bhushan Majumder,
Of Nandan Nagar, P.S. NCC., District-West Tripura.
To be represented by his wife
Smt. Anita Chowdhury (Majumder)
W/O Sri Dipak Majumder of Nandan Nagar,
P.S. NCC., District-West Tripura.
(As the injured Dipak Majumder can’t move properly,
the wife of the injured namely Smt. Anita Chowdhury
(Majumder) will represent her husband Dipak
Majumder
...... Claimant Respondent
2. (A) Smt. Sadhana Chakraborty (Sharma),
W/O Late Nepal Sharma
2. (B)Nayan Sharma,
S/O Late Nepal Sharma
2. (C)Smt. Nisha Sharma,
D/O Lt. Nepal Sharma
All are residing at Gandhigram, Airport, Mohanpur,
West, P.S.-Airport, District-West Tripura.
(Legal heirs of the registered owner of the vehicle
No.TR-01-H-2593 Auto Rickshaw namely Lt. Nepal
Sharma, S/O Lt. Rai Haran Sharma)
……Owner Respondents
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Subhajit Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Adv.
Date of Hearing
of Judgment and
Order
: 19.09.2025
Date of
Delivery of
Judgment and
Order
: 24.09.2025
Whether fit for
Reporting
: YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Both the appeals are taken up together for
hearing and disposal as because both the appeals have
arisen out of the common judgment and award dated
12.10.2023 delivered by Learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No.5, West Tripura, Agartala.
02.
The MAC App. No.24 of 2024 is preferred by the
claimant-petitioner as appellant for enhancement of the
award and the MAC App. No.97 of 2024 has been preferred
by the appellant Insurance Company i.e. Bajaj Allianz
General
Insurance
aside/modification
of
Company
the
Limited
judgment
and
for
setting
award
dated
12.10.2023 delivered by Learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No.5, West Tripura, Agartala in the said
case. Both the appeals are filed under Section 173 of MV Act,
1988.
03.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh appearing on
behalf of the claimant-petitioner-appellant (in MAC App.
No.24 of 2024) and respondent-claimant (in MAC App.97 of
2024). Also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Chakraborty
appearing on behalf of the respondent (in MAC App. No.24 of
2024) and appellant-Insurance Company (in MAC App.97 of
2024) (hereinafter referred to as “respondent-Insurance
Company”).
04.
By
the
said
judgment
and
award,
Learned
Tribunal below has awarded a sum of Rs.69,55,000/- with
interest @7% per annum from the date of filing the claim
petition i.e. w.e.f. 29.04.2022 to till the date of realization
and fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon
the respondent-Insurance Company.
05.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel, Mr.
S. Lodh appearing on behalf of the appellant in connection
with MAC App. No.24/2024 (hereinafter referred to as
“appellant-claimant petitioner) first of all drawn the attention
of the Court, referring Para No.4 of the judgment and award
delivered by the Learned Tribunal below, wherein in Para No.
4 it was specifically mentioned that no written statement is
filed
by
the
respondent-Insurance
Company,
though
summon/notice was duly served upon them.
06.
Similarly, in Para-6, Learned Tribunal below at the
time of deciding Issue No.(ii) came to the observation that
none appeared on behalf of the OP No.2 during argument.
So, referring the said observation of the Learned Tribunal
below, Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh appearing on behalf of
the appellant-claimant petitioner submitted that in view of
the settled position of law there is/was no scope on the part
of the Insurance Company to prefer the appeal i.e. MAC App.
No.97 of 2024 before this Court.
07.
In this regard, Learned Counsel for the appellant-
claimant petitioner referred the judgment of a coordinate
bench of this High Court in MAC App. No.61 of 2025, dated
07.07.2025, wherein in Para No.-7, the coordinate bench of
this High Court observed as under:“[7] It is also seen from the record that to deny the
case of claimant (respondent herein) the insurance
company has not taken any steps to lead their
evidence and to demolish the claimants case. It is not
open for the insurance company to improve their case
in appeal when there was no witness on behalf of the
insurance company. It is also not open for insurance
company to prefer an appeal when they have not taken
their defense and to prove their case for dismissing the
claim before the tribunal.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel has drawn
the attention of the Court that since the respondentInsurance Company before the Learned Tribunal below did
not
file
any
written
statement
nor
adduced
any
oral/documentary evidence on record.
In such a situation,
there is no scope for the respondent-insurance company to
prefer any appeal before this Court. Since the claimant has
made the Insurance Company as party so without going to
that aspect by a common judgment the appeals are disposed
of on merit.
08.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-claimant
petitioner thereafter drawn the attention of the Court that in
Para No.-22 of the judgment Learned Tribunal below opined
that the claimant petitioner submitted that he used to earn
Rs.35,000/- from his business and relied upon the income
certificate issued by DCM which was marked as Exhibit-19.
But, the Learned Tribunal below determined the monthly
income of deceased at Rs.15,000/- only on the ground that
the salary certificate (Exbt.19) could not be proved by the
appellant by adducing the evidence of the issuing authority
i.e. the authority who issued the income certificate. Situated
thus, Learned Tribunal below failed to appreciate Exhibit-19
i.e. the income certificate in accordance with law in absence
of contrary evidence on record from the other side and thus,
came to an erroneous observation for which the interference
of this Court is required.
09.
Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh appearing for the
appellant-claimant petitioner again drawn the attention of
the Court referring Exhibit-19 i.e. the income certificate
wherein the monthly income of the petitioner was shown at
Rs.35,000/- from all sources and the claimant petitioner
relied upon the same, but the contesting OP did not dispute
the same. Even the respondent-Insurance Company as
already stated also did not adduce any oral/documentary
evidence on record to rebut the same.
10.
Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh further submitted
that though the Learned Tribunal below did not consider
Exhibit-19 i.e. income certificate, but the Learned Tribunal
below treated the same as salary certificate. Thereafter,
Learned Counsel also relied upon the examination-in-chief in
affidavit of one Smt. Anita Choudhury (Majumder) wife of
petitioner who in her examination-in-chief in affidavit in Para
No.12, specifically stated that the monthly income of the
appellant-claimant petitioner was Rs.35,000/- which remain
unrebutted by the contesting OP.
11.
Learned Counsel further referred Para No.23 of
the judgment wherein the Learned Tribunal below awarded a
sum of Rs.30,000/- towards actual loss of income and
further submitted that the appellant was admitted in the ILS
hospital and Manipal Hospital, Bangaluru w.e.f. 04.04.2022
to 19.04.2022, 18.05.2022 to 30.05.2022, 17.08.2022 to
20.08.2022, 25.11.2022 to 29.11.2022 and 06.12.2022 to
20.12.2022. The factual condition was that the appellant was
totally in bedridden condition during that period. But, the
Learned Tribunal below only considered actual loss of income
for 53 days when he was admitted in the aforesaid hospitals
which needs to be interfered with.
12.
Further, referring Para No.27, Learned Counsel for
the appellant drawn the attention of the Court that towards
pain and suffering, the Learned Tribunal below only awarded
Rs.2,00,000/- in favour of the appellant-claimant petitioner
which was too less and the said amount needs to be
enhanced. Finally, in summing up, Learned Counsel, Mr.
Lodh drawn the attention of the Court that considering the
materials on record, the judgment and award delivered by
Learned Tribunal below needs to be enhanced and modified
and urged for allowing this appeal.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. Subhajit Chakraborty,
Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondentInsurance Company drawn the attention of the Court that
the Insurance Company has challenged the appeal towards
computation of personal disability, which could not be
properly appreciated/ assessed by the Learned Tribunal
below. In support of his contention, Learned Counsel relied
upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Raj Kumar vs. Ajay Kumar & Anr. reported in (2011) 1
SCC 343, wherein in para No.19, Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:-
“19. We may now
discussed above:
summarise
the
principles
(i) All injuries (or permanent disabilities
arising from injuries), do not result in loss of
earning capacity.
(ii) The percentage of permanent disability
with reference to the whole body of a
person, cannot be assumed to be the
percentage of loss of earning capacity. To
put it differently, the percentage of loss of
earning capacity is not the same as the
percentage of permanent disability (except
in a few cases, where the Tribunal on the
basis of evidence, concludes that the
percentage of loss of earning capacity is the
same as the percentage of permanent
disability).
(iii) The doctor who treated an injured
claimant or who examined him subsequently
to assess the extent of his permanent
disability can give evidence only in regard to
the extent of permanent disability. The loss
of earning capacity is something that will
have to be assessed by the Tribunal with
reference to the evidence in entirety.
(iv) The same permanent disability may
result in different percentages of loss of
earning capacity in different persons,
depending upon the nature of profession,
occupation or job, age, education and other
factors.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted
that in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court, the Learned Tribunal failed to assess the
percentage of disability at the time of delivery of judgment in
favour of the claimant-petitioner for which interference of
this Court is required. Learned Counsel also submitted that in
Para No.28, Learned Tribunal below awarded attendant
charges in favour of the claimant-petitioner, but surprisingly
applied multiplier of 13, resulting which a huge amount of
Rs.15,60,000/- has been awarded towards attendant charges
erroneously in absence of any law for which the interference
of this Court is also required and urged for setting aside and
modification of the judgment delivered by the Learned
Tribunal below.
14.
To counter the submission, Learned Counsel, Mr.
Lodh drawn the attention of the Court that the crossexamination part of PW-2, Dr. Manik Jamatia who in his
examination-in-chief in affidavit, in the last para, submitted
that the injury occurred due to spine and spinal cord
damage, and he further submitted that after five years
improvement may happen and patient can work with
support, but injured cannot work normally in future and
functional disability is 100%. So, Learned Counsel, Mr. Lodh
submitted that there was no infirmity in the judgment
delivered by Learned Tribunal below, save and except
determination of monthly income and as such, urged for
enhancement of the award.
15.
In this case, the appellant-claimant petitioner,
Dipak Majumder filed one claim petition before the Learned
Tribunal seeking compensation due to injury sustained by
him due to a road traffic accident on 04.04.2022 at about
18.00 hours to 18.30 hours at Nandannagar near Quarter
Complex market under NCC PS District-West Tripura. It was
the assertions of the appellant that on 04.04.2022 at about
18.00 hours to 18.30 hours, the appellant-claimant petitioner
Dipak
Majumder
was
standing
with
his
friend
at
Nandannagar near Quarter Complex market on the extreme
left side of the road. That time a vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-01-H-2593 (Auto) was coming rashly and negligently
and the driver lost control over the vehicle and dashed
against the claimant petitioner for which the accident took
place. As a result, the injured Dipak Majumder sustained
grievous injury on his head, waist, back and also got injury
in his private parts of his body. Immediately with the aid of
local people he was taken to AGMC and GBP hospital,
Agartala but considering the injuries he was referred to ILS
hospital for better treatment and at ILS hospital, he was
admitted as an indoor patient
w.e.f.
04.04.2022 to
19.04.2022 and during treatment in the said hospital an
operation was held on his backbone by the doctor of the said
hospital. After discharge he undergone treatment by private
doctors. In this regard, NCC PS Case No.38 of 2022 under
Section 279/338 of IPC was registered. Hence the claimant
petitioner filed the case.
16.
The claim petition was contested by OP number 1
being the owner of the offending Auto by filing written
statement denying the assertions of the claimant petitioner
and it was further submitted that on the alleged day of
accident, the vehicle was duly insured with the respondentInsurance Company i.e. Bajaj Allianz General Insurance
Company Limited. No written statement was filed by OP No.2
i.e. the present respondent-Insurance Company inspite of
serving of notice/summon. Upon the pleadings of the parties
Learned Tribunal below framed the following issues:(i)
Whether the case is maintainable?
(ii) Whether claimant sustained injury due to rash
and negligent driving of Auto TR-01-H-2593 on
04.04.2022 at Nandannagar near Quarter
Complex under NCC PS?
(iii) Whether
claimant
compensation?
is
entitled
to
get
(iv) What
should
compensation?
the
amount
of
just
be
(v) Who is liable to pay compensation?
To substantiate the issues, the claimant petitioner
and the OP No.1 i.e. the owner of the offending vehicle
adduced
oral/documentary
convenience
the
names
evidence.
of
For
witnesses
the
sake
and
exhibited
documents are mentioned herein below:Claimant Witness:PW.1- Smt. Anita Chowdhury (Majumder)
PW.2- Dr. Manik Jamatia
Claimant Exhibits:Ext.1- Certified copy of Printed FIR.
Ext.2- Certified copy of FIR/Ejahar.
Ext.3- Certified copy of Seizure list.
Ext.4-Certified copy of injury report.
Ext.5- Certified copy of charge sheet.
Ext.7 series- Discharge summary along with bill.
Ext.8 series- Discharge summary along with bill.
Ext.9 series- Discharge summary along with bill.
Ext.10 series- Discharge summary along with bill.
of
Ext.11 series- Discharge summary along with bill.
Ext.12 series- Prescriptions.
Ext.13 series- Bills/vouchers/pay slop from ILS
hospital and Manipal Hospital.
Ext.14- Cash memo of patients bed.
Ext.15- Bill/voucher/Air ticket.
Ext.16- Trade licence.
Ext.17-Pan Card of Dipak Majumder.
Ext.18- School certificate of Dipak Majumder.
Ext.19-Income certificate.
Ext.20- Guest house bill from Bengaluro.
Ext.21- Aadhar Card of Dipak Majumder.
Ext.22- ID card.
Ext.23- Disability certificate.
Ext.23/1- Signature
certificate.
of
PW.2
in
the
disability
Opposite party’s Witness:OPW.1- Smt. Sadhana Chakraborty.
Exhibits by Opposite party No.1Ext.A- Registration certificate.
Ext.B- Driving licence.
Ext.C-Insurance certificate.
Ext.D-Road permit.
17.
Finally on conclusion of inquiry Learned Tribunal
below allowed the claim petition filed by the appellantclaimant petitioner. The operative portion of the judgment
and award runs as follows:ORDER
“32. It is ordered that, a total amount of
Rs.69,55,000/- (Rupees sixty nine lakhs fifty five
thousand) is awarded in favour of the petitioner as
compensation. The OP No.2, the Bajaj Allianz General
Insurance Company Lt., the insurer of the vehicle
bearing
registration
No.TR-01-H-2593(Auto)
is
hereby directed to pay the compensation as awarded.
The OP No.2 is also directed to pay the interest @7
per annum on total awarded sum from the date of
filing of this petition i.e. on 29.04.2022 till the date
of realization.
Huge amount has been spent during treatment and
which is continued till date and considering this
aspect, forty (40) percent of the awarded amount is
to be fixed deposited for five years and rest amount
of compensation is to be released in favour of the
claimant in his bank account.
33. Thus, the claim petition is allowed on contest.”
Challenging the judgment and award both the
parties have preferred the appeals.
18.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides
and gone through the record of the Learned Tribunal below
including the judgment delivered by the Learned Tribunal
below. Since, Learned Counsels of both the parties have
confined their arguments to limited points so let us confine
to those relevant points only. The first contention of the
appellant-claimant petitioner is that Learned Tribunal below
inspite of producing and proving income certificate (Exbt.19) only determined the monthly income of the appellantclaimant petitioner at Rs.15,000/- in this regard on the
ground that the issuing authority was not produced as
witness. In this regard, the OP No.1 before the Learned
Tribunal below, in course of cross-examination, did not
dispute anything. Even the respondent-Insurance Company
nor
filed
any
written
statement
nor
adduced
any
oral/documentary evidence on record.
The respondent-
Insurance Company also did not come forward to crossexamine the claimant petitioner to challenge the document.
So, in the considered opinion of this Court the determination
of monthly income at Rs.15,000/- in absence of examination
of the issuing authority was not proper.
19.
Since Exbt.-19 was unrebutted by the contesting
opposite parties and there is also no contrary evidence on
record from the side of the contesting opposite parties that
the same was not genuine. So, in the considered opinion of
this Court, the monthly income of the appellant during that
relevant point of time should be assessed to Rs.35,000/- in
place of Rs.15,000/- and there is/was no cogent ground to
disbelieve the same. So, in view of the above, towards actual
loss of income, the appellant-claimant petitioner would be
entitled to get Rs.(35,000X2)/-=Rs.70,000/-. Now, regarding
future loss of income, Learned Tribunal below added 25%
towards future loss of income since he was self employed
thus
calculated
Rs.18,750/-
(Rs.15,000/-
+
25%
of
Rs.3750/-)
which
should
be
Rs.15,000/-
i.e.
actually
Rs.35,000/-
+ (25% of Rs.35,000/- i.e. Rs.8750/-) i.e.
Rs.43,750/-. As the claimant petitioner was 47 years old at
the time of accident so, relying upon the judgment of Smt.
Sarla Verma and Ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
and Anr. reported in 2009 AIR SCW 4992 here, in this
case multiplier 13 would be applied. So, the loss of income
comes to Rs.(43,750 x 12 x 13)/- = Rs.68,25,000/- (Rupees
Sixty Eight Lakh Twenty Five Thousand). Further, towards
medical treatment, hospitalization, medicine, nursing food,
etc. Learned Tribunal below awarded Rs.18,50,000/- and
since there is no contrary evidence on record, so, I also
award this amount in favour of the claimant petitioner.
Towards
special
Rs.40,000/-
diet
and
Learned
towards
Tribunal
below
awarded
cost
Learned
transportation
Tribunal below awarded Rs.50,000/-. In absence of contrary
evidence on record, the said amount is also awarded in
favour of the appellant-claimant petitioner. Learned Tribunal
below also awarded Rs.2,00,000/- towards pain, suffering
and trauma relying upon the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ramesh Vs. Karan Singh and Anr. in
Civil Appl. No.6365 of 2022 dated 16.09.2022.
So, after hearing both the sides it appears to this
Court that Learned Tribunal below also rightly awarded the
said amount in favour of the appellant-claimant petitioner.
Towards
future
medical
expenses
Rs.3,00,000/-
was
awarded since the appellant-claimant petitioner did not
dispute to that, so the same amount is also awarded in
favour of the present claimant petitioner. Now, regarding
attendant
charges
it
appears
that
Learned
Tribunal
determined Rs.10,000/- per month for 2 persons as an
attendant charges and further determined annual attendant
charges of Rs.1,20,000/- and with that amount applied
multiplier 13 and thus awarded a sum of Rs.15,60,000/which in my considered view was wrongly decided/calculated
by the Learned Tribunal below. He was admitted in the
hospital for a period of 60 days and due to accident he has
suffered 100% permanent disability and without the support
of assistant he could not perform daily functions and he has
become paralyzed. So, considering the nature and gravity of
the injury, in my considered view, the claimant petitioner
would be only entitled to attendant charges for the period of
his admission in the hospital and thereafter for a further
period of 1 (one) month i.e. for 3 (three) months only and
taking
(three)
months
into
consideration
fixing
attendants Rs.500/- per head i.e. 2 (two) attendants at the
Rs.1000/- per day for 90 days it amounts to Rs.90,000/which the claimant petitioner would be entitled to get in
place of Rs.15,60,000/-. Further, towards the attendants
charge there is no scope to apply any multiplier in view of
the judgment of Sarla Verma and Anr. (supra). Thus, the
claimant petitioner after final calculation would be entitled to
get Rs.(30,000 + 70,000 + 68,25,000 + 18,50,000 +
40,000 + 50,000 + 2,00,000 + 90,000 + 3,00,000)/=Rs.94,55,000/- from the appellant Insurance Company.
20.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
claimant petitioner is hereby allowed and modified. The
appeal filed by the Insurance Company is also partly allowed
with modification that the claimant petitioner shall be
entitled
to
get
Rs.94,55,000/-
in
total
which
is
the
respondent-Insurance Company shall pay the appellantclaimant petitioner with interest @7.5% per annum in place
of @7% with effect from date of filing the claim petition that
is w.e.f. 29.04.2022 to till the date of realization. As ordered
by the Learned Tribunal 40% of the awarded amount as
aforesaid be kept in fixed deposit certificate for a period of 5
years and the rest amount of compensation be released in
favour of the claimant petitioner to his respective bank
account by the Learned Tribunal. The respondent-Insurance
Company be asked to deposit the amount, if not deposited to
the Learned Tribunal below within a period of 2 months from
the date of delivery of the judgment.
With this observation, both the appeal stands
disposed of.
Send down the record to the Learned Tribunal
below along with a copy of this judgment/order.
Supply a copy of this judgment/order to Learned
Counsel for the appellant Insurance Company for information
and compliance and also a copy of this judgment/order be
furnished to Learned Counsel for the respondent claimant
petitioners for information.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of
accordingly.
JUDGE
Amrita
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2025.09.25
17:37:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review