Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
APHC010573962022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
THURSDAY, THE 10th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 435/2022 &
Cross Objection No.23 of 2023
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 435/2022
Between:
1. THE APSRTC, REP.BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR,
ABAD, HYDERABAD, NOW AT VIJAYAWADA.
MUSHEE-
...APPELLANT
AND
1. N VENKATESWARAIAH, S/O SIDDAIAH, HINDU, AGED ABOUT 40
YEARS, R/O MARRIKUNTAPALLE VILLAGE, H/O KALIKIRI POST
AND MANDAL, CHITTOOR DSITRICT, PRESENTLY R/O D.NO 2-250B-2, REDDY'S COLONY, MADANAPALLE TOWN.
2. C GIRI, S/O C.VENKATRAMANNA, HINDU, DRIVER UNDER L'T
RESPONDENT, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, R/O D.NO.2-250-24-G,
YOGIVEMANA NAGAR, MADANAPALLE, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High CourtAggrieved by
the order and decree dated 09.06.2022 passed in MVOP No. 32 of 2016 On
the file of the Before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal cum Court of the
Second Additional District Judge.Madanapalle
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of -X1--days in filing the appeal against the
judgment and decree passed On the file of the Before the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal cum Court of the Second Additional District
Judge.Madanapalle passed in MVOP No.32 of 2016 dt. 09.06.2022 and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to grant stay of execution of decree in pursuant to MVOP No. 32 of
2016 dated. 09.06.2022 On the file of the Before the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal cum Court of the Second Additional District Judge.Madanapalle
pending disposal of the above MACMA and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to dispense with the interim order in I.A.No.2 of 2022 in
M.A.C.M.A.No. 435 of 2022 dt.04.11.2022 and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to vacate the stay granted I.A.No.2 of 2022 in M.A.C.M.A.No. 435 of
2022 dt.04.11.2022 by permitting the petitioner to withdraw the deposited
amount in MVOP No. 32 of 2016 on the file of Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal cum court of the Second Additional District Judge, Madanapalle,
Chittoor district and
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
May be pleased to pass orders for enhancement of the compensation amount
awarded in the Decree and Judgment, Dt. 22.01.2025 in M.V.O.P. No. 32 of
2016 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-Cum II Additional District
Judge, Madanapalle from Rs. 14,56,257/- to a sum of Rs. 55,00,000/-by
considering the loss of income/ earnings, in the interest of justice and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO(SC FOR APSRTC KKAC)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. SURESH KUMAR REDDY KALAVA
Cross Objection NO: 23/2023
Between:
1. N VENKATESWARAIAH @ N VENKATESWARLU, S/O.SIDDAIAH,
HINDU, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/O.MARRIKUNTAPALLE
VILLAGE, H/O.KALIKIRI POST 85 MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT,
PRESENTLY
R/O.D.NO.2-250-B-2,
REDDYS
COLONY,
MADANAPALLETOWN, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE
APSRTC,
REP.
BY
ITS
MANAGING
DIRECTOR,
MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD NOW AT VIJAYAWADA.
2. C GIRI, S/O.C.VENKATARAMANNA, HINDU, DRIVER, AGED ABOUT
40 YEARS,
R/O.D.NO.2-250-24-G, YOGIVEMANA NAGAR,
MADANAPALLE, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
begs to present this cross objection against the order passed in
M.V.O.P.NO. 32 of 2016 on the file of the court of the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal-Cum II Additional Districrt Judge, Madanapalle, dt.04.11.2022
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 301 days in filing the cross objections in
MACMA No. 435 OF 2022 and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SURESH KUMAR REDDY KALAVA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1.
The Court made the following:
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
COMMON JUDGMENT:M.A.C.M.A.No.435 of 2022 is filed by the APSRTC/1st respondent and
Cross Objection No.23 of 2023 is filed by the claim petitioner, challenging
the award dated 09.06.2022 passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal – cum – II Additional District Judge, Madanapalle in
M.V.O.P.No.32 of 2016, whereby, the Tribunal awarded compensation of
Rs.14,56,257/- as against the claim of Rs.10,00,000/-. Hence, I feel it
appropriate to decide these matters by way of a common judgment.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The petitioner is the injured, 1st respondent is the owner and the
2nd respondent is the driver of the bus bearing No.AP-21-Z-0448
(hereinafter referred to as „crime vehicle‟). On 18.01.2015, while the
petitioner was riding from Piler to Marrikuntapalle village on his
motorcycle bearing No.AP-03-BE-6939, near Kanchamvaripalle on Piler –
Kalikir main road, at about 03.00 p.m., the crime vehicle being driven by
the 2nd respondent in a rash and negligent manner in opposite direction,
dashed the motorcycle of the petitioner due to which, the petitioner
sustain grievous injuries and his right leg above knee joint was cut and
separated from his body. Immediately, the petitioner was shifted to
Community health centre, Piler and thereafter to C.M.C. hospital, Vellore
where he was treated as in-patient from 19.01.2015 to 16.02.2015. The
incident was reported to Police who registered a case in crime No.09 of
2015 on the file of Piler police station against the 2nd respondent for the
offence punishable under Section 338 of the Indian Penal Code. It is the
claim of the petitioner that as on the date of accident, he was working as
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
V.R.O., Cluster-I, Piler in the office of Tahsildar, Piler and that he was
getting an in hand salary of Rs.18,307/- per month. It is the case of the
petitioner that due to the accident, his right leg was amputated above
knee and that his partial permanent disability was assessed as 80% by
the doctors. Seeking compensation of Rs.10,00,000/- for the injuries
sustained by the petitioner, he filed a claim petition before the Tribunal
under Section 166 of the Andhra Pradesh Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.
4.
The claim petition was contested by both the respondents by
filing their individual written statements. The 1st respondent filed its written
statement denying all the averments made by the petitioner, his
occupation, nature of injuries. It further contended that at the time of
accident, the petitioner was riding his motorcycle while having a
conversation in his cell phone and that he lost control over the
motorcycle, hit the bus, fell down and sustained injuries. It is further
stated that the accident occurred due to the negligence of the petitioner,
as such, the 1st respondent is not liable to pay compensation to the
petitioner. The 2nd respondent had also filed his written statement on
similar lines, however, he contended that the Police have registered case
against him falsely. Hence, requested to dismiss the claim petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Tribunal framed the
following issues for trial:
1)
Whether the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving
of Driver of the vehicle, bearing its registration No. AP-21-Z-0448?
2)
Whether the injuries caused to the petitioner due to the rash and
negligent driving of the offending vehicle?
3)
Whether the petitioner is entitled for compensation. If so, for what
amount and from whom?
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
4)
To what relief?
6.
During the course of trial, the petitioner got himself examined
as P.W.1 besides P.Ws.2 and 3; he got examined Exs.A1 to A12 and
Ex.X1. Though the 2nd respondent was examined as R.W.1, no
documentary evidence was adduced by the respondents.
7.
The Tribunal, after considering all the facts and material
available before it, awarded Rs.14,56,257/- to the petitioner by holding
that respondent Nos.1 and 2 are jointly and severally liable to pay. On the
grounds that the Tribunal erred in holding that the accident occurred due
to negligent driving of the 2nd respondent and that it erred in awarding
compensation under the head of loss of future earnings though the
petitioner is working in his official capacity even as on today. On the other
hand, the petitioner/claimant filed Cross Objection No.23 of 2023 seeking
enhancement of the compensation awarded on the ground that the
Tribunal erred in awarding Rs.14,56,257/- when it has computed the
amount of compensation as Rs.23,56,257/- in paragraph No.24.
8.
Suresh
Heard Sri. P. Chaitanya, learned counsel representing Sri.
Kumar
Reddy
Kalava,
learned
counsel
for
the
claim
petitioner/cross objector and Sri. Aravala Rama Rao, learned Standing
Counsel for the APSRTC/appellant.
9.
Perused the entire material available on record. To establish
the fact that the accident occurred due to the negligent driving of the 2 nd
respondent, the petitioner himself got examined as P.W.1. In his chief
examination, the petitioner stated that on 18.01.2015, he went to Piler on
his motorcycle as the Government conducted Pulse Polio programme and
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
after completion of his work, while he was returning to Marrikuntapalle on
his motorcycle slowly and cautiously, at about 03.00 p.m., near
Kanchamvaripalle turning situated on Piler – Kalikiri main road, the crime
vehicle, being driven by the 2nd respondent in a rash and negligent
manner from opposite side, dashed his motorcycle, due to which, the iron
sheet of the bus cut the petitioner‟s right leg above knee joint which led to
separation of the leg from his body. He further deposed that he also
sustained fracture of middle femur, right leg and lost the tip of the 4 th
finger of his right palm, he was immediately shifted to Community Health
Centre, Piler in an ambulance and upon advice of doctors, he was shifted
to C.M.C., hospital, Vellore, where he underwent treatment from
19.01.2015 to 16.02.2015. He further deposed that the incident was
reported to Police who filed a case against the 2nd respondent on the file
of Piler Police station in Crime No.9 of 2015 (Ex.A1) for the offence
punishable under Section 338 of the Indian Penal Code and that a charge
sheet (Ex.A2) has also been filed after completion of investigation by the
Police against the 2nd respondent.
10.
The Tribunal, after considering the evidence of P.W.1 coupled
with Exs.A1 and A2, in the absence of any record on behalf of the
respondents to show that the petitioner contributed to the accident, held
that the petitioner sustained injuries in the accident occurred due to the
rash and negligent driving of the 2nd respondent. This Court is of the
opinion that the said finding of the Tribunal need not be interfered with as
the same is on reasonable basis, in the absence of any rebutting
evidence on the part of the respondents to show that there is no
negligence on the part of the 2nd respondent to the occurrence of the
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
accident. Thus, the Tribunal has rightly answered issue No.1 in favour of
the petitioner, which needs no interference.
11.
Now coming to the quantum of compensation, it is the claim of
the petitioner that prior to the date of accident, he was healthy and was
earning Rs.18,307/- per month by working as Village Revenue Officer,
Cluster – I in the office of the Tahsildar, Piler. In support of the same, he
got marked Ex.A6 – salary certificate issued by the Tahsildar, Piler. The
petitioner deposed in his chief examination that due to the injuries
sustained in the accident, his right leg above knee got amputated and that
he is unable to attend his official duties usually; that he is unable to
perform regular activities properly. Due to amputation of his right leg
above knee, his disability was assessed by the medical board as 85%. In
support of the same, the petitioner got marked Exs.A8 and A9. Ex.A9 –
the disability certificate dated 03.07.2015 issued by the Medical Board,
Area Hospital, Madanapalli. A perusal of the said certificate would
disclose that the petitioner suffered disability of high right lower limb and
that the percentage of disability is assessed as 85%. Ex.A8 is the
disability certificate dated 03.07.2015 issued by P.W.3 – Dr. M.S.
Gnaneswar,
M.S.,
Ortho,
Assistant
Orthopaedic
Surgeon,
CHC,
Madanapalle. P.W.3, in his evidence admitted with regard to issuance of
Ex.A8 and deposed that he is a member of the Medical board that issued
Ex.A9. Thus, it can safely be concluded that the petitioner suffered from
permanent disability of 85%.
12.
The petitioner got examined P.W.2 – Dr. Manisha, Assistant
Director, C.M.C. hospital. P.W.2, in her chief examination deposed that
the petitioner was got admitted in their hospital on 18.01.2015 with ‘post
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
traumatic below knee amputation on the right side with distal femur, open
fracture right side, open patella fracture right side’. The petitioner‟s right
leg above knee was amputated. She further deposed that the bills marked
by the petitioner i.e., Exs.A7, A11 and A12 were issued by C.M.C.,
hospital. She further admitted that the petitioner underwent treatment in
the hospital from 19.01.2015 to 16.02.2015 as in-patient.
13.
Considering the material available on record, the Tribunal has
rightly considered the age of the petitioner as 40 and the monthly income
of the petitioner as Rs.18,307/-. However, in the impugned award, in
paragraph No.24, the Tribunal observed as under:
“…Taking into consideration of the facts and circumstances of
the case and in view of the nature of injuries sustained by the
petitioner, the following amounts are finally awarded towards
compensation.
1. Compensation for medical expenses
Rs. 58,029 – 00
2. Compensation for pain and sufferings
Rs.3,00,000 – 00
3. Compensation for special diet, attend and
Conveyance charges
Rs.1,00,000 – 00
4. Loss of Future earning for Permanent disability Rs.10,00,000 – 00
5. Loss of Amenities and enjoyment of life
Rs.5,00,000 – 00
6. Compensation for disfigurement and purchase
of artificial leg
Rs.1,25,000 – 00
7. Loss of income during treatment
Rs.73,228 – 00
8. Future medical expenses
Rs.2,00,000 - 00
Thus, the total compensation amount awarded to the
petitioner is Rs.14,56,257/-. Accordingly, issue No.3 is
answered.”
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
14.
However, when the amount of compensation mentioned
hereinabove under different heads is added, the resultant amount is
Rs.23,56,257/-
(Rs.58,029/-
+
Rs.3,00,000/-
+
Rs.1,00,000/-
+
Rs.10,00,000/- + Rs.1,25,000/- + Rs.73,228/- + Rs.2,00,000/-) but not
Rs.14,56,257/-. This Court is unable to understand as to why the Tribunal
erred in awarding Rs.14,56,257/- when the total amount of compensation
awarded under different heads comes to Rs.23,56,257/-. Furthermore,
this Court is of opinion that the impugned award is silent as to the basis
for awarding Rs.10,00,000/- under the head of loss of future earning for
permanent disability. Hence, this Court is of the opinion that the amount
of compensation payable to the petitioner has to be reassessed.
15.
Admittedly, the petitioner was working as a Village Revenue
Officer, Cluster – I in the office of the Tahsildar, Piler and that he was
earning Rs.18,307/- per month as on the date of accident. The same is
also supported by Ex.A6 – salary certificate issued by Tahsildar, Piler. It
is the contention of the respondents that though the disability of the
petitioner is assessed as 85%, he is still attending his official duties
without any hindrance; in such a case, the petitioner is not entitled for
compensation under the head of loss of future earnings.
16.
It is well settled law that loss of earnings capacity is a concept
distinct from immediate loss of wages or continuity of employment. Time
and again, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has consistently held that the task
of the Tribunal or the Court is to assess the functional impact of the injury
on the earning capacity of the claimant, having regard to the nature of
disability, the avocation of the injures, age and future employability. In Raj
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
Kumar Vs. Ajay Kumar 1 , the Apex Court clarified that medical or
physical disability expressed as a percentage cannot be mechanically
equated with loss of earning capacity; what must be evaluated is the
extent to which the disability affects the ability of the claimant to earn a
livelihood in future. The Hon'ble Apex Court, further held that once
functional
disability
affecting
earning
capacity
is
established,
compensation must be assessed using the multiplier method, irrespective
of the fact that the claimant may have continued in service or received
increments post-accident.
17.
The denial of compensation for loss of future earnings solely on
the ground that the claimant continues in employment or has not suffered
immediate wage loss would be inconsistent with settled Supreme Court
jurisprudence. The law recognizes that economic vulnerability, reduced
employability, and diminished labour-market acceptability and inability to
secure employment are real and compensable consequences of
permanent disability. The essence of compensation is to give reparation
to an injured who has suffered great impairment in his functionality due to
the negligence of the offending vehicle. It would be therefore, imperative
that just and reasonable compensation is provided. As such, the
compensation to the petitioner under the head of loss of future earnings
cannot be denied.
18.
If the amount of compensation under the head of loss of future
earnings is reassessed, considering the monthly income of the petitioner
as Rs.18,307/-, as per Ex.A6, the annual income of the petitioner would
become Rs.2,19,684/-. As per Sarla Verma and Ors. Vs. Delhi
(2011) 1 SCC 343
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
Transport Corporation and another2, the relevant multiplier applicable
to the persons aged between 35 and 40 is „13‟. The petitioner‟s disability
is assessed as 85% as can be seen from, Exs.A8 and A9 and he is aged
about 40 years as on the date of accident. Thus, the compensation
payable to the petitioner under the head of loss of future earnings due to
permanent disability would become Rs.24,27,508/- (Rs.2,19,684/- X „13‟
X 85%). In addition, Rs.3,00,000/- has rightly been awarded by the
Tribunal under the head of pain and suffering as the petitioner not only
suffered amputation, but also other fractures as can be seen from the
deposition of P.W.2. As the petitioner underwent in-patient treatment for
almost one month in the hospital, he would have spent considerable
amount for following special diet, attendant charges and conveyance
charges; thus, Rs.1,00,000/- can be awarded to the petitioner. Due to
amputation of right leg above knee and other grievous injuries, the
petitioner would face inability to enjoy normal daily activities, hobbies, and
overall quality of life. Thus, this Court feels it appropriate to award
Rs.5,00,000/- under the head of loss of amenities and enjoyment of life.
19.
As the petitioner‟s right leg above knee was amputated, he has
to use a prosthetic leg for the rest of his life. The Hon‟ble Apex Court, in
Mohd. Sabeer @ Shabir Hussain Vs. Regional Manager, U.P. State
Road Transport Corporation3, held that in general, a prosthetic leg is
priced at Rs.2,60,000/- and its life is only 5 to 6 years. It also requires
repair and maintenance after every 6 months to one year and each repair
costs between Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/-. In cases of motor accidents
leading to injuries and disablements, it is a well settled principle that a
(2009) 6 SCC 121
2022 LiveLaw (SC) 1017
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
person must not only be compensated for his physical injury, but also for
the non-pecuniary losses which he has suffered due to the injury.
20.
As such, the petitioner is entitled to be compensated for his
inability to lead a full life and enjoy those things and amenities which he
would have enjoyed, but for the injuries. As on the date of accident, the
claimant is aged about 40 years and it would be reasonable to assume
that he would live till he is 70 years old. Thus, the claimant must be
compensated so that he is able to purchase five prosthetic limbs in his
lifetime and is able to maintain the same at least till he has reached 70
years of age. For the prosthetic limbs alone, the claimant is to be
awarded compensation of Rs.13,00,000/- (Rs.2,60,000/- X 5). In addition,
Rs.15,000/- is to be awarded towards repair and maintenance of the
prosthetic leg for every one year. In other words, as the petitioner would
be using the prosthetic legs for 30 years in total, he is entitled for an
amount
of
Rs.4,50,000/-
as
compensation
towards
repairs
and
maintenance of the prosthetic leg. In total, the claimant is now entitled for
compensation of Rs.17,50,000 /- [Rs.13,00,000/- + Rs.4,50,000/-].
21.
In the present case, the claimants claimed an amount of
Rs.10,00,000/- only. With regard to awarding compensation more than
the claim amount claimed in the petition, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
“Nagappa Vs. Gurudayal Singh and Others4”, held as follows:
“..there is no restriction that the Tribunal/Court cannot award compensation
amount exceeding the claimed amount. The function of the Tribunal/Court
is to award “just” compensation, which is reasonable on the basis of
evidence produced on record.”
(2003) 2 SCC 274
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
22.
In “Kajal V. Jagadish Chand and Ors.5” the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court held as follows:
“33. We are aware that the amount awarded by us is more than the
amount claimed. However, it is well settled law that in the motor accident
claim petitions, the Court must award the just compensation and, in case,
the just compensation is more than the amount claimed, that must be
awarded……..”
23.
In view of the law laid down by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, this
Court need not restrict the compensation to the amount claimed in the
petition and can award more compensation than the amount claimed in
the claim petition, depending upon the facts and circumstances of the
case.
24.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the compensation now by
this Court under different heads is as under:
2020 (04) SCC 413
S.
No
Head of the claim
Amounts now
awarded by this
Court
1.
Loss of future earnings
Rs.24,27,508/-
2.
Towards pain and
suffering
Rs.3,00,000/-
3.
Attendant charges, diet
and conveyance
charges
Rs.1,00,000/-
4.
Loss of amenities and
enjoyment of life
Rs.5,00,000/-
5.
Prosthetic Leg
Rs.17,50,000/-
TOTAL
Rs.50,77,508/-
VS,J
MACMA_435_2022 &
X-OBJ_23_2023
25.
In the result, M.A.C.M.A.No.435 of 2022, filed by the
APSRTC/appellant is dismissed. Consequently, X-Obj.No.23 of 2023 filed
by the cross objector/claim petitioner is allowed and the amount of
compensation awarded by the Tribunal by way of the impugned award
dated 09.06.2022 is enhanced from Rs.14,56,257/- to Rs.50,77,508/-,
subject to payment of additional court fee by the cross objector/claim
petitioner within 30 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:10.09.2026.
Gss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review