Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010195922007
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-57
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
APPEAL Nos:1442 OF 2007 AND 2082 OF 2009
M.A.C.M.A.No.1442 OF 2007
U. Rajani Priya and Others
...Appellant(s)
Vs.
APSRTC rep by its Vice-Chairman and Managing
Director, rep. by Depot Manager, APSRTC, Kandukur.
...Respondent
**********
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 24th August 2026
Present:
Advocate for Appellants/Claimants: MR.SUDHAKARA RAO AMBATI
Advocate for Respondent/
Corporation:
MR.N.SUBRAHMANYA RUPESH,
REPRESENTING MR. P.
VENKATA RAO (SC FOR
APSRTC)
***
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals, instituted under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short, “the Act”), challenge the very same
judgment and award, dated 08.03.2007, in M.V.O.P.No.247 of 2005
passed by the Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accidents Claims Tribunal-cumDistrict Judge, Ongole (for short, “the Tribunal”), thus, are heard
together and disposed of by this common judgment.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter are referred
to as they were arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the Tribunal.
3.
M.A.C.M.A.No.1442 of 2007 is preferred by claimants seeking
enhancement of compensation, whereas, M.A.C.M.A. No.2082 of 2009,
by APSRTC (hereinafter referred to as “Corporation”) assailing the
determination of compensation.
4.
(a) Deceased claims to be Sales Representative, met with an
accident while he was proceeding on a motorcycle, the accident
occurred on 08.05.2005 at 1.30 P.M. near Old Government Hospital,
Ongole.
The driver of bus bearing registration No.AP 10 Z 7495,
belonging to the Corporation, drove the bus in a rash and negligent
manner and dashed against the motorcycle causing the accident. The
incident was reported to police.
On reporting the same, police
registered Crime No.89 of 2005 for the offence punishable under
Section 304-A of IPC against the driver of the bus. After conducting
investigation, police laid charge-sheet against driver of the bus.
(b) Deceased claimed to be aged 36 years and earning about
Rs.5,000/- per month as Sales Representative, therefore, wife, minor
son and parents of deceased preferred claim seeking compensation of
Rs.30,00,000/- along with interest.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
5.
Respondent-Corporation filed written statement denying the
manner in which accident occurred and that its driver was negligent in
causing the accident. It was further pleaded that as the motorcycle, on
which deceased was proceeding, was hit by another motorcycle,
resultantly, the deceased lost control and fell down, therefore, no
negligence can be attributed to the driver of bus. Further, age, avocation
and income of deceased were disputed.
6.
Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the Tribunal has framed the
following issues:
“1) Whether the deceased died due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the crime vehicle of Respondent?
2) What is the correct age and income of the deceased as on
the date of the accident?
3) Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so,
to what extent and from whom?
4. To what relief?”
7.
Claimants examined PW.1 and PW.2 and marked Exs.A1 to A8.
No oral or documentary evidence was adduced on behalf of respondent
Corporation.
8.
The Tribunal has answered first issue holding that both the
deceased as well as driver of bus were negligent in causing the accident
and accordingly, fixed the contributory negligence in ratio of 20:80
respectively.
For the purpose of determining the quantum of
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
compensation, the Tribunal considered age of deceased as 36 years.
The income of deceased was determined at Rs.3,000/- per month. After
applying multiplier of 16, 1/3rd of earnings were deducted towards
personal and living expenses, and accordingly, loss of income was
assessed.
Tribunal also awarded Rs.15,000/- towards loss of
consortium and Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and thus, determined
the compensation of Rs.4,90,800/-. Since the Corporation was fixed
with liability of 80%, the compensation payable was arrived at
Rs.3,92,640/-, rounded up to Rs.3,93,000/-, payable along with interest
at the rate of 7.5% p.a. from the date of petition till realisation. The said
amount has been apportioned amongst the claimants as provided under
the award.
9.
Assailing the same, present appeals are preferred by both
claimants as well as respondent Corporation.
10.
Heard Mr.Sudhakar Rao Ambati, learned counsel for claimants
and Mr.N.Subrahmanya Rupesh, learned counsel, representing Mr. P.
Venkata Rao, learned standing counsel for APSRTC, for Corporation.
11.
Learned counsel for claimants primarily contended that the
Tribunal erred in determining income of deceased merely as Rs.3,000/per month, without appreciating Ex.A8 salary certificate and Ex.A7
Adangal copy, which clearly suggested that the deceased had sufficient
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
income, and thus, the Tribunal ought to have determined the income at
least as Rs.5,000/- per month. He further contended that the Tribunal
not only failed to award future prospects, but also did not award the
components falling within conventional heads in terms of judgment of
Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi1.
12.
Per contra, learned counsel for respondent Corporation tried to
support and justify the order of Tribunal insofar as the quantum of
compensation is concerned. However, learned counsel for Corporation
contended that the Tribunal erred in fixing the contributory negligence in
the ratio of 20:80, which is erroneous, inasmuch as even as per the
evidence of PW.2 and Ex.A1 FIR, Ex.A6 charge-sheet, the motorcycle,
on which deceased was riding, was hit by another motorcycle from
behind, thus, deceased lost control and fell down towards their right
side, to their misfortune, bus coming from opposite direction had hit the
deceased, which in no manner can be attributed to the driver of bus.
Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal ought
to have determined the negligence in the ratio of 50:50.
13.
We have given our anxious consideration to the submissions
made by learned counsels for parties and perused the record.
(2017) 16 SCC 680
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
14.
Now the point that falls for consideration of this Court is:
Whether the Tribunal was justified in fixing the
contributory negligence in the ratio of 20:80 to the
deceased and the driver of bus, respectively, and
further,
whether
the
amount
of
compensation
determined under the impugned award is fair, just and
reasonable?
15.
The occurrence of accident is not in dispute. As per the version
of claimants, while deceased, along with PW.2, was proceeding on
motorcycle, the driver of Corporation bus, which came in opposite
direction, dashed against the motorcycle, therefore, deceased fell down
and succumbed due to injuries and even PW.2 also sustained injuries.
In order to establish the same, Ex.A1 FIR, Ex.A2 inquest report, Ex.A5
rough sketch and Ex.A6 charge-sheet were marked, besides examining
PW.2. Whereas, it is the case of Corporation that the deceased and
PW.2 were first hit by another motorcycle from behind, thus, having lost
control over the motorcycle, they fell down towards right side and only,
thereafter, the offending bus coming in opposite direction had hit the
deceased. To support the version of Corporation, neither its driver was
examined nor the rider of the other motorcycle, who alleged to have hit
the motorcycle of deceased. Nevertheless, in the cross-examination,
PW.2 as well as Ex.A6 charge-sheet, there was reference to another
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
motorcycle hitting the motorcycle of deceased from behind, on account
of which deceased fell down, and thereafter, the accident occurred.
Considering aforesaid evidence, the Tribunal has rendered finding that
there is some amount of negligence on the part of deceased, further that
the driver of bus cannot be held to be absolutely non-negligent, thus,
fixed the negligence in the ratio of 20:80. Even by accepting the version
of PW.2 as well as Ex.A6 charge-sheet, but for the third party hitting the
motorcycle of deceased from behind, they would not have fallen down,
resultantly, occurring the accident. At any rate, it is undeniable fact that
the driver of bus also could not control the bus in averting the accident.
Therefore, we are of the view that the finding recorded by the Tribunal
is amply justified and does not call for any interference. Thus, we uphold
the findings of the Tribunal insofar as fixing the contributory negligence
in the ratio of 20:80 to the deceased and driver of bus, respectively.
16.
Now coming to the aspect of quantum of compensation, the
important piece of evidence relied on by claimants to justify the income
of deceased as Rs.5,000/- per month are Ex.A8 salary certificate and
Ex.A7 Adangal copy for the Fasli 1410 (i.e., year 2000-’01).
The
deceased was claimed to be working as Sales Representative in M/s.Sri
Sai Agro Chemicals, Ongole, in support, Ex.A8 salary certificate was
produced. PW.2, proprietor of the said firm, deposed that deceased was
working, however, it was stated that as deceased was closely related,
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
no accounts were maintained with regard to the salary etc. In that view
of the matter, the Tribunal disbelieved Ex.A8 salary certificate. Apart
from that, it was also held that PW.2, employer, did not even produce
any evidence such as employment register, payment vouchers or any
other record to prove deceased was gainfully employed.
17.
Further, insofar as agricultural income is concerned, claimants
relied on Ex.A7 Adangal copy of the year 2000-01, which is five years
prior to the date of accident. No doubt, in the occupation column, the
record indicates that the deceased was cultivating tenant, the same
cannot be stretched to presume that deceased was continuing to
cultivate the lands and earning income.
Even otherwise also, the
Tribunal has considered the income of deceased as Rs.3,000/- per
month, as against the minimum wages payable to unskilled at relevant
point of time, ranging from Rs.69/- to Rs.80/- per day, which translates
to Rs.2,080/- p.m. (Rs.80/- per day x 26 days = Rs.2,080/- per month).
We, therefore, are satisfied that the income assessed by the Tribunal is
reasonable in all respects, thus, we maintain it.
18.
We further award future prospects at the rate of 40%.
Further,
even various amounts awarded under conventional heads also require
to be revised following the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Pranay Sethi1.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
19.
Thus, we hereby modify the impugned award and grant just and
fair compensation as detailed below.
Compensation
Heads
Net annual income
₹3,000/- x 12 = ₹36,000/-
Future Prospects
(Age being 36 years)
40% of ₹36,000/- =
₹14,400/-
Deduction (1/4th)
₹50,400/- – ₹12,600/=₹37,800/-
Multiplier (15)
₹37,800/- x 15 =
₹5,67,000/-
Loss of Income of the
deceased
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
₹18,150/-
Funeral expenses
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
₹5,67,000/₹18,150/-
Loss of Estate
In Accordance
with:
Amount Awarded
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Satinder Kaur,
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
₹48,400 x 4 = ₹1,93,600/Loss of Consortium
(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
Rajwati alias Rajjo
v. United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1699
Para 34
Sadhana Tomar v.
Ashok Khushwaha
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.1442 of 2007 &
2082 of 2009
2025 SCC OnLine
SC 554
Para 17
Total
20.
₹7,96,900/-, 80% of which comes to
Rs.6,37,520/-
Accordingly, both these appeals are disposed of and the
impugned order, dated 08.03.2007, shall stand modified, by revising the
compensation amount to Rs.6,37,520/- as just and fair compensation,
along with interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a. thereon from the date of claim
petition till date of realisation. Out of which, 1st claimant is entitled to
Rs.3,12,520/-; 2nd claimant is entitled to Rs.1,25,000/- and claimants 3
and 4 are entitled for Rs.1,00,000/- each. The respondent Corporation
to deposit the amount as aforesaid, adjusting the amount already
deposited/paid if any, before the Tribunal within one month.
On such
deposit being made, the claimants shall be entitled to withdraw the same
as apportioned above, failing which, the amount shall be recovered as
per law. No order as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
cs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review