Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 29.06.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 25.09.2026
Date of uploading
: 25.09.2026
APHC010592212023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
FRIDAY, THE 25th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT APPEAL NO: 1206 OF 2023
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent by the orders of the
learned Single Judge Her Lordships
Hon'ble Smt. Justice V.SUJATHA
passed in W.P.No.33805 of 2022, dated 112-10-202
Between:
1. The Andhra Pradesh Generation Corporation,
Rep. by its Managing Director, Vidyuth Soudha, Gunadala, Vijayawada.
2. The Chief Engineer (O and M), RTPP, V. V.Reddy Nagar,
YSR Kadapa District
...Petitioners
AND
1. E RAJASEKHAR, S/o. Rama Subbaiah,
Aged about 29 years, Rio.
H.No.4/35 A, R.T.P.P Road, Mudharur (P AND V), YSR Kadapa District.
2. E Rama Subbaiah, S/o. Venkata Subbanna, Aged about 50 years, Rio.
H.No.4/35 A, R.T.P.P Road, Mudharur (P AND V), YSR Kadapa District.
3. The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Energy
Department, Secretariat Buildings, Amaravathi, Guntur District.
4. The Revenue Division Officer, YSR Kadapa
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioners: NAGARAJU NAGURU,
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondents: G V SHIVAJI
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES I
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
And
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT APPEAL No.1206 of 2023
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon’ble Sri A. Hari Haranadha Sarma)
Introductory:This Writ Appeal is directed against the orders dated 12.10.2023
passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court in W.P. No. 33805 of
2022.
[ii]
The respondents Nos.3 and 4 in the sad writ petition are the
appellants herein. Respondents No.1 and 2 herein are the writ petitioners.
Respondents No.3 and 4 herein are the respondents No.1 and 2 in the writ
petition.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter will be referred
as per their ranking in the writ petition as the writ petitioner and the
respondents.
Case of the writ petitioners:3.
[i]
The petitioner No. 1 is the son of petitioner No. 2. Land in an
extent of Ac.0.60 cents in Survey No.368/1b of Kasinepalli village,
Muddanur Mandal, YSR Kadapa District was acquired for RTPP Stage-1
Railway Track in the year 1992. On 09.11.1993 within one year as per the
G.O., the 2nd petitioner made an application for employment promised but
the same was not considered. Then the 2 nd petitioner along with 42 others
filed Writ Petition No.27643 of 2007 before the Hon'ble High Court and the
same was disposed of vide orders dated 26.04.2010 directing the
respondents to consider the application of the petitioners in the writ petition
in proper perspective, and that the applications of the writ petitioners shall
be processed by the selection committee and prepare selection list taking
into consideration the eligibility criteria and to provide employment.
[ii]
The second petitioner attended the interview in the year 2013
at the Collector Office. As his health was deteriorating, request was made
by him to consider appointment of his son/1st petitioner for employment
under land loser category. A list of land losers was issued on 02.02.2014.
In the said list, the 1st petitioner was placed in Sl. No. 47. All the candidates
above Sl. No.47 were appointed.
[iii]
Thereafter, the 3rd respondent addressed a letter to the 1st
petitioner vide Letter No. CE/O&M/RTPP/GM(HR)/PO-B/JAO/B4/F.LL/
D.No.2080/2019 dated 12.06.2018, directing the 1st petitioner to attend the
office of the 3rd respondent on 13.06.2019 at 11.00 a.m. with all original
documents, as the District Selection Committee is meeting for preparing
merit list of the candidate, for providing employment under land loser quota,
scheduled on 18.06.2019 at 03.00p.m. in the District Collectorate, Kadapa.
The 3rd DSC merit list was prepared as per the instructions issued in Memo
No.D(HRAIR)/JS(Per)/DS(ESH)/AS(IR)P.O.H./80/2018 dated 22.03.2019.
The 1st petitioner was placed in Sl.No.1. But the candidature of the 1 st
petitioner was not considered for providing employment.
Again a
representation dated 31.08.2019 was made. Pursuant to the same,
proceedings vide Letter No.CE/O&M/RTPP/GM (HR)/PO-B/JAO/B4/ F.LL/
D.No.3213/19, dated 13.09.2019 issued stating that the 1st petitioner
attended the 3rd DSC meeting, but as on that date the final award relating to
his land was pending, and that his case will be considered after passing of
award by RDO, where as the stand of the respondents that award is not
passed is incorrect.
[iv]
Further case of the petitioners is that they have met the
peoples Representative i.e., MLA of Jammalamadugu constituency, who
has in turn wrote letter to the respondents to take action as per the rules, In
response to the same, the 3rd respondent addressed a letter to the 2nd
petitioner
vide
letter
No.
CE/O&M/RTPP/SE/ADM/PO/JAO/F.LL/
D.No.1449/2020 dated 23.03.2020, stating the same reason. Again the
petitioner made a representation dated Nil, received by the 3rd respondent
on 25.11.2021, who forwarded the same to the 2 nd respondent. In the said
representation, the 2nd petitioner made a request to provide livelihood to the
1st petitioner either on CDWC or on contract labour or in maintenance works
in APGENCO. However, no action has taken.
[v]
It is further claimed by the petitioners that in similar cases, this
Court vide W. P.No.1053 of 1995 dated 08.07.2005 held that the land loser
shall be considered taking into consideration their age at the time of passing
of award, and the same was confirmed in the Writ Appeal No.130 of 2006.
Even SLP filed against the same was rejected.
[vi]
It is the further case of the petitioners that the G.O.Ms. No.98
contemplates a scheme that the displaced land persons have to be
considered for employment on temporary basis immediately, with further
provisions that they shall be regularized, whenever regular vacancies arise.
There are number of vacancies in the categories of Junior Plant Attendant
and other the categories to which the 1st petitioner is eligible and qualified.
In spite of that the respondents are not considering his employment.
Contention of the 3rd and 4th respondents:
4.
Notifications dated 05.01.2011 and 17.10.2011 were issued for filling
up the vacancies for the posts of JPA. The qualification was acquired by
the 1st petitioner in April 2014. Appointment orders to 88 eligible candidates
were given.
Name of the petitioner was not reflected in two
recommendations made by DSC.
The 1 st petitioner was recommended
only in third DSC 24.01.2014. There are no notified vacancies available for
the posts of JPA under the land loser category. The land losers’ cases for
employment were considered subject to eligibility and seniority as per
notification.
Only 50% notified JPA vacancies are earmarked for the land
losers.
The findings and directions of the learned Single Judge in the Writ
Petition:5.
[i]
Application for appointment was made within one year in terms
of G.O.Ms.No.98.
[ii]
Land was acquired in the year 1992.
But till date no
appointment was provided to the petitioner.
[iv]
Even in 2020 and 2023 appointments were made in respect of
the persons, some land losers. Hence, appointment of the petitioner shall
be considered.
Arguments in the appeal:For the appellants [respondents No.3 and4 in the writ petition] :6.
Learned Single Judge failed to consider:(i)
Request of the 2nd petitioner was against the land loser quota
against DSC notification dated 17.10.2011 was not considered as he did not
possess a required qualification in terms of G.O.Ms.No.98.
(ii)
All the posts notified under the notification dated 17.10.2011
were duly filled by the year 2013.
(iii)
The first petitioner made an application in the year 2014, by
which time the appointment pursuant to the notification of 2011 was came to
an end.
(iv)
By the time of constitution of 3rd DSC, all the posts notified
pursuant to the notification dated 17.10.2011 were already been filled.
(v)
notification
More than twelve years have lapsed since the issuance of the
in
the
year
2011.
Therefore,
no
such
direction
for
appointment/employment can be issued at this belated stage.
(vi)
In fact, the 1st petitioner did not possess required qualification
for a JPA post i.e. ITI Trades.
(vii)
As per the clause 4 (II) of the G.O.Ms.No.98 dated 15.04.1986 -
the candidates eligible for appointment under the scheme shall be
displaced persons or his/her son, daughter or spouse, there being no other
earning member in the family.
(a)
On 29.09.2012 daughter of the 2 nd petitioner i.e., E.Divya
Bharati submitted representation enclosing her Diploma and B.Tech (ECE)
certificates. From the said application, her father's occupation disclosed as
agriculture and 1st petitioner was shown as stating studying.
The
2nd
petitioner was shown as employee working as conductor in APSRTC.
Therefore, the appellant -Corporation was misled. Her name was not
included in selection list at the time of 2nd DSC as she did not possess
requisite ITI qualification for the JPA post.
(b)
Subsequently, the 1st petitioner submitted representation
enclosing SSC and Intermediate Certificate applying for JPA post.
However, the first petitioner acquired ITI only in the year 2014. The 1st
petitioner was placed at Sl.No.47 and in the remarks column it was
mentioned that the final award is pending after passing of award during the
3rd DSC meeting.
(c)
The appellants addressed a letter to the APSRTC to
confirm the employment of the 2nd petitioner. A letter was received from
APSRTC informing that the 2nd petitioner joined in APSRTC as a casual
conductor and retired in 2019. There shall be non-earning member, since
the 2nd petitioner was in some employment, the 1st petitioner cannot be
considered as eligible on the ground that there are earning members in the
family.
For the respondents 1 and 2 herein [writ petitioners ]:7.
(i)
The application submitted by the 2nd writ petitioner was made
within the prescribed time and for the reasons best-known, no action was
taken.
(ii)
There was continuous correspondence in the matter, and the
letters addressed by the respondents indicate that the 1 st writ petitioner and
the 2nd writ petitioner were placed in the merit list at Serial Nos.47 and 1,
respectively.
(iii)
The contention that the petitioners were not eligible cannot be
accepted.
(iv)
Employment was provided to persons who were lower in rank/
merit list than the petitioners. But the case of the petitioners is not
considered.
(v)
The appellants are taking divergent and contradictory stands.
The employment of the 2nd petitioner in APSRTC as a contract employee
was opted in disguise for survival of the family.
(vi)
The orders of the learned Single Judge are well reasoned and
there are no grounds to interfere.
8.
Perused the record. Anxious consideration is given to the arguments
advanced by both sides.
Analysis and findings :9.
The facts not in dispute are:
(i)
Land of the writ petitioners was acquired.
(ii)
Within one year of such acquisition an application was made by
the 2nd petitioner for appointment, thereafter by his daughter and
subsequently by his son [1st petitioner].
(iii)
The application of the 2nd petitioner was not considered
contending that he was not qualified. However, in continuation of the same
the application of the 1st petitioner was submitted.
(iv)
There is no dispute about the land loser status of the 2nd
petitioner and relationship of the 1st petitioner with the 2nd petitioner
consequent entitlement of the 1st petitioner for employment.
Objections and Answers:10.
Objection No.1: No award was passed.
Answer:[i]
There is specific information furnished that award No.12/1992-
93 dated 30.03.1993 passed by RDO/Land Acquisition Officer, dated
06.11.1993. It is evident from the correspondence of the Department that
the 2nd petitioner is shown as land loser and the 1st petitioner is the son of
the 2nd petitioner.
[iii]
As per G.OMs. No.98, the son, daughter, spouse of the land
loser or the land loser himself are eligible for appointment.
In view of the above, this objection found not tenable.
11.
Objection No.2: The 2nd petitioner opted for some employment, and
his employment status can be considered as the 1st petitioner is having an
earning member in the family.
Answer:[i]
It is unfortunate and unfair that a mighty state is taking such a
defence for not considering the request of land loser, that too at a belated
stage. Expecting a land loser to wait for the mercy of the State with a
begging bowl, starving for decades without opting for any alternative for
survival of self and the family reflects the pale nature of the
defence/objection. The 2nd petitioner opted for employment as a casual
conductor in APSRTC. What is the income? How many members are there
in the family? What shall be the criteria of for determining whether there is
an earning member in the family sufficient to deny employment to a person
legitimately entitled are all the relevant considerations. While examining
such aspects, an empathic approach is necessary.
[ii]
It is also relevant to note that the providing employment to an
eligible family member of the land loser, in terms of the acquisition of land,
shall be treated as a part of the promised compensation.
The State,
making a promise assuring some kind of compensation in the form of
monetary benefits, employment or otherwise and going back from such
promise made to citizens after the purpose of land acquisition served and
taking all sorts of objections, twisting the arms of land-loser, would amount
to betraying the trust.
Such kind of exercise, effort etc., in raising
untenable defences by the executives of the State, shocks the conscience
when such defences are subjected to judicial review.
12.
Objection No.3: The first petitioner did not possess qualification as
on the earlier DSC notifications.
[i]
Even as per the contention of the appellant, the first petitioner
acquired ITI qualification by the year 2014. The 3rd DSC was held in
18.06.2019. The objection that ITI qualification was not possessed by the
first petitioner as on 01.10.2011 is untenable since by such date only the
candidature of the 2nd petitioner was under consideration. By the time the
candidature of the 1st petitioner came into consideration viz., 2019 i.e., 3rd
DSC meeting, he possessed the qualification required. Therefore, the
objections contra are liable to be rejected.
[ii]
All other grounds urged and objections raised are found
baseless and untenable when the same are examined in the light of the
facto matrix of the present case.
Jurisprudence relating to the compassionate appointment:13.
Compassionate appointment in respect of deserving member of a
family of an employee died in harness may be a Policy of a State as a
Social security measure but, providing employment to the land loser or his
family member is a promise. Policy may have reasonable parameters but
promise shall be strictly performed as assured, particularly when the parties
for the promise are in unequal bargaining positions. Promise and Policy
cannot be viewed with same lens.
14.
The employment promised to a land loser, shall be weighed with
greater sanctity and certainty than that of a compassionate appointment
designed by State to a member of the family of an employee died in
harness. On noting certain displeasures in implementation of land
acquisition Schemes, particularly providing compensation viz., monetary or
otherwise like providing employment during the last Century made the
welfare State to travel towards Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013 (for short Land Acquisition Act, 2013 or RFCTLARR Act] which
provides mandate for compensation, resettlement, and rehabilitation etc.,.
with all rigor.
15.
We are conscious of the fact that the present case is not falling under
RFCTLARR Act 2013. But the legitimate expectation of a land loser shall
be counted from the angle of such person, who was put under no option
than to surrender the land.
In such a situation, the State shall be
considered as a dominating position and the land losers in a weak position.
Therefore, the extent of trust expected from the State is like that of a parent
towards a child, and if a parent disowns the promise and pushes the child to
all sorts of arm twisting tests, such action of the State cannot be
appreciated.
PRECEDENTIAL GUIDANCE:16.
[i]
This Court, in a case between State of Andhra Pradesh, rep.
by its Principal Secretary and Others and Rajola Jagannadha Reddy
and Others1, vide W.A.No.356 of 2023 has observed, vide para 15, as
follows:“15. Before parting with this order, we intend to place the
following observations on record:
(i) The Governments itself framing the policies for providing
jobs to the displaced persons whose lands were acquired for various
public purposes, to ventilate the grievances and the hardships being
faced by them with a laudable intention by making certain promises
to those displaced persons. Then, it is the duty and responsibility of
the State Authorities to fulfill the promises made in such policies
without raising any technicalities or on flimsy grounds. What the
State authorities have to consider is (1) whether the applicant is
really displaced person or dependant of the displaced family or not?
(2) Whether the candidate is eligible and suitable as per the
respective schemes? Besides this, it is the duty and responsibility of
the State Authorities to fulfill all promises made to the displaced
persons within time frame to provide immediate rehabilitation to them
to overcome from the hardships they have to face immediately after
displacement from their lands.
(ii) In our society, no one can forget the attachment of people
with their lands. Nobody, normally, will be ready to lose their lands,
2025 SCC Online AP 3884
as they love it like their mother. But, when such lands are required for
public purposes, though the owners of the lands are not agreeing to
give their lands, Government is acquiring the lands as per Land
Acquisition Act and the political executive is making several
promises, like to provide employment to one member in the
displaced persons family, as they are deprived of livelihood. If such
promises are not fulfilled within reasonable time by raising
technicalities and on flimsy grounds, the people loose trust on the
State Executive. It makes them painful and then, it may leads to
unrest. As such, State has to avoid such situations by implementing
the rehabilitation schemes properly and promptly.”
[ii]
In a case Md. Yasin v. Bihar State Electricity Board2 a
Division Bench of Hon’ble High Court of Patna (Rancthi Bench) held as
follows:“5.
The question as to whether the persons whose lands have been
acquired would be provided with employment or not is a matter policy
decision of the State. It is unfortunate that despite the fact that the lands
have a acquired as far back as in the year 1960, question of providing
employment to the displaced persons have not attained finality, noticed
hereinbefore, the respondents had granted employment to 298 persons
as far hack as in the year 1977. The petitioners, on other hand, contend
that they are not guilty of any delay or latches on their part, as they all
along been pursuing the matter with Board.
6.
This court in exercise of its jurisdiction or Article 226 of the
Constitution of India not embark upon determination of disputed question
of fact. Further, after lapse of 33 years of acquisition, this Court cannot
issue a writ of or in the nature of mandamus directing the respondent
1993 SCC OnLine Pat 271 : (1994) 1 PLJR 65
Board to appoint all the persons irrespective of the fact as to whether
there are vacancies and whether the persons applying are now eligible
for appointment or not. However, the conduct of the respondent Board is
evidently not fair in so far as it appears to have been taking inconsistent
stand from time to time. It is not the case of the respondent that it had
rejected the recommendation of the Deputy Commissioner in respect of
providing employment to 114 persons. As a matter of fact, the contention
of the respondents that after inquiry a list of 220 jamabandi raiyats has
been prepared, which includes the names of some of the petitioners, but
that the names of such persons have not been verified from the Register
2 maintained in the office of the circle officer.”
[iii]
A Coordinate Division Bench of this Court in K.Lakshmi
Reddy Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh3, vide W.P.No.12681 of 2023 dated
12.08.2025 has considered the applicability of the G.O.Ms. No.98 dated
15.04.1986 and extended the benefit thereof in a similar situation,
considering the circumstances where the name of the applicant was
approved by the District Selection Committee and the appointment was
awaited.
Conclusion and Result:17.
Upon considering the factual matrix and also the observations in the
minutes of the District Selection Committee, dated 01.07.2019 and also the
discussions made above, this Court finds that there are no valid grounds to
interfere with the impugned orders dated 12.10.2023 passed by the learned
2025 Supreme (Online) (AP) 14145
Single Judge of this Court in W.P. No.33805 of 2022. Consequently, the
appeal is liable to be dismissed.
18.
Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order
as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
__________________________
JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
__________________________________
JUSTICE A.HARI HARANADHA SARMA
Dated: 25.09.2026
Pnr
Whether the order is:Reasoned
Speaking
Yes/No
Reportable
Yes/No Non-reportable
Note:L.R. copy be marked.
B/o.
Pnr
Yes/No
Yes/No
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE BATTU DEVANAND
&
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
WRIT APPEAL No.1206 of 2023
Dt. 25 -09-2026
Pnr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review