Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
ANI)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 5671 OF 2011
Petition under Section 1 15 of CPC r/w Sec. 41 of Arbitration Act, 1940,
aggrieved by the Order and decree dated 05.12.2011 passed in lA. No.33B of
2O11 it OS.No. 545 of 1989 on the file of the Court of the V Senror Civil Judge,
City Civrl Court. Hyderabad
Between:
1. The A P S R T.C rep. by its Chief Civil Engineer-ll, N/usheerabad,
Hyderabad.
2. The lVlanaging Director, APSRTC, [/lusheerabad, Hyderabad
...PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS/DEFENDANTS
AND
R.Venkat Reddy,, S/o Late Ram Reddy, Contractor, R/o- H.No. 3-5-98/9,
Narayanguda' Hyderabad
...RESpoNDENT/pETrroNER/pLATNTTFF
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section '1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
expedite the final hearing of the Civrl Revision Petition No. 5671 of 2011 by fixing
an early date of hearing.
Counsel for the Petitioners:SRl. R ANURAG, SC FOR TGRTC
Counsel for the Respondent:SRl ARPITH REPRESENTING SRl. VIVEK JAIN
The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH COURT'FOR THE STATE OF TELAI\I;ANA
AT HYDERABAD
I{ON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE K. LAKSHMA]I
AND
T{oN'I]t,E JT]STICE V. IT,\N'TAKRISHNA RT DDY
CIVtt,ITEVISI ON PETITINO No.567l OE .0ll
Betrveen
APSI(I'C. Represcntcd b1 its Chicl'CiviI Engineer-II
Musheelabad. I Il clcrahad arrd another
. . Petitioners
.
atld
.
R. Venkat Itedcll
Rcsponder-rt
This Court dclivcrcd the iollowing OTTDER
(Pcr Ilon ble Sri Justioe K L'akshman)
i
- I{eard Mr. tt. Anurag, Iearncd Standing Cc rnseI for the
I
petitioners - Ciorporalion and Mr- Arpith, learned cotLr s :I representing
I
Mr. Vivek Jain, leau'red counsel appcaring fol the Resp 'ndent'
I
2.
I
The present Civil Revision Petition is red against the
order dated 05.11-201I in I-A. No 3i8 ol 20 I1 in
I
S' No 545 of
1989 [hercirrafter' "irnpugnccl or<leL"l passed by the le rmed V Senior
I
Civil Judge' ()it1' Cir,il Cour1, Fly'derabad [hereinafl'er
I
I
I
i
..the Reference
Court"].
.oo,"
t
3. 'lhis is an unfortunate casc whero the Respondent had
invoked arbitration proceedings in 1989 However, due to the present
proceedings artd such othcr previous ploccedings initiated b1'
the
Ciorporation, the arbitration proceedir-rgs rernained pending'
4. Thc Petitioners are tl.re Andhra Pradesh (now Telangana)
State I{oad Transport Corporation (hereinatter relered to as
'corporation'). The Respondent is a private contractor' The facts
briel are that, pursuant to a tendet' tloated by tl-re Corporation'
Respondent was sclected as a contractor to construct
in
tl're
the "Acute
Medicarc and Traunia Complex,, at Gandhi Hospital, HydeLabad.
Accordingly, a Work Order dated 04 04 1987 was issued
Responder-rt to begin the construction works' Pursuant
to the
to such Work
Order, the Respondent claims to have paid the F'MD and
invested huge sums of money' However, the Respondent
to have
alleges that
the corporation had not handed over the site As there was
a delay in
handing over the site, the Respondent claims to have addressed
to the corporation. ln reply'to rvhich, he was iuformcd that
letters
the site rvas
shilted from Gandhi Hospital to Musheerabad Jail' This was followed
by other letters dated 16.06.1988 and 2206'1988 whereby the
corporation infbrmed the Respondent tl-rat the site for construction
of
,)
"Acute Medicarc and'fraurna Complex,, was not hnaliz :d and that the
Work Order dated 04.04. 1987 was cancelled.
5. Contcndins lhat thc r-rnilatcr-al ter.rnination,, ancellalion of
the Work Order dated 04.04. 1987 rvas illegal .s ht r : invest,rents
\\'erc alrcady rnadc, tl-re Respondcnt addressed l lettcl dated
l3.07. 1988 seekins rhc clispLrtcs to be refen.ed to an ir t itrator. As the
Corlroration did not aqrce lbr the r.etcrence, the Respc lenL had filcd
r
O.S. No. 545 of 1989 under Secrion l0 ol the Arbitlrt on Act, 1940
Ihelcinafter "1hc Act ol 1910"].
6. lnitially, O.S. No. 545 oi l9g9 t-rlcd for rLl pointrnent of
Arbitrator was disrnissed bv the I{el-erence Court vrr( udgrnent and
decree dated 14.10. 199j. Aggrievcd by the sarne, I c respondent
hercin pref'erred an appeal vide AAO No.62l of 1994. i ide judgment
dated 10.03.2000, learned Single Judge, allowed rl r said appeal
setting aside the.iudgrnent and decree dated 14.10.1993 nd
remanded
thc rnattel lor fresh disposal to appoint an Arbitrator h,-r r
u'as concluded contract existcd betu.een the parlies.
A1r rieved by the
said.jr-rdgment dared 10.03.2000 ol learned Singrr
Clorporation prefened I_pA No. 16g of 2000
ing that there
Judge, the
befbre tl're Division
Ilench. Vidc judgurcnt dated I:1.03.2003, a Division
t cnch o1' this
judgrnent of the
Court dismissed the said appeal confirming tlie
learned Single .ludge. l'hus. the order o1 the leamed Single
attainect finality. Pursuaut to thc judgrr.rcrrt of lcatned Single
Judge' the
Judge of
Relerence Court appointed Sri Justice Ranga Rao' Fonner
High Court as an Arbitrator" Thc Corporation instead of
orders of the learned Single Judge, tlled a Revision
Judge
obeying the
vide CRP No'2552
of 2005 challenging the appointtnent ol the said Arbitrator'
Ilowevet '
thls Court. alter hcaL'ir.rg both sicles' disrnissed the said CRP
on
05.012.2001.
7. We stre ss he re tl-rat the arbil-rator was appointed after
than 15 years since the filing of OS' No' 545 of
1989' Instead of
participating in the proceedings, the Corpolation again
relerence order dated 08.11 2004 in C R'P No
challenged the
2552 of 2005 ]'his
Courlvide order dated 05'l22OO7 dismissed the said
the reference to arbitration and the appointment
more
CRP confirming
of the arbitrator'
8. Tl-re arbitral proceedings cotntrenced During
its pendency'
the Respondent fited an application seeking to include
clairns to be adjudicated bv the arbitrator' These
additional
claims pertained to
the atteged business loss due to thc illegal tennination
of the contract
and the delay car'rsed by the Corporation in appoinlment
of the
arbitrator, Furthcr', compensation r.vas also sougltt ,owards lcgal
e\pcnses. Towards loss ol busincss, a total ol Rs. 2,2i 00,000/- (two
crores and trt,cntv lakhs onlr,) r,i as claimed
9. Tlie arbitrator ref used to entertain thes -' additional /
subsequcnt claims on thc gr.ound that such claims r,r,,,r : not r.eflemed
lbr adjLrdication br the Reference Court in O.S. No. ,..: of 19g9. The
Itefcrencc (lourt rclied on Orissa Mining Corporalio r LtrI. v. M/s
Prannath Vishwana th Rarvlevt and directed thc F espondcnt to
obtain furthcr olders from the Ref'er.ence Court in I. lation to the
adclitional clairns
10. Accordinely, the Respondent had approachrx he Reference
Corrrt vrde I.A. No. i28 ol 201I in O.S. No. 545 or' l9g9 seeking
.ef'crence of the additional / subsequent claims to ar,itration. .l.he
Ilet'e.cnce cou.t vrde the i,pugned order dated 05. r-. r0l r allowed
the Responclerrt's application and rett.red the rdditionr l claims to the
arbitrator.
I l. l'hc findings of the l{efercnce Court in the irr rugned order
are cxtractcd belor.r'
\[{ )977 S(, ]01
.+
"25- In the installt casc as scert fiottl avcrurents in thc
counter it is clcar that still thc nlattor is bcfore thc
Arbitrator and tlrc stagc ttl lhc procecdings befirrc thc
Arbitrator is conrins rtll lirt arurttttcnts At that
lll.) rrith tlte ptesent
-jlrncturc Ihc ctlrlttltatiorl cillllc
petition to includc the irtiditiortal elairtrs lirr dccisiort
bclorc thc arbitrator.
According to Scction l0 ol'tlrc Arbitration Act all thc
clisputes tllaI arosc Ilcl.ucctt tllc llltrttcs itt pttt'suatlce tll'
the agrccnrcnt sltall hc tlcettlctl [)\ tllc artritrator'
In tl.tc instant citsc a5 tl)c lllattcr is still pcnding
befbrc the athitnttor. lltc ldditrottal claills rclcrred b1
thc corporation prinia tlrcic llccds l() bc consicler ancl
exar.nined b1' thc arbitratol irlclttclirtg '"r'ith resard to
rnaintainabi litl' ol' additional clairtrs-
'l'hc additional
claitrs are in contittuatiott o1' disputcs bctu cen thc
parlies.'l'his cotlrt ltcls [.rr rcl'erritrg thc lratter to the
Arbitrary to dccitle the additional claitns also is just
and propcr thcrcbl thc itt-hitrator rrill exaurine ancl
dccidc tlte additional clairus ol' thc corporation in
accordance u'ith larr.
25. As per thc ordcr's rn lA 51ir 1989 this court
apporntcd thc t lon'blc .ltrstice Sri Lltanga Rao retired
Judge ol Ilon'blc High Cotrn ol'A I' as arbitrator and
the r attcr is still pcnding not at all disposcd ol
coming up f-or arquntctl ts.
In victr. ol'pcndcncl, of thc nrattcr, tlri; :our t t'ee ls
thc adrlitional clair.ns are continuation o
lrc rnatter
rc li'rrcrl to tltc arl)itrator.
Irt r ierr of abovc thc ahor.e tliscus:
r
l thcrc is
;ti.itttLr lttc.it' rtccds to bc consirlcrccl an,l
( xiu)l ine d
rc.qurrlins thc adriitional lssucs l)ccausc tlt,.
Ig rcc nrcn t
i is bclsccn thc partics and thc additionu
'la inrs arc
rrlsir corrtinuation of- disputc in hctrvccrr
le llal tics
pcnding. bclirre thc IIon'blc arhitrator 1,. rrir l lrc ic
Ircctls to be considercrl and c\amincd Lr. thc t t,\'
lla
inclrrdirrg rcgardine ntaintainabilitr ol' sar,l
rJd ition,rl
cllrirns irr accordance riith larr. Ilcrrcc tt
point is
rirtsrr erctl accordingly. "
a. 'firer-cfirre. considering
that the al.bitration pr ) e cd ings \\ cl'e
alLcadl pendirl{r. and rhe lact that afl trre disputes are to r. acriucricated
b'tlre arbitrat.r. the atlditional claims rvere rcl'err.ed tt, lrc erbitrator.
Thc Ref'e'cnce (l.urt also considered that thc additior* r clairns raised
b' thc- Ilcspor-rclc,t are in relatio, to the contir-ruing di,,1 utes betq,ecn
thc parties. l-ikcri isc. the maintainability and entir , rrc.1 oI rhe
additional clainrs u,as left fbr the arbitr-ator to dccide.
I 3.
,\grirst llrc .cfere.cc of atrditional crai,rs t, hc .rbitrator.,
the corporati.n hrs rlled the present civir Re'isiorr )otirion. rhe
('ontentior.ts ol'the ('or-poration are as
lbllows:
I
I
O.S. No. 545 of 1989 r'r'as clecleed by appointing an
arbitrator. Thc samc attaincd finatit,v' The Referencc
Coutt afler thc allpointmcnt o I thc arbitrator becomes
.fitnctus o.fficio. Therclbrc-
adclitionaL clairns, atier a lapse
of 07 years, could not havc bect-t ret'erred to arbitration
by
the Reference Coutt.
I
Once the main case is disposcd ot. no partl'can reopen
the proceedings b-"- fiting rnisce Ilaueotts applications'
Rcliancc was placecl or thc lrrinciple laid dotvn b1
Lhc
Apex Court in Ajay Kum:tr 'lain r'' State of U'P'2
lll
The additional clairns sought to be adjudicated b1' the
arbitrator are ve[v retnote and arc barred by limitation
The said claims do not relate to tire arbitration agreemet-It
and are non-albitrable. Reliance was placed on
principle [aid doq'n by the Apex Court in Union of
v. Raunaq lnternational Ltd'-]
' 2024 SCC Onl-ine SC i677
I
izooe; tz scc 323
the
lndia
ll
l
1l
1V
lhc proceedirrgs befbre the arbitrator wer. i t thc stag: of
argurxents. At such a belated stage, aclor ionill claims
could not havc been ref-erred to the arbitrar-(,r
The additional clain'rs are lresh claims. '[- I :rclbre, fl esh
procccclinus have to be initiated by issuinl. r notice. The
lrbitlator cannol adjr-rdicate additional cLair: s in pencling
proceed ings
14. In his rcplr'. thc Respondent supported the tlrr_l ngs rendered
in the rrnpugnccl orcler aucl contended as lollorvs
l-he aclditiotral clairr-rs relate to the loss o business on
accorrnt o1'delay attlibutable to the Corpor r ion. 'fhe said
claims are Lelated to the main claims rvhic r u,ere already
relcrred to arbitration. Therefore, such claiir s could have
bccn lef'erred to albitration. Reliance was I ,l rced on H.L.
Batra and Co. v. State ofHaryanaa.
lt.
Relying on Stnte of Goa v. Praveen ll r erprisess, ir
n as c:onrencled that unless the arbitration c I use ret'crs to
specifrc dispr-rtes, the parties are entitled Lc raise all the
'i (rgeq) 9 st( r88
(20
[) t2 s('(] .t8l
I
I
t2
disputes relation to t.he agreement. Furlher, such clajms /
counter claims can be arnended.
I5. At this stage, we rrould like to highlight thar t,hen rhe
prescnt civil Revision Petition came fbr adrnissio.. the predecessor
bencli which heard thc matter had sta) ed lhe a'bitration pr.oceedings
vide orde r dated 22-12.201 i. The said stav operatcs titt datc. Furlher,
vide order dated 11.04.2017, rhe intcrirn order dared 22.ll.l0ll u.as
niade absolute and the fbllowing obsen,ations w,er.e made:
"ln our, prinia tircic. opinion rvith the disposal o[.
the suit, the Court helol has becomc firnctus olficicr
and thcrefore, it could not havc rot'errcd additional
claims for arbitration. Moreover, thc intcrirn orclcr was
grantcd as far back as 22.12.2011_ IIencc. at this
length of tirne, it is not dcsirable Lo \racat_c the said
interirn ordcr as doing so r.i ould rendcr thc revision
pctition itself infiuctuous.
For the alorementioned reasons. C_R.p.M.l,
No.8048 ol 2016 is disrnissod. Inrcrirn ordcr. darecl
22.12.201l. in C.R.P M.P.No.7972 of 2011 is madc
absolutc. C.R.P.M.l,.No_ 1972 ol 201 l. accordingly.
stands disposed ot."
16. We have heald the learncd Counsel appearing ibr thc parries
at length. The question before us is q,hether the Rel'er.ence Court
-)
-l
becornes fazc tus officio under the Act, 1940 after the aI cointment of
an arbiLrator ancl rvhether such Refercnce Cou( could rave l'elerled
the additional clainrs to arbitration after an arbitrato' rvas alreadv
appointecl
I 7.
-[-o
ansu c[ tllc above question, it is releva r to note the
distinction betu,een the Albitlation Act. 1940 and thc . 'rbitration &
Conciliation r\cL. 1996 fhereinafter "1996 Act"-. The latter
incorporates the f'caturcs ol rninimurn judicial interlr ntion in the
conduct ot' arbitral prcceeclings, r,n,hcre as the lormer- :ontentplatcs
condirct ol' lrrbitral pr-oceedings under the control and s qren ision of
the Cour1.
I 8. Llnder the Act
ol 19.10, Section 2(c) define:' 'Cou(" as a
civil court hav ine .lurisdiction to decide the questions ibnning thc
subject mattel ol thc rcf-erence as if the same were the s rbjcct matter
of a suit. ln other u orcls. for the ptrrposes of the Act of 940. "Court"
means Lhe court u hich rvould have jurisdiction if a suit I rd been filed
under the Code ol- ('ir il l)roccdr.rrc
19. l'he Court. as deflned under Section 2 (c) of rre 1940 r\ct,
has bccn conlcrrecl u iLh varioLrs powers including the _. rrver- to reler
I
1.+
disputes an albitrator, appoir-rt an arbitrator,
relrove the arbitrator, ctc.
Under Section 20 olthe 1940 Act, pou,er
has bcen conl.cred on the
Courl to ret'er the disputes to arbitration ancl
to appoint an ar.bitrator_.
20. l'he Court, undcr the 1940 Acr, reLains
the arbitral proceedings and the post_arbitral
arvard is passed by an arbitrator appointecl
same has to be signed and filed befbrc
higher control orer.
proceedings. Once an
under the 1940 Act. tire
the Couft under Scction i-1.
After fiting ol thc award, the Court shall issue noriccs
ro rhe parliijs
and Itcal objections on the awarcl. Under
Sections l5 & 16. the C.our.t.
alter hearing the parties, can conl-rrm the
award. modify or correct the
awald, remit the award, or set aside the award.
If the awar.d is
confirmed, the Courl shall pronounce a judgment
in ternts of Lhc,
awa.d. This judgement will be followed by
a decr.ee.
.fhis
is envisased
undcr Section 17 ofthe 1940 Act.
21. It is perlinent to note here lhat the term ..Court,,
rnultiple provisions like Section 14, 15, 16, 11
undel Section 2 (c) ol the Act, 1940. Meaning
, and 20 is deflncd
thereby that, oncc an
arbit.ator is appointed under Section 20 by the Court,
be frled by the arbitrator before the same cor-,1
used in
an award has ro
and the.iudgrnent shalr
be pronounced by the sarne Court. This indicates
that the Refercncc
Court, i.e., thc Court acting undcr Section 20 ol thc M0 z\ct retains
control over the arbitr-al proccedings till the.judgemen. rnd decree are
passcd ir-r tcms of Scction 17. Ttris means that the Re 'crcnce Courl,
afier- appcrintinq iln arbitratol'. does not bccome.f nclus t lJicir..t
22. N-orv corniLrrl to the tacts of the case, it r.vas Ii vently argued
on bchalf of the ('orporation that once Sli Justice T. F anga Rao rvas
appointed as an arbitrator vlrle order datcd 08.1 1.2004 i O.S. No. 545
of li)89 and the sanre was confir'me d Lrv this CoLrrt r I 1t: order dated
05,11.1007 in C.R.P. No 1552
ol 2005, the proccc lings attained
finalit1,. Thc (ior-Por.tlion's argument is that thc Rt lcrence Courl
becorres./Lrzcl tt.s o.ffit'io and could not have enterlained .A. No. 338 of
20 I I in C).S. r\-o. i4,5 ol' 1989
23. Wc disagree r.vith the argument advanced r,r behalf of the
Corporation. As discussed sullra, the Reference (l ruft does not
becorne .ftLnctus o,ffi t ict aftcr appointment of the arbii ,rtor. The said
CoLrrt still rctains control to enterlain any "subseqr-r,: Lt applications
arising out o1'that rcterence". [n this regard, Section ] of the 1940
Act may be ret'erred to. Sccriorr 3l (4) exprcssll. tates that the
Relercnce (iru11 has.;Lirisdiction to cntertain subseqr_r: rt applications
t
arising out of the referencc. Fo. the sake o1'convenience. Section r r is
extracted below
---l
l. .lurisdiction:- ( l) Sub.iccr ro the provisions
ol this Act. au au ar-d rnay be filed in an1, CouLt
having jurisdiction in thc mattcr to rvlrich thc
I
ref'crencc rclatcs.
I
i
(2) Notu ithstanding anything containcd in anr
other la\\ ltrr the tinrc bcing in foroc ancl savc as
othcrrr isc proi.idcd in this Act, all questions
rcgarding thc validity.. eflecL or cxistence of an
arvard or atr arhitration agree ment bc[r'i ccn thc
parties to lhe aglecment o[ persons clairning
under them shall be clecidcd by the Court iu
u,hich the arvardcd under the agrcement has
been, or may bc. tiled. and by no other Ctourl.
(i) AII applications rcgarding the conducr ol
arbitration proceedings or otherwisc arising out
ol such proccedings shall be rnade to the Court
ivherc thc axard has becn. or rnav bc. filed- arrd
to no other Court.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained
elsewhere in this Act or in any other law for
thc time being in force, where in an]'
reference anS.application under this Act has
bcen made in a Court competent to entcrtain
it, that Court alonc shall have jurisdiction
ovcr the arbitration proceedings antl all
tl
subsequcnt applications arising out ( I' th at
Court lrnd in no other Court.',
24. While the Corporation is correct in cort rnding that thc
albitratol is bouncl bi the rci-cr.encc rnadc b1 the I cf'erence Couft
uude-r Section
l0 and the scope o1- the rct-erence ceLr ot bc enlarged,
r
thc 1940 Act does not proscribe amcudrrent of clr nts or seeking
ad-iud ication ol subsequent clairns. \Vhen the arbitrirl
rr-occedings are
pending and if the partv t'eels that ancillarv clairns
rise out of the
main claim, such partv rnay seek amcndment of their r Iairn petil.ion to
i
?
':
:
include such a clailr. Needless to sa1,, that the princi; es of Order VI
Rule 17 rvould apply to such cases.
25. Whilc an arnendrrent petition can be ent rtained by the
arbitrator himsell, it doe s not protribit thc party h.on i pproachir-rg the
i
Refbrence Cor-rrt seekins re l'erence of additional r' subs r quent claims to
the albitrator. In tl-ris rcgard, it is apt to note that in )rissa Mining
Corporation t,td. (Supra), it was held:
" l I . Section 20( l) of Lhc Arbirration Ac . l0 of
1940. provicles that u.herc a difl'erencc ha; rriscn
and u herc anv persons have entcred I to an
arbiLration aqreculcrlt rhe1. rnal appJl .) the
court iraving j urisd iction iu the mattcr c r hich
r
the agrcclllent rclatcs. tllat [he agrccutcnl. r lilccl
t
l8
in court. Sub-sectiou (4) to S. 20 provides that
tlre court shall ordcr thc agr.cerncnt to bc filcd.
and shall t.nake an orcler ol rcferencc to thc
arbitralor rrppointed bv thc partics. ll/hen on
l
ugreemenl is filed in court ond order of
reference is nrude then the claim ns u result of
llrc order oJ reference is limited to a particular
i'
i
l
!
relie.f anrl the urbitrutor L,annot enlarge the
tcope of the referertce and enlertain Jreslt
claims witltotrt u lirther orler of reference
I
{
from the court On a construction of S. 20 ol thc
I
j
.,\rbitration Act the plea on behalf of thc
I
appcllant ri ill liar c to be acccpted."
I
I
I
26. As is evident fi'orn the above paragraph, fiesh claims can be
cntedaillcd with a further order of reflel.ence. This, in oul. vic\\.
i
est_ablishes that a party can appll.to the [{et'erence Court for a further.
order to include additional and subseqnent claims. -lhe validity and
entitlement of such claims is for the arbitr.ator to decide.
27. ln view of the above discr-rssion, we hold that the impugncd
order is corect. -fhe unfbftunate delay in this case is regrettable. \\/c
direct all the claims to be adjudicated by the learned arbitrator. Wc
hope that the paflies cooperate and assist thc arbitrator in concludinq
the arbitral proceedings at thc carliesr
I9
28. The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. r\ll tlie interim
orders stand vacated, The parties shall bear their own , osts
I
j
I
I
Conscquently. pending r.niscellaneous pctitic,t r, i1' any, in this
revision slia Il stand closcd
I
I
i
:
i
i
i
I
I
:
29. When the present juclgrnent was pronounc: Iin open court,
I
it rvas brought to or.rr notice bv tl-re learned Cor-rnsel 1t the Respondent
r
that, due to old age, Justice T. Ranga Rao (Retd.) is rr ablc to conduct
the arbitraI proceedings. Therelorc, the leamcd I ounsel for the
Respondent requestcd tl'ris Court to appoint a srrt,: litule arbitrator
replacing Justice T. Ranga Rao (Retd.). However, the earncd Counsel
for the Petitioners opposed the same and stated thal r a petition liled
by them a substitute arbitrator cannot be appointed.
30. As statcd above, thc suit fbr ref-erring he disputes to
ar.bitlation was filed in 1989. 'lill date the arbitral 1r ccccdings have
been pending due to r.ro Iault o I the Respondent. Likr:.r rse, by virtue of
r
)0
the order dated 22.12.201I passed by this Cour1, the arbitral
prooeedings were stayed. The stal' order opL-rates till date. It is trite
law that an ac1 ol- the court shall pre.judice no one. l'his is embodicd in
the I-atin maxim 'at:lLts c:ttiue nentinem grat,uhil'. Therefbrc.
remanding thc Respondcnt back to the Civil Court to seek
l
hppointrnent of a substitute arbitlator will causc sclcre prejudice and
will furlher detay the arbitlal pr.ocecdings.
U
U
31. Under Articlc I l5 ol thc Clonstitution ol India, [his Court is
a "couft of record". A rtine .luclse Cor-rstitr-rtion Bench of the Hon'ble
Supreme Courl in Naresh Shridhar N'lirajkar v. State of
Maharashtra6, has held that a "court ol record" is a superiol court
and is not bounds by thc Iimits o l- .iurisdiction. In rppropriate cascs.
where it is expedient and to do cornplete .iustice, this Court can
exercise its plenary powcrs
32. ln tigtrt of the t'acts and circurlstanccs nartated abovc, we
deem it appropliate to appoint Sri Justice P.Naveen Rao, Former
Judge, Iligh Court of 'l'elangana, as the arbitrator to adjudicate the
disputes referred to arbitration uirlc ordct dated 08.1 1.2004 in O.S.
No. 545 of 1989 and order dated 05.12.201 1 in I.A. No. 338 of 201 I
u
1t 9oe; 3 scR z+a
?,1
in O.S. No. 54i of 1989 passed by the learned VLh Scr i rr Civil Judge,
City Clivil Court. Hyderabad.
SD/- I I. OSMAN ALI BAIG
A sl }FANT REGISTRAR
I
/
\
I
//TRUE COPY//
Justice K' LAKSH
One Fair Copy
' to the Hon'ble SRI
Perusal)
kind
LordshiP
His
lFor
I
|,
,i
Be"rtoru oFFtcER
Nj
Hon'ble SRI Justice V' RAMAKRISHI'l' ' REDDY
One Fair Copy
' to the
iFor His LordshiP kind Perusal)
To,
l
The V Senior Civil Judge' City Civil Court, Hyde'r bad (with
records, if anY)
2. 11 LR Copies
3. The Under Secretary, Union of lndia tVlinistry of Law, Jtlr; ce and Company
Affairs, New Delhi
4. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Librerrv High Court for the
State of Telangana, High Court Buildings at Hyderabetr!
5. One CC to Sri R Anurag, SC for TGRTC IOPUC]
6. One CC to Sri Vivek Jain' Advocate [OPUC]
7. T.wo CD CoPies
P]WPSL
w
I
l
HIGH COURT
DATED:0810112026
STATE
\*
o
(
itB 2025
ORDER
CRP.No.5671 of 2011
DISMISSING THE CIVIL REVISION PETI"ION
ae.
o ?'
g-\
I
$l1,1
6)
-b
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review