The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Heard both parties and perused the evidence on record. It is seen from the record that the compensations have been increased from Rs.15,00,000/- per kani to Rs.35,00,000/- per kani in respect of L.A. App. No.53 of 2020 and in respect of L.A. App No.42 of 2022 and L.A. App No.43 of 2022, the compensation Rs.15,00,000/- per kani to was increased from Rs.25,00,000/- per kani. In respect of L.A. App No.50 of 2022, compensation was increased from Rs.15,00,000/- per kani to Rs.30,00,000/- per kani. It is evident from the record that the acquired land in respect of all the 4(four) appeals belong to the same mouja and simultaneously have been acquired vide notification issued in the year 2011. But there is no uniformity in the enhancement of the compensation given for the same piece of land. No reason or basis has been given by the Court below for such non-uniformity in the enhancement of compensation of the land which belongs to the same mouja and was acquired by the notification issued in the same year. As such, this Court feels that the increase of compensation in these appeals is unreasonable. Accordingly, in the view of the above discussion and observation, the impugned judgment and award dated 06.03.2020, passed in Misc.(L.A.) No.196 of 2014, judgment and award dated 18.05.2022 passed in Misc. (L.A.) No.258 of 2016, judgment and award dated 21.06.2022 passed in Misc.(L.A.) No.06 …
11. With the above observation and direction, all these appeals are allowed and thus disposed of. Stay order, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Return the LCRs forthwith. suhanjit
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA APP. NO.53 OF 2020
The Union of India,
Represented by the 2nd-in-Command,
For Commandant HQ, 6 BN, BSF,
Fatikcheera, Mohanpur,
Dist- West Tripura.
……..Appellant(s).
Vs.
1. Sri Pradip Das,
S/o- Late Mani Bhusan Das & Late Hiran Bala Das.
2. Sri Krishna Kumar Das,
S/o. Late Mani Bhusan Das & Late Hiran Bala Das.
3. Sri Keshab Kumar Das,
S/o. Late Mani Bhusan DAS & Late Hiran Bala Das.
4. Smt. Uma Das,
D/o. Late Mani Bhusan Das & Late Hiran Bala Das,
W/o. Sri Badal Roy Sarker,
5. Smt. Purnima Das,
D/o. Late Mani Bhusan Das & Late Hiran Bala Das,
W/o. Sri Sushanta Roy,
All are C/o. Sri Pradip Das of Jugatpur,
P.O. Abhoynagar, P.S. NCC, Dist- West Tripura,
Pin-799005.
……… Principal Respondents(Claimants).
6. The Land Acquisition Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala, Pin-799001.
….. Proforma Respondent(Opposite Party No.2)
LA APP. NO.42 OF 2022
The Union of India,
Represented by the 2nd-in-Command,
For Commandant HQ, 6 BN, BSF,
Fatikcheera, Mohanpur,
Dist- West Tripura.
……..Appellant(s)-Opposite Party.
Vs.
1. Sri Dipankar Das,
Son of Sudhir Chandra Das, resident of Kalikapur,
Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala, District- West Tripura.
2. Sri Bhaskar Das,
Son of Sudhir Chandra Das, resident of Kalikapur,
Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala, District- West Tripura
……….. Respondent-Claimant(s).
3. The L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala.
………Respondent-Opposite Party.
LA APP. NO.43 OF 2022
The Union of India,
Represented by the 2nd-in-Command,
For Commandant HQ, 6 BN, BSF,
Fatikcheera, Mohanpur,
Dist- West Tripura.
……..Appellant(s)-Opposite Party.
Vs.
1. Sri Shyamal Chandra Das,
Son of late Ruhini Chandra Das,
Resident of Kalikapur, Ramnagar,
P.S.- West Agartala.
District- West Tripura.
2. Sri Nirmal Chandra Das,
Son of Late Ruhini Chandra Das, resident of Kalikapur,
Ramnagar, P.S.- West Agartala, District- West Tripura.
…….Respondents Claimants
3. The L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala.
…… Opposite Party-Respondent
LA APP. NO.50 OF 2022
The 2nd – in Command,
Head Quarter, 6 Bn. BSF,
Fatikchera, Mohanpur,
West Tripura.
….. Appellant-Opposite Party.
Vs.
1. Sri Krishna Kumar Baishya,
Son of Late Laxmi Kanta Baishya.
2. Smt. Kajal Rani Baishya,
W/o Late Sukumar Baishya,
Both are resident of Kalikapur, Ramnagar, P.S.- West
Agartala, District- West Tripura.
……..Respondent-Claimant(s).
3. The L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala.
……… Respondent-Opposite Party.
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
Mr. G.K. Nama, Sr. Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 22.02.2023
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
All these appeals are tagged, heard, and taken up
together for disposal since the common question of facts and
law are involved.
2.
These present appeals have been filed under
Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 against the
judgments and awards passed by the learned Land Acquisition
Judge, West Tripura, in their respective Misc.(L.A.).196 of 2014
dated 06.03.2020 in L.A. App.No.53 of 2020, Misc. (L.A.)
No.258 of 2016 dated 18.05.2022 in L.A. App. No. 42 of 2022,
Misc.(L.A.) No.06 of 2017 dated 21.06.2022 in LA. App No.43
of 2022 and Misc.(L.A.) No.261 of 2016 dated 16.07.2022 in
L.A. App. No.50 of 2022.
3.
The facts of the case, in brief, is that the State
respondent vide Notification No.F.09(02)-REV/ACQ/VI/11 dated
06.04.2011
acquired
‘Nal’
class
land
of
the
claimant-
respondents of L.A. App.No.53 of 2020 under District-West
Tripura, Sadar-Sub-Division, Mouja-Ramnagar, Sheet NO.2/p
and
vide
Notification
No.F.9(2)-REV/ACQ/VI/II
dated
21.02.2011 acquired ‘Nal’ class of land of the claimantrespondents in respect of other 3(three) appeals under DistrictWest Tripura, Sub-Division-Sadar, mouja-Ramnagar, sheet
No.2/p for the purpose of construction of BOP ACP of 6 BN BSF.
4.
The L.A. Collector assessed the value of the said
lands @ Rs.15,00,000/- per kani along with other statutory
benefits in the case of claimant-respondents of all the appeals.
The claimants received the amount of compensation under
protest
alleging
that
the compensation awarded by L.A
Collector towards the price of the acquired land was inadequate
to that of the prevailing market price of the land in the
particular area. The claimants being not satisfied with the
awarded compensation submitted a prayer under Section 18 of
the L.A. Act for referring the matter before the learned L.A.
Judge, West Tripura Agartala for determining the adequate
compensation. The reference was registered as Misc.(L.A.).196
of 2014 in respect of L.A. App.No.53 of 2020, Misc. (L.A.)
No.258 of 2016 in respect of L.A. App. No. 42 of 2022,
Misc.(L.A.) No.06 of 2017 in respect of LA. App No.43 of 2022
and Misc.(L.A.) No.261 of 2016 in respect of L.A. App. No.50 of
2022.
5.
The
referring
claimants
filed
their
claim
statements and stated that the land under acquisition was
situated within the Municipal area of Ramnagar Mouja and is at
a short distance from Agartala town. The said land is enriched
by
more
than
one
market
and
other
commercial
and
Government establishments. At the time of acquisition, the
value of the land was Rs.1,00,00,000/- per kani which was not
considered by L.A Collector.
6.
On the other hand, O.P. No.1, i.e. the requiring
Department filed their counter statement and stated that the
acquired land is a ‘Nal’ class of land and is situated far from the
main road. At the time of acquisition, the acquired land had no
potential value as claimed by the claimants. It was also added
that
there
were
no
amenities
or
modern
facilities
like
electricity, water supply telephone, post office, market, school
hospital, etc. The assessment done by the L.A. Collector is
reasonable which was done after considering the market value
of the land at the relevant point in time. The O.P. No.2, the
L.A. Collector, by filing their counter statements also denied
the claim of the claimants for enhancement and stated that the
O.P. No.2 has rightly awarded compensation after considering
the relevant documents as well as mandatory provision of L.A.
Act.
7.
The learned L.A. Judge, West Tripura, Agartala
after hearing the parties and after perusal of the evidence on
record,
vide
order
dated
06.03.2020,
enhanced
the
compensation @ Rs.35,00,000/- per kani along with other
statutory benefits in respect of Misc.(L.A.).196 of 2014. Vide
orders dated 18.05.2022 and 21.06.2022, the learned L.A.
Judge enhanced the compensation to Rs.25,00,000/- per kani
along with other statutory benefits in respect of Misc. (L.A.)
No.258 of 2016 and Misc.(L.A.) No.06 of 2017. In respect of
Misc.(L.A.) No.261 of 2016, vide order dated 16.07.2022, the
learned
L.A.
judge
enhanced
the
compensation
to
Rs.30,00,000/- per kani along with other statutory benefits.
8.
Aggrieved with the Judgments and awards passed
by the learned Acquisition Judge, West Tripura, Agartala, the
appellant has preferred this instant appeal and prayed for
setting aside the impugned judgments and awards.
9.
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI
appearing for the appellant-Union of India as well as Mr. P.
Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-L.A.
Collector and Mr. G.K. Nama, learned counsel appearing for
the claimant-respondents.
9.
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing
for the appellant submits that the L.A. Judge enhanced the
compensation without any basis and documents. Further there
is no uniformity in the award given for the same piece of land
which was acquired by notification issued in the same year.
Mr. G.K. Nama, learned counsel appearing for the claimants
submits that the Court below has handled the matter badly
and prayed for remanding back the matter.
10.
Heard both parties and perused the evidence on
record. It is seen from the record that the compensations
have
been
increased
from
Rs.15,00,000/-
per
kani
to
Rs.35,00,000/- per kani in respect of L.A. App. No.53 of 2020
and in respect of L.A. App No.42 of 2022 and L.A. App No.43
of
2022,
the
compensation
Rs.15,00,000/- per kani to
was
increased
from
Rs.25,00,000/- per kani. In
respect of L.A. App No.50 of 2022, compensation was
increased from Rs.15,00,000/- per kani to Rs.30,00,000/- per
kani. It is evident from the record that the acquired land in
respect of all the 4(four) appeals belong to the same mouja
and simultaneously have been acquired vide notification
issued in the year 2011. But there is no uniformity in the
enhancement of the compensation given for the same piece of
land. No reason or basis has been given by the Court below
for such non-uniformity in the enhancement of compensation
of the land which belongs to the same mouja and was
acquired by the notification issued in the same year.
As
such, this Court feels that the increase of compensation in
these appeals is unreasonable. Accordingly, in the view of the
above discussion and observation, the impugned judgment
and award dated 06.03.2020, passed in Misc.(L.A.) No.196 of
2014, judgment and award dated 18.05.2022 passed in Misc.
(L.A.) No.258 of 2016, judgment and award dated 21.06.2022
passed in Misc.(L.A.) No.06 of 2017 and judgment and award
dated 16.07.2022 passed in Misc.(L.A.) No.261 of 2016 by the
learned L.A. Judge are set aside and the matters are
remanded back to the Court below for consideration afresh.
The Court below after hearing both sides shall pass a
reasoned order by appreciating the evidence and fixing
enhancement of compensation in accordance with the law if
eligible. This exercise shall be completed within 6(six) months
from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
11.
With the above observation and direction, all
these appeals are allowed and thus disposed of. Stay order, if
any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also
stands disposed of. Return the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review