The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. As discussed earlier, the entire incident was in a sudden fight in which the appellant-accused caused head injuries on the deceased with an axe. There was no prior deliberation or determination to fight. The sudden quarrel arose between the parties due to trivial issue of grazing the buffaloes of the appellant for which, the deceased raised objection. In a sudden fight, the appellant had inflicted blows on the head of the deceased with an axe which caused six head injuries. Though the weapon used by the appellant was axe and the injuries were inflicted on the vital part of the body viz. head, knowledge is attributable to the appellant-accused that the injuries are likely to cause death. Considering the fact that the occurrence was in a sudden fight, in our view, the occurrence would fall under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC. The conviction of the appellant-accused under Section 302 IPC is therefore to be modified as conviction under Section 304 Part II IPC.”
13. Having analyzed the entire evidence on record, particularly the evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with the dying declaration – Ex.P9, we have no hesitation to come to a conclusion that the present case squarely falls within the ambit of Section 300 IPC Exception 4. Hence, the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under Section 302 IPC is not sustainable, instead the accused can be convicted under Section 304 Part II IPC. In the result, this Criminal Appeal is allowed in part and the conviction and sentence recorded against the appellant / accused by the learned XIII Additional District & Sessions Judge, Tirupati, in Sessions Case No.125 of 2015, for the charge under Section 302 IPC, vide judgment dated 28.03.2018, is hereby set aside, instead the appellant / accused is convicted under Section 304 Part II IPC and sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a period of seven years while maintaining fine amount. As the appellant / accused was already released on bail by order dated
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010910492018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3596]
WEDNESDAY, THE 15th DAY OF JULY 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SURESH REDDY
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUMATHI JAGADAM
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 3111/2018
Between:
1. THARIMINI GOVINDA RAJU,
VENKATESH CHALL, MUMBAI.
R/O.
D.NO
25,
AZAD
GALLI,
...AP
...APPELLANT
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, Rep by Public Prosecutor High
Court at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT
...RESPO
Appeal under Section 372/374(2)/378(4) of Cr.P.C praying that the High
Court may be pleased to to present this memorandum of grounds of Criminal
Appeal against his conviction appeal by the judgment dated 28/03/2018 in SC
No. 125 of 2015 on the file of the Court of III Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Chittoor District at Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 189 days in preferring the appeal against the
Judgement dated 28/03/2018 in SC no. 125 of 2015 on the file of the Court of
III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Chittoor District at Tirupati, Andhra
Pradesh and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to suspend the execution of sentence passed in S.C.No. 125 of 2015
on the file of IIIrd Additional District & Sessions Judge, Tirupati, judgement
dated 28-03¬2018, and release the petitioner on bail, pending disposal of the
above CrI.A. No. 3111 of 2018 and to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. G VIJAYA SARADHI
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (AP)
The Court made the following:
(Per Hon’ble Sri Justice K.Suresh Reddy)
Sole accused in Sessions Case No.125 of 2015 on the file of the Court
of the learned III Additional District & Sessions Judge, Tirupati (for short, ‘the
learned Additional Sessions Judge’), is the appellant.
He was tried and
convicted by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under Section 302 IPC
and was sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for ‘LIFE’ and also to
pay a fine of Rs.1,000/-, in default to suffer Simple Imprisonment for a period
of three months.
2.
Substance of the charge is that on 28.05.2014 at about 09.30 P.M., the
accused stabbed one Sammiti Govindarajulu @ S.Govinda Raju (hereinafter
referred to as ‘the deceased’) in front of the house of the accused situated at
Aruru Village, Nindra Mandal, causing his death, thereby committed an
offence punishable under Section 302 IPC.
3.
Case of the prosecution, as emanated from the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses, briefly is as follows:
(a) The accused and material prosecution witnesses are residents of
Aruru Village, Nindra Mandal. The deceased was also resident of the same
village. PW.1 is the wife, PW.2 is the mother, PW.3 is the brother-in-law and
PW.4 is the sister of the deceased respectively. The deceased along with
PWs 1 & 2 used to reside in Mumbai eking out his livelihood by doing tailoring
work. Prior to the date of offence, the accused also used to reside in Mumbai
doing the very profession.
(b) While so, in the month of May 2014, the accused as well as the
deceased returned to the native place in view of Ganga Jathara. There were
some disputes between the accused and deceased with regard to the house
site situated in Aruru Village. While so, on 28.05.2014, the accused went to
the house site of the deceased and made a galatta by claiming title over the
said house site. The deceased and PWs 1 & 2 showed their title deed, which
was executed by one S.Ganga Raju, who is the father-in-law of the accused.
The deceased asked the accused to show his title deed with regard to the said
site. On that, the accused asked them to visit his house enabling him to show
the document. At about 09.30 P.M. on the same day, the deceased and PW.1
went to the house of accused and asked him to show his title deed. On that,
the accused went inside the house and brought a knife and dealt a blow in the
Abdomen of the deceased. On hearing the cries of PW.1, PWs 2 to 4 and
others came to the house and intervened.
PW.1 shifted the injured to
Government Hospital, Nagari in 108 Ambulance for treatment. After giving
first aid at the said hospital, the deceased was shifted to S.V.R.R.G.G.
Hospital, Tirupati for better treatment.
(c)
On the early hours of 29.05.2014, PW.11 - Sub-Inspector of
Police, Nindra Police Station, having received the intimation, went to the
hospital and recorded a statement Ex.P9 from the injured. On the basis of
Ex.P9, PW.11 registered a case in Cr.No.38/2014 under Section 302 IPC. He
issued copies of F.I.R. to all the concerned. F.I.R. is marked as Ex.P10.
Later, the injured was shifted to Sri Rajiv Gandhi Government General
Hospital, Chennai. PW.11 went to Chennai and recorded statements of PWs
1 & 2 and others. He also seized the blood stained clothes of the injured,
which were marked as M.Os 2 & 3. Later, he visited the scene of offence at
about 06.00 P.M.
offence.
He prepared a Rough Sketch Ex.P11 at the scene of
He also seized Blood stained earth M.O.5 and Controlled earth
M.O.4 at the scene of offence. Later, he recorded statements of PWs 3 & 4.
Further investigation was taken over by Inspector of Police - PW.13. While
undergoing treatment, the injured succumbed to injuries on 29.05.2014.
Thereafter, PW.1 went to Police Station and gave information about the death
of deceased. PW.12-Assistant Sub-Inspector of Police, Nindra Police Station,
having received information from PW.1, altered section of law from Section
307 to 302 IPC. Altered F.I.R. is marked as Ex.P13. On 30.05.2014, PW.13 –
Inspector of Police, Nagari Police Station took up further investigation. PW.13
visited Sri Rajiv Gandhi General Hospital, Chennai and held inquest over the
dead body in the presence of blood relatives and mediator PW.6. Inquest
report is marked as Ex.P3. During the course of inquest, PW.13 recorded
statements of PWs 1 to 3 and another. Later, he sent the dead body for
Postmortem examination. PW.9 – Assistant Professor, Government Medical
College, Chennai conducted Autopsy over the dead body.
He opined the
cause of death was due to “hypovolemic shock and hemorrhage due to stab
injury to the Abdomen”. He issued Postmortem Certificate Ex.P7.
(d) On 02.06.2014, PW.13 apprehended the accused at Nagari Choultry
in the presence of mediators PW.8 and another. On the confession made by
the accused, PW.13 seized M.O.1 – knife from the house of accused under a
cover of Panchanama Ex.P6. PW.13 sent the material objects to R.F.S.L,
Tirupati under Letters of advice Exs.P14 & 15. R.F.S.L. reports were marked
as Exs.P16 & 17. On 06.06.2014, PW.13 seized Xerox copy of the alleged
disputed site ownership document under a cover of Police proceedings
Ex.P18. After receiving all the documents and after completion of
investigation, PW.13 filed charge sheet.
4.
In support of its case, the prosecution examined PWs 1 to 13, marked
Exs.P1 to P18 and exhibited MOs.1 to 5.
5.
When the accused was examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C., he denied
the incriminating evidence appearing against him.
6.
Accepting the evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with the dying
declaration Ex.P9, the learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted the
accused as aforesaid.
7.
Heard Sri G.Vijaya Saradhi, learned counsel for the appellant, and Sri
Marri Venkata Ramana, learned Additional Public Prosecutor representing the
Respondent / State.
8.
At the outset, learned counsel for the appellant fairly conceded that he
is only arguing with regard to the nature of offence and he is not arguing for
acquittal. Learned counsel for the appellant contends that all the four eye
witnesses i.e., PWs 1 to 4, in their evidence, have specifically stated that it is
the accused, who went to the house of deceased at about 09.30 P.M. on
28.05.2014. PWs 1 to 4 also stated in their evidence that when the deceased
went and questioned the accused about his title deed with regard to the
disputed house site, the accused stabbed the deceased at his Abdomen and
went away. PWs 1 to 4 in their evidence have specifically stated that the
deceased dealt only one blow in the Abdomen of the deceased. He further
contended that in the dying declaration Ex.P9, the deceased also stated the
very same fact that the accused dealt one blow in his Abdomen with M.O.1 knife. As such, he states that the conviction under Section 302 IPC is not
sustainable, instead the appellant can be convicted under Section 304 Part-II
IPC.
9.
On the other hand, learned Additional Public Prosecutor opposed the
appeal contending inter alia that the accused used a knife and he also stated
that the accused stabbed the deceased in the Abdomen, which is a vital part
of the body. As such, the intention of the accused can be gathered as the
accused selected situs of the injury, which is a vital part of the body. Hence,
he requested this Court to dismiss the appeal by confirming the conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge.
10.
We have carefully scrutinized the entire evidence on record.
11.
PW.1 is the wife, PW.2 is the mother, PW.3 is the brother-in-law and
PW.4 is the sister of the deceased respectively. PW.1 in her evidence has
stated that on 28.05.2014 at about 09.30 P.M., she along with her husband deceased went to the house of accused and asked him to show his title deed
with regard to the disputed house site. Immediately, the accused went into
the house, brought a knife and gave one blow in the Abdomen of the
deceased. Hearing her cries, PWs 2 to 4 came to the scene of offence and
rescued the deceased from the hands of accused.
PWs 2 to 4, in their
evidence, have stated that hearing the cries of PW.1 they came to the scene
of offence, which is situated in front of the house of accused and saw the
accused stabbing the deceased in his stomach with M.O.1 – knife. All the four
witnesses in their evidence have categorically stated that the accused dealt
only one blow in the Abdomen of the deceased with M.O.1 – knife and
thereafter he did not repeat the blows on the deceased.
In the dying
declaration – Ex.P9 recorded by PW.11, the deceased has also stated the
very same fact that he along with his wife went to the house of accused and
questioned the accused to show his title deed with regard to the disputed
property. Immediately, the accused stabbed him with M.O.1 – knife in the
Abdomen. As such, the evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with the dying
declaration – Ex.P9 disclose that the accused dealt only one blow in the
Abdomen of the deceased and he did not repeat the blows. After the arrival of
PWs 2 to 4, the accused left the place. Further, it is the deceased, who went
to the house of accused, and the accused never visited the house of the
deceased.
Admittedly, the incident took place in front of the house of
accused. As such, it cannot, by any stretch of imagination, be said that the
accused has got pre-mediation and also has got intention to kill the deceased.
12.
In a case of this nature, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kulwant Rai v.
State of Punjab1, held as follows:
“3. When the matter was before the High Court it was
strenuously urged that in the circumstances of the case part I of
Section 300 would not be attracted because it cannot be said that the
accused had the intention to commit the murder of the deceased. In
fact, that is conceded. More often, a suggestion is made that the case
would be covered by part 3 of Section 300 Penal Code in that not only
the accused intended to inflict that particular injury but the injury
intended to be inflicted was by objective medical test found to be
sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. The question
is in the circumstances in which the offence came to be committed,
could it ever be said that the accused intended to inflict that injury
AIR 1982 SC 126
which proved to be fatal. To repeat, there was an altercation. There
was no premeditation. It was something like hit and run. In such a
case, part 3 of Section 300 would not be attracted because it cannot be
said that the accused intended to inflict that particular injury which was
ultimately found to have been inflicted. In the circumstances herein
discussed, it would appear that the accused inflicted an injury which he
knew to be likely to cause death and the case would accordingly fall
under Section 304 Part II Penal Code.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Khuman Singh v. State of Madhya
Pradesh2, held as follows:
“8. The question falling for consideration is whether the
appellant-accused intentionally caused the death of deceased Veer
Singh? The entire incident occurred when the appellant had taken his
buffaloes for grazing in the field of the deceased for which the
deceased objected and drove all the buffaloes out of his field. It is in
these circumstances, the appellant became furious and abused the
deceased and caused injuries on his head in a sudden fight with axe.
There was no premeditation for the occurrence and because of the
grazing of the cattle, in a sudden fight, the occurrence had taken place.
9. The question to be considered is whether the act of the
appellant-accused would fall under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC?
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC can be invoked if death is caused:- (a)
without premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight; (c) without the offender
having taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner;
and (d) the fight must have been with the person killed. In the present
case, the appellant-accused and the deceased exchanged wordy
abuses on which, the appellant gave the deceased blows on his head
causing six head injuries. Where the occurrence took place suddenly
and there was no premeditation on the part of the accused, it falls
under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC.
(2020) 18 SCC 763
10. As discussed earlier, the entire incident was in a sudden
fight in which the appellant-accused caused head injuries on the
deceased with an axe. There was no prior deliberation or determination
to fight. The sudden quarrel arose between the parties due to trivial
issue of grazing the buffaloes of the appellant for which, the deceased
raised objection. In a sudden fight, the appellant had inflicted blows on
the head of the deceased with an axe which caused six head injuries.
Though the weapon used by the appellant was axe and the injuries
were inflicted on the vital part of the body viz. head, knowledge is
attributable to the appellant-accused that the injuries are likely to cause
death. Considering the fact that the occurrence was in a sudden fight,
in our view, the occurrence would fall under Exception 4 to Section
300 IPC. The conviction of the appellant-accused under Section
302 IPC is therefore to be modified as conviction under Section 304
Part II IPC.”
13.
Having analyzed the entire evidence on record, particularly the
evidence of PWs 1 to 4 coupled with the dying declaration – Ex.P9, we have
no hesitation to come to a conclusion that the present case squarely falls
within the ambit of Section 300 IPC Exception 4. Hence, the conviction and
sentence recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge under Section
302 IPC is not sustainable, instead the accused can be convicted under
Section 304 Part II IPC.
In the result, this Criminal Appeal is allowed in part and the conviction
and sentence recorded against the appellant / accused by the learned XIII
Additional District & Sessions Judge, Tirupati, in Sessions Case No.125 of
2015, for the charge under Section 302 IPC, vide judgment dated 28.03.2018,
is hereby set aside, instead the appellant / accused is convicted under Section
304 Part II IPC and sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for a period
of seven years while maintaining fine amount.
As the appellant / accused was already released on bail by order dated
10.05.2023 vide I.A.No.1/2023 in terms of the order of the Composite High
Court for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in Batchu
Rangarao v. State of Andhra Pradesh3, he is directed to surrender before
the Superintendent of Central Prison concerned to serve the remaining portion
of sentence, if any, failing which the learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class,
Nagari is directed to secure his presence by issuing Non-bailable warrants
and commit him to prison for serving the remaining portion of sentence, if any.
Needless to state that the period already undergone by the appellant /
accused shall be given set off as per the provisions of Section 428 Cr.P.C.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications pending, if any, shall also stand
closed.
__________________
K.SURESH REDDY, J
15.07.2026
MVA
2016 (3) ALT (Crl.) 505 (DB) (A.P.)
____________________
SUMATHI JAGADAM, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review