Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL
FRIDAY, THE 8
TH
DAY OF JULY 2022 / 17TH ASHADHA, 1944
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
PETITIONER:
THAHIRA,
AGED 63 YEARS,
EVOOR (SOUTH), KEERIKKADU.P.O,
KAYAMKULAM, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT, PIN-690508.
BY ADV K.P.RAJEEVAN
RESPONDENTS:
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD LTD.,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, VYDYUTHI BHAVANAM,
PATTOM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695 004.
ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
ELECTRICAL SUB DIVISION,
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD LTD,
KAYAMKULAM, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT, PIN-690502.
ASSISTANT ENGINEER,
ELECTRICAL SECTION, KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD LTD,
CHEPPAD, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT, PIN-690507.
THE STATE ELECTRICITY OMBUDSMAN,
CHARANGATTU BHAVAN, BUILDING NO.34/895, MAMANGALAM
ANCHUMANA ROAD, EDAPPALLY, KOCHI, PIN-683025.
CONSUMER GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL FORUM (CENTRAL),
220 KV SUBSTATION COMPOUND, HMT COLONY.P.O,
KALAMASERY, ERNAKULAM, PIN-683503.
BY ADV.
SRI B PREMOD, SC, KSEB
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
08.07.2022, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-2-
JUDGMENT
Petitioner
consumer
a
consumer
of
No.1155304022245
electricity
through
bearing
instant
writ
petition has assailed the order dated 03.03.2022 Ext.P13
of the Consumer Grievance Redressal Forum and order
dated
20.06.2022
whereby
the
appeal
No.P/021/22
preferred before the State Electricity Ombudsman has
been dismissed.
2.
The facts in brief are that the petitioner is
running an ice factory under the jurisdiction of electrical
Section
Kerala
State
Electricity
Board
Limited,
Cheppadu (hereinafter referred to as 'KSEBL', for short).
The consumer number aforementioned was provided a
CT operated energy meter which was being regularly
checked by the Engineers and bills were generated as
per the actual consumption.
On 14.09.2021 the Sub
Engineer, Electrical Section along with the Assistant
Executive Engineer, APTS Unit, Alappuzha inspected the
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-3-
premises and prepared a draft Ext.P1 and found that the
connection was given under LT IVA Tariff-3 Phase of
53000 Watts connected load for industrial purposes and
prima facie it was found that there was -29.70 error
(detected) and therefore the meter was recording by
reduction of 29.7%. On the basis of the site mahazar a
provisional
assessment notice was
issued to the
petitioner which was challenged and ultimately final
assessment raising a demand of Rs.96,147/- (Rupees
ninety six thousand one hundred and forty seven only)
was issued.
Petitioner assailed the order before the
Grievance Redressal Forum which was,
as
noticed
above, dismissed and statutory appeal preferred before
the State Electricity Ombudsman also entailed into
dismissal.
3.
behalf
Mr.K.P.Rajeevan, learned counsel appearing on
of
the
petitioner
challenges
the
order
aforementioned on the ground that there has been gross
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-4-
violation of the provisions of the Regulations 113, 114,
115 and 125 of the Kerala Electricity Supply Code, 2014.
The officers who inspected the premises were not
competent to examine the meter in the absence of any
equipment
as
it
requirement.
is
a
statutory
and
mandatory
Meter should have been removed and
tested in the laboratory by giving advance notice to the
petitioners.
Even as per the definition of the meter
specified under Regulation 2(57) of Supply Code, 2014,
‘meter’
means
the
device
suitable
for
measuring,
indicating and recording consumption of electricity or
any other quantity related with electrical system which
shall also include,
other equipment such as current
transformer
voltage
(CT),
transformer
(VT)
or
capacitance voltage transformer (CVT) necessary for
such purpose.
It is contended that the meter was
installed as per the directive from the electricity
department and has been regularly checked while taking
the reading.
There was no fault of the consumer of
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
tampering the meter.
-5-
If at all there was an intrinsic
defect it could have been rectified after having testing in
the assigned laboratory to find out whether any mischief
was attributed to the consumer or not.
demand should have been raised.
Only then a
Otherwise, it was
incumbent upon the electricity department to replace the
meter. All these points have not been taken care of by
both the authorities and thus there is an abdication,
illegality and repugnance.
4.
On the other hand, learned counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondents submitted that the APTS
team was competent to examine the running of the meter
and with experience as well as qualification apparently it
was found that there was a defect in current transformer
i.e., CT and by noticing all these facts it was found that
the meter was running slow by 29.7%.
demand was raised.
Accordingly
Demand is justified which was
accepted by the authorities, concurrent finding of fact
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-6-
and law cannot be interfered with while exercising the
power of judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties
and appraised the paper books.
6.
Before installation it is the responsibility of the
licensee to satisfy regarding the accuracy of the meter
which shall be tested by them or from the accredited
laboratory
or
in
approved
laboratory.
The
said
provisions had been prescribed as per Regulation 113 of
Supply Code, 2014.
Sub Regulation 2 of 113 does not
preclude the licensee to conduct a periodical inspection
or testing or both the calibration of the meter specified
in the
Central
Electricity
authority
(installation
of
operation of meters) Regulations, 2006 as amended from
time to time.
The periodical testing of the consumer
meter has to be done at the site. There is discretion to
the licensee to test the meter at the site or remove the
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-7-
meter to be tested and replaced with the correct meter
and test the removed meter in an accredited laboratory.
Thus there is a vide discretion given to the officers to
notice as to whether the consumer was indulging into
any
mischief
or
actually
it
was
having
an
meter
as
specified
in
inherent/intrinsic defect.
7.
Definition
of
the
Regulation 2(57) which reads as under:
“meter” means a device suitable for measuring,
indicating
and
recording
consumption
of
electricity or any other quantity related with
electrical system; and shall include, wherever
applicable, other equipment such as current
transformer (CT), voltage transformer (VT), or
capacitance
voltage
transformer
(CVT)
necessary for such purpose;
It clearly specifies that all these CT, CVT and other
things are the part of the meter.
8.
Report
hereinbelow:
of
the
Site
mahazar
is
extracted
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-8-
“On 14 September 2021 Tuesday at 12.15 PM
after inspecting the Electric meter and premises
of Consumer No.1155304022245 which is under
Electric Section, Cheppad of Electrical circle
Hrippad, Alappuzha District of KSEB Ltd, in the
presence of APTS Assistant Executive Engineer
and other witnesses this mahasar is prepared by
Rathesh Kumar T R, Sub Engineer in charge of
the above Section.
The above connection is given under LT-4A
Tariff, 3 Phase of 53000 Watts connected load in
the
address
Enterprises,
of
Evoor,
Mrs.
Thahira,
Pathiyoor
for
vallayil
industrial
purpose in the Building No.III/27(2011-16) Ice
Plant named as Thalavakkal Industries South to
Ramapuram Temple, Easter side of national
Highway in Pathiyoor Grama Panchayat of
Karthikapally Taluk. The Electrical meter of the
above connection is installed inside the Western
wall of the building in the panel board, facing to
the East. This is a CT(Current Transformer)
operated meter. The details of the meter is as
follows:
Make: Secure Model: Premier Type: E3T055
SL No: KSB 34112,3X 240 VoHs, -/5A
impulse:8000/KWh
During the time of reading inspection is given as
follows:
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-9-
Kwh C,38033,KwhC2: 5242, Kwh C3: 26385
CKVAH :74575, CKVArh lag: 24820
CKVArhLead :7.8
R1MD:1.75 KVA 01/09/2021 Time: 12.30
R2MD:1.66KVA 08/09/2021 Time: 19:00
R3MD:1.94KVA 05/09/201 Time: 22:30
The details of the attached CT of the Machine meter is
given as follows:
Make: PGR Poertek Ratio: 100/5 Burden: 5VA
Class: 0.5, Serial Number R-1/3338,Y-1/3336,B-1/3335
On detailed examination of the above CY from
R phase to the meter the wire which tap voltage
to the meter is seen the formation of sludge.
Then on examining each phase of the meter and
voltage it is seen recorded the voltage as
follows- R-phase-30.4V, Y-phase-234V, B phase230V. But on examination of R phase by using
the multi meter it is seen that actually there is
232 voltage. As such by recording low voltage in
R
phase
the
actual
consumption
will
be
recorded in a lower rate. In order to calculate
this difference it is examined by using MT310(sl
No 50043258) standardised and manufactured
by
Zera
and
calibrated
in
the
Electrical
Inspectorate. On such examination
-29.70%
error is detected. That is at present it is
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-10-
recorded in the meter by reducing 29.7%. At
this time the authorised person conducting the
establishment
Sri.
Abdul
shukkur,
Vellalil
House,
Kannampallybhagom,
Kayamkulam,
Mobile
No.7560801956
present
convinced
was
him. No loss is
and
caused to the
Establishment due to the Inspection. Inspection
ended at 2.53 PM today.”
9.
It reveals that there was a defect in one of the
CT and showing less voltage.
Prima facie a prudent
person would understand that it was not a mischief act
but an intrinsic defect.
meters
only
from
the
The consumers purchase the
recognized
and
approved
manufacturers. If at all such type of faults over a period
of time arises, prima facie this Court of the view that
burden should not have been passed upon the consumer,
equal responsibility of the manufacturer also is involved.
But the officials of the Kerala State Electricity Board shy
away in undertaking such exercise and put entire blame
and fault on the consumers. Such exercise in my view is
wholly
fallacious
and
arbitrary.
The
procedure
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-11-
prescribed in the Regulations 115 has totally been
thrown away for the reason that if at all prima facie
inspection team finds fault in the CT, to ascertain the
suspicion ought not to have formed the opinion at the
site but taken the meter to a laboratory (accredited
laboratory) and only after giving advance notice of three
days
as
specified
under
Regulation
which
is
extracted hereinbelow, form an opinion and thereafter
assessment has to be done.
“115 (5) Before testing a meter of the consumer,
the licensee shall give an advance notice of
three days, intimating the date, time and place
of
testing
so
that
the
consumer
or
his
authorized representative can, at his option, be
present at the testing”.
All
these
provisions
of
the
Regulations
and
arguments on the behalf of the consumer has not been
addressed ,there is a misdirection thus the orders are
wholly erroneous and aberrative. Accordingly the orders
Exts.P13, P15 and subsequent demand Ext.P16 bill are
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-12-
quashed. At the best the respondent Electricity Board is
liable to charge the amount of three past cycling bills,
that too after have been obtained the report from the
laboratory.
Since much time has already passed the
condition of the meter is not known thus the said
procedure as prescribed in Regulation 125 can also not
been adhered to at this point of time.
Sd/-
AMIT RAWAL
JUDGE
vv
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-13-
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 22214/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE MAHASAR DATED
14.9.2021.
Exhibit P1a
A TRUE COPY OF ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF
EXHIBIT P1.
Exhibit P2
A TRUE COPY OF THE BILL NO.5530210600115
DATED 1.6.2021.
Exhibit P3
A TRUE COPY OF THE BILL NO.5530210700644
DATED 1.7.2021.
Exhibit P4
A TRUE COPY OF THE BILL NO.5530210800583
DATED 2.8.2021.
Exhibit P5
A TRUE COPY OF THE BILL NO.5530210900385
DATED 1.9.2021.
Exhibit P6
A TRUE COPY OF NOTICE DATED NIL ISSUED
BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT TO THE PETITIONER.
Exhibit P7
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE AND BILL DATED
1.10.2021.
Exhibit P7 a
A TRUE COPY OF ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF
EXHIBIT P7.
Exhibit P8
A TRUE COPY OF CALCULATION STATEMENT
NO.INSP/202122/APTS DATED 14.9.2021.
Exhibit P9
A TRUE COPY OF FORWARDING LETTER I
NO/.DB/APTS DATED 1.11.2021.
Exhibit P10
A TRUE COPY OF BILL DATED 1.11.2021
ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER.
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-14-
Exhibit P10 a
A TRUE COPY OF ENGLISH TRANSLATION OF
EXHIBIT P10.
Exhibit P11
A TRUE COPY OF CIRCULAR
NO.D(D&S)/D2/GENL-08/2015 DATED
25.2.2016.
Exhibit P12
A TRUE COPY OF THE APPLICATION FOR
FILING COMPLAINT WITH THE CONSUMER
GRIEVANCE REDRESSAL FORUM (CENTRAL)
DATED 22.9.2021.
Exhibit P13
A TRUE COPY OF ORDER NO.CGRF-CR/OP
NO.53/2021-22 - 403 DATED 3.3.2022.
Exhibit P14
A TRUE COPY OF APPEAL NO.P/021/22 FILED
BY THE PETITIONER DATED 21.03.2022
BEFORE THE STATE ELECTRICITY OMBUDSMAN
Exhibit P15
A TRUE COPY OF ORDER DATED 20.06.2022 IN
APPEAL PETITION NO.P/021/2022 OF THE
STATE ELECTRICITY OMBUDSMAN
Exhibit P16
A TRUE COPY OF LETTER NO.DEMAND CUM
DISCONNECTION NOTICE/CONNO.22245/CHD/
2022-23/50 DATED 25.6.2022 WITH REVISED
BILL FOR PAYMENT OF RS.99,293/- ISSUED
BY THE 3RD RESPONDNET
Exhibit P17
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210400112
DATED 1.4.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P18
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210500113
DATED 1.5.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P19
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210600115
DATED 1.6.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P20
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210700644
DATED 1.7.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
WP(C) NO. 22214 OF 2022
-15-
Exhibit P21
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210800583
DATED 2.8.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P22
A TRUE COPY OF BILL NO.5530210900385
DATED 1.9.2021 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review