The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. The position of law being crystal clear, the writ petition seeking invocation of the writ jurisdiction of this Court, in an attempt to unseat the respondent No. 7, is therefore not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed. The judgment placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner being of no assistance to his case is not discussed.
12. Accordingly, the writ petition for the reasons aforementioned is dismissed with costs of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand) only to be paid to the Meghalaya State Legal Services Authority for the purposes of legal aid, within 15(fifteen) days from the date of this order. Judge Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 177 of 2023
Date of Decision: 22.08.2023
Shri. Tennydard M. Marak
Vs.
The Election Commission of
India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. J.C. Gaur, Adv. with
Mr. U. Das, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv. (For R 1 & 2)
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv.
Mr. S. Sahay, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA (For R 3-6).
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Oral:
1.
Yes/No
Yes/No
The instant writ petition relates to the purported inaction on the
part of the Election Commission of India, Chief Electoral Officer, State
of Meghalaya and the other official respondents on complaints by the
petitioner about the violation of the provisions of the Representation of
the People Act, 1951 as well as the Model Code of Conduct, during the
general elections for the Legislative Assembly of the State of
Meghalaya held in 2023 by the respondent No. 7, the returned candidate
from 43, Williamnagar Assembly Constituency. The prayer of the writ
petitioner is for directions for registration of a case on the basis of a
complaint dated 23.02.2023 and FIR dated 03.04.2023.
2.
Mr. J.C. Gaur, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the writ petitioner is not challenging the election of the respondent No.
7, but is aggrieved only against the action of the respondent No. 7,
which constitute offences punishable under Section 153A, 163 and 171F
of the Indian Penal Code. Learned counsel submits that inspite of the 2
complaints, the Officer In-charge of Williamnagar Police Station, by
letter dated 28.04.2023, had informed the petitioner that the matter is
clearly under the RP Act, 1951 and the Conduct of Election Rules,
1961, instead of proceeding with registration of the case. It has further
been submitted that, this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution,
has ample discretion to pass appropriate orders directing for
investigation and for action to be taken as per the provision of the RP
Act, 1951. In support of his arguments, the learned counsel has cited the
case of Benedict Denis Kinny vs. Tulip Brian Miranda & Ors. reported
in (2021) 12 SCC 780, with regard to jurisdiction under Article 226 of
the Constitution, to pass interim or final orders in matters governed by
statute and statutory authorities.
3.
The learned Advocate General, Mr. A. Kumar, in reply has
submitted that the allegations contained in the writ petition are totally
confined to allegations against the respondent No. 7, for violation of the
Model Code of Conduct and as such, the writ petition on this ground
itself is not maintainable, as the same is barred by Article 329(b) of the
Constitution, which has laid down that no election to either House of
Parliament or to the House of the Legislature of a State shall be called in
question except by an Election Petition. It is further submitted that
Section 80 of the RP Act, 1951, specifically provides that no election
shall be called in question except by an Election Petition presented in
accordance with the provisions of this part, and as such, the instant writ
petition is liable to be dismissed. In this context, the learned Advocate
General has placed the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered
in the case of N.P. Ponnuswami vs. Returning Officer, Namakkal
Constituency & Ors. reported in (1952) 1 SCC 94.
4.
The learned Advocate General, has also drawn the attention of
the Court to the fact that, the verbal submissions as made by the learned
counsel for the petitioner is not reflected anywhere in the pleadings of
the writ petition and further that, even the complaint dated 23.02.2023,
on which action is sought, was not even filed by the petitioner but by
another person namely a candidate from South Tura named Leslee K.
Sangma. The petitioner he submits, had already approached this Court,
by way of Election Petition being Election Petition No. 8 of 2023, but
withdrew the same on 25.05.2023, on realizing that the same was filed
beyond the prescribed period of limitation and therefore, was not
maintainable. He therefore submits that, the petitioner in filing the
instant writ application is abusing the process of law, in view of the
express bar by law in seeking such reliefs as prayed.
5.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI representing the respondents No.
1 and 2, while endorsing and adopting the submissions made by the
learned Advocate General, has also submitted that the results of the
election were declared on 02.03.2023, and the complaint was submitted
on 23.03.2023, after the election process was over and the Model Code
of Conduct no longer in force. Once elections are over, he submits, the
only remedy available to the petitioner, subject to establishing his locus
standi was to file and pursue an Election Petition, which the petitioner
failed to do within the prescribed time limit of 45(forty-five) days from
the date of declaration of election results. As such, he submits the writ
petition is not maintainable and liable to be rejected in limine.
6.
Heard learned counsels for the parties. Shorn of all
unnecessary details, the only point for consideration in the instant writ
application is whether the instant application is maintainable in the facts
and circumstances of the case. As discussed earlier, the writ petitioner
had approached this Court, by way of an Election Petition, but as the
same was barred by limitation had withdrawn the same and has come
again by way of the instant writ petition. A perusal of the averments and
statements made in the writ petition clearly disclose that the entire cause
of action is centered around the perceived violation of the Model Code
of Conduct, by the respondent No. 7 during the course of the Assembly
elections to 43, Williamnagar Constituency.
7.
In this scenario, therefore Article 329(b) of the Constitution
will definitely come into play. Article 329(b) of the Constitution of
India, imposes a strict bar to the interference by Courts in electoral
matters and for easy reference is quoted herein below.
“329. Bar to interference by courts in electoral
matters.-
[Notwithstanding
anything
in
this
Constitution[***]]
(b) no election to either House of Parliament or to the
House or either House of the Legislature of a State
shall be called in question except by an election petition
presented to such authority and in such manner as may
be provided for by or under any law made by the
appropriate Legislature.”
8.
Furthermore, Section 80 of the RP Act, 1951, has also provided
that no election shall be called in question, except by an Election
Petition presented in accordance with the provisions of that part which
prescribes the presentation of an Election Petition before the High
Court. Section 81 and 86 prescribe the manner of presentation and trial
of an Election Petition. Section 80, 81 and 86 are reproduced herein
below.
“80. Election petitions.—No election shall be called in
question except by an election petition presented in
accordance with the provisions of this Part.
81. Presentation of petitions.—(1) An election petition
calling in question any election may be presented on
one or more of the grounds specified in [sub-section
(1)] of section 100 and section 101 to the [High Court]
by any candidate at such election or any elector [within
forty-five days from, but not earlier than the date of
election of the returned candidate or if there are more
than one returned candidate at the election and dates
of their election are different, the later of those two
dates].
86. Trial of election petitions.—(1) The High Court
shall dismiss an election petition which does not
comply with the provisions of section 81 or section 82
or section 117.”
9.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of N.P. Ponnuswami
vs. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constituency & Ors.(supra) cited by
the learned Advocate General, at Paras – 20 and 21, held that the
language used in Article 329(b) of the Constitution, and Section 80 of
the RP Act, 1951, exclude the jurisdiction of the High Court, to deal
with any matter which may arise, while elections are in progress. The
said paragraphs are quoted herein below.
“20. It was argued that since the Representation
of the People Act was enacted subject to the
provisions of the Constitution, it cannot bar the
jurisdiction of the High Court to issue writs
under Article 226 of the Constitution. This
argument however is completely shut out by
reading the Act along with Article 329(b). It will
be noticed that the language used in that article
and in Section 80 of the Act is almost identical,
with this difference only that the article is
preceded
by
the
words
“notwithstanding
anything in this Constitution”. I think that those
words are quite apt to exclude the jurisdiction of
the High Court to deal with any matter which
may arise while the elections are in progress.
21. It may be stated that Section 107(1) of the
Representation of the People Act, 1949 (12 & 13
Geo. 6, c. 68) in England is drafted almost in the
same language as Article 329(b). That section
runs thus :“No parliamentary election and no return
to Parliament shall be questioned except by a
petition complaining of an undue election or
undue return (hereinafter referred to as a
parliamentary election petition) presented in
accordance with this Part of this Act."
10.
In the case of Ashok Shankarrao Chavan vs. Madhavrao
Kinhalkar & Ors. reported in (2014) 7 SCC 99, the Supreme Court reaffirmed this position by declaring in Para – 35, as follows.
“35.
Apart
from
the
above
provisions,
under Article 329(b), it is specified that an
Election to either House of Parliament or either
House of the Legislature of a State, cannot be
called in question except by an election petition
presented to such authority in such manner as
may be provided for by or under any law made by
the appropriate legislature. While Articles 101 to
and
to
deals
with
the
disqualification of an elected member either to
Parliament or to the State Legislature, Article
329(b) relates to the validity of a member elected
to any constituency in an election held in
accordance with law and such validity can be
examined only by a prescribed authority under
the law made by the appropriate legislature.
Reading Article 329(b) and Sections 80 to 116 of
the Act together, the position emerges that the
status of a validly elected candidate in an
election can be called in question only before the
Election Tribunal (the High Court) by way of an
election petition and such election petition to be
decided by the Election Tribunal (the High
Court) in the manner prescribed under the
abovereferred
provisions
by
following
the
procedures laid down therein. It further emerges
that the validity of an election to either of the
House of Parliament or the State Legislature
cannot be called in question in any other manner
other than what has been prescribed under the
provisions of the Act, as has been set out
in Sections 80 to 116 of the Act.”
11.
The position of law being crystal clear, the writ petition
seeking invocation of the writ jurisdiction of this Court, in an attempt to
unseat the respondent No. 7, is therefore not maintainable and is liable
to be dismissed. The judgment placed by the learned counsel for the
petitioner being of no assistance to his case is not discussed.
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition for the reasons aforementioned is
dismissed with costs of Rs.15,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Thousand) only to
be paid to the Meghalaya State Legal Services Authority for the
purposes of legal aid, within 15(fifteen) days from the date of this order.
Judge
Meghalaya
22.08.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review