Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL
982 0F 2025
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Preferred Against the Order Dated
05-12-2024 in W.P.No.16415 of 2021on the file of the High Court.
Between:
Telangana Public Service Commission (TGPSC), Rep. by its Secretary, M.J. Road,
Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana State.
.....APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO.2
ln WP.No.16415 of 2021
AND
1. Y. Jagadish, S/o Venkateswarlu, Aged 30 years Occ Unemployee, Caste OC
Male H.T.No.1218049230 Zone V, R/o H.No.2-116 Vallapurarn Village,
Mudigonda, Mandal Khammam District-S07158 TS.
2. M Sathish, S/o Kanakaiah, Aged 31 years, Occ ; Unemployee, Caste BCB
Male, H.T.No.1218030452, Zone V, R/o H.No.4-44, Dhoolmitta Village
Maddur Mandal Siddipet District-506367 T.S.
3. Chakka Venkateswar Rao, S/o Ranga Rao, Aged 32 years, Occ Unempbyee,
Caste SC Male, H T No 12180165822oneV R/o H No 17-82, Teachers
Colony, Husnabad Mandal Husnabad Dstrict-505467 TS.
4. T. Ganesh, S/o Pandu, Aged 29 years, Occ Unemployee Caste BCD Male H
T No 1218057948, ZoneVl R/o H No 2-12 Alwal Village Kashampet Mandal,
Mahabubnagar: District-509408 TS.
5. Y. Venkateshwarlu, S/o Uppalaiah, Aged 29 years, Occ Unemployee, Caste
BCD Male, Zone-V, R/o H No 16-1-168, SRR Thota, Karimabad Road,
Warangal District-506002 TS.
6. K. Bharath, S/o Ravinder, Aged 27 years, Occ Govtemployee, Caste BCB
Male, Zone-Vl, R/o H No 3-3-33 Azad Road, Bhongir, Nalgonda Districts08116 TS.
7. B. Mohan, S/o Raju, Aged 32 years, Occ Unemployee, Caste ST Male, Zone-
Vl, R/o H No 3-40, Thobmpally Village, Sirikonda Nizamabad District -503 165
TS.
caste
8. R. Rajendra Prasad, S/o Dqql_rqrq!h"q,-4g9d.??.Ye?rs, Go-{gl1gloyee
Santhosh
eCB (late, H T N;litaotOqq3, ZoneV, fu9 r1-ryo-1-3-11126127E'
tlig", Cotbny, Bhainsa Adilabad District -504103 TS'
Caste
9. P. Veer kumar Goud, S/o Mysaiah, Aged 38 yea19, 9qg ; 9n9!nP!oye^9,
Nagar
ACB nrare, H T No iZteO756Oq,Zbn6Vt, nyq!1Ng-3-89 Mallikarjun
peerie,O rg tida, t\Ied ipa lly Medchal District-500039 T'S'
S/o Badya, Aged 33 years, Occ ; Unemployee, Caste ST Male'
10.
- Ravikumar,
Z;;;- ri : Ri6. t-t. No. 3'-2b (oth urth:anda, Seetharampu ram Yelland u,
Khammam District-5071 23 T.S-
BCB
DistrictFemale, Zone-Vt,-nlo n Nd S--tO-t2671, Suryanagar Nizamabad
5030Ct1 T.S.
sT Male H T
12. R. Aslrok, S/o Deepla, Aged 30 years, o"9 i Unemployee,caste
No 1218001087 Z;;;Vl,"nlo H No s-aS Mahammadabad Thanda Jakkul,
Kamareddy District-503305 T.S.
Raiaiah, Aged 29 years, occ; Unemployee.caste BCD
13.R.
- Ramkishore, S/o
nflate, ZoneV R/o H No 7-2-53a7SO Canga nagar, Godavarikhani,
Rama gundam, Karimnagar District-505209 T.S'
11. S. Bhavana, S/o Sudhakar, Aged 26 years, Occ ; Unemployee, Caste.
14.DupaliSruthi, D/o Krishna lt/lurthy,.4-g"d abgg!.2.6.Veap, S-tyqlent R/o H No 11 t1-2Ayyappa Nagar, Narsamp6t Wirangal District TS -5061 32.
l5.Ketavath Keerthy, D/o Ketavath Makatlal, Aged ab.out27 years, R/o H No
2O32.t-3. IVIKR nlgar Devarakonda, Nalgonda District'
.....RESPONDENTSMRIT PETITIONER tN WP.NO.16415 OF 2021
16.The Sitate of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Planning
Department, Secretariat, At Hyderabad, TS17.The t)irector of Econornics and statistics, Rep. by its Director, Hyderabad,
Telangana State.....RESPONDENTS'RES PON DENTS
l.A.NO:2 ot:2025
petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavi.i filed in support of the peiition, the High Court may be pleased toof
suspend thr-, order dated' 05.12.2024 in Wp No 16415 of 2O21 in the interest
justice.
counset for Appellants : sRl P.S.RAJASEKHAR (SC FOR TGPSC)
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 5,7 to 9 & 11 to 15 : SRI D'V'SITHARAM
MURTHy, SENTOR iOUruSel REPRESENTING,SRI MAMIDI AVTNASH REDDY
Counsel for Respondent No.6 : -
I
I
counsel for the Respondent Nos.l6 & 1T : G.p FoR sERVIcES-lll
The Court rnade the following JUDGMENT : -
IN THE IIIGH COTIRT FOR THE STATE OF TEIIINGAI{A
AT TTYDERABAT)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JIISTICE SRI APARESH KT'MAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL No.982 of 2O25
DATE: l?. o/2.20.26
BETWEEN:
Telangana Public Service Commission
(TGPSC)
.Appellant
AND
Y. Jagadish and 16 others.
....ResPondents
JUDGMENT
This writ appeal, preferred under clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, assails'the order dated 05.12.2024 passed by the learned
Single Judge in w.P.No.L6415 of 2021. By the impugned order, the
learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition filed by the respondents
herein (original writ petitioners) and directed the appellantCommission to consider their candidature for the post of Mandal
planning and Statistical Officer/Assistant Statistical Officer strictly in
accordance with G.O.Ms.No.3, Planning (Establishment) Department,
dated O1.03.2012 and Notification No. 1212018, dated O2.O6.2OL8'
Factual backgrouud (in brieff
2.
On 02.06.2OL8, the appellant-Telangana Public Service
Commission (TGPSC) issued Notification No- 12/2018 inviting
A*f
applications for 474 posts of Mandal pranning
officer/Ass;istant Statistical officer
and Statistics Subordinate Services
3'
and statistical
in the Directorate of Economics
Department.
'l'he r:ducational quarifications
prescribed for the said post are
set out in paragraph 4 of trre Notification,
which are traceabre to
G'o'Ms'No.3, planning (Establishment)
01'03'2012 (whereby the Andhra pradesh
Subordinat: Service Rules, 19gr were
Department, dated
Economics and statisticar
amendecl). The relevant portion
reads as uuder:
4I IOUCATTONAL OUALIFTCATIONS:
Appl;c.tnt:, musl
n#If f f:{ii':i*":mFim*,["T"3x'J:",S;"T,T.iJ"H,n3r*y,Iffi :#Jx#:."?f ;
Sl. No.
Name of the post
as
G.O.Ms-No.3 ptanning (Esrabllshment)
1. Bachelol,s
subjec{s.
department
ot. o1t03t2012
as one of
maln
2. Bachetor's Degree ** t?X'n"r"tics (wth Starisrics
as a paper.in one year or two years or
all the three
years as the case may be) is one
sub;ecis.
of the main
3. Bacfrelor's pegr". *,nt?*norics (ivirh Staristics
as a paper.in ono year or tl^,o years or
all the three
years as lhe case may be) is
subjecls.
Mandal Planninq and
Slatrstical Office?
/Assistanl Statisttcal
Officer
one of the main
4. Bachetofs gesree *,nto*'rr"."e (wirh Sraristics
as a paper.in one year or two years
or all the lhree
years as the case may be) is
su$ects.
one of tnu ,rin
I
t p.1*pl"--D_esree *olot).*o*"r Science (with
a papef ln one year or two years or a[
:;:l,pi::
rne. mree ls
years as the case
main subjects.
from a
may be) as one of the
University established or incorporated by
or
under a Central Act or State Act, or
such lnstitutions
declared as deemed to be Universities
Section 3
cf the Un iversity Grants Commission under
Act, 1956 or a
foreign University approved by the
Central Governrnent
from trme to time
]
4.
The respondents, who are B.Tech (computer science)
graduates, applied for the said posts and were permitted to appear for
the written examination conducted on 03.09.201g and were
subsequently called for certificate verification between 10.01 .2otg
and L2.oL.2oL9. During certificate verification, the commission
noticed that the respondents had studied 'Probability and Statistics,
for only one semester (six months) in their B.Tech course, whereas the
prescribed qualification required study of Statistics for bne year,or
'two years' or 'all the three years.' In order to clarify the said
requirement, the commission issued a Memo dated 3L.L2.2oLg
containing the following notes as under:
Note- 7: study o/ sfafisfi'as for one aear or 2 semesters is necessary to
be eligible for tle said post.
2: As such candidates who studied. B.Tech (computer science)
with minimum of one year studg o,f Sfatish'cs are also eligible.
5.
Aggrieved thereby, certain candidates liled w.p.No.3o43 of 2oLg
and batch challenging the Memo dated 31.12.2o1g. By interim order
dated o4.o4.2ol9, this court directed the respondents therein to
consider the cases of the petitioners without reference to the Memo
dated 31.L2.2o18 and strictly in terms of G.o.Ms.No.3. pursuant to
the said interim order, the commission referred the matter to a
Committee of Subject Experts comprising:
i) Prof. v.v. Hara Gopal, professor of Statistics, BITS-pilani,
Hyderabad Campus;
J
)
ii) Prof. IVladhuchhanda Bhattacharjee, professor of Statistics,
University of Hyderabad, Gachibowli, Hyderabad; and
iii) Prof. B. sudhakar Reddy, chairman,; Board of Studies,
Departrnent of Economics, osmania University, Hyderabad.
6.
The Expert committee submitted its report dated L2.o4.2olg
observing, inter alia, as follows:
"As per G.o.Ms.No-3 dated. 0r.03.2012, ilte 'year' means an acad.emic
gear corLsisting of 12 month,s or two semesfers of six montlts, duration
eaclu
In an academic year, ttrc examination will be held. at the end. of the
acadernic year with full couerage of sfatistics, while in a semester (6
months), which is nof a fult academic gear, where onlg the
found.ations of
Sfatislicr; ure being leamt."
7.
Based on the rcport of the Expert committee, the appellant-
commissio. issued individual rejection memos dated 29.os.2o19 to
the respondents informing them that their candidature stood rejected
on the ground that they did not possess the requisite qualification of
harring studied Statistics for one academic year.
8.
challenging the said rejection memos, the respondents hled the
present rvrit petition uide w.p. No.16415 of 2021. During the
pendency o.. the writ petition, certain subsequent developments took
place, inclucing withdrawal of w.A.No.402 of 2olg and batch by the
State on 17.o2.2021, and closure of w.p.Nos.659s, 3043, 3332, s2o2
and 5792 of 2019 on os.or.2o2L, granting liberty to the petitioners
therein to challenge the respective rejection orders.
9. The l:arned Single Judge, by the impugned ord.er dated
05.12.2024 allowed the writ petition holding that the rejection of the
*
respondents' candidature was unsustainable.
Judge observed that study of 'probability
subject in the B.Tech course satisfies
The rearned Single
and Statistics, as a core
the requirement of studying
Statistics as a paper for one year, and further
held that issuance of
the Memo dated sr.r2.2o1g after commencement
process was impermissible in view
of the recruitment
of the decision in TeJ prq.kq.sh
Pathak a. Rajasthan Htgh Court and, oilterst.
10. Aggrieved by the said order, the Tcpsc has preferred
the
present writ appeal.
11. Heard sri p.s.Rajasekhar rearned standing counser
appearing for the appeflant and sri D.V.sitharam
senior counser representing sri M.Avinash
respondent Nos.l to 5, T to9 and 11 to
for TGpSC
Murthy, Iearned
Reddy, rearned counser flor
15 and perused the record.
contentions on behalf of appellant-commission
12' Learned standing counsel appearing for the
Commission has raised the contentions
appelant-
as under:
i- That the learned single Judge erred in interpreting the
expression 'statistics as a paper in one year,
occurring in
G'o'Ms'No.3 and the Notification. According to
learned Standing counser, the expression .one
the
year,, in
the context of an academic quarification, necessarily
means a full academic year consisting of two
'1zors; 4 scc 54o
J
semesters
(or three trimesters), culminating in an examination at
l.he end of such academic period. The respondents
rrdmittcdly studied only one paper titled 'Probability and
istatistics'in a single semester of six months, which does
not amount to study for'one Year'.
ii. 'lhat the issue pertains to interpretation of an educational
qualification, which is essentially an academic matter.
'The Commission had referred the issue to a Committee of
Subject Experts comprising Professors of Statistics from
reputed institutions. The Committee, upon deliberation,
opined that study <lf Statistics in one semester covers
only foundational aspects of the subject, r,vhereas a full
academic year providcs comprehensive coverage, and that
such expert opinion ought to have been accorded due
weight by the learned Single Judge.
iii. That the Memo dated 31.12.2018 did not alter the 'rules
of the game' mid-process, but merely clarified the existing
eligibility criteria. The Notification itself prescribed study
of Statistics for 'one year'. The Memo only clarified what
constitutes cne year, namely, two semesters or a full
academic year. Such clarification, it is argued, does not
amount to change of rules. Therefore, reliance placed on
Tej Prakosh Pathak (supra 1) is stated to be misplaced.
2W.
iv. That reliance placed by the rearned single Judge on the
order in w.P.No.lL642 of 2ol9 is misconceived, as the
said case is factually distinguishable. In that case, the
candidate had pursued an M.Sc. (Integrated) in Applied
Mathematics from I.I.T., wherein he studied probability
and statistics for two semesters, which constituted one
full academic year in that programme, and his eligibility
was acknowledged by the Expert committee itself. The
present respondents, having studied statistics only for
one semester, cannot claim parity.
v. That the B.Tech curriculum of the respondents shows
that out of more than 58 subjects studied during the
four-year course, only one subject pertained to statistics,
which constitutes a negligible portion of the overall
f
coursework. Statistics was not studied as a main subject.
The qualilication was prescribed to ensure adequate
proficiency in Statistics for discharge of duties such as
compilation of GSDP estimates, conduct of surveys, and
analysis of statistical data. A candidate who studied
Statistics for only one semester cannot be said to satisfy
this requirement.
vi. That the recruitment process was completed on
22-07 -2o 19 and, except for one vacancy under the pwD
category, all posts have been fillecl. As per the General
a 4,
B
Ranking List, the respondents were placed far below the
last selected candidate. Several candidates higher in
merit we-re not selected due to limited vacancies.
Interference. at this stage would unsettle the concluded
selection process.
vii. That Courts ordinarily do not sit in appeal over academic
determinations. The question whether a particular course
of study is equivalent to another falls within the domain
of academic experts. Unless the opinion of the expert
body is shown to be arbitrary or perverse, judicial
deference is warranted. The Expert Committee's report,
according to the appellant, is reasoned and based on
academic considerations.
viii.
That mere participation in the examination does
not confei' any vested right to appointment. Eligibility
must be determined in accordance with the rules as they
stood on the date of notification. Since the respondents
did not fulfill the prescribed qualification, tkreir
eAhdidature was rightly rejected. On the above gi-ounds, it
is prayed that the impugned judgment be set aside a-nd
the writ petition be dismissed.
Contentionrs on behalf of the respondents
13. Learnt-'d counsel appearing for the respondents has supported
the learned ilingle Judge's order and raised the contentions as under:
b
-i.
i' That rejection of the respondents,
arbitrary and violative of Articles
candidature is ,legar,
14 and 16 0f the constitution
of India. The respondents were permitted
tickets, allowed to appear in the
to appry, issued hall
examination, and called for
certificate verification. Their certificates
competent authorities. It was only
were verified by the
thereafter that the Memo
dated 3L.r2-2org introduced a restrictive
interpretation not
reflected in the original Notification.
ii' That the Memo dated 3l.r2.2o1g and the
memos dated 2g-o5.201g amount
to alteration of the .rures of
the game' after commencement of the
such alteration is impermissible in
subsequent rejection
recruitment process.
view of the taw raid down by
the Supreme court in Tej prak,.sh path,k
Manjushree u. State of a.n.z. The
respondents fulfilled the
qualification prescribed in the Notification,
namery, statistics as
a paper in one year, by studying 'probability
and statistics, in
their B.Tech course. The subsequent
clarification that bne year,
means two semesters is a substantive
modilication.
iii. That study of 'probability and statistics,
constitutes a complete course in
semester covers only foundationar
unsupported by objective material.
3 SCC s 12
in one semester
the subject as per university
curricurum' The Expert committee,s
2 (2OO8)
(supra 1) and rf.
observation that a
aspects is stated to be
iv. That tnaterials from universities including JNTU, Osmania
University, and the Indian Statistical Institute were placed on
record to demonstrate th.at 'Probability and Statistics' and
.Operat.ions Research' fall within the discipline of Statistics'
Thus, l.he learned Singte Judge rightly took these materials into
considr:ration.
v. That t.:re order in W.P.N o.11642 of 2019, wherein a similarly
placed candidate was granted relief, has attained linality'
consistency in judiciat approach requires that the same
principle be applied in the present case'
vi. That withdrawal of w.A.No.402 0f 2019 and batch on
17.O2.2O21 resulted in the inte rim directions of the learned
Single Judge attaining finality. Thosc directions required
consic-eration of candidature strictly in terms of G.o.Ms.No'3
without reference to the Memo dated 31.12.2018. The rejection
based on the Expert Committee's report is stated to be contrary
to the said direction.
vii. That the right to be considered for appointment is protected
under Article 16 of the Constitution. The respondents had a
legitirnate expectation of fair consideration, and rejection based
on a belated clarification defeats such expectation.
viii.
That the question involved is one of eligibility and not
merit, tf found eligible, the respondents are entitled to
against the vacancies kept vacant pursuant to
consileration
trh !$
interim orders of this court, and that the judicial deference to
expert opinion is not absolute. where such opinion is arbitrary
or based on an erroneous premise, the court is competent to
interfere. on the above grounds, it is prayed that the writ
appeal be dismissed and the order of the learned single Judge
be affirmed.
ix. That the essential qualification prescribed is a oBachelor,s
Degree with Mathematics, Economics, commerce and
computer science". It has to be construed as such in the light
of the settled principles of statutory interpretation of the text
placed within parentheses. It is submitted that expressions
placed within brackets are ordinarily explanatory or illustrative
in nature and therefore do not carry the same mandatory force
as the principal text. In that view of the matter, the reference to
statistics must be treated as directory rather than mandatory
and should be excluded from the core consideration of
eligibility.
x' That, as per the information obtained under the Right to
Information Act, 2oos, the Andhra pradesh public Service
commission (Appsc), vijayawada, has appointed 12 candidates
possessing B.Tech (csE) qualifications to the post of statistical
officer. It is submitted that the prescribed qualifications for the
post of statistical oflicer notified by the A.p. public Service
)
)
Commir;sion are identical to those contairled in the impugned
notifica:ion.
L4. We have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
perused the material on recorC, including the Notification dated
02.06.2018, G.O.l\{s.No.3 dated 01.03.2012, the Memo dated
31.12.2018, r:he report of the e*p"rt Committee, the respondents'
academic records, and the precedents cited.
Consideration by this Court
15. The main controversy in the present appeal revolves around the
interpretation of the educational qualification prescribed for the post
in question, tramely, that candidates possessing a Bachelor's Degree
with Comput,:r Science must have studied 'statistics as a paper in
one year or trvo years or all the three years, as the CaSe may be.'The
respondents, who are B.Tech (Computer Science) graduates, havc
studied 'Probrrbility and Statistics'only for one semester (six months)
during the (:ourse of their four-year programme. The appellantCommission, placing reliance on the report of the Subject Experts
Committee, rtjected their candidature on the ground that study of the
subject for a single Semester does not satisfy the requirement of
having studit:d Statistics for bne year' as conternplated under the
Notification ard G.O.Ms.No.3 dated 0 1.03.20 12.
16. In the present case, the learned Single judge relied upon the
well-settled principle that 'rules of the game cannot be changed after
\s '\E
the game has commenced,'as laid down in the cases of TeJ prolkash
Pathak (supra 1) and K. Manjushree (supra 2). However, it is to be
noted that its applicabitity depends upon the nature of the action
impugned.
The relevant para from the ?eJ prakash pathaks case (supra 1)
is extracted hereunder:
70. Under the scheme of our Constitution an absolute and. non-negotiable
prohibition against retrospectiue law-making is mad.e onlg with reference
to
the creation of crimes. Ang other legat right or obligation could. be created.,
attered, ertinguisled retrospectiuetg bg the souereign law-making bodies.
Houteuer, such drastic power is required- to be exercised. in a manner that it
does not conflict with any other constitutionally guaranteed. rights, such as,
Articles 14 and 16, etc. changing the "rules of game" .either mid.stream or
afier tlrc game is ptaged. is an aspect of retrospectiue raw-making power.
The relevant para from the .f(. Manjushree's case (supra 2) is
extracted hereunder:
32. In Malnrashtra sRTC u. Rajend.ra Btimrao Mand.ue
tpool) Io scc sI
: 2002 scc (L&s) 72ol this court obserued. thqt "the rutes of ttrc gam.e,
meaning therebg, that the criteria for selection cannot be altered. bg the
autlorities concemed in the mtdd.te or after the process of selection has
commenced". In this case the position is much more serious. Here, not onlg
the rules of the game were changed., but theg were changed. after the game
had been played and the results of the game were being an aited. That is
unacceptable and impermis sibte.
L7, In Tej Praka.sh pathak's case (supra r), a new minimum
quali$zing benchmark was introduced after the written examination.
In I( ManJushreers case (supra 2), an additional eligibility condition
was imposed after commencement of selection. In both cases,
substantive changes were introduced which were not part of the
original notification. However, in the present case, the Notification
itself prescribed that candidates must have studied ,statistics as a
J
)
l4
paper in one year or two years or all the three years.'The expression
'one year'wa:; thus part of the original eligibility condition
18. It is to be noted that the Memo dated 31.12.2018 clarified that
study of Statistics for 'one year'means study for one academic year,
i.e., two semr:sters. The Memo did not introduce a new qualilication; it
clarified the meaning of an existing expression. The clarification was
issued prior to certificate verification and well before hnal selection.
Therefore, the respondents were aware that their eligibility would be
assessed in accordance with the clarified understanding.
19. Furthe:, on perusal of the record, it is evident that thc
Notification ,:xpressly provided that admission to examination or
verification ot'certificates is provisional and subject to final scrutiny of
eligibility, arrd that the Commission reserves the right to reject
candidates a: any stage. in this regard, the Memo dated 31.1,2.2OI8
cannot be treated as alteration of eligibility conditions. It was a
clarification c,f an existing criterion.
20. It is pertinent to note that the Commission referred the issue of
whether study of Statistics in one semester can be equated to study
for 'one year' to a Committee of Subject Experts comprising senior
Professors of Statistics and allied disciplines.
2L. It is sel-tled law that Courts ordinarily defer to expert opinion in
matters con<:erning academic qualifications and equivalence. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in tlnlaersltg of Mgsore u. C.D. Gooinda
*r.''
Rd,ost emphasized that determination of equivalence
of qualifications
lies primarily within the domain of academic experts. The rerevant
para is extracted hereunder:
12. Before ute part with tlrcse appeals, howeuer, reference
must be made
to two oth.er matters. In dealing with the case presented before
it bg the
respondent, tle High Court has criticised. the report made
bg the Board
and has obserued that he circumstances disclosed by the report
made it
dilficutt for the High Court to treat the recommend.ations made
b'y the
expert with the respect ttnt theg generallg deserue. We
are unable to see
thE point of citicism of tlrc High court in such academic
matters. Boards of
who
(emphasis supplied)
22. The Expert committee in the present case opined that
lrear,in
the context of G.o.Ms.No.3 refers to an academic year consistin g
months or two semesters, and that a semester study ordinarily
of 12
covers
only foundational aspects of statistics. The report assigns reasons
and reflects academic consideration. No materiar has been praced
demonstrate that the opinion is arbitrary, mala
to
ftde, or based on
irrelevant considerations.
23. It is to be noted that the learned Singre Judge, while
interpreting the qualification, did not record any finding that
the
Expert committee's opinion was perverse or irrational. [n absence
RtR tgos sc 491
J
/
of
such finding, substitution of judicial interpretation in place of expert
opinion is no1. warranted.
24. The res,pondents are B.Tech (Computer Science) graduates who
studied 'Prob,ability and Statistics'in one semester of the four-year
programme. The course material on record indicates that the said
subject was taught in a single semester. The Expert Committee opined
that such study does not amount to study for one academic year.
2io. It is to be noted that the prescribed qualification specifically
requires sturly of Statistics 'for one year.' In light of the Expert
Committee's interpretation that 'one year' means one academic year
comprising two semesters, a single semester cannot be treated as
satisfying the requirement. Further, the object of prescribing such
qualification is to ensure adequate gfounding in Statistics for
discharge of dutics attached to the post. The recmiting authority is
entitled to insist upon compliance with the prescribed academic
duration. Therefore, the study of 'Probability and Statistics' for one
semester d.oe,s not fulfill the requirement of study of Statistics 'for one
year' within l.he meaning of G.O.Ms.No.3 and the Notification.
26. In regerd to the applicability of w.P.No.l1642 of 2Ol9 it is
apposite to n ote that the relief was granted therein was to a candidate
who had pursued an integrated M.Sc. programme wherein Probability
and Statistic:s rx,as studied for two semesters, which was treated as
equivalefitkr one academic year. The Expert Committee in that case
\
L7
had not found the candidate ineligible. The factual
therefore materially different. However, in
matrix was
the instant case
respondents studied statistics only for one semester.
The Expert
committee has specilically opined that they do not
requirement. The earlier order, being fact-specific, does
meet the
not lay down
any general proposition applicable to all B.Tech candidates.
It is
therefore distinguishable.
27. It is to be noted that under Articles 31s and 32o of the
Constitution of India, each State Public Service Commission
distinct authority. The Tcpsc is not legally bound by the
Appsc,s
equivalence or parity determination. The Tcpsc possesses
independent mandate to determine the suitability and
qualifications of the candidates for appointments
is a
the
educational
in the State of
Telangana' TGPSC cannot be compelled to replicate an
interpretation
made by the APPSC. TGPSC is bound by its own recruitment
and expert findings. If the expeq! comrnittee appointed by
determines that a specific qualification does not meet
rules
TGPSC
the requisite
standard, that finding remains final for all recruitment
within its
jurisdiction.
28- It is a fundamental canon of interpretation that every word,
phrase and symbol employed by the drafting authority
must be given
its full effect. The contention that the text within parentheses
be excluded from consideration is legally untenable. The
J
/
should
Honble
1B
Supreme Court has reiterated that it is not permissible to omit or
treat as surplusage any part of a statute or notification. [n
educationa[ nomenclature, parentheses are frequently used to define
the essential components of a preceding term.. When qualification
lists a bar:helor's degree in Mathematics, Economics, Commerce,
Computer lScience "(rvith Statistics as a paper in one year ......)", the
parenthetic:al clause acts as a restrictive condition. It specifies the
type of degree required, thereby narrowing the eligibility to those who
possess specific qualification, in this case, Statistics as a paper in
atleast ono year. The recruiting authcrity prescribes qualifications
based on functional requirements oi the post. lb ignore the bracketed
text woulcl be to frustrate the vcry purpose of the recruitment
notificatiorr and would result in an absurd interpretation, where a
candidate without proper background in Statistics is appointed to a
post of Statistical/Assistant Statistical Officer.
29. Furtter, we are of the considered view that the jurisprudence
on the following points/aspects is clear:
.
i. Deference to Expert bodies: In matters concerning
educational qualifications and equivalence of degrees, the
Courts are required to exercise considerable restraint. The
determination as to whether a particular course of study
satisfies a prescribed qualification lies primarily within the
dc,main of academic and expert bodies. Judicial interference
\
is warranted only where the decision of such expert body is
shown to be patently arbitrary, irrationar, mara
-fide, or
vitiated by perversity.
ii. Interpretation of qualifications: The interpretation of eligibility
conditions contained in a recruitment notification is the
function of the recruiting authorit5r. A clarification issued by
such authorit5r explaining the scope or meaning of an existing
eligibility criterion cannot be construed as a change in the
'rules of the game.'A candidate cannot claim a vested right to
an interpretation that is favourable to him when the
clari{ication merely elucidates the original prescription.
iii.
It is a settled principle that
eligibility in recruitment processes is provisional at all stages,
unless otherwise expressly declared. Mere participation in the
selection process, issuance of hall tickets, or even provisional
verification of certificates does not create any indefeasible
right to appointment, if the candidate is ultimately found not
to possess the prescribed quatification.
iv- Purpose of oualifications: The educational qualifications are
not empt5r formalities; they are prescribed with a definite
object, namely, to ensure that candidates possess the
requisite knowledge and competence to discharge the duties
attached to the post. Therefore, such qualifications must be
)
)
interpreted in a manner that advances the purpose
underlying their prescri.ption, and not in a manner that
dilutes or defeats it.
v. Finrrlitv of Recruitment: Once a recruitment process has been
conrpleted and appointments have bccn made, particularly
after a considerable lapse of time, the Court ought to be slow
in rrnsettling the same. The rights of those who have been
duly appointed and have been discha:'ging their functions
car:.not be lightly disturbed, unlcss compelling legal grounds
are made out.
30. The present case reiterates the settled limits of judicial review in
matters conccrning academic qualifications. Though the jurisdiction
of this Cou.'t under Article 226 of the Constitution is wide, it must be
exercised rsith restraint in areas involving academic or technical
expertise. Determination of whether a particular course of study
satislies a lrrescribed qualification, or whether study for one semester
is equivalent to study for one academic year, lies primarily within the
domain of s;ubject experts.
31. Even if it is presumcd that the respondents satisS the
prescribed qualification, their entitlement to appointment would still
be governe,l by their position in thc merit [ist. The material on record
indicates that the respondents'positions in the General Ranking List
range bctween 19 and 2123, whereas only 474 posts were notified. It
\
2t
is also not in dispute that several candidates higher in
merit than the
respondents could not be accommodated owing to limited
vacancies.
Any direction at this stage for appointment of the respondents
necessarily disturb the appointments already made,
wourd
and the selected
candidates are not parties to the present proceedings.
32- Further, the contention of the respondents that 25 vacancies
were kept unfilled pursuant to interim orders of this
Court does not
advance their case, as the said vacancies were retained
subject to the
outcome of pending litigations. If the respondents are found
ineligible,
the question of their adjustment against such vacancies does
arise' Even otherwise, eligibility alone would not confer an
not
automatic
right to appointment; selection would still depend upon. interse
merit
among similarly situated candidates. Thus, the respondents
have
failed to establish that they woutd fall within the zone
of selection
even if treated as eligible.
33. It is further to be noted that the recruitment process was
\
\
concluded in the year 2o]g and appointments have since
been made.
considerable time has elapsed, and interference at this stage
result in administrative complications and unsettle a process
already attained finality. Therefore, as the respondents
the prescribed qualification, no rerief can be granted.
\
\
would
that has
do not possess
Conclusiorr
34. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is oi the considered view
that the onier dated 05.12.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge
in W.P.No.l6415 of 2O2l cannot be sustained. The interpretation
placed by the respondents on the eligibility criteria and the
consequenl interference with the decision of the appellantCommissio:n is unsustainable. The impugned order dated 05.12.2024
is therefore liable to be set aside.
35. Accor:dingly, the Writ Appeal is alloweC. The impugned order
dated 05.12.2024 passed by the learned Single Judge in
W.P.No. L6z:,15 of 2021 is hereby set aside. 1'he rejection memos dated
29.O5.2019, issued by the appellant-Commission are upheld. No order
as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed.
SD'-M. RAMANA KRISHNA
JONT REGISTRAR
I
/
I
//TRUE COPYI/
sEcfloN orrtben
One fair copy to the HON'BLE THE CHIEF
(For His Lordship's Kind
KUMAR SINGH
AND
One fair copy to the HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
(For His Lordship's Kind Perusal)
To
1. The Principal Secretary, Planning Department, Secretariat State of Telangana
at Hyderabad, T.S.
2. The Director, Director of Economics and Statistics, Hyderabad, Telangana
State.
3. 11 L.R. Copies.
-4--Ihe-URder-Secretary, Union of-lndia; Minlstr,y of-Law, Justice and Gornp?oy Affairs, l\lew Delhi.
,
C-erilcJ^ --
--
5. The secretary, Telangana Advocates Association Library, High court
Buildings, Hyderabad.
6. Two CC's to G-P FOR SERVICES-||!, High Court for the State of Tetangana
\
at Hyderabad. (OUT)
- one cc to'sRt P.S.RAJASEKHAR_(qC FoR Tcpsc) Advocate topucl
-'
8. ONECC tO SRI MAMIDI AVINASH REDDY, NOVOCATE JOFU"'-'-'
9. Two CD Copies
SA
BS
P,tAt
t
a
I
I
t
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:'17li0212026
,
1.
t
'rt E 5 T.q
a
("i
'rr ,i)
JUDGME:NT
WA.No.982 of 2025
ALLOWING THE W.A
WITHOU-T COSTS.
>l^ fr.{q,
o-lzPA
IqAB 2026
*3 PAT C
o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review