Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/24
GAHC040017792025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/504/2025
Tatin Medo and 18 Ors
Son of Shri Gellong Medo, a permanent resident of Baazar Line, Tuting, PO and PS
Tuting, Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Omi Nitik
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Amin Nitik
a permanent resident of Rishing Village
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Sunyok Bomong
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Rajong Bomong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Oken Duggong @ Aken Duggong
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Asong Duggong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 2/24
5: Okit Doron
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Baduk Doron
a permanent resident of Cooperative Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Odi Danggen
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Untung Danggen
a permanent resident of Zido Village
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Gula Payeng
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Atut Peyang
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
8: Panggong Duggong
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Asong Duggong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
9: Olik Janoh
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late A Tali
resident of PI Line Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Smti Osi Nijo
Page No.# 3/24
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Banggo Nijo
resident of PI Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11: Smti Jamang Tamut
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Shri Pamin Duggong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
12: Smti Lideng Nitik
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Shri Panggong Duggong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
13: Smti Ansung Duggong
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Shri Asong Duggong
a permanent resident of Baazar Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
14: Gumbang Sitek
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Ando Sitek
a permanent resident of Zido Village
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 4/24
15: Epo Apang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Mojeng Apang
a permanent resident of PI Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
16: Akit Medo
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Lomin Medo
a permanent resident of Cooperative Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
17: Opang Tedo
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Amin Tedo
a permanent resident of PI Line
Tuting
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
18: Chocha Tondrang
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Mobuk Tondrang
a permanent resident of Rising Village
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
19: Phuntsok Tashi
Age:
Occupation :
a permanent resident of Lali Village
PO and PS Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 5/24
VERSUS
The State of AP and 5 Ors
represented by the Secretary/ Commissioner Land Management, Govt of Arunachal
Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Director of Land Management
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Deputy Commissioner cum Land Acquisition Authority
Age: 0
Occupation :
Yingkiong
PO and PS Yingkiong
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4:The Additional Deputy Commissioner cum Chairman
Age: 0
Occupation :
of board member for conducting ground survey
Tuting
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
National Highways and Infrastructure Development Company
1st and 2nd Floor
Tower A
Worlds Trade Centre
Nauroji Nagar
New Delhi 110029
6:The Managing Director
Age: 0
Occupation :
National Highways and infrastructure Development Company
1st and 2nd Floor
Tower A
World Trade Centre
Nauroji Nagar
New Delhi 11002
Page No.# 6/24
Advocate for the Petitioner : Nikita Danggen, Honi Tana Tara,K Gao,Kirpi Nyorak,Phurpa
Wangmu,Nani Kuru,Karmu Chotton
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), R B Yadav
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SUSMITA PHUKAN KHAUND
JUDGMENT
For the Petitioners
:Ms. N. Danggen, Adv.
For the Respondents
: Mr. R. H. Nabam, learned
Addl. Advocate General
Ms. P. Pangu, learned Junior
Government Advocate
Mr.R.B.Yadav, learned Standing
Counsel, NHIDCL.
Date on which judgment is reserved :
18.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment :
01.10.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
:
NA
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
The petitioners in this case have challenged the legality and validity of the
impugned Land Compensation Assessment Report prepared by ADC- cumChairman, Land Compensation Assessment in pursuance to impugned Order
No. YKLM 179/2024/53 dated 25.01.2024, issued by the Deputy Commissioner,
Yingkiong, Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.In this case, 1. the State of
Page No.# 7/24
Arunachal represented by the Secretary/Commissioner Land Management, Govt.
of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, 2. The Director, Land Management, Govt. of
Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, 3. The Deputy Commissioner- cum- land
Acquisition Authority, Yingkiong, PO/PS: Yingkiong, Upper Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.4. The Additional Deputy Commissioner cum Chairman of
board member for conducting ground survey, Tuting, Upper Siang District,
Pradesh. 5. The Secretary, National Highways and Infrastructure Development
Company, (NHIDCL for short), 6. The Managing Director, NHIDCL are arrayed as
respondent nos. 1 to 6 respectively.
2.
Heard learned counsel Ms. N. Danggen for the petitioners. Also heard Mr.
R. H. Nabam, learned Addl. Advocate General and Ms. P. Pangu, learned Junior
Government Advocate for the State respondents and Mr. R. B. Yadav, learned
Standing Counsel, NHIDCL.
3.
The petitioners are permanent residents of different villages under Tuting,
Upper Siang District. It is submitted that a speaking order No. YKLM
179/2024/53 dated 25.01.2024 was issued directing DLR & SO, Upper Siang
District, Yingkiong, to proceed with land acquisition process of Tuting-Zido Road,
NH913 (Frontier Highway) under the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act,
2013 (the Act of 2013, in short). The Deputy Commissioner drafted preliminary
notification for land acquisition of 51.147 (Hectares) and land, and had sent the
same to the Director of land management vide forwarding letter No. YKLM179/2024/106 dated 19.02.2024 and accordingly,a Notification was issued vide
order No. LMD-12/2024/2141 dated 29.02.2024, requiring 51.147 hectares of
land for construction of intermediate lane road from Tuting to Zido, under Tuting
Sub-Division, Upper Siang district for a stretch of 0.000 kms to 13.080 kms of
Page No.# 8/24
Tuting Zido section on NH-913.
4.
It is submitted that survey was conducted on 11 th, 12th and 13th May,
2024 over the petitioners’ land and a manipulated and erroneous assessment
report was prepared and finalized by the Land Compensation Assessment Board,
in an apathetic manner, on the instructions of some groups with vested
interests. The grievance of the land owners against this conduct fell on deaf
ears. Thereafter, a complaint was filed before the Deputy Commissioner, but the
Deputy Commissioner disagreed to deal with the same and advised them to
take recourse to the Court.
5.
It is averred that the minute details of the project have been kept away
from the public during the
course of
assessment
of the land
compensation. The petitioners have thus not accepted the compensation as the
same was prepared without including the valuation of genuine assets standing
over the land as per the provision under Section 26 of the Act of 2013.
6.
The other issue raised in this case is that the genuine properties were
surveyed, but kept in Compensation Oriented Structure (COS) list. Some of the
structures were erected several years ago and some old structures were
renovated, but it has been erroneously concluded that the renovated structures
were erected for the purpose of compensation.
7.
A public hearing was also not conducted by the respondent authorities
under the provision of the Act of 2013, preventing any issues to be raised, had
there been any issues at all.
8.
It is contended that the respondent authorities have decided in an
unjustified manner that the properties and assets of the petitioners as COS
properties without any finding. The petitioners then tried to collect details of
Page No.# 9/24
findings/proceedings from the office of the DLRSO which led to the respondent
authorities to consider 20-30 years old assets and properties as COS, but no
information was provided to the petitioners. It is also averred that the
petitioners learnt from reliable sources that the award was passed but the
award was never published. When the petitioners sought information about the
award, no information was provided and the petitioners had no details of the
award passed by the respondent authorities.
9.
It is also contended that evading the provision of Section 26 of the Act of
2013, the respondent authorities have adopted uniform rates for land
acquisition which is illegal, as the acquisition was initiated by invoking the
provisions of 2013 Act.
(i)
It is further submitted that the petitioner No. 1 (Chainage No. 1736 to
1920) had constructed RCC brick wall in the year 2020. This plot of land is
located near Tuting township area, a kilometer away from the town area.
(ii)
Then petitioner No. 2 has a commercial building constructed with wood,
bamboo and cement and he was running a shop in the building. This
construction at the commercial plot is of high valuation, but whimsically, the rate
has been fixed at Rs.200 (Rupees Two Hundred) per sq.mtr inspite of the fact
that the rate would be more than Rs.5000/- (Rupees Five Thousand) per
sq.meter in such an area.
(iii)
It is also averred that the petitioner no.3 (Chanaige No. 10702 to 10768)
has a WRC field and the said WRC field is surrounded by a stone wall to protect
the field from animals and this wall was built before his first son was born in the
year 1989. The wall was renovated by cement plastering as the wall was about
to collapse due to water leakage which is evident from the photograph annexed
Page No.# 10/24
as Annexure-7. It had never occurred to the petitioner no.3 that a highway
would be constructed through his land. It is also mentioned that the stone wall
of his neighbor, namely, Sri Beni Peyang (Chainage No. 10740 to 10798) has
been considered for payment and this wall was constructed at a much later
stage.
(iv) Another petitioner i.e. petitioner no.4 (Chainage No. 993 to 1093) had
constructed a retaining wall in the month of March 2023 to protect his land from
landslide as some portion of the land was loosening. This wall was also
surprisingly listed in the COS list. He was informed about the survey in a matter
of three days.
(v)
The petitioner no.5 had a farmhouse since 1970s (Chainage No. 2230 to
2320). This farm house was built for WRC field for resting and cooking. It has
been emphasized on behalf of the petitioner that it is common practice for the
local people to build a farm house in the WRC field for cooking and resting.
Periodically, the said farm house was renovated time and again. Coining the
same farm house as 'COS' is arbitrary and condemnable. The WRC field is one
of the important sources of income in the Tuting area, which is adjacent to the
township.
(vi) Irrigation canal in petitioner No. 6’s property was built before 2022 but,
the same has been kept in the COS list.
(vii) So is the case of the petitioner no.9 (Chainage No. 1131 to 1218) who
had constructed a farm house and the fish pond in the year 2023 before the
notification was issued for acquisition, but the fish pond has been kept in the
COS list and the farm house of the petitioner (OBT House) has not even been
considered for COS category. The respondent authorities were keen to acquire
Page No.# 11/24
4100 Sq. meters of land of petitioner no.9 for a price of Rs.4,10,000/- only
which is much below the current valuation of the land.
(viii) The petitioner no.10 (Chainage No.2123 to 2165), the petitioner no.11
(Chainage No.2165 to 2230) and the petitioner no.14 have properties which are
similar in nature to the other petitioners. The assets of these petitioners have
not been properly surveyed and consequentially, the number of fruit bearing
L/Cardamom trees were counted as 21, whereas in reality, there were more
than 100 fruit bearing trees. The petitioner no.14 has thus prayed for re-survey
for the interest of justice.
(ix)
The petitioner nos.12 and 13 have more than two thousand bamboo
growing but, unfortunately, 901 bamboo was assessed for compensation for the
petitioner no.12 and 200 for the petitioner no.13 at the rate of Rs.22 whereas
the Market Price is not less than Rs.150/-. Every year, the petitioners earned
Rs.50,000/- to Rs.60,000/- by selling bamboo from their land.
(x)
The property of petitioner no.15 (Chainage No.11981 to 12120) has not
been properly assessed for compensation as semi-RCC building has been
recorded as OBT house. His wooden godown and the RCC graveyard of his
father have not been estimated for compensation.
(xi)
The petitioner no.16 (Chainage No.1700 to 1736), petitioner no.17
(Chainage No.1736 to 2157), and the petitioner no.18 (Chainage No.1975 to
2047) have prayed for a direction to comply with Section 26 of the Act of 2013
as their plots of land are located only 1 km away from Tuting township. The
retaining wall constructed by the petitioner no.16 has been listed in the COS list
whereas the wall was built about 25 years ago.
(xii) It is further contended that the petitioner no.19 has a plot of land
Page No.# 12/24
bordering the Tuting township area, wherein she has built an OBT house for
commercial purpose by investing more than Rs.9,00,000/- for construction of a
shop, but only Rs.13,00,000/- has been assessed including the valuation of the
land.
(xiii) Another petitioner i.e. petitioner no.22 is running a shop at a village by
constructing the same after investing more than Rs.2,00,000/- whereas the total
compensation of the OBT shop was assessed at Rs.70,000/-.
10.
It is contended by the petitioners that the respondent Authority has adopted
uniformity of land-rate irrespective of town area and remote location and this has deprived
the petitioners from receiving fair compensation as per Section 26 of the Act of 2013. It
is averred that since the Land acquisition proceeding has been conducted under
urgency clause i.e., Section 40 of the Act of 2013, the petitioners are even entitled to
get additional compensation under sub-section 5 of Section 40. It is submitted
on behalf of the petitioners that since the primary Authority responsible for the
Arunachal Frontier Highway (NH-913) is the NHIDCL , a Central Government undertaking
under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MORTH for short) the question of
affecting the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security and strategic interest of
the State or relation with Foreign State would not arise. Moreover, when there
are no stakeholders opposing the land acquisition for a road, invoking urgency
clauses are clearly intended to exercise the provision of statutory benefits to the
petitioners which are framed under the Act of 2013.
11.
It is averred that the Board members did not follow the proper procedure
and arbitrarily decided that the properties of the petitioners are COS properties.
The petitioners are highly prejudiced because the properties which are as old as
30 years, 10 years, 3 years and more than a year before the issuance of
notification cannot be included in the COS list. It has been reiterated that the
Page No.# 13/24
erection of walls have been for the purpose to protect the land from landslide
and animals. The respondent never disclosed alignment of road to the
properties of the petitioners, and only within 3 days before conducting survey,
petitioners were informed and thus there is no question of erecting any socalled COS structures as claimed by the respondents.
12.
The petitioners have already agitated against such inclusion of the
properties in the COS list before the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Tuting,
but there has been no response from the ADC. It is contended that with
malafide, the total required land was assessed and notification was
issued by
the Government Vide notification No. LMD-12/1/2024/2141 and the area of
acquisition has been reduced from 51.147 hectares (511470 Sqms) to 43.647
hectares (436470 Sqms) at the last stage of the acquisition by the Deputy
Commissioner, Yingkiong, with respect to the land acquisition of the Tuting to Zido road
stretching from 0.00 Kms to 13.08 Kms. Thus, it is apparent that the
respondents have compromised with
the aims and objectives
of the Act
of 2013 and it is most likely to encroach upon the petitioners land during the
construction of the highways, if this deduction is permitted. So this illegal action
of the respondent Authority may also be looked into for the interest of justice.
13.
It is contended that the petitioners learnt from reliable sources that the
respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4, did not even know about the exact alignment of the
highways as it was prepared by the NHIDCL. It is submitted that during the time
of survey in some areas, the employees of the land department had included
even gorge areas for acquisition where roads are impossible to be constructed.
When the Authority was confronted about including such gorges within the
National Highway, then they tried to justify through their answer that, "the
alignment of the road was prepared by NHIDCL from satellite image without
Page No.# 14/24
physically visiting the area". Thus the petitioners are apprehensive that some
more of their land may be included to construct the National Highway by the
respondent Authorities without proper compensation.
14.
It is also averred that the Office of the Deputy Commissioner did not even
follow the procedures under the Act of 2013 and have erroneously assessed a
lower compensation for plots of land which are near the town area or within the
town area. It is submitted that as their assets have been assessed at a very low
rate for compensation, they have not accepted the compensation and the
matter is pending before the Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong. Similarly
circumstanced residents have already received the compensation in the month
of August, 2025.
15.
The petitioners have prayed to set aside the impugned land compensation
assessment report prepared by ADC-cum-Chairman, land compensation
assessment in pursuance to the impugned order dated YKLM-179/2024/53
dated 25.01.2024 issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong and for a writ
to be issued for fresh land compensation assessment of the petitioners with
complete transparency and fairness and directing the respondents to strictly
follow the provisions of Section 26 of the Act of 2013 along with additional
compensation under Section 40(5) of the Act of 2013.
16.
Through the affidavit-in-opposition submitted by the respondent Nos.2, 3,
4, 5 & 6 and through the oral submission on behalf of all the respondents, it is
submitted that the averments of the petitioners that after a survey conducted
on 11, 12 and 13th May, 2024, erroneous and manipulated land compensation
assessment report was prepared and finalized by the Board for the two-lane
road from Tuting to Zido, is absolutely false and misleading. It is averred that
Page No.# 15/24
when survey was conducted by the Board member constituted by the ADC,
Upper Siang, vide letter dated 19.03.2024 for assessment of land, assets were
falling within ROW. The joint survey was carried out w.e.f., 11.05.2024, and
completed on 17.05.2024, and the estimate was prepared based on ground
realities, by the District Administration.
17.
The respondent Nos. 5 & 6 and also the other respondents have
categorically denied that the Authority had skirted the provisions of Section 26
of the Act of 2013 while issuing public notice dated 08.11.2024, under provision
of Section 21(1) of the Act of 2013. It has been emphasized through the
argument on behalf of respondent Nos. 5 & 6 that the petitioners do not
deserve any additional compensation under Section 40(5) of the Act of 2013, as
the project is one that affects the sovereignty and integrity of India and the
security and strategic interest of the State or relations with Foreign States. The
project was declared as strategic linear project of national importance
concerning national security by the Ministry of Defence vide Office Memorandum
dated 22.08.2024. It is also averred on behalf of the respondents that the entire
Frontier highway, NH-913, stretching to a length of 1748 Kms was entrusted to
three different agencies i.e., State PWD, BRO and NHIDCL vide MoRTH Office
memorandum dated 03.04.2023, and out of 1748 Kms of the stretch 636 Kms of
length was entrusted to NHIDCL. Therefore, NHIDCL is not the only primary
Authority responsible for the Arunachal Frontier highway.
18.
The respondents through their affidavit and through their oral submission
have categorically denied the contention that the total required land issued by
the Government vide preliminary notification No. LMD-12/1/2024/2141 has been
reduced from 51.47 hectares to 43.647 hectares at last stage of the acquisition
by the Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong, with respect to land acquisition of the
Page No.# 16/24
Tuting-Zido road for 0.00 Kms to 13.08 Kms.
19.
On the other hand, it is submitted that the State Government had
published preliminary notification vide notification dated 29.02.2024, for 51.147
hectares of land including Muck dumping locations for acquisition for the
construction of Tuting-Zido road project. However, the land estimate for 43.647
hectares was submitted to Director of Land management excluding five muck
dumping locations and estimate for balance 7.50 hectares of land was under
preparation at the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Upper Siang. It is denied
on behalf of the respondent Nos. 3 & 4, that NHIDCL had prepared the
alignment and the other respondents were not privy to the exact alignment of
the National highway road.
20.
On the contrary, it is submitted that the alignment was prepared by DPR
(Detailed Project Report) consultant based on detailed ground service and
LiDAR
(Light
detection
and
ranging)
technology.
The
alignment
was
subsequently reviewed and approved by the MoRTH in consultation with the
MHA and Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP). Accordingly, tenders for civil work
were invited through the CPP portal with robust technical qualification criteria
under EPC (Engineering, procurement and construction) contracts. The EPC
contractor is being finalized strictly based on demonstrated experience and
expertise in executing EPC projects. In addition, a team of authorities, engineers
comprising of experienced experts was deployed during construction to monitor
and supervise the quality and execution of highway works there. Finally, it is
also emphasised through the argument that all the provisions of the Act of 2013
were followed by the District administration.
21.
It is argued on behalf of the State, the Director of Land Management and
the Deputy Commissioner, i.e., respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 4, and on behalf of
Page No.# 17/24
other respondents that it has been falsely alleged that the assessment report
was erroneously prepared and manipulated. It is submitted that the survey of
the land and the preparation of the land compensation were made in presence
of public/landowners. Assets were surveyed and recorded including the
Compensation Oriented structure (COS). Some of the properties were marked
as COS because it was genuinely found to be COS as the properties were newly
constructed properties. The respondents have vehemently denied that the
Authority has adopted the uniform rate of land but it is emphasized through the
argument that the Authority had followed the Manual for Land acquisition in
Arunachal Pradesh, 2022 (Manual of 2022 for short) as well as Section 26 of
the Act of 2013.
22.
The respondents laid stress in their arguments that the property of
petitioner No. 1 comes under COS list, and it has been duly verified as such by
the survey team. The respondents have categorically denied all the averments in
the writ petition that land has been acquired for construction of the Tuting-Zido
Road. It is also submitted that along with petitioner Nos. 7, 20 & 21, the
petitioner No. 8 has also submitted the deed of acceptance for compensation for
the land acquired and have already received the compensation amount. It has
been emphasized through the argument that the respondent Authority has fixed
the rate of the property as per market value and also according to the rate
provided under the Manual for Land acquisition in Arunachal Pradesh, 2022 and
as per the statutory provisions. The respondents have denied any malafide on
their part.
23.
The respondent Nos. 2, 3 & 4 have also concurred to the submissions on
behalf of the other respondent Nos. 5 & 6. Further, it is submitted that the
entire process of land acquisition has smoothly progressed. All the respondents
Page No.# 18/24
have submitted to dismiss the petition as this petition is bereft of merits.
24.
The argument submitted on behalf of the petitioners and the respondents
have been elaborately discussed in the foregoing discussions. The issue that
falls for consideration in this case is that whether the properties of the
petitioners can be enlisted in the COS list. It is to be borne in mind that
respondents have stressed on the fact that the Tuting-Zido road is an
international border highway road, and an intermediate lane is proposed to be
constructed after the acquisition of the petitioners land and land of other land
owners. Annexure-1 to the petition is the speaking order dated 25.01.2024,
passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Upper Siang District, Yingkiong. Annexure2 series is the preliminary notification for land acquisition for the construction of
the intermediate lane road at Tuting-Zido section. It also includes the forwarding
of the acquisition letter received from the General Manager (Admin and LA) of
NHIDCL, Itanagar, for the acquisition of 51.147 hectares of land for construction
of the intermediate lane road. The draft preliminary notification duly signed by
the Deputy Commissioner under Section 11(1) read with Section 40(1) of the
Act of 2013 was also forwarded along with the forwarding. The preliminary
notification in the Annexure-II series is relating to construction of the
intermediate lane from 0.000 Kms to 13.080 Kms, and the Tuting-Zido section
on NH-913 for Frontier Highway. The Deputy Commissioner along with his staff
was authorized by the Government to enter upon and survey the land under
Section 12 of the Act.
25.
The petitioners are basically aggrieved, as allegedly, the respondents have
skirted the provisions of Section 26 of the Act of 2013. It is alleged that the
market value was not taken into consideration. Although the respondents have
vehemently denied that the survey was not properly conducted by the
Page No.# 19/24
Department of Survey, yet the respondents have not annexed any market
valuation of the land acquired for construction of the intermediate lane
alongwith the three affidavits that have been filed by the respondent Nos. 2 to
6. The market valuation of the land have been submitted by the petitioners
through the annexures marked as Annexure- VI series upto Annexure- XVIII
series.
26.
It has not been clarified by the respondents through their argument as
well as through the affidavit-in-opposition, on what basis they have held the
land of the petitioners to be in the COS list. An omnibus statement has been
made that the petitioners have constructed new structures over their land after
the preliminary notification to procure the advantage of the compensation. This
preliminary notification was issued on 29.02.2024, and the Office of the Deputy
Commissioner, Yingkiong, vide letter dated 19.02.2024 forwarded the draft
preliminary notification for acquisition of land. The resondents have specifically
alleged that the petitioner No.1’s construction definitely falls in COS list.
27.
The Annexure-I series of the affidavit-in-opposition dated 23.02.2026
submitted by the respondent Nos. 3 & 4 includes the public notice which clearly
describes the area of land required for acquisition and also the area of land
which has been left out as muck disposal at Column-3 of the Public notice dated
29.04.2025. Public notices dated 21.04.2025 and 29.04.2025 are marked as
Annexure-I series. It is submitted that the Annexure-I series will clarify the
requirement of the land for the intermediate lane of Tuting-Zido road.
28.
A close scrutiny of the notifications reveal that certain portions of land
required to be acquired for the intermediate lane is also required for Muck
dumping locations. The land required to be acquired for the intermediate parts
of the project including mines and minerals which may be required to be dug or
Page No.# 20/24
removed or used during construction phase of the project purpose of the land
was being acquired and no mines, mineral, iron, stone, slate and other minerals
lying under the said land had to be extracted or removed. Thus the plan of the
land survey was proposed to be inspected in the Office of the Collector, DLR &
SO, Upper Siang District. It was also decided that no additional compensation as
per Section 40(5) of the Act of 2013 was to be paid for acquisition of the land as
this road affects the sovereignty and security of the State.
29.
It was also notified that on expiration of 30 days from the date of
notification, despite award being not made, the District Collector (Deputy
Commissioner) would take possession of the land acquired for the purpose of
the road. These are the only notifications annexed with the affidavit-inopposition submitted by the respondent Nos. 2 to 6.
30.
The petitioners are aggrieved as the valuation was according to the
Manual for Land acquisition in Arunachal Pradesh, 2022, whereas the
respondents have laid stress through their arguments that the Manual for Land
acquisition in Arunachal Pradesh, 2022 is an exact replica of the Act of 2013.
The respondents have emphasized through their arguments that the petitioners
have not been prejudiced.
31.
It is further argued on behalf of the petitioners that the allegations that
the land of the petitioners fall within the COS list are absolutely false as the land
over which action after the preliminary notification is alleged to have been taken
are mostly lands adjacent to the township area of higher valuation and the
constructions (as alleged) were not erected after the preliminary notification or
any other notification by the respondents for acquisition of land, but the walls
and other enclosures were constructed, much earlier.
Page No.# 21/24
32.
It is true that the valuation is included in the Manual of 2022 and the
Manual was prepared after including the applicability of the Act of 2013. The
Manual of 2022 shall be applicable for all land acquisitions under the Act of
2013. It therefore appears that the provisions under Section 26 of the Act of
2013 is to be followed. At the same time, this Court cannot be oblivious of the
fact that no documents relating to any public hearing for acquisition of land has
been submitted. Some documents relating to the valuation to be paid to the
petitioners has been submitted by the petitioners. This makes it difficult for this
Court to arrive at a conclusion whether the valuation of the properties of the
petitioners have been correctly assessed. Annexure-VI series to Annexure-XVI
series are certain photographs and specifications of construction of certain
walls, structures, sheds and buildings, which clearly depicts that those
structures were not newly constructed structures. They appear to be old and
definitely not for the purpose of procuring the benefits of compensation.
33.
It is true that at this stage, as submitted by the respondents, a Writ Court
cannot go into the evidence and assess the age of the structures, walls and
buildings, etc., to agree with the valuation provided by the respondents with
regard to the petitioners for acquisition of the land. It would be apt to reiterate
that Annexure-VI series to Annexure-XVIII series includes the photographs of
the walls or other structures of some of the petitioners along with the estimated
compensation of the properties of the petitioners.
34.
Most of the similarly circumstanced land owners have accepted and
received the compensation. As the petitioners are genuinely aggrieved, they
have not accepted the compensation. The documents annexed along with the
writ petition reveals the rate of the assets vis-a-vis the market valuation. It
appears that a direction can be given to the respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 to
Page No.# 22/24
consider the case of the petitioners as per the Act of 2013. The learned counsel
for the petitioners has relied on a decision of this Court in the case of Behenso
Pul and 28 Ors in WP © No.249/2024 wherein vide order dated 07.04.2026, it
has been held that;
“10. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mihin Laling (supra), vide
judgment dated 16.09.2025, has clearly laid down that the provisions of the Act
of 2013 should be applied for assessing fair compensation. In the said case, the
aspect of payment of solatium and interest has also been highlighted.
11. Section 24 of the Act, more specifically the proviso to Sub section (2),
would show that compensation, even if assessed as per the earlier Act and has
not been deposited shall be converted to compensation as per the Act of 2013.
The intention of the legislation of 2013 is to ensure that fair and proper
compensation is paid to the land affected persons and that nobody is deprived
of their due entitlement. There are various other aspects in the Act of 2013,
including solatium and interest, which would also have to form part of the
Award, including those mentioned in Schedule I of the Act.
12. The determination of the rate of Rs. 11 per square metre prima facie
appears to be absolutely on the lower side and cannot be treated as fair
compensation, more so when the materials on record suggest that for adjoining
areas, higher rates have been determined. Be that as it may, this Court is of the
opinion that the entire assessment has to be done afresh by taking into
consideration all the relevant factors, including the rates applied for acquisition
of land in the adjoining areas, provided such acquisitions have been made
during the contemporaneous period. It is also needless to state that all other
provisions of 2013 Act, which have been incorporated for the benefits of the
land affected persons are to be taken into consideration while assessing and
determining the rate to be paid to the land affected persons.”
35. The respondent authority has failed to refute the allegations of the
petitioners that the public or the petitioners were not heard before the
Page No.# 23/24
properties were acquired for construction of the intermediate lane. It is not
clear from the submissions of the respondents whether the petitioners were
heard before the properties were acquired. It would also be apt to reiterate
that the respondent nos.2,3 and 4 have denied in an omnibus manner that
they have included the structures and properties of all the petitioners as COS
structures with malafide. It is apparent that the respondents have specifically
alleged that the petitioner no.1’s structure is a COS structure, whereas the
respondents have not specifically mentioned how and in what manner the
structures of the other petitioners are COS structures or properties. Although
they have specifically alleged that petitioner no.1’s structure is a COS structure,
yet they have not demonstrated in what manner the petitioner no.1’s structure
was branded as COS structure.
36.
It has been agreed by the respondents that the entire Act of 2013 has
been included in the Manual of 2022. Therefore, the case of the petitioners can
be considered by the respondents for awarding compensation to the petitioners
as per the Act of 2013. This Court cannot be oblivious of the submission of the
petitioners that they were not allowed even three days time by the respondents,
who proceeded with the acquisition of land and this makes it impossible for
them to erect Construction Oriented Structures so as to avail the benefits of
compensation.
37.
The petitioners have submitted, through their arguments as well as in
their petition, that they have approached the ADC against the meagre
compensation awarded to them, but the ADC did not deal with the same. If any
representation of the petitioners is pending before the ADC, the ADC may also
consider the case of the petitioners. It has also to be borne in mind that most of
the petitioners have claimed that their land acquired by the Government for
Page No.# 24/24
construction of the intermediate lane is in close proximity to the township area
and is of much higher valuation than evaluated by the respondents.
38.
This Court would also like to rely on the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of State of Arunachal Pradesh and another Vs. Mihin Laling and
others, reported in 2025 Supreme (SC) 1770, wherein vide judgment and order
dated 16.09.2025, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has clearly laid down that the
provisions of the Act of 2013 should be applied for assessing fair compensation.
This Court, in Behenso Pul and 28 others (supra), has also observed that, in the
case of Mihin Laling (supra), the aspect of payment of solatium and interest as per
the Act of 2013 has also been highlighted.
39.
In the light of the decision of the Supreme Court in Mihin Laling (supra) and
the decision of this Court in Behenso Pul (supra), this writ petition is partly allowed
by remanding the matter to the concerned Deputy Commissioner, Yingkiong, Upper
Siang District (respondent No. 3), Arunachal Pradesh, to consider the case of the
petitioners and provide compensation following the provisions of the 2013 Act. This
Court has taken note of the submission on behalf of the petitioners that their
representation has not been considered by the respondent No. 4, the Additional
Deputy Commissioner, Tuting. The respondent Nos. 3 and 4 to consider any
pending representation of the petitioners. The entire process shall be undertaken
and completed expeditiously and preferably within a period of 3(three) months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review