Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 188
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP (C) No. 1433/2026
Date of pronouncement: 07.08.2026
Date of uploading:13.08.2026
M/s Tata Power Renewable Energy Limited
having its registered office at Corporate Centre, B34, Sant Tukaram Road, Carnac Bunder, Mumbai,
Maharashtra- 400009. Represented by its
authorized representative,
JATIN GHULIANI,
Tata Power Renewable Energy Limited Corporate
Center B, 34 Sant Tukaram Road, Carnac Bunder,
Mumbai- 400009, Maharashtra, India
.....Petitioner(s)
Through :- Mr. Abhinav Sharma, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Abhirash Sharma, Advocate,
Mr. Siddhant Gupta, Advocate
Mr. Akash Lamba, Advocate,
Mr. Shreyesth Ramesh Sharma, Advocate
Mr. Syed Faisal Qadri, Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Manik Dutt, Advocate.
v/s
1. UT of Jammu & Kashmir
Through its Principal Secretary/Commissioner
Secretary to the Government, Department of
Rural Development and Panchayati Raj, Civil
Secretariat, Jammu
2. State Procurement and Supplies Agency
(SPSA), Department of Rural Development and
Panchayati Raj, UT of Jammu & Kashmir,
through its Managing Director/Chief Executive
Officer, H.No. 21, Sector 1, Trikuta Nagar,
Jammu
.....Respondent(s)
Through :- Mr. Abdul Rashid Malik, Sr. AAG.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
ORDER
1.
The present petition calls in question an interlocutory order passed by the
ld. Arbitrator under Section 26 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 (“the Act”), whereby a Technical Committee has been constituted to
WP(C) No.1433/2026
undertake physical verification and technical inspection of Off-Grid Solar
PV Power Plants forming the subject matter of the arbitral proceedings.
Respondent No. 2, the State Procurement and Supplies Agency (“SPSA”),
awarded a contract to the petitioner pursuant to a Notice Inviting Tender
for the supply, installation, testing and commissioning of Off-Grid Solar
PV Power Plants of 3.5 KWP capacity at 1,013 project sites spread across
20 districts of the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir. Agreements in
furtherance thereof were executed between the parties on 16.09.2021 and
17.09.2021.
2.
According to the petitioner, it completed installation and commissioning
at all 1,013 project sites. The installations were thereafter physically
verified and certified by the Jammu and Kashmir Energy Development
Agency (“JAKEDA”), the State Nodal Agency under the Department of
Science and Technology, Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.
Commissioning certificates dated 23.01.2024 and 29.01.2024 were issued
in respect of 485 Panchayat Ghars in the Jammu Division and 528
Panchayat Ghars in the Kashmir Division respectively, thereby covering
all 1,013 sites. The petitioner also relies upon a communication dated
05.10.2024 issued by the CEO/MD of Respondent No. 2, which,
according to it, acknowledges completion of the project.
3.
The petitioner claims that, notwithstanding completion of the contractual
works, outstanding dues of approximately Rs.38.66 crore remained
unpaid. It asserts that, having completed its obligations and with nothing
further remaining to be performed, it terminated the contract on
08.06.2023. The project sites thereafter remained in the custody and
control of the respondents and/or the respective Panchayat authorities.
WP(C) No.1433/2026
Disputes having arisen between the parties, the matter was referred to
arbitration and an Arbitrator came to be appointed.
4.
During the arbitral proceedings, Respondent No. 2 filed an application
under Section 26 of the Act seeking appointment of an Expert Committee
for physical verification and technical inspection of the project sites. By a
detailed order dated 23.12.2025, the ld. Arbitrator declined the request for
a wholesale post-closure inspection. At the same time, it expressly
preserved its power to appoint an expert suo motu, or upon a renewed
request by either party, should the necessity for such expert assistance
arise at a subsequent stage.
5.
On 25.03.2026, Respondent No. 2 filed a renewed application under
Section 26 seeking appointment of an Expert Committee. The renewed
request was founded, inter alia, upon district-level field-verification
material stated to have been collected in March 2026 and a
communication dated 25.03.2026 attributed to Mr. Fayaz Ahmad Bhat,
Junior Assistant, stating that he had not been associated with the
verification exercise relating to the Kashmir Division sites. The petitioner
opposed the application by filing objections dated 17.04.2026. It
contended that the renewed application merely sought to reopen an issue
already decided; travelled beyond the pleadings; attempted to introduce a
new factual defence after closure of evidence; relied upon material
generated nearly three years after termination of the contract; and failed to
disclose any specific technical issue warranting recourse to Section 26 of
the Act.
7.
Learned Sr. Counsels appearing for the petitioner assails the impugned
order principally on four grounds. First, it is submitted that the renewed
WP(C) No.1433/2026
application was substantially a repetition of the earlier application rejected
on 23.12.2025 and did not satisfy the conditions expressly stipulated by it,
while preserving liberty for a renewed request. The direction for
inspection of all 1,013 sites across 20 districts is stated to be precisely the
kind of general and open-ended inquiry which the earlier order had
declined to permit. Second, it is contended that no foundational case of
non-installation, defective installation or non-functionality attributable to
the petitioner had been pleaded in the Statement of Defence. Respondent
No. 2 had complete access to the sites throughout execution of the project
and during the arbitral proceedings, yet no site-specific deficiencies were
pleaded. Nor, according to the petitioner, has Respondent No. 2 raised any
counterclaim founded upon defective or incomplete execution of the
works.
8.
The renewed application, it is accordingly submitted, permits Respondent
No. 2 to introduce a new factual case after closure of evidence and
substantial completion of final arguments. Section 26, according to the
petitioner, cannot be employed as a mechanism for collecting evidence or
constructing a case which does not arise from the pleadings. Reliance in
this regard is also placed upon the principles underlying the proviso to
Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 concerning due
diligence after commencement of trial. Third, the petitioner submits that
an inspection conducted in March 2026 cannot legitimately determine
whether contractual obligations had been duly performed during 2021–
2023. The contract was terminated on 08.06.2023 and the installations
thereafter ceased to be in the petitioner's custody or control. Any
deterioration, damage or non-functionality occurring subsequently, it is
WP(C) No.1433/2026
urged, cannot retrospectively impeach performance which had already
been verified and certified. Fourth, it is submitted that the material relied
upon in support of the renewed application does not constitute a genuine
subsequent circumstance. The disclaimer attributed to Mr. Fayaz Ahmad
Bhat is stated to be a unilateral declaration by a junior official made
during the pendency of the proceedings and incapable of displacing
official acts performed pursuant to Government orders.
9.
Ld. Sr. Counsels further submits that Respondent No. 2's own
communication dated 05.10.2024 acknowledged completion of the project
and recorded that the allegations raised by the Anti-Corruption Bureau
(“ACB”) had been answered point-wise and that the competent
Department had directed processing of the petitioner's outstanding dues.
Respondent No. 2, having adopted such a position, cannot now be
permitted to approbate and reprobate. It is lastly urged that, after the
learned Arbitrator had indicated on 28.03.2026 that pending applications
would be considered with the main matter, constitution of an Expert
Committee at the stage when evidence stood concluded and final
arguments had substantially been heard, amounts to reopening the
evidentiary record and creating an altogether new stream of evidence
10.
Ld. Sr.Counsels appearing for the respondents opposes the petition and
submits that the order dated 23.12.2025 itself expressly preserved the
arbitrator’s power to appoint an expert suo motu or upon a renewed and
appropriately tailored request if subsequent circumstances warranted such
a course. According to the respondents, material subsequently came to
light casting serious doubt upon the correctness of the earlier verification
and certification exercise. Reliance is placed upon the communication
WP(C) No.1433/2026
dated 25.03.2026 attributed to Mr. Fayaz Ahmad Bhat and fieldverification reports concerning Shopian, Budgam, Ganderbal and Kulgam.
It is contended that such material prima facie indicated that installations
claimed to have been commissioned were not existing at several locations
and that the Quality Inspection Report and commissioning certificates
relied upon by the petitioner required technical verification. The
respondents also questioned the commissioning certificates on the ground
that they did not bear the signature of the CEO, SPSA.
11.
Considerable reliance is also placed upon the investigation being
conducted by the ACB into alleged irregularities concerning procurement
and approval of prices of the Solar PV systems. It is submitted that
approval under Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
had been accorded for inquiry/investigation into the conduct of the
concerned public servants, including officials associated with the project.
The respondents submit that, in these circumstances, the ld. Arbitrator
considered expert assistance necessary to ascertain the factual and
technical position at the project sites.
12.
It is further contended that constitution of the Expert Committee is purely
procedural and does not determine any substantive right or liability of
either party. If the Committee's report is averse to the petitioner, the
petitioner would remain entitled to object to its methodology, correctness,
relevance and evidentiary value before the Arbitrator. Should the
arbitrator ultimately rely upon such material while rendering an award
adverse to the petitioner, the petitioner would have its statutory remedy
under Section 34 of the Act. Interference under Articles 226 or 227 at this
interlocutory stage, according to the respondents, would therefore be
WP(C) No.1433/2026
contrary to the legislative policy of minimal judicial intervention in
arbitral proceedings.
13.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and examined the
record.
14.
Before examining the rival contentions on merits, it is necessary to notice
the settled legal position governing interference by this court under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution with interlocutory orders passed
in arbitral proceedings. In SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd. and
Another, (2005) 8 SCC 618, the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasised the
legislative policy of minimal judicial intervention underlying the Act. The
Court disapproved the proposition that interlocutory orders passed by an
Arbitrator could routinely be corrected in exercise of jurisdiction under
Articles 226 or 227 of the Constitution.
15.
The principle was reiterated in Deep Industries Limited v. Oil and Natural
Gas Corporation Limited and Another, (2020) 15 SCC 706. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that the statutory scheme cannot be circumvented by
subjecting interlocutory determinations of an Arbitrator to supervisory
review at every stage. Where the Act contemplates that an objection may
ultimately be raised in proceedings under Section 34, interference during
the pendency of the arbitration must remain exceptional. InSero soft
Solutions Pvt. Ltd. v. Dexter Capital Advisors Pvt. Ltd., 2025 SCC Online
SC 22, the challenge concerned a procedural order of the Arbitrator
declining further opportunity for cross-examination. The principle
reiterated was that judicial interference with procedural and interlocutory
orders in arbitration is permissible only in rare and exceptional
circumstances, including cases involving perversity of such magnitude as
WP(C) No.1433/2026
is apparent on the face of the record. More recently, in Manish Kamal
Bezboruah v. Bokahola Tea Company Private Limited and Others, 2026
SCC Online SC 1330, the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated that, although
the constitutional supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 cannot be
altogether excluded, its exercise in arbitral matters is confined to
exceptional situations, such as a patent lack of inherent jurisdiction
apparent on the face of the record. An aggrieved party ordinarily must
await the award and pursue the statutory remedy available under Section
34 of the Act.
16.
The legal position which emerges is that the jurisdiction of this Court
under Articles 226 and 227 undoubtedly survives, but its exercise against
interlocutory arbitral orders is subject to exceptional restraint. Mere error
of fact or law, or the possibility that another view could have been taken,
does not justify supervisory interference. The Court is therefore not
required, at an intermediate stage of arbitration, to examine the
correctness of the arbitrator's procedural determination as though
exercising appellate jurisdiction. Intervention would be warranted only
where the order demonstrates a patent absence of jurisdiction or such
manifest perversity as would justify recourse to the extraordinary
constitutional jurisdiction. The challenge in the present case must be
examined against this limited jurisdictional threshold.
17.
The principal submission of the petitioner is that the impugned order
violates the arbitrator’s own earlier order dated 23.12.2025. The
submission is not without substance at first impression. The earlier order
had declined a wholesale post-closure inspection and had prescribed
safeguards governing any renewed request.
18.
WP(C) No.1433/2026
The decisive question, however, is not whether this Court, sitting in
appeal, would have considered the renewed request justified. The question
is whether the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction to entertain it or whether the
exercise of power is so manifestly perverse as to warrant constitutional
intervention during the pendency of the arbitration. On that question, the
order dated 23.12.2025 assumes significance. The arbitrator did not
finally foreclose expert assistance. On the contrary, it expressly preserved
its power to appoint an expert suo motu or upon a renewed request if
necessity arose at a subsequent stage on the basis of the record and
circumstances then obtaining. That order was never challenged and
attained finality inter partes. The respondents thereafter moved the
renewed application dated 25.03.2026, asserting that material had
subsequently surfaced which cast doubt upon the factual basis of the
commissioning and verification exercise.
19.
The respondents relied, amongst other material, upon the communication
dated 25.03.2026 attributed to Mr. Fayaz Ahmad Bhat and fieldverification reports concerning four districts. Their case before the
arbitrator was that this material called into question the correctness of the
Quality Inspection Report and the commissioning certificates upon which
the petitioner substantially relies in support of its monetary claims.
20.
Whether the said material is credible, whether it could or ought to have
been produced earlier, whether it genuinely constitutes subsequent
material, and what evidentiary weight can ultimately be attached to it are
all matters on which the petitioner has raised substantial objections. Those
objections, however, pertain primarily to the admissibility, relevance,
probative value and ultimate effect of the material rather than to the
WP(C) No.1433/2026
existence of the Arbitrator’s statutory power to obtain expert assistance.
Section 26 of the Act expressly empowers an Arbitrator, unless otherwise
agreed by the parties, to appoint one or more experts to report to it on
specific issues to be determined by the arbitrator. The petitioner does not
dispute the existence of that power.
21.
The underlying arbitration concerns the petitioner's claim for substantial
contractual payments on the basis that the Solar PV systems were duly
supplied, installed, tested and commissioned. The petitioner claims
approximately Rs.38,66,26,621/-, together with pre-reference, pendente
lite and future interest at 18% per annum, inter alia, towards unpaid
supply-stage and installation-and-commissioning payments, expenditure
incurred in completing the project and losses allegedly resulting from
breach of the agreements. Questions concerning whether the contracted
systems were in fact installed and commissioned, and the evidentiary
value of the certificates relied upon to establish such performance, are
therefore connected with the contractual dispute before the Arbitrator.
22.
The fact that an ACB investigation may separately concern alleged
irregularities in the tender process, pricing or conduct of public officials
does not alter the essentially contractual character of the disputes referred
to arbitration. Equally, however, the existence of such investigation does
not, by itself, disable the Arbitrator from examining material otherwise
relevant to the contractual disputes pending before it. The Arbitrator has
taken the view that, in light of the material subsequently placed before it,
technical assistance is required concerning the design, supply, installation,
testing, commissioning and physical position of the systems forming the
WP(C) No.1433/2026
subject matter of the contract. Whether the conclusions ultimately drawn
from such inspection are sustainable is a distinct question.
23.
The petitioner's contention that the present condition of the installations
cannot establish their condition as on the date of completion or
termination also raises an important evidentiary issue. The project sites
ceased, according to the petitioner, to remain under its custody or control
after termination on 08.06.2023. It is therefore possible that deterioration,
damage, removal or non-functionality discovered subsequently may have
causes unrelated to the petitioner's contractual performance. That
consideration, however, bears upon the relevance and weight to be
assigned to the Committee's eventual findings. It does not establish that
the Arbitrator inherently lacks jurisdiction to obtain the report.
24.
A physical condition found in 2026 cannot automatically be treated as
proof of the condition prevailing in 2023. The causal and temporal
connection, if any, between the Committee's observations and the
petitioner's contractual performance would have to be independently
established and evaluated by the Arbitrator after hearing both sides. The
same distinction applies to the petitioner's objection that the renewed
application travels beyond the pleadings. Whether a particular finding of
the Expert Committee can legitimately be relied upon in the absence of a
corresponding pleaded case, and whether doing so would prejudice the
petitioner or impermissibly enlarge the scope of the dispute, are questions
capable of being raised before the Arbitrator if and when such material is
sought to be relied upon.
25.
The constitution of the Committee does not, by itself, amount to an
adjudication that the petitioner's installations were defective, incomplete
WP(C) No.1433/2026
or non-existent. Nor does the Committee's report, when submitted,
determine the rights and liabilities of the parties. It remains material
placed before the adjudicatory forum and is subject to scrutiny in
accordance with law. The petitioner must therefore be afforded an
effective opportunity to question the report, including its methodology,
factual assumptions, temporal relevance and conclusions, and, where
permissible, to place rebuttal material or evidence before the arbitrator.
26.
The petitioner's further contention based upon Respondent No. 2's
communication dated 05.10.2024, including the plea of approbation and
reprobation, likewise concerns the evidentiary and legal effect of
Respondent No. 2's earlier acknowledgment. Nothing in the impugned
order precludes the petitioner from relying upon that communication
before the Arbitrator or from contending that the respondents are bound
by the position earlier adopted by them. Likewise, the question whether
the material relied upon in March 2026 truly satisfies the conditions
contemplated by the order dated 23.12.2025 is capable of being examined
in the arbitral proceedings and, if necessary, in a challenge to the eventual
award. At this stage, the mere fact that the petitioner disputes the
assessment of those circumstances cannot convert the impugned
procedural determination into an order passed without jurisdiction.
27.
Considered in this perspective, the impugned order represents an exercise
of a power expressly conferred upon the Arbitrator by Section 26 of the
Act and additionally preserved by its earlier order dated 23.12.2025.
Whether it has exercised that power correctly, or whether the eventual
report can legitimately sustain any finding adverse to the petitioner, are
WP(C) No.1433/2026
matters distinct from the Arbitrator’s competence to undertake the
exercise.
28.
The present challenge therefore essentially invites this Court to determine,
at an interlocutory stage, whether he has correctly assessed the necessity,
timing, scope and evidentiary justification for expert assistance.
Undertaking such an inquiry would require this Court to sit in appeal over
a procedural determination made in the course of ongoing arbitral
proceedings, which is precisely what the settled principles governing
Articles 226 and 227 cautions against. No patent lack of inherent
jurisdiction is demonstrated. Nor does the impugned order disclose
manifest perversity of the exceptional degree necessary to justify
interference with an ongoing arbitration.
29.
The petitioner's apprehension of prejudice can adequately be addressed by
ensuring that the Expert Committee's report is not acted upon adversely
without affording the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to challenge its
contents, methodology, relevance and conclusions before the learned
Arbitrator. For the reasons aforesaid, this Court finds no exceptional
circumstance warranting interference under Articles 226 or 227 of the
Constitution of India with the impugned interlocutory order. The writ
petition is, accordingly,dismissed, interim direction if any shall stand
vacated.
30.
Having regard, however, to the advanced stage of the arbitral proceedings,
the ld. Arbitrator is requested to endeavour to conclude the proceedings as
expeditiously as possible, while affording adequate opportunity of hearing
to both sides. In the event that the report of the Expert Committee, or any
part thereof, is averse to either party, the party affected shall be afforded a
WP(C) No.1433/2026
reasonable opportunity, in accordance with law, to raise objections to the
report, including its methodology, relevance and conclusions, and to lead
evidence in rebuttal, if otherwise permissible, before such report is acted
upon by the Arbitrator.
31.
It is further clarified that the physical condition of any installation found
during an inspection conducted in 2026 shall not, merely by reason of
such condition, be treated as determinative of its condition at the time of
installation, commissioning or termination of the contract. The relevance
and evidentiary weight of any such finding, including its temporal and
causal connection with the petitioner's contractual performance, shall be
independently considered by ld. Arbitrator after hearing the parties while
drawing final award.
( Sanjay Parihar )
Judge
JAMMU
07.08.2026
Manik
Whether this order is speaking: Yes
Whether this order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review