Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010626832023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
MONDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 786 OF 2023
Between:
1. TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP. BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER, VISAKHAPATNAM
...APPELLANT
AND
1. MEESALA ESWARAMMA, W/O. LATE APPALANAIDU, AGED 41
YEARS, HINDU, HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, DEVARAPALLI VILLAGE,
RANASTALAM MANDALM., SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
2. MEEALA SATISH, S/O. LATE APPALANAIDU, AGED 22 YEARS,
HINDU, DEVARAPALLI VILLAGE, RANASTALAM MANDALM,
SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
3. MEESALA SRIDEVI, D/O. LATE APPALANAIDU, AGED 16 YEARS.
MINOR, HINDU, BEING MINOR REPRESENTED BY HER MOTHER
MOTHERNEXT FRIEND, GUARDIAN
GUARDIAN-1ST
1ST PETITIONER HEREIN)
4. MEESALA APPALAMMA, W/O. LATE RAMULU, AGED 75 YEARS,
HINDU, HOUSEHOLD, DEVARAPALLI VILLAGE,
RANASTALAM
MANDALM, SRIKAKULAM
AKULAM DISTRICT.
5. KANDI NARAYANARAO, S/O. THAVUDU. OWNER
OWNER-CUM
CUM- DRIVER OF
BOLERO GOODS CARRIAGE NO. AP 39 TT 6061, D.NO.4
D.NO.4-78,
SANCLIAM,
PUNNANAPALEM,
RANASTHALAM
MANDAL,
SRIKAKULAM DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. D RAVI KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. N B CHANDRA SEKHAR
The Court made the following Judgment :
The Appellant/ Insurance Company filed the present Appeal challenging
the order and decree 01.09.2023 in M.V.O.P.No.159 of 2022 on the file of the
Court of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum- Principal District Judge,
Srikakulam, whereby and whereunder the Tribunal granted compensation of
Rs.16,45,000/- to the Respondents/ Claimants, as against the claim of
30,00,000/- for the death of one Mr. Meesala Appala Naidu, (in short ‘the
deceased’) in a motor accident that occurred on 01.06.2021.
2.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
The case of the Petitioner is briefly as follows:
On 31.05.2021, the Respondent No.1 along with one Duppada Ashok,
transported mangoes from Devarapalli to Berhampur, in the offending vehicle
and the mangoes were loaded at Devarapalli. The owner of mangoes load
also joined the, and all of them started at 8.30 p.m and while they were
proceeding towards Berhampur, on 01.06.2021 at about 2.20 a.m, when they
reached near Sri Venkateswara Weigh Bridge, ahead of sky drop junction,
Respondent No.1 drove the offending vehicle in a rash and negligent manner,
with high speed, onto divider, as a result, the offending vehicle capsized on
the road, and deceased sitting on the mangoes load fell down, and sustained
severe injuries on his head. The Ichapuram Police registered a case in Crime
No. 52 of 2021 under Section 304(A) of IPC. Therefore, the Claimants filed a
claim petition seeking compensation against the Respondents.
4.
Respondent No.1 filed Written Statement denying all material
averments made in the petition and inter alia contended that he drove the
vehicle with careful manner and possessing valid driving license to drive the
offending vehicle. If offending vehicle had involved in any accident, it would be
damage, but it did not sustain damage. The offending vehicle insured with the
Respondent No.2, who is liable to pay compensation to the Claimants if any.
5.
Respondent No.2/
Insurance Company filed Written Statement
contending that the deceased was sitting negligently on the top of the
mangoes load in the offending vehicle, as gratuitous passenger, without taking
proper care and safety and due to his negligence, the accident took place, as
the Respondent No.2 is not liable to pay compensation. Further, the driver of
offending vehicle did not possess valid driving license on the date of accident,
which amounts to breach of Section 181 read with 3 of Motor Vehicles Act and
also violation of insurance policy. Therefore, the Respondent No.2 is not liable
to pay any compensation to the Claimants.
6.
trial:
Basing on the pleadings, the Tribunal framed the following issues for
“1. Whether the death of deceased Meesala Appala Naidu, S/o late
Ramulu, took place in motor accident on 01.06.2021, at about 1.20 hours,
near Sri Venkateswara Weigh Bridge, due to rash and negligence of 1st
respondent, in driving his vehicle bearing No. AP 39 TT 6061?
2. Whether the deceased was aged 45 years, and earned Rs. 30,000/- per
month?
3. Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, for what
amount, and against whom?
4. To what relief?”
7.
On behalf of the Claimants, P.Ws 1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A1
to A5 were marked. On behalf of Respondents, RW-1 was examined and
Ex.B1 was marked.
8.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal partly allowed the claim petition
against Respondent No.2, awarding compensation of Rs.16,45,000/- with
subsequent interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of the petition
till the date of realization and directed Respondent No.2 to deposit the said
amount within a month from the date of the order.
9.
Aggrieved by the said award, the Appellant/ Claimant preferred this
appeal on the ground that the Tribunal failed to appreciate the fact that the
deceased was travelling as gratuitous passenger and was sitting on the
mangoes load on the goods carriage bearing No. AP 39 TT 6061 at the time
of accident and the act of the deceased own negligence resulted his death. As
such, the Tribunal ought to have fixed the liability on the deceased as he
contributing his life in the accident. Considering the negligence on the part of
the deceased, the Tribunal ought to have dismissed the claim petition holding
that the risk is not covered under policy as there was no premium paid as per
policy. The Tribunal while passing the orders beyond the terms and conditions
of the policy and ignored the law that the liability of the insured subject to
terms and conditions of the policy.
10.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the Respondents No.1 to 4
herein has supported the impugned award and prayed to dismiss the appeal.
11.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
POINT:
12.
On perusal of the Award passed by the Tribunal, the Claimant No.1,
who is wife of the deceased got examined herself as PW-1 and also got
examined PW-2, who is an eye witness to the accident. Basing on the report
submitted by PW-2, Ex.A1- FIR was registered. PW-2 categorically stated that
on 31.05.2021 at about 2.20 a.m the Respondent No.1 proceeded in the
offending vehicle with a load of mangoes of the deceased, which was loaded
at Devarapalli Village and deceased was sitting on the mangoes load at the
relevant point of time, coupled with Ex.A1 i.e copy of FIR in Crime No. 52 of
2021 of Ichapuram Police, which was registered basing on the report
submitted by PW-2. Ex.A2 copy of Charge Sheet in C.C.No. 491 of 2021 on
the file of Judicial Magistrate of I Class, Ichapuram, the Tribunal held that the
Respondent No.1 drove the offending vehicle towards the divider, resulting
death of the deceased due to rash and negligent driving of the offending
vehicle.
13.
Coming to the quantum of compensation, the deceased was doing
business and used to earn Rs. 30,000/- per month. However, in the absence
of any documentary evidence adduced by PW-1 to that extent, the Tribunal
holding that the deceased was the owner of the mangoes load, though it is a
seasonal business, fixed the earnings of the deceased notionally at
Rs.10,000/- per month, if same is considered, the annual income would be at
Rs. 1,20,000/- per annum. As the age of the deceased was 45 years as on the
date of accident as per Ex.A4 and Ex.A5, an addition of 25% of the income
was added towards future prospects. If the same is added, his income would
come to Rs. 1,50,000/- per annum (Rs. 1,20,000/- + 30,000/-). There are four
dependants of the deceased, therefore 1/4th was deducted towards personal
expenses, after deducting 1/4th towards personal expenses of the deceased, it
would come to Rs. 1,12,500/- After applying relevant multiplier ‘14’ as per
“Sarla
Verma
and
Others
v.
Delhi
Transport
Corporation
and
Another”1¸loss of dependency is assessed at Rs. 15,75,000/- (Rs.1,12,500/x 14). Apart from the same, the Tribunal also awarded compensation under
conventional heads such as Rs. 15,000/- towards loss of estate; Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses and Rs. 40,000/- towards loss of consortium to the
Claimant No.1 alone. In total compensation 16,45,000/- as awarded by the
Tribunal.
2009(3) ALD 83 (SC)
14.
It is curious to note that the Claimants No. 2 and 3 are the minor
children of the deceased and Claimants No.4 is the mother of the deceased,
who are also entitled to a tune of Rs. 40,000/- each under the head of
consortium. As the Tribunal has failed to award the same, this Court feels it
appropriate to consider the said aspect by awarding Rs. 40,000/- each to the
Petitioners No. 2 to 4. If the same is calculated, the total consortium would be
come to Rs. 1,20,000/- (Rs. 40,000/- x 3) apart from granting consortium to
the Claimant No.1 as Rs. 40,000/-.
15.
As the learned counsel for the Appellant has strongly contended that
the deceased has contributed to the said accident by sitting on the top of
mangoes load and if the deceased was sitting on the cabin in the said vehicle,
he can survive. As such, this Court feels it appropriate to enhance the
compensation under the head of consortium to a tune of Rs. 1,20,000/towards contributory negligence of the deceased.
16.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal under different heads and
the amounts enhanced by this Court, are as follows:S.No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Head of the Claim
Loss of dependency
Loss of estate
Funeral expenses
Loss of consortium
Total
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
15,75,000/15,000/15,000/40,000/16,45,000/-
Amounts now
enhanced by
this Court
15,75,000/15,000/15,000/1,20,000/17,25,000/-
17.
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is
dismissed. However, enhancing the compensation of Rs.17,25,000/- from
Rs.16,45,000/- with interest at 7.5% p.a from the date of filing of the Petition
till the date of realization. The compensation amount shall be apportioned
among the Claimants in the same manner and ratio as ordered by the
Tribunal. There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Date: 06.04.2026
KK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review