Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e1 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERAAAD
TFIURSDAY, THE EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
MACMA Nos.2916 and 3126 OF 2019
Com mon Praver:
Appeal filed Under Section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act,'1988 against the Order
and decree in M.V.O.P.No.1474 of 2014 daled. 03-06-2019 on the file of the Court
of the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-court of the Chief Judge, City
Civil Court, Hyderabad.
MACMA NO: 2916 OF 2019
Between:
1. Gowra Rajani, Wo Late Venkatesh, Aged 35 years, Occ Housewife
2. Gowra Bhanu, D/o Late Venkatesh, Aged 17 years, Occ- StUdent
3. Gowra Pallavi, D/o Late Venkatesh, Aged 13 years, Occ Student,
4. Gowra Kushwanth, S/o Late Venkatesh, Aged 5 years, Occ. Nil, (Petitioners 2
to 4 are minors, Rep. by their mother and natural guardian Petitioner no.1)
5. Gowra Ailaiah, S/o Late Bommaiah (died) Aged 60 Years, Occ. Nil,
6. Gowra Andalu, Wo Ailaiah, Aged 57 years, Occ. Housewife, All are R/o
22-14 Siva Nagar, l.S Sadan, Hyderabad
.. Petitioners/Appellants
AND
M. Abirami, Wo Karthikeyan, Aged. Ivlajor, Occ. Business, R/o 230,
Lingichetty Street Tondiaipet, Fort St. George, Chennai - 600001 .
TATA AIG General lnsurance Company Ltd, Rep. by its Manager, 2nd Flool
Block - A, My Home Tycoon, Green Lands, 99Sqmp9t, ltV^O^"lqPrO - 500016.
( Policy No. 015238092900 Valid from 1 5-3-201 3 to 14-3-2014)
...Respondents/Respondents No.'l & 2
Counsel for the Appellants :SRl E VENUGOPAL REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : SRI T MAHENDER RAO
MACMA NO: 3126 OF 2019
Between:
TATA AIG General lnsurance Company Ltd., rep. by / its /lanager, 2nd Floor,
Block-A, My Home Tycoon, Green Lands, Begumpet, Hyderz cad- 500 016.
...Appell;rr URespondent No.2
AND
'1 Qowra Rajani, Wo. Late Venkatesh, aged 35 years, Ocr:. Housewife,
R/o H.No 22-14, Siva Nagar, l.S. Sada-n, Hydeirabad.
2. Gowra Bhanu, D/o. Late. Venkatesh, aged 12 years, Oc<;. Student, (lVinor),
R/o.H.No 22-14, Siva Nagar, l.S. Sadan,Hydeiabad.
3 Qowra Pallvi, D/o. Late. Venkatesh, aged g years, Occ. lj udent- (Minor),
Rio. H. No.22-1 4, Siva Nagar, l.S. Sadin,Hyrierabid.
4 9gqr.r.[rllwanth, D/o. Late. Venkatesh, aged 1 years, I cc. Nil (Minor),
R/o H No.22-14, Siva Nagar, l.S. Sadan,Hyderabjd.
5 Qowra Aitaiah, S/o. Late Bommaiah (died) aged 65 years;, Occ. Nil,
R/o H.No.22-14, Siva Nagar, l.S. Sadan,Hyd-erabad'
6. Gowra Andalu, Wo. Ailaiah, aged 57 years, Occ. Housew fe, R./o. H. No.22- 14,
Siva Nagar, t.S Sadan,Hydera-bad. (Fiespoirdent Nos. 2 k 4 minors are being
rep. by her Mother and natural guardian, ihe respondent l. c,.1 herein)
...Res p < ndents/Petitioners
7. Itrl Abirami, Wo. Karthikeyan, aged.Major, Occ. Business, l/o. 1130,
Lingichetty Street, Tondiarpet, Fort St. George, Chennai_ ( 00 001.
...Responde n YRespondent No.1
lA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 of cpc praying that in the c:i c:umstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court rray be pleased ro
grant stay of all further proceedings in pursuance of the ara,i rd and the decree
dated 03-06 2019 passed in MVOP No.1474 of 2014 bythe I\4: c,rAr;cident ctaims
Tribunal - cum- the court of the chief Judge, city civir (l rurt at Hyderabad
pending disposal of the above appeal.
Counsel for the Appettant :SRl T MAHENDER RAO
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 to 6 :SRl E VENUGOPAL. IEDDY
The Court delivered the following: Common Judgment
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE WSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.2916 and 3126 of 2OL9
DATE: O8.O1.2O26
M.A.C.M.A.No.29 LG of 2Ol9
\
Between:
Gowra Rajani and five others
... Appellants
And
M. Abirami and another
Respondents
M.A.C.M.A.No .3726 ot 2Ol9
Between:
TATA AIG Genera-l Insurance Company Limited-
Appellan ts
And
Ciowra Raj ani and six others.
..
Respondents
Mr.E. Venugopal Reddy, learned counset appearing for the appellants rn h'lACMA No..2916 ot
2019 and for the respondent Nos.1 to 6 in M.A-C.M.A.No-3126 of 2019
Mr T. Mahender Rao, Iearned counsel appearing for the appellant rn M.ACMANo.3126 of
20lg arrd for the respondent No.2 in M.A.C.M.A.No.2916 of 2019
COMMON JUDGMENT:
I.
(Per Hon'ble Justice Moushumr Bhattacharya)
Mr. T. Mahender Rao, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant in M.A.C.M.A.No.3126 of 2Ol9 and for the respondent
No.2 in M.A.C.M.A.No.2916 of 2Ol9 submits that the disputc
between the parties has been settled by way of a tok Adalat
Award dated l3.Og.2O2S, and therefore nothir g further
survives
for consideration in the present Appeals.
2.
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.2916 and 3126 of 2Ot ), along with
connected applications, are accordingly dispo r:d of
all
in terms of
the Lok Adalat Award dated 13.09.2025. Intr: im orders,
if any,
shall stand vacated. There shall be no order E.r to costs.
SD/- A.V.S. PRASAD
ry'UTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SF f,ION OFFICER
To,
1. The chairman trirotor Accident craims Tribunar-cum-cc rrt of the chief Judge,
Crty Civil Court. Hyderabad(With records. if anv)
2. one CC to SRt E VENUGOPAL REDDY, AOro#t" tCt UCI
3. One CC ro SRt T MAHENDER RAO, Advocate [OpUo
4. Two CD Copies
ADK/PSL
Along with a copr ol'Lok Adalat Award.
Yk
HIGH COURT
DATED:08 t}lt2026
t
COMMON JUDGMENT
MACMA.No.2916 ot 2019
&
MACfUA.No.3126 ot 2019
DISPOSING OF THEIT,IAMCA
lryARD
COSTS
G
,e
tll
$mc
pASsED By
-: ' Hi
o
,J
I Il ,l ltl/l
C'r
.),'
*
' PAl
r i..::
IN TERMI OF THE
iiElox ab.ou, WTHOUT
,.
-ll
'''
a
SER
E
(} LC,K ADALAT
srate o! 1
'.':. : .l.'.
BEFORE THE LOK ADALAT
HICII COURT LEGAL SERVICES COI,TA4ITTEE
FOR THE STATE OF TEI-ANGANA HYDERABAD.
luMer s€ction 19 of the {.egal Services Adhori ties Act, 1987 (Centrat Act)
Date : 13-09-20 25
Present:1r Honlbls Justice G.Sri Deyi,
(Former Ju4i;f High aourt for the State o{ Telengana)
oo HIGH COURT
*
, ,. ..'-:..,
Chairman
2.- Smt. Nandita Guha, Advocate,
*
ember
MACI'IA No.2916 of 2019 an d MACrui No.3126 2Ol9
(Eefore the H on'ble'Hiih Court)
AGAINST
,rt.V.O.P .No 14
(Oo the file of the Motor Accident C taims Tribunat.cuin-
Hyderabad
the Caurt bf the Chiref Judgei City Ciyit Court:
lrtAClv{A.No.291 6 2019
Between:1. Gowr" Rajani, W/o. Late Venkatesh,.Aggd 35 ygars, Oqc:
llcusewife,
2. Gowra Bhanu, D/o. Late Venkatesh, ngla lZ yeqrs,'Oci: Student,
3. Gourra pattarr, D/o. Lare Venkatesh, Agba
Gi: Student.
4. Gowra Kushwanrh, S/o. Late Vgnkatesh, 131eari, O.i: f.fii, lSeOq V"irr;
(Peritioners Z to 4 are minors, Rep- Uy.tfrg!1qo![-e1
A'naturat guqrAian petitioner No. r )
5. Gowra Ailaiah, S/o. Lare tlommaiah (died) Ag 50 years,
Occj--Nit,
.d
6. Gowra ArrCalu, W/o. Aitaiah, Aged 57 years, b..: ff,iusewife, -' ""
At[ are R/o.22-14, Siva Nagar, l.S.Sadan, Hyderabad;.:
. ...petitioners/Appeltants
1. tr4. Aoi.ami, w/o. KarthikeyanlAceq:
j,gilhc:.Business,
'- R/o.230, Linsiche*ystreer,
Tondiarpet, Fort Sr.ceorge, Chennai-600b0i. :
2. TATA AiG General lnsura nce Comp an/ Ltd.; Rep-.by,i
t! l,leniCer 2d Floor, Btock-A,
My Home Tycoon, Green Lands, Begumpgt, Hyd drabad --5@16. ,
(Poticy No.01 523809290, vatid from 15-03-2013
tO ,{4 -03 .mla)
ndents/Responclents 1 & z
lrlACMA.|kr.312 6of 20
Eetween:-
Grnera[ lfisurancr Company Ltd., rep. by tts Managr, 2M
Floor, B{ock_A,
My H,rme Tycoon, Green l.,ands, Begumpet,' nyi*jnua_SOOOt
TATA AIG
.
O.
...AppellanURespondent No. ?,
.1.
Golra Rajani, W/o. Late Venkatesh, ag"#Dvgu^, Oci: flousewife,
-'
2. Gawra Bhanu, D/o. Late Venkaresh, Ag.A fZ
St,ra"rt,
VLu*,'O.i:
3. Gowra pattavi, D/o. Late Venkatesh, agea a yearr.Ocij Student.
4. Gowra Kushwanrh, S/o. Larr: Venkatesi, Ag"il t year, Oci: Nif
iiii*O
(Petitioners 7 to 4 are mino.s, Rep. uy tneir rnother 6
naturat guardian petitione!- No. 1 )
5. Gowra Aitaiah, S/o. Late Bommaiah (died)
{ged 65 years,.Occ: Nil,
6. Gowra Andatu, W/o. Aitaiah, Aged 57 yeais, 6ct, ff6*"*f",
(Respondent Nos.2 to 4 minors aie being rep.
by her mothei and natural guardian,
the Respondent No. _1 herein)
Att ;re R/a.?2-14, siv;r i'rag,rl, I.s.sadan, HycreraL,ad.
...Respondents/petitianers
ilarthiketyan, aged: Major, Occ: tsr.siness, R/o. 230,
-\Vlo. Tondiarp3t,
Lingichetty Street,
Fort St.G€orge, Cnennat_OmOCt.
-7..M.Aoiranri,
Counsel ror the Appe{ranrs/ciaiirants
: sri E.venugop"i ffiffXtai:::',ysPondent l{o'1
cou,ser ror rhe Responrle,lr/,nru.o*e corJilf ,G"#ir:m?,5?*uffi:l:r"..."
!-(efrreseniative of lnsurance rio:Ipany
: Sri N.p: av€en Redcly, Manager
The:e,appeats havirrg treen .eferred for settlement before
this l_ok Adatat and after hearing the
.L.arr-red counsel foi- the partie;
and also ule parties, the fottowing award is passed:
r.. \ ,r.. rfs-U6'
{1
lLr
I
t
AWARD
Compe sation
Awarded
by the Tribunat
Rs.48,96,480 /-(Rupees Forty-eight takh:
ninety-six thousand'",ur,
hundred and eighty onty) together with proportionate
cost; air{i
interest @ 9% per anoum. from the date of c rtition
i. e., O9-d5-2014 t,it
the date of reatization.
Cornpensation
Awqrded .
(Settlement Reached)
in the Lok Adatat.
A4AClv{A No.2916 of
zo 19 has been pret ( rred b y the Petitioners /
Ctaimants and l,lAClrlA No.3126 of 2019 I rs been prefeired
lnsurance Company against the orders pa.;l 1d in OP'No.1474
...-..
by the Tribunat.
by the
of 2014
The Appettant/Petitioner/Ctaimant Nos.1 t 4 and 6 along
with th6ir
'
counse[ and Sri N.praveen Redcll
./vlanager
_
: for _ the
Appettant/Respondent No.2-lnsuilnce Corr rany have appeared
and
identified before the Lok Adatat. lt is st rted that the
Appettant/
Petitioner/Ctaimant No.5 died. During the endency of 'both Appeals,
the Appellants/Petitioners/Claimants all, Resprindents-lnsurance
Company represented that they have
compromise and settted the matter. ln pu suance of the same, the
SEB
{{toltcouRT
,LOKAOAIlT
mutuatty entered into
Appetlants/Petitioners/Ctaimants have agr e :d to receive an amount
of Rs.34,00,000/- (Rupees Thirty-four taklr: onty) in addition to the
--{
:-r
amount already deposited by the lnsurance
*
finaI settlement of their ctaim and the lnsur nce Company has agreed
|n
ot 1
ompany towards fu[[ arnd
to pay the same towards fu([ and finat ittiement of the claim..
s
Accordingty, compromise is recorded and tl- : Award is passed before
the Lok Adatat.
ln view of the settlement, the lnsurance Con pany shatl pay the above
said amount within a period of six (5) weels from the date of receipt
of copy of this award after deducting the atr )unt that was deposited,
in any. ln the event of default or detay in laking suth deposit; the
amount payable shalt carry interest @ 9% I ,r-annum as awarded by
the Tribunat.
Apportioiment of
Compensation, if any
The apporti onment among the Appettants/f < titioneis/Ctaimants shatt
be made as per the apportionment deterr ined by the Tribunat in
M.V.O.P.No. 1474 of 701 4.
Additional Direction (s):
1. The Appetlants are entitted to the refund of Court Fee paid in the:;< appeats
2-The amount atready deposited by the lnsurance company if any, she t be given credit to.
3.soon after deposit by the lnsurance Company, the major Appett,r t/peiitioner/ctaimant
Nos.1 & 6 are permitted to withdraw their entiie share amounis anc he shares
of the minor
Petitioner/claimant Nos.z to 4 shatt be kept in iixed deposit in ar) Nationatized 'Bank titt
they attain majority, as per the orders and apportionmeni mace by i re Tribunal.
ln token of consent for the above setttement and award, the partie; rnd their counsel
have
signed this award in our presence.
ln terms of the compromise arrived at between the Da rties, these I AClvlA No.
91 of
and lvlACL,lA No.3126 of 2019 stand disoosed of.
( .N\
i
@
s^^i""t
|\r,iq e I-," nr
I
i
\
i;i,
'. -l
*tl
j
L\l{ i 't
I1-.
1, '!l!it * i ii(i
Appellant (s)
G Rkln r
ffiw
i*["r, !
G.a+rauiffi*' ^')
&
In
i
ia
IN
HYOEflTAA}16
.\b\*'9-'Qu
ir
o
i
:
I
*
I
i
'RrI-o
?d
.
I
.Urr"
t
Adn 6z-+LS==l>o
@_
)
SE8
tY'iJ-z
u
Chairman
ndent s
counsel for Res
couhsel ior lPPellant (s)
oo HIGH COURT
I
o LOK AO
d
t
or
Member
--t
i
t
lraro qt 1
(Seal of the Committee)
..CERTIFIED
TO BE TRLq* C*FY"
Tr'-'\"--'-
Deputy Administrative Off icer
High 0ourt Legal Servlces Corrrriiiee
'[eiangaire
For the State of
High Court Buildings, ilyiiiabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review