Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 27-07-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. ANAND VENKATESH
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
AND
CMP Nos.20130, 20136, 20152, 23621, 23624 of 2018,
CMP Nos. 8, 19, 290, 294 & 6400 OF 2019
CMA No.1865 of 2019
Tata AIG General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Corporation Office, Ahura Centre, 4th Floor, 82,
Mahakali Caves Road,
Andheri (E), Mumbai.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. P. Loganathan
2. Saju Muthew
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 2663 of 2018
Tata AIG General Insurance Co Ltd
Corporation Office. Ahura Centre,
4th Floor, 82, Mahakali Caves Road,
Andheri (E), Mumbai.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. M.Deepa
2. Saju Mathew
3. P.Loganathan
4. The National Insurance Company Limited,
Div.No.10 Flat No.101-16, N-1,
B.M.C.House, Connaught Place,
New Delhi-110001.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
..Respondent(s)
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
CMA No. 2664 of 2018
Tata AIG General Insurance Co Ltd
Corporation Office. Ahura Centre,
4th Floor, 82 Mahakali Caves Road,
Andheri (E), Mumbai – 400 093.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. L.Arunchandar
2. Saju Mathew
3. P.Loganathan
4. The National Insurance Company Limited,
Div.No.10, Flat No.101-16,
N-1, B.M.C.House,
Connaught Place, New Delhi-110001.
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 2669 of 2018
Tata AIG General Insurance Co Ltd
Corporation Office. Ahura Centre,
4th Floor, 82 Mahakali Caves Road,
Andheri (E), Mumbai – 400 093
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. L.Sumathi
2. Saju Mathew
3. P.Loganathan
4. The National Insurance Company Limited
Div.No.10 Flat No.101-16,
N-1, B.M.C.House,
Connaught Place,
New Delhi – 110 001.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
..Respondent(s)
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
Prayer in CMA Nos.1865 of 2019: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, to set aside the decree and
judgment dated 07.03.2018, made in MCOP No.604 of 2009, on the file of
MACT (Sub Court) Sangagiri.
Prayer in CMA No.2663 of 2018, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, to set aside the decree and
judgment dated 20.12.2017 made in MCOP No.594 of 2009 on the file of
MACT (Sub Court), Sangagiri.
Prayer in CMA No.2664 of 2018, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, to set aside the decree and
judgment dated 20.12.2017 made in MCOP No.593 of 2009 on the file of
MACT (Sub Court), Sangagiri.
Prayer in CMA No.2669 of 2018, Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, to set aside the decree and
judgment dated 20.12.2017 made in MCOP No.595 of 2009 on the file of
MACT (Sub Court), Sangagiri.
IN CMA No.1865 of 2019,
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr.K.Vinod
Mr.Anothil Kumaran for R1
IN CMA Nos.2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018,
For Appellant(s) :
Mr.K.Vinod
For Respondent(s) :
Mr.A.Sundaravadhanam for R1
Mr.D.Bhaskaran for R4
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
COMMON JUDGMENT
These appeals arise out of the common award passed in MCOP Nos.593
to 595 of 2009 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Sub Court),
Sangagiri dated 20.12.2017 and the award passed in MCOP No.604 of 2009, on
the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Sub Court), Sangagiri, dated
07.03.2018 respectively.
2.
The case of the injured/claimants is that on 29.04.2009, the claimant
in MCOP No.604 of 2009 was driving a Maruthi Swift car, in which the
claimants in MCOP Nos.593 to 595 of 2009 were travelling as occupants. They
were proceeding towards Coimbatore to attend a function. According to the
claimants, there was a traffic diversion near Chengapalli due to road work and
hence, the vehicles were diverted onto a single lane. When the Maruthi Swift
car was coming near the Palanigoundampalayam Pirivu Road, the offending
vehicle, which was a TATA Indica car, coming from the opposite direction in a
rash and negligent manner, collided with it. This accident resulted in the death
of three occupants and two persons sustained injuries in the TATA Indica car
and all the four occupants of the Maruti Swift car sustained injuries.
Consequently, a First Information Report came to be registered in Crime
No.147 of 2009 against the claimant in MCOP 604 of 2009 who is the driver of
the Maruti Swift car, before the Uthukulli Police Station. It is under these
circumstances, the claim petitions came to be filed before the Tribunal.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
3.
The appellant/TATA AIG General Insurance Company filed a
counter and took a stand that the accident had taken place only due to the rash
and negligent driving of the Maruti Swift car by the said Loganathan and
therefore, denied its liability to pay compensation.
4.
The Tribunal, on considering the facts and circumstances of the case
and on appreciating the oral and documentary evidence, came to a conclusion
that there was 70% negligence on the part of the driver of the TATA Indica car
and 30% negligence on the part of the driver of the Maruti Swift car.
5.
Having rendered the above finding, the Tribunal proceeded to fix
the total compensation at Rs.15,80,000/- in MCOP No.593 of 2009,
Rs.14,56,000/- in MCOP No.594 of 2009, and Rs.15,05,000/-
in MCOP
No.595 of 2009. Insofar as MCOP No.604 of 2009 is concerned, the Tribunal
fixed the total compensation at Rs.11,15,000/-.
6.
Insofar as the compensation fixed under MCOP Nos.593 to 595 of
2009 is concerned, 70% of the compensation was directed to be paid by the
appellant/TATA AIG General Insurance Company and 30% of the
compensation was directed to be paid by the National Insurance Company,
along with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum. Insofar as MCOP No.604 of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
2009 is concerned, the appellant/TATA AIG General Insurance Company was
directed to pay 70% of the compensation amount, along with interest at 7.5%
per annum. Aggrieved by the same, these four appeals have been filed by the
TATA AIG General Insurance Company.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant/ TATA AIG General Insurance
Company submitted that in the present case, the entire negligence has to be
attributed only against Loganathan, who is the driver of the Maruthi Swift car.
He further submitted that the FIR itself was registered against the said
Loganathan. It was further submitted that the legal representatives of the three
deceased persons and the two injured occupants travelling in the TATA Indica
car had filed five claim petitions before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
(MACT), Pune. In those claim petitions, both Loganthan as well as the National
Insurance Company were impleaded as respondents. The MACT, Pune, on
appreciation of evidence, came to a conclusion that the entire negligence was
attributable against Loganathan. Consequently, the compensation that was fixed
by the MACT, Pune in all five claim petitions was directed to be paid by the
National Insurance Company.
8.
The learned counsel, on instructions, submitted that the award
passed by the MACT, Pune has become final. Hence, it is contended that for the
very same accident, there cannot be two divergent opinions, insofar as the issue
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
of negligence is concerned. Since the award passed by MACT, Pune has
become final, it must be held in all these appeals that the negligence lies entirely
on the part of Loganathan, who was the driver of the Maruthi Swift Car and
therefore, the appellant/TATA AIG General Insurance Company must be
exonerated from the liability.
9.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the claimants
and the learned counsel appearing for the National Insurance Company
submitted that the Tribunal, in this case, had independently applied its mind to
the evidence and reached a conclusion that there was 70% negligence on the
part of the driver of the TATA Indica Car and 30% negligence on the part of the
driver of the Maruthi Swift Car. They further submitted that the award passed
by the MACT, Pune, was not brought to the notice of the Tribunal and that
apart, no contra evidence was let in on the side of the appellant/TATA AIG
General Insurance Company. Therefore, it is contended that the award passed
by the Tribunal in fixing the negligence is based on a proper appreciation of
evidence and it does not warrant any interference of this Court.
10.
Insofar as the quantum of compensation fixed by the Tribunal is
concerned, it is submitted on the side of the claimants that the same is
reasonable and does not require the interference of this Court.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
11.
This Court heard the learned counsel appearing on either side,
carefully considered the materials available on record and went through the
awards passed by the Tribunal.
12.
In the case in hand, this Court is now dragged into a very difficult
situation where, for the very same accident, the MACT, Pune has rendered a
finding to the effect that the entire negligence is on the driver of the Maruthi
Swift car, whereas, the MACT, Sangagiri has rendered a finding that 70%
negligence is attributable against the driver of the TATA Indica Car and 30%
negligence is attributable against the driver of the Maruthi Swift Car.
13.
The fault lies not only with the appellant/TATA AIG General
Insurance Company but with Loganathan, the driver of the Maruthi Swift Car
and the National Insurance Company, who have all failed to bring to the notice
of the MACT, Sangagiri, about the award passed by the MACT, Pune.
Admittedly, Loganthan and the National Insurance Company were respondents
in all the five claim petitions filed before the MACT, Pune, where, they
conveniently remained ex parte and nothing was revealed to the MACT,
Sangagri regarding the award passed by MACT, Pune. The appellant/TATA
AIG General Insurance Company must also take the blame for not having
brought to the notice of the MACT, Sangagiri about the award passed by the
MACT, Pune.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
14.
For the first time in this appeal, the appellant/TATA AIG General
Insurance Company has brought to the notice of this Court about the award
passed by the MACT, Pune.
15.
The version regarding the manner in which the accident had taken
place was different from how it was projected before the MACT, Pune and
before the MACT, Sangagiri. Insofar as the MACT, Pune is concerned, the
claimants therein projected a case as if the Maruthi Swift Car was driven in a
rash and negligent manner, entered on a one way road and dashed against the
TATA Indica Car. Before the MACT, Sangagiri, the version that was given is
that some road repair work was going on and as a result, the Maruthi Swift car
was diverted to the other side, where the TATA Indica car was coming in the
opposite direction and without noticing the diversion, was driven in a rash and
negligent manner and dashed against the Maruti Swift Car.
16.
Both Tribunals did not have an opportunity to deal with these
opposing projections regarding the manner in which the accident took place and
instead, each Tribunal decided the case based on one of the projection that was
made by the claimants in their respective set of claim petitions. Therefore,
strictly speaking, the finding of the MACT, Pune, will not have a direct impact
before the MACT, Sangagiri, since the latter Tribunal analysed the facts from
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
the point of view of the case that was projected by the claimants before it to the
effect that there was a traffic diversion due to road repair, which forced the
driver of the Maruthi Swift Car to drive into the lane where the TATA Indica
Car was coming in the opposite direction. Unfortunately, no contra evidence
was let in on the side of the appellant/TATA AIG General Insurance Company
and the award passed by the MACT, Pune, never surfaced before the MACT,
Sangagiri.
17.
In view of the same, on considering the evidence and taking note of
the award passed by the MACT, Pune, this Court is inclined to render a finding
to the effect that there was 50% negligence on the part of the driver of the
TATA Indica Car and 50% negligence on the part of the driver of the Maruthi
Swift Car. This finding will sufficiently balance the rights of both parties and
strike a balance between the contradictory findings rendered by the MACT,
Pune and the MACT, Sangagiri.
18.
The above finding rendered by this Court will also not revive any
further developments in the award passed by MACT, Pune. Since that award
was passed in the year 2014 and almost 12 years have gone by and there is no
material on record to show that an appeal was filed by the National Insurance
Company against such award, this Court has to proceed further on the
presumption that the award passed by the MACT, Pune has became final.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
19.
Insofar as the quantum of compensation is concerned, this Court
finds the same to be just, fair and reasonable, warranting no interference.
20.
Insofar as CMA Nos.2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018 are concerned,
the compensation amount, along with accrued interest, shall be paid to the
extent of 50% by the appellant/TATA AIG Insurance Company and 50% by the
fourth respondent/National Insurance Company along with accrued interest.
21.
Insofar as CMA No.1865 of 2019 is concerned, the first
respondent/claimant therein will be entitled to receive only 50% of the
compensation amount along with interest, which shall be payable by the
appellant/ TATA AIG General Insurance Company.
22.
In the result, these Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are partly allowed.
The TATA AIG General Insurance Company and the National Insurance
Company, are directed to deposit their respective shares of the compensation,
less the amount already deposited, together with interest at the rate of 7.5% p.a.
from the date of claim petitions till the date of deposit, within a period of four
(4) weeks from the date of receipt of this judgment. On such deposit, the
claimants are entitled to withdraw the compensation amount along with interest,
on due application. The other directions issued by the Tribunal with regard to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
the mode of payment of compensation remains unaltered. No costs.
Consequently, the connected miscellaneous petitions are closed.
27-07-2026
ham
To
1.
The Subordinate Judge,
Sub Court,
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal,
Sangagiri.
2.
The Section Officer,
VR Section,
High Court of Madras.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
N.ANAND VENKATESH J.
ham
CMA Nos.1865 of 2019, 2663, 2664 & 2669 of 2018
AND
CMP Nos.20130, 20136, 20152, 23621, 23624 of 2018,
CMP Nos. 8, 19, 290, 294 & 6400 OF 2019
27-07-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review