Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/20
GAHC040002022020
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/75/2020
TASING SINGKOM
S/O LT. TALO SINGKOM, VILLAGE RAVA, C/O PRINCIPAL GOVT HIGHER
SECONDARY SCHOOL, HAYULIANG, PO/PS HAYULIANG, ANJAW DISTT,
AP
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and 4 Ors.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY EDUCATION, GOVT OF AP, ITANAGAR
2:THE COMMISSIONER
EDUCATION
Age: 0
Occupation :
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
3:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY SCHOOL EDUCATION
Age: 0
Occupation :
GOVT OF AP
ITANAGAR
4:Tatin Mindo
Age: 0
Occupation :
ST (Biology)
C/o Principal
Govt. Higher Secondary School Mebo
East Siang District Arunachal Pradesh.
5:Tam Tapa
Age: 0
Page No.# 2/20
Occupation :
ST
(Biology)
C/o Principal Govt. Higher Secondary School
Seppa
East Kameng
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Khoda Tari, Pekyum Tamin,1 H Gyati,T J Dogum
Advocate for the Respondent : Tagum Jamoh, T Loma,Teshi Aaku,N Kanu,T Rahul,P Tatam,N
Kuma,N Rama,Taba Tagum,SC (Education),Marto Kato,Nyali Sora,Peli Ete,M Tanga,T. Deliyang
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 07.08.2026
Heard Mr. K. Tari, learned counsel, appearing for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. T. Tagum, learned Standing
Counsel,
Education
Department,
appearing
for
the
Respondent Nos.1, 2 and 3; Mr. M. Kato, learned counsel,
appearing for the Respondent No.4; and Mr. Ita Techi,
learned counsel, appearing for the Respondent no.5.
2.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has
prayed
for
a
direction
upon
the
Respondent
Authorities,more particularly the Respondent no.3, for
consideration of his case for promotion to the cadre of Post
Page No.# 3/20
Graduate Teacher (PGT), with retrospective effect i.e. w.e.f.
the
date
his
juniors
were
so
promoted
with
all
consequential reliefs.
3.
The facts in brief requisite for adjudication of the
issue arising in the present writ petition is noticed, as
under;
The petitioner, herein, was appointed as a Junior
Teacher
and
was
so
posted
at
Government
Higher
Secondary School, Daporijo, vide an order dated 22-062009. The next promotional avenue of a Junior Teacher,
having the requisite educational qualification, is to the post
of Post Graduate Teacher(PGT). The promotions to the Post
Graduate Teacher/Senior Teacher
is governed by
the
provisions of the “Senior Teacher Recruitment Rules, 2008”,
as amended.In terms of the said Rules, 50% of the post in
the cadre of Senior Teacher is to be so recruited from
Trained Graduate Teachers (TGT) and the remaining 50% is
to be so recruited by way of direct recruitment. In terms of
the provisions of the said Rule, a Trained Graduate Teacher
(TGT) is required to possess a 2 ndclass Master Degree in
Page No.# 4/20
the concerned subject from a recognized university along
with a B.Ed. Degree for being eligible for promotion to the
cadre of Post Graduate Teacher (PGT). The petitioner
projects that he was a Master Degree holder and had
acquired his B.Ed. Degree in the year 2010 and was
accordingly eligible for promotion to the cadre of Senior
Teacher/PGT,in terms of the provisions of the said Rules of
2008, as amended. It is projected that the Respondent
Nos.4 and 5, were also appointed as a Junior Teacher vide
order dated 22-06-2009.The petitioner projects that in the
year 2011, although he was eligible in terms of the
provisions of the Rules of 2008, as amended, for promotion
to the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher (PGT), his case was
not considered and the Respondent No.4 was promoted
from the cadre of Junior Teacherto that of Post Graduate
Teacher. It is further submitted that the Respondent No.5,
was also so considered in the year 2014, for promotion to
the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher and he was promoted
vide order dated 07-10-2014. However, the petitioner's
case for such promotion was not again considered by the
Page No.# 5/20
Respondent Authorities.
The petitioner being aggrieved by the denial of promotion
to him, had approached the Respondent Authorities by way
of preferring representations, praying for his retrospective
promotion. The representation submitted by the petitioner
not being considered, the petitioner had approached this
Court
by
way
of
instituting
a
writ
petition
being
WP(C).No.193 (AP)/2018. A Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court vide an order dated 27-04-2018, proceeded to
dispose of the said writ petition by directing that the
representations
dated
05-02-2013
and
28-04-2015,
preferred by the petitioner be considered in terms of the
relevant Rules, within a period of 02 (two) months.
The petitioner thereafter, was considered by the constituted
Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC)and in terms of
the recommendations made in his case, the petitioner was
promoted vide an order dated 04-12-2018, to the cadre of
Post Graduate Teacher (Biology). However, the petitioner
was so promoted prospectively.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present
Page No.# 6/20
writ petition.
4.
Mr. K. Tari,learned counsel for the petitioner, has
submitted
that
the
representations
dated
petitioner
had
05-02-2013
preferred
and
the
28-04-2015,
praying for his retrospective promotion w.e.f. the date his
juniors i.e. the Respondent Nos.4 and 5, were promoted to
the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher. However, the said
representations
preferred
by
the
petitioner
were
not
considered by the Respondent Authorities and he was
promoted
vide
the
order
dated
04-12-2018,
only
prospectively. By referring to the affidavit filed by the
Respondent No.1, the learned counselfor the petitioner has
submitted that a perusal of the said affidavit would go to
reveal that it is the stand of the Respondent Authorities
that the petitioner,herein, had not furnished his B.Ed. marksheets and certificates, before 2012 and/or before 2014
when the Respondent Nos.4 and 5, were so promoted to
the cadre of PGT.
4.1.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner had acquired his B.Ed. Degree certificate in
Page No.# 7/20
the year 2010 and had promptly furnished the mark-sheets
and the certificates, thereof, to the Respondent Authorities.
He submits that his case not being considered in the year
2011, along with the Respondent No.4, a fresh D.P.C. being
contemplated, the petitioner had again forwarded his
B.Ed.Degree marksheets as well as all his B.Ed. certificates
vide a communication dated 05-02-2013 through the
Principal of the school, he was working in. He submits that
the
respondents
have
projected
that
the
said
communication was received by the Respondent Authorities
only on 20-04-2015.
4.2.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits
that on the date when the Respondent No.4, was promoted,
the petitioner had acquired the requisite eligibility criteria
for being promoted to the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher
and accordingly, non-consideration of his case for such
promotion had violated his fundamental rights. The learned
counsel for the petitioner has further submitted that even
when
the
Respondent
No.5,
was
so
considered
for
promotion to the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher, the case
Page No.# 8/20
of
the
petitioner
was
not
considered,
although
the
petitioner fulfilled all the requisite eligibility criteria as
mandated in the said Rules of 2008, as amended.
4.3.
Mr. K. Tari, learned counsel for the petitioner,
accordingly, has submitted that the non-consideration of
the case of the petitioner had caused prejudice to his
service interest and accordingly, a direction is called upon
to be issued to the Respondent Authorities to convene a
review meeting of the Departmental Promotion Committee,
for consideration of the case of the petitioner w.e.f. the
date
when
such
consideration
was
extended
to
the
Respondent Nos.4 and 5.
5.
Per
contraMr.
T.
Tagum,
learned
Standing
Counsel, Education Department, has submitted that when
the case of the Respondent No.4 was so considered in the
year 2011, although it is projected that the petitioner had
acquired his B.Ed. Degree in the year 2010, the particulars,
thereof, was never forwarded by the petitioner and/or the
school authorities of the school, wherein, the petitioner was
so serving to the Department. Accordingly, the petitioner
Page No.# 9/20
being found to have not acquired the requisite eligibility
criteria in terms of the provisions of the Rules of 2008, as
amended, the case of the petitioner was not so considered.
Mr. T. Tagum,submits that although the petitioner has
projected
that
Degreecertificates
he
and
had
forwarded
other
his
B.Ed.
particulars
videa
communication dated 05-02-2013, the said communication
was in fact found to have been received by the Director of
the Secondary Education Department, only on 20-04-2015
and accordingly, the case of the petitioner was not
permissible to be so considered when the case of the
Respondent No.5, was considered for promotion to the
cadre ofPost Graduate Teacher.
5.1.
Mr. T. Tagum, further submits that although the
case of the petitioner was considered by the DPC in its
meeting held on 16-05-2017, the petitioner not having
submitted his vigilance clearance certificate, which is a
mandatory document for consideration of a case of an
employee for promotion to the higher post, the name of the
petitioner came to be placed in the waiting list at serial
Page No.# 10/20
no.2. The said waiting list having lapsed, the case of the
petitioner for promotion to the post of Post Graduate
Teacher, could not be considered. It is submitted that
thereafter, on a due consideration of the case of the
petitioner
by
the
Departmental
Promotion
Committee
(DPC), a recommendation being made in his favour, the
petitioner came to be promoted vide an order dated 04-122018, to the cadre of PGT, albeit prospectively. Mr. T.
Tagum,submits that the petitioner at this point of time
cannot be permitted to assail the promotion effected in
respect of the Respondent Nos.4 and 5, more particularly,
when the case of the petitioner was not so considered at
that relevant point of time only in view of the fact that the
petitioner had not furnished the requisite documents.
6.
Mr. M. Kato, learned counsel, appearing for the
Respondent No.4, has submitted that the Respondent No.4
in pursuance to the promotion effected in his case in the
year 2012, having continued against the said post and
there being no challenge to the said promotion till the
institution of the present writ petition in the year 2020, the
Page No.# 11/20
promotion effected in respect of the Respondent No.11,
would not mandate an interference from this Court. He
however, submits that in the event, without disturbing the
case of the Respondent No.4, the case of the petitioner is
directed to be considered by this Court, he would have no
objection for the same.
7.
Mr. Ita Techi, learned counsel, appearing for the
Respondent no.5, has adopted the arguments of the
learned counsel for the Respondent No.4 and has submitted
that in the event, this Court directs for a consideration of
the case of the petitioner for promotion with retrospective
effect, however without effecting the promotion effected in
respect of the Respondent No.5, he would have no
grievance with regard to the same.
8.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties
and perused the materials available on record.
9.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has
prayedfor a direction for promoting him to the cadre of Post
Graduate Teacher, with retrospective effect i.e.w.e.f. the
date his juniors more particularly the Respondent Nos.4
Page No.# 12/20
and 5 were so promoted. The promotion to the cadre of
Post Graduate Teacher is governed by the provisions of the
Senior Teacher Recruitment Rules, 2008, as amended. In
terms of the said Rules a Junior Teacher possessing a 2 nd
class Master Degree in the concerned subject from a
recognized university along with a B.Ed. Degree, is entitled
to have his case considered for promotion to the cadre of
Post Graduate Teacher. The said Rules further stipulate that
the posts in the cadre of PGT, shall be so filled up by way of
direct recruitment to the extent of 50% of the posts and
the remaining 50% of the posts would be so filled up by
way of promotion from Trained Graduate Teachers by
applying the criteria of “Seniority-cum-Merit”.
10.
The petitioner in the present writ petition has
projected that on the promotions being effected in respect
of
his
juniors,
he
had
approached
the
Respondent
Authorities for consideration of his case, for promotion with
retrospective effect, to the cadre of Post Graduate Teacher.
The representations preferred by the petitioner not having
been considered, the petitioner had approached this Court
Page No.# 13/20
by way of instituting a writ petition being WP(C).No.193
(AP)/2018.
11.
A Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated
27-04-2018, by appreciating the submissions of the learned
for the petitioner,that the petitioner was senior to the
Respondent Nos.4 and 5, herein, (who were also impleaded
as a Respondent Nos.4 and 5 in the above noted petition),
had proceeded to dispose of the said writ petition by
directing for disposal of the representations preferred by
the petitioner in the matter. Thereafter, the Respondent
Authorities had placed the case of the petitioner before the
Departmental Promotion Committee. The Departmental
Promotion Committee in its meeting held on 05-07-2018,
on a consideration of the case of the petitioner, had
proceeded to observe that the petitioner had submitted his
B.Ed Degree certificates and other testimonials along with a
forwarding
letter
from
the
Principal
only
on
05-02-
2013.However, the same was found to have been received
in the erstwhile Directorate of Secondary Education only on
20-04-2015,
after
the
meeting
of
the
DPC
was
so
Page No.# 14/20
convened. It was further observed that the name of the
petitioner was also considered by the DPC in its meeting
held on 16-05-2017. However, a recommendation was not
made in favour of the petitioner on the ground that he had
not submitted the vigilance clearance certificate. Basing on
the said conclusions and on a consideration of the matter, it
is seen that the petitioner was finally recommended for
promotion and accordingly,vide order dated 04-12-2018,
the petitioner came to be promoted to the cadre of Post
Graduate Teacher,however, with prospective effect. The
petitioner in the present writ petition has made categorical
assertion to the effect that he had submitted his B.Ed.
certificatesimmediately on acquiring the said qualification
and further, the said certificate along with other relevant
documents were submitted vide a communication dated 1905-2011 to the Directorate of Secondary Education. It is
submitted that the projection made by the respondents of
having received the said communication only in the year
2015, to be perverse.
12.
Be that as it may, this Court on a consideration of
Page No.# 15/20
the materials coming on record and by reckoning the fact
that the petitioner had the requisite qualifications as of
2011, and also as of 2015, when the Respondent Nos.4 and
5, were so promoted to the cadre of PGT, this Court is of
the considered opinion that a due consideration to the case
of the petitioner for promotion to the cadre of Post
Graduate Teacher was not extended to him by the
Respondent Authorities.
13.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court
would also notice that from the materials brought on
record, this Court is not in a position to determine the inter
seseniority between the petitioner and the Respondent
Nos.4 and 5, in the cadre of Junior Teacher, after they were
so appointed vide appointment orders all dated 22-062009. The learned counsel for the petitioner in this
connection has submitted that the petitioner had sought for
the gradation list of Junior Teachers, however, the same
was not furnished to him.
14.
In view of the above position and this Court having
already concluded that the petitioner was not extended
Page No.# 16/20
with a due consideration of his case for promotion to the
cadre of PGT, when such consideration was extended to the
Respondent Nos.4 and 5, this Court proceeds to pass the
following directions.
(i) The Respondent Authorities are now required to
convene a review meeting of the DPC, which was so
convened in the year 2011, leading to the promotion of
the Respondent No.4, to the cadre of Post Graduate
Teacher, vide the order dated 05-12- 2011.
(ii) The review DPC shall consider the B.Ed. Degree
qualification of the petitioner and if the projection made
by the petitioner that the said qualification was so
acquired by him in the year 2010, proceed to hold that
the petitioner had the requisite eligibility criteria for
being considered for promotion to the cadre of Post
Graduate Teacher. The review DPC, shall thereafter,
determine the seniority position of the petitioner in the
cadre of Junior Teacher in relation to the seniority
position assigned to the Respondent Nos.4 and 5.
(iii) In the event, it is found that the petitioner was
Page No.# 17/20
placed above the Respondent No.4 in the seniority list,
the review DPC shall,consider the case of the petitioner
in accordance with the Rules holding the field and
recommend his name for such promotion w.e.f. the date
the Respondent No.4, was so promoted.
(iv) In the event, the DPC finds that the Respondent
No.4,herein, was placed above the petitioner in the
seniority list of the cadre of Junior Teachers, the DPC
shall consider the case of the petitioner as to whether he
was also eligible for being promoted to the cadre of Post
Graduate
Teacher
w.e.f.
and
make
recommendation accordingly in this connection.
(v) In the event, the review DPC on complying with the
directions at(i) and (ii) above, finds that the petitioner is
not entitled to be promoted to the cadre of PGT w.e.f.
2011, the Departmental Authorities, would now convene
a review meeting of the DPC held on 25-08-2014,
pursuant to which the Respondent No.5, was promoted
to the cadre of PGTvide an order dated 07-10-2014.
(vi) The review DPC shall again ascertain the seniority
Page No.# 18/20
position of the petitioner vis-à-vis the Respondent No.5
in the cadre of a Junior Teacher and thereafter, in the
event the petitioner is found to be senior to the
Respondent No.5, shall by deeming that the petitioner
was eligible for promotion to the cadre of PGT, proceed
to consider his case for such promotion by applying the
criteria
ofseniority-cum-merit
and
make
its
recommendations in the matter. Such consideration be
also extended
to the petitioner, if he is found to be
eligible for such promotion,although was found to be
junior to the Respondent no.5, in the cadre of Junior
Teacher.
(vii) The recommendations of the review DPC being
received, in the event, the petitioner is found to be so
entitled for promotion either w.e.f. 2011 i.e. from the
date the Respondent No.4, was so promoted and/or
from the year 2014, when the Respondent No.5, was so
promoted, the Respondent Authorities, shall proceed to
grant retrospective effect to the promotion granted to
the petitioner vide order dated 04-12-2018 to the post
Page No.# 19/20
of PGT and make the same effective either w.e.f. from
2011 and/or 2014, as the case may be. However, while
promoting the petitioner with retrospective effect, the
promotion effected in case of the respondent nos.4 and
5, shall not be disturbed in any manner.
(viii) The petitioner on being granted retrospective
promotion either w.e.f. 2011 and/or 2014, shall not be
entitled to draw his salaries in the cadre of Post
Graduate Teacher w.e.f. the date the retrospective effect
has now been granted to his promotion to the cadre of
Post Graduate Teacher.The salaries of the petitioner
w.e.f. the retrospective date of promotion now granted
to him, shall be so fixed notionally till 04-12-2018.The
petitioner would be entitled to receive his arrear
salaries, upon such notional fixation,only w.e.f.04-122018.
(ix) The exercise now required to be initiated for
complying with the directions passed, hereinabove, be
initiated and concluded with the release of the arrear
salaries to the petitioner, if any, within a period of 04
Page No.# 20/20
(four) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
15.
With the above observations and directions, the
present writ petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review