Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.33
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No.233 of 2023
Date of Decision :23.04.2024
Shri. Taseng S. Sangma,
S/O Late Janga M. Marak,
R/O Modynagar PO & PS , Tura
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
…Writ Petitioner
-Vs1.
Garo Hills Autonomous District Council,
represented by its Secretary,
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
2.
Chief Executive Member,
Garo Hills District Council,
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
3.
Deputy Chief Executive Member,
Garo Hills District Council,
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
4.
Executive Member, Land and Revenue,
Garo Hills Autonomous District Council,
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya.
5.
Shri. Tawe S. Sangma,
S/O Late Kanjing Ch Marak,
R/O Okkapara Songgitcham
PO Melllim, PS Damalgre South West
Garo Hills.
6.
Smti. Noballin S. Sangma,
W/o Shri. Ellingstone Marak,
R/O Okkapara Songgitcham
PO Mellim, PS Damalgre South West
Garo Hills.
7.
Shri. Ellingstone Ch Marak,
R/O Okkapara Songgitcham
PO Mellim, PS Damalgre South West
Garo Hills.
…Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. H.L.Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E.Wanniang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.Deb, Adv. for R 1-4.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. for R 5-7.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. H.L.Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Ms.
E.Wanniang, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. S.Deb, learned counsel
for the respondent Nos. 1-4, as also Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos. 5-7.
2.
The writ petitioner has sought to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this
Court to question the appointment of respondent Nos. 6 and 7 as Nokmas
of Okkapara Songgitcham A’khing, Damalgre, South West Garo Hills,
only on one ground that the complaint filed by him against the said
appointment was not dealt with by the respondent Nos. 2 & 3 in a correct
manner, and that the same was disposed of without adhering to the
principles as enunciated in the judgment of Smti. Dore Sangma & Ors. vs.
Chief Executive Member, Garo Hills Autonomous District Council and
other connected matters, which is reported in 1988 (2 GLR) 120.
3.
A perusal of the impugned orders dated 21-04-2022, passed by the
Deputy Chief Executive Member, I/C Land and Revenue, GHADC, Tura,
and the Appellate order therefrom dated 28-06-2023, passed by the Chief
Executive Member, GHADC, Tura, it is seen that the writ petitioner had
objected to the appointment of respondent Nos. 6 and 7, after some initial
objectors had withdrawn their objections and complaints, and also after an
enquiry had been gone into by the Revenue authorities with regard to the
application for appointment to the office of Nokmas of the respondent Nos.
6 and 7. The order dated 21-04-2022, is reproduced herein below:
“IN THE COURT OF DEPUTY CHIEF EXECUTIVE
MEMBER
I/C LAND REVENUE, GHADC, TURA.
No. GHADC-Rev/3 A.C. of 2020/
Dated: Tura, the 21st April, 2022
…Petitioner
Tawe S. Sangma
Vs.
Shri. Taseng S. Sangma
…Objector
ORDER
C.R. Put up today
Seen the application filed by Shri. Tawe. S.
Sangma to register Nokmaship of the Okkapara
Songgitcham 11-19 (30) A’king, and also perused the
spot inquiry report dated 23-03-2020 submitted by the
Mouzadar Mouza No. 111 and Hill Mondol, Mouza No.
IV.
On perusal of the spot enquiry it is found that the
Mouzadar of Mouza No. III along with Hill Mondal of
Mouza No. IV has visited the spot after observing all
necessary formalities with the help of Shri. C.R.Marak
Mouzadar of Mouza No. IV and accordingly they have
recorded the statement from both sides.
It is learnt from the report that the objectors
Shri. Sengnam S. Marak and Shri. Witjing S. Sangma
has withdrawn their objection and complaint on 07-022020 and 12-02-2020 respectively. Further, it is seen
from the report that after the enquiry Shri. Taseng S.
Sangma has filed a complaint/objection dated
19.03.2020.
This Court is of the opinion that the petition of
Shri. Tawe S. Sangma deserves to be allowed because
in the spot inquiry report it is clearly stated that Smti.
Ningme S. Sangma who is the present female Nokma of
the Okkapara Songgitcham 11-19 (30) A’king being
without any issue/children has adopted Smt. Nobalin S.
Sangma by way of deragata (adoption) following the
customs and practices of Garos and they rightfully
deserves to be registered as Nokma, and this
application being placed after observing all the
necessary formalities and has placed a petition through
Shri. Tawe S. Sangma, one of the chra to register Smt.
Noballin S. Sangma and her husband Shri. Ellingston
Ch. Marak as Nokma of the Okkapara Songgitcham 1119 (30) has fulfilled all the customs and practices of
Garo in regards to the registration of Nokma, and as
far as the complaint/objection filed by Shri. Taseng
S.Sangma is concern he has submitted only after the
enquiry and after the withdrawal by the original
complainants/objector and therefore, I do not find any
merit, and on further perusal of the record it is found
that Shri. Taseng S. Sangma was present in a meeting
place in regards to register Smt. Noballin S. Sangma
and her husband Shri. Ellingston Ch. Marak as Nokma
along with the applicant and other clan’s people, and
for the same I do not find any weight in the complaint
filed by Shri. Taseng S. Sangma after the enquiry and
not to the satisfaction of this Court to entertain the
same.
This Court finds it fit to dismiss the
objection/complaint filed by Shri. Sengnam S. Sangma
and Shri. Witjeng S. Sangma on being withdrawn and
the complaint/objection of Shri. Taseng Sangma for
want of merit without abusing process of the Court and
without causing injustice to the petitioner and invoking
the power vested upon me. I hereby allow Smt. Noballin
S. Sangma and Shri. Ellingston Ch. Marak to register
as the Nokma of the Okkapara Songgitcham 11-19 (30)
A’king.
This petition of Shri. Tawe S. Sangma is allowed
by this order.
The parties are to bear their own cost, no order
as to cost.
Sd/Dy. Chief Executive Member
I/C Land and Revenue
Garo
Hills
Autonomous
District Council, Tura.”
4. Similarly, the order dated 28-06-2023 is reproduced herein below:
“GHADC REV.APPEAL CASE NO 21 A.C. OF 2022
Shri. Taseng S. Sangma …….Appellant
-VersusShri Tawe S. Sangma & Ors…..Respondents.
ORDER
28.6.23
1.
This appeal case is against the Order dated
21.4.22 and 27.5.22. By this order EM has finalized the
appointment of the respondents No. 2 & 3 as Nokmas of
II-19 (30) Okkapara Songgitcham.
2.
I have also heard the submissions of the
respective counsels for the parties. From the
submissions and from record it is also evident that
before appointing the respondents No. 2 & 3 the clan
people had series of meetings and discussions finally
concluded by applying before the EM for registration of
Respondents No. 2 & 3 viz., Smti. Noballin S Sangma
and Shri Ellingstone Ch Marak as Nokmas of II-19 (30)
Okkapara Songgitcham.
3.
From the record it is also clear that Smti.
Noballin S Sangma is an adoptive daughter of Smti
Ningme S Sangma Nokma, she has no female issues of
her own hence adopted Smti. Noballin S Sangma from
her close relatives. Appointment of respondent 2 & 3
was initially objected by Shri. Singan S Sangma and
Witjing S Sangma but later on they had withdrawn their
respective objection petitions. However, immediately
after their withdrawal present appellants Shri Taseng S
Sangma had filed his objection in his individual
capacity but EM did not consider his objection hence
passed the impugned order.
4.
Against the majority decision the above two
individuals have objected which was subsequently
withdrawn after this withdrawal only the present
appellant had attempted to revive this objection by
filing his separate objection petition but no resolution
or support from the clan members had been submitted
in his objection petition which indicate that this
objection is in his individual capacity only as against
the wishes and desires of the clan people to register the
respondent 2 & 3 as Nokmas of II-19 (30) Okkapara
Songgitcham. All these suggest that the appeal has no
merit therefore the same is dismissed as devoid of merit
and done with a vested interest only. Accordingly I
uphold the impugned order passed by the Ld. EM in
this case.
5.
This appeal case is disposed of accordingly,
parties are to bear their own costs.
Sd/The Chief Executive Member
Garo Hills Autonomous
District Council, Tura.”
5.
The findings in short, as can be seen from the orders above is that
the writ petitioner has nowhere established his locus or on whose authority
the complaint was filed after the entire proceedings had been concluded
i.e., the process of the application of respondent Nos. 6 & 7, the
withdrawal of objections by the initial two objectors, and also the
furnishing of the enquiry report by the Revenue Officer of the District
Council.
6.
From the side of the respondents, materials have been annexed to
show that the claim for the appointment of the respondent Nos. 6 & 7 is
based on the application of Garo customary law, and further the
application for consideration of appointment as submitted before the
District Council which is annexed as Annexure- 1 to the writ petition, has
been with the support of the Chras and Maharis, pursuant to a meeting held
on 04-01-2020 and 196 signatures have been appended thereto. It has been
brought to the notice of the Court that the petitioner himself was present in
the meeting held on 04-01-2020, and had signed the document at Sl. 143. It
is to be noted that to this document, there has been no rebuttal by the
petitioner, nor any rejoinder affidavit filed to the same.
7.
From the side of the official respondents, it has been submitted that
due process taking into account the customary law had been followed, and
that there is no illegality or irregularity whatsoever on the appointment of
respondent Nos. 6 & 7.
8.
This Court on the basis of the submissions and materials as placed,
has firstly noted that the writ petitioner himself in the writ petition has not
disclosed as to who he is, what is his interest and what relief he is entitled
to in assailing the impugned orders. Nowhere has it been reflected in the
writ petition that he has received authorization to file the complaint, after
the matter had been already concluded by the respondents, and as observed
earlier, the only ground is that there should have been more detailed
enquiry into the complaint.
9.
In the backdrop of these facts, and due to the fact that the writ
petitioner had never disclosed his locus, nor the relief he is entitled to, nor
filed any rejoinder affidavit to the affidavits filed by the respondents, there
is no merit in the writ petition and the impugned orders suffers from no
illegality.
10.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed.
Judge
Meghalaya
23.04.2024
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review