The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. This Court while passing the judgement, review of which is sought herein, has seen, observed and, thus, held that the judgement under review did not call for any interference. Learned CAT, Chandigarh Bench has dismissed the OA vide order dated 22.09.2011 and against that order, the petitioner filed writ petition being SWP No.593/2012 before this Court which too was dismissed vide order dated 10 th December, 2014 and thereafter petitioner filed Special Leave Petition bearing SLP(C) No. 26952/2015 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India which too came to be dismissed vide order dated 05.10.2015. Thus, the petitioner after challenging the order and ultimately failing upto Supreme Court cannot ask for review of the judgment passed in the year 2014 which otherwise amounts to rehearing the main case whereas the judgment under review has already been considered and taken note of all the contentions raised in the present review petition, therefore, the petitioner cannot seek rehearing of the writ petition under the garb of this review petition as this Court cannot sit over the matter as an appellate authority. The reliance placed by the learned counsel for review petitioner on the judgment reported in 2005 AIR SCW 1058 titled Secretary, Department of Home Secy. A.P. and others Vs. B. Chinnam, Naidu does not render any aid and assistance to the case set up by him or for that matter su…
20. While having glimpse of review petition on hand, no case much less cogent or material one has been made out by review petitioner to seek review of the Judgement dated 10th December, 2014. Same grounds and submissions, factual in character, have been made, which find place in the writ petition. There is no error apparent on the face of the record warranting review of the judgement dated 10th December, 2014. The review petition is wholly misplaced and liable to be dismissed as the petitioner has failed to project any error apparent on the face of record which could justify review of the judgment and order dated 10th December, 2014 passed in SWP No.593/2012.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
……..
RPSW No. 20/2017
in (SWP No. 593/2012)
Reserved on: 18.12.2024
Pronounced on: 03.01.2025
Tarsem Lal, age 33 years
S/O Sh. Tara Chand,
R/O Village Durgu Chak,
P.O. Akalpur, Tehsil and
District Jammu.
…….Petitioner(s)………
Through: Mr. K.Nirmal Kotwal, Advocate
Versus
1. Union of India through Secretary to Govt.
Ministry of Defence,
New Delhi.
2. Engineer-in-Chief, Military Engineering
Service (MES) Zone, Udhampur
C/O 56 APO
3. Col. Commander, HQ,
135Works Engineer,
C/O 56 APO.
4. Major Garrison Engineer,
881 Engineer Works Section
Pin 913881 C/O 56 APO.
……Respondent(s)…….
Through: Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSGI
CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE RAJESH SEKHRI, JUDGE
JUDGEMENT
Tashi Rabstan CJ:
1. This petition is filed by the petitioner in terms of Rule 51 of the Jammu
& Kashmir High Court Rules seeking review of the judgment and order
RPSW No. 20/2017
dated 10.12.2014 passed in SWP No. 593/2012, MP No. 921/2012
titled Tarsem Lal Vs. Union of India and others.
2. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and considered their
submissions.
3. The petitioner was appointed as Mazdoor vide order No. 1713/Rectt/
16/E1B2 dated 03.08.2004 in Military Engineering Service (MES) by
respondent No. 3 in the pay scale of Rs. 2550-55-2660-60-3200-(2550)
plus usual allowance. He was on probation for a period of two years.
His services were governed by the Civil Defence Service
(Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules 1965 [“Rules of 1965”]. The
respondents terminated the petitioner’s services vide order dated
31.10.2009 in reference to Explanation at Srl (viii) (a) Rule 11 of the
Rules of 1965.
4. Being aggrieved, the petitioner filed OA No. 967/JK/2009 before the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh, questioning the order of
termination dated 31.10.2009 on the ground that Sub Rule (VIII) (a) of
Rule 11 of the Rules of 1965 was not applicable to him because he had
already completed the maximum period of the probation and acquired
the status of a permanent employee in the department of respondents
and that the order of the termination was stigmatic in nature. The
protection provided under Article 311 of the Constitution of India has
not been provided to him as the petitioner being less educated not well
RPSW No. 20/2017
versed with language. The Tribunal dismissed the petitioner’s
application by virtue of order dated 22.09.2011.
5. Aggrieved of the Tribunal order, petitioner filed SWP No. 593/2012.
The Division Bench relying upon the decisions reported in (1996) 11
SCC 605 titled Delhi Administration Versus Sushil Kumar, (2010)
14 SCC 103 titled Daya Shanker Yadav Versus Union of India and
others and (2008) 3 SCC 222 State of Harayana Vs Dinesh Kumar
and (2008) 11 SCC 314 case titled Union of India Vs Bipad Bhanjan
Gayan and by applying the ratio of these judgments, has dismissed the
writ petition vide judgement/order dated 10.12.2014.
6. Now review is being sought by the petitioner in the instant petition. In
support of the review petition, it is stated by the learned counsel for the
review petitioner that this Court has erred in passing the judgement
under review as petitioner has completed his probation period and
acquired the status of permanent employee as such his services are
deemed to have been confirmed on the post, therefore, he is entitled to
protection in terms of Article 311 of the Constitution of India, but, this
fact of the matter has not been considered by this Court while disposing
of the petition. Learned counsel has also submittted that the petitioner
neither at any point of time has suppressed any material information
from the respondents while accepting the appointment as Mazdoor in
MES nor have the respondents at any point of time asked for the same.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the termination order is
RPSW No. 20/2017
stigmatic in nature which requires procedure to be followed under Rule
14 of Rules of 1965.
7. In rebuttal to the submissions of learned counsel for the petitioner, the
learned counsel for the respondents submits that the petitioner was on
probation as laid down in the recruitment rules and during the
probation period he was governed by the Rules of 1965. It is further
contended that the verification report received by the respondent No.3
from the SSP, District Police Headquarters, Jammu, vide letter dated
21.01.2005 reveals that the petitioner was involved in a criminal case/
FIR No.281/200 under Section 307/326/34 RPC and 4/25 Arms Act
which was registered at Police Station, Domana prior to his
appointment in the MES, but the petitioner managed to secure a fake
character certificate dated 10th August. 2004 from SDPO, Akhnoor so
as to get himself appointed in the MES. A regular inquiry was
conducted. In the inquiry, the petitioner was found guilty of
suppressing the material facts at the time of his recruitment in the
department. This Court has rightly dismissed the writ petition while
relying on various judgments on the point. Against the judgment, the
petitioner filed SLP before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India which
came to be dismissed on 05.10.2015. After about two years of
dismissal of the SLP, the petitioner has filed the present review
petition.
8. Meticulous examination of the present petition for review of the
judgement dated 10.12.2014, makes it known that none of the grounds
RPSW No. 20/2017
adumbrated therein can, strictly speaking, be said to fall within the
ambit and scope of Order XLVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
This review petition, in essence, challenges the correctness of the
judgement of this Court without pointing out any “error apparent on
the face of the record” which can be reviewed. It is well settled that the
review proceedings have to be strictly confined to the ambit and scope
of Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC.
9. The Supreme Court in Thungabhadra Industries Ltd. s. The
Government of Andhra Pradesh (1965 (5) SCR 174 at 186) has
opined:
“What, however, we are not concerned with is whether the
statement in the order of September 1959 that the case did
not involve any substantial question of law is an "error
apparent on the face of the record". The fact that on the
earlier occasion that Court held on an identical state of facts
that a substantial question of law arose would not per se be
conclusive, for the earlier order itself might be erroneous.
Similarly, even if the statement was wrong, it would not
follow that it was an "error apparent on the face of the
record", for there is a distinct which is real, though it might
not always be capable of exposition between a mere
erroneous decision and a decision which could be
characterized as vitiated by "error apparent." A review is by
no means an appeal in disguise whereby an erroneous
decision is reheard corrected. but lies only for patent error."
10.In Smt. Meera Bhanjia v. Smt. Nirmala Kumari Choudhury (1995
(1) SCC 170) while quoting with approval a passage from Abhiram
Taleshwar Sharma v. Abhiram Pishak Sharma & Ors. (1979 (4) SCC
389), the Supreme Court held that review proceedings were not by way
of an appeal and had to be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of
Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC. Under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC, a
RPSW No. 20/2017
judgment may be open to review, inter alia, if there is a mistake or an
error apparent on the face of the record. An error which is not selfevident and has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be
said to be an error apparent on the face of the record justifying the
Court to exercise its power of review under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC.
In exercise of jurisdiction under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC, it is not
permissible for an erroneous decision to be “reheard and corrected”.
It must be remembered that a review petition has limited purpose and
cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in disguise”. [See: Parsion Devi
and others v. Sumitri Devi and others, (1997) 8 SCC 715].
11.There is a clear distinction between an erroneous decision and an error
apparent on the face of the record. While the first can be corrected by
the higher forum, the later only can be corrected by exercise of the
review jurisdiction. A review cannot be permitted to operate as an
appeal in disguise so as to enable an aggrieved party to re-agitate the
matter and get it corrected.
12.In Shanti Conductors Private Limited v. Assam State Electricity
Board and others, (2020) 2 SCC 677, the Supreme Court, following
Parsion Devi (supra) dismissed review petitions and held that the
scope of review is limited and that an applicant/petitioner under the
guise of review petition cannot be permitted to reagitate and reargue
the questions which have already been addressed and decided.
RPSW No. 20/2017
13.The Supreme Court again in Shri Ram Sahu (Dead) through Legal
Representatives and others v. Vinod Kumar Rawat and others,
(2021) 13 SCC 1, restated the law qua the scope of review under
Section 114 read with Order XLVII, CPC.
14.Yet again, the Supreme Court in S. Murali Sundaram v. Jothibai
Kannan and others, reported as (2023) SCC OnLine SC 185,
observed that even though a judgement sought to be reviewed is
erroneous, the same cannot be a ground to review in exercise of powers
under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC. In the case of Perry Kansagra Vs.
Smriti Madan Kansagra, (2019) 20 SCC 753, it was observed by the
Supreme Court that Review Court, while exercising review
jurisdiction in an application under Order XLVII Rule 1 read with
Section 114 CPC, does not sit in appeal over its own order. It was also
observed that rehearing of the matter is impermissible in law and
review is not appeal in disguise and that power or review can be
exercised for correction of a mistake but not to substitute a new view
inasmuch as such powers can be exercised within the limits of the
statute dealing with the exercise of power. It is wholly unjustified and
exhibits a tendency to rewrite a judgement by which the controversy
has been finally decided.
15.In Arun Dev Upadhyaya v. Integrated Sales Service Limited and
another (2023) 8 SCC 11, the Supreme Court iterated the law, by
holding that:
RPSW No. 20/2017
“15. From the above, it is evident that a power to review
cannot be exercised as an appellate power and has to be
strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order XLVII Rule
1 CPC. An error on the face of record must be such an error
which, mere looking at the record should strike and it should
not require any long-drawn process of reasoning on the points
where there may conceivably be two opinions.”
16.A Constitution Bench in Beghar Foundation v. Justice K.S.
Puttaswamy (Retired) and others, (2021) 3 SCC 1, held that even
change in law or subsequent decision/judgement of a Coordinate
Bench or Larger Bench by itself cannot be regarded as a ground for
review.
17.In Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax Officer, (2023) SCC OnLine
SC 1406, the Supreme Court has observed that the parties are not
entitled to seek review of judgement merely for the purpose of
rehearing and a fresh decision of the case. Applying the principles of
Order 47 Rule 1 CPC, it is said that a review of a judgement is open,
inter alia, if there is a mistake or error apparent on the face of the
record. An error which is not obvious and has to be detected by a
process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the
face of the record. The Supreme Court has culled down the following
propositions relevant for the review of a judgment:
“(i) A judgment is open to review inter alia if there is a
mistake or an error apparent on the face of the record.
(ii) A judgment pronounced by the Court is final and
departure from that principle is justified only when
circumstances of a substantial and compelling character make
it necessary to do so.
(iii) An error which is not self-evident and has to be detected
by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error
apparent on the face of record justifying the court to exercise
its power of review.
RPSW No. 20/2017
(iv) In exercise of the jurisdiction under Order 47 Rule 1 CPC,
it is not permissible for an erroneous decision to be “reheard
and corrected”.
(v) A Review Petition has a limited purpose and cannot be
allowed to be “an appeal in disguise”.
(vi) Under the guise of review, the petitioner cannot be
permitted to reagitate and reargue the questions which have
already been addressed and decided.
(vii) An error on the face of record must be such an error
which, mere looking at the record should strike and it should
not require any long-drawn process of reasoning on the points
where there may conceivably be two opinions.
(viii) Even the change in law or subsequent decision/
judgment of a co-ordinate or larger Bench by itself cannot be
regarded as a ground for review.”
18. In the present case, the submissions made by the learned counsel for
the review petitioner have been given thoughtful consideration by us.
There is no potency in the submissions and contentions made by
learned counsel for review petitioner, more particularly given the
strenuous submission made by Mr. Vishal Sharma, learned DSGI
appearing for respondents, that all that has been observed and said by
this Court in the judgement knocks the bottom out of the basic edifice
of review petition.
19.This Court while passing the judgement, review of which is sought
herein, has seen, observed and, thus, held that the judgement under
review did not call for any interference. Learned CAT, Chandigarh
Bench has dismissed the OA vide order dated 22.09.2011 and against
that order, the petitioner filed writ petition being SWP No.593/2012
before this Court which too was dismissed vide order dated 10 th
December, 2014 and thereafter petitioner filed Special Leave Petition
bearing SLP(C) No. 26952/2015 before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
RPSW No. 20/2017
India which too came to be dismissed vide order dated 05.10.2015.
Thus, the petitioner after challenging the order and ultimately failing
upto Supreme Court cannot ask for review of the judgment passed in
the year 2014 which otherwise amounts to rehearing the main case
whereas the judgment under review has already been considered and
taken note of all the contentions raised in the present review petition,
therefore, the petitioner cannot seek rehearing of the writ petition
under the garb of this review petition as this Court cannot sit over the
matter as an appellate authority. The reliance placed by the learned
counsel for review petitioner on the judgment reported in 2005 AIR
SCW 1058 titled Secretary, Department of Home Secy. A.P. and
others Vs. B. Chinnam, Naidu does not render any aid and assistance
to the case set up by him or for that matter submissions made by him,
given the discourse made herein before qua scope of review.
20.While having glimpse of review petition on hand, no case much less
cogent or material one has been made out by review petitioner to seek
review of the Judgement dated 10th December, 2014. Same grounds
and submissions, factual in character, have been made, which find
place in the writ petition. There is no error apparent on the face of the
record warranting review of the judgement dated 10th December, 2014.
The review petition is wholly misplaced and liable to be dismissed as
the petitioner has failed to project any error apparent on the face of
record which could justify review of the judgment and order dated 10th
December, 2014 passed in SWP No.593/2012.
RPSW No. 20/2017
21.In view of foregoing reasons and discussion, review petition on hand
is, dismissed.
(Rajesh Sekhri)
Judge
Jammu
03.01.2025
Madan Verma, Secy.
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
Madan Lal Verma
2025.01.03 15:00
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(Tashi Rabstan)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review