Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR No.9561 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
Civil Revision No.9561 of 2025
Date of decision: February 4th, 2026
Tarlok Singh
.....Petitioner
Versus
Nimral Singh and others
.....Respondents
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKAS BAHL
Present:
Mr. Shehbaz Thind and Mr. Sultan Singh, Advocates
for the petitioner.
VIKAS BAHL, J. (ORAL)
1.
This is a civil revision petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India for setting aside the order dated 08.09.2025 vide which
the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ludhiana, has dismissed the application
filed by the petitioner for issuance of directions to the Tehsildar, Ludhiana
(East), for demarcation of the property as shown in the site plan.
2.
The facts of the present case would show that the petitioner,
who is defendant No.3 in the suit, in spite of earlier two demarcations, one
of which was conducted in pursuance of the order passed by the High Court
in a writ petition filed by the petitioner and which order had been duly
exhibited before the trial Court as Exhibit P-11, has chosen to file another
application for demarcation without disclosing the earlier demarcations.
The undisputed facts of the present case are detailed hereinbelow.
3.
Respondents No.1 to 5 had filed a suit for permanent injunction
with respect to the land comprised in specific khasra numbers, the details of
which were given in the headnote of the suit. The relevant portion of the
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
headnote of the suit is reproduced hereinbelow:
“Suit for the grant of a permanent injunction whereby
restraining the defendants either themselves or through
their attorneys, employees, agents, and servants from in
any manner illegally and forcibly interfering in the
peaceful possession of the plaintiffs over the land
detailed as under:a. Land measuring 6 Kanal 18 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 7, Khatoni No.7, Rect. No.7, Killa No.9;
b. Land measuring 8 Kanal 0 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 18, Khatoni No.19, Rect. No.4, Killa No.21;
c. Land measuring 4 Kanal 0 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 309, Khatoni No. 468, Rect. No.4, Killa No.
13/1;
d. Land measuring 16 Kanal 0 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 65/1, Khatoni No. 122/1, Rect. No.4, Killa
No.12, Rect. No.7, Killa No.1:
e. Land measuring 8 Kanal 0 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 60, Khatoni No. 83, Rect. No.5, Killa No.
15min, Khatoni No. 84, Killa No. 15min:
f. Land measuring 6 Kanal 18 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 54, Khatoni NO.71, Rect. No.4, Killa
No.9min, Khatoni No.72, Rect. No.4, Killa No.9 min;
g. Land measuring 8 Kanal 0 Marlas, comprised in
Khewat No. 64, Khatoni No.99, Rect. No.5, Killa
No.16min, 24min;
as per Jamabandi for the year 2012-2013, situated in
Village Machhian Kalan, Hadbast No.41, Tehsil Koom
Kalan, Distt. Ludhiana and from in any manner forcibly
and illegally dispossessing the plaintiffs from the
aforesaid land, on the basis of oral and documentary
evidence.”
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
4.
A perusal of the plaint would show that it was the case of the
plaintiffs that the plaintiffs along with their brother Pardhan Singh were
owners in possession of the land which had been described in the headnote
from serial No. ‘a’ to ‘f’. With respect to the land mentioned in serial No.
‘g’, it was the case of the plaintiffs that they were in possession of the same.
It was stated that the land of the Forest Department was abutting the land of
the plaintiffs and the Forest Department had built a boundary wall up to 8
feet high and the Forest Department had also got a barbed wire affixed on
the top of the boundary wall thereby separating the land of the Forest
Department from the land in possession of the plaintiffs. In paragraph 6 of
the plaint, it was stated that defendants No.1 to 6, which included the present
petitioner (defendant No.3), had a grudge against the plaintiffs and had filed
a false application to the Deputy Commissioner, subsequent to which a
demarcation was carried out by Forest Department on 06.05.2015 in the
presence of the revenue officials and the officials of the Forest Department,
who had submitted a detailed report that the land of the Forest Department
was complete at the spot and the Forest Department had constructed a
boundary wall around its own land and had fixed barbed wire on the top of
the said wall.
5.
It was further the case of the plaintiffs in paragraph 7 of the
plaint that the present petitioner along with defendant No.2 had filed CWP
No.11374 of 2015 before the High Court against the Forest Department, the
plaintiffs and defendants No.7 to 9 on false allegations and in the said case,
the Hon’ble High Court vide order dated 07.07.2015, had ordered for
conducting a demarcation of the Forest Department land, which was
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
conducted by a team of three Kanungos on 20.08.2015 in the presence of
defendants No.7 to 9 well as representatives of defendants No.1 to 6 and the
report which was submitted by the team of Halqa Kanungos showed that no
part of the land of the Forest Department had been encroached upon by the
plaintiffs and the boundary wall which was constructed was at the right
place. It was stated in the plaint that ultimately the said writ petition was
disposed of vide order dated 25.09.2017 (Annexure P-5) and in spite of the
same, the defendants have been filing false applications one after the other
against the plaintiffs.
6.
From a perusal of the record as well as the observations made in
the impugned order dated 08.09.2025, it is apparent that the first
demarcation was conducted on 06.05.2015 in which the land of the Forest
Department was demarcated in the presence of the revenue officials and the
said demarcation report had already been produced on the file of the trial
Court as Exhibits P-7 to P-10. In the writ petition filed by the petitioner as
well as defendant No.2 i.e. CWP No.11374 of 2015, the High Court vide
order dated 07.07.2015 had directed another demarcation to be carried out
and on 20.08.2015, a team of three Kanungos, in the presence of the parties
including the representatives of defendants No.1 to 6 (which included the
present petitioner who is defendant No.3) conducted fresh demarcation and
submitted a report to the effect that no part of the forest land had been
encroached by the plaintiffs and the boundary wall made by the Forest
Department was correct and thereafter the writ petition was disposed of vide
order dated 25.09.2017, which order has been annexed as Annexure P-5
along with the present petition. It is also not disputed that the certified copy
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
of the said demarcation report is exhibited as Exhibit P-11 and the order
dated 25.09.2017 is exhibited as Exhibit P-12 in the suit and that the
petitioner along with other defendants have already cross-examined the
plaintiffs’ witnesses on the basis of the said reports. In spite of the above and
without disclosing about the earlier two demarcations, an application dated
29.07.2025 was filed by petitioner-defendant No.3 for demarcating the
property in question. In paragraph 3 of the said application, it was stated that
no demarcation of the forest land had been conducted.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the said
application is meritorious and the demarcation should have been allowed in
order to finally resolve the dispute.
8.
The said submission made on behalf of the petitioner is
completely meritless and the application was rightly dismissed by the trial
Court vide order dated 08.09.2025 in which it was observed that already
there were two demarcation reports on the record, one of which was in
pursuance of the order passed by the High Court in the writ petition filed by
the petitioner along with defendant No.2 and that the petitioner was guilty of
concealment as there was no mention of the said two demarcation reports in
the application filed for demarcation. It was further observed that no party
can be permitted to seek assistance of the Court to collect favourable
evidence and thus in view of the settled law, the application was dismissed
with a cost of ₹1,000/-.
9.
From the above, it is apparent that two demarcation reports are
already on record and the petitioner has already cross-examined the
witnesses of the plaintiffs with respect to the said two demarcation reports. It
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
is not disputed before this Court that khasra numbers which are detailed in
the headnote of the suit are not the khasra numbers which are owned or
possessed by the Forest Department or by the petitioner or the other
defendants or that they have any right qua the same. The prayer in the suit is
for grant of injunction regarding the said khasra numbers qua which
admittedly neither the Forest Department nor the petitioner has any right or
concern and thus, this Court fails to understand as to on what basis the
petitioner and the other defendants are filing applications for demarcating
the land. In the written statement, it is the plea of the petitioner that the
plaintiffs have encroached upon the land in Village Garhi Fazal, which is
adjoining to the suit land and as per the petitioner is forest land, however,
it is not disputed that no suit has been filed by defendant No.3/petitioner
against the plaintiffs either for injunction or for possession. The same has
not been done in spite of the fact that the writ petition i.e. CWP No.11374 of
2015 filed by the petitioner and defendant No.2 in which a prayer was made
for taking action against the Forest Authorities for allegedly allowing the
private respondents therein, which undisputedly included the plaintiffs, to
encroach upon the land which as per the case of the petitioner belonged to
the Forest Department, was dismissed, although it was kept open to the
petitioners therein, which included the present petitioner, to seek remedy by
filing civil suit or by approaching appropriate forum.
10.
Additionally it would be relevant to note that the petitioner by
moving the present application in effect, is wanting to seek appointment of
Local Commissioner. The Division Bench of this Court in the case of Pritam
Singh Vs. Sunder Lal reported as 1990(2) PLR 191 had observed that the
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
order refusing to appoint a Local Commissioner does not decide any issue
nor adjudicates rights of the parties for the purpose of the suit and is
therefore not revisable. Learned Single Judge, vide judgment dated
18.07.2022 passed in Civil Revision No.2752 of 2022 in case titled as
Harchand Vs. Karambir Singh and another , by placing reliance upon the
above-said judgment of Division Bench and also the judgment of the learned
Single Bench in Raksha Devi Vs. Madan Lal and others reported as 2017 (3)
PLR 249, had observed that no revision would be maintainable against an
order dismissing an application for appointment of a Local Commissioner.
The relevant portion of the said judgment in Harchand's case (supra) is
reproduced as under: -
“4. Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the plaintiffpetitioner has contended that the appointment of the
Local Commissioner would be necessary in order to
bring on record the existing position of the suit property.
5. Heard.
6. In the present case the challenge is to the order
dismissing the application for appointment of a Local
Commissioner. A Division Bench of this Court in the
case of Pritam Singh Vs. Sunder Lal [1990(2) PLR 191]
inter-alia held as under:
“6. After going through the judgments cited in the
reference order, we do not find that the earlier judgment
in
Harvinder
Kaur's
case
(supra)
requires
any
reconsideration. The order refusing to appoint a local
commissioner does not decide any issue, nor adjudicates
rights of the parties for the purpose of the suit and is,
therefore, not revisable. The distinction sought to be
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
made by the learned Single Judge in view of the
CR No.9561 of 2025
Judgment in M/s Sadhu Ram Bali Ram's case (supra) was
clearly noticed by the Division Bench in Harvinder
Kaur's case (supra) and it was observed:
"It may be observed that the facts of M/s Sadhu Ram Bali
Ram's case were different as in that case the onus of an
issue had been wrongly placed and while deciding that
question, it was held that such an order would be
revisable."
Apart from that, placing the onus of an issue has
something to do with the rights of the parties whereas
refusing to appoint a Commission under Order 26, Rule
9, Code of Civil Procedure, has nothing to do with the
rights of the parties as such. It is the discretion of the
Court to appoint a Commission there under and if the
Court refuses to appoint a Commission, then no right of
any party can be said to be prejudiced as such."
7. Similar view has been taken by this Court in the case
of Smt. Raksha Devi Vs. Madan Lal & Ors. [2017(3)
PLR 249] wherein it has categorically been held that no
revision would be maintainable against an order
dismissing an application for appointment of a Local
Commissioner. It is trite that an order refusing to appoint
a Local Commissioner does not decide any issue nor does
it adjudicate any rights of the parties for the purpose of
the suit and hence would not be a revisable order.
8. In view of the law laid down by the Division Bench of
this Court, I do not find any illegality or irregularity in
the order passed by the Court below.
9. The revision petition is accordingly dismissed.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed off.”
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
CR No.9561 of 2025
11.
The provision of Order 26 Rule 9 CPC is reproduced hereinbelow:-
“9. Commissions to make local investigations. In any suit
in which the Court deems a local investigation to be
requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any
matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market-value of
any property, or the amount of any mesne profits or
damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a
commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him
to make such investigation and to report thereon to the
Court;
Provided that, where the State Government has made
rules as to the persons to whom such commission shall be
issued, the Court shall be bound by such rules.”
A perusal of the said provision would show that the same
provides that it is within the power of the Court to issue a Commission to
such person as it thinks fit, to make an investigation on some aspect.
A further reading of the said provision would show that there is no right
vested in favour of a party to get the said commission issued and rather the
same is an enabling provision that enables the Court to appoint a
Commissioner if it is of the opinion that the same is required in a case.
Moreover, it is not for the trial Court to collect evidence for the petitionerdefendant No.3.
12.
Keeping in view the abovesaid facts and circumstances, the
impugned order deserves to be upheld and is accordingly upheld and the
present revision petition being meritless, deserves to be dismissed and is
accordingly dismissed.
February 4th, 2026
(VIKAS BAHL)
JUDGE
Puneet
PUNEET SACHDEVA
2026.02.09 14:44
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this document
Chandigarh
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
:
:
Yes
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review