The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
26. Accordingly, Crl.A.No.16 of 2022 is dismissed by upholding the judgment of conviction of February 12, 2020 and finding that an appropriate punishment of rigorous imprisonment for life has been awarded, together with a fine of Rs.5000/-. As indicated earlier, the minor distraction of the appellant being of unsound mind does not warrant much attention particularly in the light of the expert opinions obtained recently.
27. Crl.M.C.No.67 of 2022 is disposed of.
28. Let an authenticated copy of this judgment and order be immediately made available to the appellant free of cost. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.A.No.16/2022 with
Crl.M.C.No.67/2022
Date of Order: 11.07.2023
Tara Miah
Coram:
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
: Mr. S.P. Mahanta, Legal Aid Counsel with
Mr. M. Lyngdoh, Adv
Mr. D. Dkhar, Adv
For the Respondent
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, Addl.Sr.GA
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
This is quite an open and shut case except that considerable
time has been wasted on a wild goose chase that was eminently avoidable.
The distraction has to be dealt with before dealing with the merits of the
matter.
2.
It appears that in the midst of the trial, the mother of the
appellant herein produced some prescriptions claiming to have been
issued by a psychiatrist who had treated the appellant. However, the trial
judge recorded in his order of March 20, 2019 that the accused in the
dock did not show any sign of mental disorder as he interacted normally
and without any sign of mental disturbance.
3.
The judge also went on to record that the medical test report of
the accused pertained to his liver functioning and though a psychiatrist’s
prescription of September, 2018 had been produced, the trial court
deemed it expedient that a specialist examine the appellant herein after
recording that the appellant’s mother claimed that since the appellant was
released on bail in 2018, the appellant seemed mentally disturbed and
“went roaming here and there hence, he was not found at home for which
he was rearrested.”
4.
Accordingly, by the order of March 20, 2019, the trial court
directed the Superintendent of Tura jail to send the accused to a
psychiatrist in Tura hospital for check-up and examination of the mental
status of the accused and to submit a report in such regard by April 3,
2019.
5.
The Superintendent of the District Jail, Tura complied with the
direction and had the appellant examined at Tura Civil Hospital. A report
in such regard was placed before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ampati
which was taken up by the court on March 29, 2019. The order passed by
the CJM on such date recorded exactly as follows:
“Seen also the reason of referral filed by Smt. Chuontie Shira,
Clinical Psychologist, Tura Civil Hospital, wherein, it is
reported that the accused has no presence of cognitive
impairment and mental illness.
“It is also reported that he has the ability to reason out and
understand abstract concept including morality and that he has
also ability to analyses the consequence of action and lastly, it
is also reported that he has low impulse control. Seen also the
administration of Psychiatric evaluation...”
6.
Accordingly, the matter was directed to be put up before the
Sessions Judge on April 3, 2019 as earlier directed by the Sessions Judge
in the order of March 20, 2019.
7.
On April 3, 2019, the trial court took notice of the medical
report pertaining to the appellant herein as furnished by the clinical
psychologist in Tura Civil Hospital. Upon recording the findings of the
specialist, the trial court required the trial to proceed in right earnest. It is
evident that the specialist at the Tura Civil Hospital had found nothing
wrong with the appellant and the trial court duly accepted such report.
8.
Following the evidence being recorded of the witnesses at the
trial, the appellant herein was examined under Section 313 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973. The evidence of each of the witnesses was
summarised and the key points therein brought out by the trial court for
the appellant to comment thereon. It is interesting to notice the appellant’s
response to the questions put to him by the trial court.
9.
The trial court summarised the evidence of the FIR-maker, who
was the father-in-law of the victim and who claimed to have been an eyePage 3 of 11
witness to the incident. Upon the trial court seeking the appellant’s
response to the evidence adduced by PW-1, the appellant claimed that at
the time of the incident he was young and was apparently playing with the
deceased as the deceased was a friend of the appellant. He went on to add
that he saw five persons quarreling and they were his brother, mother, the
complainant, the complainant’s wife and the deceased. He asserted that
the victim was his nephew but even though he said that he was present at
the place of occurrence, he claimed that he was not aware as to who
assaulted the victim or stabbed the victim. He denied that he had assaulted
the victim and insisted that he had no quarrel with the victim as the victim
was his friend.
10.
Interestingly, however, there appears to be a change of tack on
the part of the appellant in his response to the second question. Such
second question also pertained to the evidence of PW-1 and the assertion
by such witness that the appellant’s mother and brother were also present
at the place of occurrence. The appellant responded to such question by
asserting his innocence before claiming that the complainant dragged him
to the police station “because that time I was of unsound mind...” In
response to the subsequent questions, the appellant had little to say and
did not attempt to suggest his innocence, as he had done in response to the
first question, but maintained that he was mentally ill at the relevant point
of time. Finally, upon the trial court enquiring of the appellant whether he
would call any witness, he clearly responded in the negative.
11.
On a reading of the appellant’s examination and his response to
the questions put to him by the trial court after the witnesses had been
examined, it does not appear that the responses were incoherent or
unsound. After the initial attempt by the appellant to plead innocence, the
appellant resorted to plan B: that he was mentally unwell at the time of
the incident. However, the appellant admitted to have been present at the
place of occurrence and it is apparent that the appellant was a witness to
the incident and the appellant corroborated that at least the appellant’s
mother and brother along with the wife of the victim and the parents of
the victim were there or thereabouts at the place of occurrence.
12.
It is elementary that for a person to be proceeded against for the
commission of a grievous offence as in the present case, the court must be
satisfied that he had committed the offence consciously and that he was fit
to stand trial for the commission of such act. Thus, an accused has to be
found both to have been in good mental capacity at the time of the
commission of the offence and in sufficiently good mental state to be able
to stand trial for his action.
13.
No evidence was adduced on behalf of the appellant in support
of the somewhat irregular suggestion by the appellant’s mother at the
beginning of the trial that the appellant was of unsound mind. If the
appellant was of unsound mind at the time of the commission of the
offence, it had to be demonstrated. No attempt in such regard was made
on behalf of the appellant. Following the trial court’s direction to have the
appellant clinically examined, the appellant was found to be in good
mental shape by the clinical psychologist attached to the Tura Civil
Hospital.
14.
Quite needlessly, much is sought to be made by legal aid
Counsel of the fact that the trial court had required a psychiatrist to
examine the appellant but it was a clinical psychologist who had
conducted the examination. No attempt, however, is made to indicate that
a clinical psychologist cannot assess the mental condition or fitness of a
person. Indeed, it is a clinical psychologist who is the appropriate person
to assess the mental state or condition of a person. In any event, the report
furnished by the clinical psychologist indicated appropriate tests having
been conducted and, the trial court, upon due satisfaction in such regard,
proceeded with the trial.
15.
Further, and more importantly, it is said that the judges’ eyes
and the judges’ assessment are probably the best and, in such regard, the
trial court recorded that the accused in the dock showed no signs of
mental imbalance or disorder and appeared to be perfectly oriented and
responsive.
16.
At the initial stage of the present appeal, since a ground of
mental instability or insanity of the convict was taken, this Court deemed
it proper to have the appellant examined. The appellant has been
examined both at the Meghalaya Institute of Mental Health and
Neurological Sciences and at the North Eastern Indira Gandhi Regional
Institute of Health and Medical Sciences and the reports clearly indicate
that the appellant is responsive, aware and conscious. The entire exercise,
including the charade by the appellant in course of his examination under
Section 313 of the Code was a diversion to scuttle the proceedings and
gain undue advantage by resorting to a needless trick.
17.
There never was, nor is now, any merit in the assertion by or on
behalf of the appellant as to his mental capacity. No evidence was
adduced as to the appellant’s mental capacity at the time of the incident.
Both at the time of the trial and at the time of this appeal, the appellant’s
mental condition has been assessed by experts and the appellant was
found fit to stand trial and in perfect mental state as of now, at least for
the purpose of the present proceedings.
18.
As to the merits, there appears to be very little to assess or
adjudicate. The first information report was lodged on September 17,
2010 by the father-in-law of the victim at the Monabari Police Station in
the West Garo Hills claiming that in course of a quarrel involving several
persons, the appellant became ferocious and stabbed the victim with a
knife which caused the death of the victim.
19.
In course of his deposition in court, the father-in-law of the
victim as PW-1 asserted that the incident took place at around 6:30 pm
when he was at home with his wife when the appellant came to the
witness’ house, started a quarrel with the victim and assaulted the victim
with a knife. In his cross-examination, the father-in-law of the victim
reiterated that he had witnessed the incident and it happened in the
presence of the mother and a brother of the appellant between 6 and 6:30
pm when it was not completely dark. For good measure, he repeated that
he saw the appellant striking the victim with a knife which the appellant
had drawn from his waist.
20.
The wife of the victim was examined as PW-3. She claimed
that she was sitting in the verandah of the house when the appellant came
and started a quarrel with her deceased husband. According to the wife,
the quarrel pertained to a land dispute. The witness claimed that she saw
the accused with the knife stabbing the witness’ husband. In her crossexamination, she repeated that she was present when the incident took
place just outside the victim’s house. She also claimed that the appellant’s
mother and a brother were present at the place of occurrence and repeated
that she had seen the appellant actually stabbing her husband with a knife.
21.
The mother of the victim was examined as PW-4. She claimed
that the incident took place right outside her house and she saw the
appellant assaulting the victim with a knife. However, in her crossexamination, after saying that the appellant’s mother and an elder brother
were also present at the place of occurrence, she claimed that she was
inside the house and when she heard a scream, she claimed that she came
out and saw the victim lying on the ground and the appellant holding the
knife in his hand.
22.
The investigating officer referred to a dagger measuring about
11½ inches which was the murder weapon. The relevant knife was
exhibited in court. According to the investigating officer, the complainant
and the complainant’s daughter were the eye-witnesses to the incident.
23.
The doctor who conducted the post-mortem study was next
examined as PW-7 and he described the external injuries that would be
consistent with a person trying to ward off a knife brandished by a right
handed person. The medical examiner referred to the abdominal injuries
received by the victim and was of the opinion that the victim died due to
haemmorage of the abdominal organs and the shock following the assault.
Such medical practitioner indicated that he had conducted the postmortem examination at 3:15 pm on September 18, 2010 and his opinion at
the relevant point of time was that the victim had died of ante-mortem
injuries inflicted on the victim some 24 to 26 hours prior to the postmortem examination.
24.
On the basis of the evidence before the trial court, there was
little discussion which was necessary. The trial court reproduced the
material parts of the deposition of the witnesses and found that there was
nothing brought to detract from the eye-witnesses’ accounts and the
corroboration of the injuries and the cause of death by the post-mortem
examination.
25.
By the judgment and order impugned dated February 12, 2020,
the trial court sentenced the appellant to life imprisonment upon
appreciating that for an offence committed under Section 302 of the Penal
Code, 1860 no lesser sentence than life imprisonment could be awarded,
if the maximum sentence of death penalty was found to be inappropriate.
Indeed, the manner in which the trial was conducted and the reasons
furnished in the judgment and order impugned are found to be
satisfactory. This was not one of the rarest of rare cases which would
warrant the capital punishment to be imposed.
26.
Accordingly, Crl.A.No.16 of 2022 is dismissed by upholding
the judgment of conviction of February 12, 2020 and finding that an
appropriate punishment of rigorous imprisonment for life has been
awarded, together with a fine of Rs.5000/-. As indicated earlier, the minor
distraction of the appellant being of unsound mind does not warrant much
attention particularly in the light of the expert opinions obtained recently.
27.
Crl.M.C.No.67 of 2022 is disposed of.
28.
Let an authenticated copy of this judgment and order be
immediately made available to the appellant free of cost.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
11.07.2023
“Lam DR-PS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review