Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/21
GAHC010281992025
2026:GAU-AS:13846
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP/4/2026
TAPAN KR SAHA AND 3 ORS.
S/O LATE SHANTI GOPAL SAHA, PANPATTY, SILCHAR- 1, DISTRICTCACHAR, ASSAM.
2: DIPAK ROY
S/O LATE HARIPADA ROY
RESIDENT OF CENTRAL ROAD
SILCHAR TOWN
DISRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788001.
3: TINKU MAZUMDER
S/O LATE HABIBUR RAHMAN MAZUMDER
RESIDENT OF GHANIALAL
NEAR SAMAYIK PRASANGA NEWS PAPER OFFICE
SILCHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM.
4: MUMINUR RAHMAN MAZUMDER @ SANKU MAZUMDER
S/O LATE HABIBUR RAHMAN MAZUMDER
RESIDENT OF GHANIALAL
NEAR SAMAYIK PRASANGA NEWS PAPER OFFICE
SILCHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
ANABIK GUPTA AND 9 ORS.
SON OF LATE ARUNENDU KISHORE GUPTA @ ARUN KUMAR GUPTA AND
Page No.# 2/21
ARE RESIDENT OF PATHERKANDI, VILLAGE- DUHALIA- 5, P.O. AND P.S.PATHERKANDI, DISTRICT- SRIBHUMI, ASSAM, PIN- 788724.
2:AMIT GUPTA
SON OF LATE ARUNENDU KISHORE GUPTA @ ARUN KUMAR GUPTA AND
ARE RESIDENT OF PATHERKANDI
VILLAGE- DUHALIA- 5
P.O. AND P.S.- PATHERKANDI
DISTRICT- SRIBHUMI
ASSAM
PIN- 788724.
3:BIKASH RANJAN SHEE
SON OF LATE BHUPENDRA KUMAR SHEE AND ARE RESIDENT OF
HOSPITAL ROAD
OPPOSITE LAXMI NARAYAN BIBAHA BASAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788005.
4:SMT MANJU SHEE
DAUGHTER OF LATE BHUPENDRA KUMAR SHEE AND ARE RESIDENT OF
HOSPITAL ROAD
OPPOSITE LAXMI NARAYAN BIBAHA BASAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788005.
5:SMT MITALI SHEE
DAUGHTER OF LATE BHUPENDRA KUMAR SHEE AND ARE RESIDENT OF
HOSPITAL ROAD
OPPOSITE LAXMI NARAYAN BIBAHA BASAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788005.
6:ON THE DEATH OF MIRA SHYAM CHOUDHURY
HER LEGAL HEIRS
NAMELY
6.1:BACHASPATI SHYAM CHOUDHURY
HUSBAND OF LATE MIRA SHYAM CHOUDHURY
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 7
JAGAT BANDHU LANE
NATIONAL HIGHWAY
Page No.# 3/21
SILCHAR- 788012
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM.
6.2:BIPRAJIT SHYAM CHOUDHURY
SON OF LATE MIRA SHYAM CHOUDHURY
ARE RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 7
JAGAT BANDHU LANE
NATIONAL HIGHWAY
SILCHAR- 788012
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM.
6.3:SMT BORNALI DHAR
DAUGHTER OF LATE MIRA SHYAM CHOUDHURY
ARE RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 7
JAGAT BANDHU LANE
NATIONAL HIGHWAY
SILCHAR- 788012
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM.
7:ALBERT SAHA @ BISWAJIT SAHA
S/O LATE NARAYAN CHANDRA SAHA
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 6
SADHANA MANSION
LANE NO. 5
2ND LINK ROAD
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788006.
8:SMTI JHUMA SAHA @ POMPA SAHA
D/O LATE NARAYAN CHANDRA SAHA
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 6
SADHANA MANSION
LANE NO. 5
2ND LINK ROAD
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 788006.
9:ON THE DEATH OF MANSUR ALAM MAZUMDER @ MINTU MAZUMDER
HIS LEGAL HEIRS
NAMELY
Page No.# 4/21
9.1:ARPITA MAZUMDER
DAUGHTER OF LATE MANSUR ALAM MAZUMDER @ MINTU MAZUMDER
AND ARE RESIDENT OF GHANIALAL
NEAR SAMAYIK PRASANGA NEWS PAPER OFFICE
SILCHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT-CACHAR
ASSAM
9.2:ANKITA MAZUMDER
DAUGHTER OF LATE MANSUR ALAM MAZUMDER @ MINTU MAZUMDER
AND ARE RESIDENT OF GHANIALAL
NEAR SAMAYIK PRASANGA NEWS PAPER OFFICE
SILCHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT-CACHAR
ASSAM
9.3:ANUSKA MAZUMDER
DAUGHTER OF LATE MANSUR ALAM MAZUMDER @ MINTU MAZUMDER
AND ARE RESIDENT OF GHANIALAL
NEAR SAMAYIK PRASANGA NEWS PAPER OFFICE
SILCHAR
P.O. AND P.S.- SILCHAR
DISTRICT- CACHAR
ASSAM
10:ON THE DEATH OF SAHANAJ MAZUMDER @ SUSHMITA MAZUMDER
HER LEGAL HEIRS
NAMELY
10.1:SUBRATA BHATTACHARJEE
HUSBAND OF LATE SAHANAJ MAZUMDER @ SUSHMITA MAZUMDER
AND ARE RESIDENT OF C/O MR. GURUMUKH SINGH
17/1A MIDDLE ROAD
KOLKATA- 14
WEST BENGAL.
10.2:SONAL BHATTACHARJEE
DAUGHTER OF LATE SAHANAJ MAZUMDER @ SUSHMITA MAZUMDER
AND ARE RESIDENT OF C/O MR. GURUMUKH SINGH
17/1A MIDDLE ROAD
KOLKATA- 14
WEST BENGAL
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. D CHAKRABARTY, MS D.CHAKRABARTY
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. S D PURKAYASTHA (FOR CAVEATOR), J P BAISHYA (FOR
Page No.# 5/21
CAVEATOR),MR. A CHOUDHURY (FOR CAVEATOR)
BEFORE :
HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
Advocates for the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. D. Chakrabarty
Advocate for the Respondent(s) : Mr. S.D. Purkayastha
Date of Hearing
:
17.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
17.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment
:
Full judgment.
:
Yes.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced
JUDGEMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
The instant application under Section 115 of the CPC has been preferred by
the petitioner challenging the impugned judgment dated 11.11.2025 and the
decree dated 14.11.2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge Senior Division No. 2
Cachar, Silchar in Title Appeal No. 30/2004 dismissing the appeal filed by the
petitioners and upholding the judgment and decree dated 31.05.2004 passed in
Title Suit No. 37/1991.
Page No.# 6/21
2.
Heard learned counsel, Mr. D. Chakrabarty for the petitioners and learned
counsel, Mr. S.D. Purkayastha for the respondents.
3.
The instant revision petition has a long chequered history and the
chronological events of the case needs to be revisited in order to adjudicate the
matter in the right perspective.
4.
The petitioners were initially sub-tenants under the original tenant one
Bhupendra Kumar Shee with the consent of the original landlord late Arunendu
Kishor Gupta/Father of the respondent Nos. 1 & 2. After some time, the
respondents herein filed a Title Suit No. 37/1991 in the Court of Munsiff No. 2
Cachar, Silchar, denying the tenancy of Bhupendra Kumar Shee, in whose shoes
the petitioners had stepped into, and had prayed for an ejectment decree
against the petitioners and other tenants.
5.
After hearing the contesting parties, the learned Munsiff No. 2, Cachar,
Silchar vide Judgment dated 31.05.2004 and decree dated 09.06.2004 in Title
Suit No. 37/1991 decreed the suit ex-parte against defendants No. 1-5, 7 & 8
and on contest against defendants No. 6, 9, 10 & 11 for khas possession over
the suit premises by evicting the defendants/petitioners with further direction to
the defendants/petitioners to pay arrear rent for the period April 1988 to March
1991 amounting to Rs. 1440/- with interest @ 6% from the date of the filing of
Page No.# 7/21
the suit till realization.
6.
Against the aforementioned judgment and decree passed in Title Suit No.
37/1991, the petitioners being the defendants in Title Suit No. 37/1991,
preferred Title Appeal No. 30/2004 in the court of the learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division No. 1 Cachar, Silchar, and the said appeal was admitted by the
Appellate Court and further till disposal of the Appeal, the operation of the
impugned decree dated 09.06.2004 was suspended.
7.
During the pendency of Title Appeal No. 30/2004, one Raj Shekhar Saha
who was a stranger to the Title Suit No. 37/1991 obtained an ex-parte decree in
Title Suit No. 128/2012 from the court of learned Munsiff No. 1 Cachar, Silchar
on 26.03.2013. In the said Title Suit No. 128/2012, neither the petitioners nor
the defendants herein were made parties.
8.
The said Raj Sekhar Saha thereafter, instituted the Title Execution Case
No.16/2013 for execution of the decree dated 26.03.2013 passed in Title Suit
No. 128/2012. In the said Title Execution No. 16/2013, Raj Sekhar Saha
obtained a writ of symbolic possession over the suit property. The petitioners
upon inquiry later came to know about the ex-parte decree obtained by the said
Raj Sekhar Saha in Title Suit No. 128/2012.
9.
It is also stated in the pleadings that the symbolic possession obtained by
Page No.# 8/21
Raj Sekhar Saha through the execution proceedings in Title Execution Case
No.16/2013 was over the property under the occupation of the petitioners as
tenant premises.
10. After coming to know about the ex-parte decree in Title Suit No. 128/2012
and the order of symbolic possession obtained in Title Execution No. 16/2013,
the petitioners filed Title Suit No. 85/2014 in the court of Civil Judge, Cachar,
Silchar and in the said suit the petitioners arrayed Raj Sekhar Saha and the
respondents herein as party defendants. The Title Suit No. 85/2014 was
accompanied by an application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 2 of CPC registered as
MISC(J) Case No. 47/2014. The Title Suit No. 85/2014 was filed for declaration
of right, title and interest over the suit premises as a derivative tenant and for
permanent injunction. A further declaration was sought in the said suit to the
effect that the present petitioners/plaintiffs are not bound by the judgment and
decree passed in Title Suit No. 128/2012 and that the decretal property in Title
Suit No. 128/2012 does not cover the schedule-1 property of the Title Suit No.
85/2014.
11.
Subsequently, the MISC(J) Case No. 47/2014 filed by the petitioners
praying for temporary injunction was dismissed by the Civil Judge No. 2 Cachar,
Silchar by order dated 13.07.2015 and the petitioners preferred an appeal under
Page No.# 9/21
Order 43 Rule 1 (r) of the CPC before the Additional District Judge, FTC, Cachar,
Silchar against the said order dated 13.07.2015. However, the learned Additional
District Judge, FTC, Cachar, Silchar also dismissed the appeal filed by the
petitioners by order dated 14.03.2022. A Revision Petition registered as
CRP/52/2022 was preferred by the petitioners before this Court challenging the
order dated 14.03.2022 passed by the Additional District Judge, FTC, Cachar,
Silchar. The said CRP/52/2022 was also dismissed by this Court on 05.09.2022.
Ultimately the petitioners have withdrawn the title suit No. 85/2014.
12. Thereafter, the said Raj Sekhar Saha filed another Title Suit registered as
Title Suit No. 181/2018 in the court of Civil Judge No. 1, Cachar, Silchar, which
was later transferred to the court of Munsiff No. 1 Cachar, Silchar, and renumbered as Title Suit No. 36/2021. In this Suit, Raj Sekhar Saha sought for a
decree granting him title over the land described in schedule-1 of the plaint and
for delivery of symbolic possession pursuant to the judgment and decree in
terms of Title Suit 128/2012. He also prayed for a declaration that the judgment
and decree passed in Title Suit No. 37/1991 is illegal, void and liable to be
cancelled and that the plaintiff is not bound by the said illegal decree. He also
prayed for permanent and temporary injunction restraining the defendants from
proceeding with the alleged illegal decree passed in Title Suit No. 37/1991. In
the said Title Suit No. 36/2021, the petitioners as well as the respondents herein
Page No.# 10/21
have been arrayed as defendants and the said Title Suit No. 36/2021 is still
pending disposal.
13. The respondents herein also filed an application under Order 21 Rule 99
and 101 CPC in Title Execution case No. 16/2013 which was registered as MISC
Case No. 158/2022. In the said MISC Case No.158/2022 the respondents prayed
for a decree for declaration of right, title and interest over the properties
mentioned in the schedule to the plaint of Title Suit No. 128/2012 with further
declaration that the said properties are part and parcel of the decree dated
31.05.2004 passed in Title Suit No. 37/1991. The respondents also prayed for a
further declaration that the ex-parte decree dated 26.03.2013 passed in favour
of Raj Sekhar Saha in Title Suit No. 128/2012 was obtained fraudulently and on
suppression of facts. Eventually the said MISC Case No. 158/2022 filed by the
respondents herein was also dismissed by an order dated 14.05.2025 passed by
the Civil Judge, Junior Division No. 1 Cachar, Silchar.
14.
In the meantime, since the Title Appeal No. 30/2004 filed by the
petitioners against the decree dated 31.05.2004 was still pending, the
petitioners filed an application under Order 1 Rule 10 (2) and Order VI Rule 17
and Order XLI Rule 33 r/w Section 151 CPC praying for adding necessary party
and amendment incorporating subsequent events in the memo of appeal before
Page No.# 11/21
the Civil Judge No. 2 Cachar, Silchar. The application was registered as MISC (J)
Case No. 77/2021. In the said application the petitioner prayed for adding
Rajsekhar Saha and Deb Dullal Dutta Purakayastha as respondents in Title
Appeal No. 30/2004.
15. After hearing the parties, the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division No. 2
Cachar, Silchar dismissed the MISC (J) Case No. 77/2021 by an order dated
02.09.2025. Aggrieved by the said dismissal, the petitioner came before this
Court against order dated 02.09.2025 by filing CRP(IO)./425/2025. However, the
said CRP (IO)./425/2025 was withdrawn by the petitioner and it was disposed of
on withdrawal on 14.11.2025.
16. It is the stand of the petitioners in their pleadings that the petitioners at
the time of final arguments in Title Appeal No. 30/2004 submitted before the
Appellate Court regarding the vital developments which occurred subsequent to
the filing of the Title Appeal No. 30/2004. It was argued before the Appellate
Court that, the title and ownership of the suit property had changed as Raj
Sekhar Saha has obtained the decree in his favour in Title suit No. 128/2012
and also in view of the fact that the application filed by the respondents herein
under Order 21 Rule 99 & 101 CPC in Title Execution Case No. 16/2013 had
been rejected. Such developments had to be taken note of by the learned
Page No.# 12/21
Appellate Court. However, without considering such developments and without
any reference to the subsequent Title suit No. 128/2012 and Title suit No.
36/2021, the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division No. 1 Cachar, Silchar disposed
of the Title appeal 30/2004 by impugned judgment dated 11.11.2025 and
decree dated 14.11.2025 upholding the judgment and order dated 31.05.2004
passed in Title suit 37/1991. Being aggrieved the petitioners are before this
Court in the present Revision Petition under Section 115 of the CPC.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioners, Mr. D. Chakrabarty, submits that the
learned court below had committed jurisdictional error in not considering the
fact that in Title Suit No. 128/2012 the Trial Court had decreed the suit in favour
of Raj Sekhar Saha and he had taken symbolic possession of the entire suit land
during the execution of the decree in Execution Case No. 16/2013. However, the
learned court below has ignored such developments by dismissing the Title
Appeal No. 30/2004.
18.
Learned counsel also submits that the learned court below did not
appreciate the vital aspect that while the respondents and Raj Sekhar Saha
were claiming that they are the landlord of the suit premises, the issue has been
put to a conclusion with the dismissal of the application filed by the respondents
under Order 21 Rule 99 & 101 CPC. Therefore, the respondents had ceased to
Page No.# 13/21
be the owners of the tenanted premises and are not entitled to execution of a
decree of ejectment of the petitioners from the said premises under the
provisions of the Assam Urban Areas Rent Control Act, 1972.
19. It is further submitted by the learned counsel for the petitioners that the
learned court below did not take into account the changed circumstances which
had taken place during the pendency of the Title appeal and because of which
the judgment and decree of ejectment passed in Title Suit No. 37/1991 has
become un-executable. He submits that the learned court below did not
consider that the respondents herein are no longer the owners or landlords of
the disputed tenanted premises.
20.
Another ground taken by the petitioner is that the learned court below
failed to appreciate the legal position under the changed circumstances that if
the petitioners are to be evicted from the premises under their occupation, it
has to be at the instance of Raj Sekhar Saha and not the respondents herein. It
is the submission of the learned counsel that the eviction of the petitioners
under due process of law is now possible only after adjudication of the Title Suit
No. 36/2021 and not by virtue of the eviction decree passed in Title Suit No.
37/1991.
21. Per contra, the learned counsel, Mr. S.D. Purkayastha appearing for the
Page No.# 14/21
respondents has resisted the contentions of the petitioners by stating that the
petitioner’s status as a sub-tenant is particularly important in the present case.
It is an admitted fact that the petitioner is a sub-tenant under the original
landlord i.e., the principal respondent herein. The first Title Suit No. 37/1991
resulted in a decree in favour of the respondents and the tenant’s obligation
under that decree cannot be avoided merely because the third person
subsequently obtained a decree in a separate suit to which neither the
petitioner nor the respondents was a party. The tenant’s position is derivative of
the landlord’s title/interest for the purpose of the tenancy. In the context of
eviction proceedings, it is well settled that the landlord-tenant relationship
ordinarily constitutes the essential controversy between those parties.
22. Learned counsel, by relying on the case of Promod Hazarika Vs. Haren
Das, reported in 2005 (Supp) GLT 453 and Hindustan Petroleum
Cooperation Ltd. Vs. Dilbahar Singh, reported in (2014) 9 SCC 78, has
apprised this Court regarding the scope of the revisional court under Section
115 of the CPC. In the case of Promod Hazarika (supra) it was held that it is
not the duty of the revisional court to embark upon a re-appreciation of the
evidence to find out as to which appreciation of the evidence made by the two
learned courts below is a better appreciation unless the appreciation of the
evidence by the learned court below is patently wrong and unless the conclusion
Page No.# 15/21
reached are unreasonably perverse, interference of the revisional court
exercising jurisdiction under Section 115 of the CPC will not be called for.
Learned counsel submits that in a case such as the present revision where there
are concurrent findings of two subordinate courts, this Court would be slow to
interfere.
23. In the case of Dilbahar Singh (Supra), the Supreme Court held that in
exercise of revisional jurisdiction, the High Court shall not exercise its appellate
power to re-appreciate or re-assess the evidence for coming to a different
finding on facts. Revisional power is not and cannot be equated with the power
of re-consideration of all questions of fact as a court of first appeal. When the
High Court is required to be satisfied that the decision is according to law, it
may examine whether the order impugned before it suffers from procedural
illegality or irregularity.
24. Learned counsel has further relied on the case of Jaspal Kaur Cheema
and Another Vs. Industrial Trade Links and Ors . reported in (2017) 8
SCC 592. In this cited case, the Supreme Court held that the tenant who has
been let into possession cannot deny his landlord’s title, however defective it
may be, so long as he has not openly restored possession by surrender to his
landlord. The Supreme Court further held that the principle of estoppel arising
Page No.# 16/21
from a contract of tenancy is based upon the principal of law and justice and a
tenant who could not have got possession but for a contract of tenancy
admitting the right of the landlord, should not be allowed to his landlord in
some inequitable situation taking undue advantage of the position that he got
and any probable defect in the title of his landlord.
25. Learned counsel also submits that the first appellate court had passed a
speaking order on 02.09.2025 in MISC (J) case No. 77/2021 rejecting the
application of the petitioners for amendment of the memo of appeal and the
impleadment. That rejection order dated 02.09.2025 was challenged by the
petitioners in CRP(IO)./425/2025. However, the petitioners had withdrawn the
said CRP(IO)./425/2025 and it was disposed of on 14.11.2025. While the said
Revision Petition was pending before this Court the first appellate court decided
the Title Appeal No. 30/2004 on merits. Therefore, by filing the instant revision
petition against the appellate judgment dated 11.11.2025 in Title Appeal No.
30/2004, the petitioner is indirectly challenging the rejection of the amendment
application MISC (J) case No. 77/2021 again, which is not permissible.
26.
Learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the dispute
between the petitioners and the respondents started in the year 1991 and the
petitioners had filed the Title Appeal No. 30/2004 in the year 2004 and it was
Page No.# 17/21
finally disposed of on 11.11.2025, after a period of 21 (twenty one) years and
till date the petitioners have not paid any arrears of rent due to the respondents
in pursuance of the decree in Title Suit No. 37/1991 and by filing one
application after the other have been dragging the dispute for all these years.
27. In view of the submission made above, learned counsel for the respondent
submits that the petitioners have miserably failed to make out a case to invoke
the jurisdiction of this Court under Section 115 of the CPC and the petition
deserves to be dismissed.
28. I have given due consideration to the submissions made by the learned
counsel for the parties, and I have perused the pleadings and also the
judgments relied upon by the parties.
29. It is settled law that Section 115 CPC is not a second appeal. This Court in
a revision petition cannot: i) re-appreciate the evidence. ii) substitute its own
finding of fact merely because another view is possible. iii) correct every
erroneous finding of law. iv) re-assess credibility of witnesses or (v) interfere
merely because the sub-ordinate court has reached what the High Court
considers an incorrect conclusion.
30.
It has been held in a catena of decision that revisional jurisdictional is
essentially directed at jurisdictional errors and not ordinary errors of fact or law,
Page No.# 18/21
specially, when there are concurrent findings of the subordinate courts.
31. The chronology of events is important in the instant case. The first Title
Suit 37/1991 was decreed in favour of the respondents and against the
petitioners. Admittedly the respondents are the landlords and the petitioners are
sub-tenants. The petitioners preferred the Title Appeal No. 30/2004 against the
decree in Title Suit No. 37/1991. During the pendency of the appeal, a stranger
to the proceedings i.e., Raj Sekhar Saha instituted a separate Title suit
concerning the same property and obtained a decree without impleading the
petitioners or the respondents.
32. The petitioners filed the MISC (J) case No. 77/2021 in the Title appeal
seeking amendment and impleadment of Raj Sekhar Saha. However, the first
appellate court passed a speaking order dated 02.09.2025 rejecting the MISC
(J) case No. 77/2021. The petitioner thereafter challenged that rejection by a
separate Section 115 CPC Revision petition before this Court which was
registered as CRP (IO) 425/2025. The said CRP has already been disposed of
upon withdrawal by the petitioner on 14.11.2025. While CRP (IO) 425/2025 was
pending, the learned court below decided the Title Appeal No. 30/2004 by
passing the impugned order dated 11.11.2025. It is also observed that the Title
Suit No. 36/2021 filed by Raj Sekhar Saha against the petitioners and the
Page No.# 19/21
respondents remains pending.
33.
It
is
the
opinion
of
this
Court
that
the
rejection
of
the
amendment/impleadment application i.e., MISC (J) case No. 77/2021 was made
by a speaking judicial order and the petitioners had already invoked the
revisional jurisdiction of this Court against that very order. Therefore, this is not
a case where the appellate court simply overlooked the application of the
petitioner. The petitioner knew about the rejection, challenged it independently
and thereafter, withdrew the challenge because the Title appeal had already
been decided.
34.
In view of the above circumstances, the petitioners cannot turn around
and submit that the appellate court failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not
considering his prayer for amendment/impleadment. I am of the considered
opinion that the appellate court has exercised its jurisdiction over the
application. The petitioners may disagree with the decision, but that is not the
same as failure to exercise jurisdiction. In fact, the petitioners by filing the
instant petition are trying to circumvent the consequences of the rejection of
MISC (J) case No. 77/2021 by assailing the same order indirectly.
35. This Court has also observed that in the instant petition the petitioners
have not challenged the findings of the appellate court in Title Appeal No.
Page No.# 20/21
30/2004 on merits but only on the ground that the appellate court did not
consider the prayer of the petitioners for impleadment/amendment.
36.
This Court has already held that there was no failure to exercise
jurisdiction by the appellate court as the court had already considered the
application of the petitioner for impleadment/amendment on merits and had
dismissed the same by a speaking order dated 02.09.2025. Since the application
of the petitioner has already been disposed by a reasoned order, the appellate
court was not required to reproduce or reconsider that application in the final
judgment. Moreso, due to the fact that at the time when the appellate court
delivered the final judgment on 11.11.2025, the impleadment/amendment
application was no longer pending before the court. The petitioners cannot
equate absence of discussion with failure to exercise jurisdiction. The records
have already established that jurisdiction was exercised earlier in the order
dated 02.09.2025 and the petitioners themselves had recognized that order as
an independent, challengeable order because they had filed CRP(IO) No.
425/2025 against that order. In substance, the petitioner is seeking to re-open
the impleadment/amendment application through the instant petition.
37. In view of the observations made herein above and the findings arrived at,
this Court is of the view that the petitioners have not been able to make out a
Page No.# 21/21
case for the interference of this court under Section 115 CPC. Resultantly, the
Petition stands dismissed.
38. No order as to costs.
39. Registry is directed to send back the Trial Court Records.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review