Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/32
GAHC040015772025
2026:GAU-AP:505
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/439/2025
Tanyo Nyodu and 67 Ors
Son of Late Erik Nyodu, Ram Village, PO and PS Nari, East Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Hage Hanya
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Hage Rido
Hari Village
PO and PS Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Toko Kamin
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Lt Toko Jhekhon
Village Talo
PO and PS Yachuli
Keyi Panyor District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Kipa Bhai
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Kipa Tangu
Village Sango
PO and PS Nyapin
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Norbu Tsering
Age:
Occupation :
Page No.# 2/32
Son of Late Mirti Tsering
PO and PS Dirang
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Mrs Joram Yalyo
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Joram Chada
Nirjuli near Veterinary Hospital
PO and PS Nirjuli
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Mrs Tai Yatak
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tai Nikpo
Pagba Village
PO and PS Sangram
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8: Mrs Jushna Pegu
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Shaktin Pegu
Solmari Village
PO Pithaguri
PS Bihpuria
Lakhimpur District
Assam.
9: Tadar Eii
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Tadar Takiang
Laba Village
PO and PS Nyapin
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Tage Mara
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Taku Mara
Mara Village
PO and PS Taliha
Page No.# 3/32
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11: Miss Tuter Hira
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Paktu Hira
Kombo Tarasu Mohuk
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
12: Abhijeet Samanta
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Amar Kanti Samanta
Belar Village
PO Belar
PS Madhab Dihi
Burdwan District
West Bengal
13: Smti Tadar Yadam
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tadar Tayu
Yuba Village
PO and PS Nyapin
Kurung Kumey District
Arunachal Pradesh.
14: Miss Jyoti Phuntso
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Sang Phuntso
Oyan village
PO and PS Sille Oyan
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
15: Smti Nyari Likar
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Goi Likar
Sesilikar Village
PO and PS Kamba
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 4/32
16: Smti Ribi Gamlin
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Bombi Gamlin
resident of Libu Bene
PO and PS Kamba
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
17: Smti Meppak Ete
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Goto Ete
Wak Village
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
18: smti Sarboli Basumatary
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Ranjeet Kr Basumatary
Village No.2
PO and PS Udalguri
Darrang District
Assam.
19: Lham Tsering
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Langa Therchung
Yusum Village
PO and PS Tawang
Tawang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
20: Komar Yomggam
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Rikko Yomggam
resident of Likabali
PO and PS Likabali
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
21: Smti Khumyan Manjey
Age:
Page No.# 5/32
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Tangrong Manjey
Goju village
PO and PS Bordumsa
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
22: Tage Tage
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Tage Dibo
PO and PS Ziro
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
23: Smti Gopi Ete Tashi
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Jarkar Tashi
Tadin Village
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
24: Smti Sushila Devi
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Chote Lal Yadav
Rampurchit Village
PO and PS Rampur Chit
Ballia District
Uttar Pradesh.
25: smti Gichik Emik
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Gichik Massa
Dokum Colony Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
26: Obit Norah
Age:
Occupation :
Wife Late Biswswar Norah
Nongkhon Village
PO Npngkhon
Page No.# 6/32
PS Modevpur
Lohit District
Arunachal Pradesh.
27: Smti Sengmi Matcha
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Chahlat Matcha
Khimiyang Village
PO and PS Miao
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
28: Smti Benjir Angu
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Pebom Angu
Angu Village
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
29: Smti Gemur Bado (Boko)
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tami Boko
Komkar Village
PO and PS Yingkiong
Upper Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
30: Smti Bompi Gara
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Pebom Gara
Padi Village
PO and PS Basar
Leparada District
Arunachal Pradesh.
31: Smti Chawan Kungkho
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Khunsam Kungkho
Laktong Village
PO and PS Changlang
District Changlang
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 7/32
32: Chokpha Wangsu
Age:
Occupation :
Wife Late Nokthak Wangsu
Chopnu Village
PO and PS Kanubari
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
33: Miss Bimen Ruti
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Dabi Ruti
Upper Borajan Village
PO and PS Likabali
Lower Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
34: Smti Saraswati Singh
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Lallna Singh
resident of New Market Aalo
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
35: Smti Perrik Doye
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Bommar Doye
resident of Bogdo Village
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
36: Smti Rinching Droma
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Daying Bimpak
Police Colony Bomdila
Po and PS Bomdila
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
37: Arup Saikia
Age:
Page No.# 8/32
Occupation :
Brother of Late Apurba Saikia
Phulaguri
PS Bihpuria
Lakhimpur District
Assam.
38: Miss Khangcha Akhang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Jamwang Akhang
resident of Old Paniduria Village
PO and PS Borduria
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
39: Samme Shin
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Lompo Shin
Lamlo Village
PO and PS Deomali
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
40: Miss Sunita Devi
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Mangat Ram
Police Colony
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
41: Huatem Thoyang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Phuna Thoyang
Old Tupi Village
PO and PS Khonsa
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
42: Smti Phidat Kamhua (Tante)
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Taptung Tante
Page No.# 9/32
Old Changnyak Village
PO and PS Khonsa
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
43: Smti Subhawati Mungyak (Nang)
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Nong Bow Nong Singpho
Dirak Pathar
Po and PS Bordumsa
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
44: Nokte Hakhun
Age:
Occupation :
Brother of Late Komse Hakhun
Rajanagar-II
PO and PS Bordumsa
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
45: Mithilesh Thakur
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Shyam Badam Thakur
Fattu Chapur
PO Gaura Bazar
PS Kateya
Gopal Ganj District
Bihar.
46: Smti Chakphool Riba
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tali Riba
Donyi Polo Village
PO and PS Kharsang
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
47: Smti Tannem Jugli
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Jahlim Jugli
Education Colony
PO and PS Jairampur
Page No.# 10/32
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
48: Smti Ngampan Wangsa
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Lohwang Wangham
Senna Village
PO and PS Longding
District Longding
Arunachal Pradesh.
49: Smti Nang Pafawati Longkan
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Chow Engtra Longkam
Wingko Village
PO and PS Wingko
Namsai District
Arunachal Pradesh.
50: Taw Maling
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Taje Maling
Damsite Naharlagun
PO and PS Naharlagun
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
51: Smti Sunita Chowpoo
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Omit Payeng
Adi Ningroo
PO and PS Piyong
Namsai District
Arunachal Pradesh.
52: Tato Nyompu
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Tadap Nyompu
Nyompu Village
PO and PS Taliha
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 11/32
53: Vijay Goba
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Tamar Goba
Godak village
PO and PS Raga
Kamle District
Arunachal Pradesh.
54: Smti Nyamo Socia Mema
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Wangnyok Mema
Borduria Village
PO and PS Borduria
Khonsa
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
55: Smti Khingchem Tikhak
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Manlitang Tikhak
resident of New Longchong
PO and PS Nampong
Changlang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
56: Smti Gitanjali Baruah Enling
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Chow Suchingta Enling
PO and PS Namsai
District Namsai
Arunachal Pradesh.
57: Smti Gampi Uli
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Dater Uli
SRPL Filed Itanagar
PO and PS Chimpu
Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
58: Tai Rai
Age:
Page No.# 12/32
Occupation :
Son of Late Taram Rai
Village Zigba Rai
PO and PS Siyum
Upper Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
59: Rajdeep Baruah
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Priya Baruah
Sipu Riya Village
PO and PS Tinsukia
Assam.
60: Mrs Gyati Rupa
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Gyati Butung
Hari Village
PO and PS Hapoli
Lower Subansiri District
Arunachal Pradesh.
61: Romanti Brah
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tali Brah
Village Sede Natung
PO and PS Seppa
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
62: Bharat Jerang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Somen Murtem
Son of Late Taki Murtem
Khrbari Village
PO and PS Kalaptukar
Kamel District
Arunachal Pradesh.
63: Smti Withan Changmi
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Nanthang Tangha
Saching Village
Page No.# 13/32
PO and PS Changlang
District Changlang
Arunachal Pradesh.
64: Smti Mini Rigam
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Karto Riram
Sago Village
PO and PS Basar
Leparada District
Arunachal Pradesh.
65: Smti Nuwang Thingnok
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tenok Thingnok
Doidam Village
PO and PS Soha
Tirap District
Arunachal Pradesh.
66: Somen Murtem
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Late Taki Murtem
Village Kherbari
PO and PS Kalaptukar
Kamle District
Arunachal Pradesh.
67: Smti Sonam Chotten
Age:
Occupation :
Wife of Late Tsering Monpa
Pedung Village
PO and PS Bomdila
West Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
68: Miss Phamo Wangpan
Age:
Occupation :
Daughter of Late Nokdow Wangpan
F Sector
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Page No.# 14/32
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The State of AP and 7 Ors
represented by the Home Commissioner, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar 791111
2:The Director General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Chimpu
Itanagar 791111
3:The Inspector General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Chimpu
Itanagar 791111
Arunachal Pradesh.
4:The Assistant Inspector General of Police (E)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ Itanagar
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh.
5:Digam Loffa
Age: 26
Occupation :
Son of Late Dungmar Loffa
P/R Type-4 Colony Seppa
PO and PS Seppa
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6:Rajiv Samyor
Age: 26
Occupation :
Son of Late Tachung Samyor
P/R Aalo
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Page No.# 15/32
Arunachal Pradesh.
7:John Tagang
Age: 32
Occupation :
Son of Karbia Tagang
P/R Model Village Seppa
PO and PS Seppa
East Kameng District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8:Moi Bomjen
Age: 30
Occupation :
Son of Late Yamo Bomjen
P/R Peri Village
Kamba
PO and PS Aalo
West Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner : Sunil Mow, k N Maling,S Mili,Tenzin Chhoten,Chanya
Bangsia,Sonam Tsomo,Tapi Nguki
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Yasmin Gao
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
21.05.2026
:
N/A
:
Yes
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
Page No.# 16/32
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. S. Mow, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.
Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and
Ms. Y. Gao, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 5 to 8.
2.
The petitioners are aggrieved by the Result Notification dated 21.07.2025
issued by the Director General of Police, Police Headquarters, Itanagar,
Arunachal Pradesh, whereby the candidates have been shortlisted for appearing
in the written examination for recruitment to various posts under compassionate
appointment in Arunachal Pradesh Police pursuant to the advertisement dated
08.06.2024 on the basis of scrutiny of documents, Physical Standard Test (PST)
and Physical Efficiency Test (PET) conducted on 26.06.2025 and the Notice
dated 22.08.2025 issued by the Director General of Police, Police Headquarters,
Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh, calling upon the shortlisted candidates to appear
in the written examination for the posts of Head Constable and Constable under
the compassionate appointment scheme, on the ground that the conduct of PET
and written test for compassionate appointment is contrary to the Schemes of
the Compassionate Appointment.
3.
The case of the petitioners, in brief, is that they applied for appointment
on compassionate ground in the Arunachal Pradesh Police Department under
the Compassionate Appointment Scheme issued by the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh vide Memorandum dated 12.07.2001, which regulates
appointment on compassionate ground to dependent family members of
Government servants who have died-in-harness or retired on medical grounds,
thereby leaving their families in penury and without any means of livelihood,
Page No.# 17/32
with the object of relieving the family of the deceased or medically retired
Government servant from financial destitution and helping them overcome the
immediate financial crisis.
4.
The Director General of Police, vide notice dated 04.02.2021, issued a
general information to all applicants seeking appointment on compassionate
ground, informing that the Police Department would conduct recruitment under
the compassionate appointment scheme and had uploaded the list of candidates
who have already applied, while granting 15 (fifteen) days’ time to those
intending applicants who have not yet submitted their applications in the
prescribed format. Thereafter, vide notice dated 11.02.2022, all applicants were
informed that assessment and verification of the financial/economic status of
the applicants would be conducted at the respective district/unit where the
deceased Government servant last served prior to his or her death.
Subsequently, vide notice dated 06.07.2022, the applicants who had applied
under the compassionate appointment scheme in the Police Department were
directed to appear before the Committee at Police Headquarters, Itanagar for
Physical Standard Test (PST) along with all requisite documents. Further, vide
notice dated 10.08.2022, the applicants were informed that separate guidelines
for compassionate appointment in respect of the Police Department were
proposed to be framed for approval of the Government and accordingly, the
ongoing process for compassionate appointment was kept in abeyance until
further orders.
5.
After a lapse of eight months, a notice dated 28.04.2023 was issued in
respect of 36 vacancies for appointment on compassionate ground in the
Arunachal Pradesh Police, whereby the applicants were directed to produce all
relevant documents before the Board as and when called for. Thereafter, vide
Page No.# 18/32
notice dated 08.06.2024, the Assistant Inspector General of Police (E),
Arunachal Pradesh Police, introduced two additional criteria, namely Physical
Efficiency Test (PET) and Written Examination Test, under the Compassionate
Appointment Scheme of 2022.
6.
It is the contention of the petitioners that the respondent authorities have
failed to apply the Compassionate Appointment Scheme of 2001, which governs
appointment on compassionate ground in respect of the vacancies which had
arisen prior to the coming into force of the new guidelines of 2022 and have
instead issued notices introducing Physical Efficiency Test (PET) and written test
in terms of the 2022 guidelines, despite the fact that the said guidelines do not
themselves contemplate such tests for compassionate appointment. It is,
therefore, contended that the scheme/guidelines in force at the relevant point of
time ought to have been applied, as per settled principle that the applicable
rules/policy is the one prevailing at the time the cause of action arose.
7.
Mr. S. Mow, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
respondent authorities have issued the impugned notices illegally by directing all
the applicants to undergo a selection process, whereas the applications of the
petitioners ought to have been considered and evaluated strictly in accordance
with the policy and scheme prevalent at the time of death of the Government
employee or, in any case, at the time of consideration of their applications. He
submits that consideration of the applications under the new guidelines,
including the requirement to undergo PET followed by a written examination
test, which is not contemplated either under the old or the new policy governing
compassionate appointment, is wholly illegal and unsustainable. He submits that
the object of the scheme of compassionate appointment is to provide
appointment on compassionate ground to a dependent family member of a
Page No.# 19/32
Government servant who dies in harness or retires on medical grounds, thereby
leaving the family in penury and without any means of livelihood, so as to
relieve the family of the Government servant concerned from financial
destitution and to help it overcome the immediate crisis. He further submits that
the 2001 policy provides for limited eligibility criteria namely educational
qualification, PST and assessment of the condition of indigence and destitution,
which adequately serve the purpose and object of the scheme.
8.
Mr. S. Mow, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the financial
condition and state of destitution of the dependent family are required to be
duly considered while examining applications for compassionate appointment in
terms of the relevant scheme, whereas in the present case no such
consideration has been made and instead all the applicants have been called for
PET and written test, contrary to the policy/scheme, thereby defeating the very
object of compassionate appointment. It is therefore submitted that the action
of the respondent authorities in resorting to PET followed by written test for
appointment on compassionate ground, pursuant to the impugned notices and
orders, is liable to be interfered with and a direction be issued to the respondent
authorities to grant appointment to the petitioners on compassionate ground in
terms of the applicable policy/scheme.
9.
Mr. S. Mow, learned counsel for the petitioners, in support of his
submission has relied on the following judgments:
(i). Raj Kumar and Ors. vs. Shakti Raj and Ors. reported in (1997) 9
SCC 527.
(ii). Umesh Kumar Nagpal vs. State of Haryana , reported in (1994)
4 SCC 138.
Page No.# 20/32
(iii). Jomba Ingo vs. State of Arunachal Pradesh& 4 Ors.,
WP(C)304/2022, dated 23.02.2026.
10. On the other hand, Mr. S. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate, for
State respondents, submits that that the petitioners are estopped from
challenging the selection process inasmuch as petitioners Nos. 4 to 68 have
participated in the PET and have not qualified, while petitioners Nos. 1 to 3 have
already appeared in the written examination after qualifying the PET. Some of
the petitioners are in fact not eligible for the post of Constable as they have not
passed Class X, as required under the compassionate appointment scheme and
the applicable recruitment rules. Therefore, it is submitted that once a candidate
has taken a calculated chance by participating in the recruitment process, and
thereafter, having found the result not palatable, cannot challenge the selection
process and as such the writ petition is not maintainable.
11.
Mr. S. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate, submits that the
selection process for appointment on compassionate ground is being conducted
in accordance with the Government Office Memorandum dated 08.04.2023.
Clause 5(b) of the Scheme for Compassionate Appointment provides that an
applicant for compassionate appointment should be eligible and suitable for the
post in all respects under the provisions of the relevant Recruitment Rules. It is
submitted that the Recruitment Rules for the post of Constable prescribes the
educational qualification of Class X pass or equivalent from a recognized Board,
along with PST, PET, vision standards, medical fitness test and a written
examination. Having regard to the nature of the post of Constable, the
applicants are required to be physically fit and possess the requisite educational
qualification, which is mandatory for effective performance of duties relating to
maintenance of law and order and discharge of police functions. It is therefore
Page No.# 21/32
submitted that the respondent authorities have rightly decided to conduct the
selection process, including PST, PET and written examination, for the purpose
of assessing the suitability of the applicants.
12.
Mr. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the
guidelines and scheme for compassionate appointment are not suitable in the
case of the Police Department, as the requirements and criteria are different
from those applicable to other departments and the number of applicants is
substantially higher in comparison. Therefore, a separate set of guidelines was
suggested for appointment on compassionate ground in respect of the Police
Department.
13.
Mr. S. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate, in support of his
submissions, has relied upon the following authorities:
(i). State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. vs. Premlata, reported in (2022) 1
SCC 30.
(ii). State of Uttar Pradesh vs. Karunesh Kumar and Ors. reported in
2022 SCC OnLinne SC 1706.
(iii). Anurag Yadav and Ors. vs. State of U.P. and Ors. reported in
2010 Supreme (All) 630.
(iv). State of UP and Ors. vs. Geeta Rani, reported in 2024 SCC
OnLine All 2923.
(v). Union of India & Ors. vs. Krishna Kumar & Ors., reported in
(2019) 4 SCC 319.
14. Ms. Y. Gao, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 5 to 8, while adopting the
submissions of the learned Senior Government Advocate, submits that since
Page No.# 22/32
respondent Nos. 5 to 8 have already participated in the selection process
including the written examination, the authorities may be directed to declare the
result.
15.
Due consideration has been extended to the submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the parties, and the materials available on record have been
carefully perused.
16.
The petitioners are aggrieved by the introduction of Physical Efficiency
Test (PET) and written test in the selection process for compassionate
appointment vide an advertisement dated 08.06.2024 and the subsequent
notifications issued by the respondent authorities. The challenge is primarily on
the ground that the said procedure is contrary to the Compassionate
Appointment Schemes. It is contended that the scheme contemplates
consideration only of the indigence of the family of the deceased Government
servant and the eligibility and suitability of the applicant in terms of the relevant
recruitment rules and does not envisage any competitive selection process such
as written examination or inter se comparative assessment of candidates,
compassionate appointment being intended as a measure to provide immediate
relief to the family of the Government servant concerned from financial
destitution and to help it get over the immediate crisis.
17. The issue which is required to be considered in the present writ petition is
whether the action of the respondent authorities in introducing PET and written
examination in the process of selection for compassionate appointment,
pursuant to the advertisement dated 08.06.2024 and subsequent notifications,
is in consonance with the Compassionate Appointment Schemes of 2001 and
2022 as well as the applicable recruitment rules governing the field, or whether
Page No.# 23/32
the same amounts to deviation from the object and scope of the said scheme
which provides for consideration of indigence, eligibility and suitability of the
applicants for appointment on compassionate ground.
18.
It is true that the object of the scheme for compassionate appointment is
to provide appointment on compassionate ground to a dependent family
member of a Government servant who die in harness or retires on medical
grounds, thereby leaving the family in penury and without any means of
livelihood, so as to relieve the family of the Government servant concerned from
financial destitution and to help it overcome the immediate crisis. The scheme
provides for limited eligibility criteria namely educational qualification, PST and
assessment of the condition of indigence and destitution, which adequately
serve the purpose and object of the scheme.
19.
The State of Arunachal Pradesh has framed a Scheme for Compassionate
Appointment under Office Memorandum dated 04.07.2001. Clause 5 thereof lays
down the eligibility conditions as follows:
“5. ELIGIBILITY.
a) The family is indigent and deserved immediate assistance for relief
from financial destitution, and
b) Applicant for compassionate appointment should be eligible and
suitable for the post in all respects.
Under the provisions of the relevant Recruitment Rules.
Compassionate appointments are exempted from (Illegible) of the
following requirements:
a) Recruitment procedure: (Illegible) selection commission of the
Employment Exchange.
b) Clearance from the Surplus Cell of the Deptt. Of Personnel and
Training/Directorate General of Employment and Training.
Page No.# 24/32
c) The ban orders on filling up of posts issued by the Ministry of Finance
(Department of Expenditure).”
20. Clause-12 Provides the “Procedure” which is reproduced hereinunder:
“12. PROCEDURE.
a)
The
proforma
as
in
Annexure
may
be
used
by
Ministries/Departments/Offices for ascertaining necessary information and
processing the cases of compassionate appointment.
b) The Welfare Officer in each Ministry/Department/Office should meet
the members of the family of the Government servant in question
immediately after his death to advise and assist them in getting
appointment on compassionate grounds. The applicant should be called in
person at the very first stage and advised in person about the
requirements and formalities to be completed by him.
c) An application for appointment on compassionate grounds should be
considered in the light of instructions issued from time to time by the
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms & Training on the
subject by a committee of officers considering of 3 officers one Chairman
and 2 members in the rank of Joint Secretary/Dy. Secy. In the
Ministry/Department. The Welfare Officer may also be taken as one of the
Members/Chairman of the Committee Depending upon his rank. The
committee may meet during the second week of every month to consider
cases received during the previous month. The applicant may also be
granted personal hearing by the committee if necessary for better
appreciation of the facts of the cases.
d) Recommendation of the committee should be placed before the
competent authority for a decision. If the competent authority disagrees
with the committee's recommendation, the case may be referred to the
next higher authority for a decision.”
21.
Subsequently, the Scheme for Compassionate Appointment was revised
and notified vide Office Memorandum dated 02.03.2022. As regards “Eligibility”
Page No.# 25/32
under Clause 5 of the said scheme, the same is pari materia with Clause 5 of
the Office Memorandum dated 04.07.2001.
22.
Clause 13 of the Office Memorandum dated 02.03.2022 lays down the
“Procedure”, which is more elaborate than the Office Memorandum dated
04.07.2001, which is reproduced hereinunder:
“13. PROCEDURE
(i). The Welfare Officer in each Ministry/Department/Office or a senior
officer may be deputed to meet the family members of the deceased
Government Servant and apprise them of the terminal benefits available
to the family. This may be done at the earliest possible, preferably, within
30 days of death.
ii) In case it is observed by the Welfare Officer/Senior Officer that the
condition of the family of the deceased Government Servant is indigent,
the family should also be apprised of the scheme for compassionate
appointment.
iii) In such cases, the Welfare Officer or any other Officer would assist the
family member of the deceased Government servant in applying for
appointment on compassionate grounds. The application should be made
in the format prescribed as in Annexure, All assistance should be extended
to enable such family member to fill the Application Form for
compassionate appointment. The Applicant should be advised in person
about the requirements and formalities to be completed by him. The
Applicant should also be given detailed information of the posts to which
they can apply.
iv) The Administration shall satisfy itself regarding the correctness of the
details entered in the Application form and family income and other details
computed for processing the Application. During scrutiny, if any additional
details or information having a bearing on the case, emerge, the same
should be added as supplementary Note to the Application.
v) Every application found to be in order, should be acknowledged by
assigning a unique Registration number. All pending Applications should
also be assigned unique registration number. This may be done within 2 to
3 weeks of time. Once a unique registration number has been assigned to
Page No.# 26/32
an application, the Applicant, including those whose applications are
pending, may be informed through email or other forms of communication
(including digital modes of communication) of their Unique Application
Registration Number.
vi) Some Departments such as CBIC, D/o Posts, D/o Defence have devised
their own point based merit systém, for processing claims for
compassionate appointment. In order to bring in transparency and
objectivity in dealing with such claims, all Ministries/Departments, who
have not yet developed such a system, may do, so by devising their own
point based merit system for assessing the merit of the claims of
compassionate appointments.
vii) While informing the Applicants of the registration number of their
Application, they may also be informed of the likely number of vacancies
likely to be available to be filled on compassionate grounds as well as be
provided with a copy of the point based merit system.
viii) To consider the various applications and to recommend individual
applicant for grant of compassionate appointment, a Committee,
comprising three members (one Chairman and two Members), may be
constituted. The Committee may be chaired by an Officer not below the
rank of Director/Deputy Secretary in the Ministry/Department and officers
of equivalent rank in the case of attached and subordinate offices.”
23.
The recruitment rules, namely the General Arunachal Pradesh Service,
Assistant
Sub-Inspector
(Civil
Police/IRBn),
Head
Constable
(Civil
Police/AAPBn/IRBn) and Constable (Civil Police/AAPBn/IRBn), Group C, NonGazetted (Non-Ministerial) Recruitment Rules, 2022 (in short The Recruitment
Rules, 2022) regulates the recruitment to the post of Constable. Schedule-VI
thereof prescribes the educational and other qualifications required for direct
recruits and inter alia, provides for educational qualification, PST, PET, eye vision
and medical fitness test, as well as a written test comprising General English,
General Knowledge and Elementary Mathematics.
24.
Bare reading of the above procedure for consideration for appointment
on compassionate ground and Clause 5 of the Scheme, as well as Clause 13 of
Page No.# 27/32
the Office Memorandum dated 02.03.2022, shows that the entire emphasis of
the scheme is on expeditious consideration of the indigent condition of the
family of the deceased Government servant and facilitating immediate relief by
way of appointment, subject to the applicant being otherwise eligible and
suitable for the post under the relevant Recruitment Rules. The scheme does
not contemplate any competitive selection process inter se amongst eligible
applicants, nor does it prescribe any written examination or merit-based
comparative evaluation in the nature of a recruitment test. Rather, it envisages a
structured administrative assessment of indigence, verification of eligibility and
suitability and consideration of applications by a duly constituted committee,
with the object of alleviating immediate financial distress of the family of the
deceased employee.
25.
Explicitly, there is no requirement under the scheme to undergo a written
test as a condition precedent for compassionate appointment and the
introduction of such a test is not traceable to the scheme itself. However,
Clause-5 requires that the applicant must be “eligible and suitable for the post in
all respects” in terms of the relevant Recruitment Rules. Therefore, the applicant
must possess the minimum educational qualification of Class-X pass and must
satisfy the prescribed standards of physical fitness, including PST and PET,
inasmuch as the post in question is that of Constable in the Arunachal Pradesh
Police. The requirement of minimum eligibility and basic physical standards
cannot be diluted or dispensed with even under the scheme for compassionate
appointment, as the object of the scheme is only to relax the mode of
recruitment and not the essential eligibility criteria prescribed under the
Recruitment Rules. Thus, the requirement of minimum educational qualification
and prescribed physical standards continues to be mandatory and has to be
Page No.# 28/32
strictly followed, particularly for posts in a disciplined force like the police, where
fitness and basic qualification are directly linked to the nature of duties.
26.
The petitioners admittedly participated in the PST/PET in terms of the
notification dated 08.06.2024 without any objection and petitioner Nos. 4 to 68
have been found disqualified in the PET except petitioner Nos. 1 to 3, who are
stated to have qualified in the PET and appeared for the written test. It is also
brought on record that out of 68 petitioners, only 33 petitioners, namely
petitioner Nos. 1, 4, 6, 8, 12, 13, 16, 20, 24, 26, 27, 34, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41,
44, 45, 47, 49, 50, 51, 53, 54, 56, 58, 59, 60, 66 & 67, possess the educational
qualification of Class-X pass. Thus, the petitioners who do not possess the
minimum educational qualification cannot be considered for appointment on
compassionate ground even under the applicable policy, as they fail to satisfy
the threshold eligibility condition of “eligibility and suitability” under Clause 5 of
the Scheme read with the Recruitment Rules governing the post of Constable.
The scheme does not contemplate relaxation of essential educational
qualification prescribed under the Recruitment Rules and therefore, in the
absence of such eligibility, their claim for compassionate appointment is not
maintainable at the threshold itself.
27.
Be that as it may, the petitioners having participated in the selection
process, including PST/PET, without protest and having taken a conscious and
calculated chance, cannot be permitted to turn around and challenge the
selection process merely because the outcome of the PET is not palatable to
them. The law is well settled that a candidate who voluntarily participates in a
selection process, with full knowledge of the procedure involved, is estopped
from questioning the same after being unsuccessful therein. Accordingly, except
for petitioner Nos. 1 to 3, who have proceeded further in the process, the
Page No.# 29/32
challenge to the selection process at the instance of the remaining petitioners is
not sustainable.
28.
In the case of Madan Lal vs. State of Jammu and Kashmir, reported
in (1995) 3 SCC 486, it has been held that if a candidate takes a calculated
chance and appears at the interview, then merely because the result of the
interview is not palatable to him, he cannot turn around and subsequently
contend that the process of interview was unfair or that the Selection
Committee was not properly constituted. The said principle has been
consistently reiterated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court to the effect that the
result of the selection process cannot be challenged by a candidate who has
participated therein and has taken a chance to get selected, but ultimately finds
himself unsuccessful.
29.
The authorities relied upon by the respondents (supra) clearly indicate
that compassionate appointment, though a welfare measure intended to provide
immediate relief to the family of a deceased Government servant, is not dehors
the Recruitment Rules and remains strictly subject to the eligibility and
suitability conditions prescribed for the post in question. The decisions in
Premlata(supra) and Geeta Rani (supra) specifically hold that in the context
of police service, fulfilment of physical efficiency tests and other standards
prescribed under the recruitment rules is mandatory, and failure to satisfy the
same disentitles a candidate from appointment. The judgment in Karunesh
Kumar (supra) reiterates the settled principle that a candidate who voluntarily
participates in a selection process without objection cannot subsequently
challenge the same after being unsuccessful, which applies squarely to the
petitioners who participated in the PST/PET. Further, Anurag Yadav (supra)
underscores the necessity of maintaining strict physical standards in police
Page No.# 30/32
recruitment having regard to the nature of duties in a disciplined force, while
Krishna Kumar (supra) affirms that consideration must be strictly in
accordance with the rules in force at the time of consideration and that no
vested right accrues contrary to the applicable rules. Thus, the principles laid
down in the aforesaid decisions collectively support the position that
compassionate appointment cannot be claimed in derogation of the Recruitment
Rules and prescribed eligibility criteria, including physical standards and
structured selection processes.
30. The judgments relied upon by the petitioners do not advance their case in
the facts of the present matter, as they are rendered in a different context and
do not deal with the issues arising herein, namely the application of recruitment
rules and eligibility conditions for compassionate appointment in a disciplined
force. In Raj Kumar (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court considered a vitiated
selection process and the consequence of deviation from governing rules, and
did not lay down any principle enabling relaxation of eligibility under recruitment
rules in compassionate appointment. In Umesh Kumar Nagpal(supra), while
the limited scope of compassionate appointment was explained, the decision
itself emphasises the requirement of eligibility and suitability under the
applicable rules and does not support any claim for appointment dehors such
rules. The decision in Jomba Ingo (supra) deals only with procedural aspects
of processing applications under the scheme and does not consider or restrict
the application of recruitment rules prescribing essential qualifications and
physical standards. Thus, the said judgments do not support the petitioners’
challenge to the selection process or the requirement of compliance with the
recruitment rules.
31.
Reverting back to the present case, the policy for appointment on
Page No.# 31/32
compassionate ground admittedly does not explicitly provide for PST/PET and
written test for appointment on compassionate ground, however, it provides the
eligibility criteria which requires that the applicant must be eligible and suitable
in all respects under the relevant Recruitment Rules. The relevant Recruitment
Rules, namely the Recruitment Rules, 2022, prescribe that a candidate for the
post of Constable must possess the minimum educational qualification of ClassX pass and must undergo PST and PET followed by a written examination.
32.
The scheme for compassionate appointment is intended to provide
immediate relief to the family of a deceased Government servant suffering from
financial hardship and indigence and is ordinarily not intended to apply the
rigour of a full-fledged competitive selection process. However, since the policy
itself mandates that the applicant must be eligible and suitable under the
relevant Recruitment Rules, the requirement of compliance with the minimum
standards prescribed under the said rules, including PST/PET and other essential
eligibility conditions, cannot be said to be arbitrary or contrary to the scheme.
That apart, the petitioners, having been aware of the applicable policy and
having voluntarily participated in the selection process pursuant to the
notification dated 08.06.2024, cannot now be permitted to turn around and
contend that the procedure adopted is illegal merely on the ground that the
scheme does not expressly provide for PST/PET and written examination and
are thus estopped from challenging the recruitment process after having taken a
conscious and calculated chance.
33. In view of what has been discussed herein above, I am of the considered
view that the decision of the respondent authorities to conduct PST/PET and
written examination for assessing suitability for appointment to the post of
Constable on compassionate ground cannot be faulted. The Scheme itself
Page No.# 32/32
makes eligibility and suitability under the relevant Recruitment Rules a condition
precedent, and therefore, adherence to the standards prescribed under the
Recruitment Rules cannot be held to be illegal or contrary to the Scheme.
34.
Thus, the Notice dated 22.08.2025 issued by the Director General of
Police, Police Headquarters, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh, and the Result
Notification dated 21.07.2025 issued by the Director General of Police, Police
Headquarters, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh, pursuant to the advertisement
dated 08.06.2024, warrant no interference.
35. Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review