Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee
WPA 13054 of 2024
With
CAN 1 of 2024
With
CAN 2 of 2024
With
CAN 3 of 2025
Gourab Kumar Sadhu & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
With
WPA 26400 of 2024
With
CAN 1 of 2025
Tanushri Mondal & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
With
WPA 3028 of 2024
With
CAN 2 of 2024
With
CAN 3 of 2024
With
CAN 5 of 2025
Debajyoti Dey & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the petitioners
: Mr. Pratik Dhar, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Sarwar Jahan,
Mr. Shmim-ul-Bari.
For the State (in WPA 13054 of 2024
& WPA 26400 of 2024)
: Mr. Swapan Kr. Datta, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Rajat Dutta,
Mr. Dipankar Dasgupta.
For the State (in WPA 3028 of 2024)
: Mr. Sirsanya Bandyopadhyay,
Ms. Tapati Samanta.
For the respondent nos. 13 to 15
: Mr. Tanoy Chakraborty,
Mr. Chhandak Dutta.
For the B.C. Roy Engineering College : Mr. Kamalesh Bhattacharya,
Ms. Rama Halder,
Ms. Eshita Mondal.
For M.A.K.A.U.T. University
: Ms. Nandini Mitra,
Mr. Sakya Maity,
Mr. S. Banerjee.
Heard on
: 18.12.2025
Judgment on
: 15.01.2026
Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.:Preface:
1.
For the sake of thematic coherence, all three writ petitions are taken up for
hearing together. The aforesaid writ petitions have been filed by a group of
students presently pursuing the four-year B.Tech. Programme (Batch 2023–
2027) at Dr. B.C. Engineering College, Durgapur, Paschim Burdwan, calling into
question the legality and justifiability of Notification No. 466-Edn(T)/10M04/2004 (Part-IV) dated 16.10.2023 issued by the Deputy Secretary to the
Government of West Bengal, Department of Higher Education, whereby a midcourse enhancement of fees was directed. The petitioners have, therefore, prayed
for issuance of a writ of certiorari for quashing the said notification dated
16.10.2023. In addition, the petitioners have prayed for a writ of mandamus
directing the college authorities to withdraw and/or cancel the revised fee
structure appearing at Annexure-P-4 to the writ petition and to accept fees in
accordance with the earlier fee structure as reflected in Annexure-P-2 to the writ
petition.
Petitioners’ case:
2.
Before entering into the merits of the issues involved in the present writ
petition, it would be apposite to briefly advert to the facts leading to its
institution.
3.
In or about August 2023, the petitioners secured admission to the four-year
B.Tech. undergraduate course in different departments of Dr. B.C. Roy
Engineering College, Durgapur, a self-financing engineering institution affiliated
to Maulana Abul Kalam Azad University of Technology ( for short, MAKAUT) and
approved by the All India Council for Technical Education, New Delhi
(respondent no. 5 herein), as well as by the Department of Higher Education,
Government of West Bengal, through the West Bengal Joint Entrance
Examination (in short,WBJEE) and Joint Entrance Examination-Main ( in short,
JEE-Main), conducted by National Testing Agency (in short, NTA) in 2023.
4.
At the time of admission, the respondent college communicated a definitive
and uniform fee structure, which was accepted by the petitioners as governing the
financial terms of their academic engagement. Relying upon the aforesaid
representation, the petitioners completed their admission formalities. Several
petitioners, acting on the disclosed fee structure, applied for and obtained
educational loans from various nationalised and private banking institutions,
which were sanctioned strictly on the basis of the fee structure communicated by
the respondent college.
5.
In October 2023, the petitioners duly completed their registration. Upon such
registration, the petitioners’ admissions stood formally confirmed, and the
statutory window for withdrawal from, or migration to, any other institution for
the relevant academic session stood closed.
6.
Subsequent thereto, on 16th October, 2023, the Department of Higher
Education, Government of West Bengal, issued Notification No. 466-Edn(T)/10M-04/2004 (Part IV), whereby the upper fee ceiling for self-financing
engineering colleges in the State was revised upwards, ostensibly to address
increased operational and infrastructural costs.
7.
In November 2023, after completion of the MAKAUT registration process,
the respondent college authorities (respondent nos. 10–12), placing reliance on
the aforesaid notification, issued a revised fee demand upon the petitioners with
effect from the second semester commencing in January 2024. The revised fee
structure introduced an enhanced tuition fee, along with the imposition of a
newly levied “development fee” of Rs. 9,075 per semester.
8.
The cumulative effect of the revised demand resulted in an increase of nearly
37.50% over the fee structure originally disclosed at the time of admission. The
petitioners contend that the respondent college, having disclosed a definitive fee
structure at the time of admission and thereby inducing the petitioners to enroll
on the basis of such representation, subsequently altered the said fee structure to
their grave prejudice.
9.
The petitioners further contend that the mid-course escalation of fees is in
violation of Regulation 7 of the AICTE Regulations, 1994, which mandates that
once a fee structure is fixed, it shall remain unchanged for a minimum block
period of three years.
10.
In December 2023, the petitioners raised objections to the impugned fee hike.
However, finding no relief at the institutional level, the petitioners issued a
formal Notice Demanding Justice on 25th January, 2024, calling upon the
respondents to withdraw the impugned notification and restore the original fee
structure. Despite receipt of the said notice, the respondents failed to take any
remedial steps and continued to insist upon payment of the enhanced fees
between February and June 2024. Hence, this writ petition.
Respondents’ Case :
11.
Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College, Durgapur, is a self-financing professional
institution approved by the All-India Council for Technical Education (AICTE)
and the Department of Higher Education, Government of West Bengal, and
affiliated to Maulana Abul Kalam Azad University of Technology (MAKAUT), and
that it is governed by the regulatory framework prescribed by the State of West
Bengal through the Department of Higher Education.
12.
In 2016, the Fee Structure Committee headed by the Hon’ble Justice Pradipta
Roy, upon taking note of the fact that the fees charged by self-financing
engineering and technological colleges in West Bengal were lower than those
charged by comparable institutions in other States of the country, recommended
an enhancement of tuition fees by 10%. Pursuant thereto, the State Government,
by a notification dated 17.06.2016, revised the fee structure for undergraduate
courses in Engineering, Technology, Pharmacy, and Architecture in private and
self-financing institutions from the academic session 2016–17.
13.
Admittedly, since 2016, there has been no revision of course fees in selffinancing engineering and technology colleges in West Bengal. However,
respondent nos. 10 and 11, and even respondent no. 14, had, on numerous
occasions, approached the competent authority seeking revision of the fee
structure, contending that the colleges had been suffering significant financial
losses owing to inflation, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, and increased
operational expenditure.
14.
The State Level Fee Structure Committee held a meeting on 10.07.2019 for the
purpose of making recommendations regarding tuition and other fees for
undergraduate professional technical courses in self-financing engineering
colleges in the State of West Bengal. Thereafter, on 09.06.2023, the Committee
requested respondent no. 14 to appear before it in connection with the said
exercise.
15.
Lastly, after almost 7 years, in exercise of its statutory and administrative
powers, the Department of Higher Education, Government of West Bengal,
issued Notification No. 466-Edn-(T)/10M-04/2004 (Part IV) dated 16th October,
2023, revising the upper ceiling of fees chargeable by self-financing engineering
colleges in the State for the academic session 2023–2024 onwards.
16.
The said notification was issued with the approval of the competent authority
and expressly supersedes all prior orders governing fee ceilings, with the
objective of ensuring financial sustainability, maintenance of academic
standards, and infrastructural development of self-financing professional
institutions.
17.
Pursuant to the aforesaid notification, the respondent college revised its fee
structure with effect from the second semester commencing in January 2024.
The revised structure included an enhanced tuition fee and the introduction of a
development fee, framed strictly within the maximum ceilings prescribed by the
State Government.
18.
The Respondents contend that the revision was necessitated due to a
substantial increase in operational expenditures, including faculty remuneration,
infrastructural maintenance, laboratory
upgrades,
and compliance with
regulatory requirements, which had remained unaddressed for several preceding
academic years. The revised fee structure is neither arbitrary nor retrospective, as
it was implemented prospectively in accordance with the State notification and
within the permissible regulatory framework applicable to self-financing
institutions.
19.
The prospectus itself clearly informed the students that the fee structure was
liable to be revised from time to time in accordance with government decisions.
The college authorities did not enhance the fee schedule on their own but strictly
acted in compliance with the decision of the State Government as notified on
16.10.2023 with immediate effect. However, taking into consideration the
inconvenience that the students might face, implementation of the revised fee
demand was deferred until December, 2023.
20.
The respondents dispute the applicability of Regulation 7(6) of the AICTE
Regulations, 1994, relied upon by the petitioners, contending that the said
regulation has been superseded and/or suitably modified by subsequent Statelevel fee regulatory frameworks governing self-financing technical institutions. It
is further contended that, in terms of the mandate contained in the Approval
Process Handbook for 2023, which is binding on the petitioners, a self-financing
engineering college is required to charge only such fees as are fixed by the State
or the Fee Regulatory Committee.
21.
According to the Respondents, the writ petition is devoid of merit, as the
impugned fee structure is in conformity with the prevailing statutory framework
and is essential for the continued functioning and development of the institution,
as well as for the fulfillment of its academic obligations towards the students.
Arguments:
22.
Mr. Dhar, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the petitioners,
submitted that the petitioners are not opposed to the enhancement of fees by the
College. The primary question that arises for consideration in the present litigation,
however, is whether such enhancement of the fee structure can be effected for a
single semester or whether it must apply to the entire course. In this context, he
drew my attention to the document annexed as Annexure P-2 to the writ petition
(WPA 3028 of 2025), titled ‘Fee Structure B.Tech 2023–2027’. He laid immense
emphasis on the word ‘structure’ to contend that it must be viewed in its entirety and
not in a piecemeal manner. By way of analogy, he submitted that a ‘structure’ may be
compared to a building comprising several floors; however, when one speaks of the
building, it cannot be viewed floor by floor in isolation.
23.
He argued that it is not the petitioners’ case that a self-financing engineering
college lacks the authority to enhance fees. According to him, however, any such fee
enhancement cannot be made applicable to students who have already taken
admission. He further submitted that the right to revise course fees does not include
the right to disrupt the ‘Fee Structure’. In his submission, the ‘structure’ would stand
breached if the fees are enhanced after the first or second semester.
24.
He contended that there must be consistency and transparency in determining
the ‘Fee Structure’ and affordability of a student to pay that fees are also to be taken
into account. He further contended that a student must know about it before taking
admission. He argued that since the petitioners have taken admission based on the
fee structure shown to them, they cannot be forced to pay mid-course enhanced fees.
25.
To bolster his submissions, he cited a decision, reported at 2019 SCC OnLine Del
6737 (Shanker Doon & Ors. vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Ors.). In addition, he
relied on an unreported decision of a Single Bench of the High Court at Uttarakanda
rendered in a batch of writ petitions, Writ Petition (M/S) No. 513 of 2020 & Ors.
(Bindiya Khatri & Ors. vs. State of Uttarakhand & Ors.) and another unreported
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissing the Spl. Leave to Appeal (C) No.
(s). 19637 of 2019, which was preferred to assail the decision rendered in case of
Shanker Doon & Ors. (supra).
26.
Per contra, Mr. Bhattacharya, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the college
authorities, submitted that there had been no revision of fees for the last seven years.
He contended that, pursuant to the decision of the State Government, the college is
required to enhance the salaries of its staff and faculty members. However, in view of
the interim order passed in the present writ petition, the college has been unable to
effect such salary enhancements. He further submitted that other operational costs
have meanwhile increased.
27.
He further contended that the prospectus itself clearly specified that the ‘fee
structure is subject to change from time to time as per Government decision’.
Therefore, according to him, even at the time of admission, the students were fully
aware that the fee structure for the entire course could be revised. He claimed that
other students of same batch have already accepted enhancement of fees and/or
revision of fee structure.
28.
He also submitted that the decisions relied upon by the petitioners were
rendered in the context of different statutory framework and are, therefore,
distinguishable on facts.
29.
Mr. Dutta, learned Senior Advocate and Government Pleader appearing on
behalf of the State respondents, submitted that, in accordance with the provisions of
the applicable legislation, a Fee Regulatory Committee was duly constituted. The
said Committee recommended enhancement of fees, and pursuant to such
recommendation, the fees were revised. He further submitted that, despite being
aware that the fee structure was liable to be revised in accordance with Government
decisions, the students, including the petitioners, took admission. Therefore,
according to him, implementation of the notification dated 16.10.2023 in respect of
the petitioners and other students admitted to the B.Tech course for the batch 2023–
27 cannot be said to be legally unsustainable.
30.
Mr. Chakraborty, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of respondent nos. 13
and 14, contended that the course fees in self-financing engineering and
technological colleges have not been revised for the last seven years. He further
submitted that, when compared with the fee structures of similarly placed
institutions in other States of the country, the revised fee structure still remains
considerably lower.
31.
Mr. Chakraborty submitted that, under the applicable rules, colleges are
required to maintain high standards of faculty, state-of-the-art laboratory facilities,
and various other amenities and services in accordance with the stipulations of the
AICTE and the affiliating university. He contended that tuition fees constitute the
sole source of income for such colleges. According to him, the colleges are obliged to
revise the salaries of staff and faculty members and to pay dearness allowance in
accordance with Government norms, while other operational costs have also
increased. As a result, there exists a serious imbalance between income and
expenditure in most such institutions, thereby justifying the enhancement of fees. He
further submitted that students of other colleges have accepted the revised fee
structure and that only the present petitioners are resisting the revision
32.
He asserted that the judgments relied upon by the petitioners were rendered
under entirely different legislative frameworks and in distinct factual matrices, and
therefore, the principles laid down therein are not applicable to the present case.
Lastly, he submitted that although the notification dated 16.10.2023 was issued with
immediate effect, its implementation was deferred until January, 2024, keeping in
view the inconvenience that might otherwise be caused to the students.
Analysis and conclusion:
33.
Therefore, although the petitioners have challenged the legality of the
notification dated 16.10.2023, their principal contention is that the said notification
cannot be made applicable to the petitioners who had already secured admission and
are presently pursuing the four-year B.Tech course for the academic batch 2023–
2027. Accordingly, the central issue that arises for consideration is whether the
notification dated 16.10.2023 can be applied to students, including the petitioners,
who were admitted in the year 2023. Thus, the petitioners have abandoned the
challenge to the legality of the notification dated 16.10.2023.
34.
With a view to conferring statutory powers upon the All India Council for
Technical Education (hereinafter referred to as “AICTE”),forensuring proper
planning and coordinated development of technical education throughout the
country, regulating the technical education system, maintaining norms and
standards, and prescribing guidelines for student admissions and the charging of
fees etc., the All India Council for Technical Education Act, 1987 (hereinafter
referred to as “the 1987 Act”) was enacted. Clauses (j) and (o) of Section 10 of the
1987 Act cast a duty upon the AICTE to lay down norms and guidelines for charging
tuition and other fees and to prescribe guidelines for admission of students to
technical institutions and universities imparting technical education. Further,
Section 23 of the 1987 Act empowers the AICTE to frame regulations for carrying out
the purposes of the Act.
35.
In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (j) and clause (o) of Section 10 read
with Section 23 of the 1987 Act, AICTE has made All India Council for Technical
Education (norms and guidelines for fees and guidelines for admissions in
professional colleges) Regulations 1994 (for short, 1994 Regulations).
36.
In order to shed light on the issue involved in the writ petition, it would be
appropriate to examine the statutory framework of Regulation 7 of the 1994
Regulations. Regulation 7(1) mandates that tuition and other fees of a professional
college shall be determined by a State Level Committee. Regulation 7(2) directs the
AICTE to constitute a Standing Committee for each State to fix the ceiling on the fees
chargeable for individual courses offered by professional colleges.
37.
The Regulations further provide that the determination of tuition and other fees
shall be made after affording the concerned colleges an opportunity to place relevant
materials on record and on the basis of an assessment of the expenditure of the
professional college. Regulation 7(6) stipulates that no professional college shall be
entitled to receive from any student any payment or amount in addition to the fee
fixed by the Committee.
38.
Regulation 7(7) mandates that professional colleges shall intimate the competent
authority, in advance, of the fees chargeable for the entire course commencing from
the academic year for which admissions are to be made. The total fee shall be divided
according to the number of years or, as the case may be, the number of semesters of
study for the course. At the first instance, only the fee for the first year or semester
shall be collected. The fee chargeable by a professional college shall, in all cases, be
subject to the ceiling fixed by the Standing Committee.
39.
As a general rule, any enhancement of fees is required to operate prospectively,
that is, for future academic years or batches, and not retrospectively so as to affect
students who are already enrolled. In catena of judicial decisions, it was ruled that
the application of a revised fee structure to students who have secured admission
under a previously disclosed fee regime is often regarded as arbitrary and legally
impermissible. Moreso, the principle of contractual stability mandates that an
educational institution is entitled to charge only such fees as were promised at the
time of admission.
40.
However, in the present case, the respondents have contended that the right to
revise the fee structure mid-session was expressly reserved. It has further been
asserted that the enhancement of fees by the colleges was carried out in compliance
with the directions issued by the State Government. Therefore, the next question
that arises for consideration is whether, in circumstances where the power to revise
the fee structure is expressly reserved, a mid-session or mid-course enhancement of
fees can be legally effected, particularly when such enhancement is implemented
pursuant to a binding decision of the Government or a competent regulatory
authority.
41.
Admittedly, in the instant case, in the document titled “Fee Structure B.Tech
(2023–2027)”, the word “Structure” has been used. However, it is also an admitted
position that, on the very next page of the said document, it is specified that the fee
structure is subject to change from time to time in accordance with Government
decisions.
42.
The notification dated 16.10.2023 was issued in supersession of all previous
orders and/or notifications issued by the Department of Higher Education,
Technical Branch, and it was stipulated therein that the notification would take effect
from the date of its issuance. Notably, Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
provides that the power to issue a notification includes the power to amend, vary, or
rescind it.Therefore, it can safely be held that the State is empowered to rescind the
earlier notification and issue a fresh notification in its place.
43.
The question that now arises for consideration is whether the notification can be
given effect to in respect of students who have already taken admission in the fouryear B.Tech course (2023–2027), as such application would result in a change in the
fee structure.
44.
Primarily, the resolution of the said questions must be traced to the language
employed in the notification itself. In the notification dated 16.10.2023, it has been
stipulated that the fee structure for the programmes shall continue for at least four
(04) years in respect of the B.Tech and B.Pharma courses with effect from the
academic session 2023–2024, and the details of the fee structure applicable for the
academic year 2023–2024 have been specifically enumerated therein. The
notification further clarifies that the tuition fees and other fees are applicable to
students “to be admitted” in the first year of undergraduate Engineering and
Technology, Pharmacy, and Architecture courses, as well as to students admitted
through lateral entry, in self-financing Engineering and Technology, Pharmacy, and
Architecture colleges in the State, with effect from the academic year 2023–2024.
45.
Therefore, although the prospectus used the expression “Fee Structure B.Tech
(2023–2027)”, the notification employs the phrase “with effect from the academic
year 2023–2024”. It is pertinent to note that, in the present case, the mode of
payment of fees was on a semester-to-semester basis. Furthermore, Regulation 7(7)
mandates that the total fee shall be divided according to the number of years or, as
the case may be, the number of semesters of study for the course. At the first
instance, only the fee for the first year or semester is required to be collected. In all
cases, the fee chargeable by a professional college remains subject to the ceiling fixed
by the Standing Committee.
46.
Therefore, the fee structure has not been treated as indivisible either under the
1994 Regulations or under the notification dated 16.10.2023; rather, it has been
divided according to the number of years or, as the case may be, the number of
semesters of study for the course.
47.
Mr. Dhar laid emphasis on the expression “to be admitted” to contend that the
use of such words indicates that the notification is intended to operate prospectively.
Mr. Chakraborty, however, refuted this contention and asserted that the expression
“to be admitted” was used to qualify the category of students and not to indicate the
time from which the notification would take effect.
48.
In the present case, the academic year commenced in July 2023, with the first
semester running from July 2023 to December 2023. The academic year 2023–2024
comprises three semesters, namely, July 2023 to December 2023, January 2024 to
June 2024, and July 2024 to December 2024. Thus, it is evident that, despite being
aware that the academic year had already commenced in July 2023, the effect of the
notification dated 16.10.2023 was consciously given from the date of its issuance and
from the academic year 2023–2024.
49.
Undoubtedly, the use of the expression “to be admitted” gives rise to a degree of
ambiguity. However, it is a well-settled principle that where a notification expressly
specifies the date from which it is to take effect, such explicit stipulation prevails
over any conflicting or ambiguous language appearing elsewhere in the notification.
In that backdrop, the intention discernable from the notification is manifestly clear
that the notification dated 16.10.2023 was intended to take effect from the date of its
issuance and for the academic year 2023–2024 and the purpose of the notification
was to determine the fee structure from the academic year 2023-24.
50.
A prospectus or brochure ordinarily operates as a contractual arrangement
between the student and the educational institution. Upon enrolment, a student is
deemed to have accepted the terms and conditions set out therein. Where the
prospectus expressly reserves the right to revise the fee structure in accordance with
decisions taken by the Government, the institution may, in appropriate cases,
enforce a mid-session enhancement of fees even in respect of existing students. It is
pertinent to note that, in the present case, the enhancement of fees is a direct
consequence of a binding governmental mandate and has been implemented with
effect from January 2024.
51.
Needless to state, the writ jurisdiction cannot be allowed to be invoked to
facilitate the avoidance of contractual obligations voluntarily undertaken. The
occurrence of hardship or inconvenience in the performance of conditions agreed to
under a contract affords no justification for non-compliance with the terms of the
contract, which the parties had accepted with open eyes.
52.
Undeniably, the decision in Shanker Doon & Ors. (supra) was rendered in a
different statutory framework. In that case, the dispute relating to the fee structure
pertained primarily to two academic years, namely, 2014–2015 and 2015–2016. The
fee structure for the academic year 2014–2015 was sought to be revised on the basis
of a notification dated 19.02.2016. Upon considering the applicable statutory
provisions, the Hon’ble Division Bench of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi held that
the
retrospective
operation
of
the
notification
dated
19.02.2016
was
impermissible.With regard to the academic year 2015–2016, it was noted that
although a recommendation for revision of the fee structure had been made in
November 2014, the notification giving effect to such recommendation was issued
only on 19.02.2016 and was subsequently rescinded on 10.03.2016. In those
circumstances, the Hon’ble Court permitted the college to charge fees as
recommended, but only prospectively from the academic year 2015–2016.
53.
Similarly, in the case of Bindiya Khatri & Ors. (supra), there existed a specific
statutory provision, namely sub-section (14) of Section 4 of the Uttarakhand
Unaided Private Professional Educational Institutions (Regulation of Admission and
Fixation of Fee) Act, 2006, which provided that the fee determined shall be
applicable to a student admitted in that academic year and that the fee applicable at
the time of admission of a student shall not be revised until the completion of his or
her course of study.
54.
Therefore, the propositions laid down in the aforesaid two decisions cannot be
applied to the case at hand.
Order:
55.
Thus, for the reasons discussed and recorded in the preceding paragraphs,
this Court is of the view that the contentions raised by the petitioners are devoid
of merit and, accordingly, cannot be accepted.
56.
Accordingly, the writ petitions, along with the applications, if any, filed in
connection therewith, are dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
Later :
After the pronouncement of the judgment, Mr. Jahan, learned Advocate
appearing for the writ petitioner, prays for a stay of the operation of this judgment.
I do not find any scope to pass an order staying the operation of the judgment
dismissing the writ petition. Accordingly, the prayer is considered but rejected.
(Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review