Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC040007572020
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/297/2020
TAMAT TAKOH
S/O SHRI TAPOR TAKOH, PO OYAN, PS SILLE,EAST SIANG DISTRICT, AP.
2: MOJIT PAO
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT. GUPAL PAO
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
3: KINSOR BORI
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT. PORSING BORI
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
4: MONIDOR BORI
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT. MAHENTA BORI
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
5: MUHIM PAIT
Page No.# 2/11
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT. ARDLIRAM PAIT
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
6: BASONSINGH PAO
Age:
Occupation :
S/O LT. LAHORSINGH VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
7: TAKUT PAYANG
Age:
Occupation :
S/O TANONG PAYANG
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
8: YAMENG TALI
Age:
Occupation :
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
9: TAJING SARO
Age:
Occupation :
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP.
10: BENJAMIN TALI
Age:
Page No.# 3/11
Occupation :
VILLAGE OYAN
PO OYAN
PS SILLE
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
AP
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF AP, ITANAGAR.
2:THE SECRETARY
Age: 0
Occupation :
LAND MANAGEMENT
GOVT. OF A P
ITANAGAR.
3:THE DIRECTOR
Age: 0
Occupation :
LAND MANAGEMENT
GOVT. OF A P
ITANAGAR
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Occupation :
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
GOVT. OF AP
PASIGHAT.
5:THE ADDITIONAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Age: 0
Occupation :
EAST SIANG
GOVT. OFA P
RUKSIN.
6:THE DISTRICT LAND REVENUE AND SETTLEMENT OFFICER
Age: 0
Occupation :
EAST SIANG
GOVT . OF AP
PASIGHAT.
7:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
Age: 0
Page No.# 4/11
Occupation :
SILLE OYAN
EAST SIANG DISTRICT
GOVT. OF AP.
8:THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL EDUCATION
Age: 0
Occupation :
EAST SIANG DISTRICT PASIGHAT
Advocate for the Petitioner
Kamchi,Adam Tatak
: T T Tara, Sr. Adv, Tamar Gadi,D Loyi,Gamken Bam,Terji
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Taba Tagum,Tagum Jamoh,SC (Education)
Linked Case : WP(C)/310/2020
Obang Apang
Age: 55
Occupation :
Address:S/o Late Gogom Apang
aged about 55 years
permanent residentof Oyan village
PO/PS Sille Oyan
Circle
East siang District
AP
VERSUS
The State of AP and Ors
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:represented by the Secretary
Land Management
govt. of AP
Itanagar
2:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 5/11
Pasighat
AP
3:The Estate Officer-cum-Circle Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Sille-Oyan Circle
East Siang Dist. AP
-----------Advocate for : Rintu Saikia
Sr. Adv
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for The State of AP and Ors: Advocate ,
, appearing for 2,
3, respectively.
Linked Case : WP(C)/273/2022
Taniram Mingki
Age: 40
Occupation :
Address:S/o Lt. Tatok Mingki
Village Sika Tode Village
PO/PS Sille Oyan
East Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and 2 Ors.
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Represented by the Secretary (Land Management)
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
2:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:East Siang District
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Estate Officer cum Circle Officer
Page No.# 6/11
Age: 0
Occupation :
Address:Sille Oyan Circle
East Siang District
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh.
-----------Advocate for : T T Tara
Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for THE STATE OF AP and 2 Ors.: Advocate ,
, appearing for 2,
3, respectively.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
ORDER
09.09.2026
All these 3 writ petitions being connected and analogous, those have been
heard together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2.
The challenge is against a notification issued by the Land Management
Department, Government of AP dated 19.09.2019 as per which, an area of land
measuring 73.26 acres which has been described in the Schedule has been
stated to have been voluntarily donated by the land owners and were to be
utilized for the purpose of the establishment of the Sille-Oyan Circle
Headquarter / Township. The said notification also states that the earlier
notification dated 12.12.2016 stood superseded. The primary contention in
challenging this notification is that there was no donation of the land in question
which has been assumed by the authorities to the prejudice of the petitioners.
3.
I have heard Shri TT Tara, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri G. Bam,
learned counsel for the petitioners in WP(C)/297/2020 & WP(C)/273/2022 and
Shri R. Saikia, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri I. Bam, learned counsel
Page No.# 7/11
for the petitioner in WP(C)/310/2020. I have also heard Ms. R. Basar, learned
Government Advocate, AP and Shri T. Tagum, learned Standing Counsel,
Education Department.
4.
Shri Tara, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has submitted that so
far as the notification dated 12.12.2016 is concerned, the same would show that
a procedure was undertaken for the donated land in question which was
restricted to an area of 4.6 acres. He has submitted that the area has been
shown in the Schedule appended to the notification dated 12.12.2016. However,
the impugned notification has been issued by inflating the area to 73.26 acres,
which is beyond the area donated by the land owners. In this connection, the
learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has drawn the attention of this Court
to the pleadings made in paragraph 33 inWP(C)/297/2020.
5.
Endorsing the submissions of the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
in WP(C)/297/2020 & WP(C)/273/2022, Shri Saikia, learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioner in WP(C)/310/2020 has submitted that he has never donated his
land and the State authorities are taking forceful measures for evicting him from
his own land. He has submitted that unless there is a voluntary donation by
him, the State cannot assume that such land has been donated. He however
submits that his land is beyond the area mentioned in the notification dated
12.12.2016.
6.
Ms. Basar, learned Government Advocate has submitted that though
initially the notification dated 12.12.2016 was issued, the same was superseded
by the notification dated 19.09.2019, as per which the area in question which
was voluntarily donated was 73.26 acres. By drawing the attention of this Court
to the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent nos. 4 to 7 in
WP(C)/297/2020, learned State Counsel has submitted that such donation was
Page No.# 8/11
made orally.
7.
The learned State Counsel has also denied the aspect that though the
petitioners have relied upon a preliminary notification allegedly issued by the
Deputy Commissioner, East Siang District wherein the land donated has been
stated to be 4.6 acres, the land under the notification dated 12.12.2016, which
is not disputed, is much more than that and has been specifically mentioned in
the schedule appended to the said notification.
8.
Shri Tagum, learned Standing Counsel, Education Department has
submitted that he has no role but has endorsed the submissions made on behalf
of the State.
9.
The primary contention advanced by the petitioners is on the aspect of
voluntary donation with regard to the land mentioned in the notification dated
19.09.2019. The land which has been stated to be voluntarily donated measures
73.26 acres. The said notification also supersedes the earlier notification dated
12.12.2016. A bare perusal of the earlier notification dated 12.12.2016 would
show that the land which was voluntarily donated is of different plots measuring
7512 sq. mtrs., 1150 sq. mtrs., 29,299 sq. mtrs. and 6314.3 sq. mtrs. There is a
clear and specific pleading by the petitioners in WP(C)/297/2020 in paragraph
33 that there was no voluntary donation of the land mentioned in the
notification dated 19.09.2019. As mentioned above, the learned Senior Counsel
for the petitioners have however conceded that so far as the land mentioned in
the notification dated 12.12.2016 is concerned, they do not dispute to such
voluntary donations.
10.
The aforesaid averments being factual in nature, it is required to examine
the response made by the State to such categorical averments made on behalf
Page No.# 9/11
of the petitioners. The respondents in their affidavit filed on 19.06.2021 has not
specifically dealt with the averments made in paragraph 33 of the writ petition.
On the other hand, in paragraph 5 of the affidavit-in-opposition, an omnibus
statement has been made in connection with a number of paragraphs. For ready
reference, those are extracted hereinbelow:
Paragraph 33 of WP(C)/297/2020
“33.
That it is respectfully submits that the petitioners have objection
with regards to the land measuring 44266. Sq. mtrs i.e 11 acres of land
donated by the villagers for establishment of various government of
offices. Nevertheless is against the arbitrarily and illegal action of the state
respondents by the issuing notification dated 12.12.2016 whereby the
additional land of 62 acres land which is under possession of the
petitioners and others. Be that as it may, it is relevant to point out that by
the illegal impugned notification 19.09.2019 the state respondents by its
conduct itself is trying to acquire land illegally and by which whole
villagers who have established themselves will be displace without any
reasons. Therefore, this Honb'le Court may be pleased to direct to
respondent authorities to restrain from taking any coercive action against
the land owners in term of the impugned preliminary Notification dated
19.09.2019.”
Paragraph 5 of the affidavit-in-opposition
“5. That with reference to statements made in Para- 31, 32, 33, 34, 35,
36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43 & 44 of the instant writ petition your
humble deponent vehemently denies the statements made therein and
further reiterates that the present petitioner are the illegal encroachers of
Page No.# 10/11
the Government possessed land by taking the advantage of the formal
defect that the land is not Government notified land. That not only 4.6
acres of land has been donated but about more than 70 acres of land has
been orally donated to the Government of Arunachal Pradesh and the
Government of Arunachal Pradesh is in continuous possession of the same
for more than 60 years. That in fact the notification dated 12/12/2016
was notified by misleading the innocent villagers of Oyan Village.
Therefore the present preliminary notification of 2019 is notified by the
Secretary (LM) Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh superseding the previous
notification of 2016. That, there is no any case in favour of the writ
petitioners, but they are the illegal encroachers and they are liable to be
evicted in due course of time as per law. Moreover, the preliminary
notification of 2019 is yet to be considered and is at the stage of claims
and objections by the aggrieved so called private land owners and as such
no, any final notification has been issued yet. Hence this writ petition is
not maintainable in the eye of law being filed prematurely before issuance
of any final notification and as such the same is liable to be dismissed
with costs.”
11.
Though a Writ Court is not a Court on facts, in the instant case, the
aspect that there was no donation has not been specifically dealt with and the
only contention advanced on behalf of the State is that there is an oral
donation. In the considered opinion of this Court, oral donation in respect of a
huge area pertaining to 73.26 acres cannot be recognized by law. As noted
above, so far as the area connected with the notification dated 12.12.2016 is
concerned, the same is not the aspect of the present challenge and therefore,
there would be no embargo on the part of the State to go ahead with the said
Page No.# 11/11
notification. However, so far as the notification dated 19.09.2019 is concerned,
the same cannot be acted upon for lands which are beyond the areas
mentioned in the notification dated 12.12.2016.
12.
This Court has also noted that interim orders have been passed by this
Court staying the impugned order dated 19.09.2019 as well as subsequent
eviction orders. Ms. Basar, learned Government Advocate has also informed that
pursuant to such interim orders, the eviction orders have been recalled.
13.
Be that as it may and in view of the finding of this Court that the
impugned notification/order dated 19.09.2019 is not sustainable, the land which
are beyond the land covered by the notification dated 12.12.2016, which are in
the possession of the petitioners, are not to be disturbed. The respondent
authorities, however, would be at liberty to initiate appropriate land acquisition
proceedings if the land is required for public purposes, which however has to be
done strictly in accordance with law. The interim order passed earlier stands
merged with this final order.
14.
The writ petitions accordingly stand allowed, in the manner indicated
above.
15.
No order, as to cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review