Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/21
GAHC040017652025
2026:GAU-AP:154
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : IA(C)/260/2025
Tadar Mangku
Son of Late Tadar Tagam, permanent resident of Village Langht Loth, PO and PS
Nyapin, Kurung Kumey District, Arunachal Pradesh 791118 and presently residing at
Pachin Colony, PO and PS Naharlagun, Papumpare District, Arunachal Pradesh
791110
VERSUS
Tai Nikio
Son of Late Tai Kami, permanent resident of Village Peel, PO and PS Sangram,
Kurung Kumey District, Arunachal Pradesh 791118 and presently residing at
Karsingsa, Doimukh, Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh 791123
Advocate for the Petitioner
: R. Biswas; D. J. Kapil; K. Posi; D Tadar.
Advocate for the Respondent : Mr. P. K. Tiwari, Sr. Adv.; Rinchin Ledo Thungon,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
28.01.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
17.02.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
N/A
Page No.# 2/21
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
ORDER
Heard Mr. R. Biswas and Mr. D. J.
Kapil, learned counsels for the
applicant/election petitioner. Also heard Mr. P. K. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel
assisted by Mr. U. Pathak, learned counsel for the opposite party/respondent.
2.
This is an application under Order VII Rule 14(3) read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, by the applicant/election petitioner seeking
leave to produce and introduce additional documents along with the Evidencein-Affidavit of 4 (four) witnesses.
3.
The applicant/election petitioner has challenged the election of the opposite
party in the 19th Nyapin ST Assembly Constituency during the 11 th Arunachal
Pradesh Legislative Assembly Election 2024 on the ground of, inter alia,
reception of void votes, booth capturing, concealment and false information in
Form 26 etc., thereby, materially affecting the result of the election of the
returned candidate i.e. the opposite party/respondent.
4.
The election petition being EP No. 07 of 2024 was fixed for filing of
evidence-in-affidavit of the witnesses by the applicant/election petitioner on
24.10.2025. It is the case of the applicant/election petitioner that, subsequent
to the filing of the said election petition, the applicant/election petitioner has
come across and obtained certain documents which are material and relevant
for just adjudication of the case. It is contended that the material facts in
connection with all the aforesaid additional documents have already been
pleaded in the election petition. Therefore, the applicant/election petitioner
Page No.# 3/21
seeks to produce and introduce the following additional documents:
“…A. A Screenshot of the condolence message posted by the son Tai Logu in his
Facebook page regarding death of his father Late Tai Nilo on 06.03.2022 which
proves that a bogus vote has been cast against his Epic number at 16 Pagba polling
station. The said Facebook Post came to the notice of the Election Petitioner after
filing of the Election Petition. The said document is marked as Exhibit-PW-1/17 in the
Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
B. A copy of the death certificate showing that Late Niagh Yadek had passed away on
11.07.2023 but bogus vote has been cast against his Epic number at 16 Pagba polling
station. The copy of the said death certificate was handed over to the Election
Petitioner after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is marked as
Exhibit- PW-1/18 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
C. The videography of Pagba, Peel and Kambang Polling Station provided in a Pen
Drive along with the Covering Letter dated 28.05.2025 and Certificates of the Data
Entry Operator, Office of the District Election Officer, Kurung Kumey, Arunachal
Pradesh. The videography has been handed over to the election petitioner in terms of
Order dated 19.05.2025 passed in I.A. (C) No. 54/2025. The said document is marked
as Exhibit- PW-1/20 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
D. The dairy of the Presiding Officer recording that the Returned Candidate was
campaigning close to the polling station. This was provided to the Election Petitioner
after passing of the Order dated 19.05.2025 in I.A. (C) No. 54/2025. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/21 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
E. A copy of the death certificate showing that Late Dekey Tania had passed away on
26.11.2023 but bogus vote has been cast against his Epic number at 30 Peel polling
station. The copy of the said death certificate was handed over to the Election
Petitioner after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is marked as
Exhibit- PW-1/22 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
F. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Tai Kelley at Pachin Colony, Naharlagun
shows that he had expired on 01.02.2022. However, bogus vote has been cast against
his Epic number at 30 Peel polling station. The photograph was handed over to the
Election Petitioner after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is marked
as Exhibit- PW-1/23 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
G. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Tai Teli at Sangram Graveyard shows
that he had expired on 12.03.2023. However, bogus vote has been cast against his
Epic number at 30 Peel polling station. The photograph was handed over to the
Election Petitioner after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is marked
as Exhibit- PW-1/24 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
H. A certificate dated 08.09.2025 from the Head/ Gaon Bura of Rowa village which
shows that 16 people whose bogus votes have been cast using their Epic numbers had
died long before the conduct of the General Elections in 2024. The Election Petitioner
Page No.# 4/21
could obtain the said certificate after filing of the election petition. The said document
is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/25 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
I. A letter dated 01.05.2024 under No. KKD/ELN/PB-01/2024 issued by the Nodal
Officer (PB) for District Election Officer, Kurung Kumey to the Chief Election Officer
stating that 283 numbers of postal votes have been received from other districts. The
Election Petitioner could obtain the said letter only after filing of the Election
Petition. The said document is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/30 in the Evidence-inAffidavit of the PW 1.
J. Copy of the RTI application filed by Sri Tader Tabo inquiring regarding NOC for
arms transfer issued by the Officer-In Charge of the Sangram Police Station and the
Reply dated 15.04.2025 in respect of the said RTI application filed by Sri Tader Tabo.
Since, these documents were issued at dates later than that of filing of the election
petition, the election petitioner is producing them now before this Hon'ble Tribunal.
The said RTI application is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/34 and the Reply dated
15.04.2025 is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/35 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
K. Copy of the RTI application filed by Sri Tader Tabo to the Additional Deputy
Commissioner, Nyapin inquiring regarding details of gun license issued and the total
number of gun transfer between 31.01.2024 to 31.05.2024 and the Reply dated
10.04.2025 in respect of the said RTI application filed by Sri Tader Tabo. Since, these
documents were issued at dates later than that of filing of the election petition, the
election petitioner is producing them now before this Hon'ble Tribunal. The said RTI
application is marked as Exhibit- PW-1/36 and the Reply dated 15.04.2025 is marked
as Exhibit- PW-1/37 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 1.
L. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Tai Tania at Pagba Village shows that
she had expired on 14.01.2018. However, bogus vote has been cast against her Epic
number at Pagba polling station. The photograph was handed over to the Election
Petitioner by Sri Tai Radey after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is
marked as Exhibit- PW - 2/1 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 2.
M. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Tai Yachak at Peel Village shows that he
had expired on 24.12.2018. However, bogus vote has been cast against his Epic
number at Peel polling station. The photograph was handed over to the Election
Petitioner by Sri Tai Radey after filing of the Election Petition. The said document is
marked as Exhibit- PW - 2/2 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 2.
N. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Tai Nilo at Pagba Village shows that he
had expired on 06.03.2002. However, bogus vote has been cast against his Epic
number at Pagba polling station. The photograph was handed over to the Election
Petitioner by Sri Niagh Kamin after filing of the Election Petition. The said document
is marked as Exhibit- PW - 3/1 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 3.
O. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Niagh Yadek at Pagba Village shows
that he had expired on 11.07.2023. However, bogus vote has been cast against his
Epic number at Pagba polling station. The photograph was handed over to the
Page No.# 5/21
Election Petitioner by Sri Niagh Kamin after filing of the Election Petition. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-3/2 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 3.
P. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Bamang Roi at Rowa Village shows that
she had expired on 25.12.2018. However, bogus vote has been cast against her Epic
number at Rowa polling station. The photograph was handed over to the Election
Petitioner by Sri Bamang Tarak after filing of the Election Petition. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-4/1 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 4.
Q. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Bamang Taji at Rowa Village shows that
he had expired before voting. However, bogus vote has been cast against his Epic
number at Rowa polling station. The photograph was handed over to the Election
Petitioner by Sri Bamang Tarak after filing of the Election Petition. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-4/2 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 4.
R. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Bamang Yape at Rowa Village shows
that he had expired on 25.08.2022. However, bogus vote has been cast against his
Epic number at Rowa polling station. The photograph was handed over to the
Election Petitioner by Sri Bamang Tarak after filing of the Election Petition. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-4/3 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 4.
S. A photograph of the Memory Stone of Late Bamang Chapo at Rowa Village shows
that he had expired on 09.08.1990. However, bogus vote has been cast against his
Epic number at Rowa polling station. The photograph was handed over to the
Election Petitioner by Sri Bamang Tarak after filing of the Election Petition. The said
document is marked as Exhibit- PW-4/4 in the Evidence-in-Affidavit of the PW 4.
5.
Mr. R. Biswas, learned counsel, submits that a conjoint reading of Order VII
Rule 14 CPC makes it clear that documents in the possession or power of the
plaintiff on which reliance is placed are required to be filed along with the plaint
and entered in the list of documents under Rule 14(1). Where a document is not
in the possession or power of the plaintiff at the time of filing the plaint, the
plaintiff is required to disclose, wherever possible, the person in whose
possession or power such document lies, as provided under Rule 14(2). Further,
if a document could not be produced at the time of filing the plaint, whether
due to non-existence of the document at that time or subsequent discovery, the
plaintiff is not barred from relying upon it, provided that the material and
foundational facts have already been pleaded in the plaint. Order VII Rule 14(3)
Of CPC is the statutorily recognized mechanism for seeking permission of the
Page No.# 6/21
Court to place additional documents on record, provided the material facts
relating thereto are already pleaded and no prejudice is caused to the opposite
party.
6.
Mr. R. Biswas, learned counsel submits that this Court, vide judgment dated
21.03.2025 passed in I.A. (C) No. 182 of 2024, has held that the pleadings in
the Election Petition disclose allegations relating to inclusion of dead, nonexistent and bogus voters in the electoral rolls of 16-Pagba, 29-Kambang, 30Peel and 24-Rowa Polling Stations of 19 th Nyapin (ST) Assembly Constituency;
booth capturing at the said polling stations with the consent of the respondent
or his election agent and corrupt practice, non-disclosure of assets in Form-26
amounting to undue influence and corrupt practice under the Act.
7.
Mr. R. Biswas, learned counsel, submits that the aforesaid documents at
Serial Nos. A to S could not be produced earlier despite the election petitioner’s
due diligence and bona fide efforts. Some of the said documents were neither in
the possession nor within the knowledge of the election petitioner at the time of
filing of the Election Petition, while other documents were not in existence on
that date. All such documents were either obtained, issued, or delivered to the
election petitioner subsequent to the filing of the Election Petition and are
therefore being sought to be placed on record with the leave of this Court.
8.
Mr. Biswas, learned counsel submits that the objection raised by the
respondent pertains to issues such as the competency of the Election Petitioner
to prove the Facebook post, the absence of examination of the author of the
Facebook page, the admissibility of screenshots of social media posts, the nondisclosure of the date of issuance or receipt of death certificates, devices
through which photographs were taken, etc. squarely relate to the relevancy,
Page No.# 7/21
mode of proof and admissibility of the documents and not to their production on
record. Such objections are matters for consideration at the stage of evidence,
either at the time of cross examination of the witnesses or at the stage of final
hearing, when the evidentiary value, authenticity and admissibility of the
documents can be adjudicated upon. The respondent will have ample and full
opportunity to test the veracity, source and admissibility of each of the said
documents during cross-examination of the election petitioner's witnesses. He
submits that at the present stage, while considering an application under Order
VII Rule 14(3) CPC, this Court is only required to examine whether the
documents sought to be produced are relevant to the pleaded issues and
whether sufficient cause has been shown for their non-production earlier. The
objections raised by the respondent do not go to the maintainability of the
application, but seek a premature adjudication on evidentiary objections, which
is impermissible at this stage.
9.
In support of his submissions, Mr. R. Biswas, learned counsel has relied on
the following judgments:
(i). Virender Nath Gautam vs. Satpal Singh and Ors. reported in
(2007) 3 SCC 617.
(ii). Sugandhi (dead) by legal representatives and Anr. Vs. P.
Rajkumar represented by his Power Agent Imam Oli , reported in
(2020) 10 SCC 706.
(iii). Dr. Bidhan Ch. Baruah vs. M/s G. L. Publications Ltd. & Ors.
passed by the Division Bench of this Court in RFA No. 94 of 2006.
10. Objecting to the application, Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel for the
opposite party/respondent, has referred to the following relevant dates. On
Page No.# 8/21
20.03.2024, the notification for election was issued. On 02.06.2024, the result
of the election was declared. On 16.07.2024, the Election Petition was filed. On
11.06.2025, the original documents were filed by the contesting parties under
Order XIII Rule 1 of the CPC, while the election petitioner filed only one
document, namely the RTI reply dated 08.06.2024 issued by the SIC (Vig.),
Government of Arunachal Pradesh. On 23.10.2025, an interlocutory application
being I.A. (C) No. 261/2025 under Order XVI Rule 6 of the CPC was filed by the
election petitioner for issue of summons for production of documents, which
was allowed by the Court by order dated 14.11.2025. On the same day, present
interlocutory application was filed by the election petitioner for production of
additional documents. On 24.10.2025, the election petitioner filed the evidencein-affidavit of PW-1 to PW-9.
11. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that a plain reading of Order
VII Rule 14(3) makes it clear that a document which ought to be produced in
Court by the plaintiff when the plaint is presented, or to be entered in the list to
be added or annexed to the plaint but is not produced or entered accordingly,
shall not, without the leave of the Court, be received in evidence on his behalf
at the hearing of the suit. The law is well settled that before leave of the Court
can be granted for receiving documents in evidence at a belated stage, the
party seeking to produce the documents must satisfy the Court that the said
documents were earlier not within the party's knowledge or could not be
produced at the appropriate time despite due diligence. The Courts have also
held that the plaintiff cannot, by way of an application under Order VII Rule
14(3) of the CPC, be permitted to fill the lacunae in pleadings and evidence led
by him. It is further held that the provisions of Order VII Rule 14(3) do not
permit liberal interpretation and that exceptional circumstances must be
Page No.# 9/21
demonstrated by the plaintiff to bring any additional documents on record which
were not filed along with the plaint.
12. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the election petitioner
seeks to introduce an additional document at Serial No. 'A' of the interlocutory
application, which is a screenshot of the condolence message posted on the
Facebook page of Shri Tai Logu regarding the death of his father, late Tai Nilo,
on 06.03.2022. The post is dated 12.03.2022, which is more than 2 (two) years
prior to the filing of the election petition. It is evident that when the election
petition was filed, the post was very much in existence. Even otherwise, prior to
the filing of the election petition, the election petitioner had sufficient time to
procure evidence of the death of Tai Nilo from his son, Tai Logu. The failure of
the election petitioner to do so demonstrates a lack of due diligence on his part,
which constitutes a good and sufficient ground to deny leave to the election
petitioner to introduce the said additional evidence at this belated stage.
13. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that an additional document at
Serial No. 'B' of the application, is a copy of the Death Certificate of late Niagh
Yadek who died on 11.07.2023. However, the Death Certificate was belatedly
applied for, as evident from the date of registration indicated therein, i.e.
10.09.2025, and it was issued under the signature of the issuing authority on
11.09.2025. In view of the fact that I.A. (C) No. 261/2025 was filed on
23.10.2025, it is evident that this document was belatedly obtained solely for
the purpose of its introduction as evidence at this stage.
14. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the documents at Serial
Nos. 'C' and 'D' is not being objected to, as the same were procured by the
election petitioner in terms of the order of this Court dated 19.05.2025 passed
in I.A. (C) No. 54/2025.
Page No.# 10/21
15. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that an additional document at
Serial No. 'E' of the application, is a copy of the Death Certificate of late Dekey
Tania who died on 26.11.2023. The Death Certificate was applied for on
08.12.2023, as evident from the date of registration indicated therein, and was
issued on the same day, i.e. 08.12.2023. Since the election petition was filed on
16.07.2024, the said Death Certificate was very much in existence at the
relevant time, but the election petitioner made no effort to collect the same,
despite having full knowledge of the death of Dekey Tania, as evident from his
pleadings.
16. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that an additional document at
Serial No. 'F' of the application, is a photograph of the headstone showing the
date of death of Tai Kaley, i.e. Tai Kelley, as 01.02.2022. The copy of the
photograph shows that it was taken on 28.04.2025. However, if that is treated
as the date of the photograph, it is relevant to note that all the photographs of
such headstones or grave stones are uniformly dated 28.04.2025 with the same
timing. Hence, it is not clear whether 28.04.2025 is the date of the particular
photograph or of all the photographs of each of the additional evidence of
headstone sought to be introduced. Moreover, the certificate attached to the
document bears the same time stamp of 28.04.2025, but the certificate was
issued on 27.09.2025, i.e. nearly 5 (five) months after the time stamp. Be that
as it may, it is safe to presume that the photograph of the headstone was taken
primarily for the purpose of using it as evidence in the present case. There is no
indication as to when the headstone was made. If the headstone was made in
the year 2022, this evidence was very much available when the election petition
was filed, and if the election petitioner had exercised due diligence, he could
have procured the photograph prior to filing of the election petition. The
Page No.# 11/21
election petitioner has stated in his evidence that he has personal knowledge of
the death of Tai Kaley, sic Tai Kelley, as the deceased was his relative and he
attended the funeral. If that be so, the election petitioner did not plead these
facts in the election petition. In view of these pleadings, there are reasons to
believe that the election petitioner was aware of the existence of the headstone,
but despite that, no effort was made to bring this evidence while filing the
election petition.
17. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that an additional document at
Serial No. 'G' of the application, is a photograph of the headstone showing the
date of death of Tai Teli. The photograph is not legible, and as such, it is not
possible to ascertain the date of death of Tai Teli. The photograph was taken on
28.04.2025, from which it is evident that it was taken solely for the purpose of
using it as evidence in this case.
18. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that an additional document at
Serial No. 'H' of the application, is a Certificate dated 08.09.2025 from the Head
Gaon Bura of Rowa Village to the effect that 16 persons, whose bogus votes
were allegedly cast using their EPIC numbers, had died long before the conduct
of the General Elections in 2024. The Certificate bears only a thumb impression
of the Head Gaon Bura, Bameng Taji, which indicates that the said Gaon Bura is
illiterate. If that be so, the Gaon Bura himself would be unable to read the
Certificate. Hence, there are reasons to believe that the Certificate was
manufactured solely for the purpose of introduction as evidence in the present
case. The document is highly doubtful in nature and its origin is open to
question. Curiously, the Certificate also bears a photographic mark dated
28.04.2025. If the Certificate is dated 08.09.2025, then how it could bear a
photographic print dated 28.04.2025. There are therefore reasons to believe
Page No.# 12/21
that this document is doctored and manufactured.
19.
Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the introduction of
documents marked as 'I', 'J' and 'K' by the election petitioner in his interlocutory
application is not being objected to because of the nature of the documents in
the facts and circumstances of the case, subject to proving these documents in
accordance with law.
20. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that additional documents
marked as 'L' and 'M' by way of evidence-on-affidavit of PW-2, namely, Tai
Radey. Document 'L' is a photograph of the memory stone of late Tai Tania at
Pagba Village. However, the name of this voter does not appear in the list of
dead voters of 16-Pagba Polling Station and the pleadings in the election
petition do not support this evidence. There is no pleading in the election
petition that late Tai Tania was a voter from Pagba Village or that, even though
he was dead, a vote in his name was cast in the election. Hence, introduction of
this evidence is beyond the scope of the mandate of Order VII Rule 14 of the
CPC. Further, the date of death of Tai Tania as shown on the headstone is not
very clear but appears to be 14.01.2018. If this is correct, there is no reason
why appropriate pleadings to this effect could not have been made in the
election petition, or why the photograph of the headstone could not have been
enclosed with the election petition.
21.
Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that document 'M' is a
photograph of the memory stone of late Tai Yachak at Peel Village, on which the
date of death is mentioned as 24.12.2018. There is no reason why appropriate
pleadings to this effect could not have been made in the election petition, or
why the photograph of the memory stone could not have been enclosed with
the election petition.
Page No.# 13/21
22. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that additional documents
marked as 'N' and 'O' by way of evidence-on-affidavit of PW-3, namely, Niagh
Kaming. Document 'N' is a photograph of the memory stone of late Tai Nilo at
Pagba Village. This deceased is the same as in document 'A' sought to be
introduced by PW-1. While document 'A' is a screenshot of a Facebook post
made by Shri Tai Logu, son of late Tai Nilo, on 06.03.2022, document 'N' is a
photograph of the memory stone of late Tai Nilo. The date of death of Tai Nilo is
not visible in the photograph, which was taken on 26.09.2025 from a mobile
phone by PW-3. There is no pleading as to why this photograph could not have
been enclosed with the election petition, or why appropriate pleadings in this
regard could not have been made in the election petition by PW-1 (election
petitioner), given that he has claimed personal knowledge of the death of Tai
Nilo. Further, if the memory stone was in existence when the election petition
was filed, the photograph could have been easily taken and enclosed with the
election petition, but this was not done.
23. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the document 'O' is a
photograph of the memory stone of late Niagh Yadek at Pagba Village. The date
of death on the memory stone is not visible and the date on which the
photograph was taken has also not been mentioned. The evidence is not
supported by adequate pleadings or relevant material. There is no explanation
as to why the photograph of this memory stone could not have been enclosed
with the election petition.
24. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that additional documents
marked as 'P', 'Q', 'R' and 'S' by way of evidence-on-affidavit of PW-4, namely,
Bamang Tarak. The document at Serial No. 'P' is a photograph of the memory
stone of late Bamang Rui sic Roi at Rowa Village, indicating that she expired on
Page No.# 14/21
25.12.2018. According to PW-4, her name in the electoral roll is misspelled as
Bamang Rui. There is no mention of the date on which the photograph was
taken. There is no reason why the photograph could not have been taken prior
to the filing of the election petition and enclosed with it. Further, the evidence
by its very nature is highly doubtful and even the identity of the deceased is
open to question.
25. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the document at Serial No.
‘Q’ is a photograph of the memory stone of late Bamang Taji. The date of death
of the deceased is neither pleaded nor visible in the photograph, and there is no
indication as to when the photograph was taken. There is no clarity regarding
the date of death, and the evidence is highly doubtful and lacks credence.
26.
Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that document 'R' is a
photograph of the memory stone of Bamang Yape, who, according to PW-4,
died on 25.08.2022. The photograph of the memory stone was taken on
27.09.2025. There is no adequate pleading as to why this evidence could not
have been procured earlier and enclosed with the election petition.
27.
Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that document 'S' is a
photograph of the memory stone of late Bamang Chapo, who, according to PW4, died on 09.08.1990, whereas the photograph of the memory stone shows the
date of death as 28.12.2022. There is clearly a contradiction between the date
of death pleaded in the affidavit and the date shown on the memory stone. This
raises serious doubts as to whether the Bamang Chapo of the memory stone is
the same person whose death has been pleaded. On this ground alone, the
introduction of this evidence should not be allowed by the Court. There is also
no adequate explanation as to why this evidence, if genuine, could not have
been enclosed with the election petition and properly pleaded therein.
Page No.# 15/21
28. Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, submits that in view of the foregoing
submissions and the objections recorded hereinabove, the election petitioner
has failed to demonstrate the exercise of due diligence as required under Order
VII Rule 14(3) of the CPC in respect of the documents at Serial Nos. ‘A’, ‘B’, ‘E’,
‘F’, ‘G’, ‘H’, ‘L’, ‘M’, ‘N’, ‘O’, ‘P’, ‘Q’, ‘R’ and ‘S’. He submits that several of these
documents were either already in existence or could have been procured with
reasonable diligence at the time of filing the election petition, while others are
either unsupported by pleadings or raise serious doubts as to their origin and
authenticity. Accordingly, it is submitted that no exceptional circumstances exist
to warrant the grant of leave to produce these documents at this belated stage.
29. In support of his submissions, Mr. Tiwari, learned Senior Counsel, has
placed reliance on the following judgments:
(i). Gold Rock World Trade Ltd. Vs. Veejay Lakshmi Engineering
Works Ltd., reported in 2007 0 Supreme(Del) 1744.
(ii). Bhaiyalal & Ors. Vs. Ramswaroop & Ors. , reported in 2013 SCC
OnLine MP 3821.
(iii). Bagai Construction vs. Gupta Building Material Store , reported in
(2013) 14 SCC 1.
(iv). Sugandhi (dead) by legal representatives and Anr. Vs. P.
Rajkumar represented by his Power Agent Imam Oli , reported in
(2020) 10 SCC 706.
30. I have considered the submissions of the learned counsels for the parties
and perused the pleadings in the election petition and the present application.
31. By the present application under Order VII Rule 14(3) of CPC the
Page No.# 16/21
applicant/election petitioner seeks leave of this Court to produce a total of 19
(nineteen) additional documents from Serial Nos. 'A' to 'S'. Out of these,
applicant/election petitioner as PW-1 in his evidence-in-affidavit seeks to
produce 11 (eleven) additional documents at Serial Nos. 'A', 'B', 'C', 'D', 'E', 'F',
'G', 'H', 'I', 'J' and 'K'. PW-2, by way of his evidence-in-affidavit, seeks to
produce 2 (two) additional documents at Serial Nos. 'L' and 'M'. The two
additional documents at Serial Nos. 'N' and 'O' are sought to be produced by
PW-3 through his evidence-in-affidavit and PW-4 seeks to produce 4 (four)
additional documents at Serial Nos. 'P', 'Q', 'R' and 'S'.
32. Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC, 1908, lays down as under:
“…14. Production of document on which plaintiff sues or relies.—(1) Where a
plaintiff sues upon a document or relies upon document in his possession or power in
support of his claim, he shall enter such documents in a list, and shall produce it in
Court when the plaint is presented by him and shall, at the same time deliver the
document and a copy thereof, to be filed with the plaint.
(2) Where any such document is not in the possession or power of the plaintiff, he
shall, wherever possible, state in whose possession or power it is.
(3) A document which ought to be produced in Court by the plaintiff when the plaint
is presented, or to be entered in the list to be added or annexed to the plaint but is not
produced or entered accordingly, shall not, without the leave of the Court, be received
in evidence on his behalf at the hearing of the suit.
(4) Nothing in this rule shall apply to document produced for the cross-examination
of the plaintiffs witnesses, or handed over to a witness merely to refresh his memory.”
33. Reading of Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC makes it clear that where the
plaintiff sues upon a document or relies on one in his possession or power, he
must produce it in Court along with the plaint, delivering both the original and a
copy for filing. If any such document is not in his possession or power, he must,
wherever possible, disclose in whose possession it is. Any document which the
plaintiff should have produced or listed when filing the plaint, but did not,
cannot be received in evidence on his behalf at the hearing, without the leave of
Page No.# 17/21
the Court. However, these requirements do not extend to documents produced
solely for cross-examining witnesses or handed to a witness merely to refresh
his memory.
34.
The law is well settled that before leave of the Court can be granted for
receiving documents in evidence, the party seeking to produce the documents
must satisfy the Court that the said documents were earlier not within the
party's knowledge or could not be produced at the appropriate time despite due
diligence. It is also settled that the plaintiff cannot, by way of an application
under Order VII Rule 14(3) of the CPC, be permitted to fill the lacunae in
pleadings and evidence led by him. However, the provision is the statutorily
recognized mechanism for seeking leave of the Court to place additional
documents on record, provided said documents were earlier not within the
party's knowledge or could not be produced at the appropriate time despite due
diligence and that the material facts relating thereto are already pleaded and no
prejudice is caused to the opposite party.
35. This Court, by judgment dated 21.03.2025 passed in I.A. (C) No. 182/2024,
has held that the pleadings in the Election Petition disclose allegations relating
to inclusion of dead, non-existent and bogus voters in the electoral rolls of 16Pagba, 29-Kambang, 30-Peel and 24-Rowa Polling Stations of 19 th Nyapin (ST)
Assembly Constituency; booth capturing at the said polling stations with the
consent of the respondent or his election agent and corrupt practice, nondisclosure of assets in Form-26 amounting to undue influence and corrupt
practice.
36. On perusal of additional documents 'L' and 'M', in respect of evidence-onaffidavit of PW-2, Tai Radey, it shows that document 'L' is a photograph of the
Page No.# 18/21
memory stone of late Tai Tania at Pagba Village. However, the name of this
voter does not appear in the list of dead voters of 16–Pagba Polling Station and
the pleadings in the election petition do not support this evidence. There is no
pleading in the election petition that late Tai Tania was a voter from Pagba
Village or that, even though he was dead, a vote in his name was cast in the
election and the date of death of Tai Tania as shown on the headstone is not
very clear but appears to be 14.01.2018. Document 'M' is a photograph of the
memory stone of late Tai Yachak at Peel Village, on which the date of death is
mentioned as 24.12.2018. There is no specific pleading to this effect and same
could not be proved at the relevant time.
37. Document 'N' is a photograph of the memory stone of late Tai Nilo at Pagba
Village. This deceased is the same as in document 'A' sought to be introduced
by PW-1. While document 'A' is a screenshot of a Facebook post made by Shri
Tai Logu, son of late Tai Nilo, on 06.03.2022, document 'N' is a photograph of
the memory stone of late Tai Nilo. Document 'O' is a photograph of the memory
stone of late Niagh Yadek at Pagba Village. The date of death on the memory
stone is not visible.
38. Document 'P' is a photograph of the memory stone of late Bamang Rui sic
Roi at Rowa Village, indicating that she expired on 25.12.2018. According to
PW-4, her name in the electoral roll is misspelled as Bamang Rui. There is no
mention of the date on which the photograph was taken. Document ‘Q’ is a
photograph of the memory stone of late Bamang Taji. The date of death of the
deceased is neither pleaded nor visible in the photograph, and there is no
indication as to when the photograph was taken. Document 'R' is a photograph
of the memory stone of Bamang Yape, who, according to PW-4, died on
25.08.2022. The photograph of the memory stone was taken on 27.09.2025.
Page No.# 19/21
39. Document 'S' is a photograph of the memory stone of late Bamang Chapo,
who, according to PW-4, died on 09.08.1990, whereas the photograph of the
memory stone shows the date of death as 28.12.2022. There is clearly a
contradiction between the date of death pleaded in the affidavit and the date
shown on the memory stone. Upon consideration of the above documents, I
find that there is no specific pleading in respect of above documents as to why
this evidence could not have been procured earlier and placed with the election
petition. However, the applicant/election petitioner could demonstrate that the
some of the additional documents sought to be brought on record were earlier
not within the party's knowledge or could not be produced at the appropriate
time despite due diligence.
40.
This Court finds force in the submission of learned counsel for the
applicant/election petitioner that some of the objection raised by the respondent
pertains to issues such as the competency of the Election Petitioner to prove the
Facebook post, the absence of examination of the author of the Facebook page,
the admissibility of screenshots of social media posts, would relate to the
relevancy, mode of proof and admissibility of the documents and not to their
production on record. Such objections are matters for consideration at the stage
of evidence, either at the time of cross examination of the witnesses or at the
stage of final hearing, when the evidentiary value, authenticity and admissibility
of the documents can be determined. The respondent will have full opportunity
to test the veracity, source and admissibility of each of the said documents
during cross-examination of the election petitioner's witnesses.
41. Regard being had to the case laws relied upon by the learned counsel for
the parties, on perusal of the case laws, I find only 3 (three) judgments relevant
for the present application which need not elaborate discussion, however,
Page No.# 20/21
relevant paragraphs are reproduced herein under:
(i). The case of Dr. Bidhan Ch. Baruah (supra), where the Division Bench
of this Court, has held as under:
"7. So, on a perusal of the provision of law as quoted above we are of the considered
view that the document on which the plaintiff sought to rely in original in this case
is not totally precluded to be placed before the Court even after the stage of the
issues and documents. Rather the legislature made a provision to file documents at
any stage, to meet the ends of justice. However, the document is to be filed or
brought on record with the leave of the Court...
12. It is a fact that, appellant/plaintiff should have filed all the documents at the
stage of issues and documents. In case he failed to do so he could have brought the
matter to the notice of the learned Court below immediately after framing of all
issues and documents or at the stage of evidence...
14. In our considered view the learned court is to render substantial justice. It is a
settled principle of law that on mere technicality a court should not reject the plea
otherwise legally substantial. A Court is duty bound to render substantial justice
and not shut the door of justice merely on technicalities."
(ii). In the case of Gold Rock World Trade Ltd. (supra), the High Court
of Delhi has held as under:
“………..Consequently, before leave of the Court can be granted for receiving
documents in evidence at a belated stage, the party seeking to produce the
documents must satisfy the Court that the said documents were earlier not
within the partys knowledge or could not be produced at the appropriate time
in spite of due diligence. “
(iii). In the case of Bhaiyalal (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held as under:
“…4. It is further evident that when the application under Order 7 Rule 14 of
CPC was filed, the suit had reached the stage of cross-examination of plaintiff.
The request was, thus, made during the progress of the trial, which falls within
Clause (3) of Rule 14 of Order 7 of CPC, which provides that documents, which
are not presented alongwith the plaint at the time of institution of the suit,
shall not be allowed to be produced or entered in evidence without the leave of
the Court. Thus, the provisions of Clause (3) of Rule 14 of Order 7 of CPC do not
permit liberal interpretation. Thus, exceptional circumstances have to be
demonstrated by the plaintiff during the progress of the suit to bring any
additional documents on record, which have not been filed alongwith the
Page No.# 21/21
plaint.”
42. In view of the discussion made hereinabove, this Court grants leave to the
applicant/election petitioner to produce the documents listed at Serial Nos. A, B,
C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J and K as additional documents. However, leave to the
applicant/election petitioner to produce the documents listed at Serial Nos. L, M,
N, O, P, Q, R and S is hereby declined.
43. The interlocutory application stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review