Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/23
GAHC040018882024
2026:GAU-AP:1047-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/36/2024
Tadang Tamut and 12 Ors
Son of Shri Talom Tamut, Village Jomlo Mongku, PO Pessing, PS Rumgong, Siang
District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2: Tarung Nyising
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Taka Nyising
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
3: Tabom Talom
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Takir Talom
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
4: Tabir Mize
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Taker Mize
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 2/23
5: Takar Darung
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Tama Darung
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Laki Mibang
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tamer Mibang
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Tare Talom
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tarung Talom
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
8: Tabang Yosung
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tanyong Yosung
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
9: Samuel Ketan
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tator Ketan
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Page No.# 3/23
Arunachal Pradesh.
10: Tapun Gao
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tangir Gao
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
11: Tapang Tali
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Taja Tali
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
12: Tagam Ketan
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Tabuk Ketan
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh.
13: Tanyi Tali
Age:
Occupation :
Son of Shri Takut Tali
Village Jomlo Mongku
PO Pessing
PS Rumgong
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
Kaling Saro and 7 Ors
Son of Late Tanon Saro, permanent resident of Village Jomlo Mongku, PO and PS
Rumgong, Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh
Page No.# 4/23
2:The State of Arunachal Pradesh
Age: 0
Occupation :
represented through the Chief Secretary
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Secretary Land Management
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:The Secretary
Age: 0
Occupation :
Health and Family Welfare
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
5:The Director Health and Family Welfare
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Naharlagun.
6:The Deputy Commissioner
Age: 0
Occupation :
Siang District
Pangin
Arunachal Pradesh.
7:The District Medical Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Siang District
Pangin
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh.
8:The Circle Officer
Age: 0
Occupation :
Jomlo Monbuk
Siang District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Lissing Perme, T Tamut,Signal Yirang,Tabung Nonang,A
Page No.# 5/23
Perme,Krishna Dubey,K Posi
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP), Karmu Chotton,Nani Kuru,Honi Tana Tara,Oken
Duggong,Nikita Danggen,SC(Health),Taba Tagum
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
For the Appellants
:
Mr. L. Perme, Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Ms. Nikita Danggen, Advocate;
Ms. P. Pangu, Advocate;
Mr. T. Tagum,
Advocate.
Date on which Judgment is reserved : 11.08.2026
Date of pronouncement of Judgment : 07.10.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the Judgment?
: NA
Whether the full Judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Judgment & Order (CAV)
[N. Unni Krishnan Nair, J)
Heard Mr. L. Perme, learned counsel, appearing for the appellants.
Page No.# 6/23
Also heard Ms. Nikita Danggen, learned counsel, appearing for the
Respondent No.1; Ms. P. Pangu, learned Government Advocate, representing
the State Respondent Nos.2, 3, 6 and 8; and Mr. T. Tagum, learned Standing
Counsel, Health Department, appearing for the Respondent Nos.4, 5 and 7.
2.
The appellants in the present writ appeal have presented a
challenge to a Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, passed by the learned
Single Judge in WP(C).No.53 (AP)/2018.
3.
The facts leading to the institution of the writ petition being
WP(C).No.53 (AP)/2018, in brief, is noticed, as under;
3.1.
The respondent no.1, herein, claims to be the absolute owner of a
plot of land measuring 500 sq.mtr., situated at Patum (Domong) at Jomlo
Monku village, which was given to the Department of Health Services,
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, for establishment of a temporary Primary
Health Sub-Centre by his father. It is projected that the said Sub-Centre was
established, therein. It is projected that earlier in the year 1994, one Taling
Jonnam, had encroached upon the said land inspite of objections raised by
the father of the respondent no.1. The objections raised by the father of the
respondent no.1, was directed by the jurisdictional authorities to be decided
by holding a kebang. Accordingly, it is projected that a kebang was held on
03.06.1997, wherein, the father of the respondent no.1 and the said Taling
Page No.# 7/23
Jonnam, had participated. The respondent no.1, had also projected that the
title of the land was decided by the kebang in favour of the father of the
respondent no.1. Thereafter, the father of the respondent no.1, had
approached the Director of Health Services, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, requesting the latter to stop repairing the Sub- Centre, which was
constructed over the plot of land, claimed by the father of the respondent
no.1.
3.2.
It was further projected by the respondent no.1, that the land upon
which the temporary Primary Health Sub-Centre was constructed was not
acquired by the Government nor it was donated by his father or the
respondent no.1. It is also projected that the prayer made by the petitioner
for appointment of his wife in lieu of compensation was also not favourably
considered by the Director of Health Services, Government of Arunachal
Pradesh. The respondent no.1, further projects that as the respondent
authorities had not taken any steps for considering his representation, and
there being a move to construct a permanent structure over the plot of land,
contended to be his land, a complaint was filed before the jurisdictional
Deputy Commissioner. However, the Circle Officer, to whom the said
complaint was forwarded, rejected the same vide an order dated 04.08.2017,
holding that the land was donated to the Director of Health Services, for
Page No.# 8/23
setting up of Public Health Centre.
3.3.
Being aggrieved by the above developments, the respondent no.1,
had approached the Writ Court by way of instituting a writ petition being
WP(C).No.53(AP)/2018.
4.
The Writ Court vide Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, proceeded
to dispose of the said writ petition by considering the issues arising, therein,
directing the respondent authorities, to acquire the land, in question, and pay
compensation to the petitioner in accordance with law, and it was also
provided that, in the event, the land is not required by the State, to revert
the same back the respondent no.1.
5.
Being aggrieved by the said decision, the villagers of Jomlo Monku
village, through the appellants, have instituted the present writ appeal,
assailing the order dated 05.09.2024, by contending that the land, in
question, was a community land and the community had donated the land to
the Director of Health Services, Government of Arunachal Pradesh, for setting
up of the Public Health Centre, for the welfare of the people of the area. It is
also contended that the Kebang decisions would go to establish that the
land, in question, was never owned by the respondent no.1 and/or his family.
6.
Mr. L. Perme, learned counsel, appearing for the appellants, by
reiterating the facts, noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that the
Page No.# 9/23
respondent no.1, herein, was an encroacher of the plot of land and staked a
claim of being the owner of the land only in the year 2003. It is submitted
that earlier on a similar projection made by the father of the respondent
no.1, a Kebang was convened and therein, it was decided that in case, in
future, people who are residing in Domong area leave the place, then no one
shall have the right to come in Patum (Domong) area, and the father of the
respondent no.1, shall claim that area by himself.
6.1.
Mr. L. Perme, learned counsel, has further submitted that a further
Kebang was convened on 07.03.2004, and in the decision of the Kebang, it
was recorded that the plot of land, in question, was donated by the
community of Jomlo Monku village, for setting up of a Medical Complex. It
was further decided that no private person shall be allowed to construct any
house or use the land for any other purpose as it belongs to the community
and was donated for setting up of a Medical Complex. Mr. Perme, submits
that in both the said Kebangs i.e. the Kebang dated 03.06.1997 and
07.03.2004, the father of the respondent no.1 was a participant.
6.2.
Mr. Perme, submits that the State Respondents in the affidavit filed
by them before the writ Court, had brought on record the said materials, and
it was contended that the said plot of land belongs to the community and
neither to the father of the respondent no.1 nor the respondent no.1,
Page No.# 10/23
himself, can claim the plot of land, in question. Mr. Perme, submits that
although the said materials were brought on record which had disputed the
claim of the respondent no.1, before the Writ Court, the Writ Court, had
proceeded to hold that the plot of land, in question, belonged to the
respondent no.1 and passed consequential directions to the State authorities
for acquiring the said land and/or for returning the land to the respondent
no.1.
6.3.
Mr. Perme, submits that the learned Single Judge, had not
appreciated the facts coming on record in the writ proceedings with regard to
the ownership of the land, in question, and had passed directions to the
Government to acquire the land, in question, and/or to revert the land, which
was clearly not permissible in view of the Kebang decisions brought on
record both by the respondent no.1, herein, as well as the State
Respondents. He submits that the Writ Court had also drawn a conclusions to
the effect that stricto sensu, it cannot be said that the land in question, was
donated by the father of the respondent no.1, for establishment of the
Primary Health Sub-Center, but was allowed to be used temporarily.
6.4.
Mr. Perme, submits that decision of the Kebang convened on
03.06.1997, would go to clearly establish that the same had not declared the
title of the father of the respondent no.1, over the plot of land, in question,
Page No.# 11/23
and had only provided that in future, in the event, persons residing in the
Patum (Domong) area moves out of the area, and the hospital is shifted
therefrom, then only the father of the respondent no.1, can claim the area by
himself. Mr. Perme, submits that the said Kebang decision, has not been
assailed by the father of the respondent no.1 and/or the respondent no.1,
and accordingly, the same has attained it finality. Mr. Perme, submits that no
decision contrary to the Kebang decision dated 03.06.1997, would be
permissible to be taken, inasmuch as, the Health Complex over the plot of
land, in question, still continues to function, therefrom.
6.5.
Mr. Perme, further submits that although materials had come on
record which had indicated that the land, in question, was donated by the
community, no effort was made by the respondent no.1 to implead the
villagers of Jomlo Monku village, as party respondents in writ petition
instituted by him and the villagers through the present appellants, have
approached this Court by instituting the present appeal, only after coming to
learn of the directions passed by the Writ Court vide the Judgment & Order
dated 05.09.2024.
6.6.
In the above view of the matter Mr. Perme, submits that the
impugned Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, would mandate an
interference from this Court.
Page No.# 12/23
7.
Ms. Nikita Danggen, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent
no.1, has submitted that from the materials coming on record, the title of the
father of the respondent no.1, over the plot of land, in question, cannot be
disputed. She submits that the plot of land was donated by the father of the
respondent no.1, for the purpose of setting up of a temporary Primary Health
Sub-Centre and the land was never acquired by the respondent authorities.
Accordingly, she submits that the respondent no.1, cannot be deprived of his
property, without following the due process of law. She further submits that
the respondent authorities being a welfare state cannot also claim adverse
possession over the property of a citizen.
7.1.
Ms. Danggen, by taking us through the conclusions drawn by the
Writ Court in the Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, has submitted that
the conclusions so drawn are reasonable and are based on materials coming
on record in the writ proceedings and accordingly, the same would not
mandate any interference from this Court.
8.
Mr. T. Tagum, learned Standing Counsel, Health Department,
appearing for the Respondent Nos.4, 5 and 7, at the outset had denied the
claim made by the respondent no.1, in the writ petition and has reiterated
that the plot of land, in question, was donated by the villagers of Jomlo
Monku village, way back in the year 1988.
Page No.# 13/23
8.1.
Mr. Tagum, by referring to the decision of the Kebang, dated
07.03.2004, has submitted that a perusal of the same would reveal that the
land, in question, was donated not by the father of the respondent no.1 but
by the villagers of Jomlo Monku village, for setting up of a Medical Complex,
thereon. He submits that the said Kebang decision arrived at dated
03.06.1997, in absence of a challenge being made, thereto, by the
respondent no.1, herein, had attained its finality and no claim contrary
thereto, would be permissible to be raised by the respondent no.1.
8.2.
Mr. T. Tagum, has submitted that infact it is the father of the
respondent no.1, who was a encroacher of the land, in question, and after
having encroached the land, had raised claim of being the absolute owner of
the plot of land, in question, and the said claim was followed up by the
respondent no.1, herein. Mr. Tagum, submits that the jurisdictional Circle
Officer, in pursuance to a complaint raised in the matter by the father of the
respondent no.1, over illegal constructions of permanent structure, over his
land, by one Tapir Tamut, had basing on the materials coming on record,
held that in view of the Kebang decision holding the field, the father of the
respondent no.1, would have no claim of the land donated for setting up of
the Public Health Sub-Center, but in the event, the Public Health Sub-Center,
shifts from the present location, at Domong,
then the father of the
Page No.# 14/23
respondent no.1 can claim his land.
8.3.
Mr. T. Tagum, has submitted that the order dated 04.08.2017, has
the effect of reiterating the decision arrived at by the Kebang in its meeting
held on 03.06.1997. Mr. Tagum, further submits that the father of the
respondent no.1, was a party to the Kebang decisions and accordingly, the
land being donated there is no question of acquiring the same on payment of
compensation. Mr. Tagum, has further submitted that the plea raised by the
respondent no.1, to the effect that the land was donated only for the
purpose of setting up of a temporary Primary Health Sub-Centre, is not
supported by the materials coming on record and is clearly contrary to the
decisions arrived at by the Kebang in its meeting held on 03.06.1997.
8.4.
In the above premises, Mr. T. Tagum, submits that the impugned
Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, would mandate an interference by this
Court.
9.
Ms. P. Pangu, learned Government Advocate, representing the
State Respondent Nos.2, 3, 6 and 8, has submitted that she would adopt the
arguments advanced by Mr. T. Tagum, learned Standing Counsel, Department
of Health Services, Government of Arunachal Pradesh.
10.
We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused
the materials available on record.
Page No.# 15/23
11.
From the materials brought on record, this Court finds that the
villagers of Jomlo Monku village, have claimed that the land in question, was
donated by them for setting up of a Primary Health Sub-Centre, while it the
projection of the respondent no.1, that the father of the respondent no.1,
was the absolute owner of the land, in question, and had parted with the
same for setting up of a Primary Health Sub-Centre, temporarily, thereon.
12.
To appreciate the said contention, we have perused the Kebang
decision dated 03.06.1997. On a perusal of the said decision, we find that
although the dispute involved was between the father of the respondent no.1
and one Taling Jonnam, the Kebang had decided that Taling Jonnam, shall
not create any disturbance on Patum (Domong) area and further, in case, in
future people who are residing in (Domong) area, leaves the place, and/or
the hospital is shifted out from the plot of land, wherein, it is so standing, no
one shall have the right to claim to the area and the father of the respondent
no.1, shall only claim the area by himself. The said projections goes to reveal
that the Public Health Sub Centre was not ever considered to be set up
temporarily but was set up, therein, for the welfare of the people of the area.
The said Kebang decision dated 03.06.1997, was not assailed by the father of
the respondent no.1 or the respondent no.1 himself, at any point and the
same has accordingly, attained it finality.
Page No.# 16/23
13.
The parties to the proceedings have submitted that the Primary
Health Sub-Centre, continues to function even as on date over the plot of
land, which is claimed by the respondent no.1, herein. Accordingly, the said
Medical Complex continuing to function from the plot of land, in question, in
terms of the Kebang decision dated 03.06.1997, neither the father of the
respondent no.1 nor the respondent no.1, himself can claim the said plot of
land. The right of the respondent no.1, to claim the plot of land would arise
only after the villagers of Domong area leave the place and/or the Medical
Complex is shifted out, therefrom. The said Kebang decision is further
reiterated in decision arrived at by the Kebang in its meeting held on
07.03.2004, wherein, it was also recorded that the plot of land, in question,
was donated by the community of Jomlo Monku village for setting up of a
Medical Complex. The father of the respondent no.1 is found to be a
signatory in both the Kebang decisions of 03.06.1997 and 07.03.2004.
However, the decisions arrived, therein, has not been assailed either by the
father of the respondent no.1 nor the respondent no.1, herein.
14.
Having noticed the above position, this Court would now examine
the conclusions drawn by the Writ Court vide the Judgment & Order dated
05.09.2024. The Writ Court upon examining the matter had drawn the
following conclusions;
Page No.# 17/23
“11. It is not disputed that the land originally belongs to the father of the petitioner, which
was allowed to be used for establishment of Primary Health Sub Centre. By various
Kebang decisions, it appears that the land in question shall be utilized for the purpose of
establishment of Primary Health Sub Centre, which is being utilized as on date.
12. It appears that the father of the petitioner has filed a complaint before the Health
Services, in the year 2000 claiming back the land, on the ground that he has already
developed the land for horticulture garden and to not repair the structure of the Primary
Health Sub-Centre. The petitioner, thereafter, on various occasions, has approached the
respondent authorities for appointment of his wife in government service in lieu of
compensation for the land in question or to acquire the land and to pay the compensation
to the petitioner as the ownership of the land is not disputed.
13. On careful consideration of the Kebang decisions (supra), it is seen that the land in
question belongs to the father of the petitioner and same was given to the Health
Department for establishment of Primary Health Sub Centre for the people of Jomlo
Mobuk circle. In 2(two) out of 3(three) Kebang decisions, the father of the petitioner had
participated, which Indicates his agreement to the decisions of the Kebang. In stricto
sensu, it cannot be said that the land in question was donated by the father of the petitioner
for establishment-of Primary Health Sub Centre but was allowed to be used temporarily.
An act of participation and subscribing to the Kebang Decisions may lead to presumption
of donation but such presumption cannot be ground for depriving the person of his
property.
14.
Ordinarily, since the father of the petitioner has participated and subscribed to the
Kebang decisions, the claim for compensation of the land in question or to return it to the
petitioner may not be appropriate to accept as the father of the petitioner has given the
Page No.# 18/23
land to be utilized for the purpose of establishment of Primary Health Sub Centre which is
for the interest of the people of the area at large. However, since the father of the petitioner
had made a complaint not to repair the structure of the Primary Health Sub Centre, on the
ground that he has developed the area for horticultural purpose and the petitioner to
approach the respondent authorities claiming compensation including seeking appointment
of his wife in lieu of compensation or to revert back the land, no document is produced
disclosing donation of the land legally and when the title and ownership is not disputed, I
am of the considered view that petitioner cannot be deprived of his property without due
process of law which would entail infringement of right to property.
15.
In the case of Vidya Devi (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered the
constitutional right under Article 300A which provides that no person shall be deprived of
his property save by authority of or procedure established by law. It has held that to
forcibly dispossess a person of his private property, without following the due process of
law, would be violative of human right and also the constitutional right under Article 300-A
of the constitution. In a democratic polity governed by rule of law, the State could not have
deprived a citizen of their property without the sanction of law. The State being a welfare
State governed by rule of law cannot arrogate to itself a status beyond what is provided by
the constitution.
16.
Although, facts of the case in Vidya Devi (Supra), is different from the present case,
the proposition of law would be applicable. In that case, the authority has taken over the
land without due process of law and a plea was taken by the State that since it has been in
continuous possession of the land for over 42 years, it would tantamount to adverse
possession. In that context, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that it is surprised by the
plea taken by the State before the High Court, that since it has been in continuous
Page No.# 19/23
possession of land for over 42 years, it would tantamount to adverse possession. The being
a welfare State, cannot be permitted to take the plea of adverse possession, which allows a
trespasser i.e. a person guilty of a tort, or even a crime, to gain legal title over such
property for over 12 years. The State cannot be permitted to perfect its title over the land
by invoking the doctrine of adverse possession to grab the property of its own citizens.
17.
In the present case, though the father of the petitioner has allowed temporarily the
land for establishment of Primary Health Sub Centre at Patum (Domong), Jomlo Mongku
village, which is for the interest of the people in his area, there is nothing on record to show
that same was transferred absolutely in favour of the Department except the plea of
donation sought to be derived from the Kebang decisions. No doubt, the land was allowed
to be utilized but on temporary basis. The father of the petitioner filed an objection not to
further repair the structure of Health Sub Centre and thereafter, the petitioner has
approached the authorities for compensation either in the form of appointment of his wife
in the Govt. service or to pay land compensation or to return the land to the petitioner.
There is no dispute to the title and ownership of the petitioner over the land in question.
18.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances of the present case, I am of the
considered view that the petitioner has been deprived of his property. Thus, I am of the
view that the petitioner is entitled to compensation of the land as the land of the petitioner
has neither been acquired by following due process of law nor transferred by way of
donation in accordance with law.
19.
In view of the above, the respondent authorities are directed to acquire the land in
question and pay compensation to petitioner in accordance with law, if the land in question
is required by the State, and/ or to revert back the land to the petitioner. The exercise as
directed hereinabove shall be done within a period not later than 3 (three) months from the
Page No.# 20/23
receipt of the copy of this order.”
15.
A perusal of the conclusions drawn by the learned Writ Court would
go to reveal that in paragraph-13 of its decision, the Writ Court had held that
the participation of the father of the respondent no.1, herein, in 2 (two) out
of 3 (three) Kebangs involved, to indicate the acceptance of the decisions of
the Kebangs by him. It was further concluded that, it cannot be said that the
land, in question, was donated by the father of the respondent no.1, for
establishment of the Primary Health Sub-Centre, but was allowed to be used
temporarily.
16.
In paragraph-14 of its decision, the Writ Court had further recorded
that since the father of the respondent no.1, had participated and subscribed
to the Kebang decisions, the claim for compensation of the land, in question,
or to return to the respondent no.1, may not be appropriate to accept as the
father of respondent no.1, had given the land to be utilized for the purpose
of establishment of Primary Health Sub-Centre, which is for the interest of
the people of the area at large. 17.
However, having drawn the said
conclusions, Writ Court proceeded to draw a contrary conclusion to the effect
that since the father of the respondent no.1, had made a complaint to the
authorities not to repair the structure of the Primary Health Sub-Centre on
the ground that, he had developed the area for horti-culture purpose, and
Page No.# 21/23
the respondent no.1, herein, having approached the respondent authorities
claiming compensation, including seeking appointment of his wife in lieu of
compensation and or to revert back the land, no document being produced
disclosing donation of the land legally, the title and the ownership of the
respondent no.1, over the said plot of land cannot be disputed. The said
conclusions in our considered view is clearly perverse, inasmuch as, the same
is not supported by the materials brought on record. The said projection is
solely based on the projections made by the respondent no.1, in the writ
petition. The decision of the Kebang dated 03.06.1997, further fortifies our
conclusions, inasmuch as, the father of the respondent no.1, was permitted
to claim land in the area only in the event of all the villagers of Domong area
had left the place and also the Medical Complex was shifted out, therefrom.
Both the situations not having occasioned, the respondent no.1, cannot be
held to have any right to claim the plot of land in question. Accordingly, in
our considered view, the conclusions drawn by the Writ Court that the
respondent no.1 was the absolute owner of the plot of land, in question, is
clearly erroneous.
18.
The Writ Court having drawn contrary conclusions, in the matter
and the conclusions drawn in favour of the respondent no.1, not being found
by us to be supported by materials coming on record, a disputed questions of
Page No.# 22/23
fact had emerged in the matter, which was not permissible to be so resolved
by solely relying upon the materials coming on record in the writ
proceedings. The said dispute not being permissible to be resolved without
going into the factual controversy, we are of the considered view that the
Writ Court should not have entertained the writ petition. Accordingly, after
noticing the said disputed position with regard to the ownership of the land
in question, the Writ Court ought not to have proceeded further to declare
the title of the respondent no.1, over the plot of land and further direct the
State Respondents to acquire the land and/or to return the same to the
respondent no.1, herein.
19.
In view of the above conclusions drawn by us, we find that the
conclusions drawn by the Writ Court in its Judgment & Order dated
05.09.2024, in WP(C).No.53 (AP)/2018, to be not sustainable and to
mandate an interference from this Court.
20.
In view of the above discussion, we proceed to set aside the
impugned Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024. Having interfered with the
Judgment & Order dated 05.09.2024, passed by the Writ Court in
WP(C).No.53(AP)/2018, we direct that the possession of the plot of land, in
question, shall be continued to be governed by the decision of the Kebang
dated 03.06.1997.
Page No.# 23/23
21.
With the above observations and directions, the present Writ Appeal
stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review