Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/18
GAHC040004422025
2026:GAU-AP:688-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/15/2025
Taba Tagia
Son of Taba Tebi, resident of Village Billo, PO and PS Yazali, Lower Subansiri
District, Arunachal Pradesh 791119
VERSUS
The Union of India and 3 Ors
represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, Shastri Bhavan,
New Delhi 110001
2:The Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
Age: 0
Occupation :
having its registered office at 17 Jamshedji Tata Road
Mumbai 400001
Maharashtra.
3:The Chairman cum Managing Director
Age: 0
Occupation :
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
having its registered office at 17 Jamshedji Tata Road
Mumbai 400001
Maharashtra
4:The Chief Regional Manager
Age: 0
Occupation :
Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
Guwahati Retail Regional Office
Rajiv Gandhi Path
Betkuchi Near Maniram Dewan Trade Centre
Page No.# 2/18
Guwahati 781040
Kamrup District
Assa
Advocate for the Petitioner : T T Tara, Sr. Adv, Pondit Ronya,Kirmani Lollen,Terji Kamchi,Khoda
Apa,Taba Tokur,Gamken Bam
Advocate for the Respondent : Marto Kato, Tabit Tapak,DSGI
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 21.07.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 24.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Kardak Ete, J)
Heard Mr. T. T. Tara, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Mr. G. Bam, learned
counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr. M. Kato, learned DSGI for respondent
No. 1, and Mr. T. Tapak, learned Standing Counsel, HPCL, for respondent Nos. 2,
Page No.# 3/18
3 & 4.
2. This intra-court appeal is directed against the order dated 27.02.2025, passed
by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 232(AP)/2024, whereby the writ
petition filed by the appellant/ petitioner has been dismissed by holding that the
decision of the Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL), respondent
Nos. 2 to 4 herein, rejecting the appellant's candidature for the award of a
Regular/Rural Retail Outlet (Petrol Pump) Dealership on the ground that he did
not possess a valid Land Possession Certificate (LPC), as required under Clause
4(vi) of the Guidelines for Selection of Dealers for Regular/Rural Retail Outlets ,
did not warrant interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction.
3.
The facts of the case, in brief, are that the respondent No. 2-Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) issued a Notice dated 28.06.2023 inviting
applications for appointment of Regular/Rural Retail Outlet (Petrol Pump)
Dealerships at various locations, including in the State of Arunachal Pradesh.
Pursuant thereto, the appellant, belonging to the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category,
submitted an online application on 22.09.2023 under Group -1, for award of a
Retail Outlet Dealership for the location at "Within 1 Km of M/s Meens Stone
Crusher on Hoj-Potin Road, NH-13", offering his own land situated at 16 Km,
Potin area at Village Billo, Yazali, Lower Subansiri District, Arunachal Pradesh.
4.
Upon consideration of the applications, the appellant was provisionally
selected for the said dealership under Group-1 and by communication dated
13.12.2023, was directed to deposit an Initial Security Deposit of ₹30,000/- and
upload the requisite documents in support of his candidature on or before
23.12.2023. The appellant deposited the prescribed amount and submitted the
documents as called for by the respondent authorities.
Page No.# 4/18
5.
Thereafter, by communication dated 01.06.2024, the respondent-HPCL
rejected the appellant's candidature under Group-1 on the grounds that No Land
Possession Certificate (LPC) is available and the Land Availability Certificate
submitted by the appellant was not valid in terms of Rule 143 of the Arunachal
Pradesh (Land Settlement and Records) Rules, 2012. The appellant was,
however, informed that his candidature could be considered under Group-3 in
accordance with the applicable Guidelines. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant
instituted WP(C) No. 232(AP)/2024.
6.
The learned Single Judge, after consideration of the submissions advanced
by the learned counsel for the parties and the materials available on record, by
the impugned order dated 27.02.2025, has dismissed the writ petition by
holding that although the objection raised by HPCL regarding the Land
Availability Certificate issued by the Circle Officer was not sustainable, the
appellant had failed to satisfy the requirement of producing a valid Land
Possession Certificate (LPC) evidencing ownership of the offered land as on the
date of submission of the application, as contemplated under Clause 4(vi) of the
Guidelines for Selection of Dealers for Regular/Rural Retail Outlet Dealerships.
The relevant paragraphs of the impugned order are reproduced herein under:“14. As recorded here in above, the petitioner was provisionally selected and he was
also intimated as regards its provisional selection. And accordingly, he had also
deposited an amount of Rs.30,000/-(Rupees thirty thousand)only as initial security
deposit. Such provisional allotment letter was issued on June 13, 2024. In the
aforesaid document (Annexure-6), the petitioner was intimated as regards the
requirement of document, which includes amongst other Kharsa/ Khatouni or any
other equivalent revenue document or certificate obtained from revenue official
confirming the status of ownership of the land as on the date of application.
15. Admittedly, the petitioner along with his application dated 22.09.2023, though
submitted a land availability certificate issued by Circle Officer, Yazali, Lower Subansiri
District, Arunachal Pradesh but did not submit any ownership document (LPC).
Page No.# 5/18
16. The first the objection of the HPCL is that such land availability certificate is not in
terms of Rule 143 of the Arunachal Pradesh (Land Settlement and Records Rules),
2012.
17. Rule-143 reads as follows;
“the Deputy Commissioner may grant a certificate in respect of its holding to a
landowner certifying the nature of his title, the revenue payable at the area
giving such other particulars as may be necessary.”
Thus, it is the contention of the HPCL that the Land Availability
Certificate is not issued by a competent authority, i.e, not by the Deputy
Commissioner, but by a Circle Officer.
18.
In the aforesaid context, Mr. Tara, learned counsel for the petitioner contends
that in terms of Section 6 of the Arunachal Pradesh (Land Settlement and Records
Rules) Act, 2012, a Circle Officer comes within a definition of a Revenue Officer and
such Revenue Officer is authorized to take cognizance of all matters connected with
survey of land and settlement of the revenue rates and the preparation and
maintenance of land records and other registers and authorized to function and
perform all such duties as may be prescribed under the Act or by General or any
special order. And therefore, according to Mr. Tara, the guideline/Brohure prescribes
issuance of certificate by a Revenue Officer and not specifically mentioned that it
should be issued by a Deputy Commissioner. In view of such prescription, the criterion
of insisting a certificate by Deputy Commissioner is nothing but hidden criteria.
19.
Referring to a determination made by a Coordinate Bench in the case of Nang
Wontina Chowpoo Vs. the Union of India and others, (WP(C) 72/2024), Mr. Tara,
submits that in a similar circumstance, the Coordinate Bench has in no ambiguity held
that the Circle Officer/DLRSO shall be within its power to issue such a certificate.
20.
This Court has perused the aforesaid judgment and it was held that Act of 2000
recognizes the DLRSO as revenue officer and Section-6 thereof lays down power of
such officer as per which, a certificate can be issued. In the case in hand also the
Circle Officer is a revenue authority and as enumerated under Section 4 of the Act of
2000 and therefore, similar principle will be applicable in the present case also,
inasmuch as it was a land availability certificate and not LPC. Therefore, in considered
opinion of this Court, the ground of rejection that the certificate issued by the Circle
Officer is not in conformity with Rule-143 is not sustainable.
21.
Having said so, this Court cannot be unmindful of the fact that one of the
important requirements is certification/ document as regard ownership of the land
offered. It is also not in dispute that in the State of Arunachal LPC are issued for
ascertaining ownership/title of land. Therefore, let this Court now deal with the issue
Page No.# 6/18
of non-availability of LPC.
22.
Now, coming to the ownership document, i.e LPC, Mr. Tara, submits that such
certificate has been issued by the Additional Deputy Commissioner and therefore,
reading as a whole, the authorities ought not to have rejected such prayer.
23.
Countering the argument of the learned Standing Council for the HPCL that
such certificate is dated 22nd of December, 2023, whereas the guideline/brochure
strictly prohibits acceptance of any certificate beyond the last date of submission of
application and the application was submitted by the petitioner on 22.09.2023 and
therefore, the authorities cannot accept such LPC, Mr. Tara, learned counsel for the
petitioner contends that the petitioner was provisionally selected and was asked to
upload all these documents by 23.12.2023. And on the basis of such request, the
petitioner had uploaded the LPC which was dated 22.12.2023 and therefore, such LPC
is dated prior to 23.12.2023 and therefore, such document could not have been
rejected for the reason that same is not issued on the last date of filing of application.
Therefore, Mr. Tara, submits that when the authorities themselves asked the petitioner
to up load the LPC by 23.12.2023, they cannot approbate and reprobate at the same
time by insisting that such certificate should be dated at least to the last date of filing
of the application which in the case is 22.09.2023.
24.
So far relating to the uploading and non-availability of LPC, this Court, do not
find favour of the argument of Mr. Tara, learned counsel for the petitioner. It is not
disputed by either of the parties that the dealership is to be selected in terms of the
guidelines holding the field in this regard. Clause-4 (vi) (e) mandates that at least a
certificate from the revenue official confirming the status of the ownership of the land
as on the date of the application is required to be furnished. Thus, it is loud and clear
that the date of certificate confirming the status of ownership of the land should be at
least issued on the last date of filing of the application, which is 22.09.2023 and in this
case, the LPC is dated 23.12.2023. Clause-4 (vi) (f) also indicates acceptance of a
document which includes allotment letter issued by the Government, in this case in
hand, the petitioner admittedly relies on the LPC which is dated 23.12.2023.
25.
Now, coming to the communication dated 13.06.2023 by which, the petitioner
was intimated as regard his provisional selection, it is clear from the said letter that
the certificate required to be produced should be issued on or before the date of
application submitted by the petitioner i.e. it should be dated on or before 22.09.2023.
However, this is not the case in hand and the LPC was admittedly issued by the
revenue authorities on 23.12.2023, which is admittedly beyond 22.09.2023.
26.
In the aforesaid background, the decision of the HPCL holding that there was
no valid LPC cannot be faulted by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction. This
Court cannot also term the action of the authorities to be arbitrary of approbation and
Page No.# 7/18
reprobation, inasmuch as they clarified at every stage that such certificate should be
issued at least on the last date of submission of the application and therefore, asking
the petitioner to upload a certificate by 23.12.2023, shall not create a right upon the
petitioner to submit the ownership certificate beyond the time limit prescribed and as
recorded herein above.
27.
For the reasons recorded herein above, this Court cannot held the impugned
decision to be a result of, either arbitrary exercise of power or violative of any of the
legal or constitutional right of the petitioner. Accordingly, the writ petition stands
dismissed.”
7.
Mr. T. T. Tara, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, while drawing the
attention of this Court to the impugned order dated 27.02.2025, submits that
the learned Single Judge has committed a manifest error in dismissing the writ
petition by holding that the appellant did not possess a valid Land Possession
Certificate (LPC) as required under Clause 4(vi) of the Guidelines for Selection of
Dealers for Regular/Rural Retail Outlet Dealerships (hereinafter referred to as
"the Guidelines"). The learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate that the
appellant had, along with his application submitted on 22.09.2023, furnished a
Land Availability Certificate dated 22.09.2023, issued by the Circle Officer, Yazali,
certifying the status of ownership of the land offered for the dealership, which
fully satisfied the requirement of Clause 4(vi)(e) of the Guidelines.
8.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the Circle Officer is a Revenue Officer
within the meaning of Sections 4 and 6 of the Arunachal Pradesh (Land
Settlement and Records) Act, 2000, and is competent to issue a certificate
relating to the ownership and availability of land. He submits that once the
learned Single Judge himself held that the Land Availability Certificate issued by
the Circle Officer could not have been rejected on the ground that it was not
issued by the Deputy Commissioner, there remained no justification for
sustaining the rejection of the appellant's candidature by insisting upon a
separate Land Possession Certificate (LPC). The Land Possession Certificate
Page No.# 8/18
subsequently issued in respect of the very same land merely corroborated the
ownership already reflected in the Land Availability Certificate and could not
have been treated as creating a fresh title in favour of the appellant.
9.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the learned Single Judge
failed to correctly appreciate Clauses 4(vi)(e) and 4(vi)(f) of the Guidelines.
Clause 4(vi)(e) merely requires production of a certificate issued by a Revenue
Officer confirming the status of ownership of the land as on the date of the
application, whereas Clause 4(vi)(f) contemplates uploading any of the
prescribed ownership documents as and when called upon by the Oil Marketing
Company. He submits that, after the appellant was provisionally selected, he
furnished the documents called for by the respondent authorities, including the
Land Possession Certificate issued by the competent authority and therefore,
the respondent authorities could not have rejected his candidature on the
ground that the said certificate had been issued after the date of submission of
the application. He submits that such action on the part of the respondent
authorities is self-contradictory and amounts to approbate and reprobate which
is not permissible in law.
10.
Mr. Tara, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the learned Single Judge
failed to appreciate that in a similarly situated matter, the learned Single Bench
of this Court in Nang Wontina Chowpoo v. Union of India & Ors. (WP(C)
No. 72/2024) has held that a Revenue Officer under the Arunachal Pradesh
(Land Settlement and Records) Act, 2000 is competent to issue a certificate of
the nature relied upon by the appellant. He submits that the ratio of the said
decision squarely covers the present case and in the absence of any
distinguishing feature or reference to a larger Bench, the learned Single Judge
ought to have granted the appellant the same relief. Therefore, Mr. Tara, learned
Page No.# 9/18
Senior Counsel, submits that the communication dated 01.06.2024 rejecting the
appellant's candidature and the impugned order dated 27.02.2025 deserve to be
set aside.
11. On the other hand, Mr. T. Tapak, learned Standing Counsel, HPCL, submits
that the learned Single Judge has rightly dismissed the writ petition, as the
appellant admittedly failed to produce a valid Land Possession Certificate (LPC)
issued on or before the date of submission of the application, as mandated
under Clause 4(vi)(f) of the Guidelines. Since the appellant submitted his
application on 22.09.2023, whereas the Land Possession Certificate (LPC) was
issued subsequently, the respondent authorities rightly rejected the candidature
of the appellant under Group-1. He submits that the Land Availability Certificate
issued by the Circle Officer cannot be treated as a valid ownership document
under the Guidelines. As per the Arunachal Pradesh (Land Settlement and
Records) Act, 2000, the Rules framed thereunder and the relevant Government
notifications, a Land Possession Certificate can be issued only by the Deputy
Commissioner or such other competent authority and not by the Circle Officer.
Therefore, he submits that the impugned order warrants no interference.
12. We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and
also perused the materials available on record, including the impugned order
dated 27.02.2025 passed by learned Single Judge.
13.
Pursuant to Notice dated 28.06.2023 issued by the respondent-HPCL
inviting applications for appointment of Regular/ Rural Retail Outlet (Petrol
Pump) Dealerships, the appellant submitted his online application on 22.09.2023
under the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category-Group-1, for the location at "Within 1
Km of M/s Meens Stone Crusher on Hoj-Potin Road, NH-13", offering his own
land for establishment of the retail outlet. Upon being declared provisionally
Page No.# 10/18
selected, the appellant deposited an amount of Rs. 30,000/- as the Initial
Security Deposit (ISD) and furnished the documents as required by the
respondent authorities. However, by communication dated 01.06.2024, the
respondent-HPCL rejected the appellant's candidature under Group-1 on the
grounds that the Land Possession Certificate furnished by him did not satisfy the
requirements prescribed under the Guidelines and that the Land Availability
Certificate issued by the Circle Officer was not a valid document under Rule 143
of the Arunachal Pradesh (Land Settlement and Records) Rules, 2012.
14. To appreciate the controversy involved in the present appeal, it is apposite
to refer to Clause 4(vi)of the Guideline, i.e. Brochure for Selection of Dealers for
Regular & Rural Retail Outlets, which governs the selection of dealers for
Regular & Rural Retail Outlets through draw of lots/bidding process. The same is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“4.
ELIGIBILITY
CRITERIA
PROPRIETORSHIP/PARTNERSHIP
FOR
INDIVIDUAL
APPLICANTS-
………….
………….
(vi) Land (Applicable to all categories):
The applicants would be classified into three groups as mentioned below based on the
land offered or land not offered by them in the application form: Group-1: Applicants having suitable piece of land in the advertised location/area either
by way of ownership / long term lease for a period of minimum 19 years 11 months or
as advertised by the OMC.
Group-2: Applicants having Firm Offer for a suitable piece of land for purchase or longterm lease for a period of minimum 19 years 11 months or as advertised by the OMC.
Group-3: Applicants who have not offered land in the application. Only applicable for
locations advertised under SC/ST category.
Page No.# 11/18
Applications under Group 3 would be processed/advised to offer land (Annexure - D)
only in case no eligible applicant is found or no applicant get selected under Group-1&
Group-2.
In case land offered by all the applicants under Group 1 & Group 2 is found not
suitable/not meeting requirements, then these applicant/s under Group -1 & Group - 2
along with applicants under Group 3 (who did not offer land along with application)
would be advised by the OMCs to provide suitable land in the advertised location
/stretch, within a period of 90 days from the date of issuance of intimation letter to
them through SMS/e-mail. In case the applicant fails to provide suitable land within
the prescribed period, or the land provided is found not meeting the laid down criteria,
the application would be rejected.
The other conditions with respect to offering of land are as under: a) The land should be available with the applicant as on the date of application and
should have minimum lease of 19 years and 11 months (as advertised by respective oil
company) from the date or after the date of advertisement but not later than the date
of application. If the offered land is on Long-term lease and there are multiple owners,
then lease deed should be executed by all co-owners of the offered plot. Incase lease
deed is not executed by all co-owners; such lease deed shall be treated as invalid.
b) If the offered land is on long term lease, then the Lease agreement should have a
provision to sub-lease the offered land wherever the locations are advertised under
Corpus Fund Scheme (CFS) and other Corporation Owned Sites ("A"/ "CC" sites).
In case it is observed that the lease agreement for the land offered by the
provisionally selected candidate does not have a provision to sub-lease the land, in
such cases the provisionally selected candidate would be provided 21 days' time from
the date of intimation through SMS/e-mail to make suitable amendment/addendum to
the lease agreement and submit the same to the concerned OMC.
c) For Dealer owned sites ("B"/ "DC" sites), the applicant should ensure that the land
arranged by the applicant is either registered in the applicant's name or leased in
favour of the applicant for a minimum period as advertised by respective oil company,
as per terms of Letter of Intent (LOI). Investment will be made by the OMC towards
development of facilities in the offered land only after compliance of the afore
mentioned, by the applicant. In case land is obtained on long term lease by the
applicant, the lease should be valid till a period of 19 years 11 months from the date
Page No.# 12/18
or after the date of advertisement but not later than the date of application.
d) For Corporation owned sites ("A"/ "CC"/ "CFS" sites), the applicant should ensure
that the land offered by the applicant is registered in the name of the OMC either
through Long Term Lease or through outright sale before any investment is made by
the OMC towards development of facilities in the offered land. In case of long term
lease, the lease should be valid till a period of 19 years 11 months from the date or
after the date of advertisement but not later than the date of application.
e) As and when advised by the OMC, the provisionally selected candidate should
upload a copy of Khasra / Khatouni or any other equivalent revenue document or
certificate obtained from revenue official confirming the status of ownership of the
land, as on the date of application.
As and when advised by the OMC, the provisionally selected candidate will also be
required to upload a site map / layout sketch of the offered plot as per Appendix - V.
f) In addition to above, as and when advised by the OMC, provisionally selected
candidate(s) under Group-1 should also upload a copy of any one of the following
documents to establish ownership of land offered for the Dealership. The documents
must have been executed / registered / issued on or before the date of application:•
•
•
•
15.
Registered Sale deed/Registered Gift deed
Registered Lease deed for a minimum period of 19 years and 11 months (as
advertised by respective oil company).
Any other type of ownership / transfer deed document
Lease agreement or firm allotment letter issued by Government / Semi
Government bodies”
On a reading of the aforesaid Guidelines, particularly Clause 4(vi), it is
seen that the same, inter alia, classifies applicants into three groups, namely,
Group-1, Group-2 and Group-3, depending upon the nature of the land offered
by them along with the application. Insofar as the present case is concerned,
the appellant admittedly falls under Group-1, having offered his own land for
establishment of the Retail Outlet. Clause 4(vi) further stipulates the conditions
governing the land offered by an applicant and the documents required to be
Page No.# 13/18
furnished by a provisionally selected candidate in support of his claim of
ownership over such land. Clause 4(vi)(e) requires the provisionally selected
candidate, as and when advised by the Oil Marketing Company (OMC), to
upload a copy of Khasra/Khatouni or any other equivalent revenue document or
a certificate obtained from the Revenue Officer confirming the status of
ownership of the land as on the date of application. Clause 4(vi)(f) further
requires a provisionally selected candidate under Group-1 to upload any one of
the documents specified therein to establish ownership of the land offered for
the dealership, with the stipulation that such document must have been
executed, registered or issued as on the date of application.
16. The appellant/petitioner had submitted a Land Availability Certificate dated
22.09.2023 certifying that land situated at 16 KM, near M/s Meens Stone
Crushing, Potin, was available in his possession for establishment of an HPCL
Regular Retail Outlet Dealership. Thereafter, the respondent-HPCL, vide
communication dated 13.12.2023, informed the appellant that he had been
provisionally selected for award of Retail Outlet Dealership at "Within 1 Km of
M/s Meens Stone Crusher on Hoj-Potin Road, NH-13, Lower Subansiri District,
Arunachal Pradesh" under the Scheduled Tribe (ST) category pursuant to the
Notice dated 28.06.2023. By the said communication, the appellant was
required to remit an amount of Rs. 30,000/- towards the Initial Security Deposit
and upload the prescribed self-attested documents. Amongst the documents
required to be uploaded was Khasra/Khatauni or any other equivalent revenue
document or a certificate obtained from a Revenue Officer confirming the status
of ownership of the land as on the date of application. The communication
further stipulated that the candidature of the provisionally selected candidate
would be liable to be rejected in the event the Initial Security Deposit was not
Page No.# 14/18
remitted or the requisite documents were not uploaded on or before
23.12.2023. Pursuant thereto, the appellant uploaded a Land Possession
Certificate dated 12.12.2023 issued by the Additional Deputy Commissioner,
Yachuli, certifying that land situated at 16 KM Potin area was in his possession.
The said certificate was issued on the basis of the report submitted by the Circle
Officer, Yazali, dated 14.09.2023.
17.
Thereafter, the respondent-HPCL, vide communication dated 01.06.2024,
informed the appellant that his candidature under Group-1 had been rejected on
the ground that the land documents furnished by him were not valid for
consideration under Group-1, inasmuch as no Land Possession Certificate (LPC)
was available and the Land Availability Certificate relied upon by the appellant
was not a valid document in terms of Rule 143 of the Arunachal Pradesh (Land
Settlement and Records) Rules, 2012. However, it was also indicated that his
candidature could be considered along with Group-3 applicants in terms of the
Guidelines.
18. As noted above, Clause 4(vi)(e) of the Guidelines requires a provisionally
selected candidate, as and when advised by the Oil Marketing Company (OMC),
to upload Khasra/Khatauni or any other equivalent revenue document or a
certificate obtained from a Revenue Officer confirming the status of ownership
of the land as on the date of application. Clause 4(vi)(f) further requires a
provisionally selected candidate under Group-1 to upload any one of the
prescribed ownership documents, namely, a registered sale deed, registered gift
deed, registered lease deed, any other ownership/transfer deed document or a
lease agreement/firm allotment letter issued by the Government/SemiGovernment bodies. The said clause further stipulates that such document must
have been executed, registered or issued on or before the date of application.
Page No.# 15/18
19. In the present case, although the communication dated 13.12.2023 called
upon the appellant to upload the requisite documents on or before 23.12.2023,
the requirement under the Guidelines remained that the revenue document or
certificate relied upon by the appellant to establish his ownership of the land
should satisfy the eligibility criteria prescribed therein by reiterating that such
document be as on the date of application. Admittedly, while the appellant
submitted his application on 22.09.2023, the Land Possession Certificate relied
upon by him was issued only on 12.12.2023. Thus, although the fact that the
appellant uploaded the documents within the time stipulated by the respondentHPCL, the Land Possession Certificate was not a document issued on or before
the date of submission of the application. In such circumstances, we are of the
view that the rejection of the appellant's candidature under Group-1,
notwithstanding his provisional selection, cannot be said to be illegal.
20. It is well settled that an authority inviting applications or bids is entitled to
punctiliously and rigidly enforce the eligibility criteria and conditions governing
such selection. Reference in this regard may be made to the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in G. J. Fernandez Vs. State of Karnataka & Ors., reported
in (1990) 2 SCC 488.
21. It is also settled position of law that judicial interpretation of contracts in
the sphere of commerce stands on a distinct footing than while interpreting
statutes. The courts should give way to the opinion of the experts unless the
decision is totally arbitrary or unreasonable. The author of the tender document
or the authority which formulates the governing terms and conditions is the best
person to understand and appreciate its requirements and interpret its
documents. The constitutional courts must defer to this understanding and
appreciation of the tender documents, unless there is mala fide or perversity in
Page No.# 16/18
the understanding or appreciation or in the application of the terms of the
tender conditions. It is possible that the owner or employer of a project may
give an interpretation to the tender documents that is not acceptable to the
constitutional courts but that by itself is not a reason for interfering with the
interpretation given. The court does not sit as a court of appeal over the
appropriate authority; the court must realise that the authority floating the
tender is the best judge of its requirements and, therefore, the court's
interference should be minimal. The authority which floats the contract or
tender, and has authored the tender documents is the best judge as to how the
documents have to be interpreted. If two interpretations are possible then the
interpretation of the author must be accepted. The courts will only interfere to
prevent arbitrariness, irrationality, bias, mala fides or perversity.
22.
In Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation
Ltd.& Anr., reported in (2016) 16 SCC 818, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
held, which is reproduced herein below:
“15. We may add that the owner or the employer of a project, having authored the
tender documents, is the best person to understand and appreciate its requirements
and interpret its documents. The constitutional Courts must defer to this
understanding and appreciation of the tender documents, unless there is mala fide or
perversity in the understanding or appreciation or in the application of the terms of the
tender conditions. It is possible that the owner or employer of a project may give an
interpretation to the tender documents that is not acceptable to the constitutional
Courts but that by itself is not a reason for interfering with the interpretation given.”
23.
In the case of Pawan Kumar vs. Union of India & Ors, reported in
(2024) 12 S.C.R 1253, in a similar case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has
reiterated that the Public Sector Undertaking that authors the tender documents
is the best person to understand, appreciate and interpret its requirements and
the constitutional courts must defer to its understanding unless there is
Page No.# 17/18
malafides or perversity.
24.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, we find
no infirmity in the interpretation placed by the respondent-HPCL on Clause 4(vi)
(e) and (f) of the Guidelines. The Guidelines specifically require that the
revenue document/certificate confirming the status of ownership of the land
should be as on the date of application and further stipulate that the ownership
document required under Clause 4(vi)(f) must have been executed, registered
or issued on or before the date of application. Admittedly, the appellant
submitted his application on 22.09.2023, whereas the Land Possession
Certificate relied upon by him was issued subsequently on 12.12.2023. Merely
because the appellant was permitted to upload the requisite documents after his
provisional selection would not dilute or override the eligibility conditions
expressly prescribed under the Guidelines.
25. As held by Hon’ble Supreme Court and discussed herein above, the author
of the tender document is the best person to understand and interpret its terms.
Unless the interpretation adopted by the tendering authority is shown to be
arbitrary, mala fide, irrational or perverse, the Constitutional Courts ought not to
substitute their own interpretation. In the present case, we do not find that the
interpretation adopted by the respondent-HPCL suffers from any such infirmity
warranting interference in exercise of judicial review.
26.
For the foregoing reasons, we find ourselves in agreement with the view
taken by the learned Single Judge that, although the appellant had uploaded
the Land Possession Certificate within the time stipulated by the respondentHPCL, the said certificate did not satisfy the requirement of Clause 4(vi) (e)) and
(f) of the Guidelines, having admittedly been issued subsequent to the date of
submission of the appellant's application. Consequently, the rejection of the
Page No.# 18/18
appellant's candidature under Group-1 cannot be said to be arbitrary, illegal or
contrary to the terms of the Guidelines.
27. In view of the foregoing discussion, we find no merit in the present writ
appeal. Consequently, the order dated 27.02.2025, passed by the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) No. 232(AP)/2024, does not warrant any interference and the
same stands affirmed. Accordingly, the writ appeal stands dismissed. There shall
be no order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review