The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. K.Satya Raju, cleaner of the lorry was examined as P.W.2. His evidence is significant on the question of negligence. He stated that BSB, J C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003 parking lights of the lorry were not on and that both the jeep and the lorry had blocked the road and therefore the deceased coming on the moped dashed against the lorry from behind and died. b. After discussing facts of the case, the Tribunal opined that P.W.2 could not withstand the test of cross-examination and that he had come to Court to give evidence at the instance of the claimant No.1 / P.W.1, who requested him to give evidence in favour of the claimants and further P.W.2 deposed that he did not know the name of the driver of the lorry and that he had not given any statement before the police. Therefore, the Tribunal suspected the trustworthiness of his evidence. Further, the Tribunal recorded that evidence of P.W.2 is inconsistent with the documentary evidence produced by the claimants, because Ex.A1 and A2 shows that the deceased was in a drunken condition at the time of the accident and died of his own negligence. c. The Tribunal further recorded that P.W.1 admitted in her evidence that she had not given any complaint to the police or Magistrate to enquire into the matter. But, a case was registered against the deceased for the offence under Section 304 I.P.C. as can be seen from Ex.A1 and the case was abated…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010603252003
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Saturday, the thirty first day of January two thousand and twenty six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B. S. Bhanumathi
Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.2822 of 2003
Between:
T.Siromani and another
...Appellants
and
S. Mahaboob Saheb and Others
Counsel for the appellants:
1. Aravala Rama Rao
Counsel for the respondents:
1. T. V. Sri Devi
2. Sri T.Ravi Teja,, learned counsel representing
Ms.A. Jayanthi,, learned counsel
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
JUDGMENT:
This is an appeal filed under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 against the award and the decree, dated 25.04.2003, in
M.V.O.P.No.03 of 2003 on the file of the Chairman, Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal-cum-III Additional District Judge, Kurnool at Nandyal.
2.
The appellants are the claimants and the respondents are the
respondents before the Tribunal.
3.
Since the claim against the respondents Nos.2, 4 and 5 was
dismissed before the Tribunal, the respondents Nos.4 and 5 are shown
as not necessary parties to this appeal, however the respondent No.2 is
still shown as party to the appeal.
a.
Notices sent to the respondents Nos.1 and 2 were returned
unserved, though they were addressed to the address given before the
Tribunal. Hence, it is treated as sufficient service of notice. Moreover,
further notice is dispensed with as per proviso to Order XLI, Rule 14(1)
of C.P.C. as applicable to the State of Andhra Pradesh, as they
remained ex parte before the Tribunal.
4.
The case of the claimants, is briefly, as follows:
a.
The respondent No.1 is the owner, the respondent No.2 is the
driver and the respondent No.3 is the insurer of the lorry bearing
No.APD 6498. The respondent No.4 is the insurer and the respondent
No.5 is the owner of moped bearing No.AP 21 C 8835.
b.
On 17.05.1988, at about 12.30 AM, T.George who is husband of
the claimant No.1 and father of the claimant No.2 while going on a
moped bearing No.AP 21 C 8835, hit the rear side of the lorry bearing
No.APD 6498 which was negligently parked in the middle of the road
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
without keeping any warning or lights on National Highway-18 near
Sugali Metta Village. As a result, he sustained fatal injuries and died on
the spot. The deceased was an employee in Panyam Cement Company
and drawing salary of Rs.6,572/- per month. He was aged about 50
years. Therefore, the claimants sought compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-.
5.
The respondents Nos.1, 2 and 5 remained ex parte before the
Tribunal.
6.
The respondent No.3 i.e., the insurer of the lorry filed counter
resisting the claim stating that the lorry was taking a load of paddy and
that a Jeep bearing No.AP 21 T 2947 was stationed on the road for
want of diesel; that the respondent No.2 along with cleaner of the lorry,
was engaged in taking out diesel from the lorry; that while so, the
deceased himself negligently drove his moped in a drunken condition
and was unable to control himself and hit the stationed lorry on its rear
side and therefore, he died on his own negligence and that the amount
of compensation claimed is excessive.
7.
The respondent No.4 filed a counter contending that there was no
negligence of the driver of the lorry in causing the death and that the
deceased himself was negligent in driving the moped in a drunken
condition and that the deceased is not a third party to make any claim
against the respondent No.4 for negligence of the deceased and that
the claim is excessive.
8.
The claimant No.1 was examined as P.W.1 and Ex.A1 to A5 were
marked on behalf of the claimants. On behalf of the respondents R.W.1
to R.W.3 were examined and Ex.B1 to B12 were marked.
9.
K.Satya Raju, cleaner of the lorry was examined as P.W.2. His
evidence is significant on the question of negligence. He stated that
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
parking lights of the lorry were not on and that both the jeep and the
lorry had blocked the road and therefore the deceased coming on the
moped dashed against the lorry from behind and died.
b.
After discussing facts of the case, the Tribunal opined that P.W.2
could not withstand the test of cross-examination and that he had come
to Court to give evidence at the instance of the claimant No.1 / P.W.1,
who requested him to give evidence in favour of the claimants and
further P.W.2 deposed that he did not know the name of the driver of
the lorry and that he had not given any statement before the police.
Therefore, the Tribunal suspected the trustworthiness of his evidence.
Further, the Tribunal recorded that evidence of P.W.2 is inconsistent
with the documentary evidence produced by the claimants, because
Ex.A1 and A2 shows that the deceased was in a drunken condition at
the time of the accident and died of his own negligence.
c.
The Tribunal further recorded that P.W.1 admitted in her evidence
that she had not given any complaint to the police or Magistrate to
enquire into the matter. But, a case was registered against the
deceased for the offence under Section 304 I.P.C. as can be seen from
Ex.A1 and the case was abated. Thus, the Tribunal had concluded that
the accident was not caused due to negligence of the driver of the lorry.
Since there was no defect in the mechanism of the moped, the
respondents Nos.4 and 5 are not necessary parties to the petition as
per the opinion of the Tribunal. However, the Assistant Divisional
Manager of the respondent No.4 has been examined as R.W.3 denying
liability.
d.
In the light of the above findings, the Tribunal declined to award
the compensation on the ground of fault liability under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and limited the amount of compensation
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
under ‘no fault liability’ by awarding Rs.50,000/-. The Tribunal further
allowed costs and interest @ 9% per annum from the date of petition till
date of realization on the amount of Rs.50,000/-. The amount was
directed to be paid by the respondents Nos.1 and 3. The claim petition
against the respondents Nos.2, 4 and 5 was dismissed without costs.
10.
Aggrieved by the decree and the award, this appeal was filed by
the claimants contending that the Tribunal grossly erred in awarding
compensation only on no fault liability in spite of fault liability and that
there is evidence of parking the lorry negligently in the middle of the
road without switching on parking lights and that the Tribunal
erroneously rejected the evidence of P.W.2. It is also contended that
the Tribunal ought to have observed that the police falsely implicated
the deceased in the crime with a view to help the driver of the lorry and
that they are entitled to whole amount of claim of Rs.5,00,000/- as
compensation.
11.
Since there is no denial of the death of the deceased in the
accident caused when the moped hit the rear side of the stationed lorry,
no further discussion is required on that aspect but, as the respondents
blamed the deceased for his negligence in causing the accident
because he was drunk at that time, the evidence was examined by the
Tribunal on that aspect.
12.
The learned counsel for the appellants contended that the
evidence of P.W.2 who is the cleaner of the lorry clearly speaks of the
negligence of the driver of the lorry in parking the vehicle in the middle
of the road without lights on, but the Tribunal erroneously rejected his
evidence. He further submitted that undue importance has been
attached to the evidence of R.W.2 who was the driver of the jeep and
the evidence under documents filed in criminal case, marked here as
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
Exs.B1 to B.10; that the fact that the deceased was in drunken state
had not been independently established by adducing clear evidence by
the respondents; that even if the claimants failed to establish rash and
negligence of the driver of the lorry, the Tribunal ought to have awarded
compensation under Section 163-A of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
since the Act is a beneficial legislation; and that the evidence of P.W.2
clearly demonstrated that the road was completely blocked by the lorry
and jeep and the lights of the jeep were on, whereas the lights of the
lorry were not on and therefore, the accident occurred but the Tribunal
committed error in disbelieving his evidence on extraneous grounds.
13.
The learned counsel for the respondent No.3 / insurance
company submitted that the Tribunal already awarded compensation
under no fault liability and no further compensation is required to be
allowed. He further submitted that the Tribunal considered the evidence
of P.W.2 not only in chief examination which is relied on by the
appellants, but also his evidence in cross examination and had given a
categorical finding that the evidence of P.W.2 is not trustworthy. He
further submitted that P.W.2 had not given any statement to the police
as admitted by him in the cross examination.
14.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellants and the learned
counsel for the respondent No.3 represented by Sri T.Ravi Teja, learned
counsel.
15.
A perusal of the evidence shows that the reasoning given by the
Tribunal to disbelieve the evidence of P.W.2 is correct. Since the
deceased himself was at fault, the Tribunal awarded compensation on
the ground of ‘no fault liability’. Hence, this Court is not inclined to
interfere with the decree and the award of the Tribunal.
16.
BSB, J
C.M.A.No.2822 of 2003
In the result, the appeal is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
Dt. 31.01.2026
NSM / PNV / RAR
__________________
B.S. BHANUMATHI, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review