The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. 06.2022). He has also placed reliance on the judgment passed in the matter of State of Madhya Pradesh v. T.N. Verma [2001 (1) M.P.L.J]. He would argue that after retirement, the relationship of employer and employee comes to an end and, therefore, the authorities had no jurisdiction to initiate departmental enquiry. 4) On the other hand, Mr. Vinay Pandey, learned Deputy Advocate General appearing for the State would oppose the submissions made by learned counsel for the petitioner and submit that the petitioner committed certain misconduct while posted as Assistant Conservator of Forest, therefore article of charge was issued in the name of the Hon’ble Governor. He would further contend that a notification dated 02.03.2017 was issued by the State Government, according to which sanction from the Hon’ble Governor under Rule 9(2)(b) of the Rules, 1976 is not necessary, as such sanction can be granted by the Chief Minister of the State. He would contend that the sanction required under Rule 9(2)(b) of the Rules, 1976 has been granted by the Chief Minister of the State itself; therefore, the petition is misconceived and deserves to be dismissed. 5) Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents placed on file. 6) The provision of Rule 9 (2) (b) of the Rules, 1976 states that if departmental proceedings are started after a Government servant’s retirement, they can be…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010366102022
2026:CGHC:32266
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 7928 of 2022
T.R. Jaiswal S/o Late Janak Ram Jaiswal Aged About 64 Years
(Retired Assistant Conservator Of Forest) R/o H. N. 448, Near
Golden Nursery School, Shanti Nagar Bilaspur, District : Bilaspur,
Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary, Department Of Forest
Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar Nawa Raipur, District :
Raipur,
Chhattisgarh
2. Under Secretary Department Of Forest, Mantralaya, Mahanadi
Bhawan, Atal Nagar Nawa Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
3. Principal Chief Conservator Of Forest Aranya Bhawan, North
Block, Sector-19, Nava Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Syed Majid Ali, Advocate
For Respondents
: Mr. Anil Pandey, G.A.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Order On Board
28.7.2026
1) The petitioner has filed this petition seeking the following reliefs:–
10.1 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue appropriate writ, order, direction setting
aside/quashing Letter No. F 1-19/2022/10-1/Van
Nava Raipur dated 26th September 2022 and
Departmental
Enquiry
Chargesheet
with
Appendix Nos. 1 to 4 [Annexure P-1 (Colly)].
10.2 Costs of the Writ Petition.
10.3 Any other relief(s) that the Hon'ble Court
further pleased to grant in the facts and
circumstances of the case in the interest of
justice and equity.
2) Facts in brief are that at the relevant time, petitioner was posted
as Assistant Conservator of Forest, Forest Division Bilaspur. He
retired from service on attaining the age of superannuation on
30.11.2019. After retirement, an article of charge was issued on
26.9.2022 making allegations that under the State CAMPA
Scheme, petitioner manipulated the plantation area by showing 35
hectares in project report instead of actual 30 hectares, which
allegedly caused financial loss to the exchequer. It is pleaded that
the departmental enquiry has been initiated against the petitioner
after retirement without obtaining prior permission or sanction of
the Hon’ble Governor and the same is in contravention of the
provisions of Rule 9(2)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1976. (for short, Pension Rules, 1976).
3) Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would submit that the
departmental enquiry was initiated against the petitioner after
retirement on 30.11.2019 and no prior sanction was accorded by
the Hon’ble Governor, which is an essential requirement for
initiating departmental enquiry against a retired government
servant. He has placed reliance upon the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Division Bench in the matter of Vikram Singh Yadav v.
State of Chhattisgarh & ors. (WPS No.6178 of 2019, dt.
28.06.2022). He has also placed reliance on the judgment passed
in the matter of State of Madhya Pradesh v. T.N. Verma [2001
(1) M.P.L.J]. He would argue that after retirement, the relationship
of employer and employee comes to an end and, therefore, the
authorities had no jurisdiction to initiate departmental enquiry.
4) On the other hand, Mr. Vinay Pandey, learned Deputy Advocate
General appearing for the State would oppose the submissions
made by learned counsel for the petitioner and submit that the
petitioner committed certain misconduct while posted as Assistant
Conservator of Forest, therefore article of charge was issued in
the name of the Hon’ble Governor. He would further contend that
a notification dated 02.03.2017 was issued by the State
Government, according to which sanction from the Hon’ble
Governor under Rule 9(2)(b) of the Rules, 1976 is not necessary,
as such sanction can be granted by the Chief Minister of the
State. He would contend that the sanction required under Rule
9(2)(b) of the Rules, 1976 has been granted by the Chief Minister
of the State itself; therefore, the petition is misconceived and
deserves to be dismissed.
5) Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents
placed on file.
6) The provision of Rule 9 (2) (b) of the Rules, 1976 states that if
departmental proceedings are started after a Government
servant’s retirement, they can be initiated only with Hon’ble
Governor’s sanction, must relate to an event that occurred within
the last four years, and shall be conducted according to the
prescribed departmental procedure for withholding pension or
recovering loss caused to the Government.
7) In the present case, after going through the article of charge and
other documents, it appears that under the State CAMPA
Scheme, petitioner manipulated the plantation area by showing 35
hectares in project report instead of actual 30 hectares, which
allegedly caused financial loss to the exchequer. Petitioner retired
from services on 30.11.2019, whereas the article of charge was
issued against him on 26.9.2022. Perusal of the article of charge
would show that it was issued in the name of the Hon’ble
Governor by the State of Chhattisgarh. In the return filed by the
State, the concurrence order or approval of the Chief Minister has
not been placed on record.
8) With regard to the requirement of prior sanction, the Hon’ble
Division Bench in the matter of Vikram Singh Yadav (supra),
while dealing with the provisions of Rule 9(2)(b) of the Rules,
1976, held that every executive decision does not need to be
formally issued in the name of the Hon’ble Governor. However,
when a decision affects a person outside the Government or
requires official communication, it should be expressed in the
Hon’ble Governor’s name under Article 166 of the Constitution.
The relevant paragraph 46 is reproduced as under:–
“Perusal of the judgments noted above would go to
show that every executive decision need not be
formally expressed, but when an executive decision
affects an outsider or is required to be officially
notified or communicated, it should be expressed in
the name of the Governor. When there is
compliance of the requirements of Article 166 of the
Constitution, the same gives an immunity to the
order to the extent that it cannot be challenged on
the ground that it is not an order made by the
Governor. Omission to comply with the provisions of
Article 166 of the Constitution does not render an
executive action a nullity.”
9) In the instant matter, the decision taken by the respondent
authorities affects the rights of the petitioner, who would be an
outsider after retirement, therefore, the requirement of prior
sanction from the Hon’ble Governor was mandatory for initiation of
departmental enquiry against the petitioner.
10) In the matter of State of T.N. Verma (supra), the High Court of
Madhya Pradesh while dealing with similar issue in para- 5 held
as under:–
“5. We find no merit in the submission raised by
the learned counsel for the State. The learned
counsel was unable to point out that before
initiating the departmental enquiry sanction of the
Governor was obtained as mandated by the
provisions of Rule 9 of M.P. Civil Services
(Pension) Rules, 1976. It is transparent from bare
reading of Rule 9 (2) (b) that departmental
proceedings, if not instituted while the
Government servant was in service whether
before his retirement or during his re-employment,
shall not be instituted save with the sanction of the
Governor. The second rider provided by Rule 9 (2)
(b) is that such enquiry shall not be in respect of
any event which took place more than four years
before such institutions. In the instant case, first
requirement of sanction of the Governor is not
satisfied. Thus, the very institution of the
departmental enquiry and subsequent issuance of
charge-sheet was wholly unauthorised. There is
no whisper in the memo of writ petition that
Governor has sanctioned the holding of
departmental enquiry against the retired employee
as mandated under Rule 9 (2) (b) of the M.P. Civil
Services (Pension) Rules, 1976 which reads thus:
"9. Right of Governor to withhold or
withdraw pension.-- (1) The Governor
reserves to himself the right of withholding
or withdrawing a pension or part thereof,
whether permanently or for a specified
period, and of ordering recovery from
pension of the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the Government
if, in any departmental or judicial
proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty
of grave misconduct or negligence during
the period of his service, including service
rendered upon re-employment after
retirement:
***
***
***
***
(2) (a) The departmental proceedings, if
instituted while the Government servant
was in service whether before his
retirement or during his re-employment,
shall, after the final retirement of the
Government servant, be deemed to be
proceedings under this rule and shall be
continued and concluded by the authority
by which they were commenced, in the
same manner as if the Government
servant had continued in service :
Provided that where the departmental
proceedings are instituted by an authority
subordinate to [he Governor, that authority
shall submit a report regarding its findings
to the Governor.
(b) The departmental proceedings, if not
instituted while the Government servant
was in service whether before his
retirement or during his re-employment:
(i) shall not be instituted save with the
sanction of the Governor;
(ii) shall not be in respect of any event
which look place more than four years
before such institution....."
11) From bare reading of above quoted judgment it is clear that under
Rule
9(2)(b)
of
the
Pension
Rules,
1976,
departmental
proceedings against a retired Government servant can be initiated
only with the sanction of the Hon’ble Governor.
12) In the present case, there was no sanction from the Hon’ble
Governor as required under Rule 9(2)(b) of the Pension Rules,
1976, therefore, initiation of departmental enquiry and issuance of
article of charge against the petitioner is illegal and bad in law.
13) The State has also not placed any document on record to
substantiate the fact that any prior approval or sanction was
obtained from the from the Chief Minister of the State.
14) Taking into consideration the above disucssed facts and law, the
initiation of departmental enquiry and issuance of articles of
charge(s) are not sustainable in the eyes of law. Accordingly, the
articles of charge Annexure P/1 and P/3 are hereby quashed. The
petition is allowed. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
JUDGE
Ajinkya
AJINKYA PANSARE
Date: 2026.07.28
15:47:40 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review