Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:29657
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
TUESDAY, THE 8TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 18TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 4651 OF 2023
PETITIONER:
T.N. JAYASANKAR
AGED 55 YEARS
VRINDAVAN, 12/809 KRA LANE-6,
HOUSE NO. 5, INFORPARK ROAD,
KAKKANADU, ERNAKULAM,
PIN - 682030
BY ADVS.
SURIN GEORGE IPE
SREEDEV U
RESPONDENTS:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT
DEPARTMENT OF TOURISM,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
KERALA INSTITUTE OF TOURISM & TRAVEL STUDIES
RESIDENCY, THYCAUD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR, PIN – 695014
BY
SMT. ANIMA M, GOVERNMENT PLEADER
SRI. SHYAM PADMAN, SC
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
13.02.2025, THE COURT ON 08.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:2:
N. NAGARESH, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
W.P.(C) No.4651 of 2023
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 8th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
The petitioner is a Post Graduate in
Master of Tourism Administration. The petitioner holds a
Certificate in Airline Management and a Post Graduate
Diploma in Tourism and Travels Studies. The petitioner
was appointed as Special Officer for conducting a study
for restructuring of District Tourism Promotion Councils
(DTPC) in the State. During this period, the petitioner was
reporting to the 2nd respondent-Kerala Institute of Tourism
and Travel Studies (KITTS).
2.
The petitioner was appointed as a
Lecturer in KITTS, Ernakulam Chapter with effect from
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:3:
01.08.2002.
The 2nd respondent-KITTS established
Kerala Institute of Hospitality Management Studies
(KIHMS) at Malayattoor.
petitioner
as
Lecturer
The KITTS appointed the
in
KIHMS
as
per
Ext.P2
appointment order dated 30.06.2006.
3.
The
petitioner
states
that
he
was
appointed as Project Assistant in KITTS in March, 2002
and worked till July, 2002. He worked as Guest Lecturer
in KIHMS from 01.02.2002 till 15.05.2005 and from
17.10.2005 till 26.01.2006.
The petitioner states that
proposal regarding regularisation of the petitioner was
taken up by the 32nd Executive Committee meeting of the
KITTS held on 11.06.2009. In the meanwhile, KIHMS was
renamed as KITTS Study Centre on 10.06.2009.
4.
The KITTS permitted the petitioner to go
on deputation as Secretary of DTPC as per Ext.P5 letter
dated 10.08.2011.
The petitioner took charge as
Secretary, DTPC, Ernakulam on 16.08.2011.
The
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:4:
Executive
Committee
meeting
of
KITTS
held
on
11.04.2012 decided to regularise the services of their
staff.
The 2nd respondent issued Ext.P11 letter dated
20.03.2015 to the Secretary to Government seeking to
regularise the petitioner in service. The regularisation of
services
of
the
petitioner
was
approved
by
the
Government on 05.03.2016 and the proposal was sent to
the Finance Department for approval as per Ext.P15. To
the surprise of the petitioner, the Government retracted
from their earlier stand as per Ext.P16 and decided not to
regularise the services of the petitioner.
5.
The petitioner states that one Sri. Sajith
Kumar, who was working as Peon, was regularised in
service with retrospective effect as per Ext.P19.
Government
also
concurred
the
The
retrospective
regularisation of Smt. Sindhu S., who was appointed as
Lecturer on contract basis, as per Ext.P20. The petitioner
alone has been subjected to hostile discrimination in the
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:5:
matter of regularisation of service.
6.
The
petitioner
filed
W.P.(C)
No.21336/2019 seeking to regularise his service.
This
Court, as per Ext.P21 judgment dated 21.06.2022, set
aside Ext.P16 and directed the Government to take a final
decision on the request of the petitioner for regularisation.
The Government, however, again declined the request as
per Ext.P22 order dated 29.12.2022.
The petitioner
therefore challenges Ext.P22 order and seeks to direct the
respondents to regularise the services of the petitioner
and to grant him all service and monetary benefits
including pay revision with retrospective effect from the
date of joining.
7.
The 1st respondent resisted the writ
petition filing counter affidavit.
The 1 st respondent
submitted that as per letter dated 19.03.2002, KITTS had
assigned the petitioner as Special Officer for assisting Dr.
C.V. Anand Bose for conducting study on the functioning
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:6:
of DTPCs and to redefine its role. As per Ext.R1(a) order
dated 25.07.2002, the petitioner was again engaged as
Lecturer on contract basis in KITTS.
Later, an
advertisement was published as per Ext.R1(b) dated
15.02.2006 for selection to the post of Lecturer (Travel
and Tourism).
8.
The
petitioner
was
selected
and
appointed as Lecturer on contract basis in the scale of pay
of ₹6675-10550. The contract appointment was only for a
period of three years.
After the expiry of the contract
period, the question of regularisation of the petitioner was
taken up and the proposal was rejected by the Executive
Committee meeting held on 11.06.2009 as per Ext.R1(d).
9.
The
1st
respondent
submitted
that
assumption of additional charge as DTPC Secretary by
the petitioner was not deputation.
permissible work arrangement.
It was only a
The 36 th Executive
Committee decided to extend the term of the petitioner on
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:7:
contract for a period of one year.
The 1 st respondent
pointed out that when the post of Lecturer was created in
KIHMS, it was made clear that appointment to the post will
be made only on contract basis for a period of three years.
Therefore, the Government rejected the proposal for
regularisation of that period.
10.
The petitioner is a contractual appointee.
He is seeking regularisation as he is continuing work for
more than ten years. The request of the petitioner goes
against the judgment of the Apex Court in Secretary,
State of Karnataka and others v. Umadevi and others
[(2006) 4 SCC 1]. The writ petition is therefore liable to be
dismissed.
11.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the learned Government Pleader appearing for
the 1st respondent and the learned Standing Counsel
appearing for the 2nd respondent.
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:8:
12.
The petitioner holds Degree of Master of
Tourism Administration from Pondichery University, a
Certificate in Airline Management from the Institute of
Airline Management, Chennai and Post Graduate Diploma
in Tourism and Travel Studies from the Kerala Institute of
Tourism and Travel Studies.
The Kerala Institute of
Tourism and Travel Studies (KITTS) is an Autonomous
Body established by the Government of Kerala.
The
Minister for Tourism, Government of Kerala is the
Chairman of KITTS. The Director of KITTS is appointed
by the Government of Kerala.
Secretaries of the
Departments of Tourism and Finance, the Director of the
Department of Tourism, etc. are among the Executive
Committee Members of KITTs.
Therefore, it is evident
that KITTS is a Society on which Government exercises
deep and pervasive control.
13.
The petitioner was appointed to assist
the Special Officer for conducting a study of District
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
:9:
Tourism Promotion Councils (DTPC) in the State.
Ext.R1(a) dated 25.07.2002 would show that the petitioner
was appointed as Lecturer on contract basis with effect
from 01.08.2002 in the Ernakulam Chapter of KITTS,
terminating the then existing arrangement to assist the
Secretary / Special Officer in the preparation of report on
restructuring DTPCs.
14.
The KITTS established Kerala Institute of
Hospitality Management Studies (KIHMS) at Malayattoor
and the Government had accorded sanction to create
various posts in KIHMS, as per Ext.P1.
The petitioner
applied for the post of Lecturer in KIHMS and the
petitioner was appointed as Lecturer in the scale of pay as
per Ext.P2 order dated 30.06.2006 of the Director, KITTS.
15.
Ext.P3 Certificate issued by the Director,
KITTS would show that the petitioner's contribution to the
Institute
was
laudable
and
the
petitioner
almost
singlehandedly managed the Courses at KIHMS and
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 10 :
assisted the Principal in Charge for two days a week.
Ext.P3 would indicate that the petitioner used to put lots of
efforts in arranging good placements for the students and
even managed to place some of the students in Maldives
and Dubai.
16.
Ext.P4 Minutes of the 32nd Executive
Committee Meeting of the KITTS would show that the
Government, as per GO dated 17.01.2006 had created
one post of Lecturer, Tourism and Travel Studies and the
petitioner was appointed as Lecturer on 01.07.2006. The
Executive Committee recommended that a decision
regarding regularisation of the petitioner as faculty of
KIHMS may be taken.
The KIHMS was renamed as
KITTS Study Centre, Ernakulam.
17.
The pleadings would indicate that the 2nd
respondent permitted the petitioner to go on deputation as
the Secretary of District Tourism Promotion Council as per
Ext.P5 letter dated 10.08.2011. The District Collector and
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 11 :
Chairman, DTPC had made Ext.P6 request to the
Director, Department of Tourism requesting to issue
orders to permit the petitioner to hold full charge of
Secretary, DTPC and the additional charge of the post he
held in the KITTS. Ext.P6 would show that the lien of the
petitioner is to be retained in the KITTS. Pursuant thereto,
the petitioner took charge as Secretary, DTPC, Ernakulam
on 16.08.2011 which is evident from Ext.P7.
18.
the
Executive
By Ext.P8 Minutes of the 36 th Meeting of
Committee
of
the
KITTS
held
on
11.04.2012, it was resolved to regularise the services of
staff of KITTS based on the advice of the Government.
Pursuant to Ext.P8, Smt. Seema C.L., who was also
recommended for regularisation, was regularised in
service and orders were issued sanctioning the same.
The 38th Meeting of the Executive Committee of KITTS
again decided to place the matter of regularisation of the
petitioner in the next Executive Committee Meeting after
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 12 :
obtaining advice from the Government in the matter of
regularisation.
19.
The 2nd respondent sent Ext.P7 letter
dated 20.03.2015 to the Secretary to Government,
Tourism (B) Department underscoring the need for
regularisation
of
the petitioner.
Government
required
the
2nd
By Ext.P12,
respondent
to
the
give
particulars regarding sanctioned posts for the purpose of
regularisation of the petitioner.
Ext.P13 letter of the
Principal Secretary, Tourism (B) Department required the
2nd respondent to give proposals for creation of posts in
KITTS. The Director gave Ext.P4 reply stating that for the
smooth conduct of Courses, the service of the petitioner
and four others is necessary.
20.
Ext.P15 notes of the Deputy Secretary to
Government, Tourism Department would show that the
Cabinet meeting held on 02.03.2016 had taken a decision
to appoint one Sri. Jimmy Kurian and the petitioner on a
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 13 :
permanent basis with effect from the date on which they
joined service. The Deputy Secretary ordered to forward
the proposal for examination by the Finance Department.
However, Ext.P16 would show that the proposal was
rejected
by
the
Government
on
the
ground
that
regularisation of service of the petitioner would go against
the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Umadevi
(supra). Therefore, it is evident that the Government had
made recommendation for regularisation of the services of
the petitioner and it was not implemented on the ground
that it would go against the decision of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Umadevi (supra). Whether the said reason is
legally justified or not is the question arising for
consideration in this writ petition.
21.
The petitioner had earlier approached
this Court filing W.P.(C) No.21336/2019 seeking directions
for regularisation of his services. This Court noted that no
reasons have been stated as to how the proposal for
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 14 :
regularisation of appointment of the petitioner would fall
foul of Umadevi (supra).
This Court noted that even
assuming that the arguments of the respondents are
accepted, the petitioner has evidently completed more
than 15 years of service and going by the period fixed in
Umadevi (supra), the petitioner is eminently eligible for
regularisation,
though
the
question
whether
his
appointment would in any manner fall within the prohibited
categories stipulated in Umadevi (supra) is to be looked
into.
This Court therefore directed the Government to
reconsider the request of the petitioner for regularisation
as recommended by the KITTS.
22.
Pursuant to Ext.P21 judgment in W.P.(C)
No.21336/2019, the Government issued Ext.P22 order
rejecting the claim of the petitioner.
In Ext.P22, the
Government has conceded that certain other employees
of the KITTS were granted regularisation on the basis of
judgments of this Court. The proposal for regularisation of
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 15 :
the services of the petitioner was rejected on the basis of
the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Umadevi
(supra). In Ext.P22, the Government has observed that
grant of regularisation to another employee pursuant to
court order cannot be a reason for the petitioner to seek
regularisation.
23.
It is to be noted that the petitioner was
well qualified when he was appointed as a Lecturer in
KITTS in the year 2006. Ext.P3 would show that during
the initial years of the KITTS, the petitioner contributed to
the Institute in a laudable manner.
The petitioner has
been singlehandedly managing the Courses at KIHMS /
KITTS Study Centre. The petitioner's efforts in arranging
good placements for the students and in other areas, is
amply
evident
from
Ext.P3.
The
KITTS
had
recommended regularisation of his services. Ext.P15 file
notes would indicate that the Cabinet had decided to give
regular/permanent appointment to the petitioner with effect
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 16 :
from the date from which the petitioner was appointed.
However, the Government has gone back from its position
holding that regularisation of services of the petitioner
would be against the judgment of the Apex Court in
Umadevi (supra).
24.
In Amarkand Rai v. State of Bihar and
others [(2015) 8 SCC 265], the Hon’ble Apex Court held
that there is an exception to the general principles against
regularisation enunciated in Umadevi (3), if the following
conditions are fulfilled:
(i)
The employee concerned
should have worked for ten years or more in
duly sanctioned posts without the benefit or
protection of the interim order of the court or
Tribunal. In other words, the State Government
or its instrumentality should have employed the
employee and continued him in service
voluntarily and continuously for more than ten
years.
(ii)
The appointment of such
employee should not be illegal, even if irregular.
Where the appointments are not made or
continued against sanctioned posts or where
the persons appointed do not possess the
prescribed
minimum
qualifications,
the
appointments will be considered to be illegal.
But, where the person employed possessed the
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 17 :
prescribed qualifications and was working
against the sanctioned posts, but had been
selected without undergoing the process of
open competitive selection, such appointments
are considered to be irregular.
25.
In
the
case
of
the
petitioner,
petitioner has worked for nearly 15 years.
the
The KITTS
employed the petitioner and continued him in service
voluntarily and continuously for more than ten years. The
respondents have no case that the recruitment of the
petitioner was illegal. Therefore, going by the judgment of
the Hon’ble Apex Court in Amarkand Rai (supra), the
petitioner is entitled to regularisation of his services.
26.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has held in the
judgment in Vinod Kumar and others v. Union of India and
others [Civil Appeal Nos.5153-54 of 2024] that the
judgment in the case of Umadevi (supra) distinguished
between
“irregular”
and
“illegal”
appointments
underscoring the importance of considering certain
appointments even if were not made strictly in accordance
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 18 :
with the prescribed rules and procedure and such
appointment cannot be said to have been made illegally if
they had followed the procedure for regular appointments.
27.
For all the afore reasons, I find that the
petitioner is entitled to regularisation of his services.
Ext.P22 is therefore set aside.
The respondents are
directed to regularise the service of the petitioner and to
grant him all consequential service and monetary benefits.
Necessary orders shall be passed within a period of three
months.
The writ petition is disposed of as above.
Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE
aks/05.04.2025
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 19 :
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 4651/2023
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit-P1
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER
20/2006/TSM DATED 17-01-2006
Exhibit-P2
THE TRUE COPY OF THE
LETTER DATED 30.06.2006
Exhibit-P3
THE TRUE COPY OF THE APPRECIATION
LETTER ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
DIRECTOR DATED 04.04.2006
Exhibit-P4
THE TRUE COPY OF THE AGENDA NOTES OF
32ND EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE MEETING OF
2ND
RESPONDENT
KITTS
DATED
11.06.2009
Exhibit-P5
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED
BY
THE
2ND
RESPONDENT
DATED
10.08.2011
Exhibit-P6
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED
BY
THE
SECRETARY
DTPC
DATED
16.08.2011
Exhibit-P7
THE TRUE COPY OF
TRANSFER OF CHARGE
Exhibit-P8
THE TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT PAGES
OF THE MINUTES OF MEETING OF THE
36TH
EXECUTIVE
COMMITTEE
DATED
11.04.2012
Exhibit-P9
THE TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT
EXTRACT OF THE MINUTES OF 38TH
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE KITTS HELD ON
27.11.2013
Exhibit-P10
THE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE RELEVANT
EXTRACT OF THE MINUTES OF 40TH
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE KITTS HELD ON
THE
NO.
APPOINTMENT
REPORT
OF
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 20 :
17.03.2015
Exhibit-P11
THE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
2668/KITTS/MAL/14 DATED 20.03.2015
FROM 2ND RESPONDENT DIRECTOR KITTS
TO THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT;
TOURISM
Exhibit-P12
THE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
1613/B3/2015/TOURISM DATED 5.06.2015
TO THE DIRECTOR KITTS
Exhibit-P13
THE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
1613/B3/2015/TOURISM
DATED
15.02.2016 TO THE DIRECTOR KITTS
Exhibit-P14
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.
475/KITTS/MALAYATTOOR/2016/KITTS
DATED 19.02.2016 ALONG WITH REPORT
ENCLOSED THERETO
Exhibit-P15
THE PHOTOSTAT COPY OF THE RELEVANT
PROCEEDINGS
AS
PER
FILE
NO.
1613/B3/15/TOURISM DATED 5-03-2016
Exhibit-P16
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED
BY THE GOVERNMENT DATED 01.05.2017
Exhibit-P17
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
23.05.2019 IN W.P.(C) 17241/2018
Exhibit-P18
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY
THE 2ND RESPONDENT DATED 20.08.2019
Exhibit-P19
THE TRUE COPY OF THE
ORDER DATED 06.11.2021
Exhibit-P20
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
16.08.2003
ISSUED
BY
THE
2ND
RESPONDENT REGULARIZING THE SERVICE
OF THE SMT. SINDHU S
Exhibit-P21
THE TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
GOVERNMENT
2025:KER:29657
W.P.(C) No.4651/2023
: 21 :
21.06.2022 IN W.P.(C)21336/2019
Exhibit-P22
THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE
GOVERNMENT DATED 29.12.2022
Exhibit-P23
THE TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION
DATED 25.06.2008 ISSUED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
Exhibit-P24
THE TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED
TO
THE
PETITIONER
BY
THE
2ND
RESPONDENT DATED 02.02.2023
RESPONDENT'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit R1(a)
True copy of order
dated 25.07.2002
of
the
KITTS
Exhibit R1(b)
True
copy
of
the
newspaper
advertisement of Mathrubhoomi daily
dtd 15.02.2006 for selection to the
post of lecturer (Travel and tourism
was published on 15.02.2006
Exhibit R1(c)
True copy of the proceedings issued
by KITTS on dtd 24.01.2006
Exhibit R1 (d)
True copy of the extract of minutes
of the Executive committee meeting
on 11.06.2009
Exhibit R1(e)
True
copy
of
the
order
16.07.2012 issued by KITTS
Exhibit R1 (g)
True copy of the appointment letter
dtd 16.08.2003 issued to Ms.Sindhu
Exhibit R1(f)
True copy of the daily newspaper
Malayala Manorama notification dtd
03.03.1998
dated
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review