Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Reserved on
: 20.02.2026
Pronounced on : 04.03.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 04TH DAY OF MARCH, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M. NAGAPRASANNA
WRIT PETITION No.36302 OF 2025 (GM - RES)
BETWEEN:
SYED IBRAHIM THANGAL
S/O SYED HASAN THANGAL
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
R/AT BIJATHALI HOUSE
KOILA POST, RAMAKUNDA VILLAGE
VIA UPPINANGADI, KADABA TALUK
DAKSHINA KANNADA – 574 211.
... PETITIONER
(BY SRI MOHAMMED TAHIR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
STATE BY
MANGALORE NORTH P.S.,
REPRESENTED BY SPP
HIGH COURT COMPLEX
OPP. VIDHANA SOUDHA
BENGALURU – 560 001.
2.
PRADEEP T. R.,
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
R/AT PSI NORTH POLICE STATION
MANGALURU CITY,
KARNATAKA – 575 001.
... RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI B.N.JAGADEESHA, ADDL. SPP)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA READ WITH SECTION 528 OF
THE BNSS, PRAYING TO QUASH THE ARREST MEMO AT ANNEXURE
-E, REMAND ORDER DATED 10.10.2025 AT ANNEXURE -C, AND ALL
CONSEQUENTIAL PROCEEDINGS ARISING OUT OF CRIME NO.
113/2025 REGISTERED BY MANGALORE NORTH PS PENDING IN
THE FILES OF IN THE COURT OF XLIX A.C.C AND S.J., BENGALURU
AT ANNEXURE - D.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 20.02.2026, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, THE COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M.NAGAPRASANNA
CAV ORDER
The petitioner, sole accused in Crime No.113 of 2025, now
stands at the doors of this Court seeking to immediately set him at
liberty, on account of non-furnishing of the grounds of arrest.
2. Facts in brief, germane, are as follows:
A suo motu complaint comes to be registered by the
jurisdictional police which becomes a crime in Crime No.113 of
2025 for offences punishable under Sections 10(a)(i), 13 and 18 of
the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967. On 09-10-2025 the
petitioner was taken into custody and a remand application was
presented before the concerned Court and the petitioner is now in
judicial custody since 09-10-2025.
The sole score on which the
petitioner is now before the Court is on the ground that a physical
copy of the grounds of arrest was not furnished to him at the time
of his arrest and the concerned Court directed that the physical
copy shall be served at that time.
3. Heard Sri Mohammed Tahir, learned counsel appearing for
petitioner and Sri B N Jagadeesha, learned Additional State Public
Prosecutor appearing for the respondents.
4. Learned counsel Sri Mohammed Tahir appearing for the
petitioner would take this Court through the documents appended
to the petition to demonstrate that, for the first time before the
concerned Court, a copy of the grounds of arrest is given to the
petitioner, which was in violation of the judgments rendered by the
Apex Court in the case of VIHAAN KUMAR v. STATE OF
HARYANA1 as also in the case of MIHIR RAJESH SHAH v. STATE
OF MAHARASHTRA2.
He would submit that on this ground the
petitioner may be set at liberty forthwith, failing which, the
Constitutional right of the petitioner would be a mirage.
5. Per-contra, learned Additional State Public Prosecutor
would vehemently refute the submissions contending that grounds
of arrest was indeed given to the petitioner and he has signed
receiving the said grounds of arrest at the time of his arrest i.e., at
1.00 p.m. on 09-10-2025.
He would submit that there is no
violation of law as laid down by the Apex Court.
Insofar as the
judgment in the case of MIHIR RAJESH SHAH, the learned
Additional State Public Prosecutor would submit that the said
judgment cannot be pressed into service for arrests that have
happened prior to MIHIR RAJESH SHAH. In all, he would submit
that there is complete compliance with the judgment of the Apex
Court and grounds of arrest is indeed furnished.
(2025) 5 SCC 799
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2356
6. I have given my anxious consideration to the submissions
made by the respective learned counsel and have perused the
material on record.
7. The issue now lies in a narrow compass.
The compass
revolves round furnishing of grounds of arrest.
A suo motu
complaint
comes
to
be
registered
on
09-10-2025
by
the
jurisdictional police, Mangalore North. The complaint reads as
follows:
“ಪ ೕಪ .ಆ
ೕ
ಉಪ
ೕ ಕರು,
ಮಂಗಳ ರು ಉತರ
ೕ ,
ಾ ೆ : ಬಂದರು ಮಂಗಳ ರು
!ೆ ,
ಾ ಾ"#ಾ ಯವರು
ಮಂಗಳ ರು ಉತರ
ೕ
ಾ ೆ
ಬಂದರು, ಮಂಗಳ ರು,
&ಾನ()ೇ,
ಮಂಗಳ ರು
ಉತರ
ೕ
ಾ ಾ
/ೕ0ಾ"#ಾ ಗಳ ಸೂಚ.ೆಯಂ4ೆ ಮಂಗಳ ರು ಉತರ
*ಎ ಐ
ೕ
ಪ- ೕಪ
.ಆ
ಆದ
.ಾನು
ಾ ೆಯ 5, 6ೋ7ಯ8 9:;ಾ
< ಟ ಂ> ಉಸು?ಾ ಯನು@ &ಾ:#ೊಂ:ದುA, ಪ-ಮುಖ?ಾದ 6ಾ&ಾCಕ Dಾಲ4ಾಣ?ಾದ,
Facebook, Whatsapp, Youtube, ಇತgÉ Dಾಲ4ಾಣಗಳ 5 ¥ÀæZÀ°vÀ HೆಳವI!ೆಗಳJ ಮತು
#ಾನೂನು HಾKರ LMಾರಗಳ ಬ!ೆN 6ಾವOಜ ಕ QಾಂR .ೆಮS !ೆ ಭಂಗ?ಾಗುವಂತಹ Lಷಯಗಳ ಬ!ೆN
ಗಮನ ಹ W ಮುಂ ನ #ಾನೂನು ಕ-ಮ ಜರುXಸಲು /ೕ0ಾ"#ಾ ಗಳJ ಸೂYWರು4ಾ)ೆ.
ಈ
ನ
.ಾಂಕ 09-10-2025 ರಂದು Hೆ[!ೆN 08-00 ಗಂ\ೆ!ೆ HಾR]^ಾರ)ೊಬ_ರು
&ಾKR ಏ.ೆಂದ)ೆ,
ೕ:ದ
aೇ ತ ಸಂಘಟ.ೆ;ಾದ P.F.I ಮಂಗಳ ರು cೆಸ ನ 5 6ಾ&ಾCಕ
Dಾಲ4ಾಣ?ಾದ Whatsapp ಗೂ-d ಗಳ 5 ಸಯ(e ಇHಾ-Kಂ, )ಾಮ ಕುಂಜ ಪ ತೂರು, ಎಂHಾತನು
ತನ@
ೕf ನಂಬರ: 9353241169 .ೇದ ಂದ "SALAMAN SALAMA" ಎಂಬ cೆಸ ನ
Whatsapp ಗೂ-d ನ 5 ಹ g hರುವ ^ಾX R[Wರು4ಾ.ೆ.
.ಾಂಕ 28-09-2022 ರ ಅ"ಸೂಚ.ೆಯ 5 #ೇಂದ- ಸರ#ಾರವ PFI ಸಂಘಟ.ೆಯನು@
#ಾನೂನು HಾKರ ಸಂಘಟ.ೆ ಎಂದು jೂೕkಸ0ಾXರುತ^ೆ. ತದ ನಂತರವ , "SALAMAN
SALAMA" ಎಂಬ cೆಸ ನ Whatsapp ಗೂ-d ನ 5 The Popular Front of India (PFI)
ಸಂಘಟ.ೆಯನು@ ಸlಯಂ mೆ-ೕರ ೆnಂದ ಪ-Mಾರ &ಾ: 4ಾನು ಸದಸ(.ೆಂದು 4ೋಪO:W ಈ Kಂ^ೆ
ಸದಸ()ಾXದAವರನು@ ಪ ನ: 6ೆoೆಯಲು ದುµÉàçà W, ಪ-Mೋ W cಾಗೂ ಸಂಘಟ.ೆ ಇನು@ ಕೂಡ
Mಾ ಯ ^ೆ ಎಂಬುದನು@ 4ೋಪO:ಸುವ ಮೂಲಕ qಾರತದ 6ೌವOqೌಮ4ೆ, ಏಕ4ೆ ಮತು ಅಖಂಡ4ೆ
cಾಗೂ ಸುಭದ-4ೆ!ೆ Hೆದ #ೆಯ.ೊ@ಡುವ ಮತು ;ಾವ ^ೇ ವಗOದ ಜನರ 5 ಭsಂ^ೋಲವನು@
ಉಂಟು&ಾಡುವ ಉ^ೆAೕಶ ಂದ The Popular Front of India (PFI) ಸದಸ(ರನು@ ಒಟುhಗೂ:W
ಗುಂಪ !ಾ #ೆ
&ಾ:#ೊಂಡು
ಅಪ)ಾ"ಕ
బల ಪ-ದಶOನದ
ಮೂಲಕ
ಆತಂಕಪ:ಸುವ ದ#ಾvX
ಪwವOHಾL ಕೃತ(ವನು@ ಎಸಗಲು ಸಂಘ ತ ಅ)ಾಧ#ಾvX, ದುµÉàçà W,
#ಾನೂನು HಾKರ
ಚಟುವ #ೆಗಳನು@ ನzೆಸಲು ಮಂಗಳ ರು ನಗರ, ಕ.ಾOಟಕ ಮತು qಾರತ^ಾತ(ಂತ ಸ&ಾಜ {ತುಕ
ಕೃತ(ವನು@ ನzೆಸುವ ಉ^ೆAೕಶ ಂದ PFI MANGALORE cೆಸ ನ 5
ೕ h cಾಕುವ ಮು|ಾಂತರ
ಎಚ} #ೆ ಸಂ^ೇಶವನು@ 6ಾ&ಾCಕ Dಾಲ4ಾಣ?ಾದ Whatsapp ಗೂ-d ನ 5 ಹ gಟh 6ೈಯ(e
ಇHಾ-Kಂ ಮತು ಇತರ ಸಹಚರರ /ೕ0ೆ ಸೂಕ #ಾನೂನು ಕ-ಮ #ೈ#ೊಳ•Hೇ#ಾX #ೋ #ೆ.
ಸ€ಳ: ಮಂಗಳ ರು ಉತರ
ೕ .
.ಾಂಕ : 09/10/2025
Sd/ೕಸ ಉಪ
ೕ ಕರು
GvÀÛgÀ ¥Éưøï oÁuÉ
§AzÀgÀÄ, ªÀÄAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ £ÀUÀgÀ,
zÀ.PÀ.f¯Éè.”
On the registration of the complaint, the petitioner is taken into
custody, not just taken into custody, but by furnishing both, the
grounds of arrest and the reasons for arrest. The reasons for arrest
reads as follows:
A copy of the reasons for arrest is furnished to the petitioner and
his son against signature.
furnished
on
09-10-2025
Grounds of arrest is immediately
itself.
The
time
and
receipt
acknowledged by the petitioner and his son, it reads as follows:
is
The petitioner is then produced before the Special Judge.
The
proceedings before the Special Judge is as follows:
“10.10.2025
Accused by name Syed Ibrahim Thangal,
aged about 55 years, S/o Syed Hasan Thangal,
R/of Bijathali House, Koila Post, Ramakunja Village
via Uppinangadi, Kadaba Taluk, D.K District is
physically produced in open court today i.e on
10.10.2025 at 11.00 AM by Smt Nalini, Police SubInspector, Sri Satisha P.S - HC No.663, Sri
Mahantesh PC No.3266 and Sri Neelya Naik PC
No.3195 of North Police Station, Bunder,
Mangaluru alongwith remand application, arrest
memo, reasons of arrest form, grounds of arrest
form, compliance of 11 guidelines of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Format and photograph of
accused Syed Ibrahim Thangal and medical
certificate (OPD) issued by Government Wenlock
District Hospital, Mangaluru.
On enquiry, accused submits that he was not
ill-treated by the police. Accused submits that he
was arrested yesterday i.e., on 09.10.2025 at
01.00 P.M. The medical certificate (OPD) issued by
Government Wenlock District Hospital, Mangaluru
does not disclose any injuries sustained by the
accused.
Accused submits that his arrest has
been intimated to his son Syed Ismail.
Accused submits that he and his son Syed
Ismail have affixed their signature on
grounds of arrest and reasons of arrest and
also submits that reasons of arrest are not
readover to him at the time of arrest. Further
accused submits that the physical copy of
grounds of arrest has not been served on him.
The learned PP who is present before
court now served physical copy of grounds of
arrest and reasons of arrest to accused in the
open court.
Sri AMK, Adv seeks permission to take
signature of accused on vakalath. Permitted. He
files vakalath for the accused.
The IO files requisition through learned PP
seeking permission to send mobile handset to CEN
Lab to extract data from mobile phone. Permitted.
The IO through learned PP files a letter
alongwith P.F No.145/2025 and seizure mahazar
dated
09.10.2025
alongwith
closed
cover
mentioning CD mailer/Bubble envelope stated to
contain DVD-1 of HT company with regard to
seizure mahazar photo
and videos dated
09.10.2025 and certificate U/sec.63(4)(c) of BSA
and HASH values of electronic/digital record
generated details. The same are taken on record.
Perused the remand application. The IO has
sought remand of accused to Judicial Custody for
15 days.
The offences alleged against the accused are
U/secs.10(A)(I), 13 and 18 of Unlawful Activities
(Prevention) Act. The offences alleged are nonbailable and punishable with imprisonment for life.
The investigation is at the initial stage. In the
opinion of the court, the detention of the accused
in J.C is necessary in the interest of Investigation.
Hence, accused is remanded to Judicial Custody till
24.10.2025.
The jail authorities are directed to produce
accused through V.C on 24.10.2025.”
(Emphasis added)
The Special Judge records that the physical copy of the grounds of
arrest has not been served upon the accused, therefore, the Court
directs serving of the physical copy.
Taking cue from this, the
learned counsel for the petitioner is now wanting to contend that
the grounds of arrest is not furnished to him in terms of the
judgments of the Apex Court in plethora of judgments.
8.1. The Apex Court in the case of PANKAJ BANSAL v.
UNION OF INDIA3, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
38. In this regard, we may note that Article 22(1) of
the Constitution provides, inter alia, that no person who
is arrested shall be detained in custody without being
informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for such
arrest.This being the fundamental right guaranteed to
the arrested person, the mode of conveying information
of the grounds of arrest must necessarily be meaningful
so as to serve the intended purpose. It may be noted that
Section 45 PMLA enables the person arrested under Section 19
thereof to seek release on bail but it postulates that unless the
twin conditions prescribed thereunder are satisfied, such a
person would not be entitled to grant of bail. The twin
conditions set out in the provision are that, firstly, the
court must be satisfied, after giving an opportunity to
the Public Prosecutor to oppose the application for
release, that there are reasonable grounds to believe
that the arrested person is not guilty of the offence and,
secondly, that he is not likely to commit any offence
while on bail. To meet this requirement, it would be
(2024) 7 SCC 576
essential for the arrested person to be aware of the
grounds on which the authorised officer arrested
him/her under Section 19 and the basis for the officer's
“reason to believe” that he/she is guilty of an offence
punishable under the 2002 Act. It is only if the arrested
person has knowledge of these facts that he/she would
be in a position to plead and prove before the Special
Court that there are grounds to believe that he/she is
not guilty of such offence, so as to avail the relief of
bail. Therefore, communication of the grounds of arrest,
as mandated by Article 22(1) of the Constitution and
Section 19 PMLA, is meant to serve this higher purpose
and must be given due importance.
39. We may also note that the language of Section 19
PMLA puts it beyond doubt that the authorised officer has to
record in writing the reasons for forming the belief that the
person proposed to be arrested is guilty of an offence
punishable under the 2002 Act. Section 19(2) requires the
authorised officer to forward a copy of the arrest order along
with the material in his possession, referred to in Section
19(1), to the adjudicating authority in a sealed envelope.
Though it is not necessary for the arrested person to be
supplied with all the material that is forwarded to the
adjudicating authority under Section 19(2), he/she has
a constitutional and statutory right to be “informed” of
the grounds of arrest, which are compulsorily recorded
in writing by the authorised officer in keeping with the
mandate of Section 19(1) PMLA. As already noted
hereinbefore, it seems that the mode of informing this to the
persons arrested is left to the option of ED's authorised officers
in different parts of the country i.e. to either furnish such
grounds of arrest in writing or to allow such grounds to be
read by the arrested person or be read over and explained to
such person.
….
….
….
42. That being so, there is no valid reason as to why a
copy of such written grounds of arrest should not be furnished
to the arrested person as a matter of course and without
exception. There are two primary reasons as to why this
would be the advisable course of action to be followed
as a matter of principle. Firstly, in the event such
grounds of arrest are orally read out to the arrested
person or read by such person with nothing further and
this fact is disputed in a given case, it may boil down to
the word of the arrested person against the word of the
authorised officer as to whether or not there is due and
proper compliance in this regard. In the case on hand,
that is the situation insofar as Basant Bansal is
concerned. Though ED claims that witnesses were
present and certified that the grounds of arrest were
read out and explained to him in Hindi, that is neither
here nor there as he did not sign the document. Noncompliance in this regard would entail release of the
arrested person straightaway, as held in V. Senthil
Balaji [V. Senthil Balaji v. State, (2024) 3 SCC 51 :
(2024) 2 SCC (Cri) 1] . Such a precarious situation is
easily avoided and the consequence thereof can be
obviated very simply by furnishing the written grounds
of arrest, as recorded by the authorised officer in terms
of Section 19(1) PMLA, to the arrested person under
due acknowledgment, instead of leaving it to the
debatable ipse dixit of the authorised officer.
43. The second reason as to why this would be the
proper course to adopt is the constitutional objective
underlying such information being given to the arrested
person. Conveyance of this information is not only to
apprise the arrested person of why he/she is being
arrested but also to enable such person to seek legal
counsel and, thereafter, present a case before the court
under Section 45 to seek release on bail, if he/she so
chooses. In this regard, the grounds of arrest in V. Senthil
Balaji [V. Senthil Balaji v. State, (2024) 3 SCC 51 : (2024) 2
SCC (Cri) 1] are placed on record and we find that the same
run into as many as six pages. The grounds of arrest
recorded in the case on hand in relation to Pankaj
Bansal and Basant Bansal have not been produced
before this Court, but it was contended that they were
produced at the time of remand. However, as already
noted earlier, this did not serve the intended purpose.
Further, in the event their grounds of arrest were
equally voluminous, it would be well-nigh impossible for
either Pankaj Bansal or Basant Bansal to record and
remember all that they had read or heard being read out
for future recall so as to avail legal remedies. More so,
as a person who has just been arrested would not be in
a calm and collected frame of mind and may be utterly
incapable of remembering the contents of the grounds
of arrest read by or read out to him/her. The very
purpose of this constitutional and statutory protection
would be rendered nugatory by permitting the
authorities concerned to merely read out or permit
reading of the grounds of arrest, irrespective of their
length and detail, and claim due compliance with the
constitutional requirement under Article 22(1) and the
statutory mandate under Section 19(1) PMLA.”
8.2. The Apex Court in the case of RAM KISHOR ARORA v.
DIRECTORATE OF ENFORCEMENT4, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
21. In view of the above, the expression“as soon as
may be” contained in Section 19 PMLA is required to be
construed as — “as early as possible without avoidable
delay” or “within reasonably convenient” or “reasonably
requisite” period of time. Since by way of safeguard a
duty is cast upon the officer concerned to forward a
copy of the order along with the material in his
possession to the adjudicating authority immediately
after the arrest of the person, and to take the person
arrested to the court concerned within 24 hours of the
arrest, in our opinion, the reasonably convenient or
reasonably requisite time to inform the arrestee about
the grounds of his arrest would be twenty-four hours of
the arrest.
22. In Vijay Madanlal Choudhary [Vijay Madanlal
Choudhary v. Union of India, (2023) 12 SCC 1 : 2022
SCC OnLine SC 929] , it has been categorically held that
so long as the person has been informed about the
grounds of his arrest, that is sufficient compliance with
(2024) 7 SCC 599
mandate of Article 22(1) of the Constitution. It is also
observed that the arrested person before being
produced before the Special Court within twenty-four
hours or for that purposes of remand on each occasion,
the Court is free to look into the relevant records made
available by the authority about the involvement of the
arrested person in the offence of money-laundering.
Therefore, in our opinion the person arrested, if he is
informed or made aware orally about the grounds of
arrest at the time of his arrest and is furnished a written
communication about the grounds of arrest as soon as
may be i.e. as early as possible and within reasonably
convenient and requisite time of twenty-four hours of
his arrest, that would be sufficient compliance of not
only Section 19 PMLA but also of Article 22(1) of the
Constitution of India.
….
….
….
24. Insofar as the facts of the present case are
concerned, it is not disputed that the appellant was
handed over the document containing grounds of arrest
when he was arrested, and he also put his signature
below the said grounds of arrest, after making an
endorsement that “I have been informed and have also
read the abovementioned grounds of arrest.” The
appellant in the rejoinder filed by him has neither
disputed the said endorsement nor his signature below
the said endorsement. The only contention raised by the
learned Senior Counsel Mr Singhvi is that he was not
furnished a copy of the document containing the
grounds of arrest at the time of arrest. Since the
appellant was indisputably informed about the grounds
of arrest and he having also put his signature and the
endorsement on the said document of having been
informed, we hold that there was due compliance of the
provisions contained in Section 19 PMLA and his arrest
could neither be said to be violative of the said
provision nor of Article 22(1) of the Constitution of
India.”
8.3. The Apex Court in the case of PRABIR PURKAYASTHA
v. STATE (NCT OF DELHI)5, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
16. Upon a careful perusal of the statutory provisions
(reproduced supra), we find that there is no significant
difference in the language employed in Section 19(1)
PMLA and Section 43-B(1) UAPA which can persuade us
to take a view that the interpretation of the phrase
“inform him of the grounds for such arrest” made by
this Court in Pankaj Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of
India, (2024) 7 SCC 576] should not be applied to an
accused arrested under the provisions of the UAPA.
17. We find that the provision regarding the
communication of the grounds of arrest to a person
arrested contained in Section 43-B(1) UAPA is verbatim
the same as that in Section 19(1) PMLA. The contention
advanced by the learned ASG that there are some variations in
the overall provisions contained in Section 19 PMLA and
Sections 43-A and 43-B UAPA would not have any impact on
the statutory mandate requiring the arresting officer to inform
the grounds of arrest to the person arrested under Section 43B(1) UAPA at the earliest because as stated above, the
requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest is the same
in both the statutes. As a matter of fact, both the
provisions find their source in the constitutional
safeguard provided under Article 22(1) of the
Constitution of India. Hence, applying the golden rules
of interpretation, the provisions which lay down a very
important constitutional safeguard to a person arrested
on charges of committing an offence either under the
PMLA or under the UAPA, have to be uniformly
construed and applied.
18. We may note that the modified application of
Section 167CrPC is also common to both the statutes. Thus,
we have no hesitation in holding that the interpretation
(2024) 8 SCC 254
of statutory mandate laid down by this Court in Pankaj
Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, (2024) 7 SCC
576] on the aspect of informing the arrested person the
grounds of arrest in writing has to be applied pari
passu to a person arrested in a case registered under
the provisions of the UAPA.
19. Resultantly, there is no doubt in the mind of
the court that any person arrested for allegation of
commission of offences under the provisions of UAPA or
for that matter any other offence(s) has a fundamental
and a statutory right to be informed about the grounds
of arrest in writing and a copy of such written grounds
of arrest have to be furnished to the arrested person as
a matter of course and without exception at the earliest.
The purpose of informing to the arrested person the
grounds of arrest is salutary and sacrosanct inasmuch
as this information would be the only effective means
for the arrested person to consult his advocate; oppose
the police custody remand and to seek bail. Any other
interpretation would tantamount to diluting the sanctity
of the fundamental right guaranteed under Article 22(1)
of the Constitution of India.
….
….
….
24. A Constitution Bench of this Court examined in
detail the scheme of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of
India
in Harikisan v. State
of
Maharashtra
[Harikisan v. State of Maharashtra, 1962 SCC OnLine SC
117] and held that the communication of the grounds of
detention to the detenu in writing and in a language
which he understands is imperative and essential to
provide an opportunity to detenu of making an effective
representation against the detention and in case, such
communication is not made, the order of detention
would stand vitiated as the guarantee under Article
22(5) of the Constitution was violated. The relevant para
is extracted hereinbelow : (SCC OnLine SC para 7)
“7. … clause (5) of Article 22 requires that the
grounds of his detention should be made available to the
detenu as soon as may be, and that the earliest
opportunity of making a representation against the
Order should also be afforded to him. In order that the
detenu should have that opportunity, it is not
sufficient that he has been physically delivered the
means of knowledge with which to make his
representation. In order that the detenu should be
in a position effectively to make his representation
against the Order, he should have knowledge of
the grounds of detention, which are in the nature
of the charge against him setting out the kinds of
prejudicial acts which the authorities attribute to
him. Communication, in this context, must,
therefore, mean imparting to the detenu sufficient
knowledge of all the grounds on which the Order
of Detention is based. In this case the grounds are
several, and are based on numerous speeches said
to have been made by the appellant himself on
different occasions and different dates. Naturally,
therefore, any oral translation or explanation
given by the police officer serving those on the
detenu would not amount to communicating the
grounds. Communication, in this context, must
mean bringing home to the detenu effective
knowledge of the facts and circumstances on
which the Order of Detention is based.”
(emphasis supplied)
25. Further,
this
Court
in LallubhaiJogibhai
Patel v. Union of India [Lallubhai Jogibhai Patel v. Union
of India, (1981) 2 SCC 427 : 1981 SCC (Cri) 463] , laid
down that the grounds of detention must be
communicated to the detenu in writing in a language
which he understands and if the grounds are only
verbally explained, the constitutional mandate of Article
22(5) is infringed. The relevant para is extracted hereunder
: (SCC p. 436, para 20)
“20. … “Communicate” is a strong word. It means
that sufficient knowledge of the basic facts constituting
the “grounds” should be imparted effectively and fully to
the detenu in writing in a language which he
understands. The whole purpose of communicating
the “ground” to the detenu is to enable him to
make a purposeful and effective representation. If
the “grounds” are only verbally explained to the
detenu and nothing in writing is left with him, in a
language which he understands, then that purpose
is not served, and the constitutional mandate in
Article 22(5) is infringed.”
(emphasis supplied)
26. From a holistic reading of various judgments
pertaining to the law of preventive detention including
the Constitution Bench decision of this Court
in Harikisan [Harikisan v. State of Maharashtra, 1962
SCC OnLine SC 117] , wherein, the provisions of Article
22(5) of the Constitution of India have been
interpreted, we find that it has been the consistent view
of this Court that the grounds on which the liberty of a
citizen is curtailed, must be communicated in writing so
as to enable him to seek remedial measures against the
deprivation of liberty.
27. Thus, there is no hesitation in the mind of this Court
that the submission of the learned ASG that in a case of
preventive detention, the grounds of detention need not be
provided to a detenu in writing is ex facie untenable in the eye
of the law.
28. The language used in Article 22(1) and Article
22(5) of the Constitution of India regarding the
communication of the grounds is exactly the identical.
Neither of the constitutional provisions require that the
“grounds” of “arrest” or “detention”, as the case may
be,
must
be
communicated
in
writing.
Thus,
interpretation
to
this
important
facet
of
the
fundamental right as made by the Constitution Bench
while examining the scope of Article 22(5) of the
Constitution of India would ipso facto apply to Article
22(1) of the Constitution of India insofar as the
requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest is
concerned.
29. Hence, we have no hesitation in reiterating
that the requirement to communicate the grounds of
arrest or the grounds of detention in writing to a person
arrested in connection with an offence or a person
placed under preventive detention as provided under
Articles 22(1) and 22(5) of the Constitution of India is
sacrosanct and cannot be breached under any situation.
Non-compliance of this constitutional requirement and
statutory mandate would lead to the custody or the detention
being rendered illegal, as the case may be.
….
….
….
48. It may be reiterated at the cost of repetition that
there is a significant difference in the phrase “reasons for
arrest” and “grounds of arrest”. The “reasons for arrest” as
indicated in the arrest memo are purely formal
parameters viz. to prevent the accused person from
committing any further offence; for proper investigation
of the offence; to prevent the accused person from
causing the evidence of the offence to disappear or
tampering with such evidence in any manner; to prevent
the arrested person for making inducement, threat or
promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the
case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to
the court or to the investigating officer. These reasons
would commonly apply to any person arrested on
charge of a crime whereas the “grounds of arrest”
would be required to contain all such details in hand of
the investigating officer which necessitated the arrest
of the accused. Simultaneously, the grounds of arrest
informed in writing must convey to the arrested accused
all basic facts on which he was being arrested so as to
provide him an opportunity of defending himself against
custodial remand and to seek bail. Thus, the “grounds of
arrest” would invariably be personal to the accused and
cannot be equated with the “reasons of arrest” which
are general in nature.”
8.4. The Apex Court in the case of VIHAAN KUMAR v.
STATE OF HARYANA supra, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
18. Therefore, as far as Article 22(1) is concerned,
compliance can be made by communicating sufficient
knowledge of the basic facts constituting the grounds of
arrest to the person arrested. The grounds should be
effectively and fully communicated to the arrestee in
the manner in which he will fully understand the same.
Therefore, it follows that the grounds of arrest must be
informed in a language which the arrestee understands.
That is how, in Pankaj Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of
India, (2024) 7 SCC 576 : (2024) 3 SCC (Cri) 450] , this
Court held that the mode of conveying the grounds of
arrest must necessarily be meaningful so as to serve the
intended purpose. However, under Article 22(1), there
is no requirement of communicating the grounds of
arrest in writing. Article 22(1) also incorporates the
right of every person arrested to consult an advocate of
his choice and the right to be defended by an advocate.
If the grounds of arrest are not communicated to the
arrestee, as soon as may be, he will not be able to
effectively exercise the right to consult an advocate.
This requirement incorporated in Article 22(1) also
ensures that the grounds for arresting the person
without a warrant exist. Once a person is arrested, his
right to liberty under Article 21 is curtailed. When such
an important fundamental right is curtailed, it is
necessary that the person concerned must understand
on what grounds he has been arrested. That is why the
mode of conveying information of the grounds must be
meaningful so as to serve the objects stated above.
19. Thus, the requirement of informing the person
arrested of the grounds of arrest is not a formality but a
mandatory constitutional requirement. Article 22 is
included in Part III of the Constitution under the
heading of Fundamental Rights. Thus, it is the
fundamental right of every person arrested and
detained in custody to be informed of the grounds of
arrest as soon as possible. If the grounds of arrest are
not informed as soon as may be after the arrest, it
would amount to a violation of the fundamental right of
the arrestee guaranteed under Article 22(1).It will also
amount to depriving the arrestee of his liberty. The
reason is that, as provided in Article 21, no person can
be deprived of his liberty except in accordance with the
procedure
established
by
law.
The
procedure
established by law also includes what is provided in
Article 22(1). Therefore, when a person is arrested
without a warrant, and the grounds of arrest are not
informed to him, as soon as may be, after the arrest, it
will amount to a violation of his fundamental right
guaranteed under Article 21 as well. In a given case, if
the mandate of Article 22 is not followed while arresting
a person or after arresting a person, it will also violate
fundamental right to liberty guaranteed under Article
21, and the arrest will be rendered illegal. On the failure
to comply with the requirement of informing grounds of
arrest as soon as may be after the arrest, the arrest is
vitiated. Once the arrest is held to be vitiated, the
person arrested cannot remain in custody even for a
second.
20. We have already referred to what is held in
paras
and
of
the
decision
in Pankaj
Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India, (2024) 7 SCC
576 : (2024) 3 SCC (Cri) 450] . This Court has
suggested that the proper and ideal course of
communicating the grounds of arrest is to provide
grounds of arrest in writing. Obviously, before a police
officer communicates the grounds of arrest, the grounds of
arrest have to be formulated. Therefore, there is no harm if
the grounds of arrest are communicated in writing. Although
there is no requirement to communicate the grounds of
arrest in writing, what is stated in paras 42 and 43 of
the decision in Pankaj Bansal [Pankaj Bansal v. Union of
India, (2024) 7 SCC 576 : (2024) 3 SCC (Cri) 450] are
suggestions that merit consideration. We are aware that
in every case, it may not be practicable to implement what is
suggested. If the course, as suggested, is followed, the
controversy about the non-compliance will not arise at all. The
police have to balance the rights of a person arrested with the
interests of the society. Therefore, the police should always
scrupulously comply with the requirements of Article 22.
….
….
….
23. In the present case, the first respondent relied upon
an entry in the case diary allegedly made at 6.10 p.m. on 106-2024, which records that the appellant was arrested after
informing him of the grounds of arrest. For the reasons which
will follow hereafter, we are rejecting the argument made by
the first respondent. If the police want to prove
communication of the grounds of arrest only based on a
diary entry, it is necessary to incorporate those grounds
of arrest in the diary entry or any other document. The
grounds of arrest must exist before the same are
informed. Therefore, in a given case, even assuming
that the case of the police regarding requirements of
Article 22(1) of the Constitution is to be accepted based
on an entry in the case diary, there must be a
contemporaneous record, which records what the
grounds of arrest were. When an arrestee pleads before
a court that grounds of arrest were not communicated,
the burden to prove the compliance of Article 22(1) is
on the police.
….
….
….
Conclusions
26. Therefore, we conclude:
26.1. The requirement of informing a person
arrested of grounds of arrest is a mandatory
requirement of Article 22(1);
26.2. The information of the grounds of arrest
must be provided to the arrested person in such a
manner that sufficient knowledge of the basic facts
constituting the grounds is imparted and communicated
to the arrested person effectively in the language which
he
understands.
The
mode
and
method
of
communication must be such that the object of the
constitutional safeguard is achieved;
26.3. When
arrested
accused
alleges
noncompliance with the requirements of Article 22(1), the
burden
will
always
be
on
the
investigating
officer/agency
to
prove
compliance
with
the
requirements of Article 22(1);
26.4. Non-compliance with Article 22(1) will be a
violation of the fundamental rights of the accused
guaranteed by the said Article. Moreover, it will amount
to a violation of the right to personal liberty guaranteed
by Article 21 of the Constitution. Therefore, noncompliance with the requirements of Article 22(1)
vitiates the arrest of the accused. Hence, further orders
passed by a criminal court of remand are also vitiated.
Needless to add that it will not vitiate the investigation,
charge-sheet and trial. But, at the same time, filing of chargesheet will not validate a breach of constitutional mandate
under Article 22(1);
26.5. When an arrested person is produced before a
Judicial Magistrate for remand, it is the duty of the Magistrate
to ascertain whether compliance with Article 22(1) and other
mandatory safeguards has been made; and
26.6. When a violation of Article 22(1) is
established, it is the duty of the court to forthwith order
the release of the accused. That will be a ground to
grant bail even if statutory restrictions on the grant of
bail exist. The statutory restrictions do not affect the
power of the court to grant bail when the violation of
Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution is established.
….
….
….
30. Thus, the stand taken by Shri Abhimanyu is that the
grounds of arrest were explained to the appellant's wife in
detail, and when she again came to meet the appellant, she
was informed and explained the grounds of arrest. Thus, the
stand taken shows that grounds of arrest were not informed to
the appellant but to his wife. The contention that the
appellant's wife was informed about the grounds of
arrest is an afterthought, as no such contention has
been raised in the reply filed before the High Court.
Communication of the grounds of arrest to the wife of
the arrestee is no compliance with the mandate of
Article 22(1). As the ground of non-compliance with Article
22(1) has been specifically pleaded in this appeal, this was the
second opportunity available to the first respondent to plead
and prove that grounds of arrest were informed to the
appellant. However, it has not been done, and his contention
is that the grounds of arrest were communicated to the
appellant's wife.
31. A contention has been raised in the written
argument that the grounds of arrest were incorporated in the
remand report. This contention has been raised for the first
time in written submissions before this Court. This is not
pleaded in the reply filed before the High Court and this Court.
The police submit a remand report before the learned
Magistrate for seeking remand without serving a copy thereof
to the arrestee. The reason is that the police cannot divulge
the details of the investigation to the accused till the final
report is filed. Mentioning the grounds of arrest in the remand
report is no compliance with the requirement of informing the
arrestee of the grounds of arrest.
32. The stand taken before the High Court was
that the appellant's wife was informed about the arrest.
Information about the arrest is completely different
from the grounds of arrest. The grounds of arrest are
different from the arrest memo. The arrest memo
incorporates the name of the arrested person, his
permanent address, present address, particulars of FIR
and section applied, place of arrest, date and time of
arrest, the name of the officer arresting the accused and
name, address and phone number of the person to
whom information about arrest has been given. We
have perused the arrest memo in the present case. The
same contains only the information stated above and
not the grounds of arrest. The information about the
arrest is completely different from the information
about the grounds of arrest. Mere information of arrest
will not amount to furnishing grounds of arrest.
33. Reliance was placed in this regard on the case diary
entry of 10-6-2024 at 6.10 p.m., which records that the
appellant was arrested after informing him of the grounds of
arrest. This was not pleaded before the High Court as well as
in this Court in the reply of the first respondent. This is an
afterthought. Considering the stand taken in the reply filed
before the High Court and this Court, only on the basis of a
vague entry in the police diary, we cannot accept that
compliance with Article 22(1) can be inferred. No
contemporaneous documents have been put on record wherein
the grounds of arrest have been noted. Therefore, reliance
placed on the diary entries is completely irrelevant.
….
….
….
42. The purpose of inserting Section 50-ACrPC,
making it obligatory on the person making arrest to
inform about the arrest to the friends, relatives or
persons nominated by the arrested person, is to ensure
that they would be able to take immediate and prompt
actions to secure the release of the arrested person as
permissible under the law. The arrested person,
because of his detention, may not have immediate and
easy access to the legal process for securing his release,
which would otherwise be available to the friends,
relatives and such nominated persons by way of
engaging lawyers, briefing them to secure release of the
detained person on bail at the earliest. Therefore, the
purpose of communicating the grounds of arrest to the
detenue, and in addition to his relatives as mentioned
above is not merely a formality but to enable the
detained person to know the reasons for his arrest but
also to provide the necessary opportunity to him
through his relatives, friends or nominated persons to
secure his release at the earliest possible opportunity
for actualising the fundamental right to liberty and life
as
guaranteed
under
Article
of
the
Constitution.Hence, the requirement of communicating
the grounds of arrest in writing is not only to the
arrested person, but also to the friends, relatives or
such other person as may be disclosed or nominated by
the arrested person, so as to make the mandate of
Article 22(1) of the Constitution meaningful and
effective failing which, such arrest may be rendered
illegal.”
8.5. The Apex Court in the case of KASIREDDY UPENDER
v. STATE OF HARYANA6, while considering the judgment in
VIHAAN KUMAR supra,has held as follows:
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1228
“….
….
….
18. Thus, the following principles of law could be
said to have been laid down, rather very well explained,
in Vihaan Kumar (supra):
a) The requirement of informing the person
arrested of the grounds of arrest is not a
formality but a mandatory constitutional
condition.
b) Once a person is arrested, his right to liberty
under Article 21 is curtailed. When such an
important fundamental right is curtailed, it is
necessary that the person concerned must
understand on what grounds he has been
arrested.
c) The mode of conveying the information of the
grounds of arrest must be meaningful so as to
serve the true object underlying Article 22(1).
d) If the grounds of arrest are not informed as
soon as may be after the arrest, it would
amount to a violation of the fundamental right
of the arrestee guaranteed under Article 22(1).
e) On the failure to comply with the requirement
of informing the grounds of arrest as soon as
may be after the arrest, the arrest would stand
vitiated. Once the arrest is held to be vitiated,
the person arrested cannot remain in custody
even for a second.
f) If the police want to prove communication of
the grounds of arrest only based on a diary
entry, it is necessary to incorporate those
grounds of arrest in the diary entry or any
other document. The grounds of arrest must
exist before the same are informed.
g) When an arrestee pleads before a court that
the grounds of arrest were not communicated,
the burden to prove the compliance of Article
22(1) is on the police authorities.
h) The grounds of arrest should not only be
provided to the arrestee but also to his family
members and relatives so that necessary
arrangements are made to secure the release
of the person arrested at the earliest possible
opportunity so as to make the mandate of
Article 22(1) meaningful and effective, failing
which, such arrest may be rendered illegal.
19. We must clarify one important aspect
of Vihaan Kumar (supra). In Vihaan Kumar (supra) the
case was that there was an absolute failure on the part
of the police to provide the grounds of arrest. In Vihaan
Kumar (supra) reliance was placed upon the entry in
the case diary which recorded that the appellant therein
was arrested after informing him of the grounds of
arrest. In the case at hand, it is not in dispute that the
grounds of arrest were supplied to the arrestee,
however, the case put up is that those grounds are not
meaningful and are bereft of necessary essential
information.”
8.6. The Apex Court in the case of STATE OF KARNATAKA
v. DARSHAN7, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
20.1. Delay in furnishing the grounds of arrest
cannot, by itself, constitute a valid ground for grant of
bail.
20.1.1. The learned counsel for the respondents accused contended that the arrest was illegal as the grounds
of arrest were not furnished immediately in writing, thereby
violating Article 22 (1) of the Constitution and Section 50 Cr.
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1702
P.C. (now Section 47 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita). This submission, however, is devoid of merit.
20.1.2. Article 22(1) of the Constitution mandates that
“no person who is arrested shall be detained in custody
without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for
such arrest, nor shall he be denied the right to consult, and to
be defended by, a legal practitioner of his choice”. Similarly,
Section 50 (1) Cr. P.C. requires that “every police officer or
other person arresting any person without warrant shall
forthwith communicate to him full particulars of the offence for
which he is arrested or other grounds for such arrest.
20.1.3. The
constitutional
and
statutory
framework thus mandates that the arrested person
must be informed of the grounds of arrest - but neither
provision prescribes a specific form or insists upon
written
communication
in
every
case.
Judicial
precedents have clarified that substantial compliance
with
these
requirements
is
sufficient,
unless
demonstrable prejudice is shown.
20.1.4. In Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana22, it
was reiterated that Article 22(1) is satisfied if the
accused is made aware of the arrest grounds in
substance, even if not conveyed in writing. Similarly,
in Kasireddy
Upender
Reddy v. State
of
Andhra
Pradesh23, it was observed that when arrest is made
pursuant a warrant, reading out the warrant amounts to
sufficient
compliance.
Both
these
post- Pankaj
Bansal decisions clarify that written, individualised
grounds are not an inflexible requirement in all
circumstances.
20.1.5. While Section 50 Cr. P.C. is mandatory, the
consistent judicial approach has been to adopt a
prejudice-oriented
test
when
examining
alleged
procedural lapses. The mere absence of written grounds
does not ipso facto render the arrest illegal, unless it
results in demonstrable prejudice or denial of a fair
opportunity to defend.
20.1.6. The High Court, however, relied heavily on the
alleged procedural lapse as a determinative factor while
overlooking
the
gravity
of
the
offence
under
Section 302 IPC and the existence of a prima facie case. It
noted, inter alia, that there was no mention in the remand
orders about service of memo of grounds of arrest (para 45);
the arrest memos were allegedly template-based and not
personalised (para 50); and eyewitnesses had not stated that
they were present at the time of arrest or had signed the
memos (para 48). Relying on Pankaj Bansal v. Union of
India24 and Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) (supra),
it concluded (paras 43, 49 - 50) that from 03.10.2023
onwards, failure to serve detailed, written, and individualised
grounds of arrest immediately after arrest was a violation
entitling the accused to bail.
20.1.7. In the present case, the arrest memos and
remand records clearly reflect that the respondents
were aware of the reasons for their arrest. They were
legally represented from the outset and applied for bail
shortly after arrest, evidencing an immediate and
informed understanding of the accusations. No material
has been placed on record to establish that any
prejudice was caused due to the alleged procedural
lapse. In the absence of demonstrable prejudice, such as
irregularity is, at best, a curable defect and cannot, by itself,
warrant release on bail. As reiterated above, the High Court
treated it as a determinative factor while overlooking the
gravity of the charge under Section 302 IPC and the existence
of a prima facie case. Its reliance on Pankaj Bansal and Prabir
Purkayastha is misplaced, as those decisions turned on
materially different facts and statutory contexts. The approach
adopted here is inconsistent with the settled principle that
procedural lapses in furnishing grounds of arrest, absent
prejudice, do not ipso facto render custody illegal or entitle the
accused to bail.”
8.7. The Apex Court in the case of MIHIR RAJESH SHAH v.
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA supra, has held as follows:
“….
….
….
66. In conclusion, it is held that:
66.1. The constitutional mandate of informing the
arrestee the grounds of arrest is mandatory in all offences
under all statutes including offences under IPC, 1860 (now
BNS 2023);
66.2. The
grounds
of
arrest
must
be
communicated in writing to the arrestee in the language
he/she understands;
66.3. In
case(s)
where,
the
arresting
officer/person is unable to communicate the grounds of
arrest in writing on or soon after arrest, it be so done
orally. The said grounds be communicated in writing
within a reasonable time and in any case at least two
hours prior to production of the arrestee for remand
proceedings before the Magistrate.
66.4. In case of non-compliance of the above, the
arrest and subsequent remand would be rendered illegal and
the person will be at liberty to be set free.
….
….
….
68. We are cognizant that there existed no
consistent or binding requirement mandating written
communication of the grounds of arrest for all the
offences. Holding as above, in our view, would ensure
implementation of the constitutional rights provided to
an arrestee as engrafted under Article 22 of the
Constitution of India in an effective manner. Such
clarity on obligation would avoid uncertainty in the
administration of criminal justice. The ends of fairness
and legal discipline therefore demand that this
procedure as affirmed above shall govern arrests
henceforth.”
(Emphasis supplied at each instance)
The Apex Court, in the afore-quoted judgments, holds that the
grounds of arrest must be furnished to the accused as soon as may
be, from the time of arrest and a relative or a friend of the accused
is required to be informed of his or her arrest.
It is in MIHIR
RAJESH SHAH, for the first time, the Apex Court holds that it
should be furnished at least 2 hours prior to the production of the
accused before the learned Magistrate.
9. It would have been an altogether different circumstance if
no grounds of arrest had been furnished to the petitioner, whether
it is two hours or otherwise is a matter that is to be examined. But
in the case at hand, grounds of arrest are furnished, it is
acknowledged, the acknowledgement is by way of a signature.
A
stray observation in the order of the concerned Court cannot mean
that the records would get wiped away. In fact the order itself is
contradictory.
The concerned Court observes that the grounds of
arrest and reasons of arrest were given to the accused, but not
read over.
The physical copy though given, it was directed that
another copy should be given.
Though the word another copy is
not found in the order, it is ostensible, as the petitioner had
received the grounds of arrest as quoted and noted supra. In that
light, the arrest of the petitioner cannot be held to be illegal for
want of grounds of arrest and he cannot be set at liberty on the
said ground.
Finding complete compliance with the judgments of the Apex
Court, the petition lacking in merit, stands rejected.
Sd/(M.NAGAPRASANNA)
JUDGE
bkp
CT:SS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review