Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V. SHRAVAN KUMAR
Application No.2 of 2024 in C.S. No.13 of 1958
Date: 20.02.2026
Between:
Syed Gulam Syedain Razvi,
S/o. Late Mir Asad All Khan,
Aged about 60 years, Occ: Business
H.No.17-3-484, Inside Yakut Mahal, Hyderabad
and Forty Two others
…
Implead Petitioners/proposed Defendants
And
Lateefunnisa Begum
W/o.Late Nawab Syed Hasan Pasha,
Aged about 45 years,
R/o.Dewan Devidi and Two Hundred and Thirty Two others
…
Respondents
JUDGMENT: (Per the Hon’ble Sri Justice N.V. Shravan Kumar)
Mr. T.K. Sridhar, learned counsel appearing for the applicants.
Mr. Mohammed Imran Khan, learned Additional Advocate
General appears for the respondent State.
2.
This Application is filed under Order XXII Rule 10 and Order I,
Rule 10 read with Section 151 of Civil Procedure Code seeking to
permit the petitioners to implead as respondents/defendants in
C.S. No.13 of 1958.
The petitioners are 43 in number and the
petitioner No.1 on his behalf and on behalf of the other petitioners
filed the present Application under authorisation.
3.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
The petitioner claims to be authorized by other family members,
who were Plaintiffs in O.S. No.14754 of 2003.
A Judgement and
Decree was passed by the VIII Junior Civil Judge, City Civil Court
Hyderabad. The trial Court came to a conclusion that the Plaintiffs in
the said suit were declared as legal heirs and Successors of Dilawar
Begum, who is the Paternal aunt of Nawab Mir Yousuf Ali Khan (Salar
Jung-III), after who's death, the entire estate was taken into Custody
of Union of India. After the death of Mir Yousuf Ali Khan (Salar JungIII), a notification was issued dated 29.03.1956 for the properties by
the Jagir Administrator as per the provisions of Hyderabad Abolition
of Jagirs 1358 Fasli, though knowing pretty well that Salar Jung
Estate, is an exempted Big Estate as per the treaty entered by the
H.E.H Nizam-VII, Mir Osman Ali Khan, vide treaty dated 23rd and 25th
January 1950. Thereafter, two Suits No.39/1 and 40/1 of 1955 on the
file of City Civil Court Hyderabad, were filed for division of Matruka
Properties of Salar Jung Estate, later on they are re-numbered as they
were dealt with by the High Court on original Jurisdiction as
C.S.No.13 of 1958.
4.
It is further submitted that this Court has passed a preliminary
Decree on 05.03.1959 based on a memorandum of compromise dated
02.12.1958 in which Applicants grandfather Mir Asad Ali Khan, was
also shown as Defendant No.33 who died on 02.06.1974.
One Sri
Nawab Mir Turab Ali Khan (Salar Jung-I), Sheja-ul-Dowla, Muktharul-Mulk-I,
who
had
wives
namely,
1.
Azizunnisa
Begum,
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
5. Ameerunnisa Khanam 3. Vazerunnisa Khanam 4. Hussani
Khanam. The 4th wife of Salar Jung-1, Hussaini Khanam, had one
daughter by namely Dilawar Begum, and the said Dilawar Begum had
two daughters by names Deedarunnisa Begum and Noorunnisa
Begum. The said Smt.Noorunnisa Begum, had two sons and one
daughter, and the name of elder son is Mir Asad Ali Khan, and second
son namely Turab Ali Khan and daughter namely Sultan Bakth
Begum. The first son of Noorunnisa Begum, Mir Asad Ali Khan was
shown as Defendant No.33 in C.S.No.13/1958, Mir Asad Ali Khan has
filed claim before Atiyat Court in 2/56, and he was allotted Sub file
No.11, in the Inam Enquiry Mir Asad Ali Khan, claiming through his
late grandmother Dilawar Begum, D/o. Salar Jung-1 and Atiyat
Court, directed him to obtain succession from City Civil Court, vide its
Judgement
passed
on
26.06.1968.
Thereafter,
some
of
the
unsuccessful claim Petitioners filed an Appeal before Board V member
Commissioner of Board of Revenue Government of Andhra Pradesh,
and all Appeals were dismissed upholding the Judgement of Atiyat
Court dated 31.12.1976 and partly allowing some of the claim, during
the pendency of Appeal proceedings, Mir Asad Ali Khan died
02.06.1974. The Legal Heirs of sons and daughters of late Mir Asad
Ali Khan, including the Legal Heirs of the deceased daughters, have
filed O.S. No.14754 of 2003 against the Government of Andhra
Pradesh and Jagir Administrator. Wherein, the Jagir Administrator is
shown as Defendant No.5.
This Court came to a conclusion that
Plaintiffs in the Suit in O.S. No.14754 of 2003, now the implead
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
Petitioners before this Court are declared as legal Heirs and
successors of Dilawar Begum who is the Paternal aunt of Nawab Mir
Yousuf Ali Khan (Salar Jung-III), thus declared them to be Lawful
successors. The Memorandum of compromise was recorded in C.S.
No.13 of 1958 and as per Clause 11 and 13, one Smt. Munirunnisa
begum filed an implead Petition on Order XXII Rule 10, and under
Order I Rule 10 read with 151 CPC, after obtaining succession from
the Family Court in O.S.No.168 of 1998, on the File of Family Court
Hyderabad, and she was impleaded as Legal Heir vide her application
No.562 of 2014 in C.S.No.13 of 1958, where the High Court had
passed an order of Impleadment as Defendant. Similarly, the
Petitioners have got established their relationship with Salar Jung-III
from his Paternal side as such, relying on above Clauses mentioned in
the memorandum of compromise, all the implead petitioners may be
brought on records as legal Heirs of Defendant 33 in C.S. No.13 of
1958, on the File of this Court. Plaintiffs No.3, 5, 6, 7 and 25 refers in
O.S. No.14754 of 2003 and also defendant No.18 in O.S. No.14754 of
2003 and the petitioners prayed this Court to implead them as
respondents/ defendants in C.S. No.13 of 1958.
6.
For better appreciation, proceedings conducted by this Court
from time to time are extracted hereunder:
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
“02.02.2024
Mr. T.K.Sridhar, learned counsel for the
petitioners.
After arguing the matter to some extent,
learned counsel for the petitioners prays for
adjournment.
List in the next week.
13.09.2024
Application No.2 of 2024
Mr. T.K.Sridhar, learned counsel for the
applicants.
List along with Application No.1 of 2024
in C.S. No.13 of 1958.
12.12.2025
Mr. T.K. Sridhar, learned counsel for the
applicants.
Mr. Mohammed Imran Khan, learned
Additional Advocate General appears for the
respondent State.
At
request of
the learned Additional
Advocate General, list the matter after one
week for filing counter affidavit.
19.12.2025
Mr.
T.K.Sridhar,
learned
counsel
appearing for the applicants seeks further time
to file succession certificate.
Mr. Mohammed Imran Khan, learned
Additional Advocate General appears for the
respondent-State.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
As prayed by learned counsel for the
applicants, list this matter on 09.01.2026.
It
is
made
clear
that
no
further
adjournment shall be granted.”
7.
Inspite of granting several opportunities, petitioners have
neither filed any Succession Certificate nor any proceedings sourcing
their legal heir status.
8.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material made available on the record.
9.
This Application has been filed by the petitioners seeking
permission
to
come
C.S. No.13 of 1958.
on
record
as
respondents/defendants
in
It is to be noted here that this Court by a
common order dated 24.01.2023 in Applications No.299 and 1235 of
2012, appointed Commissioners to look into the extent of property
involved in the suit and apportionment thereof amongst the parties to
the suit in terms of the preliminary decree drawn up on the basis of
compromise and file report.
Accordingly, the Commissioners have
submitted a detailed report on 13.10.2025 and the report was taken
on record. Thereafter, this Court by order dated 16.10.2025 granted
permission to the contesting parties to obtain report dated 13.10.2025
from the Registry and may file objections, if any, on or before
27.11.2025.
Upon request, the Registry was directed to furnish a
copy of the Commissioners report dated 13.10.2025 to the contesting
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
parties and the matter was directed to be listed on 27.11.2025 under
the caption ‘Final Hearing’.
10.
On perusal of the record, present Application is filed on
30.10.2023.
COMMISSIONER’S REPORT
11.
For better appreciation, it is necessary to extract the relevant
portion of the report dated 13.10.2025, which is extracted as under:
“N.
FINDINGS
14.
Now that the movable and immovable
properties belonging to Nawab Salar Jung III
appears to have been dealt with under the so
called Compromise Preliminary Decree dated
05-03-1959
under
the
directions
and
permissions of this Hon’ble Court from the date
of the Conditional Compromise Preliminary
Decree dated 05-03-1959 till the order in
I.A. No.417 of 1961 dated 09-02-1962, AND
this Hon'be Court by order dated 09-02-1962
ordered passing of a final decree as prayed for
under
certain
terms
mentioned
therein.
The office has to be directed to draw a final
decree in terms of the order in I.A. No.417
of 1961 dated O9-02-1962, if it remains
unchallenged.
14.1
The
record
made
available
to
us
indicates that Application No.2 of 2023 is
filed praying the Court to declare the
preliminary decree is passed under the garb
of fake and false theory that Salar Jung
Died issueless and he was unmarried and
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
that the alleged compromise preliminary
decree is not executable.
14.2
The
record
made
available
to
us
indicates that Applications No.1 of 2023, 1 and
2 of 2024 and 1 of 2025 are filed claiming
share in the property of Nawab Salar Jung III
independently and hence they wanted their
impleadment in CS 13 of 1958.
14.3
The applicants in Application No.1 of
2024 claim share in the property left behind by
Nawab Salar Jung IlI, contending that the
Salar Jung Estate has got mixed properties of
the grand mother of the applicants therein
("Saheb Begum" D/o Mir Alam Bahadur and
grand father Ali Zaman Khan, Munir-ul-Mulk)
and also the properties of one Habeebunnisa
Begum D/o Mir Alam Bahadur and properties
of Mir-i-Duran S/o Mir Alam Bahadur.
14.4
In view of para 11 of conditional
compromise preliminary decree and in view of
peculiar circumstances under which the said
conditional
compromise
preliminary
decree
came to be passed and in view of the fact that
order in I.A. No.417 of 1961 dated 09-02-1962
is passed directing the registry to draw final
decree,
the
point
that
arises
for
the
consideration of this Hon'ble Court is, whether
the applicants in Applications No.1 and 2 of
2023, 1 and 2 of 2024 and 1 of 2025 can
maintain such application in CS No. 13 of
1958.
14.5
In
our
humble
opinion
enquiry
in
Applications No.1 and 2 of 2023, 1 and 2 of
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
2024 and 1 of 2025 amounts to reopening the
main suit in CS No.13 of 1958 which may
amount
to
discarding
the
Compromise
Preliminary Decree dated 05-3-1959. (Virtually
undoing all the labor of the then Receiver-cum
Commissioner)”.
EFFECT OF PRELIMINARY DECREE:
12.
In
the
Commissioners
Commissioner’s
report
questioned
maintainability
the
dated
13.10.2025,
of
the
the
present
Application i.e. Application No.2 of 2024 in C.S. No.13 of 1958 and
further opinied that the said Application amount to discarding the
Compromise Preliminary Decree dated 05.03.1959.
Though this
Court granted permission to the contesting parties to file objections,
if any, to the said report, the Applicants have not filed any objections
to the said report.
13.
It is to be noted that compromise has already been recorded and
preliminary decree was passed to that extent on 05.03.1959.
The
Applicants, at this point of time by filing the present Application and if
considered would virtually amounts to reopening of the compromised
preliminary decree dated 05.03.1959 in O.S. No.13 of 1958 and the
Commissioners have rightly observed in report that, it amounts to
discarding the compromise preliminary decree dated 05.03.1959.
14.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Bimal Kumar and
another Vs. Shakuntala Debi and others1 held that compromise has
already been recorded and preliminary decree was passed to that
extent on 05.03.1959, the Applicants, at this point of time, by filing
the present Application, would virtually amounts to reopening of the
main suit in O.S. No.13 of 1958 and the Commissioner has right
observed in the report that it amounts to discarding the compromise
preliminary decree dated 05.03.1959. Further, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in supra held that the term “compromise” essentially means
settlement of differences by mutual consent.
In such process, the
adversarial claims come to rest. The relevant paras No.24 to 28 are
extracted for reference:
“24. In Renu Devi v. Mahendra Singh [(2003) 10
SCC 200 : AIR 2003 SC 1608] the effect of a
compromise decree and allotment of shares in
pursuance of the said decree was dealt with. The
two-Judge
Bench
Sahu v. Ajodhya
referred
Sahu [AIR
to Raghubir
Pat
482]
and Muzaffar Husain [AIR 1933 Oudh 562] and
opined that the law had been correctly stated in
the said authorities.
25. In
the
said
case,
after
referring
to Civil
Procedure Code by Mulla, this Court in Renu Devi
case [(2003) 10 SCC 200 : AIR 2003 SC 1608] ,
while
drawing
a
distinction
between
the
preliminary and the final decree, has stated that a
preliminary decree declares the rights or shares of
the parties to the partition. Once the shares have
(2012) 3 Supreme Court Cases 548
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
been declared and a further inquiry still remains
to be done for actually partitioning the property
and placing the parties in separate possession of
the divided property, then such inquiry shall be
held and pursuant to the result of further inquiry,
a final decree shall be passed. A preliminary
decree is one which declares the rights and
liabilities of the parties leaving the actual result to
be worked out in further proceedings. Then, as a
result of the further inquiries conducted pursuant
to the preliminary decree, the rights of the parties
are finally determined and a decree is passed in
accordance with such determination, which is the
final decree. Thus, fundamentally, the distinction
between preliminary and final decree is that: a
preliminary decree merely declares the rights and
shares of the parties and leaves room for some
further inquiry to be held and conducted pursuant
to the directions made in the preliminary decree
which inquiry having been conducted and the
rights of the parties finally determined a decree
incorporating such determination needs to be
drawn up which is the final decree.
26. Applying the principles laid down in the
aforesaid authorities, it is graphically clear that in
the case at hand, the parties entered into a
compromise and clearly admitted that they were in
separate
and
exclusive
possession
of
the
properties and the same had already been allotted
to them. It was also admitted that they were in
possession
of
therefore,
no
their
final
respective
decree
or
shares
and,
execution
was
required to be filed. It is demonstrable that the
compromise application does not contain any
clause regarding the future course of action. The
parties were absolutely conscious and rightly so,
that their rights had been fructified and their
possession had been exclusively determined. They
were well aware that the decree was final in
nature as their shares were allotted and nothing
remained to be done by metes and bounds. Their
rights had attained finality and no further enquiry
from any spectrum was required to be carried out.
The whole thing had been embodied in the decree
passed on the foundation of compromise.
27. It is to be borne in mind that the term
“compromise” essentially means settlement of
differences by mutual consent. In such process,
the adversarial claims come to rest. The cavil
between the parties is given a decent burial. A
compromise which is arrived at by the parties puts
an end to the litigative battle. Sometimes the
parties feel that it is an unfortunate bitter struggle
and allow good sense to prevail to resolve the
dispute. In certain cases, by intervention of wellwishers, the conciliatory process commences and
eventually, by consensus and concurrence, rights
get concretised. A reciprocal settlement with a
clear mind is regarded as noble. It signifies
magnificent and majestic facets of the human
mind. The exalted state of affairs brings in
quintessence of sublime solemnity and social
stability.
28. In the present case, as the factual matrix
would reveal, a decree came to be passed on the
bedrock of a compromise in entirety from all
angles leaving nothing to be done in the future.
The curtains were really drawn and the court gave
the stamp of approval to the same. Thus, the
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
inescapable conclusion is that the compromise
decree dated 3-4-1964 was a final decree.”
ON AUTHORISATION:
15.
That apart, the Applicant No.4 has filed the present Application
and in support of this Application filed affidavit stating that
“I am authorised to swear to this affidavit on behalf of other petitioners
However, he has not filed any
as well under autorisation.”
authorisation to that extent seeking permission of this Court to act on
behalf of other petitioners.
Therefore, this Application is not in
accordance with the Rule 32 and 33 of the Civil Rules of Practice and
Circular Orders in A.P. / Telangana.
For reference, Rules are
extracted hereunder:
“32. Party appearing by Agent:(1) When a party appears by any agent, other
than an advocate, the agent shall, before
making
of
or
doing
any
appearance,
application, or act, in or to the court, file in
court
the
power
of
attorney,
or
written
authority, thereunto authorizing him or a
properly authenticated copy there of together
with an affidavit that the said authority shall
subsisting, or, in the case of an agent carrying
on a trade or business on behalf of a party,
without a written authority, an affidavit stating
the residence of his principal, the trade or
business carried on by the agent on his behalf
and the connection of the same with the
subject-matter of the suit, and that no other
agent is expressly authorised to make or do
such appearance, application, or act.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
(2) The Judge may thereupon record in writing
that the agent is permitted to appear and act
on behalf of the party; and unless and until the
said permission is granted, no appearance,
application, or act, of the agent shall be
recognized by the Court.
33. Signing or verification by Agent:If any proceeding, which under any provision of
law or these rules, is required to be signed or
verified by a party, is signed or verified by any
person on his behalf, a written authority in this
behalf signed by the party shall be filed in
court, together with an affidavit verifying the
signature of the party, and stating the reason
of his inability to sign or verify the proceeding,
and stating the means of knowledge or the
facts set out in the proceeding of the person
signing or verifying the same and that such
person is a recognized agent of the party as
defined by order III Rule 2 of the Code and is
duly authorized and competent so to do.”
16.
Inspite of opportunity was given to file objections, if any, to the
Commissioner’s report dated 13.10.2025, no objections have been
filed on behalf of Applicants.
The Applicants could not properly
explain their legal heirship status and their inclusion/relevancy in the
present suit.
As rightly observed by the Commissioners in their
Report dated 13.10.2025 that enquiring in Application No.2 of 2024 in
C.S. No.13 of 1958 which amount to discarding the compromise
preliminary decree dated 05.03.1959.
17.
HC, J & NVSK, J
Appln. No.2 of 2024
in
C.S. No.13 of 1958
In view of the foregoing observations and after due consideration
of the report of the Commissioners dated 13.10.2025, this Court is of
the considered view that the present Application suffers with several
material
defects
and
discrepancies
and
is
devoid
of
merits.
Accordingly, the prayer sought for by the Petitioners in the present
Application seeking permission to come on record as respondents/
defendants in C.S. No.13 of 1958 cannot be entertained at this belated
stage.
Accordingly, Application No.2 of 2024 in C.S. No.13 of 1958 is
dismissed.
_____________________________
APARESH KUMAR SINGH, CJ
_____________________________
N.V. SHRAVAN KUMAR, J
Date: 20-02-2026
LSK
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review