The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. In this case, the complaint was not given by a pubtic servant. In view of the same, the charge under Section lgg of IpC is liable to be quashed as against the petitioner herein.
10. Even as regards the charge Lrnder Section 420 tpc, this Court finds that there is norhing on record ro show that the petitioner had \ I Crl P.No.5562 of202i intended to sel thc said injections at a higher price and there is no identiflcation of any of the parties who intended to buy the said products. As therc is also no evidence that the petitioner has intended to enter into any Ergreement with any party for sale of the product, this Court is satisfieci that no case is made out for attracting the provisions of Section 420 of I ?C to the case on hand. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of N. Raghavender Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, CBI (4 supra) has clearll,held that the prosecution has to not only prove that the accused has chr:ated someone but also that by doing he has dishonestll, rnduced the person who is cheated t,) deliver property. In this case. thc sai<! ingredients arc not present. In ;iew of the same, the cirarge undei Seclion 420 of IPC is also quashed as agirinst the petitioner h erein I As there is no prohibitory order issued by anv of the authorities of the State ol Unior Governrnents prohibiting possessing of Remdesivir injections at the rclevant point of time, the charge rrnder Section 5lB of thc Disaster Man;rgement Act, 20C5 is not aftrac:ed and the same is quashetl as against the petitioner herein. \ t Crl.P.No.5562 of2023
12. The Criminal Petition is accordingly allowed and the charge sheet in C.C.No.3037 of 2022 on the file of lV Additional Metropolitan Magistrate-cum-IV Additional Junior Civit Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar is quashed as against the petitioner herein/Accused No.3.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
IVONDAY. THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION NO 't0513 0F 2026
Betwee n:
SyedAsladGhouri,S/oLateHashamGhouri.Age32'OccBusinessR/o'18-8
646lAlgot1, Near Bilal tt/lasjid, Edi Bazar, Hyderabad
..
Petitione r/Acc used No.1
AND
'l.TheStateofTelangana,Rep.byrtsPublicProsecutor'HighCourtat
Hyderabad.
2. K. Nagaraju, Sub lnspector of polrce. P.S Chandryangutta Hyderabad
..Respondents
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the
Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petitron, the High court may be pleased to
quash the proceedings against the Petrtio ners/Accused No.1.rn c.c.No. 944812025
of P S Chandryangutta, Hyderabad pending on the frle of the chref Judicial
I\4agistrate Court, Hyderabad in the interest of justice'
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the
lr/emorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition. the Hrgh Court may be pleased to
of the
stay all further proceedings including the appearanceHyderabad,
pefitioners/Accu sed No 1 in C.C.No. 9448t2025 of P S. Chandryangutta.
pending on the file of Chief Judicral N,4agrstrate Couft. Hyderabad
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the lVemorandum of Grounds
of criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Sri Nanda Kishore Yadav,
Advocate for the Petitioner and Sri Jrthender Rao Veeramalla. learned Additional
Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondents
The Court made the following: ORDER
ruqLC_AUBT EQ IT THE S TATE OF TELANGAN AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOTIRABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENTVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETIT ION No. 1 O513 of2026
Date:2O,O7,2o26
Be tu len
Sr erl ,\s jacl (ihorrrr
A]{D
Petitio ner/ accused No.1
The StaLe ol Tciainga:ral and another
Respondents
:ORDER:
This crrimr'r,i I)eiirio, has becn iired b1. the pe.titio ne r./ accu sed
No. I scokinq ro qlla:,h :he proceedings rn C.C.No.!r4:lg
o1.2025 on
the tllrr .l rht chi.r',rurLici.r \r.gistrare, H1'clerabad, for rhe ofrences
undt,r- Secriorrs 2,3o :Lncl 3 LE(+l read u.ith 3(o) of the JINS.
).
Ilcarcl ,\1r. \:rrtrl Kishore yadav, le,arned counsel [or thc
petitro,r:r. a.cl \{r. ,Jith.nci:rr R.o Veeramalia, lear.ned Additional
Pr-LblLc P:-osecutor lor t:1.c, resDr)ncients
3.
l.eirrnecl Co,_.rrst,l l',rr the pctrtioner submitted that rhe issue
raisecl :rr this c.trLi.. Le,itir.
is scluareh co\.erec b' tht, ,rcle r
nassi d L,r L\is ('Lrriri r1 C I 1, \o 5552 ol 2'123. darcd 2zl. t 1.2023
ir.rd .,1sLr pJrLccrl a i.pr ,1 :hc said order on re.cord. The petitioner is
:rls. r..til lecl lbr. I hL, r I,r. siint(. rclicf. Ilence. :he conti.,Lliition
oi the
proceedings against the petitioner is a
clear abuse of the process of
law
The said submission has not disputed by learned
Additional
Public Prosecutor
J
Taking into consideration the orders passed by
Crl. P. No.5562
this Court in
of 2023. dated 24. 11.2023, and in vievv of the
submission made b1, the both counsel, this court finds
case to exercise jurisdiction under Section S2g
it to be a fit
of BNSS to quash the
proceedings against the petitioner herein.
6.
Accordingly, rhe Criminal petition is allou,ed and
proceedings in C.C.No.9.t4g of 2025 on rhe file of
the
the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Hyderabad, againsr the pe titioner/ accused No.
1,
are
here bv quashed.
Mrscellaneous applications, pending rf any, shall stand closed
SD/- M.OSMAN ALI BAIG
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
S CTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Chief Judrcial N4agrstrate Courl Hyderabad (With records if any)
2. The Station House Officer Chandrayanagutta police Statron, Hyder6ad.
3. Two ccs to the Public Prosecutor. High courl of rerangana at Hyderabad
Iour]
4 One CC to Sn Nanda Krshore yadav. Advocate [OpUC]
5 Two CD Copies
GNK/KA
(v
HIGH COURT
DATED: 20107 t2026
ORDER
CRLP. No.1 051 3 of 2026
1 vtE
S TAaF
Y
P
o
o
"rUt
t Or:S.,\r31\
ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION
Q"
\cr
, ,\.
{'-\\l "'
I
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MADHAVI DEVI
CRIMINAL PETITION NO.5562 oF 2023
ORD ER
This petition is filed seeking quashing of the charge sheer in
C.C.No.3037 of 2022 on the fite of the IV Additional Metropolitan
Magistrate-cum-IV Additional Junior Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy District
at L.B.Nagar as against the petitioner/Accused No.3.
2.
Brief facts are that respondent No.2 had complained that on
12.05.2@.1 at about I 8. I 5 hours, the complainant along with patrol
mobile-ll staff was perlorming patrolling duty at Kothapet area and
during the said process, they received credible information that two
persons were setling Remdesivir Covid-19 emergency
injections/medicines lor higher price, i.e., each injection for an amount
of Rs.20,000/- ro the needy patients at Fruit Market, Kothapet,
Chaitanyapuri and the same was informed to their superior officers and
that the complainant secured two mediators and along with his staff
rushed to the spot and caught accused 2 and 3 red-handedly with five
Remdesivir injections and on enquiry, the accused revealed their names
I
Crl.l'.N0.5 562 of 202-l
and on the instruct;ons of accused I and 4. they were selling the above
injections for an emount ol Rs,20,000/- each to needy customers.
Pursuant to the collfession made by the accused, five Remdesivir and
three mobile phone;, i.e., three Remdesivir injections, I-Phone and One
Plus phone lrom accused No.2 and two Remdesivir Lrjections and one
Vivo mobile phone from accused No.3 were seized. Thereafter, a crime
under Sections 420. 188 read with Section 34 of tPC and Section 5IB of
the Disaster Managt:ment Act, 2005 rvas registered. It is submitted that
thereafter, the official respondent filed charge shetr on 29.03.2022
reaffirming the abcr.e position. Seeking quashing ,tf the same, the
present Criminal Pet.tion is filed by Accused No.3
3.
Leamed coursel for the petitioner submitted that the
petitioner/Accused No.l was rvorking as an Accountant. in a
Pharmaceutical Conpanv and was found holding two vials of
Remdesivir which act u,as nor prohibited by any of the authorities and
the complaint rvas also not given by a public servan! under Section
195(
I) of Cr.P.C. arrd thcrefore, the allegation of lhe offence under
Secrion 188 ol'IPC is not susrainable. In support of the said contention,
Crl.P.No.5562 of2023
he placed reliance upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Pupala
Srinadh Srinath Vs. The State of Telangana and anotherl and also
the case of the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court in the case of
Jebvanandham and others Vs. State rep. by Inspector of Police,
Velayuthampalayam Police Station, Karur District2.
4.
Further, in respect of applicability of Section 5lB of the Disaster
Management Act, 2005 to this case, the leamed counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the said provisions are not attracted to the case
on hand as there were no prohibitory orders issued by any of the
authorities, leave alone the State or the Central Governments. ln support
of this contention, he placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Chhattisgarh High Court in the case of Dr. Santosh Kumar Patel Vs.
State of Chhattisgarh a nd others3.
5.
As regards the provisions of Section 420 of IPC, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submined that the respondents have not
brought on record any evidence to show that the petitioner intended to
t
I
Criminal Petition Nos. I I f 7 t. I I 3 7,1 and I 131 1 ot 2022 dt.2'1.12.2022
Crl,O,P.No- 1356 of20 l8 and barch dt.2o.O9.2o lE
' w.p.1cr.;No.I2 of 2020 dr.14. t2.2020
(
lrl.P.No.5562 of 2021
sell thc said iniections or that the petitioner had entered into any
agreement with any party at the price mentioned in thc FIR. It is
submitted that merely because the petitioner was possessing two vials of
Remdesivir. it at al[, it can only be presumed that the petitioner intended
to sell the injections and having a mere intention or an attempt to sell,
itself does not attract an olfence under Section 42t) of IPC. He placed
reliance upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of
N. Raghavender Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, CBl4 in support otthis
contention.
6.
The learned counsel lor the petitioner/Accusecl No.3 therefore
sought quashing of the charge sheet against the peti:ioner.
7.
Sri S.Ganesh. learned Assistant Public Prcsecutor vehemently
opposed the saio contentions and submitted that the petitioner was
caught red-handetl with the vials of Remdesivir and he intended to sell
them at a higher lrice to make money and therefr,re, the provisions of
Section 420 oi- IPC ',vere clearly attracted to the crtse on hand. He also
'lo: t scc ont ine SC t- ll
Crl.P.No.5562 of202J
supported the registration ofcase under Section lgg read with Section
34 of IPC.
8.
Having regard to the rival contentions and the materiar on record,
this court finds that rhe issue of mainrainability of the charge sheet
under Section 188 of IPC is clearly covered by the judgment of this
Court in the case of Pupala Srinadh Srinath Vs. The State of
Telangana and another (l supra) and also the case of the Madras High
Court of Madurai Bench in the case ofJeevanandham and others Vs.
State rep. by Inspector of Police, Velayuthampalayam police
Station, Karur District (2 supra), wherein it was held as follows:
"The ofience under Section lE8 of tpC can only be prosecuted
on the basis of a comploint which is Jiled by a public servant into the
Court. Section 195 of Cr.P.C. prohibits taking cognizance by a Courr
excepl on lhe complaint in writing by a public servanl concerned.',
9.
In this case, the complaint was not given by a pubtic servant. In
view of the same, the charge under Section lgg of IpC is liable to be
quashed as against the petitioner herein.
10. Even as regards the charge Lrnder Section 420 tpc, this Court
finds that there is norhing on record ro show that the petitioner had
\
I
Crl P.No.5562 of202i
intended to sel thc said injections at a higher price and there is no
identiflcation of any of the parties who intended to buy the said
products. As therc is also no evidence that the petitioner has intended to
enter into any Ergreement with any party for sale of the product, this
Court is satisfieci that no case is made out for attracting the provisions of
Section 420 of I ?C to the case on hand. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in
the case of N. Raghavender Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh, CBI (4
supra) has clearll,held that the prosecution has to not only prove that the
accused has chr:ated someone but also that by doing
SO
he has
dishonestll, rnduced the person who is cheated t,) deliver property. In
this case. thc sai<! ingredients arc not present. In ;iew of the same, the
cirarge undei Seclion 420 of IPC is also quashed as agirinst the petitioner
h erein
I
I.
As there is no prohibitory order issued by anv of the authorities of
the State ol Unior Governrnents prohibiting possessing of Remdesivir
injections at the rclevant point of time, the charge rrnder Section 5lB of
thc Disaster Man;rgement Act, 20C5 is not aftrac:ed and the same is
quashetl as against the petitioner herein.
\
t
Crl.P.No.5562 of2023
12. The Criminal Petition is accordingly allowed and the charge sheet
in C.C.No.3037 of 2022 on the file of lV Additional Metropolitan
Magistrate-cum-IV Additional Junior Civit Judge, Ranga Reddy District
at L.B.Nagar is quashed as against the petitioner herein/Accused No.3.
13. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, in this Criminal Petition
shall stand closed
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review