Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3518 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
SRI
JUSTICE
VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
THE HONOURABLE
WRIT APPEAL NO: 1002 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal Preferred Against the
Order dated 28062026 in WP No 18062 oI 2026 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
Syed Abdul Khalid, S/o. Syed Abdul Rasheed Aged about 60 years Occ
Business F/o. H.No.22-7-3801N2 [\/irAlam Mandi Hyderabad Telangana State.
...APPELLANT/PETITIONER
AND
'l
. The State of Telangana, Rep.by Principal Secretary Revenue Department
Secretariat Buildings Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Hyderabad District at Lakdikapool Hyderabad.
3. The Revenue Divisional Officer, Secunderabad Division SP Road
Secunderabad.
4. The Tahsildar, Shaikpet lVlanda Banjara Hills Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition ullder Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed ln support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the operation and effect of the order dated 18.06.2026 passed in W.P.No.'18062 of
2019 pending disposal of the accompanying Writ Appeal.
I, A . NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section '1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant an
interim injunction rest'aining the respondents their officials agents subordinates or
anybody claiming through or under them from in any manner interfering with my
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the property admeasuring 4865 square yards
in Sy.No.129/56 (Newtcorresponding to Sy No.'1 64 (Old)situated at T.S.No.'19 Ward
No.'1 0 BIock-D Road l.lo.1 4 Banjara Hills Hyderabad
Counsel for the Apperllant: Sri. G V Subrahmanyam G Madhav Rao
Counsel for the Resprondents: Sri. Muralidhar Reddy Katram, GP For Revenue
The Court made the lbllowing: ORDER
4t
IN TIIE TIIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTI CE SRI APARES H KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI
A REDDY
WRIT APPEAL No.1OO2 of2026
(CNR No.HBHCo tO61Oo72O26l
Da tedt, L5.O9.2O26
BETWEEN:
.. Appellant
Syed Abdul Khali
AND
The State of Telangana, represented by its
Principal Secretary, Revenue Department,
Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad and others
...Respondents
JUDGMENT:
This lwit appeal, preferred under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, is directed against the order dated 18'O6'2026 passed by
the learned Single Judge in W.P.No 18062 of 2Ol, whereby the writ
pelition came to be dismissed with costs of Rs' 10,000/- (Rupees
ten thousand. only) payable to the High Court Legal Services
Committee, High Court for the State of Telangana, Hyderabad'
2.
Heard Sri G.V. Subrahmanyam, learned counsel for the
appellant, and Sri Muralidhar Reddy Katram, learned Government
Pleader for Revenue appearing for the respondents' Perused the
material placed on record.
BRIEF FACTS
3.
W.P.No. .8O62 of 2Ol9 was liled by the appellant seeking a
writ of mande.mus declaring the action of respondent No.4, the
Tahsildar, Shaikpet Mandal, in interfering with his peaceful
possession an<l enjoyment of land admeasuring 4,865 square yards
in Sy.No.129/li6 (New), corresponding to Sy.No.164 (Olcl), situated
at T.S.No.19, Ward No.1O, Block-D, Road No.14, Banjara Hills,
Hyderabad, as illegal, arbitrary and in violatron of Article 300-A of
the Constitution of India, and for a consequential direction to the
respondents not to interfere with his possession over the said
property.
4.
The case set out in the affidavit fi1ed in support of the writ
petition is thal one Riyaz Ahmed, son of Mir Azmathulla, was the
original pattad,r,r of land admeasuring Ac.8-12 guntas in Sy.No.l64
told), corresponding to Sy.No.129/56 (New), Banjara Hil1s,
Hyderabad; thrlt T.S.L.R. No. 19 patta in respect of the said land
was granted tc him by the Awal Taluqdar (Collector), Taluq West
District, Atraf llaldah Sarf-e-Khas Mubarak, Hyderabad Deccan, in
File No.112l18 of 134O Fas1i, on deposit of Rs.1,240/- in Osmania
currency into :he Government treasury; and that his name was
recorded as pal.tadar in the revenue records, including the Sethwar
and the Khasra Pahani for the vear 1954-55.
J
5.ItisfurtheraverredthatRaniJayantiRani,wifeoflateRaja
Dharam Karan, purchased the said land from the said
pattadar'
and that she in turn conveyed an extent of 4,865 square
yards out
of Ac.8-12 guntas in Sy.No.129/56, situated at Road No'14'
Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, to the appellant under Document
No.S1O1 dated 15.12.1969 for a consideration of Rs'24'325/-;
that
ever since the date of purchase the appellant has been
in
continuouspossessionandenjoymentoftheplopertyandhas
been paying property tax reguiarly every year'
6.
It is further averred that owing to interference by certain
private persons as well as by some Government officials in respect
of the valuable property, the appellant submitted an application
dated19.lo.l978torespondentNo'4seekingaNoobjection
Certificate; that since no objection was received either from
private
persons or from any Government department' the Tahsildar
issued
Letter No.A1/687611978 dated O9' 11 1978 stating that the
land in
Sy.No.129/56 of Banjara Hills, Shaikpet village' is
patta land' that
no Government land is included therein, and that the Government
has no objection to the appeilant alienating' mortgaging or
donating the extent of 4,865 square yards; and that thereafter
a
panchanama was conducted by the revenue authoiities in which
the property was demarcated and his possession conhrmed' no
l
objection having been received from the private or the Ciovernment
side.
7.
According to the appellant, while so, on 1,6.O8.2O79,
respondent No.4 visited the land and kept a board thereon
proclaiming that it belongs to the Government; that although he
approached rt:spondent No.4 and informed the authorities of his
ownership an<l possession, the board was not removed, and he was
therefore conslrained to file the u.rit petition.
8.
By order dated 24.O9.2OI9 in I.A.No.1 of 2019 in
W.P.No. 18062 of 2019, the learned Single Judge gran:ed interim
protection, observing that since the claim o[ the petitioner to the
subject prope:ty was backed up by registered sale deeds which
were not in di:;pute pima facie, the respondents shall not interfere
with his peaceful possession and enjoyment of the subjer:t property
without following due process of law. Alleging willful disobedience
of the said inr.erim order, lhe appellant filed C.C.No.680 of 2O25,
contending th rt the respondents lorcibly entered into l.he subj ect
property ancl erected a notice board proclaiming it to be
Government leLnd and warning that any person violating the same
would be prosecuted, and th:rt though a Iegal notice dated
13.12.2024 ca lling upon them to comply with the interim order
)
was duly received, the respondents neither responded to
it nor
complied with ttre order of the Court'
g.
Respondent No.4 fi1ed a counter affrdavit resisting the claim'
both in the writ petition and in the contempt case' The stand taken
therein is that in reply to the legal notice, respondent No'4 issued
Endorsement No.D2/WP- 18062I2OI9 daled 18 12'2024 stating
that under the guise of certain fabricated documents pertaining to
Sy.No. 129/56 the appellant was illega1ly trying to step
into
Government land in Sy.No.403 part, correlated to T'S No'17' Ward
No.10 and Block-D of Shaikpet village, and tJlat there is no
description of T.S.No.19, Block-D, Ward No' 10 in any one of the
documents relied upon by him. It is stated that the land in
Sy.No.403/P admeasuring 9,616 square metres of Shaikpet village'
correlated to T.S.No.17, Block-D, Ward No' 1O, is recorded in the
Town Survey Land Records as "Sarkari Kancha Tattikhana Jubilee Hi1ls" in Column No.10 and classified as "G" in Column
No.2O; that the said land has always remained in the custody and
possession of the Government with a Government signboard
erected thereon; and that it stands registered in the Land Bank
vide LB.No.7280O5 and has also been proposed for open auction'
10. It is further stated in the counter affidavit t]lat as per the
revenue records land admeasuring Ac.8-12 guntas 1n
Sy.No.129/56 stood recorded in the name of Syed Rivaz Ahmed,
whose name continued in the pahani records tilt the year 1980,
and that taking advantage of such entnes the appellant created a
fabricated patla certiflcate and an unregistered sale deed in Urdu
script purporl.ing to show that the Taluqdar, Taluq West, District
Atraf Baldah Sarf-e-Khas Mubarak, Hyderabad, had granted a
patta in favour of Syed Riyaz Ahmed and that the said pattadar
had conveye 1 lhe property to the appellant's vendor on
77.06.7945, rvho in turn sold the same to the appellant on
15.12.7969.I1 is stated that the said documents are unregistered,
antedated ancl contain bogus signatures, and were subsequently
validated undt:r Section 42 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1g99 solely to
grab valuable Government land; that the property tax receipts
relied upon a1'e not genuine and, in any event, mere payment of
property tax does not confer titlc to immovable propertv; and that
the letter sald to have been issued in
proceedings
No.Al/6876/i978 dated 09.11.1978 is a forged and fabricated
document, there being no practice in the office of respondent No.4
of issuing such letters, and respondent No.4 being in any case not
competent to ir;sue a 'No Objection Certihcate'.
11. Respondent No.4 also placed on record the earlier round of
litigation in respect of the same survev number. It is slated that
,7
M/s. Bharyanaga.r Studio Private Limited, represented by Sri B.
Ranga Swamy, claimed rights over the subject Government land on
the strength of registered sale deeds pertaining to Sy.No.129/56
and frled O.S.No.6O9 of 1981 against the then State of Andhra
Pradesh and the District Collector, Hyderabad, seeking perpetual
injunction in respect of land admeasuring Ac.2- 10 guntas forming
part of Sy.No.129/56; that the suit was dismissed on 24.09.7982;
that C.C.C.A.No.44 of 1983 was allowed by judgment dated
26.06.1995 setting aside the decree and remanding the matter for
fresh disposal; that on remand the trial Court again dismissed the
suit by judgment dated 10.11.1998, holding that the plaintiffs had
failed to establish the identity and correctness of the suit schedule
property and their title, that the suit schedule land was proved to
be Government land lying in between Sy.Nos.129/73 ar,d 129/56,
and that it was not part and parcel of Sy.No.129/56; that
C.C.C.A.No.22 of 1999 preferred against the said judgment was
allowed by this Court on O7.O4.2O21; and that the State of
Telangana carried the matter to the Supreme Court in S.L.P. (C)
No.6898 of 2021, which was allowed by judgment dated
17.O7.2022, setting aside the judgment dated 01.04.2021 in
C.C.C.A.No.22 of 1999 and restoring the judgment of the trial
Court in O.S.No.609 of 1981. Respondent No.4 denied any
interference with the land falling in T.S.No.19, Block-D, Ward
No.10, and prayed that the contempt case be closed, while
tendering an rtnconditional apolog, in the event the Court were to
hold that the interim order had been violated.
72. Pursuan t to the order of the learned Single Jr.rdge dated
08.01.2026, a joint survey was conducted on 21.01.2026 by the
Surveyor, Shaikpet Mandal, in the presence of the appellant, his
advocate, the Deputy Inspector of Survey, the revenue held staff
and the police officials, by measuring the land from T.S.No.23 and
T.S.No.22/2 :o T.S.No.19 with the aid of the Record of
Measurement, and the boundary points of T.S.No.19 correlated to
Sy.No.129/56 part were shown to the appeliant and his advocate.
The report of the Surveyor dated 27.O7.2026 records that the land
claimed by the appellant forms part of Sy.No.129 l56 in T.S.No. 19,
that it is patta land and is covered by houses ald road; and that
the lald in T.Si.No.17 forming part of Sy.No.4O3 part, to an extent
of Ac.1-20 gurtas, is Government land on which the Government
signboard ls existing, the said land being vacant, covered with
bushes and fer.ced with blue tin sheets on the southern side.
REASONING OF THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE
13. On a scrutiny of the translated copy of the document relied
upon by the rtppellant, the learned Single Judge helcl that the
number "8 10 1" refers only to the serial number of the non-judicial
stamp paper valued at Rs 50/- dated 15 12 1969'
and that the
documentitselfdisclosesthatitwasimpoundedunderSection42
ofthelndianstampAct,l8ggonpaymentofdefrcitstampdutyof
Rs-3,250/- before the District Registrar and Collector'
Hyderabad'
merely to
It was held that the impounding of a document relates
to
the payment of deficit stamp duty and does not amount
registration, unlike the validation or regularisation
of sale deeds in
respect of agricultural lands under Section 5-A
of the Andhra
Pradesh Rights in Land and Pattadar Pass Books
Act' 1971' and
that the aspect of non-regrstration of the document
therefore
remained unaddressed'
14. Proceeding on the settled position that rights in immovable
property are transferred only through a registered
document under
the provisions of the Tralsfer of Property Act'
Registration Act, 1908, the learned Single Judge
1882 ald the
held that as the
but is merely
document dated 15.L2.Lg6g is not registered
impounded, it does not constitute a registered
of transferring title, and that no title can be
conveyance capable
said to have passed to
the appellant thereunder' It was further held that
had failed to place on record the title document
the appellant
of his vendor' Rani
Jayanti Rani, who claimed to have purchased the
land from Riyaz
Ahmed in the year 1945, and that his assertion
that Document
-10-
No.8101 dated 15.12.1969 is a registered sale deed was contrary to
the contents of the very document relied upon by him and
amounted to a misrepresentation of the nature of the document
before the Co rrt.
15. On the question of interference with possession, the learned
Single Judge held that the sunrey report clearly distrnguishes the
land claimed by the appellant in T.S.No.19 from the Govemment
land in T.Si.No.17, and conclusively establishes that the
Government has not interfered with the property claimed by the
appellant, lht: signboard complained of having been erected in
Government lirnd in T.S.No.17 forming part of Sy.No.403; and that
once the comltetent authorities had identified and demarcated the
respective extt:nts, the very basis of the grievance raised in the writ
petition ceaserl to exist.
16. Referring to the judgments of the Hon,'ble Supreme Court in
K.D. Shanna u. SAIL| and S.P. Chengaluaraya Natdu u. Jogannatlp,
the learned Single Judge held that a party invoking the
extraordinary .jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India is required to be truthful, frank and open and to disclose all
material facts, and that one who comes to Court must come with
clean hands. Ilolding that the appellant had projected a validated
,(2OO8l 12 scc 481
211994) ISCCI
-ll-
document as if it were a registered sale deed and had claimed title
thereunder, which amounted to misrepresentation and to
approaching the Court with unclean hands, and that he had in
addition failed to establish his title and failed to prove any
interference with his possession by the Government, the learned
Single Judge dismissed the writ petition with costs of Rs. 10,000/-
payable to the High Court Legal Services Committee, and
dismissed the contempt case as a sequel.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHAL F OF THE APPELLANT:
),7
.
The grounds urged in the memorandum of the writ appeal,
and the submissions advanced in support of them by the learned
counsel for the appellant, may briefly be noticed:
(a) The appellant derives title under the registered sale deed dated
15.t2.7969, supported by the Khasra Pahani for 1954-55, the
patta certificate and the sale deeds of 1945 and 1969. The entry of
Syed Riyaz Ahmed in the revenue records in respect of Ac.8-12
guntas in Sy.No.129/56 till 1980 was also relied upon. It was
further contended that there is no documentary evidence to
establish that Sy.No.4O3/P, correlated to T S.No. 17, is Government
Iand and that the learned Single Judge erred in identifying the
scheduled property, which, according to the appellant, is situated
in Sy.No.129156 (New), Sy.No.164 (OId), T.S.No.19. The appellant
also relied upln the property tali rcceipts and disputed the finding
that the proceedings dated 09. 1 I . 1 978 were torged.
(b) It was further urged that O.S.No.609 of l9g 1 ancl the joint
survey dated 27.01.2026 relate to different extents and do not
affect the appellant's claim over 4,865 square yards in
Sy-No.129l56 The appellant also disputed the finding that he had
suppressed material facts or approached the Court with unclean
hands and cor.tended that tLre imposirion of costs of Rs. ^0.000/- is
unsustainable
SUBMISSIONS , ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
18. The leareed Government pleader for Revenue, on the other
hand, supported thc order undcr appeal, reiterating the stand
taken in the cr,unter affidavit that the appellant is seeking to grab
Government lard rn Sy.No.403/P on the strengrh of fabricated and
unregistered documents, and that the survey report obtained
under the ordr,rs of the Court demonstrates that no interference
whatsoever was, caused to the lanrl claimed bv him.
ANALYSIS
19. We havc r:arefully considerecl the submissions made on both
sides and examined the record.
-l3-
20. The controversy between the parties is a narrow one' The
appellan! claims title to an extent of 4,865 square yards on the
strength of, firstlg, a patta said to have been granted in favour of
Riyaz Ahmed in FiIe No.112/ 18 of 1340 Fasli, secondlg, a
conveyance said to have been made by the said pattadar in favour
of Rani Jayanti Rani in the year 1945, and thirdly, Document
No.8101 dated 15.12.1969 executed by the said vendor in his
favour, read along with the entries in the Sethwar and the Khasra
Pahani for the year 1954-55, the proceedings dated 09.11'1978
and the property tax receipts. The respondents, on the other hand,
assert that the land over which lhe signboard was erected is
Government land comprised in Sy.No.4O3/P, correlated to
T.S.No.17, Block-D, Ward No. 10, classified in the Town Survey
Land Records as "sarkari Kancha Tattikhana - Jubiiee Hills" and
registered in the Land Bank, and that the documents relied upon
by the appeliant are fabricated, antedated and bear bogus
signatures, the proceedings dated 09.11.1978 being itself a forged
document.
2L. The controversy so projected throws up, among others, the
following questions: whether the patta said to have been granted in
134O Fasli, the conveyance of the year 1945 and Document
No.810 1 dated
15.12.1969 are genuine and duly executed
-H-
documents, ol are fabricated and antedated as alleged; what is the
legal effect, rpon the title claimed by the appellant, of the
impounding o: the last of these documents under Section 42 of tt,e
Indian Stamp Act, 1899; whether the proceedings dated
09.11.1978 r.r,t:re in fact issued by the competent authority; what is
the evidentiary value of the entries in the Sethwar, 1.he Khasra
Pahani for th: year 1954-55 and the subsequent pahanis; and,
above a1l, what is the identity, location and extent of the land
actually held by the appellant, and whether it lies within
Sy.No.129/56 in T.S.No.19 or fa1ls within Sy.No.403 in T.S.No.17
of Shaikpet viltage.
22. Questiorrs of this nature are not capable of being decided in
a summary proceeding under Article 226 of tlne Constitution of
India, on the basis of aflidavits and of copies of documents filed
along with then. A finding whether a document of the year 1945 or
of the year 1969 is genuine or fabricated ordinarily calls for
evidence, for production and scrutiny of the original records of the
revenue and legistration offices, for examinati.on of the ofhcers
concerned, anrl for an opportunity to both sides to lead proof and
rebuttal. So tc,o, a disputed claim of title to immovable property,
and the ascerr ainment of the identity of the land on the ground
with reference to the old and new survey numbers, the town survey
-
l5-
record.s and the measurements taken
on ttre spot' are matters
whichthecompetentCivilCourtaioneisequippedtodetermirre,by
framing issues, receiving oral and documentary
evidence' having
or a survey
recourse to the report of an Advocate Commissioner
frndings after a full-fledged
ofhcer where necessary, and recording
that the writ jurisdiction is not an
trial. It is well settled
seriously disputed
appropriate forum for the resolution of
questions of title and of fact of this description'
23. That being the position, we consider it appropriate
enter into the merits of the rival claims of
not to
the parties and to grant
liberty to the parties to have their respective
rights adjudicated by
the competent Civil Court We make it clear
that we express no
opinioneit}reronthetitleassertedbytheappellantoronthe
assertion of the respondents that the subject
land is Government
land
24. Since the appellant is being relegated to his civil
since the questions of fact bearing upon
documents and upon his title have not
been, Iinally determined in the writ
remedy' and
the genuineness of his
been' and could not have
proceeding' it is only just that
thelrndingsandobservati'onsrecordedintheimpugnedorder
the conduct of the
upon those aspects, including those touching
prejudice before the Civil
appellant, should not operate to his
- t6-
Court. We accordingly direct that the observations made in the
impugned order shall nol influence the competent Court of civil
jurisdiction i! any suit is preferred by the appellant on the instant
cause of action. It is also open to the appellant to apply for such
interim protcction as he may be advised before the Crvil Court, and
any such altplication shall be dealt with on its crwn merits.
uninfluenced by the said observations.
25. For the very same reason, the costs of Rs.10,0OO/- imposed
upon the ap1>ellant by the impugned order, which flow from the
hnding of suppression and grisrepresentation, cannot be allowed to
stand. The costs so rmposed are accordingly waived.
RESULT
26. In the rr:sult,
(i) The Writ Appeal is dismrssed, with liberry to the
appellarrt to approach the competent Civil Court in respect of
the same cause of action.
(ii) The costs of Rs.1O,O00/- imposed by the impugned
order ar: waived.
(iii) TL.e observations made in the impugned order shall
not influ ence the competent Court of civil jurisdictron if any
-17 -
suit is preferred by the appellant on the instant cause of
actlon
There shall be no order as to costs in this writ appeal'
24.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand closed'
SDI MOHD.ISMAIL
DEPUW R
ISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
sEc
N OFFICER
To,
1. One CC to SRl. G.V. SUBRAHMANYAM, Advocate [OPUC]
2. fwo CCs to GP FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
3. Two CD CoPies
PSR
GJP
yL:',
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1510912026
ORDER
WA.No.1002 of 2026
t{ E 5TA}F
DISMISSING'THE
o
u
vZ
2lstP m
ct
.b
t
WRIT APPEAL
De SPAT
wtTHouT cc)sTs.
a
q
i\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review