The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. allowed. Hence this revisional application being CRR 4356 of 2024 is hereby Order passed by the learned Magistrate on 19.9.2024 is hereby set aside.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
03.07.2026
Court No.34
S/L.5
sg
CRR 4356 of 2024
In the matter of :
Sweta Yadav @ Sweta Kumari & Anr.
Petitioners.
Mr. Kusal Kumar Mukherjee
Mr. Narattam Acharyya
…for the petitioners.
Mr. Soumyajit Das Mahapatra
Ms. Madhuri Sinha
Ms. Upsana Banerjee
Mr. Bisal Roy
…for the O.P. No.2.
1.
This revisional application has been filed under Section 482 and Section
401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 corresponding to Section 528 and
Section 442 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, against an order passed
by Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Khragpur in connection with G.R.
No. 1006 of 2023 under Sections 498A/323/509/34 of the Indian Penal Code and
Section 3/4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 whereby prayer for reinvestigation
in the aforesaid matter has been allowed against her-in-laws /present petitioner
nos. 1 and 2.
2.
The factual matrix of the case unveils that aforesaid case was initiated at
the behest of the opposite party no.2 by filing written complaint alleging inter alia
of physical and mental torture as well as demand of dowry
party no.2 since after their marriage.
28.1.2022 on
upon the opposite
The said marriage was solemnized on
the basis of the said written complaint lodged before the
Women Police Station,
Khragpur Town.
All
A case was initiated being AWPS KGP
Case No. 124 of 2023 for commission of offence under the aforesaid Sections on
the basis of the said written complaint lodged before All Women Police Station,
Khragpur Town against the nine accused persons including present petitioners.
3.
On completion of investigation charge sheet was submitted against seven
accused persons and the learned Magistrate took cognizance of the said
chargesheet and vide order dated 14.8.2024 the present petitioners were not sent
for trial in the aforesaid charge sheet. An application was filed by the opposite
party no.2 praying for re-investigation before the Court of ACJM, Khragpur which
was allowed and prayed for
re-investigation .Being aggrieved thereby this
revisional application has been filed.
4.
Learned advocate representing the petitioner submits that the learned
Magistrate has no jurisdiction to conduct the de novo or re-investigation in
relation to the offence for which report has been field in terms of Section 172 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure. That apart once a report under Section 173(2) of
the Code of Criminal Procedure has been filed it can only be cancelled, proceeded
further or case closed by the Court of competent jurisdiction in accordance with
law and neither the police nor a specialized investigating agency has any right to
cancel the said report.
Learned Magistrate can direct to conduct further
investigation only in exceptional circumstances. However, the Magistrate possess
no power to direct re-investigation.
It is further submitted that in the order
impugned the learned Magistrate observed that IO did not record statement of
the defacto-complainant under Section 161 and did not bring before the learned
Magistrate to record her statement under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure and the Learned Court found justification in the prayer of the defactocomplainant and allowed such prayer for re-investigation which is not sustainable
in the eye of law.
5.
Learned advocate put reliance upon decision reported in (2013) 2 C Cr
LR (SC) 83 Vinay Tyagi Vs. Irshad Ali @ Deepak & Ors in this regard .
6.
Learned advocate representing opposite party no.2 on the other hand
raises vehement objection and submits that there is no infirmities in order passed
by the learned Magistrate and mere acceptance of incorrect phraseology by the
learned Magistrate would not inure in favour of the petitioner.
It is specifically
argued that when specific reason was assigned by the learned Magistrate it
demonstrate clearly that there was sufficient application of mind by the learned
Magistrate while passing such order which ought to have been treated
investigation’ and
not as ‘re-investigation’.
as ‘further
In this regard, learned advocate
further relied upon decision reported in 2007 SCC Online Cal 604 : 2008 Cri L.J
841 Prabir Kumar Chatterjee Vs. State of West Bengal & Ors.
7.
Heard the submission of both the learned advocates. On perusal of the
record as well as the submissions advanced by both the learned advocates the
seminal issue to be decided is whether learned Magistrate
power to
mistake
is denuded of any
direct ‘re-investigation’ or ‘fresh investigation’ or whether due to
of
the
nomenclature
or
the
incorrect
phraseology
by
the
petitioner/opposite party no.2/defacto-complainant in drafting their application or
accepting the same in the order portion can itself be treated as not having legal
sanctity in the eye of law.
8.
In the decision of Vinay Tyagi (supra) it was specific question that was
raised before the Hon’ble Supreme Court and there it was observed ‘further
investigation’ is whether the investigating officer obtains further oral and
documentary evidence after final report has been filed before the Court in terms
of Section 173(8).
It is the continuation of a previous investigation and,
therefore, is understood and described as a ‘further investigation’. It was further
held that scope of ‘further investigation’ is restricted to the discovery of further
oral and documentary evidence. The Hon’ble Supreme Court observed and held
that the learned Magistrate has no jurisdiction to direct fresh or de novo
investigation .However once the report is furnished the
Learned Magistrate has
the jurisdiction to accept or reject the same right at the threshold. There is no
provision in the code which empowers the Magistrate to disturb the status of an
accused
pending investigation or when report is filed, to wipe out the report and
effects in law.
9.
In paragraph 30 of the said decision Hon’ble Supreme Court analyzed the
various judgements and arrived at a conclusion which reads as follows :
30.
“Having analysed the provisions of the Code and the various judgments as
afore-indicated, we would state the following conclusions in regard to the powers
of a Magistrate in terms of Section 173(2) read with Section 173(8) and Section
156 (3) of the Code.
1. The Magistrate has no power to direct „re-investigation‟ or „ fresh
investigation‟ (de novo) in the case initiated on the basis of a police report.
2. A Magistrate has the power to direct „further investigation‟ after filing
of a police report in terms of Section 173 (6) of the Code.
3. The view expressed in (2) above is in conformity with the principle of
law stated in Bhagwant Singh‟s case (supra) by a three Judge Bench and thus in
conformity with the doctrine of precedence.
4. Neither the scheme of the Code nor any specific provision therein bars
exercise of such jurisdiction by the Magistrate. The language of Section 173(2)
cannot be construed so restrictively as to deprive the Magistrate of such powers
particularly in face of the provisions of Section 156(3) and the language of Section
173(8) itself.
In fact, such power would have to be read into the language of
Section 173(8).
5.
The Code is a procedural document, thus, it must receive a
construction which would advance the cause of justice
and legislative object
sought to be achieved. It does not stand to reason that the legislature provided
power of further investigation to the police even after filing a report but intended
to curtail the power of the Court to the extent that even where the facts of the
case and the ends of justice demand,the Court can still not direct the investigating
agency to conduct further investigation which it could do on its own.
6.
It has been
a procedure of proprietary that the police has to seek
permission of the Court to continue „further investigation‟ and file supplementary
charge-sheet . This approach has been approved by this
judgements.
present case.”
Court in a number of
This as such would support the view that we are taking in the
10.
On perusal of the decision of Prabir Kumar Chatterjee (supra) as relied
upon by the learned advocate by the opposite party also it is seen question arose
before the Court whether order of the learned Magistrate for re-investigation of
the case or legally justifiably or not.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court
took note of the decision in Abhinandan Jha vs
Dinesh Mishra AIR 1968 SC117 where it was held that
the Magistrate has the
jurisdiction to disagree with a final Report and can taken cognizance of an offence
under section 190(1)© of CrPC or may order further investigation under section
156(3) of CrPC . The Hon’ble court further considered Popular Muthiah VS State
Represented by Inspector
of police (2006)7SCC 296 wherein it was held by
Hon’ble Supreme Court that the jurisdiction of the Magistrate in the
matter of
issuance of process or taking cognizance offence depends upon the existence of
condition precedent thereto.
In the said case lastly Hon’ble court held that
although the word ‘re-investigation’ is used in the decision of the
Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Popular Muthiah(supra), to all intents and purposes it
is
actually a direction for ‘further investigation’ and therefore held that the order
passed by the learned Magistrate was not bad in law.
11.
In the light of the above proposition of law as laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court let me come to the fact and circumstances of the case where the
complaint was lodged by the opposite party no.2 before the Officer-in-charge
against her parent-in-law, husband and as well as other in law including present
petitioner nos. 1 & 2 who happens to be sister-in-law. Primarily on perusal of the
entire written complaint it is apparent that the complaint lacks specific detailed
description of the torture inflicted by the present petitioners upon opposite party
no.2.
In the chargesheet the investigating officer discussed the process of
investigation and that examining complaint and after recording her statement
under Section 161 he submitted the report whereby it was specifically mentioned
that in column no.13 that the present petitioners /accused may be discharged
from the case as
Thereafter
their involvement with the
incidents were
not proved.
defacto-complainant filed the application for re-investigation
with
specific averment that the investigating officer without mentioning the adequate
reasons and lack of investigation not sent up 2 F.I.R named accused persons in
serial nos. 8 and 9
qua the
despite the specific part played by them was
described in the written complaint .
12.
Learned Trial Court after hearing parties observed in his order that the
I.O did not record their statement under Section 161 of Cr.P.C and did not bring
him before the Laerned Magistrate and the allegation in respect of defactocomplaint against her sister-in-law were accordingly not investigated
and thereafter found justification in the prayer
properly
for re-investigationand directed
the I.O to re –investigate the case in respect of the specific allegations against
those two persons being the petitioners herein .
13.
This court from aforesaid factual matrix
do not find substance in the
argument that the word re-investigation as mentioned in the petition and in the
order impugned is simplicitor a mistake of incorrect phraseology and the actual
meaning and purport of such word is to be treated as ‘further investigation’ . Even
assuming such contention it would be incorrect interpretation of law as discussed
above since no new fact or circumstances were found to allow the prayer for
further investigation.
14.
More so it is apparent that even though the investigating officer recorded
the statement under section 161 of CrPC the Learned Magistrate was of the view
that no such statement was recorded and the allegations against the petitioners
were not investigated properly .
15.
It
is settled proposition of law that
the court must ensure
the
investigation is fair and does not in any way hamper the freedom of individual
except in accordance with law .On going through the materials and factual aspect
and the law laid down this Court is of the view there is sufficient reason
to
exercise the inherent power in order to prevent abuse of the process of law not to
allow the proceeding as directed for re=investigation since the order is clearly not
sustainable in the eye of law .
16.
allowed.
Hence this revisional application being CRR 4356 of 2024 is hereby
Order passed by the learned Magistrate on 19.9.2024 is hereby set
aside.
17.
Parties are to act on the server copy of this order downloaded from the
official website of the Calcutta High Court.
[Chaitali Chatterjee (Das), J.]
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review