The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. Accordingly, in view of the above, the order dated 05.06.2024, to the extent it imposes a penalty of stoppage of 1(one) increment without cumulative effect, upon the petitioner, stands set-aside. However, the order of revocation of order of suspension of the petitioner as effected vide the said order dated 05.06.2024, is not interfered with. The disciplinary authorities are granted liberty to proceed against the petitioner, if so mandated, by instituting the regular departmental proceedings against her in compliance of the provisions of the Rules of 1964. Till the time such proceedings are initiated and concluded, the directions passed by the Director, Elementary Education, Assam, vide order dated 05.06.2024, to not allow the petitioner to hold the charge of the post of Head Master shall remain in currency. The said direction, however, will be subject to the outcome of the proceedings now directed to be instituted against the petitioner, in the matter. The Director, Elementary Education, Assam, Page No.# 7/7 however, shall ensure that the post of Head Master of the School is held by a person competent to hold the post.
11. With the above observations and directions, the present Writ Petition is disposed of. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010236412024
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5963/2024
SWARNALI PATHAK
DAUGHTER OF LT. BIJAYA BORA PATHAK,
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- HAIBORGAON,
LAWKHOWA ROAD,
P.O. HAIBORGAON,
DISTRICT- NAGAON, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-6.
2:THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-19.
3:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782001.
4:CHANDAN BHATTACHARYA
TUTOR
DAKHAN JAR BAGAN LP SCHOOL
P.O. -BARPANI
P.S.- KACHUA
PIN- 782450
Page No.# 2/7
NAGAON
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR D MAHANTA, MR T GOGOI
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, ELEM. EDU,
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 23.02.2026
Heard Mr. D Mahanta, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr.
B Talukdar, learned standing counsel, Department of Elementary Education,
Assam, appearing for respondent no. 1, 2 & 3.
2.
The petitioner, by way of instituting the present Writ Petition, has
prayed for an interference with an order dated 05.06.2024, issued by the
Director, Elementary Education, Assam by which the petitioner was
imposed with a penalty of stoppage of 1 (One) increment without
cumulative effect. Further, the petitioner who was acting as the In-charge
Head Mistress of Dakhin Jarbagan L.P School, under BEEO, Kothiatoli, was
divested of the said charge and the private respondent no. 4 was allowed
to act as the In-charge, Head Master of the School, in place of the
petitioner.
3.
As projected in the Writ Petition, the petitioner had joined Dakhin
Jarbagan L.P School, under BEEO, Kothiatoli, on 01.11.2012 as an
Assistant Teacher. Thereafter, the petitioner was serving as a Head Teacher
of the said school and on 17.05.2023, an unfortunate incident occasioned,
wherein, a large number of students of the school fell seriously sick after
consuming meals under the Mid Day Meal Scheme, in the school.
The said incident having come to the notice of the District
Page No.# 3/7
Administration, the Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon, was pleased to direct
for holding of an enquiry into the matter. Accordingly, an enquiry was held
and the jurisdictional Circle Officer submitted his report, wherein, basing
on the materials coming on record, the petitioner and the cook along with
2(two) helpers were held to be responsible for the incident that resulted in
the students consuming meal on the fateful day in the school to fall sick.
In the said report, it was also stipulated that there was large enrolment of
students in the school and the Education Department was required to
urgently construct more rooms for the school and engage 1(one) more
teacher, keeping in view the high enrolment of students in the school.
Basing on the said report, the Addl. Deputy Commissioner (Edn) cum
D.M.C (S.S.A) and A.D.N.O, (PM Poshan), Nagaon, proceeded to issue a
show-cause to the petitioner requiring her to show cause as to why
disciplinary action should not be so recommended against her, for her
negligence of duty, basing on the incident that had occasioned in her
school on 17.05.2023. In pursuance to the said show-cause notice issued
to the petitioner, it is contended that the petitioner was placed under
suspension vide issuance of order dated 31.05.2023.
It is in the above background that the Director, Elementary Education,
Assam, had passed an order dated 05.06.2024, wherein, while revoking
the petitioner’s suspension and reinstating her in her services, a penalty of
stoppage of 1(one) increment without cumulative effect came to be
imposed upon the petitioner. Further, the petitioner was replaced by the
respondent no. 4 as the In-charge, Head Master of the school.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner has instituted the present proceedings.
4.
Mr. D Mahanta, learned counsel for the petitioner, by reiterating the
facts noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that a perusal of the order dated
05.06.2024, would go to reveal that the petitioner was imposed a penalty
under the provisions of Rule 7 of the Assam Services (Discipline and
Appeal) Rules, 1964. However, he submits that a departmental proceeding,
Page No.# 4/7
as mandated to be so conducted before imposition of a penalty under Rule
7 of the said Rules of 1964, however, was not instituted against the
petitioner. He submits that the show-cause dated 19.05.2023, was so
issued by the Addl. Deputy Commissioner (Edn) cum D.M.C (S.S.A) and
A.D.N.O, (PM Poshan), Nagaon, requiring the petitioner to explain as to
why disciplinary action against her is to be not initiated. It is further
submitted that the said show-cause notice dated 19.05.2023, cannot be
construed to be one so issued under the provisions of Sub-Rule (2) of Rule
9 of the Assam Services (Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 1964, initiating a
departmental proceedings against the petitioner. Accordingly, he submits
that the petitioner could not have been imposed with a penalty under Rule
7 of the Rules of 1964 without first holding a proceeding in terms of Rule 9
of the Rules of 1964. In the above premises, Mr. D Mahanta, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that the order dated 05.06.2024 would
mandate interference from this Court.
5.
Mr. B Talukdar, learned standing counsel, Department of Elementary
Education, Assam, appearing for respondent nos. 1, 2 & 3, on instructions,
has submitted that the proceedings held in the matter against the
petitioner was so held in pursuance to the show-cause notice dated
19.05.2023, issued by the Addl. Deputy Commissioner (Edn) cum D.M.C
(S.S.A) and A.D.N.O, (PM Poshan), Nagaon, to the petitioner. He further
submits that after the petitioner had submitted a reply, thereto, an Enquiry
Committee was constituted on 18.01.2024 and the petitioner was directed
to appear before the said committee. He also submits that the Enquiry
Committee proceeded with the matter and the petitioner also participated
in such enquiry. On conclusion of the enquiry, the said committee
submitted its report and accordingly, the Director, Elementary Education,
Assam, basing on the said report, proceeded to issue the order dated
05.06.2024, assailed in the present writ petition. Mr. B Talukdar, learned
standing counsel, Department of Elementary Education, Assam submits
Page No.# 5/7
that given the nature of allegations leveled against the petitioner and it
being revealed that it was on account of her negligence that many
students of the school fell ill after consuming meals under the Mid Day
Meal Scheme in the said school, the penalty imposed upon the petitioner
being commensurate to the allegations leveled against her, the same would
not mandate any interference. He further submits that the petitioner
having been found to be not in a position to manage the affairs of the
school, as its Head Teacher, the substitution of the petitioner by the next
senior most teacher of this school, would also not call for any interference
by this Court.
6.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have perused the
materials available on record.
7.
The allegations leveled against the petitioner is, admittedly, serious. It
is during the time the petitioner was holding the Charge of the Post of
Head Teacher of the school in question, that an unfortunate incident
occasioned, wherein, students studying in the said school who had
consumed meals under the Mid Day Meal Scheme, was found to be,
thereafter, seriously ill. The said students had suffered from food poisoning
and the reports of the samples of the food so tested had revealed that it
was contaminated with detergents. The petitioner can be held to be
negligent for the occasioning of the said incident in the school. Having
noticed the said position, this Court finds that the Director, Elementary
Education, Assam, vide order dated 05.06.2024, had imposed upon the
petitioner, a penalty of stoppage of 1(one) increment without cumulative
effect. The said penalty has been so imposed, in terms of the provisions of
Rule 7 of the said Rules of 1964. A penalty under Rule 7 of the Rules of
1964 would be permissible to be so imposed only upon holding of a
departmental proceeding in terms of Rule 9 of the said Rules of 1964. A
departmental proceeding can be said to have been instituted against the
delinquent under the provisions of the Rules of 1964 only when a show-
Page No.# 6/7
cause notice is issued to the delinquent, under the provisions of Rule 9 (2)
of the Rules of 1964.
8.
In the present case, no show-cause notice under the provisions of
Rule 9(2) was issued to the petitioner, herein. The entire proceeding was
initiated against the petitioner basing on the issuance of a show-cause
notice dated 19.05.2023 issued by the Addl. Deputy Commissioner (Edn)
cum D.M.C (S.S.A) and A.D.N.O, (PM Poshan), Nagaon. A perusal of the
said notice dated 19.05.2023 would reveal that the same was nothing but
an explanation call from the petitioner as to why, disciplinary action should
not be recommended against her for the negligence by her, of her duties.
The said show-cause notice cannot be held to have the effect of instituting
a departmental proceeding against the petitioner.
9.
This Court, having found that the procedure prescribed under Rule 9
of the Rules of 1964 to have not been followed in the matter, the order
dated 05.06.2024 cannot be sustained and would be mandated to be
interfered with by this Court.
10. Accordingly, in view of the above, the order dated 05.06.2024, to the
extent it imposes a penalty of stoppage of 1(one) increment without
cumulative effect, upon the petitioner, stands set-aside. However, the order
of revocation of order of suspension of the petitioner as effected vide the
said order dated 05.06.2024, is not interfered with. The disciplinary
authorities are granted liberty to proceed against the petitioner, if so
mandated, by instituting the regular departmental proceedings against her
in compliance of the provisions of the Rules of 1964. Till the time such
proceedings are initiated and concluded, the directions passed by the
Director, Elementary Education, Assam, vide order dated 05.06.2024, to
not allow the petitioner to hold the charge of the post of Head Master shall
remain in currency. The said direction, however, will be subject to the
outcome of the proceedings now directed to be instituted against the
petitioner, in the matter. The Director, Elementary Education, Assam,
Page No.# 7/7
however, shall ensure that the post of Head Master of the School is held by
a person competent to hold the post.
11.
With the above observations and directions, the present Writ Petition
is disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review