Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
---------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
----------------------------------------------------------------------
DATED : 12.06.2018
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong,
W/o William Tamang,
D/o Raju Dong,
Permanent Resident of Upper Sichey,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
… Petitioner (s).
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim.
2.
The Secretary,
Labour Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Shram Bhawan, Sokaythang,
East Sikkim.
3.
One Man Committee,
Justice Kalyanjyoti Sengupta,
Hon’ble Chairman,
Sikkim Lokyukta.
4.
Mrs. Lakchung Sherpa,
W/o Shri R.B. Subba,
Commissioner for Employees
Compensation under the Employees
Compensation Act, 1923.
… Respondent (s).
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Tashi
petitioner.
Rapden
Barfungpa,
Advocate
for
the
Mr. A. Mariarputham, Advocate General, Mr. J.B.
Pradhan, Addl. Advocate General with Mr. Santosh Kr.
Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai, Asstt. Govt. Advocates for
Respondents No. 1 and 2.
Mr. A. Moulik, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Tshering Uden
Sherpa and Ms. Archana Sharma, Advocates for
respondent No. 4.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Satish K. Agnihotri, CJ
The
Petitioner,
stated
to
be
the
applicant
for
consideration and selection for appointment on the post of
Commissioner for employees compensation under the Employees
Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter referred to as ―the Act of
1923‖), on being unsuccessful, has come up with the instant
petition questioning the legality and validity of the select list,
wherein the 4th respondent was found successful in the merit list
and placed at Sl. No. 1 and subsequently appointment on the
post.
2.
The facts, in brief, as projected in the pleadings, are
that the Labour Department, Government of Sikkim invited
applications from the eligible local candidates to fill up the post of
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
one Labour Commissioner under sub-Section (1) of Section 20 of
the Act of 1923 by publication of notice in the news papers,
Sikkim Express dated 14th December 2017 and also in other news
papers, namely Sikkim Herald dated 12th December 2017, Samay
Dainik dated 14th December 2017 and also published again on
15th December 2017.
applications
are
It was stated in the notification that
invited
for
appointment
of
the
Labour
Commissioner to deal with the compensation cases of the
labourers, prescribing the qualification as under: ―(i) The candidates should have been a member of
State Judicial Service for the period of not less than 5
(five) years or is or has been for not less than 5 (five)
years an Advocate or a Pleader or is or has been a
Gazetted Officer for not less than 5 (five) years having
educational qualification and experience in Personal
Management, Human Resource Development and
Industrial Relations.‖
3.
It was further stated that the preference shall be
given to the candidates having knowledge of local language,
culture and local law.
The last date of submission of the
application along with CV was on or before 29th December 2017.
In response thereto, as many as 11 applicants, including the
petitioner and the 4th respondent, submitted the applications.
The Labour Department appointed One Man Selection Committee
of
Mr.
Justice
Kalyanjyoti
Sengupta,
Chairman,
Sikkim
Lokayukta, former Chief Justice of a High Court. The applicants
were informed the date of interview for the post, to be held on
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
05th February 2018 at Tourist Lodge, Rangpo. Consequent to the
selection, a Select List dated 05th February 2018 of three
candidates on merit was published, wherein the 4 th respondent
ranked first, the petitioner ranked second and one Mr. Dinesh
Chawhan was at Sl. No. 3.
4.
The petitioner, finding her unsuccessful, sent a legal
notice dated 19th February 2018 to the respondents, stating that
the notification dated 03rd July 2017 issued by the Government
prescribed the upper age limit of 40 years for employment in the
State services/posts to be filled up by direct recruitment under
the Government of Sikkim and in the State Public Sector
Undertakings of Sikkim. The 4th respondent, who was placed at
Sl. No. 1 in the merit list, had already crossed the age limit of 40
years and as such her appointment was illegal. Accordingly, her
candidature and appointment be declared as illegal, null and void
and the petitioner be declared as selected.
5.
The Labour Department replied to the legal notice,
stating that the notification dated 3rd July 2017 has no relevance.
The post of Labour Commissioner is created by the Parliament
under the Act of 1923.
The notification dated 3 rd July 2017 is
applicable only to the posts created by the State Government.
The 4th respondent has also responded to the notice, as it was
addressed to her also.
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
6.
Consequent upon the selection, the 4th respondent
was appointed as Labour Commissioner by notification dated 14th
February 2018, followed by an Office Order issued on the same
date, wherein the scale of Rs.51500-1230-58930-1380-63070
was granted. It was also stated that the incumbent would be
entitled to draw all perquisite and benefits at par with officers of
the State Government in the said pay scale.
Further, it was
stated that her previous service shall be counted for pensionary
benefits. Being aggrieved, the instant petition is filed.
7.
It is averred in the petition that the appointment of
the 4th respondent is in contravention of the notification No.
M(3)/(55)/GEN/DOP/PT.II dated 03rd July 2017 wherein the
upper age limit is prescribed as 40 years and as such it was a
clear case of nepotism and favouritism by the State Government.
It is further stated that the 4th respondent had resigned from the
post of Legal Remembrancer-cum-Secretary, Law Department,
subsequently also from the post of Secretary in the Legal,
Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs Department within a short
span of time. As such, her appointment as Labour Commissioner
is a case of colourable exercise of power, overlooking the
statutory provisions, as stated hereinabove.
It is further stated
that the appointment of the 4th respondent is on account of
undue favours shown by other respondents. The notification was
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
not widely published, disabling many aspiring candidates from
making applications for the post.
Committee
is
without
any
The constitution of One Man
authority
of
law.
Confining
applications to the local candidates clearly establishes that the
provisions of Sikkim Government Establishment Rules, 1974 are
made applicable to the process of appointment. The entire
selection process was just an eye-wash.
The petitioner has
sought a declaration to the effect that the appointment of the 4 th
respondent be declared as null and void and in her place, the
petitioner be appointed.
8.
Mr.
Tashi
Rapten
Barfungpa,
learned
counsel
appearing for the petitioner, in addition to the aforestated
pleadings, submits that the selection is bad on the ground that
the advertisement does not prescribe pay scale.
It is further
alleged that since the interview was conducted in Rangpo and not
in Gangtok, it vitiates the selection process.
Mr. Barfungpa
further submits that the 4th respondent was chosen unduly in
colourable exercise of power, nepotism and favouritism. The 4 th
respondent has crossed the age limit of 40 years which was
prescribed in the Government notification dated 03rd July 2017
and as such her appointment is null and void.
Further, it was
contended that the 4th respondent had resigned from various
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
posts, thus, appointing her again shows mala fide intention of the
authorities.
9.
In response, Mr. A. Mariarputham, learned Advocate
General appearing for the 1st and 2nd respondents, referring and
relying on the counter affidavit dated 9th May 2018, denies the
allegation that the advertisement was published only in one
newspaper.
It is stated that the advertisement was widely
published firstly on 12th December 2017 in Sikkim Herald, on 14th
December 2018 in Sikkim Express and Samay Dainik, a Nepali
newspaper.
Again it was published on 15 th December 2017 in
Sikkim Herald, Sikkim Express and Samay Dainik, which was
manifest by the clippings of the newspapers, annexed to the
counter affidavit.
Further, it is contended that the purpose of
wide publicity is to inform all the eligible candidates to enable
them to make applications.
In the case on hand, no other
persons have come forward to complain that he or she didn’t
have the information of the employment notice.
The petitioner
had due knowledge and, accordingly, she made the application
and was considered for selection, thus, the petitioner cannot
raise the issue that there was lack of due publicity. It is urged by
the learned Advocate General that the appointment of Labour
Commissioner is made under the provision of Section 20 the Act
of 1923, which is a parliamentary legislation.
Under the
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
statutory provision, the post of Commissioner, being in the
nature of Tribunal, in terms of the Sikkim Public Service
Commission (Exemption from Consultation) Regulation, 1986,
wherein the State Government could have appointed a person,
whom it consider suitable, without advertisement and selection
by a Selection Committee. However, in the case on hand, proper
Committee was constituted, applications were invited from the
eligible candidates, as prescribed in the statute, and on due
selection the appointment was made. The notification dated 03 rd
July 2017 has no application, as the same is applicable only for
the posts created by the State Government and to the posts in
Public Sector Undertakings of the State.
The post of Labour
Commissioner is a creation of the Parliament and as such, the
same provision is not applicable.
It is further contended that
looking the requisite qualification and nature of job, 40 years cap
could not have been prescribed.
The notice inviting application
for the post of Labour Commissioner was confined to serve the
local needs and the interests of labourers, who are locally
employed, the responsibility of the Commissioner for Employees
Compensation is limited to local area, particularly, the labourers
who know local language only. Even otherwise, the petitioner is
a local candidate and no non-local applicant has come forward to
question the veracity of employment notice. It is also submitted
that if the selection process itself is illegal or improper, as
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
pleaded by the petitioner, claim of the petitioner for appointment
cannot be pleaded and considered.
The allegation of the
petitioner that the selection of the 4th respondent is arbitrary and
in colourable exercise of power is without any basis as the
petitioner has neither pleaded nor established any fact which
comes within the purview of the colourable exercise of power.
Resignation of the 4th respondent from the posts of Legal
Remembrancer-cum-Secretary,
Law
or
Secretary,
Legal,
Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs Department, does not debar
or disqualify the 4th respondent from being considered for
selection as there was no stigma during her service career as she
has been awarded ―outstanding‖ grade. The petition is without
any basis.
10.
Referring to the observations made by the Supreme
Court in Madras Institute of Development Studies and another
vs. Sivasubbramaniyan and others 1 and Ashok Kumar and
another vs. State of Bihar and others2, it is next contended that
the petitioner after having participated in the selection process
and having been unsuccessful, is debarred from questioning the
selection process, particularly, when she was found placed at Sl.
No. 2 in the select list.
The petitioner has not questioned the
correctness of the select list.
(2016) 1 SCC 454
(2017) 4 SCC 357
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
11.
Adopting the submissions put forth by the learned
Advocate
General,
Mr.
A.
Moulik,
learned
Senior
Council
appearing for the 4th respondent, would contend that the 4th
respondent was fully eligible for the post and there is no
challenge to her merit, the 4th respondent is not disabled on
account of the fact that she had resigned from Government
service, that the alleged notification, wherein the maximum age
limit is prescribed to 40 years, is not applicable to the post in
question, as it is a post created by Parliament and also there is
no age limit prescribed in the statute itself.
12.
On anxious and careful consideration of the pleadings
and submissions put forth by the learned counsel appearing for
the parties, it is evident that the petitioner had applied, in
response to the employment notice, participated in the selection
process and also she was placed at Sl. No. 2 in the select list, on
being unsuccessful, she has come up with this petition, now
questioning the selection process.
13.
In
Dhananjay
Malik
and
others
vs.
State
of
Uttaranchal and others3, cited by learned Advocate General, the
Supreme Court considered the selection and appointment of
Physical Education Teachers at the instance of unsuccessful
candidates and held as under:
(2008) 4 SCC 171
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
“8. In Madan Lal v. State of J&K [(1995) 3 SCC 486 : 1995
SCC (L&S) 712 : (1995) 29 ATC 603] this Court pointed out
that when the petitioners appeared at the oral interview
conducted by the members concerned of the Commission
who interviewed the petitioners as well as the contesting
respondents concerned, the petitioners took a chance to get
themselves selected at the said oral interview. Therefore,
only because they did not find themselves to have emerged
successful as a result of their combined performance both at
written test and oral interview, they have filed writ
petitions. This Court further pointed out that if a candidate
takes a calculated chance and appears at the interview,
then, only because the result of the interview is not
palatable to him, he cannot turn round and subsequently
contend that the process of interview was unfair or the
Selection Committee was not properly constituted.
9. In the present case, as already pointed out, the
respondent-writ petitioners herein participated in the
selection process without any demur; they are estopped
from complaining that the selection process was not in
accordance with the Rules. If they think that the
advertisement and selection process were not in accordance
with the Rules they could have challenged the
advertisement and selection process without participating in
the selection process. This has not been done.‖
14.
Again in Madras Institute of Development Studies and
another vs. Sivasubbramaniyan and others1, referring to the
observation made earlier by the Supreme Court in several cases,
reiterated that by having taken part in selection process with full
knowledge that the candidates have the right to question the
advertisement or methodology adopted by the selection board,
on being unsuccessful, cannot turn around and question the
selection process.
It is not proper to entertain the grievance
made by the unsuccessful candidates.
15.
In Ashok Kumar and another vs. State of Bihar and
others2, the Supreme Court re-examined the issue and held as
under:
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
13. The law on the subject has been crystallised in several
decisions
of
this
Court.
In Chandra
Prakash
Tiwari v. Shakuntala
Shukla [Chandra
Prakash
Tiwari v. Shakuntala Shukla, (2002) 6 SCC 127 : 2002 SCC
(L&S) 830] , this Court laid down the principle that when a
candidate appears at an examination without objection and
is subsequently found to be not successful, a challenge to
the process is precluded. The question of entertaining a
petition challenging an examination would not arise where a
candidate has appeared and participated. He or she cannot
subsequently turn around and contend that the process was
unfair or that there was a lacuna therein, merely because
the result is not palatable. In Union of India v. S. Vinodh
Kumar [Union of India v. S. Vinodh Kumar, (2007) 8 SCC
100 : (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 792] , this Court held that: (SCC
p. 107, para 18)
―18. It is also well settled that those candidates who
had taken part in the selection process knowing fully
well the procedure laid down therein were not
entitled to question the same. (See Munindra
Kumar v. Rajiv Govil [Munindra Kumar v. Rajiv Govil,
(1991) 3 SCC 368 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 1052]
and Rashmi
Mishra v. M.P.
Public
Service
Commission [Rashmi Mishra v. M.P. Public Service
Commission, (2006) 12 SCC 724 : (2007) 2 SCC
(L&S) 345] .)‖
14. The same view was reiterated in Amlan Jyoti
Borooah [Amlan Jyoti Borooahv. State of Assam, (2009) 3
SCC 227 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 627] wherein it was held to
be well settled that the candidates who have taken part in a
selection process knowing fully well the procedure laid down
therein are not entitled to question it upon being declared to
be unsuccessful.
16.
In the case on hand, the petitioner was a local
candidate, participated and also was selected and ranked 2nd in
the select list and as such she is not permitted to challenge the
purported non-publicity of advertisement and also the selection
process, being irregular and illegal.
17.
The colourable exercise of power, as pleaded by the
petitioner, is considered by the Supreme Court in several cases,
and defined as under.
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
18.
In State of Punjab and another vs. Gurdial Singh and
others 4 , the Supreme Court elucidated colourable exercise of
power, as under:
―9.
………………..Pithily put, bad faith which invalidates the
exercise of power — sometimes called colourable exercise
or fraud on power and oftentimes overlaps motives,
passions and satisfactions — is the attainment of ends
beyond the sanctioned purposes of power by simulation or
pretension of gaining a legitimate goal. If the use of the
power is for the fulfilment of a legitimate object the
actuation or catalysation by malice is not legicidal. The
action is bad where the true object is to reach an end
different from the one for which the power is entrusted,
goaded by extraneous considerations, good or bad, but
irrelevant to the entrustment. When the custodian of power
is influenced in its exercise by considerations outside those
for promotion of which the power is vested the court calls it
a colourable exercise and is undeceived by illusion. In a
broad, blurred sense, Benjamin Disraeli was not off the
mark even in law when he stated: ―I repeat . . . that all
power is a trust — that we are accountable for its exercise
— that, from the people, and for the people, all springs, and
all must exist‖ ……………….‖.
19.
In Kerala State Cashew Development Corporation vs.
Shahal Hassan Mussaliar and another 5, it was observed by the
Supreme Court that an exercise of power which the State did not
possess under the Act is colourable exercise of power.
20.
In State of Kerala and another vs. Peoples Union for
Civil Liberties, Kerala State Unit and others6, it is observed that –
―37. ………… The doctrine of ―colourable legislation‖ is
directly connected with the legislative competence of
the State.‖
(1980) 2 SCC 471
(2009) 12 SCC 635
(2009) 8 SCC 46
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
21.
In Pratibha Nema and others vs. State of M.P. and
others7, dealing with a case under Land Acquisition Act, wherein
the proposed acquisition of land was primarily and predominantly
meant to cater to the interests of the private companies, a twist
was given to the acquisition as if it were for a public purpose,
bypassing the requirements of Part VII of the Act, the Supreme
Court held that the entire exercise was an instance of colourable
exercise of power and was, therefore, ultra vires the powers of
the State Government
In the instant case, it is submitted that the 4 th
22.
respondent had resigned from the post of Legal Remembrancercum-Secretary, Law Department, thereafter from the post of
Secretary,
Legal,
Department.
Legislative
and
Parliamentary
Affairs
Again her case was considered and appointed to
the post of Labour Commissioner.
It is further contended that
the 4th respondent’s husband is high ranking functionary of the
State Government, thus, undue favour was shown to her.
23.
On studied examination, it is noticed that the so called
high ranking functionary of the State Government, who happens
to be the husband of the 4th respondent, has no say in the entire
exercise.
On mere assertion without producing any material,
there is no reason to accept that the High Power One Man
(2003) 10 SCC 626
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
Selection Committee of former Chief Justice was under influence
of any high ranking functionary.
Resignation from two or three
posts earlier cannot be held as a disqualification, debarring her or
him from consideration for selection to a post unless there is
some disqualification or stigma attached thereto. In the case on
hand, there is nothing to establish that there was any stigma or
disqualification.
This Court has an occasion, in the course of
argument, to examine the chart prepared by the selection
committee, wherein all the candidates were awarded marks
under different criteria.
The maximum mark meant for the
interview was only 10.
It was further found that even if the
petitioner were awarded full marks i.e. 10, in totality, her
position would not have improved or the petitioner would not
have acquired more marks than the 4th respondent.
In overall
consideration, placing the 4th respondent at Sl. No. 1 was just
and proper.
24.
Holding the interview at some place other than
Gangtok, when the place of interview was not specified in the
employment notice, cannot be held as irregular, as Rangpo is
within the territory of Sikkim. The advertisement also cannot be
held as vitiated on the stated ground that the pay scale was not
stated when the petitioner was aware of it.
However, the pay
scale granted to the successful candidate was at par with the
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
District Judge, who becomes eligible on completion of five years
to make application and participate in the selection for the post.
25.
In such backdrop, it cannot be held that there was a
colourable exercise of power or some favour was shown to the 4th
respondent.
26.
The facts are not in dispute, as stated hereinabove.
Section 20 of the Act of 1923 reads as under:
“20. Appointment of Commissioners.- (1) The State
Government may, by notification in the Official Gazette,
appoint any person who is or has been a member of a State
Judicial Service for a period of not less than five years or is
or has been for not less than five years an advocate or a
pleader or is or has been a Gazetted officer for not less than
five years having educational qualifications and experience
in personnel management, human resource development
and industrial relations to be a Commissioner for
Employees's Compensation for such area as may be
specified in the notification.
(2) Where more than one Commissioner has been appointed
for any area, the State Government may, by general or
special order, regulate the distribution of business between
them.
(3) Any Commissioner may, for the purpose of deciding any
matter referred to him for decision under this Act, choose
one or more persons possessing special knowledge of any
matter relevant to the matter under inquiry to assist him in
holding the inquiry.
(4) Every Commissioner shall be deemed to be a public
servant within the meaning of the Indian Penal Code (45 of
1860).”
27.
On bare perusal of the provision, it is manifest that
the Parliament has created the post of Labour Commissioner, on
prescribing the specific qualification. The State Government was
empowered to appoint the Labour Commissioner keeping in view
the prescribed qualification stated therein.
The prescribed
qualification under the provision of Section 20 of the Act of 1923
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
is, who is or has been a member of a State Judicial Service for a
period of not less than five years or is or has been not less than
five years an advocate or a pleader or is or has been a Gazetted
officer
for
not
less
than
five
years
having
educational
qualifications and experience in personnel management, human
resource development and industrial relations. All the candidates
had the requisite qualifications.
28.
The prime contention of the petitioner is that the
notification dated 3rd July 2017 of the Department of Personnel,
Administrative
Reforms,
Training
and
Public
Grievances,
prescribing the upper age limit of 40 years for State employees,
was not applied in the instant case.
The notification reads as
under:
―
NOTIFICATION
The State Government is hereby pleased to prescribe
a uniform upper age limit of 40 (forty) years for all
communities of the State in the services/posts to be filled
up by direct recruitment under the Government of Sikkim
and in the State Public Sector Undertakings of Sikkim with
immediate effect.
However, the posts and services for recruitment in
Sikkim Police, Indian Reserve Battalion, Sikkim Armed
Forces, Forest Services, Fire Services and any other posts
and services which have specifically prescribed upper age
limit lower than 30 (thirty) years in their recruitment rules
are kept outside the purview of this notification.
This is in supersession of
M(135)/12/GEN/DOP dated 27/05/2015.
Notification
No.
By order and in the name of the Governor.
Sd/(Surekha Pradhan) Mrs.
Additional Secretary to the Government
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms,
Training and Public Grievances‖
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
The notification is crystal clear that the uniform upper age limit of
40 years prescribed therein is applicable for all communities of
the State services/posts to be filled up by direct recruitment
under the Government of Sikkim and in the State Public Sector
Undertakings of Sikkim and some services were excluded from
the notification.
29.
Indisputably, the post of Commissioner for employees
compensation, which is termed as Labour Commissioner, is a
creation
of
Parliament
enactment,
not
under
the
State
Government but under the Central Government. This contention
of the respondents that this notification is inapplicable deserves
acceptance and I do not find any reason to the contrary.
No
other documents have been produced, in support of the
contention that the upper age limit of 40 years is prescribed for
Labour
Commissioner
also.
Moreover,
looking
into
the
requirement of requisite qualification, 40 years cannot be fixed as
upper age limit, thus the upper age limit appears to be for those
services wherein appointment is made directly by the young
freshers.
Section
of
the
Act
of
contemplates
experienced person having put in some qualifying services as
judicial officer or as a gazette officer or in legal profession. This
WP(C) No. 08 of 2018
Sushmita Dong vs. State of Sikkim & Ors.
requirement is for a senior seasoned man, wherein the upper age
limit of 40 years cannot be prescribed.
30.
It is also contended by the petitioner that before
selection, no rules were framed under the Act of 1923. Section
32 of the Act of 1923 empowers the State to make rules to carry
out the purpose of the Act.
Under that Section, there is no
delegation with regard to appointment of Labour Commissioner.
Thus, the State Government is not competent to frame rules for
selection and appointment of the Labour Commissioner.
Even
otherwise non framing of rules does not invalidate the selection
for any post.
31.
As a sequitur, the writ petition is devoid of merit and
is, accordingly, dismissed.
32.
Costs made easy.
Chief Justice
12.06.2018
jk
Approved for Reporting
Internet
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review