Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.B.:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. Appeal No. 08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma,
Aged about 26 years,
S/o late Kharananda Sharma,
R/o Lower Lingchom, Salley,
Gyalshing, West Sikkim.
… Appellant
versus
State of Sikkim.
... Respondent
---------------------------------------------------------------------------Appeal against conviction under Section 374(2) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
Appearance:
Mrs. Puja Lamichaney, Legal Aid Counsel for the
Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Additional Public Prosecutor,
with Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Additional Public
Prosecutor, Mr. S. K. Chettri and Ms. Pollin Rai,
Assistant Public Prosecutors for the StateRespondent.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(01.12.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The NDPS Act, 1985 has been enacted to consolidate
and amend the law relating to narcotic drugs; to make
stringent provisions for control and regulations of operations
relating to narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances; to
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
implement the provisions of the International Convention on
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances and for matters
connected therewith.
2.
Although the NDPS Act, 1985 was applicable in Sikkim;
the State however faced further challenges of abuse of
prescription drugs and other substances which do not fall
within the definition of drugs like eraz-ex, polish etc. As per
the statement of object and reasons of the Sikkim Anti Drugs
Bill, 2006:
“The Sikkim Anti Drugs Bill, 2006 has been framed to tackle
the problem of drug abuse and other controlled substances that are
being abused in the State. The drug abuse scenario in the State is
increasing day by day and the unique problem is the abuse of
prescription drugs that are sold by the licensed pharmacies/
medical
stores
on
the
prescription
by
registered
medical
practitioners and abuse of other substances that are not drugs like
eraz-ex, polish etc. There is no law that could deal with these
problems specifically, in the absence of which the menace of abuse
and trafficking is going unabated. Because of this, it is necessary to
have a law that could deal with these kind of offences. Hence the
Sikkim Anti Drugs Bill 2006, has been framed under which
stringent penalties have been prescribed for offences under this
Act.”
3.
The Sikkim Anti Drugs Act, 2006 (SADA, 2006) sought
to:
“control, regulate and prevent the abuse of drugs and
control substances with abuse potential being misused by addicts
and traffickers, to make stringent provisions to deal with the ever
increasing phenomenon of abuse of medicinal preparations and
matters connected therewith”.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
4.
The Sikkim Anti Drugs Bill, 2006 having received the
assent of the Governor on 25.03.2006 was published in the
Sikkim Government Gazette on 17.04.2006 from which date
the SADA 2006 came into force in Sikkim.
5.
Both the NDPS Act, 1985 as well as the SADA 2006
makes stringent provisions for control and regulations of
operations
relating
to
narcotic
drugs
or
psychotropic
substances or controlled substances. The enactments seek to
meet the problems facing society today. The SADA 2006
sought to deal with the problems faced by Sikkim for which,
as per the objects and reasons, there was no law. It deals with
the menace of abuse and trafficking. Both the enactments
seek to deal with specific operations and addiction.
The prosecution story and the trial.
6.
On 04.01.2017, at around 1030 hours “credible source
information” that the Appellant was suspected to be in
possession of contraband substances and was in the process
of selling it to prospective buyers at Gyalshing Bazar, near the
taxi stand, West Sikkim was received. The place was visited in
the presence of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Gyalshing
(SDM) and two witnesses. The Appellant was searched and
was found in possession of one blue bag containing one black
“fastrack” container with 59 capsules of Spasmo Proxyvon, 29
capsules of “N-10” and one pouch of “ganja”. The recovered
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
articles were photographed, seized, packed and sealed in
presence of independent witnesses and the SDM. Thereafter,
the Appellant was medically examined at the District Hospital
Gyalshing and his urine sample preserved by the Medical
Officer for chemical examination. The Appellant was then
brought to the police station along with the seized articles for
further legal action. Stating the above facts, Police InspectorMahindra Pradhan, Station House Officer (SHO), Gyalshing
Police Station (P.W.6) would lodge the First Information
Report (FIR) (exhibit-1) as the informant under Section 9/14
of SADA, 2006 and endorse the case for investigation to the
Investigating Officer- Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) as the Station
House Officer (SHO).
7.
On completion of the investigation a charge-sheet and a
supplementary charge-sheet were filed. Although the chargesheet alleged that the Appellant was a Government servant;
the learned Special Judge did not frame a charge under
Section 9(c) of SADA, 2006. No evidence of trafficking was
produced.
8.
On 28.03.2017 the learned Special Judge framed a
singular substance of accusation as under:
“That you on 04.01.2017, at around 10:30 hours, Gyalshing
Bazar near the taxi stand, West Sikkim, were found in
possession of contraband substances i.e. 59 numbers of
loose Spasmoproxyvon Capsules, 29 numbers of loose
Nitrosun-10 tablets and one pouch of Ganja (Marijuana)
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
without any valid medical prescriptions/documents and you
thereby committed an offence punishable under Section 9(b)
and 14 of SADA, 2006 r/w Section 20(A) of Narcotic Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances, 1985 within the cognizance of
this Court.”
9.
The Appellant pleaded not guilty. The learned Special
Judge sent him to trial on the singular charge with two
indictments. The Learned Special Judge, in spite of the
accusation made in the charge-sheet, did not frame a charge
for consumption of controlled substance without valid
prescription against the Appellant.
10. On
11.08.2017
after
examining
witnesses
the
Appellant was questioned under Section 313 of the Code of
Criminal
Procedure,
(Cr.P.C.)
and
his
statement
recorded. The Appellant did not deny the seizures. He stated
that he did not know how the said articles got into his bag
which he had kept in the taxi stand while going to Gangtok.
He also stated that he was framed by the Informant.
11. No evidence was lead by the prosecution to establish
that the Appellant was a Government servant. Evidence of the
fact would have been relevant as Section 9(c) of SADA, 2006
as it existed dealt with contravention of the law by a
Government employee. It also provided a sentence of a fixed
term as against Section 9(b) of SADA, 2006 which did not
provide for a jail term.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
12. The learned Special Judge held the Appellant guilty of
possession of controlled substances. The Learned Special
Judge also held that the Appellant had consumed Spasmo
Proxyvon which was a controlled substance. The Learned
Special Judge thus held the Appellant guilty of commission of
the offences punishable under Section 9(b) and 14 of SADA,
2006.
The learned Special Judge also found the Appellant
guilty for possession of 1.94 gms of “ganja” as well and liable
under Section 20(A) of the NDPS Act, 1985.
13. However, the learned Special Judge held that the
Appellant had been found guilty of commission of offence
under Section 9(b) punishable under Section 14 of SADA,
2006. Accordingly, the Appellant was sentenced to undergo
simple imprisonment for a term of 6 months and to pay a fine
of Rs.10,000/- and in default to further undergo simple
imprisonment for two months under Section 14 of SADA,
2006. The Appellant was also sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a term of eight months and to pay a fine of
Rs.10,000/- and in default to further undergo simple
imprisonment for a term of two months under Section 20(A) of
NDPS Act, 1985. Both the sentences were directed to run
concurrently. It was ordered that the Appellant shall undergo
compulsorily detoxification and rehabilitation.
14. The Appellant preferred the present Criminal Appeal on
05.04.2018. On 06.04.2018 a delay of 57 days for preferring
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
the appeal was condoned by this Court and the appeal
admitted for hearing. The Appellant served eight months of
sentence and was released on 20.05.2018. This was during
the pendency of the present appeal.
The Arguments
15. Heard Mrs. Puja Lamichaney, learned Legal Aid Counsel
for the Appellant and Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, learned
Additional Public Prosecutor for the State-Respondent.
16. Mrs. Puja Lamichaney would assail the impugned
judgment and the order on sentence on several grounds. She
would submit that the prosecution had failed to establish the
charges beyond reasonable doubt. She would submit that the
charge as framed was erroneous as Section 218 Cr.P.C. would
require
separate
charges
for
distinct
offences.
It
was
submitted that the learned Special Judge had not even
framed a charge for consumption of controlled substance and
therefore the conviction was not called for. She would submit
that the mandatory provisions of Section 50 and 55 of the
NDPS Act, 1985 as well as Section 21, 24, 28 and 30 of
SADA, 2006 have not been complied with rendering the
alleged recovery of suspect. It was submitted that as required
under the mandatory provision of Section 21 of SADA, 2006
no information was taken in writing or given to the immediate
superior officer. It was submitted that the prosecution has
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
failed to prove the seizure as well as the fact that the said
seized item were controlled substances. She would submit
that there was no record of what transpired to the alleged
seized articles after it was handed over to the Investigating
Officer and whether the same seized articles were in fact
examined by the forensic laboratory. She would also submit
that there is no evidence brought forth by the prosecution to
prove that the said seized articles were kept in the
“malkhana” in safe custody. It was submitted that the
difference between the quantity of seized articles and what
was received at the forensic laboratory would reflect that the
said seized articles were tampered with. She would also
submit that Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) the Junior
Scientific Officer, RFSL Saramsa neither proved that she was
an expert nor proved that the purported forensic examination
report (exhibit-8) given by her was based on sound reasons to
persuade the Court to rely upon it.
17. Per contra Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal would submit
that the conviction of the Appellant was based on cogent
evidence. He would submit that Section 21 of SADA, 2006
was not applicable. He would also submit that Section 24 of
SADA, 2006 and Section 50 of NDPS Act, 1985 was complied
with. He would rely upon the depositions of Bharani Kumaar
(P.W.1), Zangpo Sherpa (P.W.4) and Namgyal Bhutia (P.W.5)
and Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) to show compliance thereof.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
In support of his submissions he would rely upon: State of
Rajasthan v. Ram Chandra1 and Khet Singh v. Union of India2.
18. Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal would rely upon the
deposition of Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) and Naresh Chettri
(P.W.9) to show compliance of Section 28 of SADA, 2006. He
would refer to the judgment of the Supreme Court in re: Dehal
Singh v. State of H.P3 and submit that small discrepancies in
the quantity should be ignored. This was to meet the
argument of the Appellant about the discrepancies in the
number of capsules and tablets seized and examined
forensically. He would insist that Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia
(P.W.8) was in fact an expert which is evident from the fact
that she was a junior scientific officer of a forensic science
laboratory. He would also submit that although a composite
charge
had
been
framed
for
possession
of
controlled
substances and the charge as framed during trial was clear
and there was no confusion on the mind of the Appellant
about it. To augment his submission he would rely upon:
Abdul Sayeed v. State of M.P.4; Rafiq Ahmad v. State of U.P.5; Gian
Chand v. State of Haryana6.
19. Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal would also submit that the
Appellant was also not confused that he had been indicted for
(2005) 5 SCC 151
(2002) 4 SCC 380
(2010) 9 SCC 85
(2010) 10 SCC 259
(2011) 8 SCC 300
(2013) 14 SCC 420
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
consumption of controlled substances. He would thus submit
that neither the composite framing of charge for the offences
under Section 9 (b) and Section 14 of SADA, 2006 and
Section 20(A) of NDPS Act, 1985 nor the failure to frame a
charge for consumption of controlled substances would have
prejudiced the Appellant. He would submit that in such
circumstances the Appellant’s failure to show prejudice would
protect the trial and it would not be vitiated.
CONSIDERATION
Section 9(b) and Section 14 of SADA, 2006 provides
punishment for different offences.
20. The learned Special Judges’ finding that the offence
under Section 9(b) of SADA, 2006 is punishable under
Section 14 of SADA, 2006 is incorrect. Both Section 9(b) and
Section 14 of SADA, 2006 comes under Chapter IV under the
head “Offences and Penalties”. Contravention of any provision
of SADA, 2006 or the rules or order thereunder which
involves use or consumption of controlled substances without
valid medical prescription is punishable under 9(b) of SADA,
2006. Section 14 of SADA, 2006 is a residuary provision
which provides punishment for contraventions for which no
punishment is separately provided. The two provisions seek
to deal with two different situations.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Investigation must not only be fair but also on the face of
it appear to be so.
21. In spite of receipt of the credible source information no
FIR was registered or General Diary (GD) entry made. The FIR
is numbered 01/2017. The seizure memo (exhibit 2) however
records the number as FIR No./GD entry No.16/2017 and
not FIR No.1/2017. No explanation is forthcoming. This
anomaly remains unexplained. If it was a GD entry number
the GD entry has not been proved. Otherwise it reflects a
discrepancy of two FIRs’.
22. In re: Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab7 the Supreme Court,
while examining a criminal prosecution under the NDPS Act,
1985, would hold that in criminal prosecution there is an
obligation cast on the investigator not only to be fair,
judicious and just but also that the investigation on the very
face of it must appear to be so. The Supreme Court would
hold that if informant Police Officer in cases carrying a
reverse burden of proof makes the allegation and is himself
asked to investigate, serious doubt would arise with regard to
his fairness and impartiality and in such cases it is not
necessary that bias must actually be proved. In view of
conflicting opinions, the larger bench of the Supreme Court
would lay down that a fair investigation, which is but the very
foundation of fair trial, necessarily postulates that the
2018 SCC OnLine SC 974
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
informant and the investigator must not be the same person.
Justice must not only be done, but must appear to be done
also. Any possibility of bias or a predetermined conclusion
has to be excluded. This requirement is all the more
imperative in laws carrying a reverse burden of proof.
23. The prosecution evidence reflects that the Mahindra
Pradhan (P.W.6) had apprehended the Appellant. He had
called the Sub-Divisional Magistrate to carry out the search
and seizure in his presence. He had also called witnesses for
the search and seizure. He had searched the Appellant and
seized the alleged “ganja” and controlled substances. He had
packed and sealed the seized items. He had sent the
Appellant for medical examination and had his urine sample
collected. Thereafter he had headed back to the Police Station
and lodged the FIR as the first informant. As the Officer incharge of the Gyalshing Police Station he had also endorsed
the case for investigation to Naresh Chettri (P.W.9). He had
therefore,
substantially
investigated
the
case.
In
the
circumstances it is evident that the investigation had not
been fair. The prosecution was under the NDPS Act, 1985 and
SADA, 2006. Both the Acts carry a reverse burden of proof.
The evidence of search and seizure.
24. Bharani Kumaar (P.W.1) the Sub-Divisional Magistrate
deposed that he was on duty on 04.01.2017. He was
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
requested by Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) to be present as the
Appellant was suspected to be in possession of contraband
substances and his presence was required as per SADA,
2006. On reaching the taxi stand, he found two witnesses
present. The notice (exhibit-1) was read out to the Appellant.
The Appellant consented to be searched in his presence and
signed the notice (exhibit-1). The Appellant was searched. The
police recovered the controlled substances and a small pouch
of “ganja”. In cross-examination Bharani Kumaar (P.W.1)
admitted that the consent of the Appellant had not been
recorded in the notice (exhibit-1). He also admitted that he
could not recollect the exact quantity of the controlled
substances recovered from the Appellant.
25. Lance Naik-Deo Prakash Pradhan (P.W.2) was posted at
the Gyalshing Police Station. On 04.01.2017 Mahindra
Pradhan (PW 6) telephoned and informed him that the
Appellant was suspected to be moving around Gyalshing
Bazar with contraband substances. He proceeded to the
market and began looking out for the Appellant. He saw the
Appellant near the taxi stand and so he followed him. As they
reached the main bazaar, Mahindra Pradhan (PW 6) and
other police personnel also arrived. The Appellant was
apprehended on the stairs of the main bazaar. Mahindra
Pradhan (PW 6) recovered 59 numbers of blue SP capsules,
29 N-10 tablets and a small pouch “ganja” from the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Appellant. He would admit, in cross-examination, that the
search was not conducted at the Gyalshing taxi stand.
26. Constable-Dipesh
Subba
(P.W.3)
deposed
that
on
04.01.2017 Deo Prakash Pradhan (P.W.2) informed him that
one person was roaming within the Gyalshing bazaar with
contraband substances. Bharani Kumaar (PW 1), Mahindra
Pradhan (PW 6), Deo Prakash Pradhan (P.W.2) along with him
searched the body of the said suspect and recovered
the
controlled substances and one pouch of “ganja” from him. He
admitted that he had not mentioned whether the seized
articles were recovered from any bag or the pocket of the
Appellant.
27. Zangpo Sherpa (P.W.4) deposed that on 04.01.2017 he
was present with Namgyal Bhutia (P.W.5) when the police
recovered small amount of “ganja”, 59 blue capsules and 29
white tablets from the Appellant near the Gyalshing taxi
stand. He identified his signature on the notice (exhibit-1). He
had signed it on the request of the police.
In cross-
examination he admitted that he did not know the contents of
the notice (exhibit-1).
28. Namgyal Bhutia (P.W.5) deposed that on 04.01.2017
Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) telephonically called him to
Gyalshing taxi stand. He was told that he was apprehending
one suspect with contraband substances. He went to
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Gyalshing taxi stand where the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Zangpo Sherpa (P.W.4) and the Police Inspector were already
present. The Police Inspector asked the Appellant whether he
wanted his body searched before the Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate. The Appellant consented to be searched before the
Magistrate. The Police Inspector conducted the body search of
the Appellant. They recovered 59 numbers of blue capsules
(S.P.), 29 numbers of white tablets (N-10) and one pouch of
“Ganja” from the bag of the Appellant and seized them.
Safeguards provided under the NDPS Act, 1985 must be
observed strictly.
29. The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court in re:
Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja v. State of Gujarat8 would hold that
in order to prevent abuse of the provisions of the NDPS Act,
which confer wide powers on the empowered officers, the
safeguards provided by the legislature have to be observed
strictly.
Procedure for search and seizure under Section 21 and 22
of SADA, 2006.
30. Section 22 of SADA, 2006 is analogues to Section 43 of
the NDPS Act, 1985. They provide:
THE NARCOTIC DRUGS PSYCHOTROPIC
SUBSTANCE ACT, 1985
SIKKIM ANTI DRUG ACT, 2006
Section 43. Power of seizure and arrest
in public place.—Any officer of any of the
departments mentioned in Section 42
Section 22. Power of seizure and
arrest in public place.— Any officer
of any of the departments mentioned
(2011) 1 SCC 609
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
may—
in Section 21 may—
(a) seize in any public place or in transit,
any
narcotic
drug
or
psychotropic
substance or controlled substance in
respect of which he has reason to believe
an offence punishable under this Act has
been committed, and, along with such drug
or substance, any animal or conveyance or
article liable to confiscation under this Act,
any document or other article which he
has reason to believe may furnish evidence
of the commission of an offence punishable
under this Act or any document or other
article which may furnish evidence of
holding any illegally acquired property
which is liable for seizure or freezing or
forfeiture under Chapter V-A of this Act;
(a) seize in any public place or in
transit, any controlled substance in
respect of which he has reason to
believe an offence punishable under
this Act has been committed, and,
along with such drug or substance,
any animal or conveyance or article
liable to confiscation under this Act,
any document or other article which
he has reason to believe an offence
punishable under this Act has been
committed, and, along with such drug
or
substance,
any
animal
or
conveyance or article liable to
confiscation under this Act, any
document or other article which he
has reason to believe may furnish
evidence of the commission of an
offence punishable under this Act;
(b) detain and search any person whom he
has reason to believe to have committed an
offence punishable under this Act, and if
such person has any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance or controlled
substance in his possession and such
possession appears to him to be unlawful,
arrest him and any other person in his
company.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this
section, the expression “public place”
includes any public conveyance, hotel,
shop, or other place intended for use by, or
accessible to, the public.
(b) detain and search any person
whom he has, reason to believe to
have committed an offence punishable
under this Act, and if such person has
any controlled substance in his
possession and such possession
appease (sic appears) to him to be
unlawful, arrest him and any other
person in his company.
Explanation: For the purposes of this
section, the expression “public place”
includes any public conveyance, hotel,
shop, or other place intended for use
by, or accessible to, the public.
31. Section 21 of SADA, 2006 provides the power and
procedure for entry, search and seizure of any building,
conveyance or place. As the search and seizure was affected
in a public place i.e. Gyalshing bazaar Section 22 would apply
rather than Section 21. Section 22 empowers the authorised
officer to detain the suspect, search and seize on his reason
to believe that an offence punishable under SADA, 2006 has
been committed in any public place. If the suspect is in
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
possession of controlled substance which is unlawful, the
authorised officer can also arrest him or any other person in
his company. Section 22 does not mandate a search warrant
or authorisation. It does not also require recording of the
grounds for his belief that if he does not act in haste, enter,
seize and arrest the suspect would have concealed the
evidence or escaped. Section 22 does not require the
authorised officer to forward the written grounds of his belief
to his immediate superior within seventy-two hours. All the
aforesaid are requirements under Section 21. Section 22 of
SADA, 2006 is analogues to Section 43 of the NDPS Act,
1985.
As
such
the
submission
made
by
Mrs.
Puja
Lamichaney of non-compliance of Section 21 must be
rejected.
Report of arrest and seizure under Section 57 of NDPS
Act, 1985 and Section 30 of SADA, 2006.
32. Section 30 of SADA, 2006 provides that whenever any
person makes any arrest or seizure he “shall” within fortyeight hours of the arrest and seizure, make a full report of all
the particulars of such arrest or seizure to his immediate
superior. Section 30 of SADA, 2006 and Section 57 of NDPS
Act, 1985 are identically worded. They provide:
THE
NARCOTIC
DRUGS
PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCE ACT,
SIKKIM ANTI DRUG ACT, 2006
Section 57. Report of arrest and
seizure.- Whenever any person makes
any arrest or seizure, under this Act, he
Section 30. Report of arrest and
seizure.- Whenever any person makes
any arrest or seizure under this Act, he
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
shall, within forty-eight hours next after
such arrest or seizure, make a full report
of all the particulars of such arrest or
seizure to his immediate official superior.
shall, within forty-eight hours of the
arrest or seizure, make a full report of all
the particulars of such arrest or seizure
to his immediate superior official.
33. The Arrest memo (exhibit 10) dated 04.01.2016 records
the time of arrest as 1230 hours. Naresh Chettri (P.W.9)
deposed that the Appellant was thoroughly interrogated and
arrested after which the arrest memo (exhibit-10) was signed
by him. He deposed that intimation was given to the
Superintendent of Police as per the provisions of Section 30 of
SADA, 2006. He exhibited the intimation letter (exhibit-11).
The
intimation
letter
(exhibit-11)
dated
06.01.2017
is
addressed to the Superintendent of Police. As required by
Section 30 of SADA, 2006 it makes a report of the particulars
of the arrest. Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) has thus complied with
Section 30 of SADA, 2006 by informing his superior-the
Superintendent of Police-about the arrest.
34. The prosecution has sought to prove the seizure through
property seizure memo (exhibit-2). The said memo is dated
04.01.2017 and records the time of seizure as 1130 hours.
The seizure was admittedly done by Mahindra Pradhan
(P.W.6). He did not depose about intimating his immediate
superior official about the seizure. There is also no document
which reflects that he had done so. Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) in
the intimation letter (exhibit-11) has stated about the seizure
of the alleged controlled substances and “ganja” from the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
possession of the Appellant. There is no evidence that Naresh
Chettri (P.W.9) was present at the time of seizure. The
contents of the intimation letter (exhibit-11) and the evidence
of Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) regarding the search would only be
hearsay. Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) has failed to comply with
the provisions of Section 30 of SADA, 2006.
35. Section 30 of SADA, 2006 is in pari materia with Section
57 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
36. In re: State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh9 the Supreme Court
would hold that the provision of Section 57 which deal with
the steps to be taken by the officers after making arrest or
seizure under Sections 41 to 44 is by itself not mandatory
and if there is non-compliance or if there are lapses like delay
etc. then the same has to be examined to see whether any
prejudice has been caused to the accused and such failure
will have a bearing on the appreciation of evidence regarding
arrest or seizure as well as on merits of the case. Thus it is
essential to examine the case and see whether any prejudice
was caused to the Appellant. The prosecution case cannot be
thrown out on the failure of the prosecution to comply with
the provisions of Section 57 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and
Section 30 of SADA, 2006 alone. The learned Special Judge
has not examined the compliance of the said provisions.
(1994) 3 SCC 299
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Compliance of Section 50 of NDPS Act, 1985 and Section
24 of SADA, 2006.
37. In re: Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab10 the Supreme
Court would have occasioned to examine the ambit and scope
of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985. It would hold that
Section 50 would not be applicable if recovery was made from
bag and not from the body of a suspect. Section 50 of the
NDPS Act, 1985 can be invoked only in cases where the
drug/narcotic/NDPS
substance
is
recovered
as
a
consequence of the body search of the accused.
38. The prosecution’s evidence regarding the recovery of the
“ganja” and controlled substances is not clear as to whether
the same were recovered from the body or the bag. Only
Namgyal Bhutia (P.W.5) deposed that the said articles were
recovered from the bag of the Appellant. Bharani Kumaar
(P.W.1) did not specify the details. Deo Prakash Pradhan
(P.W.2) stated that the articles were seized. No further details
were given. Dipesh Subba (P.W.3) deposed that the articles
were seized from the body of the Appellant. Zangpo Sherpa
(P.W.4) stated that the articles were recovered from the
Appellant. All of them are prosecution witnesses. Even the
property seizure memo (exhibit-2) does not reflect that the
controlled substances and “ganja” was seized from the bag.
The prosecution had however, on its own thought it fit to
(2011) 3 SCC 521
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
issue a notice under Section 24 of SADA, 2006. Therefore,
this Court shall consider compliance of Section 24 of SADA,
2006. As the conviction of the Appellant is also under Section
20 of NDPS Act, 1985 it is necessary to consider compliance
of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 as well.
39. Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 24 of the
SADA, 2006 are reproduced below:
THE
NARCOTIC
DRUGS
PSYCHOTROPIC
SUBSTANCE
ACT,
SIKKIM ANTI DRUG ACT, 2006
Section 50. Conditions under which
search of persons shall be conducted.-
Section 24. Conditions under which
search of persons shall be conducted.—
(1) When any officer duly
authorised
under section 42 is about to search any
person under the provisions of section 41,
section 42 or section 43, he shall, if such
person so requires, take such person
without unnecessary delay to the nearest
Gazetted Officer of any of the departments
mentioned in section 42 or to the nearest
Magistrate.
(1) When any officer duly authorized
under Section 21 is about to search any
person under the provisions of Section 20,
Section 21 or Section 22, he shall, if
possible, take such person to the nearest
gazetted officer of any of the departments
mentioned in Section 21 or to the nearest
Magistrate.
(2) If such requisition is made, the officer
may detain the person until he can bring
him before the gazetted officer or the
Magistrate referred to in sub-section (1).
(3) The gazetted officer or the Magistrate
before whom any such person is brought
shall, if he sees no reasonable ground for
search, forthwith discharge the person
but otherwise shall direct that search be
made.
(4) No female shall be searched by anyone
excepting a female.
(5) When an officer duly authorised under
Section 42 has reason to believe that it is
not possible to take the person to be
searched to the nearest Gazetted Officer
or Magistrate without the possibility of the
person to be searched parting with
possession of any narcotic drug or
psychotropic substance, or controlled
substance or article or document, he may,
instead of taking such person to the
nearest Gazetted Officer or Magistrate,
proceed to search the person as provided
(2) When an officer duly authorized under
Section 19 has reason to believe that it is
not possible to take the person to be
searched to the nearest gazetted officer or
Magistrate without the possibility of the
person to be searched parting with
possession of any controlled substance or
article or document, he may, instead of
taking such person to the nearest
gazetted officer or Magistrate, proceed to
search the person as provided under
Section 100 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973.
(3) After a search is conducted under subsection (2), the officer shall record the
reasons for such belief which necessitated
such search and within seventy-two
hours send a copy thereof to his
immediate official superior.
(4) No female shall be searched by anyone
except female or in presence of a female.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
under Section 100 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974).
(6) After a search is conducted under subsection (5), the officer shall record the
reasons for such belief which necessitated
such search and within seventy-two
hours send a copy thereof to his
immediate official superior.
40. The ingredients of Section 24 of SADA, 2006 are:
(i)
The officer conducting the search must be an
authorised officer under Section 21.
(ii)
When such authorised officer is about to search
any person he shall, “if possible” take him to the
nearest gazetted officer of any of the Department
mentioned in Section 21 or to the nearest
Magistrate.
(iii)
When such authorised officer “has reason to
believe” that it is not possible to take the person
to be searched to the nearest Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate “without the possibility of the person to
be searched partying with possession of any
controlled substance or article or document” he
may, instead, proceed to search as provided
under Section 100 Cr.P.C. In such circumstances
it is incumbent upon the authorised officer to
record the reasons for such belief within 72 hours
and send a copy of the same to his immediate
Superior.
(iv)
A female must be searched either by a female or
in the presence of a female.
41. The ingredients of
are:
Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
(i)
The officer conducting the search must be an
authorised officer under Section 42 of the NDPS
Act, 1985.
(ii)
When such authorised officer is about to search
any person he shall, “if such persons so requires”
take such person without any unnecessary delay
to the nearest Gazetted Officer of any of the
departments mention in Section 42 or to the
nearest Magistrate.
(iii)
When such a requisition is made the authorised
officer has the power to detain the said person
until he can bring him before the Gazetted Officer
or the Magistrate.
(iv)
The Gazetted Officer or the Magistrate before
whom such a person is brought “if he sees no
reasonable ground for search”; has has the power
to forthwith discharge the person or otherwise
direct the search be made.
(v)
No female shall be searched by anyone except a
female.
(vi)
The authorised officer, if he has reason to believe
that it is not possible to take the person to be
searched to the nearest Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate without the possibility of the person to
be searched partying with possession of any
narcotic drug or psychotropic substance, or
controlled substance or article or document, he
may, instead of taking such person to the nearest
Gazetted Officer or Magistrate, proceed to search
the person as provided under Section 100 Cr.P.C.
(vii) If the authorised officers proceeds to search as
provided under Section 100 Cr.P.C then. In that
case the said authorised officer must record the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
reasons for such belief and within 72 hours sent
a copy thereof to his immediate official superior.
42. Section 24 of SADA, 2006 and Section 50 of the NDPS
Act, 1985 deals with condition under which search of persons
shall be conducted. However, there is a slight difference.
43. Section 24 of SADA, 2006 mandates that before
searching any person the authorised officer, “if possible”, take
such person to the nearest Gazetted Officer of any of the
Departments mentioned in Section 21 or to the nearest
Magistrate. Therefore unless it is not possible the authorised
officer before searching any person must take such person to
the nearest Gazetted Officer or to the nearest Magistrate. If it
is not possible the authorised officer must record reasons in
writing and forward the same within 72 hours to his
immediate superior.
44.
Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 however, provides
that when any officer duly authorised is about to search any
person he shall, “if such person so requires” take such person
without unnecessary delay to the nearest Gazetted Officer of
any of the Departments mentioned in Section 42 or to the
nearest Magistrate. Thus, under Section 50 of the NDPS Act,
1985 option must be given to the person to be searched.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
45. In re: State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh11 the Supreme Court
would
hold
that
there
is
unanimity
of
judicial
pronouncements to the effect that it is an obligation of the
empowered officer and his duty before conducting the search
of the person of a suspect, on the basis of prior information,
to inform the suspect that he has the right to require his
search being conducted in the presence of a Gazetted Officer
or a Magistrate. The failure to so inform the suspect of his
right would render the search illegal because the suspect
would not be able to avail of the protection which is inbuilt in
Section 50. Similarly, if the person concerned requires, on
being so informed by the empowered officer or otherwise, that
his search be conducted in the presence of a Gazetted Officer
or a Magistrate, the empowered officer is obliged to do so and
failure on his part to do so would also render the search
illegal and the conviction and sentence of the accused bad.
The Supreme Court would further hold that the right of the
accused to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate, if the suspect so requires, is extremely valuable.
This has been given to the person concerned having regard to
the grave consequences that may entail the possession of
illicit articles under the NDPS Act. It was held that the search
before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate would impart much
more authenticity and creditworthiness to the search and
(1999) 6 SCC 172
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
seizure proceeding. It is, therefore, necessary that the
safeguards provided in Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 are
observed scrupulously. The failure to conduct the search of
the suspect before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate would
render the recovery of the illicit articles suspect and vitiate
the conviction and sentence.
46. In re: Beckodan Abdul Rahiman v. State of Kerala12 the
Supreme Court would come to the finding that there has been
a violation of the mandatory provisions of Section 42 and 50
of the NDPS Act, 1985 rendering the case as not established
and therefore the Appellant’s therein entitled to an acquittal.
47. In re: Vijaysinh Chandubha Jadeja (supra) the Supreme
Court would hold that the object of Section 50 of the NDPS
Act, 1985 is to check the misuse of power, to avoid harm to
innocent persons and to minimise the allegations of planting
or foisting of false cases by the law enforcement agencies. The
Supreme Court would hold that the mandate of Section 50 is
precise and clear viz. If the person intended to be searched
expresses to the authorised officer his desire to be taken to
the nearest gazetted officer or the Magistrate, “he cannot be
searched till the gazetted officer or the Magistrate, as the case
may be, directs the authorised officer to do so.” The Supreme
Court would then hold:
(2002) 4 SCC 229
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
“24. Although the Constitution Bench in Baldev Singh case [(1999)
6 SCC 172 : 1999 SCC (Cri) 1080] did not decide in absolute terms
the question whether or not Section 50 of the NDPS Act was
directory or mandatory yet it was held that provisions of subsection (1) of Section 50 make it imperative for the empowered
officer to “inform” the person concerned (suspect) about the
existence of his right that if he so requires, he shall be searched
before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate; failure to “inform” the
suspect about the existence of his said right would cause prejudice
to him, and in case he so opts, failure to conduct his search before
a gazetted officer or a Magistrate, may not vitiate the trial but
would render the recovery of the illicit article suspect and vitiate the
conviction and sentence of an accused, where the conviction has
been recorded only on the basis of the possession of the illicit
article, recovered from the person during a search conducted in
violation of the provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act. The Court
also noted that it was not necessary that the information required
to be given under Section 50 should be in a prescribed form or in
writing but it was mandatory that the suspect was made aware of
the existence of his right to be searched before a gazetted officer or
a Magistrate, if so required by him. We respectfully concur with
these conclusions. Any other interpretation of the provision would
make the valuable right conferred on the suspect illusory and a
farce.”
48. In re: Saiyad Mohd. Saiyad Umar Saiyad & Ors. v. State of
Gujarat13 the Supreme Court would endorse the finding in re:
State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh14 that the provisions of Section
50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 is mandatory it would hold that the
language thereof obliges the officer concerned to inform the
person to be search of his right to demand that the search be
conducted in the presence of a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate. The Supreme Court would further hold that
(1995) 3 SCC 610
(1994) 3 SCC 299
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
having regard to the object for which the provisions of Section
50 had been introduced into the NDPS Act, 1985 there is no
room
for
drawing
a
presumption
under
Section
114,
illustration (e) of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 because the
possession of illicit articles under the NDPS Act, 1985 has to
be satisfactorily established before the Court. The fact of
seizure after a search has to be proved. When evidence of
search is given all that transpired in its connection must also
be stated. The Supreme Court would hold:
“7. ........... Very relevant in this behalf is the testimony of the officer
conducting the search that he had informed the person to be
searched that he was entitled to demand that the search be carried
out in the presence of a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate and that
the person had not chosen to so demand. If no evidence to this
effect is given the court must assume that the person to be
searched was not informed of the protection the law gave him and
must find that the possession of illicit articles under the NDPS Act
was not established.
8. We are unable to share the High Court's view that in cases
under the NDPS Act it is the duty of the court to raise a
presumption, when the officer concerned has not deposed that he
had followed the procedure mandated by Section 50, that he had in
fact done so. When the officer concerned has not deposed that he
had followed the procedure mandated by Section 50, the court is
duty-bound to conclude that the accused had not had the benefit of
the protection that Section 50 affords; that, therefore, his
possession of articles which are illicit under the NDPS Act is not
established; that the precondition for his having satisfactorily
accounted for such possession has not been met; and to acquit the
accused.
9. The High Court relied upon the fact that the argument that
Section 50 had not been complied with had not been made before
the trial court and held that a point of fact could not be taken for the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
first time in appeal. The protection that Section 50 gives to those
accused of being in possession of illicit articles under the NDPS Act
is sacrosanct and cannot be disregarded on the technicality that
the point was not taken in the court of first instance.
10. Finding a person to be in possession of articles which are illicit
under the provisions of the NDPS Act has, as we have said, the
consequence of requiring him to prove that he was not in
contravention of its provisions and it renders him liable to
punishment which can extend to 20 years' rigorous imprisonment
and a fine of Rupees two lakhs or more. It is necessary, therefore,
that courts dealing with offences under the NDPS Act should be
very careful to see that it is established to their satisfaction that the
accused has been informed by the officer concerned that he had a
right to choose to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or a
Magistrate. It need hardly be emphasised that the accused must be
made aware of this right or protection granted by the statute and
unless cogent evidence is produced to show that he was made
aware of such right or protection, there would be no question of
presuming that the requirements of Section 50 were complied with.
Instructions in this behalf need to be issued so that investigation
officers take care to comply with the statutory requirement and
drug-pedlars do not go scot-free due to non-compliance thereof.
Such instructions would be of great value in the effort to curb drug
trafficking. At the same time, those accused of possessing drugs
should, however heinous their offence may appear to be, have the
safeguard that the law prescribes.”
[emphasis supplied]
49. In re: State of Rajasthan v. Ram Chandra15 the Supreme
Court would reiterate the essence of Section 50 of the NDPS
Act, 1985 referring to its judgment in re: Raghbir Singh v. State
of Haryana16 it would hold that the option given to the accused
is only to choose whether he would like to be searched by the
officer making the search or in the presence of the nearest
(2005) 5 SCC 151
(1996) 2 SCC 201
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
available Gazetted Officer or the nearest available Magistrate.
The choice of the nearest Gazetted Officer or the nearest
Magistrate has to be exercised by the officer making the
search and not by the accused.
50. Under Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 24
of the SADA, 2006 there is no requirement for serving a
notice.
51. Even before the Appellant was apprehended Mahindra
Pradhan (P.W.6) had telephonically called Bharani Kumaar
(P.W.1) the Sub-Divisional Magistrate who accompanied the
police team and apprehend the Appellant. The notice marked
(exhibit-1) was thereafter read out to the Appellant. The
Appellant consented to be searched in his presence. Bharani
Kumaar (P.W.1) therefore was made a part of the search team
of Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6)-the Station Housing Officer who
apprehended the Appellant at the Gyalshing bazaar. The
requirement under Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 as well
as Section 24 of the SADA, 2006 is to provide an opportunity
as a right of the accused to be searched in the presence of a
neutral Magistrate or a Gazetted Officer. In fact he cannot be
searched till the gazetted officer or the Magistrate, as the case
may be, directs the authorised officer to do so. Bharani
Kumaar (P.W.1) who accompanied Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6)
would depose nothing about granting permission authorising
the Police Officer to conduct the search. Notice (exhibit-1)
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
admittedly does not reflect the exercise of the option by the
Appellant even though it records in writing that the Appellant
was asked whether in exercise of his legal right he required
the presence of any Magistrate or Gazetted Officer during the
search. All that was obtained was the Appellant’s purported
signature on it. Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 requires
that the said option must be given to the suspect. Even before
the said option was exercised by the Appellant Bharani
Kumaar (P.W.1) was brought in front of the Appellant. Dipesh
Subba (P.W.3) the Constable who was part of the Police team
deposed that the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, the Station
House Officer and Deo Prakash Pradhan (P.W.2) searched the
body of the Appellant and recovered the seized articles. The
evidence
of
prosecution.
Dipesh
Subba
(P.W.3)
is
binding on
the
Zangpo Sherpa (P.W.4) would depose nothing
about the option being given to the Appellant. In fact he
would also not depose about the signing of the said notice
(exhibit-1) by the Appellant. Although the other witness to the
notice (exhibit-1) Namgyal Bhutia (P.W.5) did depose that the
Appellant was asked by the Police Inspector and he gave his
consent he also did not identify the Appellant’s signature in
the notice (exhibit-1).
52. The option to be given under the NDPS Act, 1985 must
be meaningful and not an empty formality.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
53. Under Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 24
of SADA, 2006 the Gazetted Officer or the Magistrate before
whom the accused is produced must be neutral, appear to be
neutral and the act of conducting the search must be
meaningful and not an empty formality.
54. In the situation as described with the presence of SubDivisional Magistrate, Station House Officer and other Police
Officers even the assertion by Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) of
signing of a previously prepared notice (exhibit-1) by the
Appellant under Section 24 (1) of SADA, 2006 may not satisfy
the Court that the requirement of the provisions of Section 50
of the NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 24 of the SADA, 2006 in
its essence and spirit had been complied with contrary to
what has been held by the learned Special Judge. This
situation is more aggravated by the fact that the Mahindra
Pradhan (PW 6) who conducted the investigation partially was
also the informant. It is vital to draw a distinction of a case in
which search was conducted on the basis of prior information
and
search
conducted
on
a
chance
recovery.
The
prosecution’s case is that of prior information and not of
chance recovery and therefore strict compliance of the
aforesaid provision was required.
Keeping the seized articles in safe custody - Compliance
of Section 55 of NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 28 of SADA,
2006.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
55. Both the NDPS Act, 1985 and the SADA, 2006 mandates
a strict compliance of the procedure. On the seizure of the
narcotic drug or controlled substances certain precautions
are absolutely necessary to ensure that no false implication is
made.
The learned Special Judge did not examine the
compliance of the mandate of Section 55 of NDPS Act, 1985
or Section 28 of SADA, 2006.
56. Section 28 of SADA, 2006 deals with safe custody of
seized articles. The said section is almost identical to Section
55 of the NDPS Act, 1985. The said provisions provide:
THE
NARCOTIC
DRUGS
PSYCHOTROPIC
SUBSTANCE
ACT,
SIKKIM ANTI DRUG ACT, 2006
Section 55. Police to take charge of
articles seized and delivered.—An
officer-in-charge of a police station shall
take charge of and keep in safe custody,
pending the orders of the Magistrate, all
articles seized under this Act within the
local area of that police station and which
may be delivered to him, and shall allow
any officer who may accompany such
articles to the police station or who may
be deputed for the purpose, to affix his
seal to such articles or to take samples of
and from them and all samples so taken
shall also be sealed with a seal of the
officer-in-charge of the police station.
Section 28. Police to take charge of
articles seized and delivered.— An
officer-in-charge of a police station shall
take charge of and keep in safe custody,
pending the orders of the Magistrate, all
articles seized under this Act within the
local area of that police station and which
may be delivered to him.
57. Both under Section 28 of SADA, 2006 and Section 55 of
the NDPS Act, 1985 an Officer In-charge of the Police Station
“shall” take charge of and “keep in safe custody” pending the
orders of the Magistrate, all articles seized under the said
Acts within the local area of that Police station and which
may be delivered to him. In addition under Section 55 of the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
NDPS Act, 1985 the officer-in-charge of the Police Station
taking charge and keeping in safe custody the articles seized
shall allow any officer who may accompany such articles to
the police station or who may be deputed for the purpose, to
affix his seal to such articles or to take samples of and from
them and all samples so taken shall also be sealed with a seal
of the officer-in-charge of the police station. Both provisions
are to be strictly complied with.
58. In re: Mohan Lal v. The State of Punjab17 the Supreme
Court would have been occasion to examine the provision of
Section 55 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and hold that a plain
reading of the provision makes it manifest that it is the duty
of the police officer to deposit the seized material in the police
station “malkhana”.
59. Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) the Investigating Officer as per
his deposition was posted at the Gyalshing Police Station as a
sub-Inspector. He was not therefore, Officer In-charge of the
Gyalshing Police Station. Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) as per
his deposition was the Station House Officer and therefore the
Officer In-charge of the Gyalshing Police Station. Mahindra
Pradhan (P.W.6) who as Officer In-charge of the Police Station
ought to have kept the alleged seized items in safe custody as
required by both the enactments however, handed over the
same to Naresh Chettri (P.W.9). The evidence that even
2018 SCC OnLine SC 974
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) kept the seized item in safe custody is
lacking. There is no evidence put forth by the prosecution as
to what transpired with the seized articles after it was seized
on 04.01.2017 till it was sent for forensic examination on
17.01.2017. The fact that the forensic examination report
(exhibit 8) records receipt of lesser number of the alleged
controlled substances makes it further doubtful as to whether
the sized articles were actually kept in safe custody. If the
seized articles had infact been seized, packed and sealed by
Mahindra Pradhan (PW 6) and kept in safe custody then there
was no reason for shortage of the seized articles. Prosecution
witnesses have not deposed that the seized articles were
secured at the “malkhana” of the Police Station.
There is
non-compliance of the mandate of Section 28 of SADA, 2006
as well as Section 55 of NDPS Act, 1985.
60. The submission of the prosecution that the defence had
not raised the objection of the failure of the prosecution to
prove the mandatory provisions of search, seizure and safe
custody of the seized articles under the NDPS Act, 1985 and
SADA, 2006 during trial and was thus precluded from raising
them at the Appellate stage cannot be accepted. Firstly, the
impugned judgment itself records that the learned Special
Judge would examine whether the recovery and seizure were
done in accordance with the mandatory provisions of the two
enactments and goes on to examine the compliance of Section
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
50 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and Section 24 of SADA, 2006.
Secondly when the said enactments provide for reverse
burden of proof it is imperative that the prosecution establish
with cogent evidence the compliance of the mandatory
provisions. Further when the NDPS Act, 1985 and SADA,
2006 requires certain things to be done in a particular
manner it must also be shown that it was done in the said
manner. Failure to do so would lead to the conclusion that
the seized articles were not kept in safe custody.
Possession of “Ganja” in contravention of the laws.
61. Section 2(iii) of NDPS Act, 1985 defines “cannabis
(hemp)”. It provides:
“2. Definitions.—In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,(iii) ““cannabis (hemp)” means-—
(a)
charas, that is, the separated resin, in whatever form,
whether crude or purified, obtained from the cannabis
plant and also includes concentrated preparation and
resin known as hashish oil or liquid hashish;
(b)
ganja, that is, the flowering or fruiting tops of the
cannabis plant (excluding the seeds and leaves when not
accompanied by the tops), by whatever name they may
be known or designated; and
(c)
any mixture, with or without any neutral material, of any
of the above forms of cannabis or any drink prepared
therefrom;”
62. Section 2(xiv) of NDPS Act, 1985 defines “narcotic drug”. It
provides:
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
“(xiv) “narcotic drug” means coca leaf, cannabis (hemp), opium,
poppy straw and includes all manufactured goods;”
63. Section 2(xxiii) of NDPS Act, 1985 defines “psychotropic
substance”. It provides:
“(xxiii) “psychotropic substance” means any substance, natural
or synthetic, or any natural material or any salt or preparation of
such substance or material included in the list of psychotropic
substances specified in the Schedule;”
64.
The Appellant was convicted under Section 20(A) of the
NDPS Act, 1985. Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985 provide:
“20. Punishment for contravention in relation to cannabis
plant and cannabis.-Whoever, in contravention of any
provisions of this Act or any rule or order made or condition
of licence granted thereunder,(a) cultivates any cannabis plant; or
(b) produces,
manufactures,
possesses,
sells,
purchases,
transports, imports inter-State, exports inter-State or uses
cannabis,
shall be punishable,(i) where such contravention relates to clause (a) with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which may extend to ten years and
shall also be liable to fine which may extend to one lakh rupees;
and
(ii) where such contravention relates to clause (b),-—
(A) and involves small quantity, with rigorous imprisonment for a
term which may extend to six months, or with fine, which may
extend to ten thousand rupees, or with both;
(B) and involves quantity lesser than commercial quantity but
greater than small quantity, with rigorous imprisonment for a
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
term which may extend to ten years and with fine which may
extend to one lakh rupees;
(C) and involves commercial quantity, with rigorous imprisonment
for a term which shall not be less than ten years but which may
extend to twenty years and shall also be liable to fine which
shall not be less than one lakh rupees but which may extend to
two lakh rupees:
Provided that the court may, for reasons to be recorded in the
judgment, impose a fine exceeding two lakh rupees.]
65. Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985 deals with two
operations relating to cannabis plant and cannabis. These
two
operations
production,
are
cultivation
manufacture,
of
cannabis
possession,
sale,
plant
and
purchase,
transportation, inter-State imports, inter-State exports and
use of cannabis. Both these operations are made an offence if
it is in contravention of any provisions of the NDPS Act, 1985,
of any rule or order made or condition of license granted
thereunder.
66. The learned Special Judge has convicted the Appellant
under Section 20(A) of the NDPS Act, 1985. There is no such
provision. The learned Special Judge has also not stated
which provision of the NDPS Act, 1985 or rule or order made
or condition of license granted thereunder was contravened
by the Appellant.
67. The learned Special Judge had charged the Appellant for
possession of one pouch “ganja” without any valid medical
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
prescription/documents. Thus, the prosecution was required
to prove that the Appellant was guilty of violation of Section
20(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act, 1985 which prescribes punishment
for the “possession” of “ganja” in contravention of the
provisions of clause (b) of Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
The ingredient of Section 20(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act, 1985 is
possessing cannabis in contravention of any provisions of the
NDPS Act, 1985 or any rule or order made or conditions of
license granted.
68. The substance of accusation thus framed against the
Appellant under Section 20(A) of NDPS Act, 1985 lacked
clarity. Firstly, it was incumbent upon the learned Special
Judge to have framed a separate charge for the offence under
Section 20(b) (ii) (A) of the NDPS Act, 1985, separate from the
charges under the SADA, 2006. It was also incumbent upon
the learned Special Judge to have specified precisely the
contravention of any provision of the NDPS Act, 1985 or any
rule or any order made or condition of license granted by
possessing the “ganja”. Charge framing is a vital aspect of
criminal trial and the provisions of Sections 211 to 224
Cr.P.C. must be carefully complied with. Merely because
Section 464 CrPC exist in the statute book does not warrant
the trial court to frame a charge incorrectly. Clarity in framing
the charge has a dual purpose. A properly framed charge
would guide the trial to establish the ingredients of the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
offence. It would also assist the defence to understand the
charge correctly and lead their evidence.
69. Section 8 of the NDPS Act, 1985 provides:
“8. Prohibition of certain operations.-—No person shall(a) cultivate any coca plant or gather any portion of coca
plant; or
(b) cultivate the opium poppy or any cannabis plant; or
(c) produce, manufacture, possess, sell, purchase, transport,
warehouse, use, consume, import inter-State, export interState, import into India, export from India or tranship any
narcotic drug or psychotropic substance,
except for medical or scientific purposes and in the manner and to
the extent provided by the provisions of this Act or the rules or
orders made thereunder and in a case where any such provision,
imposes any requirement by way of licence, permit or authorisation
also in accordance with the terms and conditions of such licence,
permit or authorisation:
Provided that, and subject to the other provisions of this Act
and the rules made thereunder, the prohibition against the
cultivation of the cannabis plant for the production of ganja or the
production,
possession,
use,
consumption,
purchase,
sale,
transport, warehousing, import inter-State and export inter-State of
ganja for any purpose other than medical and scientific purpose
shall take effect only from the date which the Central Government
may, by notification in the Official Gazette, specify in this behalf:
Provided further that nothing in this section shall apply to the
export of poppy straw for decorative purposes.”
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
70. Notification
No.
12/89-OPIUM
dated
30-5-1989
published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, of even date
provides:
“In exercise of the powers conferred by the first proviso to
Section 8 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substance Act,
1986 (61 of 1986), the Central Government hereby specifies the
13th December 1989 as the date from which the prohibition against
the production, possession, use, consumption, purchase, sale,
transport, warehousing, import inter-State and export inter-State of
Ganja for any purpose other than medical and scientific purpose
shall take effect.”
71. Thus in view of the provision of Section 20(b) (ii) and
Section 8 of the NDPS Act, 1985 read with Notification No.
12/89-OPIUM dated 30-05-1989 issued by the Central
Government under Section 8 of the NDPS Act, 1985 the
possession of “ganja” for any purpose other than medical and
scientific purpose has been made an offence. Unlike the
charge framed against the Appellant for possession of one
pouch of “ganja” without medical prescription the charge
which was required to be framed and proved by the
prosecution was for possession of “ganja” for any purpose
other than medical and scientific purpose in contravention of
Section 8 of the NDPS Act, 1985 read with Notification
No.12/89-OPIUM dated 30.05.1989.
Vital to power the seized article was cannabis.
72. To secure a conviction under Section 20(b) (ii) of the
NDPS Act, 1985 it is also vital for the prosecution to prove
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
that the alleged substance seized was “cannabis (hemp)” i.e.
“ganja”, that is, the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis
plant (excluding the seeds and leaves when not accompanied
by the tops), by whatever name they may be known or
designated as defined under Section 2 (iii) (b) of the NDPS Act,
1985.
73. The learned Special Judge would rely upon the evidence
of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) the Junior Scientific
Officer of RFSL Saramsa, Ranipool and her report (exhibit-8)
to hold that the seized pouch of “ganja” was in fact cannabis.
In the description of exhibits received in the forensic
examination report it is recorded that one sealed cloth
covered box containing “3. a paper packed containing a plastic
pouch containing brown dried plant material, weighing 1.94
gms, marked as exhibit (C)-marked here as exhibit number
Chem-781 (C)”
was
also
received.
The
said
forensic
examination report (exhibit-8) records that the articles were
examined
by
chemical
analysis
using
Colour
Test,
Spectrophotometric and Chromatographic techniques and
based on this examination “the exhibit number Chem-781(C)
gave positive test for Cannabis (Ganja), which is a psychotropic
substance.”
74. Section 2 (xxiii) of
the
NDPS
Act,
defines
“psychotropic substance” to mean any substance, natural or
synthetic, or any natural material or any salt or preparation
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
of such substance or material included in the list of
“psychotropic substances” specified in the Schedule. The
schedule
lists
various
“psychotropic
substances”.
The
schedule does not list cannabis as psychotropic substance. In
her deposition Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) reiterated that
as per her examination the said item tested positive for
cannabis (ganja) “which is a psychotropic substance”.
75. As per the definitions cannabis is a “narcotic drug”
under Section 2 (xiv) of the NDPS Act, 1985.
76. Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) states in her deposition
that she is a Junior Scientific Officer, Chemistry Division
posted at RFSL, Saramsa. She does not elucidate further on
her expertise. Whilst Ms. Puja Lamichaney would submit that
the evidence of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) fall short of
proving that she was an expert and that her opinion was
based on sound reason to inspire confidence to rely upon the
same, Mr. Karma Thinlay would submit that the defence had
not even raised an issue about her expertise during the trial.
Ms. Puja Lamichaney would rely upon Ramesh Chandra
Agrawal v. Regency Hospital Limited & Ors.18; Anish Rai v. State
of Sikkim19; Central Bureau of Investigation v. Nar Bahadur
Bhandari20.
(2009) 9 SCC 709
2018 SCC OnLine Sikk 141
Criminal Appeal No. 4 of 2007
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
77. For the admissibility of the experts’ evidence the expert
must be within the recognised field of expertise. The evidence
given by the expert must be based on reliable principles and
the expert must be qualified in that discipline. Section 45 of
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 provides that when the Court
has to form an opinion upon a point of foreign law, or of
science, or art, or as to identity of handwriting or finger
impressions, the opinions upon that point of persons
specially skilled in such foreign law, science or art, or in
questions as to identity of handwriting or finger impressions
are relevant facts. Such persons are called experts. Thus, in
order to bring the evidence of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8)
as that of an expert it is necessarily to be shown that she had
made a special study of the subject and acquired special
experience thereby gaining expertise and adequate knowledge
of the subject. It is well settled that the expert is neither judge
nor jury and thus Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia’s (P.W.8) real
function was to place before the Court all materials together
with reasons which made her come to the conclusion. It
would allow the Court, which may not have the necessary
expertise, to form its own judgment by its own observation of
those materials placed by her and the reasons and conclusion
provided by her.
78. An expert opinion is an opinion. The opinion which
reflects the expertise on the subject of the expert and provides
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
the necessary scientific criteria for testing the accuracy of the
conclusions arrived at would inspire confidence upon the
Court to rely upon the same and come to its independent
judgment. The scientific opinion must therefore necessarily be
intelligible and convincing. The credibility of the expert’s
opinion would depend on the reasons stated in support of her
conclusions and the data and material furnished which form
the basis of the conclusion. Mere assertion without material
cannot be considered evidence even if it is stated by an
expert. When an expert gives no real data in support of what
they call their expert opinion, the evidence even though
admissible, may be excluded from consideration as it would
provide no assistance to the Court to form its judgment.
79. In re: Sultan Singh v. State of Haryana21 it has been held
by the Supreme Court that the opinion of an expert on
technical aspect has relevance but the opinion has to be
based on specialised knowledge and the data on which it is
based has to be found acceptable by the Court. In re: Madan
Gopak Kakkad v. Naval Dubey22 the Supreme Court would hold
that a medical witness called in as an expert to assist the
Court is not a witness of fact and the evidence given by the
Medical Officer is of an advisory character given on the basis
of symptoms found on examination. The expert witness is
(2014) 14 SCC 664
(1992) 3 SCC 204
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
therefore, expected to put before the Court all materials
inclusive of the data which induced him to come to the
conclusion. The expert is required to enlighten the Court on
the technical aspect of the case by explaining the terms of
science so that the Court although, not an expert may form
its own judgment on those materials. Once the expert opinion
is accepted, it is not the opinion of the Medical Officer but
that of the Court.
80. The deposition of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) is
lacking in all these aspects. No evidence has been placed
before the Court to satisfy that she is an expert. No data or
material
whatsoever
is
placed
either
in
the
forensic
examination report (exhibit-8) or in her deposition save
stating that the items were examined by chemical analysis
using Colour Test, Spectrophotometric and Chromatographic
techniques. The details of these tests have also not been
revealed. In the circumstances the very fact that Sonam
Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) opines that on her examination of
the brown dried plant material it tested positive for cannabis
(Ganja) “which is a psychotropic substance” troubles this
Court to consider her opinion, the sole evidence, to fasten a
verdict of guilt upon the Appellant in a prosecution under the
NDPS Act, 1985 and SADA, 2006. At this juncture Mr. Karma
Thinlay Namgyal would rely upon the judgment of the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Supreme Court in re: Durand Didier v. Chief Secretary, Union
Territory of Goa23 in which it was observed that:
“12. The criticism levelled by the learned defence counsel is that
the evidence of PW 6 is not worthy of acceptance since she has
admitted that she does not know the difference between the
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances. This attack, in our
view, does not assume any significance because as rightly pointed
out by Mr. Anil Dev Singh, the learned senior advocate for the
respondent, the Medical Officer is not expected to know the
differences in the legal parlance as defined in Section 2(xiv) and
(xxii) and specified under Schedules I to III in accordance with the
concerned Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Rules,
1985 made under the Act and so this ground by itself, in our view,
is no ground for ruling out the evidence of PW 6.”
81. However, in re: Durand Didier (supra) the Supreme Court
had categorically held that the testimony of the expert was
“unimpeachable”. The opinion rendered by Sonam Zangmoo
Bhutia (P.W.8) is a mere statement and not an opinion. It is
definitely not unimpeachable and therefore the facts before
the
Supreme
Court
in
re:
Durand
Dodier
(Supra)
is
distinguishable from the facts of the present prosecution.
82. It was the duty of the prosecution to establish that the
seized item was “ganja” and therefore a “narcotic drug”. The
burden was upon the prosecution. The failure of the defence
to demolish the evidence if the prosecution had at the first
instance
established
Sonam
Zangmoo
Bhutia’s
(P.W.8)
expertise and her reasoned opinion may have led the Court to
(1990) 1 SCC 95
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
rely upon the forensic examination report (Exhibit 8).
However, when the prosecution fails to establish the essential
requirements of an expert opinion the Court would have little
choice but to discard the same. This Court is afraid that the
finding of the learned Special Judge that the testimony of
Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) could not be demolished
under cross-examination and that her testimony clearly
establishes the facts stated therein does not reflect the correct
analysis of the relevant facts and of the laws. An opinion is
but an opinion and the Court may or may not accept it. If
however, the opinion is a reasoned opinion the Court would
be persuaded to rely upon the opinion. Merely because the
defence failed to demolish the cryptic statements without
adequate reasons made by Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) it
would not be enough to accept the forensic examination
report (exhibit 8).
Ascertaining the quantity is vital to a prosecution under
Section 20 of NDPS Act, 1985.
83. Section 20(b)(ii) of the NDPS Act, 1985 prescribes
different degrees of punishment depending upon the quantity
of cannabis.
84. Under Section 20 (b) (ii) (A) of the NDPS Act, 1985 where
such contravention relates to sub-clause (b) and involves
“small quantity” the punishment prescribed is rigorous
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months, or
with fine, which may extend to Rs.10,000/- or with both.
85. Under Section 20 (b) (ii) (B) of the NDPS Act, 1985 where
such contravention relates to sub-clause (b) and involves
“quantity lesser than commercial quantity but greater than
small quantity”
the punishment prescribed
is rigorous
imprisonment for a term which may extend to 10 years, and
with fine, which may extend to Rs.1,00,000/-.
86. Under Section 20 (b) (ii) (C) of the NDPS Act, 1985 where
such contravention relates to sub-clause (b) and involves
“commercial quantity” the punishment prescribed is rigorous
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than 10
years but which may extend to 20 years and shall also be
liable to fine which shall not be less than Rs.1,00,000/- and
which may extend to Rs.2,00,000/- provided that the Court
may, for reasons to be recorded in the judgment, impose a
fine exceeding Rs.2,00,000/-.
87. Reading Section 20 (b) (ii) (A), (B) and (C) of the NDPS
Act, 1985 there is no room to doubt that to secure a
conviction under Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985 the
prosecution must determine and establish the quantity of
cannabis in possession of the accused.
88. Under Section 2 (xxiiia) of the NDPS Act, 1985 “small
quantity” in relation to narcotic drugs means any quantity
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
lesser than the quantity specified by the Central Government
by notification in the Official Gazette.
89. The
learned
Special
Judge
would
hold
that
the
prosecution case all along was that one pouch of “ganja” was
recovered from the Appellant however, nowhere was the
amount/weight
of
the
said
“ganja”
indicated
both
in
documentary as well as in oral testimony. The learned Special
Judge would also hold that it is also not in the evidence that
the said pouch of “ganja” was ever weighed at any point of
time after the seizure, to ascertain whether it fell within either
of the quantities specified in the table of the NDPS Act, 1985.
The learned Special Judge would however, rely upon the
deposition of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) whereby she
would state that she had examined “a paper packet containing
a plastic pouch with brown dried material, weighing 1.94 gms.”
On such evidence the learned Special Judge would come to
the conclusion that the weight of the “ganja” seized was in
fact 1.94 gms and sentence the Appellant accordingly.
90. Under Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985 quantity of
cannabis alleged to be in possession of the Appellant would
determine the quantum of punishment. The Supreme Court
in re: Mohinder Singh v. The State of Punjab24 would hold that
for proving the offence under the NDPS Act, it is necessary for
the prosecution to establish the quantity of the contraband
2018 SCC OnLine SC 973
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
goods allegedly seized from the possession of the accused and
the best evidence would be the court records as to the
production of the contraband before the Magistrate and
deposit of the same before the “malkhana” or the document
showing destruction of the contraband.
91. The quantity of cannabis is a vital ingredient of the
offence punishable under Section 20 of the NDPS Act, 1985
which is required to be proved by the prosecution. On the
determination thereof the quantum of punishment is required
to be decided. It is clear that the prosecution has not even
bothered to prove the quantity of “ganja” allegedly seized on
04.01.2017. The evidence of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8)
which merely describes the articles received for forensic
examination cannot convince this Court about the weight of
the “ganja” allegedly seized on 04.01.2017 which was not
kept in safe custody by the Officer-In-charge of the Police
Station as required under the law and sent for forensic
examination only on 17.01.2017 after 13 days along with the
alleged controlled substances the quantity of which also
would not tally with the alleged seizure.
Possession of controlled substances.
92. Possession of controlled substances is an offence under
Rule 17 of the Sikkim Anti Drugs Rules, 2006 which
provides:-
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
“17. (1) No person shall possess any controlled substance, unless
he is lawfully authorised to possess such substance for any of the
said provisions in the rules.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule
(1), any person who is not so authorised under clause (c) of rule 2
of the Rules, may possess a quantity of such controlled substance
that is commensurate with his personal need, and shall carry with
him the valid prescription of a registered medical practitioner, or
hospital, or an institution authorised to prescribe the same, and the
quantity of the controlled substance in his possession shall not
exceed the quantity so prescribed:
Provided that a person, who is carrying the controlled
substance for another person, shall carry with him a valid
prescription for such person, and the quantity so possessed shall
not exceed the quantity so prescribed.
(3). The provision of sub-rule (1) shall not apply to –
(i) common carriers or warehouseman while engaged in lawfully
transporting or storing such substances or to any employee of the
same acting within the scope of his employment.
(ii) public officers or the employees in the lawful performance of
their official duties requiring possession of controlled substances; or
(iii) temporary incidental possession or by persons
whose
possession is for lawfully entitled to possession or by persons whose
possession is for the purpose of aiding public officers in performing
their official duties.”
93. The
possession
of
controlled
substances
in
contravention of Rule 17 of the Sikkim Anti Drugs Rules,
2006 is punishable under Section 14 of SADA, 2006. It
provides:
“Section
14.
Punishment
for
offence
for
which
no
punishment is provided.— Whoever contravenes any provisions
of this Act or any rule or order made thereunder for which no
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
punishment is separately provided in this chapter, shall be
punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to six
months, or with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees,
or with both.”
94. The learned Special Judge would also convict the
Appellant for possession of controlled substances.
95. To establish a charge of possession of controlled
substance
two
ingredients
are
essential.
It
must
be
established that the Appellant was in possession of the
controlled substances. It must also be established that the
articles seized were controlled substances. In that event
unless he is lawfully authorised to possess such controlled
substances for any of the said provisions in the rules the
possession would attract the punishment prescribed by
Section 14 of SADA, 2006. Failure to establish either of the
two ingredients by the prosecution would result in the charge
not being proved.
96. The learned Special Judge has framed the charge for
possession
of
controlled
substances
without
specifying
violation of Rule 17 of Sikkim Anti Drug Rules 2007. She did
not also examine the said provision.
97. The only evidence available on the record that the seized
articles were controlled substances is the evidence of Sonam
Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) and forensic examination report
(exhibit-8). The said evidence has been examined in detail
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
while
considering
the
conviction
of
the
Appellant
for
possession of “ganja”. In view of the said findings on her
expertise
and
the
cryptic
statement
in
the
forensic
examination report (exhibit-8) this Court is unable to accept
the conclusion of the learned Special Court that the
prosecution has been able to prove that the seized items were
controlled substances. The seizure is of 59 loose capsules of
“Spasmoproxyvion” and 29 tablets of “N-10”. Sonam Zangmoo
Bhutia (P.W.8) and the forensic examination report (exhibit-8)
records
receipt
of
capsules
marked
“SPM-PRX+”
“WOCKHARDT” and 28 tablets without any details. The
forensic examination report (exhibit 8) merely states that the
said capsules tested positive for Tramadol Hydrochloride and
the tablets tested positive for Nitrozapen which accordingly to
Sonam Zamgmoo Bhutia (PW 8) are controlled substances. No
scientific data has been provided by Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia
(P.W.8) in support of her findings. The evidence led by the
prosecution falls short of establishing beyond all reasonable
doubt that what was seized from the Appellant were actually
the same which were sent for forensic examination. The
evidence led by the prosecution does not rule out the
possibility of tampering with the seized articles. No evidence
has been led by the prosecution of the safe custody of the
seized articles.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
98. In exercise of the powers conferred by clause (iii) of
Section 2 of SADA, 2006 the State Government vide
Notification No.16/HC-HS & FW dated 06.06.2007 declared
certain substances to be controlled substances namely:
“(2). medicines containing the following Psychotropic
Substances namely:
(kk)
1,3-Dihydro-7-nitro-5-phenyl-2H-1-4-benzodiazepine-2-one
(commonly known as “Nitrazepam”); its salts, its esters and salts of
its
esters
and
preparations,
admixtures,
extracts
or
other
substances containing any of these drugs, in any dosage form or
quantity or combination.”
99. The said Notification dated 06.06.2007 was amended
vide Notification No. 16/HC. HS & FW dated 01.06.2015 and
inserted the following:
“(1) medicines containing the following namely;
(w) 2-{(dimethylamino) methyl}-1-(3-methoxyphenyl) cyclohexanol
(commonly known as TRAMADOL”); its salts, its esters and salts of
esters and preparations, admixtures, extracts or other substances
containing any of these drugs in any dosage form or quantity or
combination”.
100. The prosecution was required to therefore prove that the
alleged seized Spasmo proxyvon capsules were medicines
which contained the chemical specified in clause (1) and item
(w) of the Notification dated 06.06.2007 as amended by
Notification dated 01.06.2015 which is commonly known as
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
TRAMADOL its salts, its esters and salts of esters and
preparations,
admixtures,
extracts
or
other
substances
containing any of these drugs in any dosage form or quantity
or combination.
101. Similarly, the prosecution was also required to prove
that the N-10 or Nitrosun 10 tablets seized were medicines
containing the Psychotrophic substances as specified in
clause (2) (kk) of the Notification dated 06.06.2007 which is
commonly known as “Nitrazepam”; its salts, its esters and
salts of its esters and preparations, admixtures, extracts or
other substances containing any of these drugs, in any
dosage form or quantity or combination.
102. The testimony of Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8)
however, merely states that the Spasmo Proxyvon capsules
tested positive for Tramadol Hydrochloride and the tablets
tested positive for Nitrazepam and both are controlled
substances.
103. The evidence led by the prosecution does not establish
beyond reasonable doubt that the seized articles were
controlled substances. Therefore, the charge of possession of
controlled substances stands not proved by the prosecution.
Consumption of controlled substance.
104. The learned Special Judge would also convict the
Appellant for consumption of controlled substances under
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
Section 9(b) of SADA, 2006. Consumption of controlled
substance is an offence under Rule 18 of the Sikkim Anti
Drugs Rules 2007 which provides:
“18. (1) No person shall use or consume any controlled
substance unless he is lawfully authorised to do so for any of
the said purposes in the rules.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-rule (1), a
controlled substance may be used for(i) therapeutic requirement by a person who has been
prescribed the medicine by a registered medical practitioner,
a hospital or an institution for the possible cure of ailment, or
amelioration of symptoms.
(ii) Scientific requirement including analytical requirements of
any Government laboratory or research institution; or
(iii) the purpose of de-addition of drug addicts by the
Government or by an approved charity or by such other
institution as may be approved by the government.”
105. Consumption of controlled substances is prohibited
unless it is lawful. The Learned Special Judge has framed no
charge for consumption of controlled substances. She has
also not examined the provisions of Rule 18 of the Sikkim
Anti Drug Rules 2007. Violation of Rule 18 of the Sikkim Anti
Drug Rules 2007 is punishable under Section 9(b) of SADA,
2006.
106. The learned Special Judge has reproduced, examined,
convicted and sentenced the Appellant under Section 9 (b) of
SADA, 2006 as it existed prior to the amendment made by the
Sikkim Anti Drug (Amendment) Act, 2011 which was enforced
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
on 18.11.2011. The alleged offence having been committed on
04.01.2017 the amended Section 9 (b) of SADA, 2006 was
applicable. The amended Section 9 (b) of SADA, 2006 reads as
under:
“9.
Whoever, contravenes any provisions of this Act or any rule
or any order made there under shall be punishable[(a)
..................
(b)
where
the
contravention
consumption
without
valid
of
the
involves
controlled
medical
use
or
substances,
prescription
by
any
means/route of intake, in any chemical form,
such person shall undergo with compulsory
detoxification,
rehabilitation
and
and
to
be
followed
also
will
remain
by
under
observation/probation, and such person shall
also be liable to pay a fine which may extend to
(fifty thousand)25 rupees (*).
(c)
........
(d)
.........
(e)
.........
(f)
.........
107. Section 9 provides for punishment for contravention of
the provisions of SADA, 2006 or any rule or any order made
thereunder. Section 9(b) of SADA, 2006 relates to the
contravention involving use or consumption of controlled
substances
without
valid
medical
prescription
by
any
means/route of intake in any chemical form.
The words “ten thousand rupees” was substituted with the words “fifty thousand rupees” and the
words “if the users is young, unmarried or unemployed” was (*) omitted vide Section 2(2) of the
Sikkim Anti Drugs (Amendment) Act, 2011.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
108. The learned Special Judge relied upon the deposition of
Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7). He deposed that the Appellant
confessed to having consumed three Spasmo Proxyvon
capsules at 9.30 a.m. on the same day. The learned Special
Judge also examined the deposition of Sonam Zangmoo
Bhutia (P.W.8) who deposed that Tramadol which is a
“controlled substance” was found in the urine sample of the
Appellant collected by Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7). The
learned Special Judge thus convicted the Appellant for
consumption of controlled substances under Section 14 of
SADA, 2006.
109. On 04.01.2017 Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7) examined the
Appellant, took his urine sample and handed over the same
to the police as requested. The confession made by the
Appellant to Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7) of having consumed
three Spasmo Proxyvon capsules cannot be relied upon by the
prosecution as the same is hit by the provision of Section 25
and 26 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. At the time of
forwarding the Appellant for medical examination he was
already in police custody. From the evidence of Dr. Suman
Gurung (P.W.7) it is clear that the urine sample was taken
from the Appellant on 04.01.2017 itself. The handing/taking
memo (exhibit-6) reflects that a bottle of urine which was
handed over by Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7) was taken over
from Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) by Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) on
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
04.01.2017. Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) and Naresh Chettri
(P.W.9) both deposed that the Appellant was taken to the
District Hospital and medically examined and the urine
sample was preserved by the Medical Officer in order to send
for forensic analysis. The handing/taking memo (exhibit-6)
clearly establishes that the urine sample was in the custody
of Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) and thereafter Naresh Chettri
(P.W.9) on 04.01.2017 itself and not preserved by the Medical
Officer Dr. Suman Gurung (P.W.7) as stated by them. In fact
Dr.
Suman
Gurung’s
(P.W.7)
report
(exhibit-7)
dated
04.01.2017 clearly records the handing over of the urine
sample to the police on the said date. The evidence of
Mahindra Pradhan (PW 6) and Naresh Chhetri (PW 9) which
states that the urine sample was preserved by the Medical
Officer is falsified by the evidence of Dr. Suman Gurung
(P.W.7) and his report (exhibit-7). The said sample was
forwarded for forensic examination only on 17.01.2017 after
13 days of collection. Neither Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6) nor
Naresh Chettri (P.W.9) would depose under what conditions
the urine sample was kept in their custody for the period of
13 days.
Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia (P.W.8) deposed about
receipt of one sealed cloth covered box on 17.01.2017 for
forensic
examination
which
included
a
paper
packet
containing a glass vial with approximately 11ml of urine. She
deposed that the said exhibits were “examined by chemical
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
analysis
using
chromatographic
colour
test,
techniques”
and
spectrophotometric
based
on
the
and
said
examinations the urine sample tested positive to Tramadol
which is a controlled substances.
110. In “A textbook of Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology”25th Edition published by LexisNexis under the chapter
“examination of biological stains and hair” by Jaising P Modi it
is stated:
“Biological samples of toxicological analysis in
medicolegal autopsy cases.Urine: Urine specimen is of great value even in small
amount expecially in screening of unknown drug or poison,
particularly substance of abuse since the concentrations are
generally higher than in blood and a number of metaboliltes
may also be present. Urine specimen is also valuable in the
quantitative analysis of alcohol where there is uncertainty
over their validity of a blood specimen. Before conducting the
autopsy, urine can be collected by catheter or suprapubic
puncture with 5-10 ml syringe and needle (22 gauge 3 inch).
It has to be preserved in sodium fluoride (10 mg/ml) in a 30
ml glass container with a screw cap.”
111. The evidence led by the prosecution does not reflect that
the urine sample was preserved in the manner required. It
does question the dexterity of the investigating agency to
preserve the urine sample which is vital evidence in the
required controlled conditions and send it for forensic
examination without any delay.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
112. The cryptic opinion given by Sonam Zangmoo Bhutia
(P.W.8) does not help this Court to arrive at a firm conclusion
that the opinion regarding the urine sample testing positive to
Tramadol even after the period of 13 days is acceptable. The
fact that the prosecution has failed to establish that the
seized articles as well as the urine sample were kept in safe
and controlled conditions further aggravates the situation
making it impossible to fasten the guilt upon the Appellant.
113. In re: Mohan Lal (supra) the Supreme Court would also
hold:
“13. Unlike the general principle of criminal jurisprudence
that an accused is presumed innocent unless proved guilty, the
NDPS Act carries a reverse burden of proof under Sections 35
and 54. But that cannot be understood to mean that the moment
an allegation is made and the F.I.R. recites compliance with
statutory procedures leading to recovery, the burden of proof
from the very inception of the prosecution shifts to the accused,
without the prosecution having to establish or prove anything
more. The presumption is rebuttable. Section 35(2) provides that
a fact can be said to have been proved if it is established beyond
reasonable doubt and not on preponderance of probability. The
stringent provisions of the NDPS Act, such as Section 37, the
minimum sentence of ten years, absence of any provision for
remission, do not dispense with the requirement of
the
prosecution to establish a prima facie case beyond reasonable
doubt after investigation, only after which the burden of proof
shall shift to the accused. The case of the prosecution cannot be
allowed to rest on a preponderance of probabilities.
14. A fair trial to an accused, a constitutional guarantee
under Article 21 of the Constitution, would be a hollow promise if
the investigation in a NDPS case were not to be fair or raises
serious questions about its fairness apparent on the face of the
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
investigation. In the nature of the reverse burden of proof, the
onus will lie on the prosecution to demonstrate on the face of it
that the investigation was fair, judicious with no circumstances
that may raise doubts about its veracity. The obligation of proof
beyond reasonable doubt will take within its ambit a fair
investigation, in absence of which there can be no fair trial. If the
investigation
itself
is
unfair,
to
require
the
accused
to
demonstrate prejudice will be fraught with danger vesting
arbitrary powers in the police which may well lead to false
implication also. Investigation in such a case would then become
an empty formality and a farce. Such an interpretation therefore
naturally has to be avoided.”
114. SADA, 2006 also carried a reverse burden of proof under
Section 16 thereof. This cannot however be understood to
mean that the moment an allegation is made and the FIR
recites compliance with statutory procedures leading to
recovery, the burden of proof from the very inception of the
prosecution shifts to the accused, without the prosecution
having to establish or prove anything more. The presumption
under Section 16 of SADA, 2006 is rebuttable. Only if proof
“beyond reasonable doubt” after investigation as provided in
Section 16 of SADA, 2006 is established prima facie by the
prosecution would shift the burden to the accused.
115. In the circumstance the conviction of the Appellant for
consumption of controlled substances without even framing a
charge by the learned Special Judge is required to be set
aside.
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
116. In view of the pronouncement of the Supreme Court in
re: Mohan Lal (supra) as quoted above there is also no room
but to hold that the investigation in the present case
conducted by Mahindra Pradhan (P.W.6), although partially,
cannot be held to be free from unfairness and bias.
The
Appellant is entitled to the benefit of a doubt due to the
failure of compliance of Section 50 and 55 of the NDPS Act,
1985 as well as Section 24 and 28 of the SADA, 2006 by the
prosecution as well. The fairness of the investigation done by
the investigating agency being doubtful the non compliance of
the provision of Section 57 of the NDPS Act, 1985 of SADA,
2006 by Mahendra Pradhan (P.W.6) who conducted the
search would further strengthen the doubt. Unfairness of
investigation would directly prejudice the accused.
117. This Court is unable to agree with the conclusions
arrived at by the learned Special Judge convicting the
Appellant for possession of “ganja”, controlled substances and
for consumption of “controlled substances”. When the entire
prosecution against the Appellant is dependent upon the
prosecution establishing the seized items to be a narcotic
drug under the NDPS Act, 1985 and controlled substances
under the SADA, 2006 which in turn is dependent upon an
expert opinion the said opinion must inspire confidence. The
Appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt due to the failure
of the prosecution to establish this case in the manner
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
required while dealing with cases under the NDPS Act, 1985
and SADA, 2006.
118. A person who has been found to have consumed
controlled substance may not be an addict. However, a
person who consumes controlled substance is liable under
Rule 18 of the Sikkim Anti Drug Rules, 2006 and punishable
under Section 9(b) of SADA, 2006. The provision of Section
9(b) of SADA, 2006 makes it clear that the legislature
intended to deal with consumption of controlled substances
differently.
It
must
be
noted
that
for
an
offence
of
consumption of controlled substances as it existed prior to
the Sikkim Anti Drug (Amendment) Act, 2017 notified vide
Notification No.21/LD/17 dated 19.09.2017 and published in
the Sikkim Government Gazette on 19.09.2017 on which date
the said amendments to the SADA, 2006 came into force no
sentence of a jail term was prescribed.
119. Section 9 (b) of SADA, 2006 deals with consumption of
controlled substance more as a disease and less as a crime. It
provides for compulsory detoxification, rehabilitation and also
to remain under observation/probation. A sentence a fine of
Rs. 50,000/- was prescribed. This is more as deterrence. The
object of the provision clearly is to ensure that a person who
consumes controlled substance is compulsorily detoxified,
rehabilitated and kept under observation to ensure that he
does not get back into the habit. The role of the investigating
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
agency in such circumstances is vital. Fair and focused
investigation would result in critical evaluation of the person
who is alleged to have consumed controlled substance as to
whether he is a onetime consumer or an occasional
consumer, addict or a peddler trafficking drugs, psychotropic
substance or controlled substance. An addict has been
defined under Section 2 (ii) of SADA, 2006 to mean a person
who has dependence in any drug having abuse potential and
consumes the said drug. The certainty of purpose of the
investigating agencies will only ensure that the object for
which the provision has been made would be achieved.
120. This Court is of the view that in order to meet the
challenges faced by Society the investigation of the offences
both under the NDPS Act, 1985 as well as under SADA, 2006
should be focused and the conclusion of the investigation
must be arrived at with clinching evidence for the Court to
arrive at a decision as how best to deal with the offender. The
prosecution and the trial that follows must be done keeping
paramount the intention of the legislative in enacting the
NDPS Act, 1985 and SADA, 2006. When in spite of the
investigation it is difficult to come to the conclusion as to
whether the offender was a peddler of narcotic drug and
controlled substances who is needed to be punished severely
or an
“addict”
or a consumer
who
needs immediate
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
detoxification and rehabilitation the object and purpose of the
enactment cannot be achieved.
121. Only because it is a menace it does not permit the
enforcement agencies, the prosecution as well as the judiciary
to overlook the stringent requirements of the procedural laws
both under NDPS Act, 1985 and SADA, 2006. Securing a
conviction by leading cogent evidence proved in the manner
provided would help the judiciary to impose the correct
sentence focussed on the problem. Accurate identification
whether the suspect is a onetime or an occasional consumer,
addict or a peddler trafficking drugs, psychotropic substances
or controlled substances with certainty is crucial to the
resolution of the problem.
Otherwise even securing a
conviction may not serve the purpose of SADA, 2006. The
State is bound to ensure that the addicts and consumers are
detoxified,
rehabilitated,
kept
under
observation
and
reintegrated into the society they belong. When SADA, 2006
provides for compulsory detoxification, rehabilitation and
observation without adequate and proper detoxification,
rehabilitation and observation centres for consumers and
addicts the State enforcement agencies would not be in a
position to enforce the mandate of the law.
This would
amount to failure of the State to implement the SADA, 2006.
The Peddlers and the traffickers on the other hand must be
dealt with swiftly and sternly.
Their proper identification,
Crl. Appeal No.08 of 2018
Sushil Sharma v. State of Sikkim
focused prosecution and if found guilty imposition of the
correct and adequate sentence would help meet the need of
the society grappling with the menace today.
122. The impugned judgment dated 02.11.2017 as well as the
order on sentence dated 07.11.2017 passed by the learned
Special Judge (SADA), West Sikkim at Gyalshing in Sessions
Trial (SADA) Case No. 01 of 2017 are set aside. If the
Appellant has paid the fine imposed the same shall be
returned. The Appeal is allowed.
123. A copy of the judgment be sent forthwith to the Court of
the learned Special Judge (SADA), West Sikkim at Gyalshing.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
01.12.2018
to
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review