Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------S.B.: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SATISH K. AGNIHOTRI, ACJ.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl. M. C. No. 07 of 2016
1.
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah,
Aged about : 29 years,
S/o Sh. Nagina Kumar Shah,
R/o IBM Rangpo,
P.O. & P.S. Rangpo,
East Sikkim.
2.
Shri Sanjay Shah,
Aged about : 49 years,
S/o Bunilall Shah,
R/o Baga Jyoti Colony,
Road No: 2/3 Pradhan Nagar, Siliguri,
District : Darjeeling,
State of West Bengal.
3.
Smt. Munni Devi Shah,
Aged about : 47 years,
W/o Sh. Sanjay Shah,
R/o Baga Jyoti Colony,
Road No: 2/3 Pradhan Nagar, Siliguri,
District : Darjeeling,
State of West Bengal.
4.
Shri Appu Shah,
Aged about : 27 years,
S/o Sh. Sanjay Shah,
R/o Baga Jyoti Colony,
Road No: 2/3 Pradhan Nagar, Siliguri,
District : Darjeeling,
State of West Bengal.
… Accused/Petitioners.
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
5.
Smt. Shyama Kumari,
Aged about : 24 years,
W/o Sushil Kumar Shah,
D/o Shri Lallan Prasad,
R/o Barapathar, Mawbah,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills,
State of Meghalaya.
… Petitioner/Informant.
versus
State of Sikkim
Through :
The Ld. Public Prosecutor,
High Court of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
…
Respondent.
Petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973
----------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Mr. Rahul Rathi, Mr. Aditya Makkhim,
Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa and Mr. Pramit Chhetri,
Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. J. B. Pradhan, Public Prosecutor and Mr. Karma
Thinlay, Additional Public Prosecutor with Mr. S. K.
Chettri and Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public
Prosecutors for the State.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
(24.08.2016)
Satish K. Agnihotri, ACJ
The Petitioners 1 to 4, being the alleged accused,
and the Petitioner No.5, being the complainant, who are stated
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
to be family members, have come up with this petition under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short,
the Code), seeking to quash the first information report (for
short, FIR) bearing No.47(12)14 dated 25.12.2014 and the
consequential proceedings in General Register Case No.237 of
2015 (State of Sikkim vs. Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors.) pending
on the file of the Court of Judicial Magistrate (First Class), East
Sikkim at Gangtok.
2.
The facts, in nutshell relevant for adjudication and
disposal of the case, are that the Petitioner No.1 was married to
the Petitioner No.5 in accordance with Hindu rites at Sahu
Bhawan, Siliguri, West Bengal on 10.12.2013 and, thereafter,
they began to live together at Rangpo, P.O. & P.S. Rangpo, East
Sikkim.
The Petitioner No.2 and the Petitioner No.3 are
respectively the brother-in-law and sister of the Petitioner No.1
and the Petitioner No.4 is the son of the Petitioners 2 and 3.
3.
While living together, the Petitioner No.5 lodged a
FIR at Jhalupara Beat House, Shillong on 30.04.2014, making a
complaint against the Petitioners 1 to 4 of causing physical and
mental torture to her and demanding dowry, wherein a criminal
case was registered vide FIR bearing No. 36(4)14 dated
30.04.2014 under Section 498A/34 of the Indian Penal Code,
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
1860 (for short, the IPC) read with Section 4 of the Dowry
Prohibition Act, 1961.
4.
Being aggrieved, the Petitioner No.1 approached the
High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong under provision of Section
438 of the Code in A.B. No.26 of 2014, wherein it was observed
that the case did not fall within the jurisdiction of the Meghalaya
Police and the said FIR be forwarded to the concerned Police
Station for investigation.
5.
Rangpo
Pursuant thereto, the said FIR was transferred to
Police Station wherein it
was registered
as FIR
No.47(12)14 dated 25.12.2014 under provision of Section
498A/34 of the IPC and Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act,
1961 against the Petitioners 1 to 4 on the complaint of the
Petitioner No.5. The charge-sheet was, accordingly, filed in the
Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, East and North Sikkim,
Gangtok in General Register Case No.237 of 2015 which was
made over to the Court of the Judicial Magistrate, East Sikkim
for trial vide order dated 04.08.2016. During pendency of the
afore-stated trial, it appears that the complainant as well as
Petitioner No. 1/accused have reached to a family settlement,
which occasioned filing of the instant petition jointly by the
Petitioners 1 to 4/accused and the complainant, seeking
quashing of FIR and charge-sheet, as afore-stated.
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
6.
Mr. Rahul Rathi, learned Counsel appearing for the
Petitioners, referring to and relying on a decision of the
Supreme Court in Gian Singh vs. State of Punjab & Anr.1,
would submit that the dispute, being family dispute, has been
settled amicably and the alleged accused and the complainant
have re-established their family relationship and living happily.
Thus, the FIR, leading to the case pending in the trial court, be
quashed in the interest of family settlement.
It is further
contended that the allegation is also not of such nature, which is
not capable of settlement and the alleged accused are required
to be dealt with for the alleged offence under provisions of law.
7.
In response, Mr. Karma Thinlay, learned Additional
Public Prosecutor, fairly submits that the nature of complaint is
such which is required to be resolved and settled amicably.
Since the parties have settled the dispute, it is proper not to
proceed with the case.
8.
Heard learned Counsel for the parties, perused
pleadings and documents appended thereto.
9.
The Petitioner No.5 has filed an affidavit in this Court
on 18.08.2016, stating inter alia as under:
“7.
------------------------1 (2012) 10 SCC 303
That the instant case has been amicably settled
and I do now have a peaceful relationship with my
husband and rest of the petitioners.”
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
10.
The Petitioner No.5/complainant was also examined
by the Investigating Officer (IO). The IO, by her Report dated
19.08.2016 annexing the statement recorded under provision of
Section 161 of the Code, states that the complainant had clearly
deposed that the family dispute has been settled and, as such,
the complaint lodged by her be cancelled as she wants to
continue her marriage with her husband, Shri Sushil Kumar
Shah (Petitioner No.1).
The Petitioner No.1, in support of his
affidavit, has reiterated the same and expressed his desire to
maintain a good relation with his wife, Petitioner No.5.
The
Petitioners 2 to 4 have also reiterated the same statement.
11.
The question involved herein is as to whether
charges relating to the offences punishable under Section 4 of
the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 and Section 498A of the IPC,
which are non-compoundable, may be quashed in exercise of
jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code.
12.
As afore-stated, the complaint was lodged by wife
against the husband and other relatives alleging mental and
physical torture and demand of dowry.
Thereafter, as posited
by the Petitioner No. 1 (Accused) and the Complainant, who
have filed this petition jointly, they have come to an amicable
settlement between them to live together peacefully.
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
13.
In the case of Manoj Sharma vs. State & Ors.2,
wherein the question involved was as to whether a first
information report under Sections 420/468/471/34/120-B IPC
can be quashed either under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure or under Article 226 of the Constitution,
when the accused and the complainant have compromised and
settled the matter between themselves.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice
Altamas Kabir (as he then was) observed as under:
“ 8. In our view, the High Court’s refusal to exercise its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution for
quashing the criminal proceedings cannot be supported.
The first information report, which had been lodged by
the complainant indicates a dispute between the
complainant and the accused which is of a private nature.
It is no doubt true that the first information report was
the basis of the investigation by the police authorities, but
the dispute between the parties remained one of a
personal nature. Once the complainant decided not to
pursue the matter further, the High Court could have
taken a more pragmatic view of the matter. We do not
suggest that while exercising its powers under Article 226
of the Constitution the High Court could not have refused
to quash the first information report, but what we do say
is that the matter could have been considered by the High
Court with greater pragmatism in the facts of the case.”
Concurring, Hon’ble Mr. Justice Markandey Katju (as he then
was) observed as under:
“ 27. There can be no doubt that a case under Section
302 IPC or other serious offences like those under
Sections 395, 307 or 304-B cannot be compounded and
hence proceedings in those provisions cannot be quashed
by the High Court in exercise of its power under Section
482 CrPC or in writ jurisdiction on the basis of
compromise. However, in some other cases (like those
akin to a civil nature), the proceedings can be quashed by
the High Court if the parties have come to an amicable
settlement even though the provisions are not
compoundable. ……………………….”
------------------------2 (2008) 16 SCC 1
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
14.
In yet another case, Sushil Suri vs. Central
Bureau of Investigation & Anr.3, while examining the scope,
ambit and extent of Section 482 of the Code, the Supreme
Court held as under:-
“ 16.
Section 482 CrPC itself envisages three
circumstances under which the inherent jurisdiction may
be exercised by the High Court, namely, (i) to give effect
to an order under CrPC; (ii) to prevent an abuse of the
process of court; and (iii) to otherwise secure the ends of
justice. It is trite that although the power possessed by
the High Court under the said provisions is very wide but
it is not unbridled. It has to be exercised sparingly,
carefully and cautiously, ex debito justitiae to do real and
substantial justice for which alone the Court exists.
Nevertheless, it is neither feasible nor desirable to lay
down any inflexible rule which would govern the exercise
of inherent jurisdiction of the Court. Yet, in numerous
cases, this Court has laid down certain broad principles
which may be borne in mind while exercising jurisdiction
under Section 482 CrPC. Though it is emphasized that
exercise of inherent powers would depend on the facts
and circumstances of each case, but the common thread
which runs through all the decisions on the subject is that
the Court would be justified in invoking its inherent
jurisdiction where the allegations made in the complaint
or charge-sheet, as the case may be, taken at their face
value and accepted in their entirety do not constitute the
offence alleged.”
15.
In Rajiv Saxena & Ors. vs. State (NCT of Delhi)
& Anr.4, the Supreme Court, recording the affidavit of wife who
was the complainant in the FIR under provision of Sections
498A, 496 read with Section 34 of the IPC, quashed the charge
and proceedings pending before the Magistrate.
------------------------3 (2011) 5 SCC 708
4 (2012) 5 SCC 627
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
16.
A larger Bench of Supreme Court in Gian Singh vs.
State of Punjab & Anr.1, examining the correctness of the
decisions of the Supreme Court in B. S. Joshi & Ors. vs. State
of Haryana & Anr5, Nikhil Merchant vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation & Anr.6 and Manoj Sharma vs. State & Ors.2
in reference made in Gian Singh vs. State of Punjab & Anr.7
settled the proposition of law as under:
“ 57.
Quashing of offence or criminal proceedings on
the ground of settlement between an offender and victim
is not the same thing as compounding of offence. They
are different and not interchangeable. Strictly speaking,
the power of compounding of offences given to a court
under Section 320 is materially different from the
quashing of criminal proceedings by the High Court in
exercise of its inherent jurisdiction. In compounding of
offences, power of a criminal court is circumscribed by
the provisions contained in Section 320 and the court is
guided solely and squarely thereby while, on the other
hand, the formation of opinion by the High Court for
quashing a criminal offence or criminal proceeding or
criminal complaint is guided by the material on record as
to whether the end of justice would justify such exercise
of power although the ultimate consequence may be
acquittal or dismissal of indictment.
58.
Where the High Court quashes a criminal
proceeding having regard to the fact that the dispute
between the offender and the victim has been settled
although the offences are not compoundable, it does so
as in its opinion, continuation of criminal proceedings will
be an exercise in futility and justice in the case demands
that the dispute between the parties is put to an end and
peace is restored; securing the ends of justice being the
ultimate guiding factor. ………………”
------------------------5 (2003) 4 SCC 675
6 (2008) 9 SCC 677
7 (2010) 15 SCC 118
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
17.
Subsequently, in Ashok Sadarangani & Anr. vs.
Union of India & Ors.8, referring to earlier decision rendered
by the Supreme Court, the Supreme Court observed as under:
“ 24.
Having carefully considered the facts and
circumstances of the case, as also the law relating to the
continuance of criminal cases where the complainant and
the accused had settled their differences and had arrived
at an amicable arrangement, we see no reason to differ
with the views that had been taken in Nikhil Merchant
case or Manoj Sharma case or the several decisions that
have come thereafter. It is, however, no coincidence that
the golden thread which runs through all the decisions
cited, indicates that continuance of a criminal proceeding
after a compromise has been arrived at between the
complainant and the accused, would amount to abuse of
the process of court and an exercise in futility, since the
trial could be prolonged and ultimate, may conclude in a
decision which may be of any consequence to any of the
other parties.”
18.
Applying the well-settled proposition of law, as afore-
stated, to the facts of the case wherein the complaint was made
by wife, Petitioner No.5 herein, against the husband and other
relatives which led to lodging of FIR and filing of charge-sheet in
the Court.
After cognizance was taken by the Court, a
settlement between the complainant and the accused took
place, as stated hereinabove. Having regard to the relationship
between the complainant and accused, Petitioner No.1 herein,
and in the interest of justice to attain peace in the family and in
the society, I have no hesitation to allow this petition.
------------------------8 (2012) 11 SCC 321
2016:SHC:131
Crl. M. C. No. 07/2016
Shri Sushil Kumar Shah & Ors vs. State of Sikkim
19.
Resultantly,
FIR
bearing
No.
47(12)14
dated
25.12.2014 and the consequential proceedings in General
Register Case No.237 of 2015 (State of Sikkim vs. Sushil Kumar
Shah & Ors.) pending on the file of the Court of Judicial
Magistrate (First Class), East Sikkim at Gangtok are quashed.
20.
Petition is allowed.
Sd/-
Acting Chief Justice
24.08.2016
Approved for Reporting
Internet
pm
: Yes/No.
: Yes/No.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review