Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:3552-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MA No. 11 of 2026
Suryakant Tiwari S/o Late Shri Shashibhushan Tiwari Aged About 51 Years
R/o I-34 Anupam Nagar Raipur, C.G.
--- Appellant
versus
Directorate Of Enforcement Through Assistant Director Zonal Office Raipur
C.G.
--- Respondent
MA No. 12 of 2026
Kailash Tiwari W/o Lt. Sh. Shashibhushan Tiwari Aged About 70 Years R/o
I-34 Anupam Nagar Raipur, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
Directorate Of Enforcement Through Assistant Director Zonal Office Raipur
... Respondent
MA No. 13 of 2026
Suryakant Tiwari S/o Lt. Sh. Shashibhushan Tiwari Aged About 51 Years
R/o I-34 Anupam Nagar Raipur, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
Directorate Of Enforcement Through Assistant Director Zonal Office, Raipur
--- Respondent
(Cause title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellants
:
Mr. Ankush Borkar, Advocate (through
virtual mode) and Mr. Akshat Gupta,
Advocate
For Respondent
:
Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, Deputy
Advocate Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, C.J.
21/01/2026
1.
Since all these appeals filed under section 42 of the Prevention of
Money Laundering Act, 2002 (in short ‘the PMLA’), arise from a
common order passed by the learned Appellate Tribunal under
Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of
Property) Act, 1976 (in short ‘SAFEMA’), New Dehli, they are being
heard and decided together by this common order.
2.
The appellant in M.A. No. 11 of 2026 has prayed for the following
reliefs:“It is therefore prayed that this Hon’ble Court may
be pleased to set aside the impugned order dated
14.10.2025 passed by the Ld. Appellate Tribunal
under the PMLA in FPA-PMLA No.77/RP/2025
and the Order dated 17.07.2023 passed by the
Ld Adjudicating Authority in OC No.1906/2023
dt.25.02.2023
in
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022
dt.
29.09.2022; and pass such further orders as this
Hon’ble Court may deem fit and necessary in the
interest of justice.”
3.
The appellant in M.A. No. 12 of 2026 has prayed for the following
reliefs:“It is therefore prayed that this Hon’ble Court may
be pleased to set aside the impugned order dated
16.10.2025 passed by the Ld. Appellate Tribunal
under the PMLA in FPA-PMLA No.6895/RP/2023
and the Order dated 09.10.2023 passed by the
Ld Adjudicating Authority in OC No.1988/2023
dt.28.05.2023
in
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022
dt.
29.09.2022; and pass such further orders as this
Hon’ble Court may deem fit and necessary in the
interest of justice.”
4.
The appellant in M.A. No. 13 of 2026 has prayed for the following
reliefs:“It is therefore prayed that this Hon’ble Court may
be pleased to set aside the impugned order dated
16.10.2025 passed by the Ld. Appellate Tribunal
under the PMLA in FPA-PMLA No.6895/RP/2023
and the Order dated 09.10.2023 passed by the
Ld Adjudicating Authority in OC No.1988/2023
dt.28.05.2023
in
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022
dt.
29.09.2022; and pass such further orders as this
Hon’ble Court may deem fit and necessary in the
interest of justice.”
5.
The facts, in brief, as projected by the learned counsel for the parties
is that on 12.07.2022 an FIR bearing Crime No. 129/2022 was
registered by the Kadugodi Police station Whitefield, Bengaluru,
Karnataka, for the offences under Section 186, 204, 353 and 120B of
the Indian Penal Code (for short, the IPC). Suryakant Tiwari, a
resident of Raipur, Chhattisgarh, was alleged to be the main
accused. The offence under Section 384 IPC was thereupon added
by the Karnataka State Police on 03.09.2022. The Central Board of
Direct Taxes (for short, the CBDT) issued an Office Memorandum
(for short, the OM) on 13.09.2022 titled as “sharing of information
with ED in the case of M/s Jai Ambey Group of Raipur (Suryakant
Tiwari Group)” based on the report of DGIT, Investigation, Bhopal. As
per the said OM, Suryakant Tiwari in connivance with the
Government officials of the State of Chhattisgarh carried out the
offences of large scale illegal extortion punishable under Section 384
read with 120B of the IPC. The CBDT disclosed the need of ED to
investigate the matter for contravention of Section 3 of the PMLA.
According to the FIR and the documents received by the Income Tax
Department, a search and seizure operation was conducted on the
premises of Suryakant Tiwari and his associates. Various evidences
in the form of handwritten diaries, papers and digital evidences were
collected which revealed cash transaction by a syndicate operated
and coordinated by Mr. Suryakant Tiwari along with his associates
and other individuals. The syndicate was collecting unauthorized
cash over and above the legal amount fixed against the Coal
Delivery Order issued by the South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. for
various entities carrying out lifting and transportation of coal
throughout the State of Chhattisgarh. The syndicate operated by
Suryakant Tiwari and his associates was involved in illegal collection
of Rs.25/- per every ton of coal transportation from mines with the
active involvement of State Mining Officials/District Officials and
network agents stationed in the coal belt. The syndicate operated in
a well planned conspiracy, with delivery of orders only after illegal
payment to the syndicate. Surya Kant Tiwari was assisted by the
Government official like Smt. Saumya Chaurasia, Deputy Secretary,
CMO (Chhattisgarh Administrative Officer), Sameer Vishnoi, Indian
Administrative Services Officer and associates like Rajnikant Tiwari,
Roshan Singh, Nikhil Chandrakar, Sheikh Moiunudeen Qureshi,
Hemant Jaiswal, Joginder Singh etc. The collected money was to be
distributed amongst the accused and even to settle the bribe money
to the Government Officers and politicians to fund election
expenditures. The investigation revealed that large portion of money
has been channelized into layered transactions to project it as
untainted money and brought into the main stream by investing in the
properties, coal washeries and other assets.
6.
In terms of the permission received from the learned Court of
Metropolitan Magistrate, Bangalore, Section 384 IPC was added in
the FIR but while filing the charge-sheet on 08.06.2023, it was not for
the offence under Section 384 IPC and thereby cognizance of
offence was taken for offence under Section 204 and 353 of IPC only.
The ECIR was registered on 29.09.2022 when the offence under
Section 384 IPC was existing with its addition in the FIR though
while filing the charge sheet much later on 08.06.2023, it was not
filed for the offence under Section 384 IPC. However, it was with the
endorsement that Suryakant Tiwari and its syndicate were operating
in the State of Chhattisgarh. Thus, the offence under Section 384
IPC be taken up by Chhattisgarh State Police. An FIR was thus
registered by the Chhattisgarh State Police on 17.01.2024 vide FIR
number 03/2024 which was for the offence transferred to the State
Police of Chhattisgarh was coupled with the offence under Section
7A and 12 of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 420/120
B of IPC against Suryakant Tiwari and others. It is also a fact that on
26.06.2023, the offences and facts disclosed by the Income Tax
Department were incorporated in the ECIR by issuing an addendum.
7.
The ED filed prosecution complaints under Sections 44 and 45 of the
PMLA against the accused persons in the ECIR and proceeded to
attach the properties vide the PAO dated 09.12.2022 in exercise of
its power under Section 384 of the IPC. The appellants tried to offer
explanation, however, their respective properties were attached.
Following the PAO, the ED on 05.01.2023 filed a complaint under
Section 5(5) of the PMLA before the learned AA seeking confirmation
of the PAO No. 2/2022 dated 09.12.2022, against Suryakant Tiwari,
Rajnikant Tiwari, Laxmikant Tiwari, Sunil Kumar Agrawal, M/s.
Indermani Minerals India Pvt. Ltd ( for short, the IMIPL), M/s. KJSL
Coal & Power Pvt. Ltd., Sameer Vishnoi, Smt. Preeti Godara, M/s.
Sri Preeti Trimula Agro Farm, M/s. Tejaswi Sunshine Pvt. Ltd. Smt.
Saumya Chaurasia, Smt. Shanti Devi Chaurasia, Anurag Chaurasia,
Sourabh Modi and Anil Agrawal. A supplementary complaint was also
filed by the ED before the learned trial Court arraigning some of the
appellants as accused person therein.
8.
On 12.01.2023, the learned AA issued show cause notices to the
appellants under Section 8(1) of the MPLA. The appellants filed their
respective replies to the said notices. Rejoinder was also filed by the
ED to the reply filed by the appellants. Thereafter, the learned trial
Court, took cognizance of the first prosecution complaint and the first
supplementary prosecution complaint on 30.05.2023 and thereafter,
the learned AA, vide Confirmation Order dated 01.06.2023,
confirmed the attachment of properties provisionally attached by the
respondent/ED vide PAO No. 2/2022, dated 09.12.2022.
9.
After passing of the confirmation order by the learned AA, the
Karnataka Police filed its charge sheet under Section 173 of the
Cr.P.C. before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bengaluru, Rural in
respect of the predicate FIR which forms the substratum of the ECIR
and consequent proceedings under the PMLA. However, Section 384
IPC which was the only scheduled offence in the predicate FIR was
not included in the charge sheet. Based on the charge sheet
submitted, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, took cognizance of
the offences under Sections 204 and 353 of IPC on 16.06.2023. The
ED had also sent possession notice under Section 8(4) of the PMLA
as well as eviction notice under Rule 5(2) of the Prevention of Money
Laundering (Taking Possession of Attached Properties Confirmed by
the Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2013 for some of the properties
attached by the AA in the subject OC. Aggrieved by the Confirmation
Order and Possession Notice issued on the strength of the
Confirmation Order, the appellants filed an appeal before the learned
Appellate Tribunal under Section 26 of the PMLA which were
dismissed vide final order dated 05.12.2024.
10.
The appeals before the learned Appellate Tribunal with respect to the
present impugned orders, were heard on 28.07.2025 and the order
has been passed on 16.10.2025, dismissing the appeals filed by the
appellants directing that, the appeals to be governed by the order
dated 05.12.2024, passed by learned Appellate Tribunal in the case
of ‘Smt. Shanti Devi Chaurasia and others v. Directorate of
Enforcement” (FPA-PMLA-6157/RP/2023). The said orders dated
16.10.2025 are under challenge in the present appeals.
11.
Mr. Ankush Borkar, learned counsel appearing for the appellants (in
MA No. 11 of 2026) would submit that, the impugned order passed by
the learned Appellate Tribunal dismissing the Appellant’s appeal on
the ground of limitation is ex facie illegal and contrary to Section
26(3) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. The statutory
period of 45 days commences only from the date on which a copy of
the order of the Adjudicating Authority is received by the aggrieved
person. In the present case, there was no service of the adjudication
order upon the Appellant in the manner prescribed under Rule 27 of
the Adjudicating Authority (Procedure) Regulations, 2013. The
alleged acknowledgment relied upon by the Respondent clearly
shows that the order was issued to a third party and not to the
Appellant. In the absence of valid service, limitation never
commenced, and the appeal could not have been dismissed as timebarred. The further finding that mere “knowledge” of the order is
sufficient to trigger limitation is contrary to the express mandate of
the statute.
*******It is further submitted that the entire proceedings under the
PMLA are without jurisdiction inasmuch as there was no subsisting
scheduled offence forming the basis of the subject ECIR. The
offences initially relied upon as scheduled offences were dropped
after investigation, and the concerned courts took cognizance only of
non-scheduled offences. It is settled law, as held by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, that the existence of a scheduled offence is a sine
qua non for proceedings under the PMLA, and in the absence
thereof, there can be no proceeds of crime or offence of money
laundering. This jurisdictional defect goes to the root of the matter
and renders the ECIR, the Original Complaint, and all consequential
proceedings, including the attachment, void ab initio. Despite this
being specifically urged, the learned Appellate Tribunal failed to
consider this foundational issue.
*******Without prejudice to the above, it is submitted that the
proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority are vitiated by nonapplication of mind and violation of mandatory provisions of Section 8
PMLA, as the so-called “reasons to believe” are a mere reproduction
of the Enforcement Directorate’s allegations. The adjudication was
further conducted by an illegally constituted Adjudicating Authority,
comprising a single member without a judicial member, rendering the
proceedings coram non-judice. The Appellant, who was in judicial
custody for a substantial period, has suffered grave prejudice by the
dismissal of his appeal at a preliminary stage without adjudication on
merits. It is therefore prayed that the impugned order be set aside
and the Appellant’s appeal be restored for consideration on merits in
the interest of justice.
12.
Learned counsel for the appellants (in MA No. 12 of 2026) would
submit that, the proceedings before the learned Adjudicating
Authority are vitiated by a complete failure to comply with the
mandatory requirements of Section 8 of the Prevention of Money
Laundering Act, 2002. The Adjudicating Authority was required to
independently apply its mind and record valid “reasons to believe”
that the attached properties constituted proceeds of crime or were in
possession thereof, prior to issuance of the show cause notice. In the
present case, though the show cause notice dated 07.06.2023 refers
to separate reasons to believe, the same were never supplied to the
Appellant, thereby depriving him of an effective opportunity to
respond.
The
show
cause
notice
is
non-speaking,
reflects
mechanical acceptance of the Enforcement Directorate’s allegations,
and discloses no independent judicial scrutiny of the material relied
upon. Such non-application of mind strikes at the root of jurisdiction
and renders the entire proceedings, including the Provisional
Attachment Order and Original Complaint, illegal.
*******It is further submitted that the entire action under the PMLA is
wholly without jurisdiction inasmuch as there is no subsisting
scheduled offence forming the basis of the subject ECIR. The
offences initially treated as scheduled offences under Sections 120B
and 384 IPC were expressly dropped after investigation, and the
competent court took cognizance only of non-scheduled offences. It
is settled law that the existence of a scheduled offence is a sine qua
non for the offence of money laundering, and in its absence, there
can be no proceeds of crime. This legal position has been expressly
noticed and affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in subsequent
orders passed in the Appellant’s own case, which clearly record that
no offence under Section 384 IPC was registered or investigated by
the Chhattisgarh Police. Consequently, the ECIR, the Original
Complaint, and all consequential attachment proceedings are void ab
initio. The reliance placed by the learned Appellate Tribunal on the
decision in Saumya Chaurasia is misplaced in view of later binding
orders of coordinate and larger Benches of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
*******Without prejudice to the above, it is submitted that no prima
facie offence of money laundering is made out against the Appellant.
The attached bank accounts contain legitimate business income with
no nexus to any alleged criminal activity. The alleged quantification of
proceeds of crime is speculative, contradictory, and unsupported by
admissible evidence. The Respondent’s case rests primarily on
statements of co-accused recorded under Section 50 PMLA and
alleged diary entries, both of which are inadmissible and unreliable in
law without independent corroboration. Additionally, the entire
adjudication stands vitiated as having been conducted by a Single
Member Adjudicating Authority lacking a judicial member, contrary to
the mandatory scheme of Section 6 PMLA, rendering the
proceedings coram non-judice. The learned Appellate Tribunal failed
to consider these foundational defects, and therefore, the impugned
order is bad in law and liable to be set aside in the interest of justice.
13.
Learned counsel for the appellants (in MA No. 13 of 2026) would
submit that, the entire adjudication under Section 8 of the Prevention
of Money Laundering Act, 2002 is vitiated for non-compliance with
the mandatory statutory requirements. The Learned Adjudicating
Authority failed to independently apply its mind and record valid
“reasons to believe” as required under Section 8(1) PMLA prior to
issuance of the Show Cause Notice dated 07.06.2023. Though the
said notice refers to separate reasons to believe, the same were
admittedly never supplied to the Appellant, thereby depriving him of
an effective opportunity to respond and rendering the proceedings
violative of principles of natural justice. The Show Cause Notice is
non-speaking and reflects a mechanical acceptance of the
Enforcement Directorate’s allegations without any judicial scrutiny of
the material relied upon. Such failure goes to the root of jurisdiction
and renders the Provisional Attachment Order, Original Complaint,
and all consequential proceedings illegal. These foundational defects
have not been considered by the Learned Appellate Tribunal,
rendering the impugned order unsustainable in law.
*******It is further submitted that the proceedings under the PMLA are
wholly without jurisdiction inasmuch as there was no subsisting
scheduled offence forming the basis of the subject ECIR. The
offences initially treated as scheduled offences, namely Sections
120-B and 384 IPC, were expressly dropped in the final report filed
by the Bengaluru Police, and the competent court took cognizance
only of non-scheduled offences. Even the EOW, Raipur FIR did not
initially contain any scheduled offence. It is settled law that the
existence of a scheduled offence is a sine qua non for proceedings
under the PMLA and for the existence of any “proceeds of crime”.
This jurisdictional defect has been expressly noticed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in its orders dated 17.05.2024 and 04.10.2024 in the
Appellant’s own case. The belated addition of Section 384 IPC in
May 2024 is a colourable exercise and cannot retrospectively
validate proceedings which were void ab initio. The reliance placed
by the Learned Appellate Tribunal on Saumya Chaurasia is
misplaced in view of subsequent and binding orders of larger
Benches of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
*******Without prejudice to the above, it is submitted that the
Appellant is prima facie not guilty of the offence of money laundering.
The attached bank accounts contain legitimate business income
earned by the Appellant over decades of lawful business activity and
have no nexus whatsoever with any alleged criminal activity. The
alleged
quantification
of
proceeds
of
crime
is
speculative,
contradictory, and unsupported by admissible evidence. The
Respondent’s case rests primarily on statements of co-accused
recorded under Section 50 PMLA and alleged diary entries, both of
which are inadmissible and unreliable in law without independent
corroboration. Additionally, the entire adjudication is rendered null
and void as it was conducted by a Single Member Adjudicating
Authority without a judicial member, contrary to the mandatory
scheme of Section 6 PMLA, rendering the proceedings coram nonjudice. The Learned Appellate Tribunal failed to examine these
jurisdictional and constitutional infirmities, and therefore, the
impugned order deserves to be set aside in the interest of justice.
14.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent/ED would
submit that, the present appeals under Section 42 of the Prevention
of Money Laundering Act, 2002 are devoid of merit and do not raise
any substantial question of law warranting interference by this
Hon’ble Court. The learned Appellate Tribunal has rightly dismissed
the appeals by a reasoned order, following its earlier detailed
decision dated 05.12.2024 passed in Smt. Shanti Devi Chaurasia
and Others v. Directorate of Enforcement, which squarely governs
the present cases. The Appellants were fully aware of the
adjudication proceedings and the confirmation orders passed by the
Adjudicating Authority, and had actively participated therein. The plea
of non-service is a hyper-technical attempt to circumvent statutory
timelines and has been rightly rejected. Mere absence of formal
service cannot override admitted knowledge and participation,
particularly when no prejudice has been demonstrated.
*******It is further submitted that the contention regarding absence of
a scheduled offence is misconceived and contrary to the material on
record. At the time of registration of the ECIR on 29.09.2022, the
predicate FIR included Section 384 IPC, a scheduled offence under
the PMLA, thereby conferring complete jurisdiction upon the
Respondent to initiate proceedings. Subsequent developments in the
predicate proceedings do not invalidate actions lawfully taken under
the PMLA. The investigation has revealed a well-orchestrated
conspiracy involving systematic extortion in coal transportation,
generation of huge proceeds of crime, and their subsequent layering
and projection as untainted money. The existence of proceeds of
crime and their nexus with the criminal activity has been duly
established through documentary evidence, statements recorded
under Section 50 PMLA, and financial trail analysis. The reliance
placed by the Appellants on selective observations in subsequent
Supreme Court orders is misplaced and does not dilute the binding
ratio of Vijay Madanlal Choudhary and Saumya Chaurasia, which
continue to hold the field.
*******Without prejudice to the above, it is submitted that the
proceedings before the Adjudicating Authority fully comply with the
mandate of Section 8 of the PMLA. The reasons to believe were duly
recorded on the basis of material placed by the Enforcement
Directorate, and the Appellants were afforded adequate opportunity
to file replies and participate in the adjudication. The confirmation of
attachment was passed after due consideration of the replies and
material on record. The challenge to the composition of the
Adjudicating Authority and allegations of lack of independence are
speculative, unfounded, and contrary to the statutory framework
upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The Appellants have failed to
demonstrate any actual prejudice caused to them. The appeals are,
in effect, an attempt to re-agitate factual issues already considered
and rejected by the Appellate Tribunal. It is therefore respectfully
prayed that the present appeals be dismissed with costs, and the
impugned orders be affirmed in the interest of justice.
15.
Lastly, learned counsel for the respondent/ED would submit that, the
issue involved in these appeals has already been decided by this
Court in MA No. 34 of 2025 and other batch of appeals, and
therefore, in view of the order dated 23.07.2025, passed in MA No.
34 of 2025 and other batch of appeals and the issue involved in the
present appeals are also identical, all these appeals are liable to be
dismissed.
16.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have carefully
perused the impugned orders passed by the learned Appellate
Tribunal, the material placed on record, and the statutory provisions
governing the field.
17.
On an anxious consideration of the rival submissions, we find no
infirmity, illegality, or perversity in the orders impugned warranting
interference by this Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 42
of the PMLA. The learned Appellate Tribunal has rightly dismissed
the appeals by following its earlier detailed and reasoned decision
dated 05.12.2024 in Smt. Shanti Devi Chaurasia and Others v.
Directorate of Enforcement, which squarely governs the issues
raised herein. The contentions urged by the appellants with regard to
limitation, alleged non-service of the adjudication orders, absence of
a scheduled offence, non-compliance of Section 8 of the PMLA, and
the composition of the Adjudicating Authority have been duly
considered and rejected by the Appellate Tribunal by cogent reasons.
We also find that identical issues have already been considered and
decided by this Court in MA No. 34 of 2025 and other connected
matters by order dated 23.07.2025, and no distinguishing feature has
been pointed out to take a different view. The appeals essentially
seek re-appreciation of facts and evidence, which is impermissible in
an appeal under Section 42 of the PMLA, absent any substantial
question of law.
18.
Since, the issue has already been decided by this Court in MA No. 34
of 2025 and other batch of appeals on 23.07.2025 considering all the
facts and circumstances of the case as well as law applicable to it
and we are not inclined to take a different view, other that the view,
which has already been taken in MA No. 34 of 2025 and other batch
of appeals decided by this Court on 23.07.2025.
19.
In view of the foregoing discussion, and for the reasons stated above,
we are of the considered opinion that no substantial question of law
arises for determination in the present appeals. Consequently, all the
appeals being M.A. Nos. 11 of 2026, 12 of 2026 and 13 of 2026 are
hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Padma
V PADMAVATHI
Date: 2026.02.02
16:35:27 +0530
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review