Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 24149 of 2025
Surya Alloy Industries Limited & Anr.
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Soumya Majumdar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Farhan Ghaffar
Mr. Kallol Saha
Mr. Akash Ghosh
Ms. Nabanita Chakraborty
....For the petitioners.
Mr. Sanajit Kumar Ghosh
Ms. Sayani Roy Choudhury
Ms. Biswadeepa Mandal
….For the U.O.I.
Hearing Concluded On : 23.06.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 07.07.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 07.07.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1.
The petitioners have filed this present writ petition challenging the
delisting order dated 9th October, 2025, wherein and where under the
petitioner firm is being temporarily delisted from the item ‘Elastic Rail
Clips’.
2.
The East Coast Railway floated tender for manufacture and supply of
Elastic Rail Clips-MK-V (T-5919) confirming to T-31 of the IRS
specification. The petitioners have participated in the said tender
process and was found L-1 bidder for manufacture and supply of the
said materials. The respondent no.4 has issued purchase order dated
3rd October, 2024 for supply of the said materials. The supplies were to
be made in terms of the delivery schedule and the materials were
required to be inspected prior to its dispatch by M/s. RITES Limited.
3.
Mr. Soumya Mazumdar, Learned Senior Advocate, representing the
petitioners submits that the petitioners manufactured the said
materials and were inspected by the M/s. RITES prior to dispatch to
the respondent no. 4. He submits that the samples were inspected for
both raw materials and finish materials/ products in terms of the
contract. The supplies were checked and accepted by the respondent
no.4 and the petitioners have submitted its invoices which were duly
accepted and made payments.
4.
Mr. Mazumdar submits that on 20th August, 2025, the petitioners has
received the show cause notice from the respondent no.2 on the
allegation of failure of a sample of the materials supplied by the
petitioners to the respondent no.4. In the show cause notice, it was
alleged that a joint sampling of the materials supplied by the petitioners
was done on 12th May, 2025 by the RDSO and the Track Depot officials
of the East Coast Railway. The show cause notice also indicated that
the samples have been tested and test result have been found as not
confirming to IRS T- 31-2021.
5.
The petitioners have challenged the said show cause notice in the writ
proceeding being WPA No. 21634 of 2025. The writ petition was
disposed of on 19th September, 2025, recording that the time period to
submit reply to the show cause notice has not expired and it will be
open to the petitioners to respond to the said show cause notice and
directed the respondents to consider the response of the petitioners to
the show cause notice in accordance with the legal statutory
conditions.
6.
The petitioners have submitted reply to the show cause notice on 19 th
September, 2025, stating that the alleged testing of the sample has
been done in violation of the Clauses 15.1 to 15.8 of the IRS
Specification for ERC T-31-2021 corrigendum No.2 of October 2023.
Mr. Mazumdar submits that in terms of the provisions of Clause 1502
of IRS Conditions of Contract RDSO has no authority to test or to reject
the materials beyond the period of 90 days of supply. Mr. Mazumdar
submits that inspite of receipt of reply submitted by the petitioners, the
respondents have issued the impugned order dated 9th October, 2025
by temporarily delisting the petitioner firm for item ‘Elastic Rail Clip’.
7.
Mr. Mazumdar submits that the petitioners have submitted reply to the
show cause notice but in the impugned order, it is mentioned that the
petitioners have not submitted reply to the show cause notice. He
submits that the impugned order is issued in violation of the principle
of natural justice as neither the respondents have considered the reply
submitted by the petitioners, nor personal hearing was provided to the
petitioners.
8.
Mr.
Sanajit
Kumar
Ghosh,
Learned
Advocate
representing
the
respondents submits that the main depot of East Coast Railway
received materials from the petitioners on 8th March, 2025. The
Assistant Divisional Engineer of the East Coast Railway (Consignee)
communicated to the Senior Divisional Engineer, East Coast Railway
that during inspection at PQRS depot at KBM, the ERC MK-V was
found breaking while fixing into the sleeper during making PQRS
panels. The Senior Divisional Engineer of the East Coast Railway
communicated the same to the Chief Track Engineer and accordingly
show cause notice was issued to the petitioners on 20th August, 2025.
9.
Mr. Ghosh submits that prescribed time of 30 days for giving reply to
the show cause notice expired on 18th September, 2025 but the reply
from the petitioners was received on 1st October, 2025, thus the
respondent authorities have not considered the reply submitted by the
petitioners and accordingly on 9th October, 2025, the penalty order was
issued against the petitioners.
10. Mr. Ghosh submits that in the order of penalty, it was categorically
mentioned that if the petitioners are aggrieved with the order of
delisting, the petitioners have an opportunity to file an appeal but the
petitioners instead of filing an appeal, have filed the present writ
petition.
11. In the show cause notice, it is mentioned that joint sampling was done
on 12th May, 2025 but in the affidavit-in-opposition it is mentioned that
one technical representative from the firm of the petitioners arrived
KBM and visited the site along with SSE (P. Way)/ CHE on 1st May,
2025 and found 300 nos ERCs were in broken condition. It is also
mentioned that the firm representatives had not done joint inspection
with Railways. Thus, it is clear that the sampling was not done in the
presence of the petitioner firm.
12. In the show cause notice, it is the allegation that the samples were
tested and test results are not found conforming to IRS: T-31-2021.
Clause 15 of the IRS Specification for ECR T-31-2021, Corrigendum No.
2 of October’ 2023 specifies as follows:
“15.1-Consignee End Inspection of ERCs –
The Purchaser/Consignee or its nominated
representative shall pick up and seal 02 sample
sets per lot in the presence of firm’s
representative within 01 month after receipt the
material (ERC) at the consignee depot which shall
be preserved in the consignee depot or nominated
location for a period of one year from the date of
receipt of material. One sample set shall comprise
of 30 nos. ERCs picked randomly.
15.2. If the firm’s representative does not turn
up within one month after receipt of material (ERC)
at the consignee end for joint sampling by
Purchaser/Consignee, the sampling shall be done
by Purchaser/Consignee solely.
15.3. The sealed sample set can be got tested
by the Purchaser/Consignee, from RDSO or NABL
accredited labs within 12 months from the date of
receipt of material with the approval of an officer
not below the level of JAG of the concerned Zonal
Railway or equivalent as per the observation
during field inspections/ specific nature of
complaint regarding performance of ERC. 14 nos.
ERCs from the first sample set shall be tested for
conformity as per following scheme:
Test to be conducted for conformity
14 nos-Dimension
6 nos-Hardness, depth of decarburization
and freedom from surface defects
8 nos-Toe-load, flat bearing
application & deflection test
area,
15.4. After decision for testing of samples, the
supplier shall be informed to witness the test of
first sample set. Second sample shall be kept as
standby as per the provisions of ISO Apex
documents.
15.5. If the first sample set passes the tests,
no further action will be needed. In case the first
sample set fails as per acceptance/rejection
criteria, the corresponding lot shall be rejected. The
supplier/firm shall remove the rejected lot from the
consignee depot at their own cost, but only after the
supplier/firm has reimbursed payments already
made if any by Purchaser/Consignee or an
equivalent amount has been recovered for this
purpose. However, the Purchaser/Consignee shall
not be liable to return the material that is already
put into track and the supplier/firm shall have no
claim for compensation.
15.6. The rejected lot shall be removed by the
supplier/firm within 03 months of date of rejection
advice, failing which the Purchaser/Consignee
shall not be liable to return the rejected lot and the
supplier/firm shall have no claim for compensation
for such material. The rejected clips shall be cut
into two pieces by the supplier/firm using oxyacetylene flame at their own cost before removing
the rejected clips from purchaser/consignee depot.
15.7. Financial recovery and Penal action
shall be taken as per the provisions of ISO Apex
documents and Railway Board's extant policy.
We say that clause 15.1 to 15.8 specifically
provide the manner in which the samples are
required to be picked up and tested and the
subsequent action which are required to be taken if
the samples are found not to be in conformity.”
As per Clauses 15.1 and 15.4, purchaser/ consignee has to
inform the supplier to remain present during pickup of the samples and
to witness the test samples but admittedly the same was not followed in
the present case.
13. As per guidelines for testing of the materials, firm’s representative
should be present at the time of testing. Before testing of such
materials, a notice has to be served upon the firm and inform them to
be present at the time of testing of such materials. The said procedure
has not followed in the present case before issuance of the show cause
notice and the impugned order.
14. It is also the case of the respondents that the petitioners have not
submitted reply to the show cause notice within 30 days. Initially on
receipt of show cause notice, the petitioners have challenged the show
cause notice in a writ proceeding. This Court by an order dated 19th
September, 2025, disposed of the said writ application given liberty to
the petitioners to respond to the show cause notice and the authority
shall consider the response of the petitioners to the show cause notice
in accordance with law.
15. The petitioners have submitted reply to the show cause notice on 19 th
September, 2025 and the same was received by the respondents on
29th September, 2025. The impugned order of temporary delisting was
passed on 9th October, 2025. It is admitted by the respondents in
paragraph 4 of the affidavit-in-opposition that “the prescribed period of
30 days was to expire on 18th September, 2025. The petitioners firm
neither sought any extension of time nor approached this office prior to
18th September, 2025.
Thus the reply dated 19th September, 2025 from the petitioners firm
received in RDSO on 1st October, 2025 was not considered ……….”
16. This Court disposed of the earlier writ petition on 19 th September, 2025
and on the same day the petitioners have submitted reply to the show
cause notice. Admittedly, the respondents have received reply on 1st
October, 2025 and the impugned order of temporary delisting was
issued on 9th October, 2025 i.e. after the period of nine days. The
respondents ought to have considered the reply of the petitioners but
fail to consider the same.
17. Temporary Delisting
is provided in Clause 4.2.2 which reads as
follows:
“4.2.2 TEMPORARY DELISTING
Temporary delisting of vendors can
restored to under the following conditions:
be
a) Cases where repeated failures are noticed in
the items supplied
b) Direction from law enforcing agencies
JRE/ISO Cell
Prepared By
SSRE/ISO
Cell
Checked By
ISO9001:2015 Document No:
QO-D-8. 1-11
MRI/ISO
Cell
Issued By
Printed:23.07.2025
Version No: Date Effective:
3.5
23.07.2025
Document Title: Vendor – Changes in approved status
c) If quality audit is refused by the firm or
RDSO is not allowed by the firm to perform
quality audit, the firm shall be temporarily
delisted and shall be removed from the
vendor list in next updation, till such time
quality audit is performed.
d) Expiry of ISO 9001 certificate.
e) Deficiencies/non-functioning
of
major
machinery & plants affecting the quality.
f) During a course of time, if the specification is
amended and the vendor is not upgrading
the additional requirements within a
specified timeframe.
g) Major deficiencies found during quality
audit/process
audit
and
their
noncompliance.
h) The entire factory or part of it is reported
closed/shut down/lock out.
Note: In case of closure/ lockout, the firm
may be temporarily delisted and status
restored on resumption after verification of
facilities and audit of the production
process, as decided by the Concerned
Vendor Approving Authority.
i) If change in the name, address, work place
and ownership not initiated to RDSO within
one month.
j) If sample picked up by an investigating
agency (CBI/Vigilance) (as per prescribed
procedure of sampling) fails in testing.
k) If the vendor does not participate in any of
the Railway tender between two consecutive
quality audits or in last five years, whichever
is earlier.
l) Any other serious reason.”
The show cause notice as well as the impugned notice is not
covered under any of the clauses for temporary delisting.
18. As regard to the maintainability of the writ petition and not filing of
appeal by the petitioners, this Court finds that the petitioners have
challenged the impugned order on the ground of violation of natural
justice as the respondents have not provided any opportunity of
hearing to the petitioners. This Court already held that sampling was
not done in accordance with law and not in presence of the petitioners.
The respondents though received reply to the show cause after the
period of 30 days but before issuance of the impugned order dated 9th
October, 2025, ought to have consider the same but without
considering the reply submitted by the petitioners, the respondent
authorities have passed the impugned order. Thus the writ petition is
maintainable.
19. Considering the above, the show cause notice dated 20th August, 2025
and the impugned order dated 9th October, 2025, of temporary delisting
of the petitioner firm is set aside and quashed.
20. The respondent authorities are at liberty to take samples of the
materials supplied by the petitioners in presence of the representatives
of the petitioners and after testing of the materials, if the respondents
finds that the materials supplied by the petitioners is not conformity
with IRS: T-31-2021, the respondents are at liberty to take appropriate
action in accordance with law.
21. WPA No. 24149 of 2025 is allowed. Accordingly, all connected
applications are disposed of.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review