Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 246 of 2019
Date of Decision: 02.05.2023
Smti. Surmamon Nongbri & Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. P.K. Shati, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. A.H. Hazarika, GA with
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The present writ petition by the instant petitioners is a
second round of litigation which had earlier culminated in a writ
appeal being Writ Appeal No. 54 of 2017, which was disposed of on
26.09.2017, by allowing the petitioners to make a representation
before the Chief Secretary for an expeditious decision on their
prayers.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the writ petitioners are
stated to be owners of land situated at Village Nongkrem, Laitlyngkot
(Nongkynrih), East Khasi Hills District, where the construction of the
„Wahtyngngai Combined Water Supply Scheme‟ (RCC Dam) under
the National Rural Development Water Project Scheme (NRDWP),
for supplying water to over 30 villages situated in the neighbouring
areas, was undertaken by the PHE Department, in the year 2006-07.
The grievance of the writ petitioners is that, portions of their land had
been inundated after the construction of the RCC Dam, and that
though some steps had been taken by the concerned Department for
calculating the estimate of the probable cost of land compensation,
the same did not culminate into any acquisition proceedings as per
laid down procedure, which has deprived them of their property,
without the due process of law being followed, or they being paid
adequate and fair compensation under the relevant Land Acquisition
Act.
3.
Pursuant to the order of the Division Bench in the earlier
round of litigation, the writ petitioners had submitted representations
on 06.10.2017, and though steps were then taken by the respondents
to address the issue, due to the uncertainty and lack of clarity as to
which Land Acquisition Act would be applicable i.e., the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 or the new Act, namely the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013, the matter stood unresolved. Further the
stand of the respondents changed, as by the counter affidavit filed in
the present proceedings, the respondents have made a categorical
statement that none of the petitioners‟ land had been affected and the
inundation that has been alleged has not occurred after 2011, and as
such there is no question of compensation.
4.
In the course of the instant proceedings before this Court,
to ascertain the claims of the writ petitioners as many disputed facts
had arisen, this Court by order dated 21.06.2022, apart from other
directions given therein, ordered for a spot inspection of the site in
question. The learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, Shillong
with the assistance of an Officer in the rank of Additional Deputy
Commissioner, was directed to file a report, as to whether any portion
of the land of the petitioners had been taken over, in connection with,
and for the use of the said „Wahtyngngai Combined Water Supply
Scheme‟ (RCC Dam). A report was then submitted on 05.08.2022
before this Court but however, apart from observing that there was
nothing to indicate that the land situated on the banks of the said
Scheme had been acquired, it was also reported that no process of
land acquisition had been initiated. The report therefore, being vague
and inconclusive, as neither any definite plots have been identified
which were said to have been inundated, or having arrived at any
other conclusive findings, this Court therefore cannot place any
reliance on the same for effective adjudication of the matter.
5.
In this backdrop, Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Senior
counsel assisted by Mr. P.K. Shati, learned counsel on behalf the writ
petitioners submits that it is a fact, that portions of the lands of the
writ petitioners after construction of the RCC Dam in 2011, were
inundated and that proceedings and estimate for land compensation
had been initiated. He submits that, the respondent No. 11 (Executive
Engineer, PHE), pursuant to a communication from the Deputy
Commissioner, Revenue, as to whether the PHE still intended to
proceed with the land acquisition under the Act, of 1894, in view of
the coming into force of the new Act of 2013, had communicated on
18.07.2018, that compensation, had been assessed at Rs. 6,64,51,580/(Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs Fifty-One Thousand Five
Hundred and Eighty only), of which Rs. 5 Crores, had been placed at
the disposal of the Deputy Commissioner. The learned Senior counsel
then submits that, as it was felt that the new Act of 2013 would be
applicable, re-evaluation was done by the PHE, and submitted to the
Deputy Commissioner for an amount of Rs.78,87,43,573/- (Rupees
Seventy-Eight Crores Eighty-Seven Lakhs Forty-Three Thousand
Five Hundred and Seventy-Three only), and the same was
communicated to the Joint Secretary, Revenue and Disaster
Management, Government of Meghalaya. He submits that thereafter
from 07.12.2018, after the said communication, and even in spite of
issuance of a legal notice on 07.02.2019, addressed to the Chief
Secretary for settlement of the matter, no relief was forthcoming and
in fact due to inordinate delay the petitioners have been deprived of
rightful compensation.
6.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the respondent
State has taken over the agricultural land of the writ petitioners
without the due process of law, or by invoking the relevant statute,
and though it may appear that disputed of facts have arisen, the matter
being purely of compensation, this Court under Article 226 can issue
directions to award such compensation to the writ petitioners. The
learned counsel then submits, the change in the stance of the
respondents in the affidavit, whereby averments have been made that
the land is not required, or that no compensation is payable is a
complete turnaround of the earlier position, inasmuch as, valuation
had even been done with regard to the amount of compensation that
the petitioners were entitled to.
The learned Senior counsel in support of his case, has relied on
the following decisions: On the question of disputed facts:
i)
M.C. Mehta vs. Union of India & Ors. (2003) 5 SCC 376
(Para 20)
ii)
Century Spinning and Manufacturing Company Ltd. & Anr.
vs. The Ulhasnagar Municipal Council & Anr. (1970) 1 SCC
528 (Para 13)
iii)
ABL International Ltd. & Anr. vs. Export Credit Guarantee
Corporation of India Ltd & Ors. (2004) 3 SCC 553 (Para 16
and 51)
iv)
National Thermal Power Corporation Limited vs. Mahesh
Dutta & Ors. (2009) 8 SCC 339 (Para 38 & 39)
v)
C.A. No. 5577 of 1998, order dated 27.04.2004 in the case of
H.S.E.B. vs. Ram Nath.
Reliance has also been placed on the following decisions
with regard to deprivation of property and violation of Article 300A
of the Constitution of India and on the change of stance of the
respondents.
i)
Tukaram Kana Joshi & Ors. vs. Maharashtra Industrial
Development Corporation & Ors. (2013) 1 SCC 353 (Para
9,10,11,12,17 and 22)
7.
ii)
Mahanadi Coal Fields Ltd & Anr. vs. Mathias Oram &
Ors. (2010) 11 SCC 269 (Para 10,11,12,14,19 and 21)
iii)
Bhimandas Ambwani (Dead) Through LRS. Vs. Delhi
Power Company Ltd. (2013) 14 SCC 195 (Para 14)
iv)
Vinod Kumar vs. Surjit Kaur AIR (1987) SC 2179 (Para
11)
v)
Cauvery Coffee Traders, Mangalore vs. Hornor Resources
(International) Co. Ltd. (2011) 10 SCC 420 (Para 34 and
35)
vi)
Bibhudatta Mohanty vs. Union of India & Ors. (2002) 4
SCC 16 (Para 11)
The learned Senior counsel has also referred to the
affidavits filed by the respondents and submits that, the Agreement
Deed dated 05.05.2007, signed by the petitioner and others and
annexed to the affidavit of the respondents PHE, wherein the
petitioner had agreed to donate the land situated at Dkong
Nongkynrih for the construction of the Water Supply Scheme, was
never acted upon and cannot be considered to be a bar for the
petitioners to claim compensation. He submits that, the very fact that,
land compensation was assessed by the respondents, points to the fact
that the agreement was a non-starter. On the other ground taken by
the respondents that the acquisition process was not necessary, and
that the money already deposited with the Deputy Commissioner, was
for payment of compensation to the affected persons whose standing
crops were damaged due to the overflow of Wahtyngngai Scheme,
which had happened in 2011 and not thereafter, the learned Senior
counsel contends that the same is untenable, as at the relevant point of
time, there was no mention of compensation for any damage. He
finally submits that, the statement that, no land of the petitioners was
taken over for the said project and as such, no compensation is
payable, is farfetched and made without any basis whatsoever,
inasmuch as, there was a conscious decision by the respondents at the
time of the project to acquire portions of the land of the petitioners.
8.
Mr. A.H. Hazarika, learned GA for the State respondents
in his reply submits that, the prayer as set out in the writ petition is
not tenable, as a mandamus has been sought to direct the respondents
to pay suitable compensation as per the provisions of the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act, 2013, for land allegedly taken over or
submerged, where in fact, no proceedings had ever been initiated for
the same. The learned GA submits that the provisions of the Act of
2013, have to be gone into for acquisition and has drawn the attention
of this Court to Section 11 which stipulates that, when land is
required or likely to be required for any public purpose, a preliminary
notification to that effect along with details of the land is to be
published in the manner provided therein. He contends that, no such
procedure having ever been adopted by the respondents, there is no
question of payment of any land compensation, especially when there
is no requirement for the same. The learned GA, has not advanced
any further arguments, but submits that, on other grounds reliance is
placed on the affidavits filed by the State respondents.
9.
I have heard learned counsels for the parties. This Court
notes that, even on a cursory examination of the matter, it is faced
with a bewildering chain of events, which smack of attempts at
circumventing due process by interested parties in the PHE
Department, at that point of time, all at the expense of the poor land
owners who were caught in the middle of this controversy and left to
pursue this litigation with no relief in immediate sight. This
observation is made in view of the facts and events that unfolded in
the matter since the inception of the project i.e., „Wahtyngngai
Combined Water Supply Scheme‟ (RCC Dam), which are laid out
below.
i)
From the affidavit of the respondent No. 7 (Additional Chief
Engineer, PHE Engineer), it is seen that, prior to the
implementation of the water supply scheme for construction
of the RCC Dam, an agreement was entered on 05.05.2007,
between the Synjuk ki saw Rangbah Shnong, Nongkynrih,
Khyrim Syiemship in which the petitioner Smti. Surmamon
Lyngdoh and along with other land owners signed and
submitted to the respondent PHE department, which
included a map of the said area. In the said agreement, the
petitioner agreed to donate the land situated in Dkong
Nongkynrih, free of cost without compensation and free of
charges ad taxes, whatsoever and the land would be vested
with the Durbar free from all encumbrances.
ii)
In 2006-07, the construction of RCC Dam under the
National
Rural
Development
Water
Project
(herein
mentioned as NRDP) at River Umiew under Nongkynrih
Village, East Khasi Hills District, commenced and was
completed in 2011, the year where allegedly, the lands of
the petitioners was inundated due to high water levels. The
Government through respondent No. 13, Collector, East
Khasi Hills, then made an estimation to acquire the said
lands affected by construction of dam which was assessed at
Rs.6,64,51,580.00/- (Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs
Fifty-One Thousand Five Hundred and Eighty only) to be
paid under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and subject to
government‟s approval. It is noted that, no proper
acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 were initiated by the respondents at that stage.
iii)
The petitioners apparently being unaware as to the situation
of the proceedings, filed an application under the Right to
Information Act, 2005 on 29.02.2016, seeking information
as to whether the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 had been applied in connection with the acquisition,
which on 14.03.2016, was replied to the effect that, the state
was yet to invoke the provisions of the Act. Being aggrieved
thereby on 04.04.2016, the writ petitioners filed the first
writ petition registered as WP (C) No. 117 of 2016 before
the High Court.
iv)
By order dated 08.09.2016, the matter was disposed of, by
the Learned Single Judge, directing the writ petitioners to
make a representation before the respondent Collector,
which was appealed therefrom, before the Division Bench.
The Division Bench of this Court, then by order dated
26.09.2017, modified the impugned order of the Single
Bench, and directed the Chief Secretary of the Government
to take appropriate decision and expeditiously settle the
matter within 90 days on receiving the representation from
the writ petitioners.
v)
On 14.03.2018, as per the order passed by the Learned
Division bench, the Chief Secretary informed the writ
petitioners that on their representation, to acquire their land,
the respondent PHE has taken necessary steps in pursuing
the matter, and the matter relating to land compensation was
being
taken
up
for
consideration
with
concerned
Departments.
vi)
A letter No. L14/5(2)2012/11 dated 15.02.2016, then
surfaces wherein, it is seen, the Deputy Commissioner
Revenue, had queried the PHE Department, with regard to
the status on the land acquisition, for which the documents
had been submitted on 16.07.2012, but no information
received thereafter. It was also noted in the letter that, the
earlier estimated compensation of Rs.6,64,51,580.00/(Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs Fifty-One Thousand
Five Hundred and Eighty only) was no longer relevant as
the new Land Acquisition Act of 2013 would be applicable
for acquiring the land of the petitioners.
vii)
The respondent PHE then vide letter dated 18.07.2018,
requested the Collector to exempt the application of the new
Act of 2013 and to proceed under the old Land Acquisition
Act,
with
the
earlier
estimated
amount
of
Rs.6,64,51,580.00/- (Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs
Fifty-One Thousand Five Hundred and Eighty only), of
which Rs. 5 crores has been sanctioned and the remaining
amount subject to sanction of the government. However, on
29.08.2018, the PHE requested the Collector to re-evaluate
the amount of compensation as per the new act of 2013, and
not the old Act. In pursuance thereof, the Collector reevaluated the compensation amount under the new Act of
2013, and a new amount for compensation of Rs.
78,87,43,573/- (Rupees Seventy Eight Crores Eighty-Seven
Lakhs Four Three Thousand and
Five Hundred and
Seventy-Three only) for acquiring the lands of the
petitioners, was arrived at.
viii) Communications
thereafter
on
07.12.2018-
intra
departmentally were made, from the Collector to the Joint
Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Revenue &
Disaster Management Department for information and
approval. On 25.01.2019, the PHE requested the Collector
to furnish the newly estimated amount under the new Act of
2013, for submission of the same to the government for
sanction.
On
01.02.2019,
the
respondent
Collector
forwarded the copy of the estimated amount to the PHE, for
approval of the state indicating it is an “urgent matter” and
that inordinate delay was caused by the PHE.
ix)
On 07.02.2019, the petitioners issued a legal notice to the
Chief Secretary, and urged him to expedite the payment to
the petitioners, as the estimated amount of compensation has
already been forwarded by the Collector, whereafter on
14.02.2019, the Executive Engineer PHE, then submitted
the estimate to the Superintending Engineer, PHE for
necessary action. On 07.03.2018 another legal notice was
issued to the Chief Secretary and Principal Secretary, PHE
for payment of suitable compensation.
x)
A meeting was then held on 29.05.2019, chaired by the
Chief Secretary, which took the following decisions:
i.
The Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi Hills shall verify
the matter in detail and submit the information to the
Principal Secretary, to the Government of Meghalaya,
PHE Department as to how the new assessment has been
made.
ii.
Re-assess the whole process of acquiring of land only if
the land is required for keeping the scheme functional.
xi)
Thereafter, the Deputy Commissioner, then made an
assessment of the old probable cost of Rs. 6,64,51,580/(Rupees Six Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs Fifty-One Thousand
Five Hundred and Eighty only), as compared to the new
estimated probable cost of Rs. 78,87,43,573 (Rupees
Seventy-Eight Crores Eighty-Seven Lakhs Forty-Three
Thousand Five Hundred and Seventy-Three only), and
forwarded the same to the PHE.
xii)
However, it appears the Government thereafter decided not
to initiate land acquisition proceedings for the aforesaid
project, and took the stand, that the amount that was
assessed earlier, and 5 crores deposited with the Collector,
was for payment of compensation to the affected persons,
whose standing crops was damaged only in the year 2011
and not thereafter. The present stand by the State is that, no
land of the petitioners was ever taken over for the said
project, and therefore, question of payment of land
compensation does not arise. In this context, it is noteworthy
to refer to a report under a covering letter dated 25.2.2020
issued by the Chief Engineer, PHE, wherein it has been
observed as follows.
Report on Providing Compensation to Land Owners upstream of the
RCC Dam of Wahtyngngai Combined Water Supply Scheme
1. Wahtyngngai Combined Water Supply Scheme intended to
provide water supply to villages under Raid Nongkynrih and
under Laitlyngkot Sirdarship was accorded sanction vide
Administrative Approval No. PHE.341/2006/80 under NRDWP
on March 2007 for an amount of ₹10,90,08,500.00 (Rupees Ten
Crore Ninety Lakh Eight Thousand Five Hundred) only.
2. The scheme envisages pumping of water from river Umiew at
Dkong to the Main Reservoir located at Lumthanding, the
highest point among the Villages, whereby water shall then be
distributed to different villages in the Scheme.
3. One of the major components in the scheme involves
construction of RCC Dam across the river Umiew at Dkong
near Nongkynrih village for creating necessary head for the
water to flow to Slow Sand Filtration Plant located
downstream of the Dam.
4. Construction of the Dam across river Umiew, at Dkong under
the jurisdiction of Raid Nongkynrih, was taken up following the
permission accorded by the Nongkynrih Village Durbar. The
Dam, initially meant to be of 5.00m in height, was constructed
at a height of 3.75m above bed level approximately just
sufficient enough to create necessary head for water to
gravitate to the Filtration Plant. The height was reduced in
order to avoid inundation of cultivable land.
5. The villages upstream of the Dam raised their concern during
the rainy season of 2011 on flooding of cultivable land. Though
the construction of the Dam across river Umiew at Dkong was
taken up at the sloping portion of the river for possible
avoidance of inundation of areas upstream of the Dam but on
account of heavy rain there was backflash of water impounded
against the Dam. However, there has not been any report of
inundation of cultivable land after 2011.
Executive Engineer (PHE)
Electrical Division
Mawphlang
10.
The entire saga as noted hereinabove, are akin to the
shifting sands of the desert, on account of the shifting stands of the
petitioners and the respondents, and where the proceedings are not
based on any foundation, and in fact, have been visited with events
and circumstances, which has effectively frustrated any meaningful
outcome. This observation is being made on account of the fact that,
from the inception of the project itself, the respondents never made
any effort to gauge the effect or impact the project would have on the
petitioners‟ land, nor any exercise as per law conducted, to assess the
requirement of land. Added to this quagmire, is the existence of an
agreement dated 05.05.2007, donating the land in the vicinity of the
project by the petitioner to the respondents, and the subsequent
purported rescinded compromise agreement for acceptance of
compensation at the earlier assessment of over 6 Crores. What
followed was the sham of assessment and fixation of the value of the
land, that was supposed to be acquired, at a cost of over 78 Crores,
which is approximately 13 times, the earlier assessment, on a project
worth about 10 Crores, which certainly raises serious doubts about the
object of the entire exercise. What is remarkable, is that without any
due process being adopted under the relevant Land Acquisition
statute, a huge amount of public money was sought to be obtained and
disbursed in a shortcut manner.
11.
It is observed that, it is only after the meeting dated
29.05.2019, that the matter assumed some direction, which
culminated in the decision of the respondents, as given in the
affidavit, that no land of the petitioners had been taken over and that
the petitioners were not entitled to claim any compensation. It is
undeniable that, due process such as, notifications under the Land
Acquisition Act of 1894, which was the prevailing act then, were
never issued identifying the land required or its owners. No material
exists to show that, the Collector had ever issued any notification.
What is present however, is the overreaching activity of the PHE
Department in rushing to deposit Rs. 5 Crores before the Collector at
that point of time, even though, no proceedings under law existed, to
warrant assessment in the absence of appropriate notifications.
12.
It is not known, or has it been discerned as to the extent
of, or whether any land was acquired at all, or submerged as alleged
by the petitioners which is now disputed by the respondents. The only
point or fact that seems to make any sense, as to the rival arguments is
that, as per the report which has been quoted earlier, some lands had
been submerged in 2011, which had affected the cultivation and crops
of the petitioners, which has somehow morphed into the present
dispute. Even the spot inquiry conducted on 22.07.2022, by the
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Shillong, under orders of this
Court, failed to arrive at any definite finding and does not reveal any
reliable evidence as to the exact physical situation, as to whether any
land has been submerged. Even the individual plots said to be
affected, and its owners were not identified in the said report, which
in effect only reiterated the known position that, no acquisition
proceedings, were ever adopted in the course of the execution of the
project.
13.
Looking into the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, which was
the relevant Act, at that point of time, sections 1 to 3 give the short
title, object and reasons and the important definitions. Sections 4 to
17 deals with the process of acquisition. Then comes sections 18 to 28
which describes the reference to court and procedure thereupon, in the
off chance of a conflict with respect to compensation. Sections 29 and
30 deal with apportionment in case of more than one individual
interested, and section 3 to 34 lay down the payment of
compensation. The mandatory provisions of the Land Acquisition
Act, are therefore to be compulsorily followed, in such projects,
which involves the occupation or acquisition of private lands. The
Collector in any process of land acquisition, holds a very crucial
position and exercises power under the Act, to arrive at an award,
after all the stages as stipulated by the Act, have been complied with,
such as, the issuance of appropriate notifications under Section 4, 5A
and so on. The award should also contain the following.
14.
i)
Correct area of land.
ii)
Amount of compensation he thinks should be given
iii)
Apportionment of compensation.
In the instant case, there is no semblance of any
procedure under the old Act, nor any procedure initiated under the
new Act, namely the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition Act, etc., 2013, apart from fixation of the probable
compensation on an unknown basis, at an amount of over 78 Crores
87 Lakhs for land compensation. It is also pertinent to note that, the
initial assessment of over 6 Crores has later been termed by the
respondents, not to be on account of award for land compensation, but
for the damages that the petitioners incurred, due to the destruction of
crops in the year 2011, when some lands were inundated and
damaged, but which has not occurred since.
15.
In this backdrop of events and circumstances, where
nothing is clear to facilitate conclusive adjudication, this Court in the
absence of any due process being adopted by the respondents, and
looking into the plight of the land owners, who may, or may not have
been affected after 2011, but however, have been pursuing this
litigation, deems it fit, inspite of the presence of disputed facts, to
direct as follows:i)
the respondent in the PHE department shall from
available records, such as, the details contained in
the affidavit filed by the State respondents in
WP(C) No. 117 of 2016, which is annexed to the
writ petition, as well as, by fresh survey identify
and establish as to whether lands of the petitioners
remain submerged after 2011, till date.
ii)
if the same after survey and examination is found
to be true as alleged by the petitioners, the
respondents
shall
initiate
the
process
for
acquisition of the said portions of land that have
remained submerged till date.
iii)
if it is found otherwise, that after only one instance
in 2011, portions of land had been submerged,
which
has
not
occurred
since,
after
due
identification of the owners and the plots that were
affected in 2011, the Collector shall from the
amount of Rs.6,64,51,581.00/- (Rupees Six Crores
Sixty Four Lakhs Fifty One Thousand Five
Hundred and Eighty-One) only deposited by the
PHE, since 20.09.2018, apportion the said amount
as compensation to the land owners, after due
assessment and examination of their respective
plots.
16.
The above noted directions have been passed considering
the nature of the case, especially the stand of the respondents that, no
land of the petitioners is required nor there is any proposal for
acquisition. Coupled with this fact, is the impact on the exchequer,
such an acquisition will have, if entered into at this stage, especially
taking into account the project cost which is only of about 10 Crores.
Further, it is also not deemed practicable or reasonable, to direct the
writ petitioners to seek alternate remedy or to relegate them to the
Civil Courts, and subject them to endless litigation.
17.
Accordingly, as ordered and directed above, this writ
petition stands closed and is disposed of.
18.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
02.05.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review