Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(1)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Rajasekhar Mantha
And
The Hon’ble Justice Md. Shabbar Rashidi
CRA 618 of 2016
Surjyo Haldar @ Tanmoy Halder @ Surya Halder & Ors.
Vs.
The State of West Bengal
With
CRA 124 of 2021
With
CRAN 1 of 2021
With
CRAN 2 of 2024
Banamali Sharma
Vs.
The State of West Bengal & Anr.
With
CRA 241 of 2016
Indrajit Deb @ Khapa
Vs.
The State of West Bengal
With
CRA 746 of 2015
With
CRAN 1 of 2016 (Old No: CRAN 3336 of 2016)
With
CRAN 2 of 2025
Tanmoy Chatterjee
Vs.
The State of West Bengal
For the Appellant in CRA 124 of 2021: Mr. Moinak Bakshi
Ms. Niketa Bhattacharjee
For the Appellant in CRA 746 of 2015 : Mr. Partha Sarathi Bhattacharyya
Ms. Sukla Das Chandra
Mr. Bhaskar Seth
Ms. Swarnali Saha
For the Appellant in CRA 618 of 2016 : Mr. Saryati Datta
& CRA 241 of 2016
For the State
: Mr. Madhusudan Sur, Ld. A.P.P.
Mr. Mainak Gupta
Heard on
: 17.02.2026 & 19.02.2026
Judgment on
: 19.02.2026.
Rajasekhar Mantha, J.:
1.
The subject appeals are directed against a judgement and order of
conviction dated 30th September, 2015 and 5th October, 2015 respectively,
passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Bishnupur, Bankura in
Sessions
Trial
No.04(04)/2007
arising
out
of
Sessions
Case
No.01(02)/2007.
2.
The appellants were convicted under Section 302 of the IPC to suffer
rigorous imprisonment for life and with fine of Rs.10,000/- each.
In
default thereof, to suffer further imprisonment for a term of two years.
Fine amount, if realized, is to be paid to the mother of the victim.
3.
The appellants were also sentenced under the later part of the first
paragraph of Section 307 of the IPC to suffer rigorous imprisonment for
life and with fine of Rs.5,000/- each. In default thereof, to suffer
imprisonment for a term of one year. Fine amount, if realized, was to be
paid to the mother of the injured victims. The sentences were run
consecutively after the expiry of other.
PROSECUTION CASE,THE EVIDENCE ON RECORD AND ANALYSIS OF
THIS COURT:
4.
On 8th January, 2006, the appellants namely Tanmoy Chatterjee,
Banamali Sharma @ Rakshit, Sagar Bauri, Kartick Bauri @ Bagdi, Surya
Haldar and Indrajit Deb @ Khapa entered the house of PW-1 Ramchandra
De at village Hut Krishnanagar, Bankura at about 1:30 am. The house
was large in size. The victims Susanta Dey, Prasanta Dey, Sumonta Dey
and Srikanta Dey(deceased victim) lived there and were present in the said
house.
5.
The said Susanta Dey, Prasanta Dey, Sumonta Dey and Srikanta
Dey were sleeping in their rooms in the house. The appellants were
carrying sharp cutting weapons like, bhojali, khukri and knifes and
attacked the victims with the said weapons. There were long pending land
dispute between the parties. While running away from the P.O the
appellant threw a bomb at P.W1. It however hit a wall. P.W1 hid away out
of fear.
6.
The injured victims sustained serious injuries and were initially
taken to Patrasayer BPHC and latter to Bankura Medical College and
Hospital. They recovered from their injuries.
7.
The appellants, however, inflicted fatal injures on said Srikanta Dey
that his internal organs from the abdomen protruded and fell out at the
PO. He was also taken to Patrasayer BPHC, where he was declared dead.
8.
All the appellants except Surya Haldar fled the place of occurrence.
Surya Haldar was restrained by two of the injured witnesses and their
family members and tied him with a post.
9.
The police arrived at the place of occurrence early in the morning.
The incident was witnessed by PW-1 Ramchandra De, PW-4 Lakxikanta
De, PW-5 Rawni Dey, PW-6 Smt. Hiru Dey, PW-7 Soma Sharma, PW-9
Smt. Priya Dey, PW-10 Smt. Purnima Dey and PW-11 Piru Dey. They
were eye witnesses.
10.
PW-14 Prasanta Dey, PW-16 Srimanta Dey and PW-17 Sushanta
Dey were the injured eyewitnesses.
11.
A UD case was registered in respect of the said incident. The
inquest on the deceased victim, was conducted by PW-33 SI Phalari
Kumar, who was also the investigating officer. The said inquest was
witnessed by PW-1 Ramchandra De, PW-2 Jagabandhu Sutradhar, PW-3
Haru Banerjee, PW-4 Lakxikanta De and PW-12 Sadhananda Sharma. It
was conducted at the Patrasayer BPHC.
12.
All the accused persons were later arrested from time to time.
13.
On the leading statement of the accused Indrajit Deb @ Khapa,
Banamali Sharma, and Tanmoy, the police seized the blood stained
weapons and a bomb. The I.O also seized blood stained earth and a bomb
splintered earth from the P.O.
14.
PW-1 Ramchandra De woke up first after the incident. He shouted
to alert the others.
15.
Indrajit Deb @ Khapa threw a bomb which hit the wall of the said
house. The earth strained with the splinters of the bomb also seized by the
police. Another bomb was recovered from the appellant/ Indrajit Deb @
Khapa.
16.
After investigation was completed by PW-33 SI Phalari Kumar and
PW-34, charge sheet was filed. Charges were framed against the
appellants under Sections 149, 302 and 307 of the IPC.
17.
PW-1 Ramchandra De filed a formal complaint after Srikanta Dey
was declared
death.
The complaint was written by PW-2 Jagabandhu
Sutradhar, on the instruction of PW-1 Ramchandra De.
18.
The list of prosecution witnesses are given below:PW-1 : Ramchandra De, uncle of the deceased.
PW-2 : Jagabandhu Sutradhar, scribe and nephew of PW-1.
PW-3: Haru Banerjee, local villager and a seizure witness
PW-4: Lakxikanta De, cousin of the injured witnesses and an
eyewitness
PW-5: Rawni Dey, granddaughter of PW-1 and an eyewitness.
PW-6: Smt. Hiru Dey, wife of PW-1 and an eyewitness.
PW-7: Soma Sharma, neice of PW-1
PW-8: Subhas Kundu, a seizure witness
PW-9: Smt. Priya Dey, wife of Prasanta Dey who was an injured
eyewitness.
PW-10: Smt. Purnima Dey, granddaughter of PW-1 and wife of
Susanta Dey, the injured witness.
PW-11: Smt. Piru Dey, wife of Panchanan Dey and sister-in-law of
PW-1.
PW-14: Prasanta Dey, injured victim and an eyewitness.
PW-16, Srimanta Dey, nephew of PW-1 and an injured eyewitness.
PW-17: Sushanta Dey, injured victim and eyewitness.
PW-18: Meghnad Bagdi, a local villager and a seizure witness.
PW-19: Jaladhar Sutradhar, a seizure witness and maternal uncle
of accused Banamali Sharma
PW-20: Milan Karmakar, Seizure witness.
PW-21: ASI R. Pati, a police personnel and a seizure witness.
PW-22: NVF S. Ghosh, a police personnel and seizure witness.
PW-23: Const. A.K. Sarkar, a police personnel and seizure witness.
PW-24: Const. A. Sannigrahi, a police personnel and seizure
witness.
PW-25: Const. B. Misra, police personnel and inquest witness, who
took dead body to morgue.
PW-26: Const. D. Das, police personnel and seizure witness.
PW-29:
Dr.
Ramkrishna
Mondal,
Medical
Officer
of
the
Patrasayer BPHC
PW-30: Dr. D. Gautom is an Associate Professor of Surgery at
Bankura Sammilani Medical College & Hospital.
19.
PW-1 Ramchandra De, PW-4 Lakxikanta De, PW-5 Rawni Dey, PW-6
Smt. Hiru Dey, PW-7 Soma Sharma, PW-9 Smt. Priya Dey, PW-10 Smt.
Purnima Dey and PW-11 Smt. Piru Dey narrated the entire incident on the
lines of the prosecution case in course of trial. Their statements were
recorded by the investigating officer in course of investigation.
20.
The evidence of PW-14 Prasanta Dey, PW-16 Srimanta Dey and PW-
17 Sushanta Dey, who are injured witnesses, clearly establish the role of
each of the appellants in commission of the crime.
21.
The formal FIR was written by PW-32, SI P.C. Roy.
22.
The
injured
witnesses
including
the
deceased
were
initially
examined by PW-29 Dr. Ramkrishna Mondal at the Patrasayer BPHC, who
detailed injuries of the victims. The injury report was exhibited and taken
on record. The referral card of the victim to Bankura Hospital was also
taken on record.
23.
PW-30, Dr. D. Gautom, who treated the injured victims at the
Bankura Medical College and Hospital.
Exhibit-17, Exhibit-18 and
Exhibit-19 were the bed head tickets, referral cards and discharge
certificates of the injured victims.
24.
PW-29, another person also named Dr. Ramkrishna Mondal, was a
Medical Officer of the Patrasayer BPHC listed out the following injuries on
the victims, which are set out hereinbelow:“I found injuries on the person of Susanta Dey, 1. Stab
injury on the right side of abdomen and part of small
intestine is out from the wound, 2. 1 and half inch
incised wound back of the right knee joint, 3. 2 inches
incised wound below and medial size of right knee, 4.
10 inches chop wound lateral side of right thigh, 5. 2
inches incised wound left side of buttocks.
On examination of Srimanta Dey I found 1. One inch
incised wound on left hand.
On examination of Prasanta Dey I found 1. Five inches
incised wound back of waist.
The parties were brought by Kartick Ch. Bit,
Laxmikanta Dey and Tarapada Sharma. The patients
were referred to the Bankura Sammilani Medical
College & Hospital for better treatment on that date.
The details of reports injuries may be obtained from
higher center. This is the document which was sent to
the OC Patrasayer PS stating therein the injuries of the
injured persons. This document was written by me
which also bears my signature and seal. The document
is marked exbt. 15.
In case of injuries of Susanta Dey the same may
be caused by bhojali or sharp cutting weapon. This is a
referral card which was written by me. This referral
card is marked exbt. 16 which relates to the injured
person namely Prasanta Dey. Under the same process
Srimanta Dey and Susanta Dey were also referred.”
25.
The injuries of Susanta Dey, Srimanta Dey and Prasanta Dey were
enlisted by PW-30, Dr. D. Gautom, which are set out hereinbelow:“On examination I found the following injuries of
Susanta Dey.
Stab wound in the thigh and mid abdomen. Colon was
also stabbed. He was brought to OT and Emergency
surgery was done on that date. The patient was also
admitted on that date and he was discharged on
18.1.06. This is that referral card which was issued
from the BPHC. This is the BHT. This is the discharge
certificate. These documents are marked exbt. 17
series. The injuries were grievous in nature. The
injuries were also caused by sharp cutting weapon.
After examination of Srimanta Dey I found the
following injuries.
Stab injury over left palm and wrist. The patient was
admitted on 8.1.06 and he was discharged on 10.1.06.
This is the referral card. This is the BHT and this is the
discharge certificate which are marked as exbt. 18 series.
The injuries were caused by stabbing.
After examination of Prasanta Dey I found the
following injuries:Stab injury in the back. This is the BHT and this is the
discharge certificate which are marked as exbt.19 series.
The treatment sheets of all the patients have been
attached with the certificates.
There is similarity in respect of the injuries which
were noticed by Dr. RamKrishna Mondal of Patrasayer
BPHC with the injuries which I found. Exbt.15 is al
shown to the witness.”
26.
PW-33 Phalari Kumar was the first investigating officer, who took up
the investigation on the date of the incident. He conducted the inquest on
the victim Srikanta Dey. He seized the clothes of the victim and the bomb
strained earth. He also recovered one more bomb and a bulb. PW-1 and
other witnesses identified the appellants.
27.
On the leading statements under Section 27 of the Evidence Act of
Kartick Bauri @ Bagdi, Tanmoy Chatterjee, Surya Haldar and Indrajit Deb
@ Khapa and Banamali on different dates, the I.O recovered the offending
weapons namely a Chora/Knife, two or three Bhojalis and a Khukri and a
bomb.
28.
PW-34 is the second investigating officer who claims to have sent
one of the Bhojalis for FSL. But no FSL report was, however, produced in
Court and only some of the offending weapons were produced.
29.
The post mortem on the deceased victim was conducted by PW-27
Dr. T.K. Pal, who stated that several injuries on the body of the victim in
the nature of incised wounds that were homicidal and ante mortem in
nature. The victim died due to hemorrhage shock. He identified the post
mortem report in the trial, which was exhibited as Exhibit No.-14. He
confirmed that the injuries might have been inflicted by Bhojali and kukri.
30.
A confessional statement of Surya Haldar was also taken on record
by the Trial Court.
31.
Having regard to the evidence that has come up on record, the Trial
Judge convicted each of the appellants under Sections 302 and 307 of the
IPC.
32.
Mr. Moinak Bakshi, learned counsel for the appellant, Banamali
Sharma has argued that the appellants not having been convicted under
Section 149 of the IPC or even under Section 34 of the IPC the prosecution
was required to prove the role of each of the appellants in the commission
of the crime. Absence of Section 34 of the IPC would negate common
intention. Absence of Section 149 of the IPC, according to Mr. Bakshi,
would not prove that the appellants and each of them acted in concert and
as part of a prior assembly and with common motive.
33.
This Court, however, notes that the role of each of the appellants
have been clearly and distinctly described by the injured witnesses namely
PW-14 Prasanta Dey, PW-16 Srimanta Dey, PW-17 Sushanta Dey. The
Trial
Court
found
common
intention
amongst
the
appellants
in
committing the offence against the victims.
34.
Section 34 and 149 of the IPC do not define any substantive
offences. They are invoked for the purpose of proving a premeditated
common intention or an assembly for that matter to commit a crime in
which a majority of the members of the assembly participate. The absence
of mention of Section 34 and 149 of the IPC in the order of conviction,
therefore, is not fatal to the prosecution case.
35.
The appellants were put on notice as regards the charges against
them. The framing of charge clearly linked the appellants with one
another. The appellants were made to understand by the Trial Court that
they were tried together for collectively committing the said offences on the
victims. The appellants have led evidence along the lines of they being
tried together for committing the said offences. No prejudice therefore has
been caused to the appellants for non-mention of Sec.34 and 149 of the
IPC in the impugned judgment.
36.
This
Court
further notices that
the evidence on record
is
overwhelming and proves the offence under Sections 302 and 307 of the
IPC having been committed by the appellants beyond any reasonable
doubt. The judgement and order of conviction, therefore, calls for no
interference.
37.
However, in so far as the appellant Tanmoy Chatterjee is concerned
the Trial Court records indicates that he was apprehended and
participated in the trial at the inception. While on bail, he absconded. The
trial was split by the Trial Court to proceed against the other appellants.
38.
After being apprehended, Tanmoy Chatterjee applied before the Trial
Court for recall of the witnesses, who are examined in his absence. By an
order dated 2nd January, 2014 the Trial Judge declined the prayer for
recall of the aforesaid witnesses for examination and cross-examination.
The Trial Judge was of the view that the appellant Tanmoy Chatterjee
abandoned the trial and allowed the witness action to continue against the
other accused at his own peril.
39.
The Trial Judge further attempted to reason the refusal by holding
that Tanmoy Chatterjee cannot be allowed to take advantage of his own
wrong. Based on the above reasoning the Trial Court declined the prayer
for recalling of the witnesses examined in the absence of Tanmoy
Chatterjee.
40.
Mr. Partha Sarathi Bhattacharyya, learned counsel for the appellant
Tanmoy Chatterjee has relied upon a judgement of the Supreme Court in
the case of Atam Ram and Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan reported in
(2019) 20 SCC 481 particularly paragraph 17, 20 and 24 to 26.
41.
A trial of an accused is split and is conducted independently when a
joint trial cannot be held. In JAMIN & ANR.
v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH & ANR. reported in 2025 INSC 330, it was held as follows:58…. To illustrate, say in a case with accused ‘A’ and accused ‘B’ the trial was
split-up by the court in respect of accused ‘B’ because he was found to be
absconding, then the main trial in respect of the accused ‘A’ can continue
separately without any hindrance or delay.
Emphasis Applied
42.
One of the exceptions to the conduction of the joint trial is, thus,
when the accused is absconding.
43.
A trial is split in light of Art. 21 of the Constitution of India, since
the other accused persons and the victim have a right to speedy trial.
In A.T. Mydeen v. Commr. of Customs, reported in (2022) 14 SCC
392, it was held as follows:42. The provisions of law and the essence of case laws, as discussed above, give a
clear impression that in the matter of a criminal trial against any accused, the
distinctiveness of evidence is paramount in light of accused's right to fair
trial, which encompasses two important facets along with others i.e. firstly, the
recording of evidence in the presence of accused or his pleader and
secondly, the right of accused to cross-examine the witnesses…….In other
words, the culpability of any accused cannot be decided on the basis of any
evidence, which was not recorded in his presence or his pleader's presence
and for which he did not get an opportunity of cross-examination, unless
the case falls under exceptions of law, as noted above.
43. The essence of the above synthesis is that evidence recorded in a criminal
trial against any accused is confined to the culpability of that accused
only and it does not have any bearing upon a co-accused, who has been
tried on the basis of evidence recorded in a separate trial, though for the
commission of the same offence.
44.
The consequence of a split trial is that the evdience adduced in the
other trial cannot be imported to the split trial. In MAMMAN KHAN v.
STATE OF HARYANA reported in 2025 INSC 1113, it was held as
follows:16. From the above, the following propositions stand reiterated:
(iv) Evidence recorded in one trial cannot be imported into another, which
may give rise to serious procedural complications if the trial is bifurcated;
22.....Separate
witnesses.....
trials
would
necessarily
involve
recalling
the
same
Emphasis applied
45.
The Trial Court, has in its order dated 2nd January, 2014 therefore,
has recalled its own order of splitting the Trial. It did so by relying on
the evidence of prosecution witnesses to convict Tanmoy. The trial
Court did not allow the appellant Tanmoy to recall and cross-examine
the said witnesses. A split trial is independent of the trial held earlier
even though the witnesses of the prosecution are the same in both the
Trials. The accused has a right to distinguish the same witness in his
own way. The said right is one of the facets of the fundamental right of
fair trial.
46.
Having regard to the aforesaid discussions, this Court is of the view
that the order of the Trial Judge dated 02.01.2014 refusing to recall the
witnesses who were examined in the absence of Tanmoy Chatterjee for
examination is ex facie illegal. Tanmoy Chatterjee could not have been
examined under Section 313 of the Cr. P. C. since he has not heard or
noticed the evidence of any of the witnesses, who were examined in his
absence when he was absconding. The Trial Judge ought to have
recalled the said witnesses.
47.
Hence, the conviction of Tanmoy Chatterjee by the Trial Court is
illegal and contrary to the provisions of the Cr. P. C. His conviction is
set aside.
48.
The Trial Judge shall recall all witnesses of the prosecution only to
examine the participation of Tanmoy Chatterjee in the offences alleged
against him in the charge sheet and those he has been charged with by
the Trial Court.
49.
The Trial Judge, therefore, commence afresh insofar as Tanmoy
Chatterjee is concerned.
50.
Accordingly, Tanmoy Chatterjee, the appellant in CRA 746 of 2015
shall be released on bail upon furnishing a bond of Rs.20,000/- with
two sureties of like amount each, one of whom must be local, to the
satisfaction of the Trial Judge on condition that Tanmoy Chatterjee
shall not leave the jurisdiction of the Trial Court without its leave. He
shall attend the Trial Court on all days of the split trial.
51.
In view of the above, CRA 746 of 2015 is allowed and disposed of.
Consequently all connected pending applications, if any, are also
disposed of
52.
CRA 618 of 2016, CRA 124 of 2021 and CRA 241 of 2016 are
dismissed. Consequently connected all pending applications, if any, are
also dismissed.
53.
Let the Trial Court Records be returned to the Trial Court for
necessary action as indicated herein above.
54.
All parties shall act on the server copy of this order duly downloaded
from the official website of this Court.
(Rajasekhar Mantha, J.)
I Agree.
(Md. Shabbar Rashidi, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review