Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ananya Bandyopadhyay
C.R.A. 631 of 2007
Niyati Karan
-VsKhandu Kharah & Ors.
For the Appellant
: Mr. Provas Bhattacharyya
For the Opposite Parties
: Mr. Usof Ali Dewan
Judgment on
: 06.05.2026
Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.:1. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order of acquittal dated
25.05.2007 passed by the Learned Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Paschim
Medinipur (Sadar) in T.R. No.121/1994 arising out of CR 639 of 1994
acquitting
the
appellant
of
the
charge
under
Sections
148/149/324/379/506 of the Indian Penal Code.
2. The prosecution case precisely stated on 18.06.1994 at about 10 p.m., the
accused persons under the leadership of Sri Dinesh Chandra Bhattacharya
went to the pond of the complainant at Plot No. 155 and 156 under MouzaAsnaboni with arms, deadly weapons, fishing net and started angling from
the pond. Accused Paban Kumar Ghosh had gun in his hand. The accused
persons caught about 3 quintals of fish from the pond and fled. The
witnesses saw the entire incident but could not resist and restrain them as
the accused persons were armed with deadly weapons. Prior to that incident,
the accused persons had assaulted the complainant’s husband Saktipada
Karam and his maternal uncle Sri Bamapada Ghosh with “tangi” on
18.06.1994 at about 04:30 p.m. The injured persons were taken to the
hospital by the police, where subsequently the complainant’s husband died.
The accused persons committed theft of fish from the pond of the
complainant valued about Rs.6,500/The complainant also informed the matter to the local police, who failed
to
take
any
action
on
(G.D.E.
No.430/94)
dated
22.06.1994
and
consequently the complainant also filed one declaratory suit in the Court of
the Learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division), 2nd Court. Learned Court passed an
ad interim order of injunction directing both parties to maintain status quo
which was communicated to those accused persons on 18.06.1994 at
around 02:00 p.m., and thereafter the accused persons committed such an
act.
3. Based on the aforesaid complaint,
4. charge was framed on 14.11.2006 under Sections 148/149/324/379/506 of
Indian Penal Code against 31 accused persons to which they pleaded not
guilty and claimed to be tried.
5. In order to prove its case the prosecution examined as many as 8 witnesses
and exhibited certain documents.
6. The Learned Advocate for the appellant submitted as follows:-
i.
“PW-1, Niyati Karam, was the complainant in that case. During his
examination-in-chief stated that the incident took place on 3rd Ashar,
1401 B.S., at about 04:00/4.30 p.m. At that time and date, Rabi Ghosh
came to the pond to catch fish. Her husband protested at this, then the
accused persons assaulted him with fists and blows and he fell down
near the pond. On hearing his cry herself and others went to the spot
and rescued him and sent him to hospital. On that day at about 10.30
p.m., the accused persons who were named in the complaint being
armed with lathi, gun etc., assembled on the bank and caught fish from
the pond. He further stated that she tried to resist them but the accused
persons assaulted by fist, blows and kicks. She further stated that the
pond was situated on plot no.155 and 156 of Asnaboni Mouza and due
to such theft of fish, she sustained a loss of huge amount.
During his cross-examination PW-1 stated that at relevant time the
pond was surrounded by concrete. Police came for investigation, after
her husband received injury. Bamapada Ghosh, who was admitted at
Chandmari Hospital from the evening on that day and was released
after few days. She further denied that the suggestions that the
accused persons have right title and interest in the pond.
ii.
PW-2, Tarini Prasad Santra, deposed that on the date of occurrence at
about 10 p.m., he heard a hue and cry from the house of the
complainant. He came out from his house and found that the accused
persons were catching fish from the pond of complainant. Accused
persons were armed with gun and lathis. He could identify them by the
light of Hazak which (they) had carried with them. Chuni Khamrai,
Bijoy Khamroi, Milan Santra and others also witnessed the occurrence.
iii.
PW-3, Umashankar Sahoo, deposed that the incident took place on 3rd
Ashar 1401 B.S. He found about 40 people armed with lathi, gun etc.,
assembled on the pond side and caught fish from the pond. There was
a gun in the hand of Paban Ghosh. The accused persons also brought
hazak and fishing nets. Paban Ghosh, Dinesh Bhattacharya and others
told among them to come to pond to catch fish Khandu Kharah, Anath
Bhattacharya, Kanta Shit and others came to pond and caught fishes
weighing about 3 quintals. Tarini Santra, Anima Karam, Sarathi
Karam. Niyati Karam, Kachi Patra and others witnesses the occurrence.
iv.
During his cross-examination deposed that on 18.06.1994 he went to
Kalaikonda Beat House. Police interrogated him on 19.06.1994
regarding Sakti Karam in the house of complainant. Police remained in
the spot for 1 to 2 hours. Police made a camp at the place of occurrence
on 19.06.1994. He had seen around 40 people assembled on the bank
of pond with lathi, tangi, and ballam and hazak and fishing nets.
Accused Khandu, Kanta took fish from the tank weighing about 3
quintals and took it toward Paban Ghosh.
v.
PW-4, Laxmi Ghosh, deposed the incident took place on 3rd Ashar, 1401
B.S. He heard hue and cry of Niyati Karam coming from the side of the
pond of Niyati Karam. Her house was situated at a distance of about
one minute walk from the said pond. Persons were armed with lathi,
tangi, ballam gun etc. They also brought Hazak light. Chuni Khamrai,
Tarini Santra, Kachi Patar, Niyati Karam Uma Sahoo and others also
witnessed the occurrence.
vi.
PW-5, Kachi Patra, deposed during examination-in-chief that the
incident took place on 3rd Ashar, 1401 B,S. He heard hue and cry from
house. He found persons were armed with lathi, tangi, ballam gun etc.
They also brought Hazak light and fishing net. He could not go to resist
them as they were armed.
During his cross-examination stated that police had taken him along
with Bibhuti De, Nemai De, Chandan De, Bhakti Karam from house on
14.06.1994. Police kept camp in their village from evening of
18.06.1994. To the northern side of the pond was the moram road. The
pond was used by all the villagers.
vii.
PW-6, Chunilal Khamrui, during examination-in-chief that the incident
took place on 3rd Ashar, 1401 B.S. He heard hue and cry from house.
He found persons were armed with lathi, tangi, ballam gun etc. He
could not go towards the pond as the accused persons were
threatening with dire consequences.
viii.
PW-7, Sarathi Karam, during examination-in-chief that the incident took
place on 3rd Ashar 1401 B.S. He found about 40 people armed with
lathi, gun etc. assembled on the bank and caught fish from the pond.
He heard hue and cry from house. There was a gun in the hand of
Paban Ghosh. He could not go towards the pond as the accused
persons were threatening with dire consequences. Kachi Patra, Laxmi
Ghosh, Chunilal Khamrai and others witnessed the occurrence.
ix.
PW-8, Sasanka Sekhar Kuilya, deposed the occurrence took place on
18.06.1994. He found that in the bank of the pond of complainant Sakti
Karam and Bamapada Ghosh was lying in injured condition and their
family members were surrounding them. He adduced them to inform
the Police and at around 6:30 p.m. Police came at place of occurrence.
Some of the accused persons took the fish to the house of Paban Ghosh.
Points of Arguments:x.
PW-1 Niyati Karam was an eye witness of the incident dated
18.06.1994 and had seen the entire occurrence from a close proximity
and herself suffered injury, she was assaulted by 30-35 people with
fist and blows and kicks, she was medically treated.
xi.
PW-3 Umashankar Sahoo stated in his evidence that on the ill-fated
day around 40 people armed with lathi, tangi assembled at the bank of
pond and caught fishes weighing about 3 quintal and when they
protested
the
accused
persons
threatened
them
with
dire
consequences. It might be mentioned that PW-1 and PW-3 at the same
time corroborated the evidence of PW-6, PW-7 , PW-8 and it had been
specifically stated by PW-7 that she found that accused Paban Ghosh
was
standing
with
a
gun
and
ordered
the
accused
Dinesh
Bhattacharya to catch fish from the pond.
xii.
PW-8 Sasanka Sekhar Kuilya stated in his evidence that on 18.06.1994
which he was returning to his house he found that Shakti Karam and
Bamapada Ghosh were lying on the bank of the tank in injured
condition. On that day around 10:30 p.m., he saw that 20/25 persons
with hazak light were catching fish. Delay in filing the complaint has
been properly explained as her husband expired on 18.06.1994.
xiii.
As such if all the evidence of the witness and materials on record are
taken into consideration as a whole the complaint case is proved
beyond all reasonable doubts. It is true that there was dispute
regarding a tank and the bank of the said tank which is situated in plot
no.155 and 156 under Asnaboni mouza and just prior to the incident
there was an order of Status quo by Civil Judge in Title Suit. The
complainant and his family members were in exclusive physical
possession of the aforesaid plot of land including the pond.
xiv.
But in spite of sufficient evidence the Ld. Magistrate without
considering the materials only consider the case and arguments of the
accused persons and disbelieve the complainant’s case and acquitted
the accused persons. As such the said impugned Judgment and Order
is liable to be set aside and they are liable to be convicted on the
charges which they have been acquitted.”
7. The Learned Advocate representing the respondents submitted as follows:i.
“PW-1, (Niyati Karam), complainant, she stated before the Court in chief
that she sustained a loss of Rs.6000/- to Rs.6500/- (but at the time of
examination
under
Section
before
the
Ld.
Magistrate
on
25.07.1994, she stated that she sustained a loss of about Rs.3000/-.
She also deposed that she informed the matter to police 4 (four) days
after the incident at Kalaikunda Beat House.
In cross-examination she stated that she did not know as to who
wrote the petition of complaint. The petition of complaint was written as
per construction of her father-in-law. Prior to the tank was owned by
Mitras. Police came at 4:30 p.m. on that day but never came after that.
She could not say whether the police outpost was situated at a distance
of 10/15 minutes from their house. She did not know whether decree
passed by the Ld. Civil Judge, (Jr. Div.) had been stayed by Ld. District
Judge.
ii.
PW-2, Tarani Prasad Santra, deposed before the Court in-chief that on
the date of occurrence at about 10:00 p.m., He heard a hue and cry
from the house of the complainant. He came out from his house and
found that the accused persons were catching fish from the pond of the
complainant. The accused persons were armed with gun and lathis. He
could identify them by the light of hazak which they had carried with
them. He did not try to resist them out of fear. He declined crossexamination.
iii.
PW-3, Umashankar Sahoo, deposition in chief before the Court was
similar to that of the deposition PW-2. He added that they informed the
incident in Kharagpur (local), P.S. on 22.06.1994 vide G.D. Entry No.
430 dated 22.06.1994. But the complainant deposed before the Court
that 4(four) days after the incident she informed the matter at
Kalaikunda Beat House.
In cross-examination he stated that he was the near relation of the
complainant. As he was an outsider, he was not acquainted with the
ghat of the pond. Apart from informed police and villagers he had not
done anything during the occurrence.
iv.
PW-4, (Smt. Laxmi Ghosh), in her cross-examination stated that “there
was no tank in the name of the complainant at the time”. The fish was
taken away to the house of accused Paban Ghosh.
v.
PW-5, (Kachi Patra), on 3rd Ashar, 1401 B.S., at about 10:30 p.m., he
heard a hue and cry of women-folk of Karam’s and came out from his
house. Then he found the accused persons and others being armed
with “lathi”, “tangi” etc., caught fishes from the pond of Karam's. They
also brought one hazak light and fishing net. They witnessed the
occurrence from a distance. He could not go to resist them as they were
armed. He could identify 5/7 accused persons in hazak light.
In cross examination he stated that “police kept a camp in our
village school from the evening of 18.06.1994. To the northern side of
the tank is the moram road. The tank is used by all the villagers.” He
deposed as per instruction of the complainant.
vi.
PW-6, (Chuni Lal Khamru), deposed before the Court in chief similar to
the other witnesses.
In cross examination PW-6 stated that from the house of Niyati
Karam the school was visible. There were 2(two) houses in between.
He had deposed in the murder case of Sakti Karam before Ld. 1st
Track, First Court, against the accused persons. He had also deposed
in the Title Suit before Ld. 2nd Munsif Bijoy Khamru (brother of PW-6)
was made accused in the house burn case of Khandu Khara
(Respondent No.1 in the instant appeal).
vii.
PW-7 (Sarathi Karam) also deposed before the Court in chief similar to
other witness.
viii.
PW-8 (Sasanka Sekhar Kuillya) deposed before the Court examinationin-chief that at around 6:30 p.m., police came at the P.O. Later he came
to know from Niyati Karam that accused Dinesh Bhattacharya & Ors.,
came to catch fish from the pond. He was a post occurrence witness.
In cross examination stated that he was a supporter of congress
party. He lost one election of panchayat where he stood on the congress
ticket. He did not know which party was supported by Dinesh Babu.
He was implicated as an accused in a criminal case. He did not
received any summon to depose in that case. In the petition of
complaint his name did not appear as a witnesses.
ix.
On 25.05.2007 Ld. Judicial Magistrate, 2nd Court, Midnapore delivered
the Judgement in Case No. CR 693/1994 (T.R.121/1994) whereby all
31 accused persons were found not guilty of the offence under Sections
148/149/324/379/506 Indian Penal Code and they were acquitted
under Section 248(1) Cr.P.C.
x.
The Learned Magistrate of the Trial Court, observed in the judgement,
“the defence suggested that they preferred an appeal against the
decree and the operation of such decree is stayed to which the
complainant expressed her ignorance. The complainant also drew the
attention of the Court to Exbt.-1, the injunction order passed by Ld. Civil
Judge, Jr. Div. (2nd Court), Midnapore by which the defendants of suit
were restrained to disturb the peaceful possession of the plaintiff.
Merely an interlocutory order of a civil Court is not enough to show that
the complainant exclusively possessed the disputed tank because the
interlocutory order could be totally reversed in the final trail. More so
when the witnesses of the complainant, PW-5, admitted during his
cross examination that the tank is also used by villagers and therefore
it can be said that the villagers also possess the tank.
xi.
The instant appeal was preferred against 31 persons who were
acquitted from all charges by a judgement dated- 25.05.2007 passed in
CR 639 of 1994 (T.R. 121 of 1994) by the Ld. Judicial Magistrate, 2nd
Court, Midnapore during pendency of the instant appeal being CRA No.
631 of 2007, 8(eight) persons expired before 10th May, 2023 being
Respondent No. 3, 6, 9, 13, 19, 20, 22 and 23 which appears from the
report submitted by the O/C Kharagpur Local P.S. dated-10.05.2023
and the said report was reflected from the order dated-05.06.2023
passed in the instant appeal. Thereafter respondent No. 2 namely
Baidyanath Pramanik expired on 30.05.2023 and respondent no.15
namely Shaktipada Dhal expired on 16.08.2023.
xii.
According to the petition of complaint dated- 14.07.1994, alleged
incident happened on 18.06.1994 but after a month petition of
complaint was moved without explaining the delay properly.
xiii.
The complainant stated in the petition of complaint that she sustained a
loss of Rs.6500/- for catching of fish from the pond but in her
examination under Section 200 Cr.P.C., she stated that she sustained a
loss of about Rs.3000/-.
xiv.
According to the evidence of PW-1 stated that she informed the matter
to police at Kalaikunda Beat House 4(four) days after the incident but
the PW-3 Umashankar Sahoo deposed before the Court that they
informed the incident at Kharagpur (LPS) on 22.06.1994 which was
contrary to each other.
xv.
According the evidence of PW-5 Kachi Patra stated in cross-examination
that police kept a camp in their village school from the evening of
18.06.1994. The pond was used by all the villagers. He also deposed
that as per instruction of the complainant he deposed before the Court.
xvi.
PW-1 also admitted that “prior to the tank was owned by Mitras.” It
was admitted that there was a civil suit between the parties over the
pond in question. On 28.08.2009 son of the complainant namely Sri
Sanajit Karam son of Saktipada Karam along with 3(three) others
purchased the share of the pond in question from the respondent No.22,
26, 8, 9, 5 and others by a registered deed of Kabala dated 28.08.2009
registered before the District Sub-Registrar-1, Paschim Medinipore being
Deed No.04921 for the year 2009 recorded in book no.1 CD Volume
No.15 pages from 1992 to 2010.
xvii.
Over the incident dated 18.06.1994 at 4:30 p.m., case and counter case
was started being Kharagpur local P.S. Case No.124/1994 dated
18.06.1994 and Kharagpur local P.S. Case No.125/1994 dated
18.06.1994. In both the cases trial had commenced before the Ld. Addl.
Sessions Judge, 1st Track Court, Paschim Midnapore. Against the
judgement and order passed in both the cases appeals were preferred
before the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta being CRA No.151 of 2005
and CRA No.154 of 2005. In the said appeals the convicted persons of
both the appeals obtained Bail from the Hon’ble High Court at Calcutta.
The said 2(two) appeals being CRA No.151 of 2005 and CRA No.154 of
2005 were still pending.
xviii.
The husband of the complainant died over the incident dated
18.06.1994 at 4:30 p.m. The instant complain case was cooked up by
making a concocted story against the respondents by filing a petition of
complaint on 14.07.1994, after 1(one) month from the date of alleged
occurrence. The complainant was examined under Section 200 Cr.P.C.,
on 25.07.1994.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances stated hereinabove
the instant criminal appeal being CRA No. 631 of 2007 should be
dismissed in limine with costs.”
7. A circumspection of evidence of the prosecution witnesses revealed as
follows:i. PW–1, the de facto complainant, narrated two facets of the
occurrence. According to her, on 3rd Ashar, 1401 B.S., at about
4:00/4:30 p.m., the accused persons namely Dinesh Bhattacharya,
Paban Ghosh, Amal Ghosh and Rabi Ghosh came to their pond for
catching fish. When her husband protested, he was assaulted with
fists and blows and fell near the pond. He was thereafter rescued and
taken to the hospital. She further stated that at about 10:30 p.m.,
the accused persons again assembled on the bank of the pond armed
with gun, “lathi” and other weapons and removed all the fishes from
the pond. When she attempted to resist, she too was assaulted. She
alleged loss of fishes valued at about Rs.6,000/- to Rs.6,500/-. Her
husband subsequently succumbed to the injuries. She admitted in
cross-examination that the written complaint had been prepared as
per the instruction of her father-in-law and she herself did not know
who had drafted it. She further admitted that she had not earlier
informed the police regarding theft of fish on the date of occurrence
and that such information was conveyed only after three days. It also
transpired that the petition of complaint did not specify from which
side of the pond the alleged theft had taken place.
ii. PW–2 stated that on hearing hue and cry at about 10:00 p.m., he
came out of his house and found the accused persons catching fish
from the complainant’s pond while armed with gun and “lathis”. He
claimed that the accused persons could be identified in the light of a
hazak lamp carried by them. He, however, admitted that he did not
intervene out of fear. He asserted that the pond belonged to the
complainant who used to cultivate the same.
iii. PW–3 deposed that while he was present at the house of Niyati Karam
at about 10:30 p.m., he heard cries from the side of the pond situated
about 50/60 feet away. On proceeding there, he found nearly forty
persons assembled with “lathi”, “tangi”, “ballam” and firearms.
According to him, Paban Ghosh, Dinesh Bhattacharya and others
had declared that they had come to catch fish from the pond. The
fishes, weighing approximately three quintals, were allegedly removed
towards the house of Paban Ghosh. He further stated that a General
Diary entry had been lodged at Kharagpur Police Station on
22.06.1994 though no action was taken by the police. In crossexamination, he admitted that Kushadhwaj Karam was his father-inlaw and that despite police remaining at the place of occurrence for a
considerable period, he had not shown the police the place where the
alleged stolen articles were kept. He further stated that except
informing the villagers and police, he had taken no steps during the
occurrence.
iv. PW–4 stated that on hearing hue and cry from the side of the pond of
Niyati Karam at about 10:00/10:30 p.m., she rushed to the spot and
found the accused persons armed with “lathi”, “tangi”, “ballam” and
gun, catching fish from the pond. She claimed that hazak light had
been brought to the place of occurrence. She further stated that when
she attempted to resist, accused Prafulla Ghosh directed her to
return home. According to her, the fishes were ultimately taken to the
house of Paban Ghosh.
v. PW–5 also claimed to have seen the accused persons armed with
“lathi”, “tangi”, “ballam”, bows and arrows catching fish from the
pond at about 10:30 p.m. He stated that they had brought a hazak
lamp and fishing nets and that he could identify five to seven accused
persons in the hazak light. In cross-examination, however, he
admitted that the pond was used by all villagers and further stated
that he had deposed as per the instruction of the complainant. He
also disclosed that police had taken him and several others from their
houses on 14.06.1994 and had camped in the village school from the
evening of 18.06.1994.
vi. PW–6 deposed in similar vein that on hearing cries of the womenfolk
of the Karam family, he went near the pond and found some persons
in the pond and others on its bank armed with “lathi”, “ballam”, bows
and arrows. He stated that due to threats extended by the accused
persons, he did not proceed further. In cross-examination, he
admitted that he had earlier deposed in the murder case concerning
Shakti Karam as also in a title suit and that he did not know whether
Niyati Karam actually owned the pond in question.
vii. PW–7 stated that on hearing hue and cry at about 10:00 p.m., he
reached the pond and found Paban Ghosh standing with a gun while
Dinesh Bhattacharya and others were catching fish from the pond
with the aid of a hazak lamp and fishing nets. He stated that the
fishes were removed towards the house of Paban Ghosh and that the
accused persons threatened him when he attempted resistance. He
further referred to a civil suit concerning ownership of the pond and
stated that a decree had been passed in favour of the complainant
party, a certified copy whereof was marked Exhibit–1.
viii. PW–8, the teacher of the village primary school, stated that on the
date of occurrence he first saw Shakti Karam and Bamapada Ghosh
lying injured near the pond and later, at about 10:30 p.m., witnessed
around twenty to twenty-five persons armed with deadly weapons
and carrying hazak lights catching fish from the pond. According to
him, some of the accused persons carried the fishes towards the
house of Paban Ghosh. In cross-examination, he admitted that some
of the accused persons were school teachers and established
cultivators. He further admitted that he had been implicated in
another criminal case along with members of the complainant party
and had deposed in several cases involving the complainant. He also
stated that he was a supporter of a political party and had contested
a Panchayat election.
8. At the outset, the substratum of the prosecution case itself appears
uncertain and wavering. PW–1, the de facto complainant, introduced two
distinct incidents allegedly occurring on the same day — one in the
afternoon involving assault upon her husband and another at night
concerning alleged theft of fish from the pond. Yet, in her cross-examination,
she admitted that she had not informed the police about theft of fish on the
date of occurrence and that such allegation surfaced only after three days.
The complaint itself did not disclose from which side of the pond the alleged
theft had been committed. Such omissions are not peripheral in nature; they
strike at the spontaneity and authenticity of the prosecution narrative.
9. The evidence regarding unlawful assembly and rioting under Sections 148
and 149 Indian Penal Code also remains deficient. Though several witnesses
made omnibus allegations that a large number of persons had assembled
armed with “lathi”, “tangi”, “ballam” and firearms, the prosecution failed to
establish with precision the common object of the assembly or the distinct
role attributable to each accused. Mere presence in a gathering, absent clear
proof of participation in prosecution of a common object, cannot attract the
vicarious liability contemplated under Section 149 Indian Penal Code. The
witnesses, in broad and generalized terms, implicated numerous persons
without furnishing a coherent account regarding overt acts committed by
each accused. Such sweeping allegations, particularly in a case emerging
from acknowledged prior hostility and civil litigation concerning possession
of the pond, require cautious judicial scrutiny.
10. Significantly, several witnesses admitted longstanding disputes and prior
litigations between the parties. PW–7 referred to a civil suit concerning the
pond. PW–6 admitted he had earlier deposed in the murder case involving
Shakti Karam and also in the title suit. PW–8 admitted political rivalry and
his involvement in previous litigations connected with the complainant party.
The evidence therefore unmistakably reveals an atmosphere of entrenched
animosity between the factions. In such circumstances, the possibility of
embellishment and over-implication cannot be brushed aside.
11. The charge under Section 324 Indian Penal Code is equally unsupported by
reliable evidence. Although references were made to assault by fists, blows
and weapons, the prosecution did not produce cogent medical evidence
establishing injuries caused by dangerous weapons in the manner alleged.
The witnesses spoke in varying tones regarding the nature of assault and
weapons used. The evidence remains insufficient to prove beyond reasonable
doubt that hurt within the meaning of Section 324 Indian Penal Code had
been voluntarily caused by the accused persons by dangerous weapons or
means.
12. Equally fragile is the allegation under Section 379 Indian Penal Code. The
prosecution sought to establish theft of fish from the pond, yet the evidence
regarding ownership and exclusive possession of the pond itself remained
uncertain. PW–5 admitted that the pond was used by all villagers. PW–6
candidly stated that he did not know whether Niyati Karam owned the pond
at all. Though PW–7 referred to a civil decree, the prosecution did not
establish exclusive possession in a manner eliminating all reasonable doubt.
In a prosecution for theft, proof of dishonest removal of movable property out
of another’s possession is indispensable. Where possession itself remains
clouded in dispute and the occurrence arises amidst ongoing civil discord
over property, the criminal charge of theft cannot rest merely on interested
assertions unsupported by unimpeachable evidence.
13. The allegation of criminal intimidation under Section 506 Indian Penal Code
also rests upon vague and generalized statements that the accused persons
threatened the witnesses with “dire consequences.” None of the witnesses
described the precise nature of the threat, the words used or the immediate
impact
thereof.
The
evidence
falls
short
of
establishing
intentional
intimidation with the object of causing alarm as contemplated under law.
14. It is also of considerable significance that many of the witnesses admitted
that despite police presence in the locality and subsequent investigation,
they had not shown the place where the alleged stolen fishes were kept, nor
was any recovery effected. Independent and disinterested witnesses from the
locality were conspicuously absent though the prosecution case itself
suggested that numerous villagers had assembled at the spot. The
prosecution evidence thus remained confined substantially within a circle of
interested and previously litigating witnesses.
15. The inconsistencies regarding the number of accused persons, the weapons
carried, the quantity of fish allegedly removed and the sequence of events
further weaken the prosecution edifice. The evidence does not attain the
degree of certainty necessary for overturning an order of acquittal.
16. An appellate court dealing with an appeal against acquittal is required to
bear in mind that the presumption of innocence stands fortified by the
acquittal recorded by the Learned Trial Court. Unless the findings are
manifestly unreasonable or wholly unsupported by evidence, interference is
not warranted merely because another view may also be possible.
17. In the present case, the view adopted by the Learned Trial Court emerges as
a plausible and reasoned appreciation of the evidence on record. The
prosecution having failed to establish the essential ingredients of Sections
148, 149, 324, 379 and 506 Indian Penal Code beyond reasonable doubt, the
order of acquittal calls for no interference.
18. Accordingly, the instant criminal appeal being CRA 631 of 2007 is
dismissed.
19. There is no order as to costs.
20. Trial Court records along with a copy of this judgment be sent down at once
to the Learned Trial Court for necessary action.
21. Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the
parties on priority basis on compliance of all formalities.
(Ananya Bandyopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review