Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$$
% & % ' $ ()
*%
(
+
!
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"#$#! %
#
!&
'
'
%()
%(*
!$
'
-2-
%*%
+,-.+
*
'
/+.0 1,/ !$*
( )
!
'
'
'
#
5-6 .77/.0 -6 ,-8/9:/, .;.-+6: :5/ <=,;>/+: 1? 91+@-9:-1+
.+, 18,/8 1? 6/+:/+9/ ,.:/,
.6/
1 %(*
.-95=8 .+,
!$ AB :5/
7/9-.0
7/9-.0 '=,;/D
:5/
( )
,,0
! 7.66/, -+
-6:8-9: .+,
1=8: ?18
?18
/9:-1+6 %*% .+, %(* 1?
/66-1+6 '=,;/ .:
?18 A8/@-:B C:5/ 0/.8+/,
E5/8/AB :5/ 0/.8+/,
.99=6/, .77/00.+:
7/9-.0 '=,;/ 91+@-9:/,
:5/
1??/+9/6
7=+-65.A0/
.+,
/9:-1+ * 1?
5/ .A8-,;/, ?.9:6 1? :5/ 9.6/ .8/ :5.:
-6 :5/ ,.=;5:/8 1?
26 ! .+, (
7.8/+:6 .+, 6-6:/8 .:
=00.7=8.
=+,/8
9:
"@-9:->
5/ -6 8/6-,-+; .01+; E-:5 5/8
-00.;/ .:
.-95=8
9918,-+; :1
2 ! 1+/ B/.8 78-18 :1 :5/ -+9-,/+: :5/ ?.:5/8 1? .99=6/," F.0
.>.-.5 E51 A/01+;6 :1 :5/ 9.6:/ 1?
2 ! .7781.95/, 5->
E-:5 . >.88-.;/ 781716.0 1? .99=6/, E-:5 @-9:->
1E/@/8 :5/
-3-
6.>/ E.6 ,/+-/, AB
2 ! 6-+9/ :5/ @-9:-> E.6 >-+18 .: :5.:
:->/
%
7>
5-+;6 6:11, :5=6
1+
)
!$ .: .A1=: (3%
:5/ @-9:-> .01+/ 0/?: :5/ 51=6/ :1 .::/+, +.:=8/ 9.00
:5/8/.?:/8 65/ ,-, +1: 8/:=8+/, :1 :5/ 51=6/
6 6=95
2!
.+, 5-6 ?.>-0B >/>A/86 6/.895/, 5/8 -+ :5/ @-00.;/ .: :5.:
:->/&
2 G" 5->.FF. -+?18>/,
2 ! :5.: 65/ 5.6 6//+ :5/
@-9:-> .+, .99=6/, 7819//,-+; :1E.8,6
1E/@/8
70.9/
6 6=95 5/ 01,;/, . 91>70.-+: A/?18/ :5/ 8/671+,/+:"
8->/
%**"
.>7
2 ! ,-, +1: ?-+, :5/ @-9:-> 18 .99=6/, .: :5/ 6.-,
10-9/ 1+ )
-+
-00/6=;.8
)
1 )#
1?
!$ .;.-+6: :5/ .99=6/, E5-95 E.6 8/;-6:/8/,
!$ ?18 :5/ 1??/+9/ 7=+-65.A0/ =+,/8
.:/8 1+
* )
!$
:5/ @-9:-> .+, .99=6/,
:8.9/, -+ . 5=: 6-:=.:/, -+ . 0.+, +/.8AB
167-:.0 .:
1,,.+/FF=+,-
/+;.0=8=
/9:-1+
.-+A1E
5-0,8/+
5/8/.?:/8 :5/ .99=6/,
E.6 .88/6:/, .+, :5/ 8/671+,/+:" 10-9/ 8/918,/, :5/ 6:.:/>/+:
1? @-9:-> E5/8/-+ 65/ 6:.:/, :5.: 1+
:.F/+ 5/8 :1
)
!$ :5/ .99=6/,
.+;.018/ AB /+:-9-+; 5/8 :5.: 5/ E1=0, >.88B 5/8
.+, :5/8/.?:/8 :5/B A1:5 :8.@/00/, :1
6:.B/, -+ . 5=: -+
1,,.+/FF=+,-
.+;.018/ -+ . A=6 .+,
/+;.0=8= .+, :5/8/ 5/
-4-
91>>-::/, ?189-A0/ 6/H=.0 -+:/891=86/ 1+ 5/8 -+ :5/ +-;5: 51=86
6 6=95 :5/ 8/671+,/+:" 10-9/ -+@/6:-;.:/, :5/ 9.6/ .+, 0.-,
95.8;/ 65//: .;.-+6: :5/ .99=6/, ?18 :5/ 1??/+9/6 7=+-65.A0/
=+,/8
/9:-1+ %**"
.+, %(* 1?
.+,
/9:-1+6 ) .+, * 1?
9:
)
1 781@/ :5/ 95.8;/6 0/@/0/, .;.-+6: :5/ .99=6/,
:5/ 7816/9=:-1+ -+ :1:.0 /H.>-+/,
$ E-:+/66/6 .6
26 ! :1
.+, >.8F/,
H6 ! :1
5/ .99=6/,
>.8F/,
! ,19=>/+:6 .6
,19=>/+:6 .6 H6
#
! .+,
!
$
1+ 5-6 A/5.0?
+ .66/66>/+: 1? 18.0 .+, ,19=>/+:.8B /@-,/+9/
:5/ 0/.8+/,
7/9-.0 '=,;/ 91+@-9:/, :5/ .99=6/, ?18 :5/
1??/+9/6 7=+-65.A0/ =+,/8
/9:-1+6 %*% 1?
9:
5->
.+,
6/+:/+9/,
:1
.+,
/9:-1+ * 1?
=+,/8;1
8-;181=6
->78-61+>/+: ?18 . 7/8-1, 1? # B/.86 .+, :1 7.B . ?-+/ 1?
6!
" -+ ,/?.=0: :1 =+,/8;1 8-;181=6 ->78-61+>/+: ?18 .
7/8-1, 1? * >1+:56 ?18 :5/ 1??/+9/ 7=+-65.A0/ =+,/8
%*% 1?
/9:-1+
/ .061 6/+:/+9/, :1 =+,/8 8-;181=6 ->78-61+>/+:
?18 . 7/8-1, 1? !
B/.86 .+, :1 7.B . ?-+/ 1?
" -+
,/?.=0: :1 =+,/8;1 8-;181=6 ->78-61+>/+: ?18 . 7/8-1, 1? !
B/.8 ?18 :5/ 1??/+9/ 7=+-65.A0/ =+,/8
/9:-1+ * 1?
9:
-5-
=8:5/8 ,-8/9:/, :5.: .00 :5/ 6/+:/+9/6 65.00 8=+ 91+9=88/+:0B
5/ 6.-, <=,;>/+: -6 95.00/+;/, AB :5/ .99=6/, -+ :5-6 .77/.0
*
/.8, 0/.8+/, 91=+6/0 ?18 :5/ .77/00.+:
91=+6/0 ?18 8/671+,/+:
8/671+,/+:
(
91=+6/0
0/.8+/,
1 !" :.:/ .+, 0/.8+/, 91=+6/0 ?18
7.8: ?81> =8;-+; 6/@/8.0 91+:/+:-1+6
?18
:5/
.77/00.+:
78->.8-0B
91+:/+,/,
0/.8+/,
:5.:
:5/
<=,;>/+: =+,/8 :5-6 .77/.0 6=??/86 ?81> 7/8@/86-:B .+,
-00/;.0-:B
6-+9/
:5/
/66-1+6
/@-,/+9/
-+
8-;5:
7/867/9:-@/
.
'=,;/
?.-0/,
9918,-+;
.778/9-.:/
:1
5->
:5/
:5/
7816/9=:-1+ 5.6 ?.-0/, :1 781@/ :5/ .;/ 1? @-9:-> :5.: 65/ E.6
>-+18 .: :5/ :->/ 1? -+9-,/+:
:5/ 9/8:-?-/, 917B 1?
$":5/
-+ :5/
66-6:.+:
95110
95110
/.95/8
,>-66-1+
7816/9=:-1+ .061 8/0-/, 1+
2 !*" /.,>-6:8/66 1?
.+,5.0
5/ 7816/9=:-1+ 5.6 8/0-/, H
,>-66-1+
/;-6:/8 -66=/, AB
$ -6 +1: .+ .=:518 1? /+:8B
/;-6:/8
H !
!
-/
.+95.>=F5-
7.8: ?81> :5.:
:5/
:5/ 9/8:-?-9.:/ -66=/, AB
1@/8+>/+:
-;5
95110
H9/7: :5/6/ :E1 ,19=>/+:6 :5/ 7816/9=:-1+ 5.6 +1:
70.9/, .+B .=:5/+:-9.:/, ,19=>/+:6 0-F/
-8:5
/8:-?-9.:/ 18 :5/
.:8-9=0.:-1+ >.8F6 9.8, :1 781@/ :5.: :5/ @-9:-> E.6 >-+18 .:
-6-
:5/ :->/ 1? -+9-,/+:
5/
19:18" 2 !G E51 /H.>-+/, :5/
@-9:-> .061 +1: 6:.:/, .A1=: :5/ .;/ 1? @-9:->
+ 6=95
9-89=>6:.+9/ .9918,-+; :1 :5/ 0/.8+/, 91=+6/0 :5/ 7816/9=:-1+
5.6 ?.-0/, :1 781@/ :5.: :5/ 65/ E.6 >-+18 .: :5/ :->/ 1?
-+9-,/+:
$
/ ?=8:5/8 6=A>-::/, :5.:
-+ 5/8 /H.>-+.:-1+
9.:/;18-9.00B 6:.:/, :5.: 65/ .+, .99=6/, E/8/ -+ 01@/ .+, 65/
@10=+:.8-0B .991>7.+-/, 1+
=8:5/8
)
!$ .: .A1=: (3%
7>
65/ 6:.B/, .01+; E-:5 .99=6/, ?18 :E1 ,.B6 .+,
E-:51=: 8/6-6:-+; 18 -+?18>-+; :5/ 6.>/ :1 .+BA1,B
18/1@/8
:5/ >/,-9.0 /@-,/+9/ .061 ,1/6 +1: 8/@/.0 :5.: :5/8/ E.6 .
?189-A0/ 6/H=.0 .9: 1+ 5/8 .6 .00/;/, AB :5/ 7816/9=:-1+
9918,-+;0B 5/ 78.B6 :1 .001E :5/ .77/.0
G
0/.8+/,
91+:/+,/, :5.: :5/
8-.0
1=8: .?:/8 >/:-9=01=60B /H.>-+-+; :5/ /@-,/+9/ 1+ 8/918,
8-;5:0B 91+@-9:/, :5/ .99=6/, -+ . E/00 8/.61+/, <=,;>/+:
E5-95 ,1/6 +1: 9.00 ?18 .+B -+:/8?/8/+9/ .: :5/ 5.+,6 1? :5-6
91=8:
/
91+:/+,/,
:5.:
:5/
/@-,/+9/
1?
"@-9:->
9.:/;18-9.00B /6:.A0-65/, :5.: :5/ .99=6/, F-,+.77/, 5/8 .+,
5., ?189-A0/ 6/H=.0 -+:/891=86/ 1+ 5/8 ?18 . 7/8-1, 1? :E1 ,.B6
-7-
=8:5/8 5/8 /@-,/+9/ 91881A18.:/6 :5/ :/6:->1+B 1?
( -/
5/8 7.8/+:6 .+, .061 :5/ /@-,/+9/ 1?
:5/ >/,-9.0 9/8:-?-9.:/" H !$
19:18" 2 !G .+,
/ .061 91+:/+,/, :5.: :5/
@-9:-> E.6 >-+18 .: :5/ :->/ 1? -+9-,/+: .6 7/8 H6 !
-66=/, AB
26 !* .+,
26 ! .+,
$ 8/67/9:-@/0B
.+,
!
+ 6=95 9-89=>6:.+9/
:5/6/ .67/9:6 1? :5/ >.::/8 8-;5:0B .778/9-.:/, AB :5/
8-.0
1=8: .+, 91+@-9:/, :5/ .99=6/, ?18 :5/ 95.8;/6 0/@/0/, .;.-+6:
5->
9918,-+;0B 5/ 78.B6 :1 ,-6>-66 :5/ .77/.0
!
5.@/ ;-@/+ >B .+H-1=6 91+6-,/8.:-1+ A1:5 1+ :5/
6=A>-66-1+6 >.,/ AB :5/ 0/.8+/, 91=+6/0 ?18 :5/ 8/67/9:-@/
7.8:-/6 .+, 7/8=6/, :5/ ,19=>/+:6 >.,/ .@.-0.A0/ A/?18/ :5-6
1=8:
!!
6 91=0, A/ ;.:5/8/, ?81> :5/ /@-,/+9/ 1?
91>70.-+.+: - /
2 !"
:5/ ?.:5/8 1? @-9:-> 1+/ B/.8 78-18 :1 :5/
-+9-,/+: :5/ ?.:5/8 1? .99=6/, .7781.95/, 5-> E-:5 . >.88-.;/
781716.0 1? .99=6/, E-:5 @-9:->
1E/@/8
:5/ 6.>/ E.6
8/</9:/, AB
2 ! ?18 :5/ 8/.61+ :5.: :5/ @-9:-> E.6 >-+18 .:
:5.: :->/
9918,-+; :1
2 "@-9:-> 65/ .+, .99=6/, E/8/ -+
01@/ ?18 .A1=: % B/.86 .+, :5/ .99=6/, 781>-6/, 5/8 :5.: 5/
E1=0, >.88B 5/8
=8:5/8
65/ @10=+:.8-0B .991>7.+-/, :5/
-8-
.99=6/, 1+
A=6
)
?81>
!$
,>-::/,0B :5/B A1:5 :8.@/00/, -+ .
>>-;.+=8
1,,.+/FF=+,-
:1
.+;.018/
/+;.0=8= ?18 % ,.B6
.+,
6:.B/,
.:
5/ ,-, +1: -+?18> :5/
6.>/ :1 .+BA1,B -+90=,-+; :5/ -+>.:/6 1? :5/ A=6 18 .+B 1:5/8
7/861+ E5/8/ 65/ 6:.B/, ?18 . 7/8-1, 1?
"% ,.B6
9918,-+; :1
5/8 :5/ .99=6/, 91>>-::/, ?189-A0/ 6/H=.0 -+:/891=86/ 1+ 5/8
-+ :5/ +-;5: 51=86
,>-::/,0B
:5/8/ .8/ +1 6=95 6-;+6 1?
?189-A0/ 6/H=.0 -+:/891=86/ 1+ 5/8 .6 7/8 :5/ >/,-9.0 8/718:"
H !$
/ :5.: .6 -: >.B :1 781@/ :5/ .;/ 1? @-9:-> :5.: 65/
E.6 >-+18 .: :5/ :->/ 1? -+9-,/+:
70.9-+;
H6 !
.+,
!":5/
95110
.=:5/+:-9.:/, ,19=>/+:6 .8/ 70.9/,
:5/ .=:5186 1?
95110
A.6/, 1+ 6=95
,>-66-1+
7/8
H6 !
.+,
,>-66-1+
!
/8:-?-9.:/6
2 !* .+,
/;-6:/86
+1 1:5/8
2 ! .8/ +1:
9918,-+; :1 :5/>
/;-6:/8 :5/B -66=/, 9/8:-?-9.:/ .6
5/8/
-6
?18:591>-+; 1+ /@-,/+9/ :5.: E5B :5/
-6 +1: 70.9/, AB
:5/ 7816/9=:-1+ /H9/7:
26 ! 18 (
+1
-8:5
8/.61+
E5.:61/@/8
/8:-?-9.:/ 1? @-9:->
,/67-:/ 5/8 >.:8-9=0.:-1+
9/8:-?-9.:/ -6 .@.-0.A0/ 6-+9/ 65/ 91>70/:/, 5/8 >.:8-9=0.:-1+
2 !G" 19:18 .061 ,1/6 +1: ,-69016/, :5/ .;/ 1? @-9:->
5/8/
-6 +1 8.,-101;B 8/718: 18 166-?-9.:-1+ :/6: 91+,=9:/, AB :5/
7816/9=:-1+
:1
.69/8:.-+
:5/
.;/
1?
@-9:->
+
6=95
-9-
9-89=>6:.+9/ 610/0B 8/0B-+; 1+
!
95110
/8:-?-9.:/6" H6 !
.+,
:5/ .;/ 1? @-9:-> 9.++1: A/ ,/:/8>-+/, :5.: 65/ E.6
>-+18 .: :5/ :->/ 1? -+9-,/+:
!
1=8: -+
+ 6=95 9-89=>6:.+9/
8->-+.0
77/.0
5/
-@-6-1+
! G
!) ,.:/,
/+95 1? :5-6
# !!
)
5/0, 8/;.8,-+; ,/:/8>-+.:-1+ 1? :5/ .;/ 1? :5/ @-9:-> .:
7.8.;8.756
"
'-*.
1 ) .+, )! .6 =+,/83
#
#
!
%&'()*+ , #!!
/
$
'*
'*
)'
)'
'((, 1
-
- 10 -
&*+
)'
)'&*+
)'&*+
&
)'&*+
+
)'&*+
)'&*+
:
)'&*+
- 11 -
;
)'
"
"
/
)'
< =
&*+ 7
>
!
< & +& +
?
? & +
&
+
?
? & +
?;
!%
-@-6-1+
=0/ !
+ 7/8=6.0 1? :5/ .A1@/ <=,;>/+: 7.66/, AB :5/
/+95 1? :5-6
1=8: -: -6 8/0.:-@/0B 90/.8 :5.: .6 7/8
1? :5/ '=@/+-0/ '=6:-9/
=0/6 -+ 18,/8 :1 781@/ :5/ .;/
1? :5/ 95-0, 18 <=@/+-0/ :5/ 7819/,=8/ :1 A/ ?1001E/, .+, :5/
,19=>/+:6 :1 A/ 8/0-/, AB :5/ 7816/9=:-1+ .8/ :5/ >.:8-9=0.:-1+
18 /I=-@.0/+: 9/8:-?-9.:/6 -? .@.-0.A0/& .+, -+ :5/ .A6/+9/ :5/
,.:/ 1? A-8:5 9/8:-?-9.:/ ?81> :5/ 695110
1:5/8 :5.+ . 7.B
695110 ?-86: .::/+,/,& .+, -+ :5/ .A6/+9/ :5/ A-8:5 9/8:-?-9.:/
- 12 -
;-@/+ AB .
18718.:-1+ 18 .
=+-9-7.0
=:518-:B 18 . .+95.B.:
/+9/ 91+6-,/8-+; :5/ .A1@/ .67/9:
.> 1? :5/ 91+6-,/8/,
@-/E :5.: :5/ 7816/9=:-1+ .061 ?.-0/, :1 781@/ :5.: :5/ @-9:->
E.6 . >-+18 .6 1+ :5/ ,.:/ 1? -+9-,/+:
!)
5/
1+JA0/
7/H
1=8: -+ :5/ 9.6/ 1?
8/718:/, -+
5.6 5/0, .6 =+,/83
@
*'
A
@
#
$
&
+
#
*,- &'+
*)
& + 7 !
*'/
*)
B
*'
>
#
)-)
&!
#
)-C
!+ 271
>
D
- 13 -
>
D
;
!#
+ 7/8=6.0 1? :5/ .A1@/ ,-9:=> -: -6 90/.8 :5.:
:51=;5 :5/8/ -6 +1 A.8 :1 8/0B 610-:.8B /@-,/+9/ 1? :5/
7816/9=:8-H
:5/
6.-,
/@-,/+9/
1?
7816/9=:8-H
-6
:1
A/
:8=6:E18:5B =+A0/>-65/, .+, -: 651=0, A/ 1? 6:/80-+; I=.0-:B
+
:5/ -+6:.+: 9.6/ :5/ /@-,/+9/ 1? 7816/9=:8-H .77/.86 :1 A/ +1:
8/0-.A0/
!*
770B-+; :5/ ?-+,-+;6 1? :5/
1+JA0/
7/H
1=8: -+
:5/ .A1@/ <=,;>/+: :1 :5/ ?.9: .+, 9-89=>6:.+9/6 1? :5-6 9.6/
.> 1? :5/ 91+6-,/8/, @-/E :5.: :5/ -+:/8?/8/+9/ -+ :5/
->7=;+/, <=,;>/+: -6 9.00/, ?18 6-+9/ :5/
:5/ /@-,/+9/ 1+ 8/918,
9918,-+;0B
8-.0
1=8: >-68/.,
7819//, :1 7.66 :5/
?1001E-+;3
-
5/
8->-+.0
77/.0 -6
--
5/ <=,;>/+: 1? 91+@-9:-1+ .+, 18,/8 1?
/+:/+9/ ,.:/,
( )
! 7.66/, -+
7/9-.0
.6/
1 %(*
!$ AB :5/ 0/.8+/,
- 14 -
7/9-.0
1=8:
8B
??/+9/6
?
81:/9:-1+
?
??/+9/6
9:
81@-6-1+6
/H=.0
/66-1+6 '=,;/
!
.-95=8
+,/8
5-0,8/+
5/
81>
.+,
,,-:-1+.0
-6:8-9: .:
.-95=8
-6 5/8/AB 6/: .6-,/
---
1+6/I=/+:0B .77/00.+:".99=6/, -6 .9I=-::/,
1? :5/ 1??/+9/6 7=+-65.A0/ =+,/8
.+, %(* 1?
.+,
/9:-1+6 %*%
/9:-1+ * 1?
9:
!
-@
.-0 A1+, 1? :5/ .99=6/, .+, :5.: 1? 5-6
6=8/:-/6 65.00 6:.+, 9.+9/00/,
@
-+/ .>1=+: -? .+B ,/716-:/, AB .99=6/, -6
18,/8/, :1 A/ 8/?=+,/, :1 5-> 1+ ,=/
-,/+:-?-9.:-1+ .?:/8 .77/.0 7/8-1, -6 1@/8
/;-6:8B -6 ,-8/9:/, :1 6/+, A.9F :5/
.01+; E-:5
9/8:-?-/, 917B 1? :5-6 <=,;>/+: :1 :5/ 91+9/8+/,
?18:5E-:5
,)
%
-6: 1 3 !
3 '6
1 3 !G
(
1=8:
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review