The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. Accordingly, no substantial question of law is made out, the impugned judgment and decree passed by both the learned Courts are hereby affirmed and in result thereof, the present civil second appeal being devoid of merits, is hereby dismissed.
22. Accordingly, the present second appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.
23. All other pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of. (MANEESH SHARMA),J SOURAV /6
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Second Appeal No. 503/2024
1.
1/1.
1/2.
1/3.
2.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
5/1.
5/2.
5/3.
6.
7.
Suresh Narayan Mathur son of Late Shri Nand Lal Mathur,
Now Deceased,
Smt. Manju Mathur Wife,
Shri Rajat Mathur @ Gaurav Mathur Son,
Shri Shubham Mathur Son,
Shri Anil Kumar Mathur son of late Shri Nand Lal Mathur.
All Resident of 193/38 Purani Mandi, Ajmer.
----Appellants
Versus
Shrimati Premlata Wife of Shri Jatan Lal Jain,
Shrimati Sunita Jain Wife of Shri Dalip Jain,
Shrimati Rekha Wife of Shri Vinay Kumar Lodha,
All the three daughters of Shri Dhanraj Jain, R/o Purani
Mandi, Ajmer
Shri Bhagchand, Son of Shri Dhanraj Jain
Shri Ashok Kumar Son of Shri Dhanraj Jain, now
deceased
Shri Dipanshu Son of Late Shri Ashok Jain Modi, Resident
of Mahavir Colony Ke Saamne, Pushkar Road, Ajmer
Shri Himanshu Son of Late Shri Ashok Jain Modi, Resident
of Mahavir Colony Ke Saamne, Pushkar Road, Ajmer
Shrimati Pritee Jain Wife of Late Shri Ashok Jain Modi,
Resident of Mahavir Colony Ke Saamne, Pushkar Road,
Ajmer
Shri Dilip Kumar Son of Shri Dhanraj Jain,
Shri Rajesh Kumar Son of Shri Dhanraj Jain,
Both resident of C/o Shri Dhanraj Jain Bahiwala, Purani
Mandi, Ajmer.
----Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R.K. Mathur, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Deependra Yadav
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANEESH SHARMA
Order
27/03/2026
1.
The present civil second appeal has been filed by the
plaintiff/appellants, against the judgment and decree dated
14.08.2024 passed in Civil Appeal No.56/2016 (115/07) (CIS
No.854/2014) titled as 'Suresh Narayan Mathur & Anr. Vs. Smt.
Premlata & Ors.', whereby the learned Additional District Judge
(2 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
No.4,
Ajmer,
whereby
the
[CSA-503/2024]
appeal
preferred
by
the
plaintiff/appellants has been dismissed and the judgment dated
02.04.2007 passed in Civil Suit No.447/93 by the learned Civil
Judge (Junior Division) and Judicial Magistrate, Ajmer City (West)
has been affirmed. Consequently, the suit filed by the appellants
for declaration and permanent injunction has been dismissed.
2.
Brief facts giving rise to the present appeal are that the
plaintiffs/appellants
have
filed
a
suit
for
declaration
and
permament injunction while stating that one shop and roof
thereupon were rented out to them @ Rs.29/- per month. Initially,
the appellants’ father and uncle, namely, Nandlal and Shivlal were
tenants and after death of the Nandlal, the plaintiffs/appellants
are carrying on the business as successors.
3.
In the plaint, the plaintiffs/appellants have stated that
though the roof of the shop is included in tenancy, but the
defendant/respondents have created hindrance in peaceful use
and occupation of the said roof, therefore they have sought a
relief of declaration that roof is part of tenanted premises and
injunction to the effect that the respondents may be restrained
not to create any hindrance in peaceful occupation of the suit
property i.e. roof of the shop and not to raise any construction
thereupon.
4.
In
the
said
defendant/respondents
suit,
after
(landlord)
service
filed
a
of
notice,
the
reply
refuting
the
averments made in the plaint and denying the fact that the roof of
the shop was ever let out. It was averred that there is no
independent
access
to
the
said
roof
and
that
the
plaintiffs/appellants have no right, title or interest with regard to
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
(3 of 7)
[CSA-503/2024]
the roof of the said shop, and accordingly prayed for dismissal of
the suit.
5.
Thereafter, the plaintiffs/appellants, filed a rejoinder to the
said written statement, reiterating the averments made in the
plaint and accordingly sought the reliefs as prayed for in the suit.
6.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties following issues
were framed:
1- vk;k] oknhx.k oknxzLr nqdku vkSj lEiw.kZ Nr ds vius firk o pkpk
uUnyky o f'koyky ds mRrjkf/kdkjh gksus ds dkj.k fof/k ds izorZu ds
dkj.k fdjk;snkj gS o iwoZ edku ekfyd }kjk okn ifjlj esa Åij dh Nr
Hkh 'kkfey fdjk;snkjh esa nh gqbZ Fkh \
& oknh
2- vk;k] izfroknhx.k dks fdjk;s'kqnk Nr ij dksbZ Hkh fuekZ.k djus ;k
vojks/k mRiUu djus ls jksdus dh LFkkbZ fu"ks/kkKk oknh tkjh djokus ds
vf/kdkjh gS \
&oknh
3- vk;k] fdjk;s'kqnk nqdku ds lkFk Nr Hkh izfroknh la0 3 dks cspku dh
xbZ gS vkSj bl Nr gsrq izfroknh la0 1 o 2 ds lkFk feydj dksbZ dkWeu
jkLrk miyC/k ugha gS rFkk iwoZ edku ekfydku }kjk oknhx.k dks Nr dh
lqfo/kk ls oafpr dj fn;k Fkk \
&izfroknhx.k
4- vuqrks"k \
7.
In order to substantiate the averments of the plaint, the
plaintiffs/appellants examined Anil Mathur (PW-1) and produced
documents Ex-1 to Ex.-5 (rent receipts).
8.
Oppositely, the defendant/respondents in order to controvert
the averments made in the plaint and the evidence so adduced,
examined Dilip Jain (DW-1) and produced documents Ex.A-1 to
Ex.A-37.
9.
After hearing arguments of the parties, the learned Trial
Court held that the alleged rent receipts (Ex.1 to Ex.5) do not
inspire any confidence, more particularly in view of the receipts
produced by the defendant/respondents (Ex.A-1 to Ex.A-34) which
were issued prior to 1989, and held that the plaintiffs/appellants
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
(4 of 7)
[CSA-503/2024]
have no right, title or interest with regard to roof of the shop and
accordingly dismissed the suit.
10.
Being aggrieved of the above judgment and decree, the
plaintiffs/appellants preferred a regular first appeal, whereby the
learned Appellate Court, while re-endorsing the findings recorded
by the learned Trial Court, dismissed the appeal and confirmed the
impugned judgment and decree passed by the learned Trial Court.
11.
Being aggrieved by the concurrent findings recorded by both
the learned courts below, the plaintiffs/appellants have preferred
the present appeal.
12.
Learned counsel for the plaintiffs/appellants submits that
both the learned Courts below seriously erred in dismissing the
suit while misinterpreting the rent receipts produced by them
(Ex.1 to Ex.5), which include the roof in the rented premises. He
also submits that misreading of the rent receipts (Ex.1 to Ex.5) is
a substantial question of law.
13.
Heard and considered the submissions made by learned
counsel for the appellant and perused the material available on
record.
14.
From a bare perusal of the record, it is evident that there is
no dispute about the fact that the shop was let out to the
plaintiffs/appellants. However, the main dispute between the
parties is with respect to tenancy rights over the roof and
accordingly the plaintiffs/appellants claim right on the basis of few
rent receipts (Ex.1 to Ex.5) which were issued by the agent of the
defendant/respondants - landlord i.e. Mahender and to counter
the said evidence the landlord produced rent receipts issued prior
to 1989 (Ex.A-1 to 34), wherein the rent receipts does not specify
(5 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
[CSA-503/2024]
the fact that the roof of the shop was ever let out or was part of
the tenancy.
15.
The rent receipts so produced by the plaintiffs/appellants
relate to 1989-1990 and there is an evidence available on record
that the agent of the defendant/respondants - landlord i.e.
Mahender mistakenly added word 'Chhat' in the rent receipts,
whereas
the
aforesaid
roof
was
never
let
out
to
the
plaintiffs/appellants (tenant). Therefore, in the absence of any
documentary or oral evidence proving that the roof in question is
a part of tenanted premises, both the learned Courts below have
rightly held that the plaintiffs/appellants have failed to prove the
fact that the roof was ever let out to the plaintiffs/appellants. On
the contrary, the landlord has produced rent receipts (Ex.A-1 to
34), wherein it is evident that only shop was let out to the
appellant.
16.
From a bare perusal of the judgments and decrees passed by
the learned Courts below, it is evident that both the learned
Courts below have considered the pleadings and evidence led by
the parties in detail and found that the plaintiff/appellant - Suresh
Narayan
(PW1)
in
his
cross-examination
has
deposed
the
following:
^^-----fdjk;s 'kqnk nqdku ds vykok mldh Nr esjh fdjk;snkjh esa gS bldh
fy[kkoV esjs ikl gS tks eSa fn[kk ldrk gwaA-----**
However, he failed to produce any documentary evidence to
establish that the roof in question was a part of the tenanted
premises and it is not a case of the plaintiff/appellant that at the
first instance the shop was let out and thereafter the roof was also
let out to him. Furthermore, it is also pertinent to mention here
(6 of 7)
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
[CSA-503/2024]
that there is no separate way for the said roof, thus, the learned
Courts
below
rightly
dismissed
the
suit
filed
by
the
plaintiffs/appellants.
17.
Further the alleged question of law so proposed by the
learned counsel for the plaintiffs/appellants is a question of fact,
as per the evidence available on record, it is established that due
to mere inadvertence in few rent receipts where the agent of the
defendant/respondents - landlord has mistakenly mentioned the
roof, that ipso facto will not create any right of tenancy, more
particularly when all previous rent receipts produced by the
defendant/respondents (Ex.A-1 to 34) clearly indicate that only
the shop was let out to the appellant meaning thereby the roof
was never intended to be a part of the tenanted premises and the
plaintiff/appellant has not disputed those rent receipts. Moreover,
there is no separate way for the roof and the plaintiff/appellant in
his cross-examination has mentioned that the roof is included in
the tenanted premises and he can show document in this regard,
but failed to produce the same, therefore, it is prima facie evident
that he has withheld the said vital evidence (if any), thus, there is
no substantial question of law is involved in the present civil
second appeal.
18.
That the Hon'ble Apex Court in the matter of Nazir
Mohamed vs J.Kamala And Ors.,1 has held that the condition
precedent for entertaining and deciding a second appeal is the
existence of a substantial question of law.
19.
A second appeal is entertainable only when a substantial
question of law arises in the matter. The High Court is not
AIR 2020 SC (4321)
[2026:RJ-JP:12881]
(7 of 7)
[CSA-503/2024]
empowered to re-examine the factual findings made by the first
appellate court, as its jurisdiction is limited to substantial
questions of law. Second appeals cannot be decided on equitable
considerations; compliance with the requirements of Section 100
of CPC is mandatory for admission or entertaining a second
appeal.
20.
In view of the above discussion, it is clear that no question of
law, much less a substantial question of law, arises in the present
second appeal that would warrant interference by this Court under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
21.
Accordingly, no substantial question of law is made out, the
impugned judgment and decree passed by both the learned Courts
are hereby affirmed and in result thereof, the present civil second
appeal being devoid of merits, is hereby dismissed.
22.
Accordingly, the present second appeal fails and is hereby
dismissed.
23.
All other pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of.
(MANEESH SHARMA),J
SOURAV /6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review