Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
INDRAJEET
SAHU
Digitally signed
by INDRAJEET
SAHU
Date: 2026.04.21
16:50:29 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WP227 No. 918 of 2025
1 - Suresh Kumar Pahuja S/o Late Jeevan Lal Pahuja Aged About 53 Years
R/o M P Nagar, Korba, P.S. Rampur, P.O. Korba, District- Korba (C.G.) (Due
To Inadvertence, Fathers Name Not Mentioned In Lower Court Cause Title)
... Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - Shri Vishwa S/o Late Maniram Patel Aged About 62 Years R/o Dadar
Khurd, Korba, Tehsil- Korba, District- Korba (C.G.) (Due To Inadvertence,
Fathers Name Not Mentioned In Lower Court Cause Title)
2 - Shri Bisheshar S/o Late Maniram Patel Aged About 56 Years R/o Dadar
Khurd, Korba, Tehsil- Korba, District- Korba (C.G.) (Due To Inadvertence,
Fathers Name Not Mentioned In Lower Court Cause Title)
3 - Shri Baleshwar S/o Late Maniram Patel Aged About 50 Years R/o Dadar
Khurd, Korba, Tehsil- Korba, District- Korba (C.G.) (Due To Inadvertence,
Fathers Name Not Mentioned In Lower Court Cause Title).
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
For Respondent 1&3
For Respondent No.2
:
:
:
Ms. Shivangi Agrawal, Advocate.
None though served.
Shri T.R. Patel, Advocate.
Hon’ble Shri Justice Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, J
Judgment reserved on 16.04.2026
Judgment delivered on 21.04.2026
1. The present writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
has been filed by the petitioner challenging the order dated 18.08.2025
passed by the Second District Judge, Korba, in Civil Suit No.A(DJ-
ADJ)/7/2022 whereby the application filed by the petitioner under
Sections 39 and 40 of Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 read with
Order 16 Rule 2(2) CPC has been rejected.
2. Brief facts of the case are that, the petitioner is the plaintiff before trial
court. He is prosecuting a civil suit for specific performance of contract
dated 30.10.2021. It is pleaded in the plaint that with respect to land
bearing Khasra No.500 Area 7 dismil, out of total 10 dismil, was agreed
to be sold in favour of plaintiff by the defendants for a total
consideration of Rs.26,25,000/- and an agreement was executed on
30.10.2021.
Out
of
total
sale
consideration,
an
amount
of
Rs.10,10,000/- on 30.10.2021, Rs.10,000/- on 31.10.2021 and
Rs.20,000/- on 01.11.2021 have been paid to them. Thus, total
Rs.10,40,000/-have been paid to the defendants. Despite repeated
request when the defendants did not execute the sale deed in his
favour and not performed their part of contract, he served a legal notice
to the defendants and then he filed the civil suit on 23.11.2022. The
defendants, after service of summons upon them, made appearance
and filed their written statement. In their written statement though they
have not specifically denied execution of agreement dated 30.10.2021,
but have pleaded that no advance amount was paid as shown in the
agreement and only an assurance was given to the defendants that
plaintiff will pay the advance amount. In their written statement they
have also pleaded that since the plaintiff has not paid any amount to
them, they are not bound to execute the sale deed in his favour. The
agreement got executed by the plaintiff by playing fraud which is not
acceptable and therefore they prayed for dismissal of the suit.
3. During pendency of suit, based on the pleadings of the parties, the
issues were framed and the trial court proceeded for recording
evidence of the party. After examination of plaintiff’s evidence, the
defendant No.2 Visheshar examined himself as DW-1 before the trial
court. In his cross examination, he denied the execution of agreement
and also denied his signature over the said agreement Ex.P/1. He also
denied his signature in every pages of the agreement Ex.P/1.
4. Considering the evidence given by defendant No.1 that the defendants,
in written statement, though have not specifically denied execution of
agreement and their signature, but in the evidence of defendant No.2
he specifically denied execution of agreement and signature over the
agreement Ex.P/1, the plaintiff filed an application under Sections 39 &
40 of Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam read with Order 16 Rule 2(2) CPC
before the trial court on 04.08.2025 for examining the signature of
defendant over the agreement Ex.P/1 by handwriting expert. The said
application of plaintiff has been rejected by the trial court on
18.08.2025 on the ground that in the written statement, the defendants
have admitted execution of agreement and therefore there is no need
to get the agreement again examined by handwriting expert. The said
order dated 18.08.2025 is under challenge in the present writ petition.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that although in the
written statement the defendants have not specifically denied about
execution of agreement and their signature, however, in the cross
examination of defendant No.2 he specifically denied execution of
agreement and his signature over it. In such a situation, the plaintiff
wants to get the agreement examined by handwriting expert to prove
the execution of agreement by the defendants. She would further
submit that no prejudice would be caused to the defendants as they
are having ample opportunity to cross examine the witness of
handwriting expert to that effect. Had the defendant No.2 not denied
his signature over the agreement, she would not have any cause of
action to get the said deed examined by handwriting expert, but in view
of his evidence, the examination of deed by the handwriting expert is
necessary to prove the execution of agreement in favour of the plaintiff.
In support of her submissions, she would rely upon the judgment
passed by Supreme Court in 2008(4)SCC 530, Thiruvengadam Pillai
Vs. Navaneethammal & Another and also 2015 SCC Online Hyd.
799, Mudi Reddy Tirupathi Reddy Vs.T. Linga Reddy and Another.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent opposes the
submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner and have submitted
that it is for the plaintiff to prove his case by leading other evidences
that the defendants have executed the agreement in his favour and
they failed to perform their part of contract. Even if the agreement is
said to be proved that it was executed in favour of the plaintiff, the
plaintiff is not entitled for any decree for specific performance of the
contract as he himself was negligent and not performed his part of
contract. There is no need to send the document for its examination by
handwriting expert and the writ petition filed by the petitioner is liable to
be dismissed.
7. I have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the material
annexed with the petition.
8. The claim of the plaintiff in the present case is that the defendants have
executed an agreement on 30.10.2021 for sale of 7 dismil of their land
in favour of plaintiff and advance amount of Rs.10,10,000/-have been
paid on 30.10.2021 and thereafter an amount of Rs.30,000/- were
again paid in two installments on 31.10.2021 and 01.11.2021 and thus
total amount of Rs.10,40,000/- have been paid as an advance amount
to the defendants. The copy of agreement dated 30.10.2021 is also
annexed with the petition as Annexure P/2 which has also been
perused by this court, in which the payment of advance consideration
have been mentioned. In paragraph 2 of plaint (Annexure P/3), the
plaintiff has pleaded that :
“2. यह कि, प्रतिवादीगण के नाम पर ग्राम- दादरखुर्द पटवारी हल्का नंबर 21,
राजस्व निरीक्षक मंडल- कोरबा, तहसील एवं जिला कोरबा (छ.ग.) में खसरा नंबर
500 रकबा 0.0400 हेक्टेयर (10 डीसमिल) भूमि राजस्व अभिलेखों में अवस्थित
है और प्रतिवादीगण के द्वारा उक्त भूमि खसरा नंबर 500 के सम्पूर्ण रकबे में से
रकबा 0. 07 एकड भूमि, कुल विक्रय मूल्य रकम 26,25,000/- रूपये (छब्बीस
लाख पच्चीस हजार रूपये ) में वादी के पास विक्रय किये जाने हेतु निवेदन किया गया
है। प्रतिवादीगण के उक्त विक्रय के प्रस्ताव को वादी के द्वारा स्वीकार किया गया और
इस कारण से वादी तथा प्रतिवादीगण के मध्य खसरा नंबर 500 के सम्पूर्ण रकबे में
से रकबा 0.07 एकड भूमि, जिसे आगे सुविधा के दृष्टिकोण से वाद भूमि लेख किया
जावेंगा, उक्त वाद भूमि के विक्रय हेतु इकरारनामा दिनांक 30/10/2021 को अंतिम
रूप से निष्पादित हुआ है।"
9. The defendant filed their written statement on 21.08.2023, however,
they denied payment of advance amount and pleaded in paragraph 1 &
2 of written statement that “1. यह कि, वाद पत्र की कंडिका 01 आं शिक रूप से स्वीकार है तथा विक्रय विलेख
का इकरारनामा के आधार पर वादी ने प्रतिवादीगण को किसी प्रकार का रकम
अदायगी एडवांश के रूप में नहीं दिया था। खसरा नंबर-500 रकबा 10 डिसमिल
भूमि वास्तव में प्रतिवादीगण की भूमि है जिसका लगान वगैरह अदा करते हुए चला
आ रहा है। दिनांक-30.10.2021 को अंतिम रूप से एक इकरारनामा निष्पादित
किया था परंतु कोई एडवांश नहीं दिया था केवल एडवांश का आश्वासन दिया था।
2. यह कि, वाद पत्र की कंडिका 02 से 03 तक का कथन अस्वीकार है। खसरा
नंबर-500 के संपूर्ण रकबे की भूमि में से 07 डिसमिल भूमि का विक्रय संबंधित
विक्रय इकरारनामा किया था कीमत भी 26 लाख 25 हजार रूप्ये में कीमत तय
हुआ था परंतु न तो एडवांश की राशि दी गई इकरारनामा होते समय प्रतिवादी को
गुमराह करते हुए एडवांश की राशि दे रहे कहकर एडवांश राशि दिया गया जो 10
हजार, 20 हजार राशि नहीं दिया गया है इस प्रकार से प्रतिवादी को अभी तक वादी
गुमराह कर रखा है केवल नाममात्र इकरारनामा के आधार पर वाद प्रस्तुत किया है
जो चलने योग्य नहीं है, इसी बीच में अधिवक्ता के द्वारा नोटिस भी दिया गया था
अग्रिम राशि न तो दी गई थी न तो किसी प्रकार विक्रय विलेख का रजिस्ट्री कराया,
रजिस्ट्री के समय पैसा दे दगं ू ा बोला था इस प्रकार एडवांश राशि नहीं दी गई और न
ही वादी का रजिस्ट्री का भुगतान कराया और न ही रजिस्टी कराया l”
10. The copy of deposition of defendant No.2 who has been examined
before the trial court as DW-1 has also been annexed in the petition as
Annexure P/4 & P/5. As per evidence of defendant No.2, in paragraph
11 of his cross examination he stated that ekeys es izLrqr Hkwfe fodz;
bdjkjukek fnukad 30-10-2021 ds nksuks istksa dks fn[kkdj iwNs tkus ij lk{kh us
fo’ks’kj iVsy ds uke ds gLrk{kj gksus ls badkj fd;k A Further, in the same
paragraph he denied his signature by saying that
mDRk nLrkost ds
vkosnd ds gLrk{kj ds LFkku ij vius gLrk{kj dks gksus ls badkj fd;k gS A In
paragraph 15 of his further cross examination he has stated that ;g
dguk xyr gS fd mDr bdjkjukek ds izR;sd i`”B esa esjs gLrk{kj gS A In
paragraph 16 also, he denied his signature over the agreement by
saying that ;g dguk lgh gS fd eSus vius eq[; ijh{k.k esa lqjs’k ikgwtk }kjk
nLrkost esa gLrk{kj ysus dh ckr fy[kh gS tcfd eSa fdlh Hkh nLrkost esa
gLrk{kj ugh fd;k FkkA These part of statement gives cause to the
plaintiff for filing application under Sections 39 and 40 of Bhartiya
Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 read with Order 16 Rule 2(2) CPC. In
paragraph 6 of his application filed by the petitioner on 04.08.2025 he
specifically pleaded that since the defendant No.2 denied his signature
over the agreement dated 30.10.2021, there is a need to get the said
deed examined by handwriting expert.
11. Although the trial court is empowered to compare the signature of
parties to the suit if occasion arises for its consideration as provided
under Section 73 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (72 of Bhartiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023), however, keeping in view the fact that courts are not
expert in scientifically examining or comparing the signature of person,
the remedy provided under Sections 39 and 40 of Bhartiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam to get the deed examined by handwriting expert.
12. In case of Thiruvengadam Pillai (Supra) in paragraph 16, it has been
held as under :
“16. While there is no doubt that court can compare the disputed
handwriting/signature/finger impression with the admitted handwriting/
signature/finger impression, such comparison by court without the
assistance of any expert, has always been considered to be
hazardous and risky. When it is said that there is no bar to a court to
compare the disputed finger impression with the admitted finger
impression, it goes without saying that it can record an opinion or
finding
on
such comparison, only after an analysis of the
characteristics of the admitted finger impression and after verifying
whether the same characteristics are found in the disputed finger
impression. The comparison of the two thumb impressions cannot be
casual or by a mere glance. Further, a finding in the judgment that
there appeared to be no marked differences between the admitted
thumb impression and disputed thumb impression, without anything
more, cannot be accepted as a valid finding that the disputed signature
is of the person who has put the admitted thumb impression. Where
the Court finds that the disputed finger impression and admitted thumb
impression are clear and where the court is in a position to identify the
characteristics of finger prints, the court may record a finding on
comparison, even in the absence of an expert's opinion. But where the
disputed thumb impression is smudgy, vague or very light, the court
should not hazard a guess by a casual perusal.”
13. Similar issue arose in case of Mudi Reddy (Supra) and the High Court
for the State of Telangana in paragraph 10,14&15 held as under:
“10. Admittedly, the suit has been filed for specific performance in
receipt of land, which is covered by the disputed document. The
signature on it is alleged to be forged by the respondents. Therefore,
the entire suit rests on the question as to whether the disputed
document was executed by the respondents or not. The application
seeking to refer the document to an expert was filed in April, 2012. It
came to be decided in July, 2012. According to the petitioner, it was
filed at the stage when D.W. 1's cross-examination was done, but the
Court below held that the application was filed after the matter was
posted for arguments. Since the Division Bench of this Court in
Janachaitanya's case (1 supra) had held that no hard and fast rule
controlling the discretion of the Court to send a disputed document or
writing for opinion of the expert. I am of the view that the Court below
cannot reject it on mere ground that it was filed at that stage. When the
entire case rests upon the question whether the disputed document
was executed by the respondents or not, in my considered opinion, the
Court below is not right, in not referring the said document to an
expert.
14.In State v. Pali Ram (6) (1979) 2 SCC 158 the Supreme Court held
that although there is no legal bar to the Judge using his own eyes to
compare the disputed writing with the admitted writing, even without
the aid of the evidence of any handwriting expert, the Judge should, as
a matter of prudence and caution, hesitate to base his finding with
regard to the identity of a handwriting, which forms the sheet anchor of
the prosecution case against a person accused of an offence, solely
on comparison made by himself. It also observed that it is not
advisable that a Judge should take upon himself the task of comparing
the admitted writing with the disputed one to find out whether the two
agree with each other; and the prudent course is to obtain the opinion
and assistance of an expert.
15. After considering these decisions and also the decisions in Murali
Lal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (7) (1980) 1 SCC 704; Shashi Kumar
v. Subodh Kumar (8) AIR 1964 SC 529; Magan Bihari Lal v. State of
Punjab (9) (1977) 2 SCC 210 AIR 1977 SC 1091; Vadrevu
Annapurnamma v. Vadrevu Bhima Sankara Rao (10) ARI 1960 A.P.
359, this Court in Velaga Sivarama Krishna's case (2) supra, held that
expert's opinion is not excluded from the purview of examination and it
would help the Court in exercising power of comparison under Section
73 of the Evidence Act. It also held in paragraphs 7 and 8 as under;
"Whenever a party disputes the signature on a particular
document, two remedies are open to him, either to request the
Court to compare the signatures or to file an application to send
the document to the expert for comparison. When the petitioner
opted to file an application to send the document to the
handwriting expert, no prejudice will be caused to either party.
When he is asserting that the signature is that of the said party,
even though there is a gap between the disputed signatures and
admitted signatures, a science has been developed to compare
such signatures also by taking into consideration the direction of
the strokes, the speed of writing, the pattern of writing etc.,
therefore, it cannot be said that no useful purpose will be served
by sending the document to the expert. After comparison, if the
similarities of the disputed signature and the admitted signatures
are very negligible, then the Court can formulate its opinion with
the assistance of the expert's report and by comparing the
signatures whether the report has to be accepted or not. But, if
the opportunity is denied to the defendant and if the matter is
carried to the appellate Court, there is every likelihood of
commenting that he did not avail the opportunity of filing an
application for sending the document for handwriting expert's
opinion, if he is so sure that the disputed signature does not
belong to him.
In view of the circumstances, I am of the view that it is
essential to send the document to the expert for comparison at the
request of the party in the interests of justice, which cannot cause any
amount of prejudice to the plaintiffs in the present suit, therefore, the
order of the lower Court is liable to be set aside".
14. In case of The State (Delhi Administration) Vs. Pali Ram, 1979 (2)
SCC 158, the Supreme Court has observed in paragraph 30 as under :
“30.The matter can be viewed from another angle, also. Although there
is no legal bar to the Judge using his own eyes to compare the
disputed writing with the admitted writing, even without the aid of the
evidence of any handwriting expert, the Judge should, as a matter of
prudence and caution, hesitate to base his finding with regard to the
identity of a handwriting which forms the sheet-anchor of the
prosecution case against a person accused of an offence solely on
comparison made by himself. It is, therefore, not advisable that a
Judge should take upon himself the task of comparing the admitted
writing with the disputed one to find out whether the two agree with
each other; and the prudent course is to obtain the opinion and
assistance of an expert.”
15. In the present case by calling handwriting expert’s report after
examination of signature of defendants, in the opinion of this court, no
prejudice appears to be caused to the parties as they have every right
to call the handwriting experts for their cross examination. Accordingly,
I am of the considered opinion that the trial court has not exercised its
jurisdiction vested in it for calling handwriting expert’s report.
16. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 18.08.2025 is set aside. The
application filed by the petitioner/plaintiff dated 04.08.2025 under
Sections 39 and 40 of Bhartiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 read with
Order 16 Rule 2(2) CPC is allowed. The trial court is directed to take
necessary steps to get the document Ex.P/1 examined by handwriting
expert with the consent of the parties. All the expenditure for
examination of documents by a competent handwriting expert shall be
borne by the plaintiff.
17. With the aforesaid observations, the writ petition is allowed. No order
asto costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
inder
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review